TED2004
Paul Moller: My dream of a flying car
Filmed:
Readability: 4
477,921 views
Paul Moller talks about the future of personal air travel -- the marriage of autos and flight that will give us true freedom to travel off-road. He shows two things he's working on: the Moller Skycar (a jet + car) and a passenger-friendly hovering disc.
Paul Moller - Inventor
With a team of engineers, Paul Moller works on the Skycar, a combination car and jet, as well as the M200, a saucer-shaped hovering car. He also develops next-generation engines to power these and other amazing vehicles. Full bio
With a team of engineers, Paul Moller works on the Skycar, a combination car and jet, as well as the M200, a saucer-shaped hovering car. He also develops next-generation engines to power these and other amazing vehicles. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
Many of you could ask the question, you know,
0
1000
2000
00:15
why is a flying car, or maybe more accurately,
1
3000
3000
00:18
a roadable aircraft, possible at this time?
2
6000
4000
00:22
A number of years ago,
3
10000
2000
00:24
Mr. Ford predicted that flying cars
4
12000
2000
00:26
of some form would be available.
5
14000
2000
00:28
Now, 60 years later,
6
16000
2000
00:30
I'm here to tell you why it's possible.
7
18000
2000
00:32
When I was about five years old,
8
20000
2000
00:34
not very much -- about a year after
9
22000
2000
00:36
Mr. Ford made his predictions,
10
24000
2000
00:38
I was living in a rural part of Canada,
11
26000
3000
00:41
on the side of a mountain in a very isolated area.
12
29000
4000
00:46
Getting to school, for a kid that was actually pretty short for his age,
13
34000
4000
00:50
through the Canadian winter, was not a pleasant experience.
14
38000
3000
00:53
It was a trying and scary thing
15
41000
4000
00:57
for a young kid to be going through.
16
45000
3000
01:00
At the end of my first year in school, in the summer of that year,
17
48000
3000
01:05
I discovered a couple hummingbirds
18
53000
3000
01:08
that were caught in a shed near my home.
19
56000
2000
01:10
They'd worn themselves out,
20
58000
2000
01:12
beating themselves against the window,
21
60000
2000
01:14
and, well, they were easy to capture.
22
62000
2000
01:16
I took them outside and as I let them go, that split second, even though they were very tired,
23
64000
4000
01:20
that second I let them go they hovered for a second,
24
68000
2000
01:22
then zipped off into the distance.
25
70000
2000
01:24
I thought, what a great way to get to school.
26
72000
2000
01:26
(Laughter)
27
74000
2000
01:29
For a kid at that age, this was like infinite speed, disappearing,
28
77000
3000
01:33
and I was very inspired by that.
29
81000
2000
01:35
And so the next -- over the next
30
83000
2000
01:37
six decades, believe it or not,
31
85000
2000
01:39
I've built a number of aircraft,
32
87000
3000
01:42
with the goal of creating something that could do for you, or me,
33
90000
4000
01:46
what the hummingbird does,
34
94000
2000
01:48
and give you that flexibility.
35
96000
3000
01:51
I've called this vehicle, generically, a volantor,
36
99000
4000
01:55
after the Latin word "volant," meaning,
37
103000
2000
01:57
to fly in a light, nimble manner.
38
105000
3000
02:00
Volantor-like helicopter, perhaps.
39
108000
2000
02:02
The FAA, the controlling body above all,
40
110000
3000
02:05
calls it a "powered lift aircraft."
41
113000
3000
02:08
And they've actually issued a pilot's license --
42
116000
3000
02:11
a powerlift pilot's license -- for this type of aircraft.
43
119000
2000
02:15
It's closer than you think. It's kind of remarkable when you consider that
44
123000
3000
02:18
there are no operational powered lift aircraft.
45
126000
3000
02:21
So for once, perhaps, the government is ahead of itself.
46
129000
3000
02:25
The press calls my particular volantor a "Skycar."
47
133000
5000
02:30
This is a little bit earlier version of it,
48
138000
3000
02:33
that's why it's given the X designation,
49
141000
2000
02:35
but it's a four-passenger aircraft
50
143000
2000
02:37
that could take off vertically, like a helicopter --
51
145000
2000
02:39
therefore it doesn't need an airfield.
52
147000
2000
02:41
On the ground, it's powered electrically.
53
149000
3000
02:45
It's actually classified as a motorcycle
54
153000
3000
02:48
because of the three wheels, which is a great asset
55
156000
2000
02:50
because it allows you, theoretically, to use this on the highways
56
158000
2000
02:52
in most states, and actually in all cities.
57
160000
3000
02:55
So that's an asset because if you've got to deal with the crash protection issues
58
163000
3000
02:58
of the automobile, forget it -- you're never going to fly it.
59
166000
3000
03:02
(Laughter)
60
170000
2000
03:07
One could say that a helicopter
61
175000
2000
03:09
does pretty much what the hummingbird does,
62
177000
3000
03:12
and gets around in much the same way, and it's true,
63
180000
2000
03:14
but a helicopter is a very complex device.
64
182000
4000
03:18
It's expensive --
65
186000
2000
03:20
so expensive that very few people could own or use it.
66
188000
3000
03:24
It's often been described because of its fragile nature and its complexity,
67
192000
4000
03:28
as a series of parts -- a large number of parts --
68
196000
2000
03:30
flying in formation.
69
198000
2000
03:32
(Laughter)
70
200000
4000
03:37
Another difference, and I have to describe this,
71
205000
2000
03:39
because it's very personal,
72
207000
2000
03:41
another great difference between the helicopter
73
209000
2000
03:43
and the volantor --
74
211000
2000
03:45
in my case the Skycar volantor --
75
213000
2000
03:47
is the experience that I've had
76
215000
2000
03:49
in flying both of those.
77
217000
2000
03:51
In a helicopter you feel -- and it's still a remarkable sensation --
78
219000
3000
03:54
you feel like you're being hauled up from above
79
222000
3000
03:57
by a vibrating crane.
80
225000
2000
03:59
When you get in the Skycar -- and I can tell you,
81
227000
2000
04:01
there's only one other person that's flown it, but he had the same sensation --
82
229000
3000
04:04
you really feel like you're being lifted up
83
232000
2000
04:06
by a magic carpet,
84
234000
3000
04:09
without any vibration whatsoever. The sensation is unbelievable.
85
237000
3000
04:12
And it's been a great motivator.
86
240000
2000
04:14
I only get to fly this vehicle occasionally,
87
242000
3000
04:17
and only when I can persuade my stockholders
88
245000
2000
04:19
to let me do so,
89
247000
2000
04:21
but it's still one of those wonderful experiences
90
249000
3000
04:24
that reward you for all that time.
91
252000
2000
04:30
What we really need is something to replace the automobile
92
258000
3000
04:33
for those 50-plus mile trips.
93
261000
3000
04:36
Very few people realize that 50 mile-plus trips
94
264000
2000
04:38
make up 85 percent of the miles traveled in America.
95
266000
3000
04:41
If we can get rid of that,
96
269000
2000
04:43
then the highways will now be useful to you,
97
271000
3000
04:46
as contrasted by what's happening
98
274000
2000
04:48
in many parts of the world today.
99
276000
3000
04:52
On this next slide, is an interesting history
100
280000
4000
04:56
of what we really have seen in infrastructure,
101
284000
4000
05:00
because whether I give you a perfect Skycar,
102
288000
3000
05:03
the perfect vehicle for use, it's going to have very little value to you
103
291000
3000
05:06
unless you've got a system to use it in.
104
294000
2000
05:08
I'm sure any of you have asked the question,
105
296000
2000
05:10
yeah, are there great things up there -- what am I going to do, get up there?
106
298000
2000
05:12
It's bad enough on a highway, what's it going to be like to be in the air?
107
300000
3000
05:15
This world that you're going to be talking about tomorrow
108
303000
3000
05:18
is going to be completely integrated. You're not going to be a pilot,
109
306000
2000
05:20
you're going to be a passenger.
110
308000
2000
05:22
And it's the infrastructure that really determines whether this process goes forward.
111
310000
3000
05:25
I can tell you, technically we can build Skycars --
112
313000
2000
05:27
my God, we went to the moon!
113
315000
2000
05:29
The technology there was much more difficult than what I'm dealing with here.
114
317000
3000
05:32
But we have to have these priority changes,
115
320000
2000
05:34
we have to have infrastructure to go with this.
116
322000
2000
05:36
Historically you see that we got around
117
324000
2000
05:38
200 years ago by canals,
118
326000
2000
05:40
and as that system disappeared, were replaced by railroads.
119
328000
3000
05:43
As that disappeared we came in with highways.
120
331000
2000
05:45
But if you look at that top corner -- the highway system --
121
333000
3000
05:48
you see where we are today. Highways are no longer being built,
122
336000
3000
05:52
and that's a fact. You won't see any additional highways
123
340000
3000
05:55
in the next 10 years.
124
343000
2000
05:57
However, the next 10 years, if like the last 10 years,
125
345000
2000
05:59
we're going to see 30 percent more traffic.
126
347000
3000
06:02
And where is that going to lead you to?
127
350000
2000
06:04
So the issue then, I've often asked, is
128
352000
2000
06:06
when is it going to happen?
129
354000
3000
06:09
When are we going to be able to have these vehicles?
130
357000
3000
06:12
And of course, if you ask me, I'm going to give you a really optimistic view.
131
360000
3000
06:15
After all, I've been spending 60 years here believing it's going to happen tomorrow.
132
363000
3000
06:18
So, I'm not going to quote myself on this.
133
366000
3000
06:21
I'd prefer to quote someone else,
134
369000
2000
06:23
who testified with me before Congress,
135
371000
2000
06:25
and in his position as head of NASA
136
373000
4000
06:29
put forward this particular vision
137
377000
2000
06:31
of the future of this type of aircraft.
138
379000
3000
06:35
Now I would argue, actually, if you look at the fact that on the highways today,
139
383000
3000
06:38
you're only averaging about 30 miles per hour --
140
386000
3000
06:41
on average, according to the DOT --
141
389000
3000
06:44
the Skycar travels at over 300 miles an hour,
142
392000
2000
06:46
up to 25,000 feet.
143
394000
3000
06:49
And so, in effect, you could see perhaps a tenfold increase
144
397000
2000
06:51
in the ability to get around
145
399000
3000
06:54
as far as speed is concerned.
146
402000
2000
07:01
Unbeknownst to many of you,
147
409000
3000
07:04
the highway in the sky that I'm talking about here
148
412000
2000
07:06
has been under construction for 10 years.
149
414000
2000
07:09
It makes use of the GPS -- you're familiar with GPS in your automobile,
150
417000
3000
07:12
but you may not be familiar with the fact that there's a GPS U.S.,
151
420000
3000
07:15
there's a Russian GPS,
152
423000
2000
07:17
and there's a new GPS system
153
425000
2000
07:19
going to Europe, called Galileo.
154
427000
2000
07:21
With those three systems,
155
429000
2000
07:23
you have what is always necessary --
156
431000
2000
07:25
a level of redundancy that says,
157
433000
2000
07:27
if one system fails, you'll still have a way
158
435000
2000
07:29
to make sure that you're being controlled.
159
437000
2000
07:31
Because if you're in this world, where computers are controlling what you're doing,
160
439000
3000
07:34
it's going to be very critical that something can't fail on you.
161
442000
3000
07:39
How would a trip in a Skycar work?
162
447000
2000
07:41
Well, you can't right now
163
449000
2000
07:43
take off from your home because it's too noisy.
164
451000
3000
07:46
I mean to be able to take off from your home, you'd have to be extremely quiet.
165
454000
3000
07:49
But it's still fairly quiet.
166
457000
2000
07:51
You'd motor, electrically, to a vertiport,
167
459000
4000
07:55
which may be a few blocks, maybe even a few miles away.
168
463000
2000
07:57
This is clearly, as I said earlier, a roadable aircraft,
169
465000
3000
08:00
and you're not going to spend that much time on the road.
170
468000
2000
08:02
After all, if you can fly like that,
171
470000
2000
08:04
why are you going to drive around on a highway?
172
472000
2000
08:06
Go to a local vertiport,
173
474000
2000
08:08
plug in your destination,
174
476000
3000
08:11
delivered almost like a passenger.
175
479000
4000
08:15
You can play computer games, you can sleep, you can read on the way.
176
483000
3000
08:19
This is the world -- there won't be you as a pilot. And I know the pilots in the audience aren't going to like that --
177
487000
3000
08:22
and I've had a lot of bad feedback
178
490000
2000
08:24
from people who want to be up there, flying around
179
492000
2000
08:26
and experiencing that.
180
494000
3000
08:29
And of course, I suppose like recreational parks you can still do that.
181
497000
3000
08:32
But the vehicle itself is going to be a very, very controlled environment.
182
500000
4000
08:36
Or it's going to have no use to you as a person who might use such a system.
183
504000
4000
08:40
We flew the first vehicle for the international press
184
508000
3000
08:43
in 1965, when I really got it started.
185
511000
2000
08:45
I was a professor at the U.C. Davis System,
186
513000
2000
08:47
and I got a lot of excitement around this,
187
515000
2000
08:49
and I was able to fund the initiation of the program back in that time.
188
517000
4000
08:53
And then through the various years
189
521000
2000
08:55
we invented various vehicles.
190
523000
2000
08:57
Actually the critical point was in 1989,
191
525000
3000
09:00
when we demonstrated the stability of this vehicle --
192
528000
2000
09:02
how completely stable it was in all circumstances,
193
530000
3000
09:05
which is of course very critical.
194
533000
2000
09:07
Still not a practical vehicle during all of this,
195
535000
3000
09:10
but moving in the right direction, we believe.
196
538000
3000
09:14
Finally, in the early part of --
197
542000
3000
09:17
or actually the middle of 2002,
198
545000
4000
09:21
we flew the 400 -- M400, which was the four-passenger vehicle.
199
549000
4000
09:25
In this case here, we're flying it remotely, as we always did at the beginning.
200
553000
4000
09:29
And we had very small power plants in it at this time.
201
557000
3000
09:32
We are now installing larger powerplants,
202
560000
2000
09:34
which will make it possible for me to get back on board.
203
562000
2000
09:36
A vertical-takeoff aircraft
204
564000
2000
09:38
is not the safest vehicle during the test flight program.
205
566000
4000
09:42
There's an old adage that applied for the years
206
570000
3000
09:45
between 1950s and 1970s,
207
573000
3000
09:48
when every aeronautical company
208
576000
2000
09:50
was working on vertical-takeoff aircraft.
209
578000
2000
09:54
A vertical-takeoff aircraft
210
582000
2000
09:56
needs an artificial stabilization system --
211
584000
2000
09:58
that's essential.
212
586000
2000
10:00
At least for the hover,
213
588000
2000
10:02
and the low-speed flight.
214
590000
3000
10:06
If that single-stability system,
215
594000
2000
10:08
that brain that flies that aircraft, fails, or if the engine fails,
216
596000
4000
10:12
that vehicle crashes. There is no option to that.
217
600000
3000
10:15
And the adage that I'm referring to,
218
603000
2000
10:17
that applied at that time,
219
605000
2000
10:19
was that nothing comes down faster
220
607000
2000
10:21
than a VTOL aircraft upside down.
221
609000
2000
10:23
(Laughter)
222
611000
2000
10:25
That's a macabre comment because we lost a lot of pilots.
223
613000
3000
10:28
In fact, the aircraft companies gave up on
224
616000
2000
10:30
vertical-takeoff aircraft
225
618000
2000
10:32
more or less for a number of years.
226
620000
2000
10:34
And there's really only one operational aircraft in the world today
227
622000
3000
10:37
that's a vertical-takeoff aircraft -- as distinct from a helicopter --
228
625000
2000
10:39
and that's the Hawker Harrier jump jet.
229
627000
3000
10:47
A vertical-takeoff aircraft,
230
635000
2000
10:49
like the hummingbird,
231
637000
2000
10:51
has a very high metabolism,
232
639000
2000
10:53
which means it requires a lot of energy.
233
641000
3000
10:56
Getting that energy is very, very difficult. It all comes down
234
644000
3000
10:59
to that power plant -- how to get a large amount of power in a small package.
235
647000
4000
11:05
Fortunately, Dr. Felix Wankel
236
653000
2000
11:07
invented the rotary engine.
237
655000
3000
11:10
A very unique engine -- it's round,
238
658000
2000
11:12
it's small, it's vibration-free.
239
660000
3000
11:15
It fits exactly where we need to fit it,
240
663000
2000
11:17
right in the center of the hubs of the ducts in the system --
241
665000
3000
11:20
very critical. In fact that engine --
242
668000
2000
11:22
for those who are into the automobile --
243
670000
2000
11:24
know that it recently is applied to the RX8 --
244
672000
2000
11:26
the Mazda.
245
674000
2000
11:28
And that sportscar won Sports Car of the Year.
246
676000
3000
11:32
Wonderful engine.
247
680000
2000
11:34
In that application, it generates one horsepower per pound,
248
682000
2000
11:36
which is twice as good as your car engine today,
249
684000
3000
11:39
but only half of what we need.
250
687000
2000
11:41
My company has spent 35 years
251
689000
3000
11:44
and many millions of dollars taking that rotary engine,
252
692000
3000
11:47
which was invented in the late '50s, and getting it to the point that we get
253
695000
3000
11:50
over two horsepower per pound, reliably, and critical.
254
698000
3000
11:53
We actually get 175 horsepower
255
701000
3000
11:56
into one cubic foot.
256
704000
2000
11:59
We have eight engines in this vehicle.
257
707000
2000
12:01
We have four computers. We have two parachutes.
258
709000
3000
12:05
Redundancy is the critical issue here.
259
713000
2000
12:07
If you want to stay alive you've got to have backups.
260
715000
2000
12:09
And we have actually flown this vehicle and lost an engine,
261
717000
2000
12:11
and continued to hover.
262
719000
2000
12:13
The computers back up each other. There's a voting system --
263
721000
3000
12:16
if one computer is not agreeing with the other three,
264
724000
4000
12:20
it's kicked out of the system.
265
728000
1000
12:21
And then you have three -- you still have the triple redundancy.
266
729000
3000
12:24
If one of those fails, you still have a second chance.
267
732000
3000
12:27
If you stick around, then good luck.
268
735000
2000
12:29
There won't be a third chance.
269
737000
3000
12:33
The parachutes are there -- hopefully,
270
741000
2000
12:35
more for psychological than real reasons, but
271
743000
3000
12:38
they will be an ultimate backup if it comes to that.
272
746000
3000
12:41
(Laughter)
273
749000
1000
12:44
I'd like to show you an animation in this next one,
274
752000
2000
12:46
which is one element
275
754000
2000
12:48
of the Skycar's use,
276
756000
2000
12:50
but it's one that demonstrates how it could be used.
277
758000
2000
12:52
You could think of it personally in your own terms,
278
760000
2000
12:54
of how you might use it.
279
762000
2000
12:56
Video: Skycar dispatched, launch rescue vehicle for San Francisco.
280
764000
4000
13:28
Paul Moller: I believe that personal transportation
281
796000
2000
13:30
in something like the Skycar,
282
798000
2000
13:32
probably in another volantor form as well,
283
800000
3000
13:35
will be a significant part of our lives,
284
803000
3000
13:38
as Dr. Goldin says, within the next 10 years.
285
806000
3000
13:41
And it's going to change the demographics in a very significant way.
286
809000
3000
13:45
If you can live 75 miles from San Francisco and get there in 15 minutes,
287
813000
4000
13:49
you're going to sell your 700,000-dollar apartment,
288
817000
4000
13:53
buy an upscale home on the side of a mountain,
289
821000
2000
13:55
buy a Skycar,
290
823000
2000
13:57
which I think would be priced at that time perhaps
291
825000
2000
13:59
in the area of 100,000 dollars, put money in the bank ...
292
827000
3000
14:02
that's a very significant incentive for getting out of San Francisco.
293
830000
3000
14:06
But you better be the first one out of town as the real estate values go to hell.
294
834000
3000
14:09
(Laughter)
295
837000
4000
14:14
Developing the Skycar has been a real challenge.
296
842000
3000
14:17
Obviously I'm dependent on a lot of other people
297
845000
2000
14:19
believing in what I'm doing -- both financially and in technical help.
298
847000
3000
14:23
And that has --
299
851000
2000
14:25
you run into situations where you have this great acceptance of what you're doing,
300
853000
4000
14:29
and a lot of rejection of the same kind of thing.
301
857000
3000
14:32
I characterized this emerging technology
302
860000
4000
14:36
in an aphorism,
303
864000
2000
14:38
as it's described,
304
866000
3000
14:41
which really talks about what I've experienced,
305
869000
2000
14:43
and I'm sure what other people may have experienced
306
871000
2000
14:45
in emerging technologies.
307
873000
3000
14:53
There's an interesting poll that came out recently
308
881000
2000
14:55
under NAS --
309
883000
2000
14:57
I think it's MSNBC --
310
885000
2000
14:59
in which they asked the question,
311
887000
2000
15:01
"Are you in the market for a volantor?"
312
889000
3000
15:04
Twenty-three percent said, "Yes, as soon as possible."
313
892000
3000
15:07
Forty-seven percent -- yes, as soon as they could -- price could come down.
314
895000
3000
15:10
Twenty-three percent said, "As soon as it's proven safe."
315
898000
3000
15:13
Only seven percent said
316
901000
2000
15:15
that they wouldn't consider buying a Skycar.
317
903000
3000
15:18
I'm encouraged by that. At least it makes me feel like,
318
906000
3000
15:22
to some extent, it is becoming self-evident.
319
910000
3000
15:25
That we need an alternative to the automobile,
320
913000
2000
15:27
at least for those 50-mile trips and more,
321
915000
2000
15:29
so that the highways become usable in today's world.
322
917000
3000
15:32
Thank you.
323
920000
2000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Paul Moller - InventorWith a team of engineers, Paul Moller works on the Skycar, a combination car and jet, as well as the M200, a saucer-shaped hovering car. He also develops next-generation engines to power these and other amazing vehicles.
Why you should listen
Paul Moller is the president, CEO and chair of Moller International, a company devoted to engineering the combination of automobile and jet known as the Moller Skycar. His company also works on the M200, a low-flying disc, or volantor, that may go into production later in 2009. (As cool as it looks, the M200 has serious applications as a rescue vehicle.) A partner company, Freedom Motors, builds the Rotapower engine.
Moller developed the Aeronautical Engineering program at UC Davis while a professor there from 1963 to 1975. In 1972 he founded SuperTrapp Industries, and also led the group that developed the Davis Research Park Complex between 1975 and 1983. He's been working on VTOL (vertical takeoff and landing) personal vehicles since the late 1960s.
Paul Moller | Speaker | TED.com