TED2013
Jennifer Granholm: A clean energy proposal -- race to the top!
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
776,264 views
Kicking off the TED2013 conference, Jennifer Granholm asks a very American question with worldwide implications: How do we make more jobs? Her big idea: Invest in new alternative energy sources. And her big challenge: Can it be done with or without our broken Congress?
Jennifer Granholm - Former governor of Michigan
A former two-term governor of Michigan, Jennifer M. Granholm makes the case for empowering states to create jobs through a Clean Energy Jobs Race to the Top. Full bio
A former two-term governor of Michigan, Jennifer M. Granholm makes the case for empowering states to create jobs through a Clean Energy Jobs Race to the Top. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Well, I was introduced as
0
578
2918
00:19
the former Governor of Michigan,
1
3496
2032
00:21
but actually I'm a scientist.
2
5528
3016
00:24
All right, a political scientist, it doesn't really count,
3
8544
2992
00:27
but my laboratory was the laboratory of democracy
4
11536
3796
00:31
that is Michigan, and, like any good scientist,
5
15332
3156
00:34
I was experimenting with policy
6
18488
2842
00:37
about what would achieve the greatest good
7
21330
2694
00:39
for the greatest number.
8
24024
2109
00:42
But there were three problems, three enigmas
9
26133
4278
00:46
that I could not solve,
10
30411
2534
00:48
and I want to share with you those problems,
11
32945
3478
00:52
but most importantly,
12
36423
2006
00:54
I think I figured out a proposal for a solution.
13
38429
3756
00:58
The first problem
14
42185
1869
00:59
that not just Michigan, but every state, faces is,
15
44054
1991
01:01
how do you create good jobs in America
16
46045
3319
01:05
in a global economy?
17
49364
1748
01:07
So let me share with you some empirical data from my lab.
18
51112
3492
01:10
I was elected in 2002 and, at the end of my first year in office in 2003,
19
54604
4510
01:15
I got a call from one of my staff members, who said,
20
59114
2532
01:17
"Gov, we have a big problem.
21
61646
2368
01:19
We have a little tiny community called Greenville, Michigan,
22
64014
3620
01:23
population 8,000,
23
67634
2262
01:25
and they are about to lose their major employer,
24
69896
2795
01:28
which is a refrigerator factory that's operated by Electrolux."
25
72691
4819
01:33
And I said, "Well, how many people work at Electrolux?"
26
77510
2679
01:36
And he said, "3,000 of the 8,000 people in Greenville."
27
80189
4930
01:41
So it is a one-company town.
28
85119
2781
01:43
And Electrolux was going to go to Mexico.
29
87900
4928
01:48
So I said, "Forget that. I'm the new Governor.
30
92828
2888
01:51
We can fix this. We're going to go to Greenville
31
95716
2288
01:53
with my whole cabinet and we will just
32
98004
1968
01:55
make Electrolux an offer they can't refuse."
33
99972
2905
01:58
So I brought my whole cabinet,
34
102877
2431
02:01
and we met with all of the pooh-bahs of little Greenville --
35
105308
3712
02:04
the mayor, the city manager, the head of the community college --
36
109020
3230
02:08
and we basically emptied our pockets
37
112250
3595
02:11
and put all of our chips on the table,
38
115845
3293
02:15
incentives, you name it, to convince Electrolux to stay,
39
119138
4128
02:19
and as we made our pile of chips,
40
123266
1651
02:20
we slid them across the table to the management of Electrolux.
41
124917
5107
02:25
And in the pile were things like zero taxes for 20 years,
42
130024
4108
02:30
or that we'd help to build a new factory for the company,
43
134132
4216
02:34
we'd help to finance it. The UAW, who represented the workers,
44
138348
2793
02:37
said they would offer unprecedented concessions,
45
141141
3839
02:40
sacrifices to just keep those jobs in Greenville.
46
144980
4053
02:44
So the management of Electrolux took our pile,
47
149033
2878
02:47
our list of incentives, and they went outside the room
48
151911
2813
02:50
for 17 minutes,
49
154724
2520
02:53
and they came back in and they said,
50
157244
2231
02:55
"Wow, this is the most generous
51
159475
2941
02:58
any community has ever been to try to keep jobs here.
52
162416
4489
03:02
But there's nothing you can do
53
166905
3395
03:06
to compensate for the fact that we can pay $1.57 an hour
54
170300
4289
03:10
in Juarez, Mexico. So we're leaving."
55
174589
3258
03:13
And they did. And when they did, it was like
56
177847
3005
03:16
a nuclear bomb went off in little Greenville.
57
180852
3256
03:20
In fact, they did implode the factory.
58
184108
2315
03:22
That's a guy that is walking on his last day of work.
59
186423
3978
03:26
And on the month that the last refrigerator rolled off the assembly line,
60
190401
4024
03:30
the employees of Electrolux in Greenville, Michigan,
61
194425
2640
03:32
had a gathering for themselves that they called the last supper.
62
197065
5665
03:38
It was in a big pavilion in Greenville, an indoor pavilion,
63
202730
2983
03:41
and I went to it because I was so frustrated as Governor
64
205713
4489
03:46
that I couldn't stop the outflow of these jobs,
65
210202
3897
03:49
and I wanted to grieve with them,
66
214099
2523
03:52
and as I went into the room-- there's thousands of people there.
67
216622
3320
03:55
It was a just big thing. People were eating boxed lunches
68
219942
3743
03:59
on roundtop tables, and there was a sad band playing music,
69
223685
4160
04:03
or a band playing sad music, probably both. (Laughter)
70
227845
3737
04:07
And this guy comes up to me,
71
231582
3227
04:10
and he's got tattoos and his ponytail and his baseball cap on,
72
234809
3740
04:14
and he had his two daughters with him,
73
238549
2618
04:17
and he said, "Gov, these are my two daughters."
74
241167
3607
04:20
He said, "I'm 48 years old,
75
244774
3048
04:23
and I have worked at this factory for 30 years.
76
247822
4558
04:28
I went from high school to factory.
77
252380
2656
04:30
My father worked at this factory," he said.
78
255036
2608
04:33
"My grandfather worked at this factory.
79
257644
2849
04:36
All I know is how to make refrigerators."
80
260493
5023
04:41
And he looked at his daughters,
81
265516
1353
04:42
and he puts his hand on his chest,
82
266869
2488
04:45
and he says, "So, Gov, tell me,
83
269357
2550
04:47
who is ever going to hire me?
84
271907
5328
04:53
Who is ever going to hire me?"
85
277235
3433
04:56
And that was asked not just by that guy
86
280668
3522
05:00
but by everyone in the pavilion,
87
284190
2678
05:02
and frankly, by every worker at one of the 50,000 factories
88
286868
5840
05:08
that closed in the first decade of this century.
89
292708
4312
05:12
Enigma number one: How do you create jobs
90
297020
2894
05:15
in America in a global economy?
91
299914
2433
05:18
Number two, very quickly:
92
302347
2300
05:20
How do you solve global climate change
93
304647
2732
05:23
when we don't even have a national energy policy in this country
94
307379
4337
05:27
and when gridlock in Congress seems to be the norm?
95
311716
4928
05:32
In fact, there was a poll that was done recently
96
316644
3162
05:35
and the pollster compared Congress's approval ratings
97
319806
4277
05:39
to a number of other unpleasant things,
98
324083
2430
05:42
and it was found, in fact, that Congress's approval rating
99
326513
3520
05:45
is worse than cockroaches,
100
330033
2882
05:48
lice, Nickelback the band, root canals and Donald Trump. (Laughter)
101
332915
6992
05:55
But wait, the good news is it's at least better
102
339907
4279
06:00
than meth labs and gonorrhea. (Laughter)
103
344186
4856
06:04
We got a problem, folks.
104
349042
3825
06:08
So it got me thinking, what is it?
105
352867
1638
06:10
What in the laboratory that I see out there,
106
354505
3762
06:14
the laboratories of democracy, what has happened?
107
358267
2150
06:16
What policy prescriptions have happened
108
360417
2699
06:19
that actually cause changes to occur
109
363116
1792
06:20
and that have been accepted in a bipartisan way?
110
364908
3567
06:24
So if I asked you, for example,
111
368475
1278
06:25
what was the Obama Administration policy
112
369753
2480
06:28
that caused massive changes across the country,
113
372233
3114
06:31
what would you say?
114
375347
1288
06:32
You might say Obamacare, except for those were not voluntary changes.
115
376635
3795
06:36
As we know, only half the states have opted in.
116
380430
2541
06:38
We might say the Recovery Act, but those didn't require policy changes.
117
382971
3509
06:42
The thing that caused massive policy changes to occur
118
386480
4351
06:46
was Race to the Top for education.
119
390831
2420
06:49
Why? The government put a $4.5 billion pot
120
393251
3242
06:52
and said to the governors across the country, compete for it.
121
396493
3446
06:55
Forty-eight governors competed,
122
399939
3176
06:59
convincing 48 state legislatures to essentially
123
403115
3299
07:02
raise standards for high schoolers
124
406414
2286
07:04
so that they all take a college prep curriculum.
125
408700
2311
07:06
Forty-eight states opted in, creating a national [education] policy from the bottom up.
126
411011
5386
07:12
So I thought, well, why can't we do something like that
127
416397
2603
07:14
and create a clean energy jobs race to the top?
128
419000
4046
07:18
Because after all, if you look at the context,
129
423046
2351
07:21
1.6 trillion dollars has been invested in the past eight years
130
425397
3978
07:25
from the private sector globally,
131
429375
1942
07:27
and every dollar represents a job,
132
431317
2372
07:29
and where are those jobs going?
133
433689
1595
07:31
Well, they're going to places that have policy, like China.
134
435284
2424
07:33
In fact, I was in China to see what they were doing,
135
437708
2022
07:35
and they were putting on a dog-and-pony show for the group that I was with,
136
439730
2708
07:38
and I was standing in the back of the room during one of the demonstrations
137
442438
3003
07:41
and standing next to one of the Chinese officials,
138
445441
2363
07:43
and we were watching, and he says,
139
447804
1662
07:45
"So, Gov, when do you think the U.S. is going to get national energy policy?"
140
449466
4634
07:50
And I said, "Oh my God -- Congress, gridlock, who knows?"
141
454100
3568
07:53
And this is what he did, he goes, he says,
142
457668
4014
07:57
"Take your time."
143
461682
2737
08:00
Because they see our passivity as their opportunity.
144
464419
4638
08:04
So what if we decided to create
145
469057
2933
08:07
a challenge to the governors of the country,
146
471990
2699
08:10
and the price to entry into this competition
147
474689
2806
08:13
used the same amount that the bipartisan group approved in Congress
148
477495
3648
08:17
for the Race to the Top for education, 4.5 billion,
149
481143
2690
08:19
which sounds like a lot, but actually it's less than
150
483833
2383
08:22
one tenth of one percent of federal spending.
151
486216
2489
08:24
It's a rounding error on the federal side.
152
488705
2024
08:26
But price to entry into that competition would be,
153
490729
3918
08:30
you could just, say, use the President's goal.
154
494647
3305
08:33
He wants Congress to adopt a clean energy standard
155
497952
3073
08:36
of 80 percent by 2030,
156
501025
2275
08:39
in other words, that you'd have to get 80 percent
157
503300
1979
08:41
of your energy from clean sources by the year 2030.
158
505279
3650
08:44
Why not ask all of the states to do that instead?
159
508929
2701
08:47
And imagine what might happen,
160
511630
1991
08:49
because every region has something to offer.
161
513621
1988
08:51
You might take states like Iowa and Ohio --
162
515609
2982
08:54
two very important political states, by the way --
163
518591
2017
08:56
those two governors, and they would say,
164
520608
1888
08:58
we're going to lead the nation in producing
165
522496
2715
09:01
the wind turbines and the wind energy.
166
525211
2602
09:03
You might say the solar states, the sun belt,
167
527813
3171
09:06
we're going to be the states that produce solar energy for the country,
168
530984
3700
09:10
and maybe Jerry Brown says, "Well, I'm going to create
169
534684
2170
09:12
an industry cluster in California
170
536854
2177
09:14
to be able to produce the solar panels
171
539031
1839
09:16
so that we're not buying them from China
172
540870
1649
09:18
but we're buying them from the U.S."
173
542519
1863
09:20
In fact, every region of the country could do this.
174
544382
3430
09:23
You see, you've got solar and wind opportunity all across the nation.
175
547812
4106
09:27
In fact, if you look just at the upper and northern states
176
551918
4004
09:31
in the West, they could do geothermal,
177
555922
2175
09:33
or you could look at Texas and say,
178
558097
2312
09:36
we could lead the nation in the solutions to smart grid.
179
560409
3368
09:39
In the middle eastern states which have access to forests
180
563777
4092
09:43
and to agricultural waste, they might say,
181
567884
2324
09:46
we're going to lead the nation in biofuels.
182
570208
2601
09:48
In the upper northeast, we're going to lead the nation
183
572809
2516
09:51
in energy efficiency solutions.
184
575325
2864
09:54
Along the eastern seaboard, we're going to lead the nation
185
578189
2969
09:57
in offshore wind.
186
581158
1819
09:58
You might look at Michigan and say, we're going to lead the nation
187
582977
2583
10:01
in producing the guts for the electric vehicle, like the lithium ion battery.
188
585560
3894
10:05
Every region has something to offer,
189
589454
3407
10:08
and if you created a competition,
190
592861
2322
10:11
it respects the states and it respects federalism.
191
595183
4118
10:15
It's opt-in. You might even get Texas and South Carolina,
192
599301
3554
10:18
who didn't opt into the education Race to the Top,
193
602855
2670
10:21
you might even get them to opt in. Why?
194
605525
2401
10:23
Because Republican and Democratic governors
195
607926
2551
10:26
love to cut ribbons.
196
610477
1654
10:28
We want to bring jobs. I'm just saying.
197
612131
4314
10:32
And it fosters innovation at the state level
198
616445
2620
10:34
in these laboratories of democracy.
199
619065
2461
10:37
Now, any of you who are watching anything about politics lately
200
621526
4306
10:41
might say, "Okay, great idea, but really?
201
625832
2757
10:44
Congress putting four and a half billion dollars on the table?
202
628589
2632
10:47
They can't agree to anything."
203
631221
2273
10:49
So you could wait and go through Congress,
204
633494
3295
10:52
although you should be very impatient.
205
636789
2576
10:55
Or, you renegades, we could go around Congress.
206
639365
7904
11:03
Go around Congress.
207
647269
1558
11:04
What if we created a private sector challenge to the governors?
208
648827
6628
11:11
What if several of the high-net worth companies
209
655455
4960
11:16
and individuals who are here at TED decided
210
660415
4390
11:20
that they would create, band together, just a couple of them,
211
664805
3528
11:24
and create a national competition to the governors
212
668333
3560
11:27
to have a race to the top
213
671893
2256
11:30
and see how the governors respond?
214
674149
2669
11:32
What if it all started here at TED?
215
676818
4888
11:37
What if you were here
216
681706
2659
11:40
when we figured out how to crack the code
217
684365
5348
11:45
to create good paying jobs in America -- (Applause) --
218
689713
5446
11:51
and get national energy policy
219
695159
3721
11:54
and we created a national energy strategy from the bottom up?
220
698880
5978
12:00
Because, dear TEDsters,
221
704858
3451
12:04
if you are impatient like I am,
222
708309
2762
12:06
you know that our economic competitors,
223
711071
3558
12:10
our other nations, are in the game
224
714629
3440
12:13
and are eating us for lunch.
225
718069
2352
12:16
And we can get in the game or not.
226
720421
4546
12:20
We can be at the table or we can be on the table.
227
724967
4319
12:25
And I don't know about you,
228
729286
2421
12:27
but I prefer to dine.
229
731707
2707
12:30
Thank you all so much. (Applause)
230
734414
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jennifer Granholm - Former governor of MichiganA former two-term governor of Michigan, Jennifer M. Granholm makes the case for empowering states to create jobs through a Clean Energy Jobs Race to the Top.
Why you should listen
Jennifer M. Granholm was elected governor of Michigan in 2002, and in 2006, she was re-elected with the largest number of votes ever cast for governor in Michigan. As governor, Granholm led the state through a brutal economic downturn that resulted from a meltdown in the automotive and manufacturing sectors. She worked relentlessly to diversify the state’s economy, strengthen its auto industry, preserve the advancedmanufacturing sector, and add new, emerging sectors, such as clean energy, to Michigan’s economic portfolio.
During her tenure, she pioneered clean energy policies, working with business and labor, Republicans and Democrats to create new economic opportunities in Michigan. In 2005, the Granholm economic development team put together an aggressive strategy to make Michigan the hub of clean-energy development in North America by developing entire supply chains in Michigan, fostering critical partnerships between industry, government and researchers and by creating economic incentives that made Michigan the place to locate. Granholm’s plan included specific clustering strategies targeted at battery manufacturing, bio-energy, solar and wind power. Her leadership attracted to Michigan more than 89,000clean energy jobs and $9.4 billion in investments in that sector. By the time she left office at the start of 2011, Michigan’s economy was rebounding and Gallup listed Michigan as state with the most improved jobs climate.
Her book A Governor’s Story: The Fight for Jobs and America’s Economic Future tells how Michigan pioneered ways out of an economic storm and offers advice for a nation desperate to create jobs.
Jennifer Granholm | Speaker | TED.com