Victoria Pratt: How judges can show respect
Viktorija Prat (Victoria Pratt): Kako sudije mogu da pokažu poštovanje
Judge Victoria Pratt is inspiring a global revolution in criminal justice. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
I want to tell you something.
Želim nešto da vam kažem.
by a transgender prostitute
na stolicu za sudije,
koja je sedela pored nje:
sitting next to her,
I look better than the girl you're with."
nego devojka sa kojom si.“
izgovorila dovoljno tiho,
be picked up by the record,
towards counselor's table with dignity.
došeta prolazom do savetnikovog stola.
also known as procedural fairness,
poznato i kao proceduralna pravičnost,
of an African-American garbageman
koji je bio smećar,
in the segregated South.
na rasno podeljenom jugu.
you're still paying attention.
da li me pažljivo slušate.
for a better life for her unborn children.
za boljim životom za svoju nerođenu decu.
you meet with dignity and respect,
ophodi se prema svima
no matter how they dress,
šta imaju obučeno,
it would be the most important lesson
da je to bila najvažnija lekcija
to the Newark Municipal Court bench.
za sudiju Opštinskog suda u Njuarku.
off the playground
sa igrališta sa samo 10 godina
to translate for family members
to the United States,
u Sjedinjene Američke Države,
for a person, a novice,
za neku osobu, početnika,
kroz bilo koji državni sistem.
and around the globe,
that is foreign, intimidating
nastrojeno prema njima.
about the nature of their charges,
with the police
their relationships, their finances
na njihove odnose, njihove finansije,
who encounters our courts.
susret sa sudom.
going through court security.
dok prolaze kroz sudsko obezbeđenje.
they walk around the building,
pitaju različite ljude ista pitanja
the same question
to where they're supposed to be,
do mesta gde bi trebali da budu,
when they encounter the courts.
kada se susreću sa sudom.
people's court experience,
ljudsko iskustvo sa sudovima,
the public's trust
is procedural justice
je proceduralna pravda
they are treated fairly
da se prema njima ophodi pravedno,
Yale professor Tom Tyler found
Tom Tajler sa Jejla shvatio
as far back in the '70s
see the justice system
vide pravosudni sistem
to impose rules and regulations,
koji nameće pravila i propise,
na njihovu štetu,
that they were treated fairly
postupali pravedno,
begins with what?
to court participants.
a reserve seat to a tragic reality show
za neki tragični rijaliti šou
da je njihova potreba za pomoći
of appearing vulnerable on the bench,
da ispadnem ranjiva kao sudija,
did I need to do something,
nešto da uradim,
of procedural justice are easy
proceduralne pravde jednostavni
as quickly as tomorrow.
that it can be done for free.
not going to let them speak.
da govorite sada.
that's going to hurt your case."
što će štetiti vašem slučaju.“
of giving them voice.
college student an essay.
od 18 godina da napiše esej.
za maloletničko konzumiranje alkohola.
i čitao svoj esej,
and his hands trembling,
had become an alcoholic like his mom,
alkoholičar, kao njegova mama,
due to alcohol-related liver disease.
od bolesti jetre uzrokovane alkoholom.
to my father, a letter to my son,
pismo mom ocu, pismo mom sinu:
positive thing about myself,
pozitivnu stvar o sebi,
to be introspective,
da bude introspektivna,
that goes beyond their criminal record
izvan njihovog kriminalnog dosijea
in the justice system,
u pravosudni sistem,
to be favoring one side over the other.
ko favorizuje jednu stranu naspram druge.
not to say things like,
da ne izgovara reči kao što su:
"my defense attorney."
„moj tužilac“, „moj branilac“.
when we work in environments
assigned to your courts,
in and out of your courts as well.
koji ulaze i izlaze iz vaše sudnice.
a new Rutgers Law grad
Ratgersove škole za pravo
and I was greeted by two grey-haired men
gde su me pozdravila dva seda muškarca
the last game of golf they played together
partije golfa koju su zajedno odigrali
a fair shot in that forum.
da se tretira pravično na tom skupu.
understand the process,
razumeju proces,
is the language we use to confuse.
jezik koji koristimo da bismo zbunjivali.
who appear before me,
da ljudi koji se pojave preda mnom,
nisko obrazovanje,
their second language.
engleski u sudu.
was when I was a young judge --
je kada sam bila mladi sudija -
a senior judge comes to me,
stariji sudija je došao do mene,
has mental health issues,
mentalnih problema,
možeš dati svoju procenu.“
and you can get your evaluation."
was a mental health issue,
da je mentalni problem,
and I started to ask questions.
i počela postavljati pitanja:
um, psychotrop --
psiho... hm... psihotrop...
with a psychiatrist before?"
bili lečeni kod psihijatra?“
was suffering from mental illness.
patila od nekog oblika mentalne bolesti.
to scrap the script and ask one question.
da bacim skriptu i pitam jedno pitanje:
to clear your mind?"
da razbistrite mozak?“
for my schizophrenia,
za moju šizofreniju,
čak i kad ne funkcioniše.
to clear your mind?"
da razbistrite mozak?“
no medication to clear my mind.
da bih razbistrio mozak,
to stop the voices in my head,
da zaustavim glasove u glavi,
understand the question,
to make meaningful decisions
da donosi svrsishodne odluke
of the other principles can work.
nijedan od prethodnih principa.
"Good morning, ma'am."
„Dobro jutro, gospođo.“
who is standing before you,
osobi koja stoji pred vama,
"Um, how are you doing today?
actually interested in the response.
interesuje odgovor.
in the paperwork?"
u tim papirima?“
read and write, can't you?"
i pišete, zar ne?“
there's a literacy issue.
problem sa pismenošću.
is that it's contagious.
jeste što je ono zarazno.
respectful to other folks
that respect to themselves.
to poštovanje sebi samima.
the transgender prostitute was telling me.
što mi je transrodna prostitutka govorila.
as you think you may be judging me.
da možeš suditi meni.
to change the culture at my courthouse
da bih promenila kulturu u svom sudu
to the criminal court,
as the worst courtroom in the city,
kao najgora sudnica u gradu,
with revolving door justice,
sa jednim istim ljudima,
of low-level offenders --
sitni prestupnici -
with quality-of-life tickets,
zbog ugrožavanja kvaliteta života,
and the misguided young people --
i postao diler droge
sa pravog puta -
doing a life sentence
decided that Newarkers deserved better,
da stanovnici Njuarka zaslužuju bolje,
with the Center for Court Innovation
sa Centrom za inovacije sudova
za zajednicu Njuarka,
to punishment with assistance.
uz dodeljenu pomoć.
otherwise get a jail sentence
dobio kaznu zatvora,
individual counseling sessions,
individualne savetodavne seanse,
as well as community giveback,
kao i da se oduže zajednici,
that this wonderful program
and was going to be housed where?
the attitudes were terrible there
tamo bilo strašno
shvatao da je tamo poslat po kazni.
being sent there as punishment.
disciplinary actions at times,
imali disciplinske mere,
a 30-day jail sentence on their rotation,
zatvorsku kaznu svakih 30 dana,
they were being hazed
da su im zadali težak zadatak
sorority or fraternity.
an attorney who worked there
da se advokat koji je radio tu
as "the scum of the earth"
kao o „svetskom šljamu“
with those people? They're so nasty.
sa tim ljudima? Oni su grozni.
we criminalize social ills,
kriminalizujemo društvene bolesti,
and say, "Do something."
i kažemo: „Učini nešto.“
to lead by example.
came when a 60-something-year-old man
bio je kad se muškarac u šezdesetim
was showing the signs of drug withdrawal.
je pokazivalo znakove narkomanske krize.
and he said, "30 years."
a on mi je odgovorio: „30 godina.“
I have a 32-year-old son."
32 godine“, odgovorio je.
had the opportunity
vi nikad niste imali priliku
because of your addiction."
zbog svoje ovisnosti.“
I'm going to let you go home,
pustiću vas da da idete kući
some assistance for your addiction."
neku vrstu pomoći za vašu ovisnost.“
and he was sitting the courtroom.
dve nedelje potom, on je sedeo u sudnici.
"Judge, I came back to court
„Sudijo, vratio sam se u sud
than I had for myself."
nego što sam ja ikada imao za sebe.“
he heard love from the bench?
on je čuo ljubav sa moje stolice?
when the court behaves differently,
ako se sud drugačije ponaša,
you can go to for assistance,
da zatražite pomoć,
schizophrenic homeless woman
beskućnica koja ima šizofreniju,
and screams, "Judge!
for a couple of months,
a couple of weeks ago.
njen slučaj, nekoliko nedelja ranije.
of coaxing by the judge,
nagovaranja od strane sudije,
sa svojom zajednicom
was terrible, Judge.
je bio strašan, sudijo.
and it was full of empty heroin envelopes,
praznih vrećica od heroina,
taj isti park da se drogiram,
to do community service,
na društveno koristan rad,
when I wasn't high,
a da nisam bio nadrogiran,
the children playing there."
da se deca tamo igraju.“
lowered their head.
its relationship with the community,
odnos sa zajednicom,
sa dvadesetogodišnjim momkom
through the court program.
kroz sudski program.
at an office cleaning company,
u kompaniji za čišćenje kancelarija,
after the interview,
u svom odelu nakon razgovora,
how bad I wanted the job."
koliko jako želim taj posao.“
when a person in authority
sa dostojanstvom i poštovanjem,
who struts down the aisle
na koga sam naletela u ulici
do you notice anything different?"
primećujete li nešto drugačije?“
a referral from the program,
nakon uputa kroz program,
to replace the old teeth
da bi zamenio stare zube
of years of heroin addiction.
dugogodišnjeg korišćenja heroina.
that judges will use these tools
koristiti ovo sredstvo
the communities that they serve.
u zajednicama kojima služe.
are not miracle cure-alls,
nisu čudotvorni štapići,
brže mestu gde želimo da budemo,
to where we want to be,
that people enter our halls of justice
ulaze u naše sudnice
with dignity and respect
ophoditi sa dostojanstvom i poštovanjem
will be served there.
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Victoria Pratt - ProfessorJudge Victoria Pratt is inspiring a global revolution in criminal justice.
Why you should listen
Judge Victoria Pratt has gained national and international acclaim for her commitment to reforming the criminal justice system. As the Chief Judge in Newark Municipal Court in Newark, New Jersey, a busy urban court, she spent years gaining a deep understanding of how justice could be delivered to court participants in a manner that increased their trust in the legal system. While presiding over Newark Community Solutions, the Community Court Program, she provided alternatives to jail to low-level offenders. These alternatives included community service, individual and group counseling sessions, and her signature assignment of introspective essays. Her respectful approach has had a positive effect on court participant’s court experience -- and how the community viewed the court.
Pratt is now serving as a Professor at Rutgers Law School in Newark, an institution that has always been committed to social justice. Her teaching load includes problem-solving courts and restorative justice. As a graduate of Rutgers Law, she is excited by the opportunity to influence the minds of future lawyers and judges with innovative and humane ways of dealing with court participants. She also continues to champion criminal justice reform through her consulting firm Pratt Lucien Consultants, LLC, by sharing her skills and approach with others.
Pratt’s work has been featured in The Guardian and Rutgers Magazine (both written by Pulitzer-winning author Tina Rosenberg.) As a nationally recognized expert in procedural justice and alternative sentencing, she has been asked by numerous professional organizations and jurisdictions to share her story and philosophy. Judge Pratt has also appeared on MSNBC's "Melissa Harris Perry Show," the Emmy-winning PBS show "Due Process," and National Public Radio's "Conversations with Allan Wolper."
Pratt is licensed to practice law in both New Jersey and New York and is admitted to the US Supreme Court. She also facilitates empowerment sessions to help people live their best lives.
(Photo: Erik James Montgomery)
Victoria Pratt | Speaker | TED.com