TEDGlobal 2012
Leslie T. Chang: The voices of China's workers
Filmed:
Readability: 3.8
1,558,400 views
In the ongoing debate about globalization, what's been missing is the voices of workers -- the millions of people who migrate to factories in China and other emerging countries to make goods sold all over the world. Reporter Leslie T. Chang sought out women who work in one of China's booming megacities, and tells their stories.
Leslie T. Chang - Journalist
In her reporting and writing, Leslie T. Chang explores the lives of workers in China, focusing on the experience of women. Full bio
In her reporting and writing, Leslie T. Chang explores the lives of workers in China, focusing on the experience of women. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Hi. So I'd like to talk a little bit about the people
0
794
2416
00:19
who make the things we use every day:
1
3210
2529
00:21
our shoes, our handbags, our computers and cell phones.
2
5739
3760
00:25
Now, this is a conversation that often calls up a lot of guilt.
3
9499
4446
00:29
Imagine the teenage farm girl who makes less than
4
13945
3591
00:33
a dollar an hour stitching your running shoes,
5
17536
2856
00:36
or the young Chinese man who jumps off a rooftop
6
20392
2698
00:38
after working overtime assembling your iPad.
7
23090
4040
00:43
We, the beneficiaries of globalization, seem to exploit
8
27130
3608
00:46
these victims with every purchase we make,
9
30738
2703
00:49
and the injustice
10
33441
1633
00:50
feels embedded in the products themselves.
11
35074
3089
00:54
After all, what's wrong with a world in which a worker
12
38163
2560
00:56
on an iPhone assembly line can't even afford to buy one?
13
40723
3776
01:00
It's taken for granted that Chinese factories are oppressive,
14
44499
2650
01:03
and that it's our desire for cheap goods
15
47149
2731
01:05
that makes them so.
16
49880
2361
01:08
So, this simple narrative equating Western demand
17
52241
3815
01:11
and Chinese suffering is appealing,
18
56056
2812
01:14
especially at a time when many of us already feel guilty
19
58868
2635
01:17
about our impact on the world,
20
61503
2578
01:19
but it's also inaccurate and disrespectful.
21
64081
3783
01:23
We must be peculiarly self-obsessed to imagine that we
22
67864
2984
01:26
have the power to drive tens of millions of people
23
70848
3168
01:29
on the other side of the world to migrate and suffer
24
74016
2712
01:32
in such terrible ways.
25
76728
2795
01:35
In fact, China makes goods for markets all over the world,
26
79523
2818
01:38
including its own, thanks to a combination of factors:
27
82341
3588
01:41
its low costs, its large and educated workforce,
28
85929
3406
01:45
and a flexible manufacturing system
29
89335
2466
01:47
that responds quickly to market demands.
30
91801
3151
01:50
By focusing so much on ourselves and our gadgets,
31
94952
3049
01:53
we have rendered the individuals on the other end
32
98001
2463
01:56
into invisibility, as tiny and interchangeable
33
100464
3360
01:59
as the parts of a mobile phone.
34
103824
3055
02:02
Chinese workers are not forced into factories
35
106879
2665
02:05
because of our insatiable desire for iPods.
36
109544
2479
02:07
They choose to leave their homes in order to earn money,
37
112023
3072
02:10
to learn new skills, and to see the world.
38
115095
3953
02:14
In the ongoing debate about globalization, what's
39
119048
2393
02:17
been missing is the voices of the workers themselves.
40
121441
3431
02:20
Here are a few.
41
124872
2305
02:23
Bao Yongxiu: "My mother tells me to come home
42
127177
3749
02:26
and get married, but if I marry now, before I have fully
43
130926
3724
02:30
developed myself, I can only marry an ordinary worker,
44
134650
4085
02:34
so I'm not in a rush."
45
138735
2503
02:37
Chen Ying: "When I went home for the new year,
46
141238
3042
02:40
everyone said I had changed. They asked me,
47
144280
3256
02:43
what did you do that you have changed so much?
48
147536
3097
02:46
I told them that I studied and worked hard. If you tell them
49
150633
3278
02:49
more, they won't understand anyway."
50
153911
3368
02:53
Wu Chunming: "Even if I make a lot of money,
51
157279
3385
02:56
it won't satisfy me.
52
160664
2151
02:58
Just to make money is not enough meaning in life."
53
162815
4369
03:03
Xiao Jin: "Now, after I get off work, I study English,
54
167184
4712
03:07
because in the future, our customers won't
55
171896
1789
03:09
be only Chinese, so we must learn more languages."
56
173685
3862
03:13
All of these speakers, by the way, are young women,
57
177547
2771
03:16
18 or 19 years old.
58
180318
3082
03:19
So I spent two years getting to know assembly line workers
59
183400
2942
03:22
like these in the south China factory city called Dongguan.
60
186342
3929
03:26
Certain subjects came up over and over:
61
190271
2520
03:28
how much money they made,
62
192791
1904
03:30
what kind of husband they hoped to marry,
63
194695
2379
03:32
whether they should jump to another factory
64
197074
2125
03:35
or stay where they were.
65
199199
2200
03:37
Other subjects came up almost never, including
66
201399
2193
03:39
living conditions that to me looked close to prison life:
67
203592
3447
03:42
10 or 15 workers in one room,
68
207039
2283
03:45
50 people sharing a single bathroom,
69
209322
3359
03:48
days and nights ruled by the factory clock.
70
212681
3334
03:51
Everyone they knew lived in similar circumstances,
71
216015
3488
03:55
and it was still better than the dormitories and homes
72
219503
2761
03:58
of rural China.
73
222264
2568
04:00
The workers rarely spoke about the products they made,
74
224832
2726
04:03
and they often had great difficulty explaining
75
227558
2344
04:05
what exactly they did.
76
229902
2442
04:08
When I asked Lu Qingmin,
77
232344
1711
04:09
the young woman I got to know best,
78
234055
2102
04:12
what exactly she did on the factory floor,
79
236157
2467
04:14
she said something to me in Chinese that sounded like
80
238624
2405
04:16
"qiu xi."
81
241029
1777
04:18
Only much later did I realize that she had been saying
82
242806
2969
04:21
"QC," or quality control.
83
245775
3224
04:24
She couldn't even tell me what she did on the factory floor.
84
248999
3863
04:28
All she could do was parrot a garbled abbreviation
85
252862
2457
04:31
in a language she didn't even understand.
86
255319
3994
04:35
Karl Marx saw this as the tragedy of capitalism,
87
259313
3622
04:38
the alienation of the worker from the product of his labor.
88
262935
4043
04:42
Unlike, say, a traditional maker of shoes or cabinets,
89
266978
3624
04:46
the worker in an industrial factory has no control,
90
270602
3247
04:49
no pleasure, and no true satisfaction or understanding
91
273849
3257
04:53
in her own work.
92
277106
2191
04:55
But like so many theories that Marx arrived at
93
279297
2416
04:57
sitting in the reading room of the British Museum,
94
281713
2819
05:00
he got this one wrong.
95
284532
2826
05:03
Just because a person spends her time
96
287358
2299
05:05
making a piece of something does not mean
97
289657
2768
05:08
that she becomes that, a piece of something.
98
292425
2552
05:10
What she does with the money she earns,
99
294977
3103
05:13
what she learns in that place, and how it changes her,
100
298080
3505
05:17
these are the things that matter.
101
301585
2761
05:20
What a factory makes is never the point, and
102
304346
2300
05:22
the workers could not care less who buys their products.
103
306646
4084
05:26
Journalistic coverage of Chinese factories,
104
310730
2488
05:29
on the other hand, plays up this relationship
105
313218
2112
05:31
between the workers and the products they make.
106
315330
2829
05:34
Many articles calculate: How long would it take
107
318159
3089
05:37
for this worker to work in order to earn enough money
108
321248
2844
05:39
to buy what he's making?
109
324092
2460
05:42
For example, an entry-level-line assembly line worker
110
326552
2488
05:44
in China in an iPhone plant would have to shell out
111
329040
3272
05:48
two and a half months' wages for an iPhone.
112
332312
3545
05:51
But how meaningful is this calculation, really?
113
335857
3337
05:55
For example, I recently wrote an article
114
339194
1990
05:57
in The New Yorker magazine,
115
341184
978
05:58
but I can't afford to buy an ad in it.
116
342162
3239
06:01
But, who cares? I don't want an ad in The New Yorker,
117
345401
2056
06:03
and most of these workers don't really want iPhones.
118
347457
2865
06:06
Their calculations are different.
119
350322
2760
06:08
How long should I stay in this factory?
120
353082
1814
06:10
How much money can I save?
121
354896
2463
06:13
How much will it take to buy an apartment or a car,
122
357359
2570
06:15
to get married, or to put my child through school?
123
359929
4590
06:20
The workers I got to know had a curiously abstract
124
364519
2691
06:23
relationship with the product of their labor.
125
367210
3758
06:26
About a year after I met Lu Qingmin, or Min,
126
370968
3142
06:30
she invited me home to her family village
127
374110
2034
06:32
for the Chinese New Year.
128
376144
2223
06:34
On the train home, she gave me a present:
129
378367
2386
06:36
a Coach brand change purse with brown leather trim.
130
380753
4391
06:41
I thanked her, assuming it was fake,
131
385144
1673
06:42
like almost everything else for sale in Dongguan.
132
386817
3477
06:46
After we got home, Min gave her mother another present:
133
390294
3809
06:50
a pink Dooney & Bourke handbag,
134
394103
2185
06:52
and a few nights later, her sister was showing off
135
396288
2423
06:54
a maroon LeSportsac shoulder bag.
136
398711
3504
06:58
Slowly it was dawning on me that these handbags
137
402215
3800
07:01
were made by their factory,
138
406015
2017
07:03
and every single one of them was authentic.
139
408032
3166
07:07
Min's sister said to her parents,
140
411198
2465
07:09
"In America, this bag sells for 320 dollars."
141
413663
3362
07:12
Her parents, who are both farmers, looked on, speechless.
142
417025
3039
07:15
"And that's not all -- Coach is coming out with a new line,
143
420064
2559
07:18
2191," she said. "One bag will sell for 6,000."
144
422623
4801
07:23
She paused and said, "I don't know if that's 6,000 yuan or
145
427424
4247
07:27
6,000 American dollars, but anyway, it's 6,000." (Laughter)
146
431671
5647
07:33
Min's sister's boyfriend, who had traveled home with her
147
437318
2595
07:35
for the new year, said,
148
439913
2117
07:37
"It doesn't look like it's worth that much."
149
442030
2833
07:40
Min's sister turned to him and said, "Some people actually
150
444863
2825
07:43
understand these things. You don't understand shit."
151
447688
3544
07:47
(Laughter) (Applause)
152
451232
4655
07:51
In Min's world, the Coach bags had a curious currency.
153
455887
4040
07:55
They weren't exactly worthless, but they were nothing
154
459927
2320
07:58
close to the actual value, because almost no one they knew
155
462247
2710
08:00
wanted to buy one, or knew how much it was worth.
156
464957
3930
08:04
Once, when Min's older sister's friend got married,
157
468887
3355
08:08
she brought a handbag along as a wedding present.
158
472242
2828
08:10
Another time, after Min had already left
159
475070
2168
08:13
the handbag factory, her younger sister came to visit,
160
477238
3142
08:16
bringing two Coach Signature handbags as gifts.
161
480380
4111
08:20
I looked in the zippered pocket of one,
162
484491
2075
08:22
and I found a printed card in English, which read,
163
486566
4239
08:26
"An American classic.
164
490805
3258
08:29
In 1941, the burnished patina
165
494063
2510
08:32
of an all-American baseball glove
166
496573
2362
08:34
inspired the founder of Coach to create
167
498935
2200
08:37
a new collection of handbags from the same
168
501135
2409
08:39
luxuriously soft gloved-hand leather.
169
503544
3209
08:42
Six skilled leatherworkers crafted 12 Signature handbags
170
506753
4175
08:46
with perfect proportions and a timeless flair.
171
510928
4136
08:50
They were fresh, functional, and women everywhere
172
515064
2280
08:53
adored them. A new American classic was born."
173
517344
5336
08:58
I wonder what Karl Marx would have made of Min
174
522680
2326
09:00
and her sisters.
175
525006
1908
09:02
Their relationship with the product of their labor
176
526914
2607
09:05
was more complicated, surprising and funny
177
529521
2295
09:07
than he could have imagined.
178
531816
2258
09:09
And yet, his view of the world persists, and our tendency
179
534074
2823
09:12
to see the workers as faceless masses,
180
536897
2609
09:15
to imagine that we can know what they're really thinking.
181
539506
3874
09:19
The first time I met Min, she had just turned 18
182
543380
3401
09:22
and quit her first job on the assembly line
183
546781
2655
09:25
of an electronics factory.
184
549436
2315
09:27
Over the next two years, I watched as she switched jobs
185
551751
2646
09:30
five times, eventually landing a lucrative post
186
554397
3076
09:33
in the purchasing department of a hardware factory.
187
557473
3574
09:36
Later, she married a fellow migrant worker,
188
561047
2525
09:39
moved with him to his village,
189
563572
2142
09:41
gave birth to two daughters,
190
565714
2203
09:43
and saved enough money to buy a secondhand Buick
191
567917
2188
09:46
for herself and an apartment for her parents.
192
570105
4406
09:50
She recently returned to Dongguan on her own
193
574511
3133
09:53
to take a job in a factory that makes construction cranes,
194
577644
3616
09:57
temporarily leaving her husband and children
195
581260
2200
09:59
back in the village.
196
583460
1983
10:01
In a recent email to me, she explained,
197
585443
2581
10:03
"A person should have some ambition while she is young
198
588024
4046
10:07
so that in old age she can look back on her life
199
592070
2662
10:10
and feel that it was not lived to no purpose."
200
594732
4783
10:15
Across China, there are 150 million workers like her,
201
599515
4396
10:19
one third of them women, who have left their villages
202
603911
2753
10:22
to work in the factories, the hotels, the restaurants
203
606664
3543
10:26
and the construction sites of the big cities.
204
610207
2605
10:28
Together, they make up the largest migration in history,
205
612812
3744
10:32
and it is globalization, this chain that begins
206
616556
3000
10:35
in a Chinese farming village
207
619556
2519
10:37
and ends with iPhones in our pockets and Nikes on our feet
208
622075
3777
10:41
and Coach handbags on our arms
209
625852
2424
10:44
that has changed the way these millions of people
210
628276
2289
10:46
work and marry and live and think.
211
630565
4913
10:51
Very few of them would want to go back
212
635478
1949
10:53
to the way things used to be.
213
637427
2557
10:55
When I first went to Dongguan, I worried that
214
639984
3180
10:59
it would be depressing to spend so much time with workers.
215
643164
4375
11:03
I also worried that nothing would ever happen to them,
216
647539
2771
11:06
or that they would have nothing to say to me.
217
650310
2629
11:08
Instead, I found young women who were smart and funny
218
652939
2650
11:11
and brave and generous.
219
655589
2847
11:14
By opening up their lives to me,
220
658436
2331
11:16
they taught me so much about factories
221
660767
2206
11:18
and about China and about how to live in the world.
222
662973
4206
11:25
This is the Coach purse that Min gave me
223
669486
2712
11:28
on the train home to visit her family.
224
672198
2410
11:30
I keep it with me to remind me of the ties that tie me
225
674608
2643
11:33
to the young women I wrote about,
226
677251
2724
11:35
ties that are not economic but personal in nature,
227
679975
4270
11:40
measured not in money but in memories.
228
684245
3567
11:43
This purse is also a reminder that the things that you imagine,
229
687812
3419
11:47
sitting in your office or in the library,
230
691231
3542
11:50
are not how you find them when you actually go out
231
694773
2403
11:53
into the world.
232
697176
1507
11:54
Thank you. (Applause)
233
698683
1988
11:56
(Applause)
234
700671
6672
12:03
Chris Anderson: Thank you, Leslie, that was an insight
235
707343
2069
12:05
that a lot of us haven't had before.
236
709412
2597
12:07
But I'm curious. If you had a minute, say,
237
712009
3487
12:11
with Apple's head of manufacturing,
238
715496
3721
12:15
what would you say?
239
719217
2360
12:17
Leslie Chang: One minute?
240
721577
1128
12:18
CA: One minute. (Laughter)
241
722705
1513
12:20
LC: You know, what really impressed me about the workers
242
724218
1926
12:22
is how much they're self-motivated, self-driven,
243
726144
3226
12:25
resourceful, and the thing that struck me,
244
729370
2617
12:27
what they want most is education, to learn,
245
731987
2965
12:30
because most of them come from very poor backgrounds.
246
734952
1547
12:32
They usually left school when they were in 7th or 8th grade.
247
736499
2944
12:35
Their parents are often illiterate,
248
739443
2239
12:37
and then they come to the city, and they, on their own,
249
741682
2640
12:40
at night, during the weekends, they'll take a computer class,
250
744322
2125
12:42
they'll take an English class, and learn
251
746447
2268
12:44
really, really rudimentary things, you know,
252
748715
2124
12:46
like how to type a document in Word,
253
750839
1739
12:48
or how to say really simple things in English.
254
752578
2664
12:51
So, if you really want to help these workers,
255
755242
2128
12:53
start these small, very focused, very pragmatic classes
256
757370
3223
12:56
in these schools, and what's going to happen is,
257
760593
3129
12:59
all your workers are going to move on,
258
763722
1419
13:01
but hopefully they'll move on into higher jobs within Apple,
259
765141
3407
13:04
and you can help their social mobility
260
768548
2941
13:07
and their self-improvement.
261
771489
997
13:08
When you talk to workers, that's what they want.
262
772486
1778
13:10
They do not say, "I want better hot water in the showers.
263
774264
2674
13:12
I want a nicer room. I want a TV set."
264
776938
1985
13:14
I mean, it would be nice to have those things,
265
778923
1623
13:16
but that's not why they're in the city,
266
780546
1158
13:17
and that's not what they care about.
267
781704
2089
13:19
CA: Was there a sense from them of a narrative that
268
783793
3550
13:23
things were kind of tough and bad, or was there a narrative
269
787343
3412
13:26
of some kind of level of growth, that things over time
270
790755
3013
13:29
were getting better?
271
793768
1623
13:31
LC: Oh definitely, definitely. I mean, you know,
272
795391
1907
13:33
it was interesting, because I spent basically two years
273
797298
2366
13:35
hanging out in this city, Dongguan,
274
799664
1994
13:37
and over that time, you could see immense change
275
801658
2111
13:39
in every person's life: upward, downward, sideways,
276
803769
2795
13:42
but generally upward.
277
806564
1821
13:44
If you spend enough time, it's upward, and I met people
278
808385
1787
13:46
who had moved to the city 10 years ago, and who are now
279
810172
2295
13:48
basically urban middle class people,
280
812467
2107
13:50
so the trajectory is definitely upward.
281
814574
2021
13:52
It's just hard to see when you're suddenly
282
816595
1935
13:54
sucked into the city. It looks like everyone's poor and
283
818530
2121
13:56
desperate, but that's not really how it is.
284
820651
1738
13:58
Certainly, the factory conditions are really tough,
285
822389
2154
14:00
and it's nothing you or I would want to do,
286
824543
2317
14:02
but from their perspective, where they're coming from
287
826860
3145
14:05
is much worse, and where they're going
288
830005
1997
14:07
is hopefully much better, and I just wanted to give
289
832002
2008
14:09
that context of what's going on in their minds,
290
834010
2361
14:12
not what necessarily is going on in yours.
291
836371
2363
14:14
CA: Thanks so much for your talk.
292
838734
1496
14:16
Thank you very much. (Applause)
293
840230
4369
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Leslie T. Chang - JournalistIn her reporting and writing, Leslie T. Chang explores the lives of workers in China, focusing on the experience of women.
Why you should listen
Leslie T. Chang's book Factory Girls: From Village to City in a Changing China traces the lives of Chunming and Min, two young women working in Dongguan, a factory city in South China. Leaving their home villages far behind in pursuit of work, Chunming and Min are part of an estimated 10 million young migrants (estimated to be 70 percent women) who work in China's booming factories. These migrants live in a "perpetual present," forging individual and nontraditional lives amid the breakneck pace of manufacturing.
As Chang gets to know these two women and others, she reveals the harsh realities of China's spectacular industrial growth, and also explores her family's own history of migration from mainland China.
Chang lived in China for a decade as a correspondent for The Wall Street Journal. She is now based in Egypt.
Leslie T. Chang | Speaker | TED.com