TEDMED 2016
Sharon Terry: Science didn't understand my kids' rare disease until I decided to study it
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
1,352,657 views
Meet Sharon Terry, a former college chaplain and stay-at-home mom who took the medical research world by storm when her two young children were diagnosed with a rare disease known as pseudoxanthoma elasticum (PXE). In this knockout talk, Terry explains how she and her husband became citizen scientists, working midnight shifts at the lab to find the gene behind PXE and establishing mandates that require researchers to share biological samples and work together.
Sharon Terry - Citizen biomedical researcher
Sharon Terry is developing ways for ordinary people to transform biomedical research and healthcare. Full bio
Sharon Terry is developing ways for ordinary people to transform biomedical research and healthcare. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
The best Christmas my children ever had
0
440
3136
00:15
was also the worst Christmas
my husband and I ever had.
my husband and I ever had.
1
3600
3320
00:19
Elizabeth, age seven,
2
7800
1816
00:21
and her brother, Ian, age five,
3
9640
2856
00:24
couldn't imagine why they were getting
everything they wanted for Christmas.
everything they wanted for Christmas.
4
12520
3719
00:29
The reason Santa was so generous
5
17240
2720
00:32
was because of something
my husband Pat and I knew
my husband Pat and I knew
6
20760
3256
00:36
and the kids couldn't comprehend.
7
24040
1840
00:38
Something that we had just learned,
and it terrified us.
and it terrified us.
8
26440
3160
00:43
This was 1994
9
31560
2256
00:45
and the story actually starts
a few years earlier.
a few years earlier.
10
33840
2360
00:48
For a couple of years I had noticed
a rash on the sides of Elizabeth's neck
a rash on the sides of Elizabeth's neck
11
36800
4800
00:54
that looked like prickly heat.
12
42400
1480
00:56
For those same years,
my father and brother both died of cancer,
my father and brother both died of cancer,
13
44960
3880
01:01
and I was probably
overanxious about illness.
overanxious about illness.
14
49600
2680
01:05
The doctors assured us
there was nothing wrong
there was nothing wrong
15
53120
2776
01:07
and I shouldn't worry,
16
55920
1736
01:09
but I wasn't so sure.
17
57680
1400
01:12
And so without a referral,
and paying out-of-pocket,
and paying out-of-pocket,
18
60200
3096
01:15
I took Elizabeth to a dermatologist.
19
63320
2199
01:18
She was probably
just allergic to something,
just allergic to something,
20
66560
2336
01:20
but why did it appear
just on the sides of her neck, this rash?
just on the sides of her neck, this rash?
21
68920
4400
01:26
So it's two days before Christmas,
22
74840
1936
01:28
1994,
23
76800
1200
01:31
and the dermatologist
takes a quick look at her neck and says,
takes a quick look at her neck and says,
24
79200
3376
01:34
"She has pseudoxanthoma elasticum."
25
82600
2040
01:37
And then he shuts off the lights
and looks in her eyes.
and looks in her eyes.
26
85640
3600
01:42
It turns out, by chance,
27
90320
1656
01:44
this dermatologist
also trained in ophthalmology.
also trained in ophthalmology.
28
92000
3120
01:48
Our lucky day.
29
96080
1200
01:51
I am sick to my stomach.
30
99400
1760
01:53
"Oma?"
31
101640
1256
01:54
Oma's like melanoma, lymphoma --
32
102920
2896
01:57
cancer.
33
105840
1200
01:59
"Why are you looking
in her eyes for a skin rash?"
in her eyes for a skin rash?"
34
107840
3736
02:03
I scream and make no sound.
35
111600
2080
02:06
So there it is.
36
114720
1200
02:08
Elizabeth has pseudoxanthoma elasticum,
37
116800
3560
02:13
PXE for short.
38
121440
1560
02:16
Questions mix with fear
39
124880
2296
02:19
and erupt like bile in my throat.
40
127200
2200
02:21
Why are you looking in her eyes?
41
129919
1721
02:24
What do you know about this?
How do you know for sure?
How do you know for sure?
42
132840
2976
02:27
What is the prognosis?
43
135840
1480
02:30
My training in pastoral counseling
did not prepare me for this.
did not prepare me for this.
44
138200
3720
02:35
Dr. Bercovitch tells us
everything he knows about PXE.
everything he knows about PXE.
45
143680
3880
02:40
It's a rare genetic disorder,
46
148840
1760
02:43
it's systemic,
47
151800
1200
02:46
it's a slowly progressing,
premature aging disease.
premature aging disease.
48
154040
3920
02:50
It causes loose wrinkly skin
in the flexor areas.
in the flexor areas.
49
158840
3560
02:55
It causes legal blindness,
50
163600
1936
02:57
like macular degeneration,
51
165560
1720
02:59
and a host of cardiovascular problems.
52
167960
2720
03:03
Little is known about this disease,
53
171680
2080
03:06
and some people die in their 30s,
54
174600
2816
03:09
say some of the reports at the time.
55
177440
2480
03:13
He then just glances at our son and says,
56
181440
2800
03:18
"He has it, too."
57
186120
1200
03:21
We want to flee
back to the land of normal.
back to the land of normal.
58
189400
4840
03:30
Two days after Christmas,
59
198920
1416
03:32
researchers come
from a university in Boston,
from a university in Boston,
60
200360
3016
03:35
and they take blood
from us and our children
from us and our children
61
203400
2496
03:37
for a research project
focused on finding the gene.
focused on finding the gene.
62
205920
2640
03:41
A few days later,
63
209360
1376
03:42
researchers come
from a medical center in New York
from a medical center in New York
64
210760
2416
03:45
and say they want blood, too.
65
213200
1520
03:47
"These are children.
66
215520
1400
03:49
They're five and seven years old.
67
217560
2096
03:51
Don't make them face the needle twice.
68
219680
2000
03:54
Go and get your share
from the other researchers."
from the other researchers."
69
222360
3040
03:58
They laugh, incredulous.
70
226440
2216
04:00
"Share?"
71
228680
1200
04:03
It is then that we learn that there
is little sharing in biomedical research.
is little sharing in biomedical research.
72
231200
4400
04:08
This moment, more than any other,
73
236520
2696
04:11
lit a fire beneath my husband Pat and me.
74
239240
2640
04:15
Pat and I went to a medical school library
75
243640
2176
04:17
and we copied every article
we could find on PXE.
we could find on PXE.
76
245840
2960
04:21
We didn't understand a thing.
77
249720
1960
04:24
We bought medical dictionaries
and scientific textbooks
and scientific textbooks
78
252840
2736
04:27
and read everything
we could get our hands on.
we could get our hands on.
79
255600
2143
04:30
And though we still didn't understand,
80
258560
1856
04:32
we could see patterns,
81
260440
1856
04:34
and it became quickly
apparent within a month
apparent within a month
82
262320
3376
04:37
that there was no systematic effort
to understand PXE.
to understand PXE.
83
265720
3960
04:43
In addition,
84
271000
1216
04:44
the lack of sharing
that we experienced was pervasive.
that we experienced was pervasive.
85
272240
3240
04:48
Researchers competed with each other
86
276480
2280
04:51
because the ecosystem
was designed to reward competition
was designed to reward competition
87
279640
4040
04:56
rather than to alleviate suffering.
88
284560
1960
04:59
We realized that we would have to do
work on this condition ourselves
work on this condition ourselves
89
287840
5016
05:04
to find solutions
for ourselves and others like us.
for ourselves and others like us.
90
292880
3520
05:09
But we faced two major barriers.
91
297560
2336
05:11
The first one:
92
299920
1496
05:13
Pat and I have no science background.
93
301440
2360
05:16
At the time, he's the manager
of a construction company,
of a construction company,
94
304920
3416
05:20
and I'm a former college chaplain
stay-at-home mom --
stay-at-home mom --
95
308360
3856
05:24
hardly the backgrounds
to take the research world by storm.
to take the research world by storm.
96
312240
3640
05:29
The second barrier:
97
317480
1680
05:32
researchers don't share.
98
320360
1480
05:35
People told us you can't herd cats.
99
323000
2520
05:38
Well, yes you can if you move their food.
100
326640
3536
05:42
(Laughter)
101
330200
2040
05:45
(Applause)
102
333400
3560
05:49
DNA and clinical data is the food.
103
337400
3000
05:52
So we would collect blood
and medical histories,
and medical histories,
104
340960
3136
05:56
and require that all scientists
using these resources
using these resources
105
344120
3576
05:59
would share results with each other
and with the people who donated.
and with the people who donated.
106
347720
3680
06:05
Well before the internet
was in common use,
was in common use,
107
353080
2216
06:07
Pat and I established PXE International,
108
355320
2856
06:10
a nonprofit dedicated to initiating
research and conducting it on PXE
research and conducting it on PXE
109
358200
4896
06:15
and also supporting
individuals with the disease.
individuals with the disease.
110
363120
3480
06:19
Using traditional media,
111
367840
1336
06:21
we garnered around
100-150 people around the world
100-150 people around the world
112
369200
4416
06:25
who we asked,
113
373640
1256
06:26
would you give us your blood,
your tissue, your medical histories,
your tissue, your medical histories,
114
374920
3256
06:30
your medical records?
115
378200
1200
06:32
And we brought all of that together.
116
380200
1840
06:34
We quickly learned that this shared
resource was not going to be enough.
resource was not going to be enough.
117
382920
3960
06:39
And so we decided we had
to do hardcore bench science --
to do hardcore bench science --
118
387920
5336
06:45
hardcore research.
119
393280
1360
06:47
So we borrowed bench space
at a lab at Harvard.
at a lab at Harvard.
120
395400
2320
06:50
A wonderful neighbor
came a couple times a week
came a couple times a week
121
398200
2776
06:53
and sat with the kids from 8pm to 2am
122
401000
4056
06:57
while Pat and I extracted DNA,
123
405080
2336
06:59
ran and scored gels
124
407440
1736
07:01
and searched for the gene.
125
409200
1280
07:03
Generous postdocs
tutored us as we went along.
tutored us as we went along.
126
411240
2480
07:06
Within a few years, we found the gene.
127
414640
2200
07:09
We patented it so that
it would be freely available.
it would be freely available.
128
417360
3016
07:12
We created a diagnostic test.
129
420400
2056
07:14
We put together a research consortium.
130
422480
2160
07:17
We held research meetings
and opened a center of excellence.
and opened a center of excellence.
131
425600
3200
07:21
We found more than 4,000 people
around the world who had PXE,
around the world who had PXE,
132
429360
5376
07:26
and held patient meetings
133
434760
1936
07:28
and did clinical trials and studies.
134
436720
2560
07:32
Through all this,
135
440840
1496
07:34
we lived with fear.
136
442360
1280
07:37
Fear of the disease
breathing down our neck
breathing down our neck
137
445040
2800
07:41
while the clock ticked.
138
449360
1320
07:43
Fear of researchers,
139
451280
2160
07:46
so well credentialed and positioned
in a world made for them.
in a world made for them.
140
454200
3840
07:50
Fear that we were making
the wrong choices.
the wrong choices.
141
458920
2440
07:54
Fear that the naysayers were right
142
462440
2336
07:56
and the cats would simply find a new food.
143
464800
3120
08:00
But greater than all these fears
was our drive to make a difference
was our drive to make a difference
144
468800
3176
08:04
for our kids and for all those
we had met along the way.
we had met along the way.
145
472000
3000
08:08
And very quickly,
146
476280
1216
08:09
we also realized what we
were doing for one disease,
were doing for one disease,
147
477520
2736
08:12
we should do for all diseases.
148
480280
2120
08:16
We joined with, and I eventually led,
149
484200
1816
08:18
Genetic Alliance --
150
486040
1216
08:19
a network of health advocacy,
151
487280
2296
08:21
patient advocacy,
152
489600
1216
08:22
research and health organizations.
153
490840
1640
08:25
We built scalable
and extensible resources,
and extensible resources,
154
493160
2456
08:27
like biobanks and registries
and directories of support
and directories of support
155
495640
2816
08:30
for all diseases.
156
498480
1320
08:32
And as I learned about all those diseases
and all those disease communities,
and all those disease communities,
157
500800
4056
08:36
I realized that there were
two secrets in health care
two secrets in health care
158
504880
2856
08:39
that were impacting me greatly.
159
507760
1800
08:42
The first:
160
510480
1256
08:43
there are no ready answers
for people like my kids
for people like my kids
161
511760
3416
08:47
or all the people I was working with,
162
515200
1935
08:49
whether common or rare conditions.
163
517159
2041
08:51
And the second secret:
164
519919
1240
08:53
the answers lie in all of us together,
165
521760
4096
08:57
donating our data,
166
525880
1480
09:00
our biological samples
167
528240
2296
09:02
and ultimately ourselves.
168
530560
1720
09:06
There is a small
groundswell of individuals
groundswell of individuals
169
534440
3336
09:09
who are working to change this.
170
537800
2256
09:12
Citizen scientists, activists, hacks
171
540080
3056
09:15
who are using crowdsourcing,
do-it-yourself science
do-it-yourself science
172
543160
3176
09:18
are changing the game.
173
546360
1200
09:20
Even President Obama
and Vice President Biden
and Vice President Biden
174
548600
2920
09:24
are evangelists for the idea
175
552680
1696
09:26
that people should be
partners in research.
partners in research.
176
554400
2480
09:29
This is a founding principle
of our organization.
of our organization.
177
557680
2600
09:32
Sure, it's really hard
178
560960
2136
09:35
to discover and develop
interventions and therapies.
interventions and therapies.
179
563120
3200
09:39
The science is hard,
180
567480
2336
09:41
the regulatory regime is difficult.
181
569840
2280
09:44
There are a lot of stakeholders
with lots of interests
with lots of interests
182
572960
3016
09:48
and misaligned incentives
like publishing, promotion and tenure.
like publishing, promotion and tenure.
183
576000
4280
09:53
I don't fault scientists
for following this path,
for following this path,
184
581360
3416
09:56
but I challenge them and us
to do this differently.
to do this differently.
185
584800
2840
10:00
To recognize that people
are at the center.
are at the center.
186
588400
3160
10:05
Genetic Alliance has experimented
187
593400
1776
10:07
in what it will take
to transform these crusty systems.
to transform these crusty systems.
188
595200
3480
10:12
Our goal is to work without boundaries.
189
600920
2240
10:15
That sounds abstract,
but for us it's quite practical.
but for us it's quite practical.
190
603880
3120
10:21
When we're frustrated
that entities won't share data --
that entities won't share data --
191
609400
3696
10:25
data that comes from people who gave
their energy, their time, their blood
their energy, their time, their blood
192
613120
5096
10:30
and even their tears --
193
618240
1520
10:32
we need to stop and ask,
194
620520
1616
10:34
"How is it true that we
could share, but we aren't?"
could share, but we aren't?"
195
622160
3120
10:37
We're part of this system, too.
196
625840
1520
10:42
How do we make it
so that people can share ideas freely?
so that people can share ideas freely?
197
630440
4120
10:47
So that people can take risks
and move closer to one another?
and move closer to one another?
198
635400
4480
10:53
This leads to a dissolving
of us versus them,
of us versus them,
199
641480
3256
10:56
not only for organizations
but also for individuals.
but also for individuals.
200
644760
3360
11:00
If I'm going to ask
organizations or individuals
organizations or individuals
201
648720
3376
11:04
to strive for these standards,
202
652120
2216
11:06
then I too need to explore
my own being and my practices.
my own being and my practices.
203
654360
4880
11:12
If I'm going to ask clinicians
and researchers and administrators
and researchers and administrators
204
660120
3256
11:15
to take risks,
205
663400
1576
11:17
then I, Sharon,
need to take risks as well.
need to take risks as well.
206
665000
3000
11:20
I need to face my personal fears.
207
668840
2840
11:24
My fear of not having enough impact.
208
672680
2880
11:29
My fear of not leading well.
209
677400
2480
11:33
My fear of not being enough.
210
681000
2920
11:38
Just before they entered their teens,
our kids stopped us in our tracks
our kids stopped us in our tracks
211
686720
3936
11:42
and said, "You have to stop worrying
about making a difference,
about making a difference,
212
690680
3696
11:46
making an impact,
213
694400
1256
11:47
and instead, like us,
learn to live with disease
learn to live with disease
214
695680
3976
11:51
rather than fight it."
215
699680
1880
11:56
I have to ask,
216
704600
1296
11:57
where does all my fear come from?
217
705920
2240
12:01
The kids' declaration
shines a spotlight on that fear.
shines a spotlight on that fear.
218
709320
3760
12:05
It arises from a bedrock of love.
219
713760
3080
12:09
I love Elizabeth and Ian.
220
717920
2560
12:14
I love people with PXE.
221
722320
2120
12:17
I love people with any disease.
222
725520
2120
12:20
I love people.
223
728720
1200
12:24
Some of my colleagues have discovered
that it is not death we fear,
that it is not death we fear,
224
732520
4616
12:29
it is the enormity of our loving.
225
737160
2200
12:32
This expansive love opens me to great pain
226
740760
4776
12:37
as I face loss.
227
745560
1720
12:41
As I discover my fear,
228
749040
2360
12:44
I discover that I
229
752160
1776
12:45
and all those around me
230
753960
1616
12:47
have boundless capacity for love.
231
755600
2720
12:53
And I also discover
232
761640
1400
12:56
as I move into this fear,
233
764240
1600
12:59
that I can learn many new things
234
767400
2456
13:01
and find paths
235
769880
1360
13:04
to things like practical solutions
236
772320
3856
13:08
as well as the core of healing and health.
237
776200
3160
13:15
I don't fear fear the way I used to.
238
783000
3560
13:20
In fact lately, with enormous support
from all my fellow journeyers,
from all my fellow journeyers,
239
788560
5136
13:25
I notice that it's not a warning
the way it used to be.
the way it used to be.
240
793720
3320
13:30
I notice that instead,
241
798040
2856
13:32
it's an invitation to go forward
242
800920
1896
13:34
because in it lies love
and the path to greater love.
and the path to greater love.
243
802840
3240
13:39
If I turn with gentle curiosity
toward that fear,
toward that fear,
244
807640
3600
13:44
I find enormous wealth
within myself and others
within myself and others
245
812800
5056
13:49
and the ability to step into challenges
that I never thought I could.
that I never thought I could.
246
817880
3320
13:54
My kids are ahead of me
on that path still.
on that path still.
247
822960
2360
13:58
At ages 29 and 27,
248
826360
1896
14:00
they declare they are happy and healthy
249
828280
2456
14:02
despite having manifestations of PXE
in their skin and eyes and arteries.
in their skin and eyes and arteries.
250
830760
5120
14:09
And so I invite you, us, we,
251
837160
3336
14:12
to turn toward our fear;
252
840520
1576
14:14
to embrace the things that scare us
253
842120
2936
14:17
and find the love at the center.
254
845080
2136
14:19
We'll not only find ourselves there
255
847240
2216
14:21
but we'll also be able
to step into the shoes of those we fear
to step into the shoes of those we fear
256
849480
3976
14:25
and those who fear us.
257
853480
1360
14:27
If we breathe into that fear
258
855440
2080
14:30
and are vulnerable with the systems
and people who challenge us,
and people who challenge us,
259
858560
4656
14:35
our power as changemakers
grows exponentially.
grows exponentially.
260
863240
4080
14:40
And when we realize
261
868400
1256
14:41
that working on our inner life
is working on our outer life
is working on our outer life
262
869680
3656
14:45
and outer work is inner work,
263
873360
2736
14:48
we get down to what is real
264
876120
2136
14:50
and shit gets done.
265
878280
1416
14:51
(Laughter)
266
879720
1456
14:53
There is no limit
to what we can accomplish together.
to what we can accomplish together.
267
881200
3816
14:57
Thank you.
268
885040
1216
14:58
(Applause)
269
886280
2560
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Sharon Terry - Citizen biomedical researcherSharon Terry is developing ways for ordinary people to transform biomedical research and healthcare.
Why you should listen
Former college chaplain and Ashoka Fellow Sharon Terry is President and CEO of Genetic Alliance, a network of more than 10,000 organizations. She's the founding CEO of PXE International, a research advocacy organization for the genetic condition pseudoxanthoma elasticum (PXE), which affects Terry's two adult children. She has taken citizen science (discovering the gene for PXE, developing a diagnostic test, conducting clinical trials) to a national and international arena and is developing participant-centric pathways for ordinary people to transform biomedical research and healthcare. She serves in leadership roles for many collaborations focused on productively disrupting research and policy. Terry led the coalition that fought for the passage of the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act. In her spare time, she enjoys traveling and paragliding with her husband.
More profile about the speakerSharon Terry | Speaker | TED.com