TEDxUSC
Jane Poynter: Life in Biosphere 2
Filmed:
Readability: 3.3
1,078,073 views
Jane Poynter tells her story of living two years and 20 minutes in Biosphere 2 -- an experience that provoked her to explore how we might sustain life in the harshest of environments.
Jane Poynter - Biospherian
After weathering two years in Biosphere 2, Jane Poynter is trying to create technologies that allow us to live in hostile environments -- like outer space. Full bio
After weathering two years in Biosphere 2, Jane Poynter is trying to create technologies that allow us to live in hostile environments -- like outer space. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I have had the distinct pleasure
0
0
3000
00:15
of living inside two biospheres.
1
3000
3000
00:18
Of course we all here in this room live in Biosphere 1.
2
6000
4000
00:22
I've also lived in Biosphere 2.
3
10000
4000
00:26
And the wonderful thing about that is that I get to compare biospheres.
4
14000
4000
00:30
And hopefully from that I get to learn something.
5
18000
3000
00:33
So what did I learn? Well,
6
21000
2000
00:35
here I am inside Biosphere 2, making a pizza.
7
23000
3000
00:38
So I am harvesting the wheat, in order to make the dough.
8
26000
3000
00:41
And then of course I have to milk the goats
9
29000
2000
00:43
and feed the goats in order to make the cheese.
10
31000
3000
00:46
It took me four months in Biosphere 2 to make a pizza.
11
34000
2000
00:48
Here in Biosphere 1, well it takes me about two minutes,
12
36000
3000
00:51
because I pick up the phone and I call and say,
13
39000
2000
00:53
"Hey, can you deliver the pizza?"
14
41000
2000
00:55
So Biosphere 2
15
43000
3000
00:58
was essentially a three-acre,
16
46000
2000
01:00
entirely sealed, miniature world
17
48000
2000
01:02
that I lived in for two years and 20 minutes.
18
50000
3000
01:05
(Laughter)
19
53000
3000
01:08
Over the top it was sealed with steel and glass,
20
56000
2000
01:10
underneath it was sealed with a pan of steel --
21
58000
3000
01:13
essentially entirely sealed.
22
61000
2000
01:15
So we had our own miniature rainforest,
23
63000
2000
01:17
a private beach with a coral reef.
24
65000
2000
01:19
We had a savanna, a marsh, a desert.
25
67000
3000
01:22
We had our own half-acre farm that we had to grow everything.
26
70000
3000
01:25
And of course we had our human habitat, where we lived.
27
73000
3000
01:28
Back in the mid-'80s when we were designing Biosphere 2,
28
76000
3000
01:31
we had to ask ourselves some pretty basic questions.
29
79000
2000
01:33
I mean, what is a biosphere?
30
81000
2000
01:35
Back then, yes, I guess we all know now
31
83000
2000
01:37
that it is essentially the sphere of life around the Earth, right?
32
85000
3000
01:40
Well, you have to get a little more specific than that if you're going to build one.
33
88000
3000
01:43
And so we decided that what it really is
34
91000
3000
01:46
is that it is entirely materially closed --
35
94000
3000
01:49
that is, nothing goes in or out at all, no material --
36
97000
3000
01:52
and energetically open,
37
100000
2000
01:54
which is essentially what planet Earth is.
38
102000
2000
01:56
This is a chamber that was 1/400th the size of Biosphere 2
39
104000
3000
01:59
that we called our Test Module.
40
107000
2000
02:01
And the very first day that this fellow, John Allen,
41
109000
2000
02:03
walked in, to spend a couple of days in there
42
111000
2000
02:05
with all the plants and animals and bacteria that we'd put in there
43
113000
2000
02:07
to hopefully keep him alive,
44
115000
2000
02:09
the doctors were incredibly concerned
45
117000
2000
02:11
that he was going to succumb to some dreadful toxin,
46
119000
2000
02:13
or that his lungs were going to get choked with bacteria or something, fungus.
47
121000
4000
02:17
But of course none of that happened.
48
125000
3000
02:20
And over the ensuing few years,
49
128000
2000
02:22
there were great sagas about designing Biosphere 2.
50
130000
2000
02:24
But by 1991
51
132000
2000
02:26
we finally had this thing built.
52
134000
2000
02:28
And it was time for us to go in
53
136000
2000
02:30
and give it a go.
54
138000
2000
02:32
We needed to know,
55
140000
2000
02:34
is life this malleable?
56
142000
2000
02:36
Can you take this biosphere,
57
144000
2000
02:38
that has evolved on a planetary scale,
58
146000
2000
02:40
and jam it into a little bottle,
59
148000
2000
02:42
and will it survive?
60
150000
2000
02:44
Big questions.
61
152000
2000
02:46
And we wanted to know this both for being able to go somewhere else
62
154000
3000
02:49
in the universe -- if we were going to go to Mars, for instance,
63
157000
3000
02:52
would we take a biosphere with us, to live in it?
64
160000
2000
02:54
We also wanted to know so we can understand more about
65
162000
2000
02:56
the Earth that we all live in.
66
164000
2000
02:58
Well, in 1991 it was finally time for us to go in
67
166000
3000
03:01
and try out this baby.
68
169000
2000
03:03
Let's take it on a maiden voyage.
69
171000
2000
03:05
Will it work? Or will something happen
70
173000
2000
03:07
that we can't understand and we can't fix,
71
175000
4000
03:11
thereby negating the concept of man-made biospheres?
72
179000
4000
03:15
So eight of us went in: four men and four women.
73
183000
3000
03:18
More on that later.
74
186000
2000
03:20
(Laughter)
75
188000
2000
03:22
And this is the world that we lived in.
76
190000
3000
03:25
So, on the top, we had
77
193000
2000
03:27
these beautiful rainforests and an ocean,
78
195000
2000
03:29
and underneath we had all this technosphere, we called it,
79
197000
4000
03:33
which is where all the pumps and the valves
80
201000
2000
03:35
and the water tanks and the air handlers, and all of that.
81
203000
3000
03:38
One of the Biospherians called it "garden of Eden
82
206000
2000
03:40
on top of an aircraft carrier."
83
208000
2000
03:42
And then also we had the human habitat of course,
84
210000
2000
03:44
with the laboratories, and all of that.
85
212000
2000
03:46
This is the agriculture.
86
214000
2000
03:48
It was essentially an organic farm.
87
216000
3000
03:51
The day I walked into Biosphere 2,
88
219000
2000
03:53
I was, for the first time,
89
221000
2000
03:55
breathing a completely different atmosphere
90
223000
3000
03:58
than everybody else in the world,
91
226000
2000
04:00
except seven other people.
92
228000
2000
04:02
At that moment I became part of that biosphere.
93
230000
4000
04:06
And I don't mean that in an abstract sense;
94
234000
3000
04:09
I mean it rather literally.
95
237000
2000
04:11
When I breathed out, my CO2
96
239000
3000
04:14
fed the sweet potatoes that I was growing.
97
242000
4000
04:18
And we ate an awful lot of the sweet potatoes.
98
246000
3000
04:21
(Laughter)
99
249000
2000
04:23
And those sweet potatoes
100
251000
2000
04:25
became part of me.
101
253000
2000
04:27
In fact, we ate so many sweet potatoes
102
255000
2000
04:29
I became orange with sweet potato.
103
257000
2000
04:31
I literally was eating the same carbon over and over again.
104
259000
4000
04:35
I was eating myself in some strange sort of bizarre way.
105
263000
4000
04:39
When it came to our atmosphere, however,
106
267000
2000
04:41
it wasn't that much of a joke over the long term,
107
269000
4000
04:45
because it turned out that we were losing oxygen, quite a lot of oxygen.
108
273000
4000
04:49
And we knew that we were losing CO2.
109
277000
2000
04:51
And so we were working to sequester carbon.
110
279000
3000
04:54
Good lord -- we know that term now.
111
282000
2000
04:56
We were growing plants like crazy.
112
284000
2000
04:58
We were taking their biomass, storing them in the basement,
113
286000
2000
05:00
growing plants, going around, around, around,
114
288000
2000
05:02
trying to take all of that carbon out of the atmosphere.
115
290000
2000
05:04
We were trying to stop carbon from going into the atmosphere.
116
292000
3000
05:07
We stopped irrigating our soil, as much as we could.
117
295000
2000
05:09
We stopped tilling, so that we could prevent greenhouse gasses from going into the air.
118
297000
4000
05:13
But our oxygen was going down faster
119
301000
2000
05:15
than our CO2 was going up, which was quite unexpected,
120
303000
3000
05:18
because we had seen them going in tandem in the test module.
121
306000
3000
05:21
And it was like playing atomic hide-and-seek.
122
309000
3000
05:24
We had lost seven tons of oxygen.
123
312000
2000
05:26
And we had no clue where it was.
124
314000
2000
05:28
And I tell you, when you lose a lot of oxygen --
125
316000
3000
05:31
and our oxygen went down quite far;
126
319000
2000
05:33
it went from 21 percent down to 14.2 percent --
127
321000
3000
05:36
my goodness, do you feel dreadful.
128
324000
3000
05:39
I mean we were dragging ourselves around the Biosphere.
129
327000
3000
05:42
And we had sleep apnea at night.
130
330000
2000
05:44
So you'd wake up gasping with breath,
131
332000
3000
05:47
because your blood chemistry has changed.
132
335000
2000
05:49
And that you literally do that. You stop breathing and then you -- (Gasps) --
133
337000
3000
05:52
take a breath and it wakes you up. And it's very irritating.
134
340000
2000
05:54
And everybody outside thought we were dying.
135
342000
2000
05:56
I mean, the media was making it sound like were were dying.
136
344000
2000
05:58
And I had to call up my mother every other day saying, "No, Mum, it's fine, fine.
137
346000
3000
06:01
We're not dead. We're fine. We're fine."
138
349000
2000
06:03
And the doctor was, in fact, checking us
139
351000
2000
06:05
to make sure we were, in fact, fine.
140
353000
2000
06:07
But in fact he was the person who was most susceptible to the oxygen.
141
355000
4000
06:11
And one day he couldn't add up a line of figures.
142
359000
2000
06:13
And it was time for us to put oxygen in.
143
361000
4000
06:17
And you might think, well,
144
365000
2000
06:19
"Boy, your life support system
145
367000
2000
06:21
was failing you. Wasn't that dreadful?"
146
369000
2000
06:23
Yes. In a sense it was terrifying.
147
371000
4000
06:27
Except that I knew I could walk out the airlock door
148
375000
3000
06:30
at any time, if it really got bad,
149
378000
2000
06:32
though who was going to say, "I can't take it anymore!"?
150
380000
3000
06:35
Not me, that was for sure.
151
383000
2000
06:37
But on the other hand, it was the scientific gold of the project,
152
385000
4000
06:41
because we could really crank this baby up,
153
389000
2000
06:43
as a scientific tool,
154
391000
2000
06:45
and see if we could, in fact, find
155
393000
2000
06:47
where those seven tons of oxygen had gone.
156
395000
3000
06:50
And we did indeed find it.
157
398000
2000
06:52
And we found it in the concrete.
158
400000
2000
06:54
Essentially it had done something very simple.
159
402000
2000
06:56
We had put too much carbon in the soil in the form of compost.
160
404000
3000
06:59
It broke down; it took oxygen out of the air;
161
407000
2000
07:01
it put CO2 into the air; and it went into the concrete.
162
409000
3000
07:04
Pretty straightforward really.
163
412000
2000
07:06
So at the end of the two years
164
414000
2000
07:08
when we came out, we were elated,
165
416000
2000
07:10
because, in fact, although you might say
166
418000
3000
07:13
we had discovered something that was quite "uhh,"
167
421000
3000
07:16
when your oxygen is going down,
168
424000
2000
07:18
stopped working, essentially, in your life support system,
169
426000
3000
07:21
that's a very bad failure.
170
429000
2000
07:23
Except that we knew what it was. And we knew how to fix it.
171
431000
3000
07:26
And nothing else emerged
172
434000
2000
07:28
that really was as serious as that.
173
436000
2000
07:30
And we proved the concept, more or less.
174
438000
2000
07:32
People, on the other hand, was a different subject.
175
440000
3000
07:35
We were -- yeah I don't know that we were fixable.
176
443000
3000
07:38
We all went quite nuts, I will say.
177
446000
2000
07:40
And the day I came out of Biosphere 2,
178
448000
2000
07:42
I was thrilled I was going to see all my family and my friends.
179
450000
4000
07:46
For two years I'd been seeing people through the glass.
180
454000
3000
07:49
And everybody ran up to me.
181
457000
2000
07:51
And I recoiled. They stank!
182
459000
4000
07:55
People stink!
183
463000
2000
07:57
We stink of hairspray and underarm deodorant,
184
465000
3000
08:00
and all kinds of stuff.
185
468000
2000
08:02
Now we had stuff inside Biosphere to keep ourselves clean,
186
470000
3000
08:05
but nothing with perfume.
187
473000
2000
08:07
And boy do we stink out here.
188
475000
3000
08:10
Not only that,
189
478000
2000
08:12
but I lost touch of where my food came from.
190
480000
4000
08:16
I had been growing all my own food.
191
484000
3000
08:19
I had no idea what was in my food, where it came from.
192
487000
3000
08:22
I didn't even recognize half the names in most of the food that I was eating.
193
490000
3000
08:25
In fact, I would stand for hours in the aisles of shops,
194
493000
3000
08:28
reading all the names on all of the things.
195
496000
2000
08:30
People must have thought I was nuts.
196
498000
2000
08:32
It was really quite astonishing.
197
500000
6000
08:38
And I slowly lost track
198
506000
3000
08:41
of where I was in this big biosphere, in this big biosphere that we all live in.
199
509000
4000
08:45
In Biosphere 2 I totally understood
200
513000
3000
08:48
that I had a huge impact on my biosphere, everyday,
201
516000
4000
08:52
and it had an impact on me,
202
520000
2000
08:54
very viscerally, very literally.
203
522000
2000
08:56
So I went about my business:
204
524000
2000
08:58
Paragon Space Development Corporation,
205
526000
2000
09:00
a little firm I started with people while I was in the Biosphere,
206
528000
2000
09:02
because I had nothing else to do.
207
530000
2000
09:04
And one of the things we did was
208
532000
2000
09:06
try to figure out: how small can you make these biospheres,
209
534000
2000
09:08
and what can you do with them?
210
536000
2000
09:10
And so we sent one onto the Mir Space Station.
211
538000
3000
09:13
We had one on the shuttle and one on the International Space Station,
212
541000
3000
09:16
for 16 months, where we managed to produce
213
544000
2000
09:18
the first organisms to go through
214
546000
2000
09:20
complete multiple life cycles in space --
215
548000
2000
09:22
really pushing the envelope
216
550000
2000
09:24
of understanding how malleable
217
552000
2000
09:26
our life systems are.
218
554000
3000
09:29
And I'm also proud to announce
219
557000
2000
09:31
that you're getting a sneak preview -- on Friday we're going to announce
220
559000
3000
09:34
that we're actually forming a team
221
562000
2000
09:36
to develop a system to grow plants on the Moon,
222
564000
3000
09:39
which is going to be pretty fun.
223
567000
2000
09:41
And the legacy of that is a system that we were designing:
224
569000
3000
09:44
an entirely sealed system to grow plants to grow on Mars.
225
572000
4000
09:48
And part of that is that we had to model
226
576000
2000
09:50
very rapid circulation of CO2
227
578000
4000
09:54
and oxygen and water through this plant system.
228
582000
3000
09:57
As a result of that modeling
229
585000
2000
09:59
I ended up in all places,
230
587000
2000
10:01
in Eritrea, in the Horn of Africa.
231
589000
3000
10:04
Eritrea, formerly part of Ethiopia,
232
592000
3000
10:07
is one of those places that is astonishingly beautiful,
233
595000
5000
10:12
incredibly stark, and I have no understanding
234
600000
4000
10:16
of how people eke out a living there.
235
604000
2000
10:18
It is so dry.
236
606000
2000
10:20
This is what I saw.
237
608000
2000
10:22
But this is also what I saw.
238
610000
2000
10:24
I saw a company that had
239
612000
3000
10:27
taken seawater
240
615000
3000
10:30
and sand, and they were growing
241
618000
3000
10:33
a kind of crop that will grow on pure salt water without having to treat it.
242
621000
4000
10:37
And it will produce a food crop.
243
625000
2000
10:39
In this case it was oilseed.
244
627000
2000
10:41
It was astonishing. They were also producing mangroves
245
629000
3000
10:44
in a plantation.
246
632000
2000
10:46
And the mangroves were providing wood
247
634000
2000
10:48
and honey and leaves for the animals,
248
636000
2000
10:50
so that they could produce milk and whatnot,
249
638000
2000
10:52
like we had in the Biosphere.
250
640000
2000
10:54
And all of it was coming from this: shrimp farms.
251
642000
4000
10:58
Shrimp farms are a scourge on the earth,
252
646000
2000
11:00
frankly, from an environmental point of view.
253
648000
2000
11:02
They pour huge amounts of pollutants into the ocean.
254
650000
3000
11:05
They also pollute their next-door neighbors.
255
653000
3000
11:08
So they're all shitting each other's ponds, quite literally.
256
656000
3000
11:11
And what this project was doing
257
659000
3000
11:14
was taking the effluent of these,
258
662000
2000
11:16
and turning them into all of this food.
259
664000
2000
11:18
They were literally turning pollution into abundance for a desert people.
260
666000
5000
11:23
They had created an industrial ecosystem, of a sense.
261
671000
4000
11:27
I was there because I was actually modeling the mangrove portion
262
675000
4000
11:31
for a carbon credit program, under the U.N.
263
679000
2000
11:33
Kyoto Protocol system.
264
681000
2000
11:35
And as I was modeling this mangrove swamp,
265
683000
2000
11:37
I was thinking to myself, "How do you put a box around this?"
266
685000
3000
11:40
When I'm modeling a plant in a box, literally,
267
688000
3000
11:43
I know where to draw the boundary.
268
691000
2000
11:45
In a mangrove forest like this I have no idea.
269
693000
3000
11:48
Well, of course you have to draw the boundary around the whole of the Earth.
270
696000
3000
11:51
And understand its interactions with the entire Earth.
271
699000
3000
11:54
And put your project in that context.
272
702000
5000
11:59
Around the world today we're seeing an incredible transformation,
273
707000
5000
12:04
from what I would call a biocidal species,
274
712000
4000
12:08
one that -- whether we intentionally or unintentionally --
275
716000
3000
12:11
have designed our systems to kill life, a lot of the time.
276
719000
4000
12:15
This is in fact, this beautiful photograph,
277
723000
4000
12:19
is in fact over the Amazon.
278
727000
2000
12:21
And here the light green are areas of massive deforestation.
279
729000
5000
12:26
And those beautiful wispy clouds
280
734000
2000
12:28
are, in fact, fires, human-made fires.
281
736000
4000
12:32
We're in the process of transforming from this,
282
740000
3000
12:35
to what I would call a biophilic society,
283
743000
4000
12:39
one where we learn to nurture society.
284
747000
3000
12:42
Now it may not seem like it, but we are.
285
750000
3000
12:45
It is happening all across the world,
286
753000
3000
12:48
in every kind of walk of life,
287
756000
2000
12:50
and every kind of career
288
758000
2000
12:52
and industry that you can think of.
289
760000
4000
12:56
And I think often times people get lost in that.
290
764000
3000
12:59
They go, "But how can I possibly find my way in that?
291
767000
3000
13:02
It's such a huge subject."
292
770000
2000
13:04
And I would say that the small stuff counts. It really does.
293
772000
4000
13:08
This is the story of a rake in my backyard.
294
776000
5000
13:13
This was my backyard,
295
781000
2000
13:15
very early on, when I bought my property.
296
783000
2000
13:17
And in Arizona, of course, everybody puts gravel down.
297
785000
3000
13:20
And they like to keep everything beautifully raked. And they keep all the leaves away.
298
788000
4000
13:24
And on Sunday morning the neighbors leaf blower comes out,
299
792000
3000
13:27
and I want to throttle them.
300
795000
2000
13:29
It's a certain type of aesthetic.
301
797000
3000
13:32
We're very uncomfortable with untidiness.
302
800000
3000
13:35
And I threw away my rake.
303
803000
4000
13:39
And I let all of the leaves fall from the trees that I have on my property.
304
807000
4000
13:43
And over time, essentially what have I been doing?
305
811000
2000
13:45
I've been building topsoil.
306
813000
2000
13:47
And so now all the birds come in. And I have hawks.
307
815000
2000
13:49
And I have an oasis.
308
817000
4000
13:53
This is what happens every spring. For six weeks,
309
821000
4000
13:57
six to eight weeks, I have this flush of green oasis.
310
825000
3000
14:00
This is actually in a riparian area.
311
828000
2000
14:02
And all of Tucson could be like this
312
830000
2000
14:04
if everybody would just revolt and throw away the rake.
313
832000
3000
14:07
The small stuff counts.
314
835000
4000
14:11
The Industrial Revolution -- and Prometheus --
315
839000
3000
14:14
has given us this, the ability to light up the world.
316
842000
5000
14:19
It has also given us this,
317
847000
2000
14:21
the ability to look at the world from the outside.
318
849000
4000
14:25
Now we may not all have
319
853000
2000
14:27
another biosphere that we can run to,
320
855000
2000
14:29
and compare it to this biosphere.
321
857000
3000
14:32
But we can look at the world,
322
860000
2000
14:34
and try to understand where we are in its context,
323
862000
5000
14:39
and how we choose to interact with it.
324
867000
4000
14:43
And if you lose where you are in your biosphere,
325
871000
3000
14:46
or are perhaps having a difficulty connecting
326
874000
2000
14:48
with where you are in the biosphere,
327
876000
2000
14:50
I would say to you,
328
878000
3000
14:53
take a deep breath.
329
881000
3000
14:56
The yogis had it right.
330
884000
2000
14:58
Breath does, in fact, connect us all
331
886000
3000
15:01
in a very literal way.
332
889000
2000
15:03
Take a breath now.
333
891000
2000
15:05
And as you breathe, think
334
893000
2000
15:07
about what is in your breath.
335
895000
4000
15:11
There perhaps is the CO2 from the person sitting next-door to you.
336
899000
5000
15:16
Maybe there is a little bit of oxygen
337
904000
2000
15:18
from some algae on the beach not far from here.
338
906000
5000
15:23
It also connects us in time.
339
911000
3000
15:26
There may be some carbon in your breath
340
914000
4000
15:30
from the dinosaurs.
341
918000
3000
15:33
There could also be carbon that you are exhaling now
342
921000
5000
15:38
that will be in the breath
343
926000
4000
15:42
of your great-great-great-grandchildren.
344
930000
3000
15:45
Thank you. (Applause)
345
933000
2000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jane Poynter - BiospherianAfter weathering two years in Biosphere 2, Jane Poynter is trying to create technologies that allow us to live in hostile environments -- like outer space.
Why you should listen
Jane Poynter is one of only eight people to live in Biosphere 2 for two years. In 1991, she and seven others were locked in a three-acre, hermetically-sealed environment in the Arizona desert. Nothing was allowed in or out, and everything had to be recycled. Poynter, and the rest of the team, endured dangerously low oxygen levels and constant hunger, but they survived -- something many scientists said was impossible.
After leaving Biosphere 2, Poynter went on to found Paragon Space Development Corporation, along with her former fellow biospherian and now husband, Taber MacCallum. Paragon develops technologies that might allow humans to live in extreme environments such as outer space and underwater. As president of Paragon, Poynter has had experiments flown on the International Space Station, Russian Mir Space Station and US Space Shuttle, as well as working on underwater technologies with the US Navy.
However, Poynter has not given up on her homeland -- Biosphere 1. She continues to consult on and write about sustainable development and new green technologies. In concert with the World Bank, she has worked on projects to mitigate climate change and to grow crops in typically arid and hostile regions of Africa and Central America. Through talks and appearances, she builds awareness of the fragile state of the environment. After all, she knows what it's like to watch your biosphere begin to break down.
The New York Times looks back on the Biosphere 2 story >>
Jane Poynter | Speaker | TED.com