TEDSalon London Spring 2012
Tracy Chevalier: Finding the story inside the painting
Filmed:
Readability: 2.9
1,389,986 views
When Tracy Chevalier looks at paintings, she imagines the stories behind them: How did the painter meet his model? What would explain that look in her eye? Why is that man ... blushing? She shares three stories inspired by portraits, including the one that led to her best-selling novel "Girl With a Pearl Earring."
Tracy Chevalier - Author
Novelist Tracy Chevalier is the author of "Girl With a Pearl Earring." Full bio
Novelist Tracy Chevalier is the author of "Girl With a Pearl Earring." Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
I'm going to tell you about an affliction I suffer from.
0
516
4107
00:20
And I have a funny feeling that quite a few of you
1
4623
2504
00:23
suffer from it as well.
2
7127
1920
00:24
When I'm walking around an art gallery,
3
9047
2097
00:27
rooms and rooms full of paintings,
4
11144
2103
00:29
after about 15 or 20 minutes,
5
13247
4517
00:33
I realize I'm not thinking about the paintings.
6
17764
1891
00:35
I'm not connecting to them.
7
19655
1608
00:37
Instead, I'm thinking about that cup of coffee
8
21263
2504
00:39
I desperately need to wake me up.
9
23767
3000
00:42
I'm suffering from gallery fatigue.
10
26767
3184
00:45
How many of you out there suffer from --
11
29951
2376
00:48
yes. Ha ha, ha ha!
12
32327
2005
00:50
Now, sometimes you might last longer
13
34332
2150
00:52
than 20 minutes, or even shorter,
14
36482
2094
00:54
but I think we all suffer from it. And do you have
15
38576
2214
00:56
the accompanying guilt?
16
40790
2081
00:58
For me, I look at the paintings on the wall
17
42871
2987
01:01
and I think, somebody has decided to put them there,
18
45858
3015
01:04
thinks they're good enough to be on that wall,
19
48873
2528
01:07
but I don't always see it.
20
51401
1358
01:08
In fact, most of the time I don't see it.
21
52759
2664
01:11
And I leave feeling actually unhappy.
22
55423
3774
01:15
I feel guilty and unhappy with myself,
23
59197
3467
01:18
rather than thinking there's something wrong with the painting,
24
62664
2063
01:20
I think there's something wrong with me.
25
64727
1457
01:22
And that's not a good experience, to leave a gallery like that.
26
66184
2908
01:24
(Laughter)
27
69092
1271
01:26
The thing is, I think we should give ourselves a break.
28
70363
2309
01:28
If you think about going into a restaurant,
29
72672
2460
01:31
when you look at the menu, are you expected to order
30
75132
3687
01:34
every single thing on the menu?
31
78819
2183
01:36
No! You select.
32
81002
1882
01:38
If you go into a department store to buy a shirt,
33
82884
3175
01:41
are you going to try on every single shirt
34
86059
2977
01:44
and want every single shirt?
35
89036
1328
01:46
Of course not, you can be selective. It's expected.
36
90364
4127
01:50
How come, then, it's not so expected
37
94491
2621
01:53
to be selective when we go to an art gallery?
38
97112
2573
01:55
Why are we supposed to have a connection with every single painting?
39
99685
3295
01:58
Well I'm trying to take a different approach.
40
102980
2704
02:01
And there's two things I do:
41
105684
1618
02:03
When I go into a gallery, first of all, I go quite fast,
42
107302
4494
02:07
and I look at everything, and I pinpoint the ones
43
111796
4235
02:11
that make me slow down for some reason or other.
44
116031
3054
02:14
I don't even know why they make me slow down, but something
45
119085
2801
02:17
pulls me like a magnet
46
121886
2057
02:19
and then I ignore all the others, and I just go to that painting.
47
123943
3118
02:22
So it's the first thing I do is, I do my own curation.
48
127061
2464
02:25
I choose a painting. It might just be one painting in 50.
49
129525
3296
02:28
And then the second thing I do is I stand in front of that painting,
50
132821
3690
02:32
and I tell myself a story about it.
51
136511
3077
02:35
Why a story? Well, I think that we are wired,
52
139588
3598
02:39
our DNA tells us to tell stories.
53
143186
3891
02:42
We tell stories all the time about everything,
54
147077
2369
02:45
and I think we do it because the world is kind of a crazy, chaotic place,
55
149446
5111
02:50
and sometimes stories, we're trying to make sense of the world a little bit,
56
154557
3951
02:54
trying to bring some order to it.
57
158508
2169
02:56
Why not apply that to our looking at paintings?
58
160677
3991
03:00
So I now have this sort of restaurant menu
59
164668
3715
03:04
visiting of art galleries.
60
168383
3223
03:07
There are three paintings I'm going to show you now
61
171606
3208
03:10
that are paintings that made me stop in my tracks
62
174814
3064
03:13
and want to tell stories about them.
63
177878
2546
03:16
The first one needs little introduction --
64
180424
3551
03:19
"Girl with a Pearl Earring" by Johannes Vermeer,
65
183975
3031
03:22
17th-century Dutch painter.
66
187006
2156
03:25
This is the most glorious painting.
67
189162
2500
03:27
I first saw it when I was 19,
68
191662
2144
03:29
and I immediately went out and got a poster of it,
69
193806
2280
03:31
and in fact I still have that poster. 30 years later it's hanging in my house.
70
196086
4157
03:36
It's accompanied me everywhere I've gone,
71
200243
3150
03:39
I never tire of looking at her.
72
203393
2344
03:41
What made me stop in my tracks about her to begin with
73
205737
3779
03:45
was just the gorgeous colors he uses
74
209516
2557
03:47
and the light falling on her face.
75
212073
1944
03:49
But I think what's kept me still coming back
76
214017
2784
03:52
year after year is another thing, and that is
77
216801
3056
03:55
the look on her face, the conflicted look on her face.
78
219857
3694
03:59
I can't tell if she's happy or sad,
79
223551
2418
04:01
and I change my mind all the time.
80
225969
2967
04:04
So that keeps me coming back.
81
228936
3599
04:08
One day, 16 years after I had this poster on my wall,
82
232535
4009
04:12
I lay in bed and looked at her,
83
236544
2682
04:15
and I suddenly thought, I wonder what
84
239226
2579
04:17
the painter did to her to make her look like that.
85
241805
3918
04:21
And it was the first time I'd ever thought that
86
245723
2944
04:24
the expression on her face is actually reflecting
87
248667
2800
04:27
how she feels about him.
88
251467
2139
04:29
Always before I'd thought of it as a portrait of a girl.
89
253606
3156
04:32
Now I began to think of it as a portrait of a relationship.
90
256762
4769
04:37
And I thought, well, what is that relationship?
91
261531
2832
04:40
So I went to find out. I did some research and discovered,
92
264363
3208
04:43
we have no idea who she is.
93
267571
2325
04:45
In fact, we don't know who any of the models
94
269896
2347
04:48
in any of Vermeer's paintings are,
95
272243
2360
04:50
and we know very little about Vermeer himself.
96
274603
2127
04:52
Which made me go, "Yippee!"
97
276730
2774
04:55
I can do whatever I want, I can come up with whatever story I want to.
98
279504
4659
05:00
So here's how I came up with the story.
99
284163
2596
05:02
First of all, I thought,
100
286759
1877
05:04
I've got to get her into the house.
101
288636
2092
05:06
How does Vermeer know her?
102
290728
2488
05:09
Well, there've been suggestions that
103
293216
1544
05:10
she is his 12-year-old daughter.
104
294760
4423
05:15
The daughter at the time was 12 when he painted the painting.
105
299183
2225
05:17
And I thought, no, it's a very intimate look,
106
301408
2696
05:20
but it's not a look a daughter gives her father.
107
304104
2184
05:22
For one thing, in Dutch painting of the time,
108
306288
1840
05:24
if a woman's mouth was open, it was indicating sexual availability.
109
308128
3592
05:27
It would have been inappropriate for Vermeer
110
311720
1888
05:29
to paint his daughter like that.
111
313608
1896
05:31
So it's not his daughter, but it's somebody
112
315504
1880
05:33
close to him, physically close to him.
113
317384
2250
05:35
Well, who else would be in the house?
114
319634
2264
05:37
A servant, a lovely servant.
115
321898
3383
05:41
So, she's in the house.
116
325281
1561
05:42
How do we get her into the studio?
117
326842
2661
05:45
We don't know very much about Vermeer,
118
329503
2134
05:47
but the little bits that we do know, one thing we know
119
331637
2139
05:49
is that he married a Catholic woman, they lived with her mother
120
333776
2991
05:52
in a house where he had his own room
121
336767
2273
05:54
where he -- his studio. He also had 11 children.
122
339040
4283
05:59
It would have been a chaotic, noisy household.
123
343323
3077
06:02
And if you've seen Vermeer's paintings before,
124
346400
2944
06:05
you know that they're incredibly calm and quiet.
125
349344
3864
06:09
How does a painter paint such calm, quiet paintings with 11 kids around?
126
353208
3896
06:13
Well, he compartmentalizes his life.
127
357104
2296
06:15
He gets to his studio, and he says, "Nobody comes in here.
128
359400
3680
06:18
Not the wife, not the kids. Okay, the maid can come in and clean."
129
363080
4728
06:23
She's in the studio. He's got her in the studio, they're together.
130
367808
7051
06:30
And he decides to paint her.
131
374859
2080
06:32
He has her wear very plain clothes.
132
376939
2268
06:35
Now, all of the women, or most of the women in Vermeer's other paintings
133
379207
3371
06:38
wore velvet, silk, fur, very sumptuous materials.
134
382578
5966
06:44
This is very plain; the only thing that isn't plain
135
388544
2520
06:46
is her pearl earring.
136
391064
2040
06:49
Now, if she's a servant, there is no way she could afford
137
393104
3447
06:52
a pair of pearl earrings.
138
396551
2207
06:54
So those are not her pearl earrings. Whose are they?
139
398758
3262
06:57
We happen to know, there's a list of Catharina, the wife's clothes.
140
402020
5041
07:02
Amongst them a yellow coat with white fur,
141
407061
3616
07:06
a yellow and black bodice,
142
410677
1747
07:08
and you see these clothes on lots of other paintings,
143
412424
3694
07:12
different women in the paintings, Vermeer's paintings.
144
416118
3114
07:15
So clearly, her clothes were lent to various different women.
145
419232
4478
07:19
It's not such a leap of faith to take
146
423710
2519
07:22
that that pearl earring actually belongs to his wife.
147
426229
3584
07:25
So we've got all the elements for our story.
148
429813
3177
07:28
She's in the studio with him for a long time.
149
432990
2430
07:31
These paintings took a long time to make.
150
435420
2043
07:33
They would have spent the time alone, all that time.
151
437463
2871
07:36
She's wearing his wife's pearl earring.
152
440334
2000
07:38
She's gorgeous. She obviously loves him. She's conflicted.
153
442334
2815
07:41
And does the wife know? Maybe not.
154
445149
2792
07:43
And if she doesn't, well --
155
447941
3378
07:47
that's the story.
156
451319
1855
07:49
(Laughter)
157
453174
2177
07:51
The next painting I'm going to talk about
158
455351
2590
07:53
is called "Boy Building a House of Cards" by Chardin.
159
457941
3247
07:57
He's an 18th-century French painter best known for his still lifes,
160
461188
4376
08:01
but he did occasionally paint people.
161
465564
2593
08:04
And in fact, he painted four versions of this painting,
162
468157
3967
08:08
different boys building houses of cards, all concentrated.
163
472124
3960
08:11
I like this version the best, because some of the boys
164
476084
3464
08:15
are older and some are younger, and to me, this one,
165
479548
3393
08:18
like Goldilocks's porridge, is just right.
166
482941
2952
08:21
He's not quite a child, and he's not quite a man.
167
485893
3991
08:25
He's absolutely balanced between innocence and experience,
168
489884
4793
08:30
and that made me stop in my tracks in front of this painting.
169
494677
4483
08:35
And I looked at his face. It's like a Vermeer painting a bit.
170
499160
3717
08:38
The light comes in from the left, his face is bathed
171
502877
2623
08:41
in this glowing light. It's right in the center of the painting,
172
505500
2224
08:43
and you look at it, and I found that when I was looking at it,
173
507724
3012
08:46
I was standing there going,
174
510736
1207
08:47
"Look at me. Please look at me."
175
511943
2953
08:50
And he didn't look at me. He was still looking at his cards,
176
514896
2736
08:53
and that's one of the seductive elements of this painting is,
177
517632
2752
08:56
he's so focused on what he's doing that he doesn't look at us.
178
520384
4490
09:00
And that is, to me, the sign of a masterpiece,
179
524874
3893
09:04
of a painting when there's a lack of resolution.
180
528767
3977
09:08
He's never going to look at me.
181
532744
1521
09:10
So I was thinking of a story where,
182
534265
1679
09:11
if I'm in this position, who could be there looking at him?
183
535944
3216
09:15
Not the painter, I don't want to think about the painter.
184
539160
2202
09:17
I'm thinking of an older version of himself.
185
541362
2526
09:19
He's a man, a servant, an older servant looking at this younger servant,
186
543888
5945
09:25
saying, "Look at me. I want to warn you about
187
549833
2471
09:28
what you're about to go through. Please look at me."
188
552304
2450
09:30
And he never does.
189
554754
1526
09:32
And that lack of resolution, the lack of resolution in "Girl with a Pearl Earring" --
190
556280
3803
09:35
we don't know if she's happy or sad.
191
560083
2044
09:38
I've written an entire novel about her,
192
562127
1649
09:39
and I still don't know if she's happy or sad.
193
563776
2000
09:41
Again and again, back to the painting,
194
565776
2104
09:43
looking for the answer, looking for the story to fill in that gap.
195
567880
4681
09:48
And we may make a story, and it satisfies us momentarily,
196
572561
3447
09:51
but not really, and we come back again and again.
197
576008
5815
09:57
The last painting I'm going to talk about
198
581823
2538
10:00
is called "Anonymous" by anonymous. (Laughter)
199
584361
4864
10:05
This is a Tudor portrait bought by the National Portrait Gallery.
200
589225
3051
10:08
They thought it was a man named Sir Thomas Overbury,
201
592276
2613
10:10
and then they discovered that it wasn't him,
202
594889
2664
10:13
and they have no idea who it is.
203
597553
1600
10:15
Now, in the National Portrait Gallery,
204
599153
2143
10:17
if you don't know the biography of the painting,
205
601296
1769
10:18
it's kind of useless to you.
206
603065
1624
10:20
They can't hang it on the wall, because they don't know who he is.
207
604689
2424
10:23
So unfortunately, this orphan spends most of his time in storage,
208
607113
4904
10:27
along with quite a number of other orphans,
209
612017
2144
10:30
some of them some beautiful paintings.
210
614161
2511
10:32
This painting made me stop in my tracks for three reasons:
211
616672
5003
10:37
One is the disconnection between his mouth
212
621675
2877
10:40
that's smiling and his eyes that are wistful.
213
624552
2705
10:43
He's not happy, and why isn't he happy?
214
627257
3007
10:46
The second thing that really attracted me
215
630264
3717
10:49
were his bright red cheeks.
216
633981
1716
10:51
He is blushing. He's blushing for his portrait being made!
217
635697
3607
10:55
This must be a guy who blushes all the time.
218
639304
3034
10:58
What is he thinking about that's making him blush?
219
642338
2142
11:00
The third thing that made me stop in my tracks
220
644480
3776
11:04
is his absolutely gorgeous doublet.
221
648256
2800
11:06
Silk, gray, those beautiful buttons.
222
651056
3568
11:10
And you know what it makes me think of,
223
654624
1632
11:12
is it's sort of snug and puffy; it's like a duvet spread over a bed.
224
656256
4792
11:16
I kept thinking of beds and red cheeks,
225
661048
2656
11:19
and of course I kept thinking of sex when I looked at him,
226
663704
2760
11:22
and I thought, is that what he's thinking about?
227
666464
2608
11:24
And I thought, if I'm going to make a story,
228
669072
2272
11:27
what's the last thing I'm going to put in there?
229
671344
1984
11:29
Well, what would a Tudor gentleman be preoccupied with?
230
673328
3630
11:32
And I thought, well, Henry VIII, okay.
231
676958
1930
11:34
He'd be preoccupied with his inheritance, with his heir.
232
678888
4144
11:38
Who is going to inherit his name and his fortune?
233
683032
3649
11:42
You put all those together, and you've got your story
234
686681
3880
11:46
to fill in that gap that makes you keep coming back.
235
690561
3354
11:49
Now, here's the story.
236
693915
4721
11:54
It's short.
237
698636
2930
11:57
"Rosy"
238
701566
2731
12:00
I am still wearing the white brocade doublet Caroline gave me.
239
704297
4050
12:04
It has a plain high collar, detachable sleeves
240
708347
4311
12:08
and intricate buttons of twisted silk thread,
241
712658
3176
12:11
set close together so that the fit is snug.
242
715834
2926
12:14
The doublet makes me think of a coverlet on the vast bed.
243
718760
3563
12:18
Perhaps that was the intention.
244
722323
3750
12:21
I first wore it at an elaborate dinner her parents held in our honor.
245
726073
4918
12:26
I knew even before I stood up to speak
246
730991
1826
12:28
that my cheeks were inflamed.
247
732817
2569
12:31
I have always flushed easily, from physical exertion,
248
735386
3701
12:34
from wine, from high emotion.
249
739087
2355
12:37
As a boy, I was teased by my sisters and by schoolboys,
250
741442
4465
12:41
but not by George.
251
745907
2447
12:44
Only George could call me Rosy.
252
748354
3074
12:47
I would not allow anyone else.
253
751428
2159
12:49
He managed to make the word tender.
254
753587
4224
12:53
When I made the announcement, George did not
255
757811
2799
12:56
turn rosy, but went pale as my doublet.
256
760610
3064
12:59
He should not have been surprised.
257
763674
1904
13:01
It has been a common assumption
258
765578
1672
13:03
that I would one day marry his cousin.
259
767250
3848
13:06
But it is difficult to hear the words aloud.
260
771098
2584
13:09
I know, I could barely utter them.
261
773682
3301
13:12
Afterwards, I found George on the terrace overlooking the kitchen garden.
262
776983
4402
13:17
Despite drinking steadily all afternoon, he was still pale.
263
781385
5257
13:22
We stood together and watched the maids cut lettuces.
264
786642
4225
13:26
"What do you think of my doublet?" I asked.
265
790867
2262
13:29
He glanced at me. "That collar looks to be strangling you."
266
793129
5444
13:34
"We will still see each other," I insisted.
267
798573
2004
13:36
"We can still hunt and play cards and attend court.
268
800577
3288
13:39
Nothing need change."
269
803865
1736
13:41
George did not speak.
270
805601
3717
13:45
"I am 23 years old. It is time for me to marry
271
809318
3394
13:48
and produce an heir. It is expected of me."
272
812712
4105
13:52
George drained another glass of claret and turned to me.
273
816817
3581
13:56
"Congratulations on your upcoming nuptials, James.
274
820398
4083
14:00
I'm sure you'll be content together."
275
824481
4836
14:05
He never used my nickname again.
276
829317
3317
14:08
Thank you.
277
832634
1759
14:10
(Applause)
278
834393
3382
14:13
Thank you.
279
837775
1182
14:14
(Applause)
280
838957
1547
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tracy Chevalier - AuthorNovelist Tracy Chevalier is the author of "Girl With a Pearl Earring."
Why you should listen
Tracy Chevalier pulls stories from paintings and historical episodes, finding the human thread behind opaque images. Her best-known book is Girl With a Pearl Earring, inspired by a Vermeer painting; other books include The Lady and the Unicorn and Burning Bright, about two children who become neighbours of William Blake. Her upcoming book, The Last Runaway, tells a story from the Underground Railroad.
For the anthology Imagined Lives, she wrote about an unknown portrait sitter whom she calls "Rosy." Hear the podcast of her story. and find more stories from the National Portrait Gallery.
Tracy Chevalier | Speaker | TED.com