TEDGlobal 2012
Shimon Schocken: The self-organizing computer course
Filmed:
Readability: 4.9
1,052,300 views
Shimon Schocken and Noam Nisan developed a curriculum for their students to build a computer, piece by piece. When they put the course online -- giving away the tools, simulators, chip specifications and other building blocks -- they were surprised that thousands jumped at the opportunity to learn, working independently as well as organizing their own classes in the first Massive Open Online Course (MOOC). A call to forget about grades and tap into the self-motivation to learn.
Shimon Schocken - Computer Scientist, Educator
Shimon Schocken is a computer science professor and dedicated educator. Full bio
Shimon Schocken is a computer science professor and dedicated educator. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:19
So, this is my grandfather,
0
3646
2966
00:22
Salman Schocken,
1
6612
1501
00:24
who was born into a poor and uneducated family
2
8113
4437
00:28
with six children to feed,
3
12550
3437
00:31
and when he was 14 years old, he was forced to
4
15987
3696
00:35
drop out of school in order to help put bread on the table.
5
19683
3960
00:39
He never went back to school.
6
23643
3420
00:42
Instead, he went on to build a glittering empire
7
27063
4147
00:47
of department stores.
8
31210
2108
00:49
Salman was the consummate perfectionist,
9
33318
3253
00:52
and every one of his stores was a jewel
10
36571
2564
00:55
of Bauhaus architecture.
11
39135
1929
00:56
He was also the ultimate self-learner,
12
41064
3190
01:00
and like everything else, he did it in grand style.
13
44254
2903
01:03
He surrounded himself with an entourage
14
47157
2688
01:05
of young, unknown scholars like Martin Buber
15
49845
3387
01:09
and Shai Agnon and Franz Kafka,
16
53232
3139
01:12
and he paid each one of them a monthly salary
17
56371
2925
01:15
so that they could write in peace.
18
59296
3051
01:18
And yet, in the late '30s, Salman saw what's coming.
19
62347
4937
01:23
He fled Germany, together with his family,
20
67284
3314
01:26
leaving everything else behind.
21
70598
2089
01:28
His department stores confiscated,
22
72687
3210
01:31
he spent the rest of his life in a relentless pursuit
23
75897
3089
01:34
of art and culture.
24
78986
2469
01:37
This high school dropout
25
81455
1939
01:39
died at the age of 82,
26
83394
2280
01:41
a formidable intellectual, cofounder and first CEO
27
85674
4129
01:45
of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem,
28
89803
2145
01:47
and founder of Schocken Books,
29
91948
1764
01:49
an acclaimed imprint that was later acquired
30
93712
3371
01:52
by Random House.
31
97083
1670
01:54
Such is the power of self-study.
32
98753
3976
01:58
And these are my parents.
33
102729
2516
02:01
They too did not enjoy the privilege of college education.
34
105245
4047
02:05
They were too busy building a family and a country.
35
109292
3971
02:09
And yet, just like Salman, they were lifelong,
36
113263
4028
02:13
tenacious self-learners, and our home was stacked
37
117291
3758
02:16
with thousands of books, records and artwork.
38
121049
4163
02:21
I remember quite vividly my father telling me
39
125212
2396
02:23
that when everyone in the neighborhood will have a TV set,
40
127608
4832
02:28
then we'll buy a normal F.M. radio. (Laughter)
41
132440
4618
02:32
And that's me,
42
137058
3029
02:35
I was going to say holding my first abacus,
43
140087
1724
02:37
but actually holding what my father would consider
44
141811
3011
02:40
an ample substitute to an iPad. (Laughter)
45
144822
2952
02:43
So one thing that I took from home is this notion
46
147774
3662
02:47
that educators don't necessarily have to teach.
47
151436
2841
02:50
Instead, they can provide an environment and resources
48
154277
3229
02:53
that tease out your natural ability to learn on your own.
49
157506
5148
02:58
Self-study, self-exploration, self-empowerment:
50
162654
4094
03:02
these are the virtues of a great education.
51
166748
3320
03:05
So I'd like to share with you a story about a self-study,
52
170068
4195
03:10
self-empowering computer science course
53
174263
2554
03:12
that I built, together with my brilliant colleague Noam Nisan.
54
176817
4186
03:16
As you can see from the pictures, both Noam and I
55
181003
2757
03:19
had an early fascination with first principles,
56
183760
3418
03:23
and over the years, as our knowledge of
57
187178
1522
03:24
science and technology became more sophisticated,
58
188700
3575
03:28
this early awe with the basics
59
192275
3196
03:31
has only intensified.
60
195471
2100
03:33
So it's not surprising that, about 12 years ago, when
61
197571
3699
03:37
Noam and I were already computer science professors,
62
201270
3482
03:40
we were equally frustrated by the same phenomenon.
63
204752
3752
03:44
As computers became increasingly more complex,
64
208504
2818
03:47
our students were losing the forest for the trees,
65
211322
3204
03:50
and indeed, it is impossible to connect
66
214526
3087
03:53
with the soul of the machine if you interact
67
217613
2642
03:56
with a black box P.C. or a Mac which is shrouded
68
220255
3409
03:59
by numerous layers of closed, proprietary software.
69
223664
3376
04:02
So Noam and I had this insight that if we want our students
70
227040
3690
04:06
to understand how computers work,
71
230730
2019
04:08
and understand it in the marrow of their bones,
72
232749
3088
04:11
then perhaps the best way to go about it
73
235837
1561
04:13
is to have them build a complete, working,
74
237398
4594
04:17
general-purpose, useful computer, hardware and software,
75
241992
3712
04:21
from the ground up, from first principles.
76
245704
3530
04:25
Now, we had to start somewhere, and so Noam and I
77
249234
4208
04:29
decided to base our cathedral, so to speak,
78
253442
3490
04:32
on the simplest possible building block,
79
256932
3139
04:35
which is something called NAND.
80
260071
2801
04:38
It is nothing more than a trivial logic gate
81
262872
3938
04:42
with four input-output states.
82
266810
3038
04:45
So we now start this journey by telling our students
83
269848
2666
04:48
that God gave us NAND — (Laughter) —
84
272514
2068
04:50
and told us to build a computer, and when we asked how,
85
274582
3985
04:54
God said, "One step at a time."
86
278567
3184
04:57
And then, following this advice, we start
87
281751
3093
05:00
with this lowly, humble NAND gate,
88
284844
2959
05:03
and we walk our students through an elaborate sequence
89
287803
1940
05:05
of projects in which they gradually build a chip set,
90
289743
3737
05:09
a hardware platform, an assembler, a virtual machine,
91
293480
4112
05:13
a basic operating system and a compiler
92
297592
3577
05:17
for a simple, Java-like language that we call "JACK."
93
301169
6189
05:23
The students celebrate the end of this tour de force
94
307358
2548
05:25
by using JACK to write all sorts of cool games
95
309906
2834
05:28
like Pong, Snake and Tetris.
96
312740
2992
05:31
You can imagine the tremendous joy of playing
97
315732
3615
05:35
with a Tetris game that you wrote in JACK
98
319347
3024
05:38
and then compiled into machine language in a compiler
99
322371
2790
05:41
that you wrote also, and then seeing the result
100
325161
2408
05:43
running on a machine that you built starting
101
327569
2883
05:46
with nothing more than a few thousand NAND gates.
102
330452
3284
05:49
It's a tremendous personal triumph of going
103
333736
3190
05:52
from first principles all the way to a fantastically complex
104
336926
4725
05:57
and useful system.
105
341651
2351
05:59
Noam and I worked five years to facilitate
106
344002
4397
06:04
this ascent and to create the tools and infrastructure
107
348399
3208
06:07
that will enable students to build it in one semester.
108
351607
3173
06:10
And this is the great team that helped us make it happen.
109
354780
4039
06:14
The trick was to decompose the computer's construction
110
358819
4247
06:18
into numerous stand-alone modules,
111
363066
2954
06:21
each of which could be individually specified,
112
366020
3900
06:25
built and unit-tested in isolation from the rest of the project.
113
369920
5235
06:31
And from day one, Noam and I decided to put
114
375155
2989
06:34
all these building blocks freely available in open source
115
378144
3536
06:37
on the Web.
116
381680
1480
06:39
So chip specifications, APIs, project descriptions,
117
383160
4471
06:43
software tools, hardware simulators, CPU emulators,
118
387631
3904
06:47
stacks of hundreds of slides, lectures --
119
391535
3702
06:51
we laid out everything on the Web
120
395237
2227
06:53
and invited the world to come over,
121
397464
3027
06:56
take whatever they need,
122
400491
1536
06:57
and do whatever they want with it.
123
402027
2390
07:00
And then something fascinating happened.
124
404417
3899
07:04
The world came.
125
408316
1583
07:05
And in short order, thousands of people
126
409899
3158
07:08
were building our machine.
127
413057
1544
07:10
And NAND2Tetris became one of the first
128
414601
3924
07:14
massive, open, online courses,
129
418525
3230
07:17
although seven years ago we had no idea that what
130
421755
2744
07:20
we were doing is called MOOCs.
131
424499
2161
07:22
We just observed how self-organized courses
132
426660
3858
07:26
were kind of spontaneously spawning
133
430518
3082
07:29
out of our materials.
134
433600
1383
07:30
For example, Pramode C.E.,
135
434983
3091
07:33
an engineer from Kerala, India,
136
438074
1909
07:35
has organized groups of self-learners
137
439983
1809
07:37
who build our computer under his good guidance.
138
441792
3044
07:40
And Parag Shah, another engineer, from Mumbai,
139
444836
3022
07:43
has unbundled our projects into smaller,
140
447858
2845
07:46
more manageable bites that he now serves
141
450703
2022
07:48
in his pioneering do-it-yourself computer science program.
142
452725
3802
07:52
The people who are attracted to these courses
143
456527
3411
07:55
typically have a hacker mentality.
144
459938
2420
07:58
They want to figure out how things work,
145
462358
2105
08:00
and they want to do it in groups,
146
464463
1760
08:02
like this hackers club in Washington, D.C.,
147
466223
2811
08:04
that uses our materials to offer community courses.
148
469034
3665
08:08
And because these materials are widely available
149
472699
2946
08:11
and open-source, different people take them
150
475645
2694
08:14
to very different and unpredictable directions.
151
478339
2943
08:17
For example, Yu Fangmin, from Guangzhou,
152
481282
2913
08:20
has used FPGA technology
153
484195
2846
08:22
to build our computer and show others how to do the same
154
487041
3725
08:26
using a video clip, and Ben Craddock developed
155
490766
3363
08:30
a very nice computer game that unfolds
156
494129
3601
08:33
inside our CPU architecture, which is quite a complex
157
497730
4969
08:38
3D maze that Ben developed
158
502699
2485
08:41
using the Minecraft 3D simulator engine.
159
505184
3908
08:44
The Minecraft community went bananas over this project,
160
509092
3018
08:48
and Ben became an instant media celebrity.
161
512110
3384
08:51
And indeed, for quite a few people,
162
515494
2902
08:54
taking this NAND2Tetris pilgrimage, if you will,
163
518396
4077
08:58
has turned into a life-changing experience.
164
522473
2712
09:01
For example, take Dan Rounds, who is a music
165
525185
3189
09:04
and math major from East Lansing, Michigan.
166
528374
2769
09:07
A few weeks ago, Dan posted a victorious post
167
531143
3444
09:10
on our website, and I'd like to read it to you.
168
534587
2620
09:13
So here's what Dan said.
169
537207
3458
09:16
"I did the coursework because understanding computers
170
540665
2812
09:19
is important to me, just like literacy and numeracy,
171
543477
3346
09:22
and I made it through. I never worked harder on anything,
172
546823
3017
09:25
never been challenged to this degree.
173
549840
2709
09:28
But given what I now feel capable of doing,
174
552549
2387
09:30
I would certainly do it again.
175
554936
2158
09:32
To anyone considering NAND2Tetris,
176
557094
2250
09:35
it's a tough journey, but you'll be profoundly changed."
177
559344
3746
09:38
So Dan demonstrates the many self-learners
178
563090
4900
09:43
who take this course off the Web, on their own traction,
179
567990
4646
09:48
on their own initiative, and it's quite amazing because
180
572636
4589
09:53
these people cannot care less about
181
577225
4587
09:57
grades.
182
581812
1242
09:58
They are doing it because of one motivation only.
183
583054
3905
10:02
They have a tremendous passion to learn.
184
586959
3486
10:06
And with that in mind,
185
590445
1924
10:08
I'd like to say a few words about traditional college grading.
186
592369
4604
10:12
I'm sick of it.
187
596973
2360
10:15
We are obsessed with grades
188
599333
1433
10:16
because we are obsessed with data,
189
600766
1866
10:18
and yet grading takes away all the fun from failing,
190
602632
4587
10:23
and a huge part of education
191
607219
2476
10:25
is about failing.
192
609695
1591
10:27
Courage, according to Churchill,
193
611286
2475
10:29
is the ability to go from one defeat to another
194
613761
2946
10:32
without losing enthusiasm. (Laughter)
195
616707
2614
10:35
And [Joyce] said that mistakes
196
619321
3830
10:39
are the portals of discovery.
197
623151
1469
10:40
And yet we don't tolerate mistakes,
198
624620
3346
10:43
and we worship grades.
199
627966
1309
10:45
So we collect your B pluses and your A minuses
200
629275
3788
10:48
and we aggregate them into a number like 3.4,
201
633063
2837
10:51
which is stamped on your forehead
202
635900
1911
10:53
and sums up who you are.
203
637811
2443
10:56
Well, in my opinion, we went too far with this nonsense,
204
640254
3283
10:59
and grading became degrading.
205
643537
2681
11:02
So with that, I'd like to say a few words about upgrading,
206
646218
4901
11:07
and share with you a glimpse from my current project,
207
651119
4425
11:11
which is different from the previous one,
208
655544
2030
11:13
but it shares exactly the same characteristics
209
657574
2014
11:15
of self-learning, learning by doing,
210
659588
3827
11:19
self-exploration and community-building,
211
663415
2775
11:22
and this project deals with K-12 math education,
212
666190
5860
11:27
beginning with early age math,
213
672050
1904
11:29
and we do it on tablets because we believe that
214
673954
4493
11:34
math, like anything else, should be taught hands on.
215
678447
4405
11:38
So here's what we do. Basically, we developed
216
682852
3155
11:41
numerous mobile apps, every one of them explaining
217
686007
3758
11:45
a particular concept in math.
218
689765
1497
11:47
So for example, let's take area.
219
691262
3441
11:50
When you deal with a concept like area --
220
694703
2472
11:53
well, we also provide a set of tools that the child
221
697175
5244
11:58
is invited to experiment with in order to learn.
222
702419
2631
12:00
So if area is what interests us, then one thing
223
705050
3953
12:04
which is natural to do is to tile the area
224
709003
4138
12:09
of this particular shape and simply count
225
713141
3650
12:12
how many tiles it takes to cover it completely.
226
716791
3863
12:16
And this little exercise here gives you a first
227
720654
2482
12:19
good insight of the notion of area.
228
723136
3429
12:22
Moving along, what about the area of this figure?
229
726565
2790
12:25
Well, if you try to tile it, it doesn't work too well, does it.
230
729355
4657
12:29
So instead, you can experiment
231
734012
2304
12:32
with these different tools here by some process
232
736316
2680
12:34
of guided trial and error,
233
738996
2039
12:36
and at some point you will discover that one thing
234
741035
2838
12:39
that you can do among several legitimate transformations
235
743873
3088
12:42
is the following one. You can cut the figure,
236
746961
2831
12:45
you can rearrange the parts, you can glue them
237
749792
3616
12:49
and then proceed to tile just like we did before.
238
753408
3117
12:52
(Applause)
239
756525
5275
12:57
Now this particular transformation
240
761800
2723
13:00
did not change the area of the original figure,
241
764523
3984
13:04
so a six-year-old who plays with this
242
768507
2187
13:06
has just discovered a clever algorithm
243
770694
2884
13:09
to compute the area of any given parallelogram.
244
773578
4040
13:13
We don't replace teachers, by the way.
245
777618
1856
13:15
We believe that teachers should be empowered, not replaced.
246
779474
3129
13:18
Moving along, what about the area of a triangle?
247
782603
3295
13:21
So after some guided trial and error,
248
785898
2795
13:24
the child will discover, with or without help,
249
788693
3935
13:28
that he or she can duplicate the original figure
250
792628
3858
13:32
and then take the result, transpose it,
251
796486
3408
13:35
glue it to the original and then proceed [with] what we did before:
252
799894
3748
13:39
cut, rearrange, paste — oops— paste and glue,
253
803642
7728
13:47
and tile.
254
811370
1596
13:48
Now this transformation has doubled the area
255
812966
3827
13:52
of the original figure, and therefore we have just learned
256
816793
3850
13:56
that the area of the triangle equals the area of this rectangle
257
820643
3766
14:00
divided by two.
258
824409
2454
14:02
But we discovered it by self-exploration.
259
826863
3448
14:06
So, in addition to learning some useful geometry,
260
830311
6080
14:12
the child has been exposed to some pretty sophisticated
261
836391
4387
14:16
science strategies, like reduction,
262
840778
3027
14:19
which is the art of
263
843805
2914
14:22
transforming a complex problem into a simple one,
264
846719
3586
14:26
or generalization, which is at the heart
265
850305
2369
14:28
of any scientific discipline,
266
852674
2843
14:31
or the fact that some properties are invariant
267
855517
2590
14:34
under some transformations.
268
858107
3024
14:37
And all this is something that a very young child
269
861131
3285
14:40
can pick up using such mobile apps.
270
864416
4309
14:44
So presently, we are doing the following:
271
868725
3094
14:47
First of all, we are decomposing the K-12 math curriculum
272
871819
4309
14:52
into numerous such apps.
273
876128
2891
14:54
And because we cannot do it on our own,
274
879019
2577
14:57
we've developed a very fancy authoring tool
275
881596
3094
15:00
that any author, any parent or actually anyone
276
884690
3275
15:03
who has an interest in math education,
277
887965
2353
15:06
can use this authoring tool to develop similar apps
278
890318
3272
15:09
on tablets without programming.
279
893590
3405
15:12
And finally, we are putting together an adaptive ecosystem
280
896995
3220
15:16
that will match different learners
281
900215
2828
15:18
with different apps according to their evolving learning style.
282
903043
5377
15:24
The driving force behind this project
283
908420
2521
15:26
is my colleague Shmulik London,
284
910941
2947
15:29
and, you see, just like
285
913888
2644
15:32
Salman did about 90 years ago,
286
916532
4073
15:36
the trick is to surround yourself with brilliant people,
287
920605
3971
15:40
because at the end,
288
924576
2756
15:43
it's all about people.
289
927332
1903
15:45
And a few years ago, I was walking in Tel Aviv
290
929235
3419
15:48
and I saw this graffiti on a wall,
291
932654
2830
15:51
and I found it so compelling
292
935484
1791
15:53
that by now I preach it to my students,
293
937275
2143
15:55
and I'd like to try to preach it to you.
294
939418
2266
15:57
Now, I don't know how many people here are familiar
295
941684
1740
15:59
with the term "mensch."
296
943424
1828
16:01
It basically means to be human
297
945252
2608
16:03
and to do the right thing.
298
947860
1935
16:05
And with that, what this graffiti says is,
299
949795
2429
16:08
"High-tech schmigh-tech.
300
952224
2086
16:10
The most important thing is to be a mensch." (Laughter)
301
954310
2563
16:12
Thank you. (Applause)
302
956873
3395
16:16
(Applause)
303
960268
4783
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Shimon Schocken - Computer Scientist, EducatorShimon Schocken is a computer science professor and dedicated educator.
Why you should listen
Shimon Schocken is a former dean at Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) Herzliya, a new Israeli private university which he helped found in 1995. He's also taught at NYU, Harvard and Stanford. Together with Noam Nisan he developed a freely available, open-source, self-paced program for learning applied computer science: The Elements of Computing Systems. Offered in 2005, this led to one of the first successful open online courses. Now, courses based on the approach are offered by traditional universities as well as in crowd-sourced settings, and have been taken freely by thousands of self-learners over the web. Registration, lecture and project schedules are managed by volunteer course coordinators, and student questions are answered by the course alumni community.
His current project focuses on developing instructional materials for early-age math education, which he thinks can be transformed using low-cost tablet computers. He uses his other life passion, mountain biking, to teach adolescent boys in Israelʼs juvenile detention centers valuable life lessons through challenging bike rides in remote locations. He was co-organizer and program chair of TEDxTelAviv 2010.
Shimon Schocken | Speaker | TED.com