ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Toby Eccles - Social investment visionary
Toby Eccles has created a radical financial instrument that helps private investors contribute to solving thorny public problems.

Why you should listen

All too often, an ex-inmate walks out of prison with the exact same problems he or she walked in with: lack of skills, lack of support, no job. And they end up re-offending and back in jail. It's an expensive problem to fix, but it's a much more expensive one to ignore. A director at Social Finance in London, Toby Eccles explores the arbitrage between those two options.

In 2010, his pioneering Social Impact Bond allowed private investors to support a UK program targeting ex-prisoners who served short sentences (the limited government funding only goes to ex-inmates who served long terms). The £5m scheme, funded by 17 investors, supports training and support for 1,000 ex-inmates; if they re-offend less than a control group, the government will pay investors back, plus interest, through the savings accrued by achieving the program's targets.

More such bonds are now being tried across the world, including in New York City and Massachusetts (both addressing recidivism), and extended to new fields such as development. Eccles founded Social Finance in 2007, and he oversees all of the firm's social impact bond work, where, he says: "We are incentivised to work with the complicated and with those willing to change." "We are incentivised to work with the complicated and with those willing to change."

More profile about the speaker
Toby Eccles | Speaker | TED.com
TEDGlobal 2013

Toby Eccles: Invest in social change

Filmed:
980,881 views

Here's a stat worth knowing: In the UK, 63% of men who finish short-term prison sentences are back inside within a year for another crime. Helping them stay outside involves job training, classes, therapy. And it would pay off handsomely -- but the government can't find the funds. Toby Eccles shares an imaginative idea for how to change that: the Social Impact Bond. It's an unusual bond that helps fund initiatives with a social goal through private money -- with the government paying back the investors (with interest) if the initiatives work.
- Social investment visionary
Toby Eccles has created a radical financial instrument that helps private investors contribute to solving thorny public problems. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
I'm here today to talk about social change,
0
397
3560
00:15
not a new therapy or a new intervention
1
3957
3283
00:19
or a new way of working with kids
or something like that,
2
7240
2717
00:21
but a new business model for social change,
3
9957
2945
00:24
a new way of tackling the problem.
4
12902
2907
00:27
In Britain, 63 percent of all men
5
15809
4174
00:31
who come out of short sentences from prison
6
19983
3063
00:35
re-offend again within a year.
7
23046
2521
00:37
Now how many previous offenses
8
25567
2618
00:40
do you think they have on average
9
28185
2383
00:42
managed to commit?
10
30568
2585
00:45
Forty-three.
11
33153
2148
00:47
And how many previous times
do you think they've been in prison?
12
35301
3663
00:50
Seven.
13
38964
1187
00:52
So we went to talk to the Ministry of Justice,
14
40151
2814
00:54
and we said to the Ministry of Justice,
15
42965
1888
00:56
what's it worth to you
16
44853
2352
00:59
if fewer of these guys re-offend?
17
47205
2177
01:01
It's got to be worth something, right?
18
49382
2169
01:03
I mean, there's prison costs,
19
51551
1827
01:05
there's police costs, there's court costs,
20
53378
3528
01:08
all these things that you're spending money on
21
56906
2732
01:11
to deal with these guys. What's it worth?
22
59638
2513
01:14
Now, of course, we care about the social value.
23
62151
2995
01:17
Social Finance, the organization I helped set up,
24
65146
3286
01:20
cares about social stuff.
25
68432
2243
01:22
But we wanted to make the economic case,
26
70675
3042
01:25
because if we could make the economic case,
27
73717
1778
01:27
then the value of doing this
would be completely compelling.
28
75495
3021
01:30
And if we can agree on both a value
29
78516
2835
01:33
and a way of measuring whether we've been
30
81351
2337
01:35
successful at reducing that re-offending,
31
83688
2398
01:38
then we can do something
32
86086
1971
01:40
we think rather interesting.
33
88057
2563
01:42
The idea is called the social impact bond.
34
90620
3924
01:46
Now, the social impact bond is simply saying,
35
94544
2377
01:48
if we can get the government to agree,
36
96921
1639
01:50
that we can create a contract where
37
98560
2751
01:53
they only pay if it worked.
38
101311
3459
01:56
So that means that they can try out new stuff
39
104770
3169
01:59
without the embarrassment
40
107939
1463
02:01
of having to pay if it didn't work,
41
109402
2008
02:03
which for still quite a lot of bits of government,
42
111410
1672
02:05
that's a serious issue.
43
113082
1347
02:06
Now, many of you may have noticed
44
114429
1595
02:08
there's a problem at this point,
45
116024
1486
02:09
and that is that it takes a long time to measure
46
117510
2214
02:11
whether those outcomes have happened.
47
119724
2766
02:14
So we have to raise some money.
48
122490
3216
02:17
We use the contract to raise money
49
125706
2447
02:20
from socially motivated investors.
50
128153
2224
02:22
Socially motivated investors:
51
130377
2354
02:24
there's an interesting idea, right?
52
132731
2298
02:27
But actually, there's a lot of people who,
53
135029
2391
02:29
if they're given the chance,
54
137420
1233
02:30
would love to invest in something
55
138653
1882
02:32
that does social good.
56
140535
2763
02:35
And here's the opportunity.
57
143298
1973
02:37
Do you want to also help government find
58
145271
2257
02:39
whether there's a better economic model,
59
147528
2436
02:41
not just leaving these guys to come out of prison
60
149964
2376
02:44
and waiting till they re-offend
and putting them back in again,
61
152340
2871
02:47
but actually working with them
62
155211
1557
02:48
to move to a different path
63
156768
1559
02:50
to end up with fewer crimes
64
158327
2599
02:52
and fewer victims?
65
160926
2015
02:54
So we find some investors,
66
162941
2511
02:57
and they pay for a set of services,
67
165452
2370
02:59
and if those services are successful,
68
167822
2265
03:02
then they improve outcomes,
69
170087
2493
03:04
and with those measured reductions in re-offending,
70
172580
2641
03:07
government saves money,
71
175221
1075
03:08
and with those savings,
72
176296
1537
03:09
they can pay outcomes.
73
177833
2454
03:12
And the investors do not just get their money back,
74
180287
2176
03:14
but they make a return.
75
182463
2008
03:16
So in March 2010, we signed
76
184471
2441
03:18
the first social impact bond
77
186912
2020
03:20
with the Ministry of Justice
78
188932
1827
03:22
around Peterborough Prison.
79
190759
2037
03:24
It was to work with 3,000 offenders
80
192796
3024
03:27
split into three cohorts of 1,000 each.
81
195820
2928
03:30
Now, each of those cohorts
82
198748
1989
03:32
would get measured over the two years
83
200737
1831
03:34
that they were coming out of prison.
84
202568
1202
03:35
They've got to have a year to commit their crimes,
85
203770
2055
03:37
six months to get through the court system,
86
205825
2545
03:40
and then they would be compared to a group
87
208370
2395
03:42
taken from the police national computer,
88
210765
2068
03:44
as similar as possible,
89
212833
1827
03:46
and we would get paid
90
214660
1534
03:48
providing we achieved a hurdle rate
of 10-percent reduction,
91
216194
2789
03:50
for every conviction event that didn't happen.
92
218983
3558
03:54
So we get paid for crimes saved.
93
222541
3477
03:58
Now if we achieved that 10-percent reduction
94
226018
4104
04:02
across all three cohorts,
95
230122
1685
04:03
then the investors get a seven and a half percent
96
231807
3140
04:06
annualized return on their investment,
97
234947
2143
04:09
and if we do better than that,
98
237090
1540
04:10
they can get up to 13 percent
99
238630
1596
04:12
annualized return on their investment,
100
240226
2533
04:14
which is okay.
101
242759
2118
04:16
So everyone wins here, right?
102
244877
3208
04:20
The Ministry of Justice can try out a new program
103
248085
2715
04:22
and they only pay if it works.
104
250800
2443
04:25
Investors get two opportunities:
105
253243
2412
04:27
for the first time, they can invest in social change.
106
255655
3056
04:30
Also, they make a reasonable return,
107
258711
2031
04:32
and they also know that
108
260742
2173
04:34
first investors in these kinds of things,
109
262915
2272
04:37
they're going to have to believers.
110
265187
1657
04:38
They're going to have to care in the social program,
111
266844
2103
04:40
but if this builds a track record
112
268947
1992
04:42
over five or 10 years,
113
270939
1448
04:44
then you can widen that investor community
114
272387
2064
04:46
as more people have confidence in the product.
115
274451
2456
04:48
The service providers, well, for the first time,
116
276907
2188
04:51
they've got an opportunity to provide services
117
279095
2859
04:53
and grow the evidence for what they're doing
118
281954
2227
04:56
in a really constructive way and learn
119
284181
2560
04:58
and demonstrate the value of what they're doing
120
286741
1822
05:00
over five or six years, not just one or two
121
288563
2019
05:02
as often happens at the moment.
122
290582
1841
05:04
Society wins: fewer crimes, fewer victims.
123
292423
3478
05:07
Now, the offenders, they also benefit.
124
295901
2826
05:10
Instead of just coming out of the prison
125
298727
1430
05:12
with 46 pounds in their pocket,
126
300157
1924
05:14
half of them not knowing where they're spending
127
302081
1499
05:15
their first night out of jail,
128
303580
2138
05:17
actually, someone meets them in prison,
129
305718
2919
05:20
learns about their issues,
130
308637
1864
05:22
meets them at the gate,
131
310501
1919
05:24
takes them through to somewhere to stay,
132
312420
2753
05:27
connects them to benefits,
connects them to employment,
133
315173
2418
05:29
drug rehabilitation, mental health,
134
317591
2068
05:31
whatever's needed.
135
319659
1730
05:33
So let's think of another example:
136
321389
2679
05:36
working with children in care.
137
324068
1890
05:37
Social impact bonds work great
138
325958
1624
05:39
for any area where there is at the moment
139
327582
2661
05:42
very expensive provision that produces
140
330243
2399
05:44
poor outcomes for people.
141
332642
1574
05:46
So children in the state care
142
334216
1914
05:48
tend to do very badly.
143
336130
2435
05:50
Only 13 percent achieve a reasonable level
144
338565
3925
05:54
of five GCSEs at 16,
145
342490
2899
05:57
against 58 percent of the wider population.
146
345389
2470
05:59
More troublingly, 27 percent of offenders in prison
147
347859
3659
06:03
have spent some time in care.
148
351518
2041
06:05
And even more worryingly,
149
353559
1292
06:06
and this is a Home Office statistic,
150
354851
1972
06:08
70 percent of prostitutes
151
356823
1900
06:10
have spent some time in care.
152
358723
2184
06:12
The state is not a great parent.
153
360907
3000
06:15
But there are great programs
154
363907
2825
06:18
for adolescents who are on the edge of care,
155
366732
3012
06:21
and 30 percent of kids going into care
156
369744
1876
06:23
are adolescents.
157
371620
1659
06:25
So we set up a program with Essex County Council
158
373279
2840
06:28
to test out intensive family therapeutic support
159
376119
3646
06:31
for those families with adolescents
160
379765
3040
06:34
on the edge of the care system.
161
382805
1571
06:36
Essex only pays in the event
162
384376
2786
06:39
that it's saving them care costs.
163
387162
2782
06:41
Investors have put in 3.1 million pounds.
164
389944
2764
06:44
That program started last month.
165
392708
2258
06:46
Others, around homelessness in London,
166
394966
2324
06:49
around youth and employment and education
167
397290
3880
06:53
elsewhere in the country.
168
401170
1367
06:54
There are now 13 social impact bonds in Britain,
169
402537
3355
06:57
and amazing levels of interest in this idea
170
405892
2475
07:00
all over the world.
171
408367
1523
07:01
So David Cameron's put 20 million pounds
172
409890
2715
07:04
into a social outcomes fund to support this idea.
173
412605
3250
07:07
Obama has suggested 300 million dollars
174
415855
3180
07:11
in the U.S. budget for these kinds of ideas
175
419035
3533
07:14
and structures to move it forward,
176
422568
1686
07:16
and a lot of other countries
177
424254
1491
07:17
are demonstrating considerable interest.
178
425745
2217
07:19
So what's caused this excitement?
179
427962
2056
07:22
Why is this so different for people?
180
430018
2519
07:24
Well, the first piece, which we've talked about,
181
432537
2492
07:27
is innovation.
182
435029
1218
07:28
It enables testing of new ideas
183
436247
3198
07:31
in a way that's less difficult for everybody.
184
439445
3593
07:35
The second piece it brings is rigor.
185
443038
2636
07:37
By working to outcomes, people really have to test
186
445674
3293
07:40
and bring data into the situation
that one's dealing with.
187
448967
3869
07:44
So taking Peterborough as an example,
188
452845
2493
07:47
we add case management
189
455338
2223
07:49
across all of the different organizations
that we're working with
190
457561
2656
07:52
so they know
191
460217
1285
07:53
what actually has been done with different prisoners,
192
461502
2149
07:55
and at the same time they learn
193
463651
2069
07:57
from the Ministry of Justice, and we learn,
194
465720
2426
08:00
because we pushed for the data,
195
468146
1735
08:01
what actually happens, whether
they get re-arrested or not.
196
469881
2207
08:04
And we learn and adapt the program accordingly.
197
472088
3288
08:07
And this leads to the third element, which is new,
198
475376
2937
08:10
and that's flexibility.
199
478313
2102
08:12
Because normal contracting for things,
200
480415
3113
08:15
when you're spending government money,
201
483528
2061
08:17
you're spending our money, tax money,
202
485589
2511
08:20
and the people who are in charge
of that are very aware of it
203
488100
2697
08:22
so the temptation is to control
exactly how you spend it.
204
490797
3850
08:26
Now any entrepreneur in the room knows
205
494647
3053
08:29
that version 1.0, the business plan,
206
497700
2097
08:31
is not the one that generally works.
207
499797
2847
08:34
So when you're trying to do something like this,
208
502644
2303
08:36
you need the flexibility to adapt the program.
209
504947
2693
08:39
And again, in Peterborough, we started off
210
507640
2712
08:42
with a program, but we also collected data,
211
510352
4157
08:46
and over the period of time,
212
514509
1877
08:48
we nuanced and changed that program
213
516386
2198
08:50
to add a range of other elements,
214
518584
2620
08:53
so that the service adapts
215
521204
1765
08:54
and we meet the needs of the long term
216
522969
2501
08:57
as well as the short term:
217
525470
2064
08:59
greater engagement from the prisoners,
218
527534
3109
09:02
longer-term engagement as well.
219
530643
2779
09:05
The last element is partnership.
220
533422
2536
09:07
There is, at the moment, a stale
debate going on very often:
221
535958
3177
09:11
state's better, public sector's better,
222
539135
2125
09:13
private sector's better, social sector's better,
223
541260
3511
09:16
for a lot of these programs.
224
544771
1668
09:18
Actually, for creating social change,
225
546439
1982
09:20
we need to bring in the expertise
226
548421
1739
09:22
from all of those parties
227
550160
1696
09:23
in order to make this work.
228
551856
1588
09:25
And this creates a structure
229
553444
2043
09:27
through which they can combine.
230
555487
1975
09:29
So where does this leave us?
231
557462
1932
09:31
This leaves us with a way
232
559394
1834
09:33
that people can invest in social change.
233
561228
2987
09:36
We've met thousands, possibly millions of people,
234
564215
2987
09:39
who want the opportunity to invest in social change.
235
567202
2433
09:41
We've met champions all over the public sector
236
569635
3089
09:44
keen to make these kinds of differences.
237
572724
2415
09:47
With this kind of model,
238
575139
1785
09:48
we can help bring them together.
239
576924
1936
09:50
Thank you.
240
578860
1962
09:52
(Applause)
241
580822
4200

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Toby Eccles - Social investment visionary
Toby Eccles has created a radical financial instrument that helps private investors contribute to solving thorny public problems.

Why you should listen

All too often, an ex-inmate walks out of prison with the exact same problems he or she walked in with: lack of skills, lack of support, no job. And they end up re-offending and back in jail. It's an expensive problem to fix, but it's a much more expensive one to ignore. A director at Social Finance in London, Toby Eccles explores the arbitrage between those two options.

In 2010, his pioneering Social Impact Bond allowed private investors to support a UK program targeting ex-prisoners who served short sentences (the limited government funding only goes to ex-inmates who served long terms). The £5m scheme, funded by 17 investors, supports training and support for 1,000 ex-inmates; if they re-offend less than a control group, the government will pay investors back, plus interest, through the savings accrued by achieving the program's targets.

More such bonds are now being tried across the world, including in New York City and Massachusetts (both addressing recidivism), and extended to new fields such as development. Eccles founded Social Finance in 2007, and he oversees all of the firm's social impact bond work, where, he says: "We are incentivised to work with the complicated and with those willing to change." "We are incentivised to work with the complicated and with those willing to change."

More profile about the speaker
Toby Eccles | Speaker | TED.com