TED2014
Michel Laberge: How synchronized hammer strikes could generate nuclear fusion
Filmed:
Readability: 3.6
1,108,602 views
Our energy future depends on nuclear fusion, says Michel Laberge. The plasma physicist runs a small company with a big idea for a new type of nuclear reactor that could produce clean, cheap energy. His secret recipe? High speeds, scorching temperatures and crushing pressure. In this hopeful talk, he explains how nuclear fusion might be just around the corner.
Michel Laberge - Plasma physicist
In a lab near Vancouver, Michel Laberge and his team at General Fusion are building a prototype fusion reactor that mimics the processes of the sun to produce cheap, clean and abundant energy. Full bio
In a lab near Vancouver, Michel Laberge and his team at General Fusion are building a prototype fusion reactor that mimics the processes of the sun to produce cheap, clean and abundant energy. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
Wow, this is bright.
0
1090
2031
00:15
It must use a lot of power.
1
3121
2991
00:18
Well, flying you all in here
2
6112
1492
00:19
must have cost a bit of energy too.
3
7604
2448
00:22
So the whole planet needs a lot of energy,
4
10052
2918
00:24
and so far we've been running mostly on fossil fuel.
5
12970
2901
00:27
We've been burning gas.
6
15871
2049
00:29
It's been a good run.
7
17920
1387
00:31
It got us to where we are, but we have to stop.
8
19307
2868
00:34
We can't do that anymore.
9
22175
2154
00:36
So we are trying different types of energy now,
10
24329
2281
00:38
alternative energy,
11
26610
1214
00:39
but it proved quite difficult to find something
12
27824
2498
00:42
that's as convenient and as cost-effective
13
30322
2801
00:45
as oil, gas and coal.
14
33123
2817
00:47
My personal favorite is nuclear energy.
15
35940
4090
00:52
Now, it's very energy-dense,
16
40030
2601
00:54
it produces solid, reliable power,
17
42631
2481
00:57
and it doesn't make any CO2.
18
45112
2383
00:59
Now we know of two ways
19
47495
1492
01:00
of making nuclear energy: fission and fusion.
20
48987
5174
01:06
Now in fission, you take a big nucleus,
21
54161
2345
01:08
you break it in part, in two,
22
56506
1635
01:10
and it makes lots of energy,
23
58141
1547
01:11
and this is how the nuclear reactor today works.
24
59688
2213
01:13
It works pretty good.
25
61901
1409
01:15
And then there's fusion.
26
63310
2154
01:17
Now, I like fusion. Fusion's much better.
27
65464
2406
01:19
So you take two small nuclei,
28
67870
1694
01:21
you put it together, and you make helium,
29
69564
2506
01:24
and that's very nice.
30
72070
1358
01:25
It makes lots of energy.
31
73428
1546
01:26
This is nature's way of producing energy.
32
74974
2600
01:29
The sun and all the stars in the universe
33
77574
2408
01:31
run on fusion.
34
79982
2245
01:34
Now, a fusion plant
35
82227
1896
01:36
would actually be quite cost-effective
36
84123
2315
01:38
and it also would be quite safe.
37
86438
1990
01:40
It only produces short term radioactive waste,
38
88428
4433
01:44
and it cannot melt down.
39
92861
2032
01:46
Now, the fuel from fusion comes from the ocean.
40
94893
2527
01:49
In the ocean, you can extract the fuel
41
97420
1818
01:51
for about one thousandth of a cent
42
99238
1890
01:53
per kilowatt-hour, so that's very, very cheap.
43
101128
2331
01:55
And if the whole planet would run on fusion,
44
103459
3388
01:58
we could extract the fuel from the ocean.
45
106847
1444
02:00
It would run for billions and billions of years.
46
108291
3264
02:03
Now, if fusion is so great, why don't we have it?
47
111555
3772
02:07
Where is it?
48
115327
1336
02:08
Well, there's always a bit of a catch.
49
116663
1848
02:10
Fusion is really, really hard to do.
50
118511
3238
02:13
So the problem is, those two nuclei,
51
121749
2484
02:16
they are both positively charged,
52
124233
1628
02:17
so they don't want to fuse.
53
125861
1791
02:19
They go like this. They go like that.
54
127652
1777
02:21
So in order to make them fuse,
55
129429
964
02:22
you have to throw them at
each other with great speed,
each other with great speed,
56
130393
2187
02:24
and if they have enough speed,
57
132580
913
02:25
they will go against the repulsion,
58
133493
1834
02:27
they will touch, and they will make energy.
59
135327
2153
02:29
Now, the particle speed
60
137480
2407
02:31
is a measure of the temperature.
61
139887
1770
02:33
So the temperature required for fusion
62
141657
1742
02:35
is 150 billion degrees C.
63
143399
3162
02:38
This is rather warm,
64
146561
1831
02:40
and this is why fusion is so hard to do.
65
148392
3446
02:43
Now, I caught my little fusion bug
66
151838
2025
02:45
when I did my Ph.D. here at the
University of British Columbia,
University of British Columbia,
67
153863
3670
02:49
and then I got a big job in a laser printer place
68
157533
3052
02:52
making printing for the printing industry.
69
160585
2538
02:55
I worked there for 10 years,
70
163123
2252
02:57
and I got a little bit bored,
71
165375
1680
02:59
and then I was 40, and I got a mid-life crisis,
72
167055
2953
03:02
you know, the usual thing:
73
170008
1633
03:03
Who am I? What should I do?
74
171641
2459
03:06
What should I do? What can I do?
75
174100
2586
03:08
And then I was looking at my good work,
76
176686
2052
03:10
and what I was doing is I was cutting the forests
77
178738
2051
03:12
around here in B.C.
78
180789
1355
03:14
and burying you, all of you,
79
182144
1594
03:15
in millions of tons of junk mail.
80
183738
3442
03:19
Now, that was not very satisfactory.
81
187180
1935
03:21
So some people buy a Porsche.
82
189115
2265
03:23
Others get a mistress.
83
191380
2771
03:26
But I've decided to get my bit
84
194151
1674
03:27
to solve global warming and make fusion happen.
85
195825
4263
03:32
Now, so the first thing I did
86
200088
1731
03:33
is I looked into the literature and I see,
87
201819
2429
03:36
how does fusion work?
88
204248
2742
03:38
So the physicists have been
working on fusion for a while,
working on fusion for a while,
89
206990
3142
03:42
and one of the ways they do it
90
210132
1316
03:43
is with something called a tokamak.
91
211448
2306
03:45
It's a big ring of magnetic coil,
92
213754
2730
03:48
superconducting coil,
93
216484
1326
03:49
and it makes a magnetic field
94
217810
1350
03:51
in a ring like this,
95
219160
1788
03:52
and the hot gas in the middle,
96
220948
1392
03:54
which is called a plasma, is trapped.
97
222340
2130
03:56
The particles go round and round and round
98
224470
1748
03:58
the circle at the wall.
99
226218
1440
03:59
Then they throw a huge amount of heat in there
100
227658
1528
04:01
to try to cook that to fusion temperature.
101
229186
2474
04:03
So this is the inside of one of those donuts,
102
231660
2328
04:05
and on the right side you can see
103
233988
1332
04:07
the fusion plasma in there.
104
235320
2140
04:09
Now, a second way of doing this
105
237460
2248
04:11
is by using laser fusion.
106
239708
2400
04:14
Now in laser fusion, you have a little ping pong ball,
107
242108
2120
04:16
you put the fusion fuel in the center,
108
244228
2046
04:18
and you zap that with a whole
bunch of laser around it.
bunch of laser around it.
109
246274
2930
04:21
The lasers are very strong, and it squashes
110
249204
1704
04:22
the ping pong ball really, really quick.
111
250908
1726
04:24
And if you squeeze something hard enough,
112
252634
1955
04:26
it gets hotter,
113
254589
1375
04:27
and if it gets really, really fast,
114
255964
1396
04:29
and they do that in one billionth of a second,
115
257360
2318
04:31
it makes enough energy and enough heat
116
259678
1903
04:33
to make fusion.
117
261581
1336
04:34
So this is the inside of one such machine.
118
262917
2077
04:36
You see the laser beam and the pellet
119
264994
1843
04:38
in the center.
120
266837
1549
04:40
Now, most people think that fusion is going nowhere.
121
268386
2962
04:43
They always think that the physicists are in their lab
122
271348
2932
04:46
and they're working hard, but nothing is happening.
123
274280
1815
04:48
That's actually not quite true.
124
276095
1520
04:49
This is a curve of the gain in fusion
125
277615
1992
04:51
over the last 30 years or so,
126
279607
2192
04:53
and you can see that we're making now
127
281799
1558
04:55
about 10,000 times more fusion than we used to
128
283357
2833
04:58
when we started.
129
286190
1074
04:59
That's a pretty good gain.
130
287264
995
05:00
As a matter of fact, it's as fast
131
288259
1986
05:02
as the fabled Moore's Law
132
290245
1700
05:03
that defined the amount of transistors
133
291945
2204
05:06
they can put on a chip.
134
294149
1517
05:07
Now, this dot here is called JET,
135
295666
3005
05:10
the Joint European Torus.
136
298671
1423
05:12
It's a big tokamak donut in Europe,
137
300094
2430
05:14
and this machine in 1997
138
302524
3070
05:17
produced 16 megawatts of fusion power
139
305594
3224
05:20
with 17 megawatts of heat.
140
308818
2158
05:22
Now, you say, that's not much use,
141
310976
1805
05:24
but it's actually pretty close,
142
312781
1711
05:26
considering we can get
143
314492
1040
05:27
about 10,000 times more than we started.
144
315532
2307
05:29
The second dot here is the NIF.
145
317839
2613
05:32
It's the National Ignition Facility.
146
320452
2286
05:34
It's a big laser machine in the U.S.,
147
322738
2526
05:37
and last month they announced
148
325264
1277
05:38
with quite a bit of noise
149
326541
1853
05:40
that they had managed to make more fusion energy
150
328394
2158
05:42
from the fusion
151
330552
1590
05:44
than the energy that they put in
the center of the ping pong ball.
the center of the ping pong ball.
152
332142
2856
05:46
Now, that's not quite good enough,
153
334998
1825
05:48
because the laser to put that energy in
154
336823
1700
05:50
was more energy than that,
155
338523
1732
05:52
but it was pretty good.
156
340255
2040
05:54
Now this is ITER,
157
342295
1727
05:56
pronounced in French: EE-tairh.
158
344022
2058
05:58
So this is a big collaboration of different countries
159
346080
3131
06:01
that are building a huge magnetic donut
160
349211
1855
06:03
in the south of France,
161
351066
1944
06:05
and this machine, when it's finished,
162
353010
2008
06:07
will produce 500 megawatts of fusion power
163
355018
2778
06:09
with only 50 megawatts to make it.
164
357796
2400
06:12
So this one is the real one.
165
360196
1186
06:13
It's going to work.
166
361382
732
06:14
That's the kind of machine that makes energy.
167
362114
2192
06:16
Now if you look at the graph, you will notice
168
364306
1756
06:18
that those two dots are a little bit
169
366062
1505
06:19
on the right of the curve.
170
367567
1042
06:20
We kind of have fallen off the progress.
171
368609
1936
06:22
Actually, the science to make those machines
172
370545
1989
06:24
was really in time
173
372534
1536
06:26
to produce fusion during that curve.
174
374070
2836
06:28
However, there has been a bit of politics going on,
175
376906
2739
06:31
and the will to do it was not there,
176
379645
2132
06:33
so it drifted to the right.
177
381777
1678
06:35
ITER, for example, could have been built
178
383455
2056
06:37
in 2000 or 2005,
179
385511
1851
06:39
but because it's a big international collaboration,
180
387362
2445
06:41
the politics got in and it delayed it a bit.
181
389807
2448
06:44
For example, it took them about three years
182
392255
1624
06:45
to decide where to put it.
183
393879
1568
06:47
Now, fusion is often criticized
184
395447
2536
06:49
for being a little too expensive.
185
397983
1600
06:51
Yes, it did cost
186
399583
1541
06:53
a billion dollars or two billion dollars a year
187
401124
2036
06:55
to make this progress.
188
403160
1193
06:56
But you have to compare that to the cost
189
404353
1590
06:57
of making Moore's Law.
190
405943
1240
06:59
That cost way more than that.
191
407183
1888
07:01
The result of Moore's Law
192
409071
1518
07:02
is this cell phone here in my pocket.
193
410589
1936
07:04
This cell phone, and the Internet behind it,
194
412525
2229
07:06
cost about one trillion dollars,
195
414754
2680
07:09
just so I can take a selfie
196
417434
3231
07:12
and put it on Facebook.
197
420665
2574
07:15
Then when my dad sees that,
198
423239
1501
07:16
he'll be very proud.
199
424740
3180
07:19
We also spend about 650 billion dollars a year
200
427920
3908
07:23
in subsidies for oil and gas
201
431828
2302
07:26
and renewable energy.
202
434130
1630
07:27
Now, we spend one half of a percent of that on fusion.
203
435760
4174
07:31
So me, personally, I don't think it's too expensive.
204
439934
2648
07:34
I think it's actually been shortchanged,
205
442582
1780
07:36
considering it can solve all our energy problems
206
444362
2392
07:38
cleanly for the next couple of billions of years.
207
446754
2674
07:41
Now I can say that, but I'm a little bit biased,
208
449428
2660
07:44
because I started a fusion company
209
452088
1888
07:45
and I don't even have a Facebook account.
210
453976
2558
07:48
So when I started this fusion company in 2002,
211
456534
5383
07:53
I knew I couldn't fight with the big lads.
212
461917
2842
07:56
They had much more resources than me.
213
464759
1577
07:58
So I decided I would need to find a solution
214
466336
2240
08:00
that is cheaper and faster.
215
468576
1887
08:02
Now magnetic and laser fusion
216
470463
1910
08:04
are pretty good machines.
217
472373
1431
08:05
They are awesome pieces of technology,
218
473804
1441
08:07
wonderful machines, and they have shown
219
475245
1874
08:09
that fusion can be done.
220
477119
1479
08:10
However, as a power plant,
221
478598
1954
08:12
I don't think they're very good.
222
480552
1871
08:14
They're way too big, way too complicated,
223
482423
2057
08:16
way too expensive,
224
484480
1138
08:17
and also, they don't deal very much
225
485618
1756
08:19
with the fusion energy.
226
487374
1274
08:20
When you make fusion, the energy comes out
227
488648
1758
08:22
as neutrons, fast neutrons comes out of the plasma.
228
490406
2668
08:25
Those neutrons hit the wall of the machine.
229
493074
2260
08:27
It damages it.
230
495334
1385
08:28
And also, you have to catch
the heat from those neutrons
the heat from those neutrons
231
496719
1964
08:30
and run some steam to spin a turbine somewhere,
232
498683
2433
08:33
and on those machines,
233
501116
1284
08:34
it was all a bit of an afterthought.
234
502400
2631
08:37
So I decided that surely there
is a better way of doing that.
is a better way of doing that.
235
505031
3151
08:40
So back to the literature,
236
508182
1284
08:41
and I read about the fusion everywhere.
237
509466
1992
08:43
One way in particular attracted my attention,
238
511458
2722
08:46
and it's called magnetized target fusion,
239
514180
2090
08:48
or MTF for short.
240
516270
2588
08:50
Now, in MTF, what you want to do
241
518858
2442
08:53
is you take a big vat
242
521300
1970
08:55
and you fill that with liquid metal,
243
523270
2016
08:57
and you spin the liquid metal
244
525286
1520
08:58
to open a vortex in the center,
245
526806
1648
09:00
a bit like your sink.
246
528454
1136
09:01
When you pull the plug on a sink, it makes a vortex.
247
529590
2104
09:03
And then you have some pistons driven by pressure
248
531694
2396
09:06
that goes on the outside,
249
534090
1476
09:07
and this compresses the liquid metal
250
535566
1920
09:09
around the plasma, and it compresses it,
251
537486
1762
09:11
it gets hotter, like a laser,
252
539248
1654
09:12
and then it makes fusion.
253
540902
1226
09:14
So it's a bit of a mix
254
542128
920
09:15
between a magnetized fusion
255
543048
1655
09:16
and the laser fusion.
256
544703
1983
09:18
So those have a couple of very good advantages.
257
546686
2773
09:21
The liquid metal absorbs all the neutrons
258
549459
2343
09:23
and no neutrons hit the wall,
259
551802
1756
09:25
and therefore there's no damage to the machine.
260
553558
2136
09:27
The liquid metal gets hot,
261
555694
1456
09:29
so you can pump that in a heat exchanger,
262
557150
2000
09:31
make some steam, spin a turbine.
263
559150
1880
09:33
So that's a very convenient way of doing
264
561030
1179
09:34
this part of the process.
265
562209
1260
09:35
And finally, all the energy to make the fusion happen
266
563469
3591
09:39
comes from steam-powered pistons,
267
567060
2135
09:41
which is way cheaper than lasers
268
569195
1656
09:42
or superconducting coils.
269
570851
1894
09:44
Now, this was all very good
270
572745
1488
09:46
except for the problem that it didn't quite work.
271
574233
2504
09:48
(Laughter)
272
576737
1870
09:50
There's always a catch.
273
578607
1296
09:51
So when you compress that,
274
579903
1514
09:53
the plasma cools down
275
581417
1924
09:55
faster than the compression speed,
276
583341
1628
09:56
so you're trying to compress it,
277
584969
1313
09:58
but the plasma cooled down and
cooled down and cooled down
cooled down and cooled down
278
586282
2335
10:00
and then it did absolutely nothing.
279
588617
1941
10:02
So when I saw that, I said,
well, this is such a shame,
well, this is such a shame,
280
590558
2035
10:04
because it's a very, very good idea.
281
592593
1750
10:06
So hopefully I can improve on that.
282
594343
2354
10:08
So I thought about it for a minute,
283
596697
1095
10:09
and I said, okay, how can we make that work better?
284
597792
2077
10:11
So then I thought about impact.
285
599869
1858
10:13
What about if we use a big hammer
286
601727
1834
10:15
and we swing it and we hit the nail like this,
287
603561
2532
10:18
in the place of putting the hammer on the nail
288
606093
1974
10:20
and pushing and try to put it in? That won't work.
289
608067
2195
10:22
So what the idea is
290
610262
1931
10:24
is to use the idea of an impact.
291
612193
1744
10:25
So we accelerate the pistons with steam,
292
613937
2082
10:28
that takes a little bit of time,
293
616019
1279
10:29
but then, bang! you hit the piston,
294
617298
1983
10:31
and, baff!, all the energy is done instantly,
295
619281
2552
10:33
down instantly to the liquid,
296
621833
1596
10:35
and that compresses the plasma much faster.
297
623429
2050
10:37
So I decided, okay, this is good, let's make that.
298
625479
2448
10:39
So we built this machine in this garage here.
299
627927
3725
10:43
We made a small machine
300
631652
1085
10:44
that we managed to squeeze
301
632737
1972
10:46
a little bit of neutrons out of that,
302
634709
1648
10:48
and those are my marketing neutrons,
303
636357
2201
10:50
and with those marketing neutrons,
304
638558
1443
10:52
then I raised about 50 million dollars,
305
640001
2599
10:54
and I hired 65 people. That's my team here.
306
642600
2890
10:57
And this is what we want to build.
307
645490
1582
10:59
So it's going to be a big machine,
308
647072
1514
11:00
about three meters in diameter,
309
648586
1474
11:02
liquid lead spinning around,
310
650060
1802
11:03
big vortex in the center,
311
651862
1592
11:05
put the plasma on the top and on the bottom,
312
653454
2320
11:07
piston hits on the side,
313
655774
1426
11:09
bang!, it compresses it,
314
657200
1510
11:10
and it will make some energy,
315
658710
1284
11:11
and the neutron will come out in the liquid metal,
316
659994
2392
11:14
going to go in a steam engine and make the turbine,
317
662386
2600
11:16
and some of the steam will go back
318
664986
1506
11:18
to fire the piston.
319
666492
998
11:19
We're going to run that about one time per second,
320
667490
1890
11:21
and it will produce 100 megawatts of electricity.
321
669380
5384
11:26
Okay, we also built this injector,
322
674764
1685
11:28
so this injector makes the plasma to start with.
323
676449
2287
11:30
It makes the plasma at about
324
678736
1715
11:32
a lukewarm temperature of three million degrees C.
325
680451
3975
11:36
Unfortunately, it doesn't last quite long enough,
326
684426
2207
11:38
so we need to extend the life
of the plasma a little bit,
of the plasma a little bit,
327
686633
3135
11:41
but last month it got a lot better,
328
689768
1632
11:43
so I think we have the plasma compressing now.
329
691400
2585
11:45
Then we built a small sphere, about this big,
330
693985
2556
11:48
14 pistons around it,
331
696541
1466
11:50
and this will compress the liquid.
332
698007
2324
11:52
However, plasma is difficult to compress.
333
700331
2105
11:54
When you compress it,
334
702436
789
11:55
it tends to go a little bit crooked like that,
335
703225
2552
11:57
so you need the timing of the piston
336
705777
1608
11:59
to be very good,
337
707385
1096
12:00
and for that we use several control systems,
338
708481
2672
12:03
which was not possible in 1970,
339
711153
2202
12:05
but we now can do that
340
713355
1392
12:06
with nice, new electronics.
341
714747
3292
12:10
So finally, most people think that fusion
342
718039
2529
12:12
is in the future and will never happen,
343
720568
2152
12:14
but as a matter of fact, fusion is getting very close.
344
722720
3094
12:17
We are almost there.
345
725814
1076
12:18
The big labs have shown that fusion is doable,
346
726890
2637
12:21
and now there are small companies
that are thinking about that,
that are thinking about that,
347
729527
2307
12:23
and they say, it's not that it cannot be done,
348
731834
2361
12:26
but it's how to make it cost-effectively.
349
734195
2105
12:28
General Fusion is one of those small companies,
350
736300
2153
12:30
and hopefully, very soon, somebody, someone,
351
738453
3318
12:33
will crack that nut,
352
741771
1283
12:35
and perhaps it will be General Fusion.
353
743054
1574
12:36
Thank you very much.
354
744628
1779
12:38
(Applause)
355
746407
4180
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michel Laberge - Plasma physicistIn a lab near Vancouver, Michel Laberge and his team at General Fusion are building a prototype fusion reactor that mimics the processes of the sun to produce cheap, clean and abundant energy.
Why you should listen
Fusion, putting it briefly, is what happens inside the sun: intense heat and pressure combine to convert hydrogen into helium, releasing heat and energy in a self-sustaining reaction. Harnessing that same kind of reaction could someday solve the energy crisis here on Earth, and the US (at the National Ignition Facility in California, using the world's most powerful laser), Europe (at ITER) and China are all working on fusion in multi-billion-dollar labs. Meanwhile, just outside Vancouver, a private-government collaboration spending millions-with-an-m is keeping pace.
At General Fusion, plasma physicist Michel Laberge hopes to start a fusion reaction by combining several techniques in one reactor. Inside a spherical chamber, molten lead-lithium is spun up into a vortex, then shot with a pulse of magnetically contained plasma -- meanwhile, around the edge of the sphere, an array of pistons will drive a pressure wave into the center of the sphere, compressing the plasma to fusion conditions. General Fusion is designing and protoyping each piece of this system.
More profile about the speakerAt General Fusion, plasma physicist Michel Laberge hopes to start a fusion reaction by combining several techniques in one reactor. Inside a spherical chamber, molten lead-lithium is spun up into a vortex, then shot with a pulse of magnetically contained plasma -- meanwhile, around the edge of the sphere, an array of pistons will drive a pressure wave into the center of the sphere, compressing the plasma to fusion conditions. General Fusion is designing and protoyping each piece of this system.
Michel Laberge | Speaker | TED.com