TEDxEQChCh
Ernesto Sirolli: Want to help someone? Shut up and listen!
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
3,300,101 views
When most well-intentioned aid workers hear of a problem they think they can fix, they go to work. This, Ernesto Sirolli suggests, is naïve. In this funny and impassioned talk, he proposes that the first step is to listen to the people you're trying to help, and tap into their own entrepreneurial spirit. His advice on what works will help any entrepreneur.
Ernesto Sirolli - Sustainable development expert
Ernesto Sirolli got his start doing aid work in Africa in the 70's -- and quickly realised how ineffective it was. Full bio
Ernesto Sirolli got his start doing aid work in Africa in the 70's -- and quickly realised how ineffective it was. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:17
Everything I do, and everything I do professionally --
0
1235
3479
00:20
my life -- has been shaped
1
4714
3985
00:24
by seven years of work as a young man in Africa.
2
8699
5824
00:30
From 1971 to 1977 --
3
14523
3521
00:33
I look young, but I'm not — (Laughter) --
4
18044
3880
00:37
I worked in Zambia, Kenya, Ivory Coast, Algeria, Somalia,
5
21924
4933
00:42
in projects of technical cooperation with African countries.
6
26857
4217
00:46
I worked for an Italian NGO,
7
31074
3118
00:50
and every single project that we set up in Africa
8
34192
6150
00:56
failed.
9
40342
3444
00:59
And I was distraught.
10
43786
4144
01:03
I thought, age 21, that we Italians were good people
11
47930
4248
01:08
and we were doing good work in Africa.
12
52178
3382
01:11
Instead, everything we touched we killed.
13
55560
7013
01:18
Our first project, the one that has inspired my first book,
14
62573
5103
01:23
"Ripples from the Zambezi,"
15
67676
2888
01:26
was a project where we Italians
16
70564
2565
01:29
decided to teach Zambian people how to grow food.
17
73129
5921
01:34
So we arrived there with Italian seeds in southern Zambia
18
79050
4349
01:39
in this absolutely magnificent valley
19
83399
3480
01:42
going down to the Zambezi River,
20
86879
3253
01:46
and we taught the local people how to grow Italian tomatoes
21
90132
3628
01:49
and zucchini and ...
22
93760
2791
01:52
And of course the local people had absolutely no interest
23
96551
2195
01:54
in doing that, so we paid them to come and work,
24
98746
2915
01:57
and sometimes they would show up. (Laughter)
25
101661
4135
02:01
And we were amazed that the local people,
26
105796
2727
02:04
in such a fertile valley, would not have any agriculture.
27
108523
3087
02:07
But instead of asking them how come they were not
28
111610
3208
02:10
growing anything, we simply said, "Thank God we're here." (Laughter)
29
114818
4022
02:14
"Just in the nick of time to save the Zambian people from starvation."
30
118840
4668
02:19
And of course, everything in Africa grew beautifully.
31
123508
3460
02:22
We had these magnificent tomatoes. In Italy, a tomato
32
126968
2658
02:25
would grow to this size. In Zambia, to this size.
33
129626
3609
02:29
And we could not believe, and we were telling the Zambians,
34
133235
2821
02:31
"Look how easy agriculture is."
35
136056
2472
02:34
When the tomatoes were nice and ripe and red,
36
138528
3011
02:37
overnight, some 200 hippos came out from the river
37
141539
3428
02:40
and they ate everything. (Laughter)
38
144967
4003
02:44
And we said to the Zambians, "My God, the hippos!"
39
148970
4584
02:49
And the Zambians said, "Yes, that's why we have no agriculture here." (Laughter)
40
153554
5681
02:55
"Why didn't you tell us?""You never asked."
41
159235
6252
03:01
I thought it was only us Italians blundering around Africa,
42
165487
5088
03:06
but then I saw what the Americans were doing,
43
170575
2744
03:09
what the English were doing, what the French were doing,
44
173319
2736
03:11
and after seeing what they were doing,
45
176055
2593
03:14
I became quite proud of our project in Zambia.
46
178648
3359
03:17
Because, you see, at least we fed the hippos.
47
182007
4989
03:22
You should see the rubbish — (Applause) --
48
186996
4247
03:27
You should see the rubbish that we have bestowed
49
191243
2494
03:29
on unsuspecting African people.
50
193737
1800
03:31
You want to read the book,
51
195537
1576
03:33
read "Dead Aid," by Dambisa Moyo,
52
197113
4931
03:37
Zambian woman economist.
53
202044
3007
03:40
The book was published in 2009.
54
205051
2370
03:43
We Western donor countries have given the African continent
55
207421
4574
03:47
two trillion American dollars in the last 50 years.
56
211995
4993
03:52
I'm not going to tell you the damage that that money has done.
57
216988
3825
03:56
Just go and read her book.
58
220813
2188
03:58
Read it from an African woman, the damage that we have done.
59
223001
8363
04:07
We Western people are imperialist, colonialist missionaries,
60
231364
5967
04:13
and there are only two ways we deal with people:
61
237331
3314
04:16
We either patronize them, or we are paternalistic.
62
240645
4389
04:20
The two words come from the Latin root "pater,"
63
245034
3104
04:24
which means "father."
64
248138
2230
04:26
But they mean two different things.
65
250368
3853
04:30
Paternalistic, I treat anybody from a different culture
66
254221
3361
04:33
as if they were my children. "I love you so much."
67
257582
5803
04:39
Patronizing, I treat everybody from another culture
68
263385
4507
04:43
as if they were my servants.
69
267892
2398
04:46
That's why the white people in Africa are called "bwana," boss.
70
270290
6071
04:52
I was given a slap in the face reading a book,
71
276361
3583
04:55
"Small is Beautiful," written by Schumacher, who said,
72
279944
4967
05:00
above all in economic development, if people
73
284911
2958
05:03
do not wish to be helped, leave them alone.
74
287869
4555
05:08
This should be the first principle of aid.
75
292424
2827
05:11
The first principle of aid is respect.
76
295251
3686
05:14
This morning, the gentleman who opened this conference
77
298937
2528
05:17
lay a stick on the floor, and said,
78
301465
3801
05:21
"Can we -- can you imagine a city
79
305266
4258
05:25
that is not neocolonial?"
80
309524
3922
05:29
I decided when I was 27 years old
81
313446
4153
05:33
to only respond to people,
82
317599
4207
05:37
and I invented a system called Enterprise Facilitation,
83
321806
4424
05:42
where you never initiate anything,
84
326230
3375
05:45
you never motivate anybody, but you become a servant
85
329605
4222
05:49
of the local passion, the servant of local people
86
333827
3561
05:53
who have a dream to become a better person.
87
337388
4398
05:57
So what you do -- you shut up.
88
341786
4409
06:02
You never arrive in a community with any ideas,
89
346195
3712
06:05
and you sit with the local people.
90
349907
4439
06:10
We don't work from offices.
91
354346
2192
06:12
We meet at the cafe. We meet at the pub.
92
356538
3966
06:16
We have zero infrastructure.
93
360504
3315
06:19
And what we do, we become friends,
94
363819
3327
06:23
and we find out what that person wants to do.
95
367146
4760
06:27
The most important thing is passion.
96
371906
1858
06:29
You can give somebody an idea.
97
373764
2240
06:31
If that person doesn't want to do it,
98
376004
1622
06:33
what are you going to do?
99
377626
3681
06:37
The passion that the person has for her own growth
100
381307
4546
06:41
is the most important thing.
101
385853
1726
06:43
The passion that that man has for his own personal growth
102
387579
4557
06:48
is the most important thing.
103
392136
1665
06:49
And then we help them to go and find the knowledge,
104
393801
3087
06:52
because nobody in the world can succeed alone.
105
396888
5469
06:58
The person with the idea may not have the knowledge,
106
402357
2719
07:00
but the knowledge is available.
107
405076
2138
07:03
So years and years ago, I had this idea:
108
407214
3859
07:06
Why don't we, for once, instead of arriving in the community
109
411073
4166
07:11
to tell people what to do, why don't, for once,
110
415239
4703
07:15
listen to them? But not in community meetings.
111
419942
4825
07:20
Let me tell you a secret.
112
424767
4914
07:25
There is a problem with community meetings.
113
429681
4345
07:29
Entrepreneurs never come,
114
434026
3706
07:33
and they never tell you, in a public meeting,
115
437732
3172
07:36
what they want to do with their own money,
116
440904
3616
07:40
what opportunity they have identified.
117
444520
3829
07:44
So planning has this blind spot.
118
448349
4924
07:49
The smartest people in your community you don't even know,
119
453273
4291
07:53
because they don't come to your public meetings.
120
457564
7840
08:01
What we do, we work one-on-one,
121
465404
3960
08:05
and to work one-on-one, you have to create
122
469364
1713
08:06
a social infrastructure that doesn't exist.
123
471077
2675
08:09
You have to create a new profession.
124
473752
2572
08:12
The profession is the family doctor of enterprise,
125
476324
5504
08:17
the family doctor of business, who sits with you
126
481828
3571
08:21
in your house, at your kitchen table, at the cafe,
127
485399
3125
08:24
and helps you find the resources to transform your passion
128
488524
4038
08:28
into a way to make a living.
129
492562
2393
08:30
I started this as a tryout in Esperance, in Western Australia.
130
494955
5321
08:36
I was a doing a Ph.D. at the time,
131
500276
2252
08:38
trying to go away from this patronizing bullshit
132
502528
4323
08:42
that we arrive and tell you what to do.
133
506851
3812
08:46
And so what I did in Esperance that first year
134
510663
4580
08:51
was to just walk the streets, and in three days
135
515243
4626
08:55
I had my first client, and I helped this first guy
136
519869
2894
08:58
who was smoking fish from a garage, was a Maori guy,
137
522763
4545
09:03
and I helped him to sell to the restaurant in Perth,
138
527308
3305
09:06
to get organized, and then the fishermen came to me to say,
139
530613
3130
09:09
"You the guy who helped Maori? Can you help us?"
140
533743
2986
09:12
And I helped these five fishermen to work together
141
536729
3164
09:15
and get this beautiful tuna not to the cannery in Albany
142
539893
4136
09:19
for 60 cents a kilo, but we found a way
143
544029
3833
09:23
to take the fish for sushi to Japan for 15 dollars a kilo,
144
547862
5351
09:29
and the farmers came to talk to me, said,
145
553213
1522
09:30
"Hey, you helped them. Can you help us?"
146
554735
2289
09:32
In a year, I had 27 projects going on,
147
557024
2926
09:35
and the government came to see me to say,
148
559950
2152
09:38
"How can you do that?
149
562102
2387
09:40
How can you do — ?" And I said, "I do something very, very, very difficult.
150
564489
3326
09:43
I shut up, and listen to them." (Laughter)
151
567815
5653
09:49
So — (Applause) —
152
573468
8222
09:57
So the government says, "Do it again." (Laughter)
153
581690
4605
10:02
We've done it in 300 communities around the world.
154
586295
3158
10:05
We have helped to start 40,000 businesses.
155
589453
3535
10:08
There is a new generation of entrepreneurs
156
592988
1672
10:10
who are dying of solitude.
157
594660
2529
10:13
Peter Drucker, one of the greatest management consultants in history,
158
597189
6159
10:19
died age 96, a few years ago.
159
603348
4552
10:23
Peter Drucker was a professor of philosophy
160
607900
1780
10:25
before becoming involved in business,
161
609680
1964
10:27
and this is what Peter Drucker says:
162
611644
2877
10:30
"Planning is actually incompatible
163
614521
5664
10:36
with an entrepreneurial society and economy."
164
620185
4249
10:40
Planning is the kiss of death of entrepreneurship.
165
624434
6243
10:46
So now you're rebuilding Christchurch
166
630677
2695
10:49
without knowing what the smartest people in Christchurch
167
633372
3481
10:52
want to do with their own money and their own energy.
168
636853
4658
10:57
You have to learn how to get these people
169
641511
3198
11:00
to come and talk to you.
170
644709
2997
11:03
You have to offer them confidentiality, privacy,
171
647706
4828
11:08
you have to be fantastic at helping them,
172
652534
3784
11:12
and then they will come, and they will come in droves.
173
656318
3994
11:16
In a community of 10,000 people, we get 200 clients.
174
660312
2895
11:19
Can you imagine a community of 400,000 people,
175
663207
2572
11:21
the intelligence and the passion?
176
665779
2242
11:23
Which presentation have you applauded the most this morning?
177
668021
3531
11:27
Local, passionate people. That's who you have applauded.
178
671552
5960
11:33
So what I'm saying is that
179
677512
5271
11:38
entrepreneurship is where it's at.
180
682783
2467
11:41
We are at the end of the first industrial revolution --
181
685250
3146
11:44
nonrenewable fossil fuels, manufacturing --
182
688396
3313
11:47
and all of a sudden, we have systems which are not sustainable.
183
691709
4457
11:52
The internal combustion engine is not sustainable.
184
696166
2647
11:54
Freon way of maintaining things is not sustainable.
185
698813
3321
11:58
What we have to look at is at how we
186
702134
3088
12:01
feed, cure, educate, transport, communicate
187
705222
6018
12:07
for seven billion people in a sustainable way.
188
711240
3551
12:10
The technologies do not exist to do that.
189
714791
3894
12:14
Who is going to invent the technology
190
718685
3368
12:17
for the green revolution? Universities? Forget about it!
191
722053
6498
12:24
Government? Forget about it!
192
728551
2893
12:27
It will be entrepreneurs, and they're doing it now.
193
731444
5254
12:32
There's a lovely story that I read in a futurist magazine
194
736698
2895
12:35
many, many years ago.
195
739593
1673
12:37
There was a group of experts who were invited
196
741266
2220
12:39
to discuss the future of the city of New York in 1860.
197
743486
4628
12:44
And in 1860, this group of people came together,
198
748114
2490
12:46
and they all speculated about what would happen
199
750604
2947
12:49
to the city of New York in 100 years,
200
753551
1854
12:51
and the conclusion was unanimous:
201
755405
1476
12:52
The city of New York would not exist in 100 years.
202
756881
3941
12:56
Why? Because they looked at the curve and said,
203
760822
2261
12:58
if the population keeps growing at this rate,
204
763083
2966
13:01
to move the population of New York around,
205
766049
4136
13:06
they would have needed six million horses,
206
770185
2865
13:08
and the manure created by six million horses
207
773050
3355
13:12
would be impossible to deal with.
208
776405
2379
13:14
They were already drowning in manure. (Laughter)
209
778784
5630
13:20
So 1860, they are seeing this dirty technology
210
784414
5049
13:25
that is going to choke the life out of New York.
211
789463
4818
13:30
So what happens? In 40 years' time, in the year 1900,
212
794281
5129
13:35
in the United States of America, there were 1,001
213
799410
4603
13:39
car manufacturing companies -- 1,001.
214
804013
6380
13:46
The idea of finding a different technology
215
810393
3606
13:49
had absolutely taken over,
216
813999
2362
13:52
and there were tiny, tiny little factories in backwaters.
217
816361
4916
13:57
Dearborn, Michigan. Henry Ford.
218
821277
5632
14:02
However, there is a secret to work with entrepreneurs.
219
826909
4371
14:07
First, you have to offer them confidentiality.
220
831280
3394
14:10
Otherwise they don't come and talk to you.
221
834674
2338
14:12
Then you have to offer them absolute, dedicated,
222
837012
4310
14:17
passionate service to them.
223
841322
3452
14:20
And then you have to tell them the truth about entrepreneurship.
224
844774
3647
14:24
The smallest company, the biggest company,
225
848421
2771
14:27
has to be capable of doing three things beautifully:
226
851192
3390
14:30
The product that you want to sell has to be fantastic,
227
854582
4251
14:34
you have to have fantastic marketing,
228
858833
3824
14:38
and you have to have tremendous financial management.
229
862657
3369
14:41
Guess what?
230
866026
2588
14:44
We have never met a single human being
231
868614
2414
14:46
in the world who can make it, sell it and look after the money.
232
871028
5647
14:52
It doesn't exist.
233
876675
2831
14:55
This person has never been born.
234
879506
2750
14:58
We've done the research, and we have looked
235
882256
2492
15:00
at the 100 iconic companies of the world --
236
884748
3951
15:04
Carnegie, Westinghouse, Edison, Ford,
237
888699
4581
15:09
all the new companies, Google, Yahoo.
238
893280
2603
15:11
There's only one thing that all the successful companies
239
895883
2676
15:14
in the world have in common, only one:
240
898559
3488
15:17
None were started by one person.
241
902047
4535
15:22
Now we teach entrepreneurship to 16-year-olds
242
906582
4502
15:26
in Northumberland, and we start the class
243
911084
3541
15:30
by giving them the first two pages of Richard Branson's autobiography,
244
914625
4424
15:34
and the task of the 16-year-olds is to underline,
245
919049
3837
15:38
in the first two pages of Richard Branson's autobiography
246
922886
3628
15:42
how many times Richard uses the word "I"
247
926514
3155
15:45
and how many times he uses the word "we."
248
929669
2709
15:48
Never the word "I," and the word "we" 32 times.
249
932378
4740
15:53
He wasn't alone when he started.
250
937118
3253
15:56
Nobody started a company alone. No one.
251
940371
5044
16:01
So we can create the community
252
945415
3106
16:04
where we have facilitators who come from a small business background
253
948521
3426
16:07
sitting in cafes, in bars, and your dedicated buddies
254
951947
7497
16:15
who will do to you, what somebody did for this gentleman
255
959444
3672
16:19
who talks about this epic,
256
963116
3241
16:22
somebody who will say to you, "What do you need?
257
966357
2255
16:24
What can you do? Can you make it?
258
968612
1939
16:26
Okay, can you sell it? Can you look after the money?"
259
970551
2250
16:28
"Oh, no, I cannot do this.""Would you like me to find you somebody?"
260
972801
3754
16:32
We activate communities.
261
976555
2088
16:34
We have groups of volunteers supporting the Enterprise Facilitator
262
978643
4044
16:38
to help you to find resources and people
263
982687
3123
16:41
and we have discovered that the miracle
264
985810
2989
16:44
of the intelligence of local people is such
265
988799
2504
16:47
that you can change the culture and the economy
266
991303
3707
16:50
of this community just by capturing the passion,
267
995010
4181
16:55
the energy and imagination of your own people.
268
999191
3637
16:58
Thank you. (Applause)
269
1002828
4693
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Ernesto Sirolli - Sustainable development expertErnesto Sirolli got his start doing aid work in Africa in the 70's -- and quickly realised how ineffective it was.
Why you should listen
Ernesto Sirolli is a noted authority in the field of sustainable economic development and is the Founder of the Sirolli Institute, an international non-profit organization that teaches community leaders how to establish and maintain Enterprise Facilitation projects in their community. The Institute is now training communities in the USA, Canada, Australia, England and Scotland.
In 1985, he pioneered in Esperance, a small rural community in Western Australia, a unique economic development approach based on harnessing the passion, determination, intelligence, and resourcefulness of the local people. The striking results of "The Esperance Experience" have prompted more than 250 communities around the world to adopt responsive, person-centered approaches to local economic development similar to the Enterprise Facilitation® model pioneered in Esperance.
Ernesto Sirolli | Speaker | TED.com