TED Talks Live
Samantha Nutt: The real harm of the global arms trade
Filmed:
Readability: 3.6
1,121,591 views
In some parts of the world, it's easier to get an automatic rifle than a glass of clean drinking water. Is this just the way it is? Samantha Nutt, doctor and founder of the international humanitarian organization War Child, explores the global arms trade -- and suggests a bold, common sense solution for ending the cycle of violence. "War is ours," she says. "We buy it, sell it, spread it and wage it. We are therefore not powerless to solve it."
Samantha Nutt - Doctor, writer and humanitarian
Samantha Nutt envisions a world where no child knows war. Full bio
Samantha Nutt envisions a world where no child knows war. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Thank you very much. Good evening.
0
727
1631
00:14
Some of you may have noticed
that my last name is Nutt.
that my last name is Nutt.
1
2382
3316
00:18
And if you did,
you are forgiven for wondering
you are forgiven for wondering
2
6336
2803
00:21
how a Nutt managed
to end up in a war zone.
to end up in a war zone.
3
9163
2916
00:24
I actually was offered, right out
of medical school, and accepted
of medical school, and accepted
4
12103
4341
00:28
a volunteer contract to work
with UNICEF in war-torn Somalia,
with UNICEF in war-torn Somalia,
5
16468
3837
00:32
that was worth one dollar.
6
20329
2479
00:34
And, you see, I had to be paid this dollar
7
22832
2411
00:37
in the event that the UN needed
to issue an evacuation order,
to issue an evacuation order,
8
25267
3135
00:40
so that I would be covered.
9
28426
2070
00:42
I was, after all, heading into one
of the world's most dangerous places.
of the world's most dangerous places.
10
30520
4372
00:47
And by now, some of you
may be asking yourselves,
may be asking yourselves,
11
35340
3135
00:50
and I just want to reassure you,
12
38499
1532
00:52
that I did get half the money up front.
13
40055
2299
00:54
(Laughter)
14
42378
1788
00:56
But you see, this is how,
with 50 cents in my pocket,
with 50 cents in my pocket,
15
44717
2852
00:59
I ended up in Baidoa, Somalia.
16
47593
2292
01:02
Journalists called it the "city of death."
17
50615
2270
01:05
And they called it the city of death
18
53299
1824
01:07
because 300,000 people
had lost their lives there --
had lost their lives there --
19
55147
3158
01:10
300,000 people,
20
58765
3598
01:14
mostly as a result
of war-related famine and disease.
of war-related famine and disease.
21
62387
4156
01:19
I was part of a team that was tasked
with trying to figure out
with trying to figure out
22
67487
3947
01:23
how best to respond
to this humanitarian catastrophe.
to this humanitarian catastrophe.
23
71458
2969
01:26
It was right on the heels
of the Rwandan genocide,
of the Rwandan genocide,
24
74839
2715
01:29
and aid money to the region was drying up.
25
77578
2667
01:32
Many aid organizations, unfortunately,
26
80269
2042
01:34
had been forced to close their doors.
27
82335
2576
01:36
And so the question that I was asked
to specifically help answer,
to specifically help answer,
28
84935
3710
01:40
which is one that aid workers ask
themselves in war zones the world over,
themselves in war zones the world over,
29
88669
5676
01:47
is: What the hell do we do now?
30
95202
2048
01:50
You know, the security environment
in Somalia at that moment in time --
in Somalia at that moment in time --
31
98131
3404
01:53
and nothing has really changed too much --
32
101559
2031
01:55
can best be described as "Mad Max"
by way of "A Clockwork Orange."
by way of "A Clockwork Orange."
33
103614
4438
02:01
And I remember very distinctly
a couple of days after my arrival,
a couple of days after my arrival,
34
109477
5131
02:06
I went up to a feeding clinic.
35
114632
2605
02:09
There were dozens of women
who were standing in line,
who were standing in line,
36
117967
2538
02:12
and they were clutching
their infants very close.
their infants very close.
37
120529
2740
02:16
About 20 minutes into
this conversation I was having
this conversation I was having
38
124309
2745
02:19
with this one young woman,
39
127078
2024
02:21
I leaned forward
40
129126
1376
02:23
and tried to put my finger
in the palm of her baby's hand.
in the palm of her baby's hand.
41
131260
3536
02:28
And when I did this,
42
136225
1311
02:29
I discovered that her baby
was already in rigor.
was already in rigor.
43
137560
3998
02:34
She was stiff,
44
142249
1754
02:36
and her little, lifeless hand
was curled into itself.
was curled into itself.
45
144709
3405
02:40
She had died hours before
46
148986
3067
02:44
of malnutrition and dehydration.
47
152759
2187
02:48
I later learned
that as her baby was dying,
that as her baby was dying,
48
156242
2898
02:51
this young woman had
been held for two days
been held for two days
49
159164
4322
02:55
by some teenage boys who were armed
with Kalashnikov rifles,
with Kalashnikov rifles,
50
163510
4736
03:00
and they were trying
to shake her down for more money,
to shake her down for more money,
51
168270
2530
03:02
money she very clearly did not have.
52
170824
2682
03:05
And this is a scene that I have confronted
53
173807
3341
03:09
in war zones the world over;
54
177172
2587
03:12
places where kids, some as young
as eight -- they are this big --
as eight -- they are this big --
55
180435
5313
03:18
and those kids, they have
never been to school.
never been to school.
56
186345
2323
03:21
But they have fought and they have killed
with automatic rifles.
with automatic rifles.
57
189049
6072
03:28
Is this just the way the world is?
58
196589
2913
03:32
Some will you tell you
that war is unavoidably human.
that war is unavoidably human.
59
200451
4349
03:37
After all, it is as old
as existence itself.
as existence itself.
60
205234
3113
03:41
We say never again, and yet it happens
again and again and again.
again and again and again.
61
209419
6634
03:49
But I will tell you
that I have seen the absolute worst
that I have seen the absolute worst
62
217232
5731
03:55
of what we as human beings
are capable of doing to one another,
are capable of doing to one another,
63
223671
3773
04:00
and yet I still believe
a different outcome is possible.
a different outcome is possible.
64
228222
4405
04:05
Do you want to know why?
65
233659
1234
04:07
Because over 20 years of doing this work,
66
235536
2318
04:09
going in and out of war zones
around the world,
around the world,
67
237878
2711
04:12
I have come to understand
68
240613
2143
04:14
that there are aspects of this problem
69
242780
1920
04:16
that we, all of us, as people
occupying this shared space,
occupying this shared space,
70
244724
4078
04:21
that we can change --
71
249421
2183
04:23
not through force or coercion or invasion,
72
251628
3934
04:27
but by simply looking at all
of the options available to us
of the options available to us
73
255586
3729
04:31
and choosing the ones that favor
peace at the expense of war,
peace at the expense of war,
74
259940
5118
04:37
instead of war at the expense of peace.
75
265722
4202
04:43
How so?
76
271158
1262
04:44
Well, I want you to consider this:
77
272444
1739
04:46
there are at least 800 million
small arms and light weapons
small arms and light weapons
78
274207
5457
04:51
in circulation in the world today.
79
279688
2456
04:54
The vast majority of civilians,
like that young baby,
like that young baby,
80
282788
3489
04:58
who are dying in war zones
around the world,
around the world,
81
286301
2389
05:00
are dying at the hands
of various armed groups
of various armed groups
82
288714
2975
05:03
who rely on a near-infinite supply
of cheap, easy and efficient weapons
of cheap, easy and efficient weapons
83
291713
6326
05:10
to rape, threaten, intimidate
and brutalize those civilians
and brutalize those civilians
84
298063
4660
05:14
at every turn.
85
302747
1404
05:16
How cheap?
86
304937
1151
05:18
Well, in some parts of the world,
87
306112
1616
05:19
you can buy an AK-47
for as little as 10 dollars.
for as little as 10 dollars.
88
307752
4398
05:24
In many places in which I have worked,
89
312174
2856
05:27
it is easier to get access
to an automatic rifle
to an automatic rifle
90
315621
4497
05:32
than it is to get access
to clean drinking water.
to clean drinking water.
91
320142
4121
05:37
And so now the important part:
92
325040
1596
05:39
Can anything be done about this?
93
327699
3119
05:43
To answer that question,
94
331922
1880
05:45
let's take a look
at this map of the world.
at this map of the world.
95
333826
2010
05:48
And now, let's add in all of the countries
that are currently at war,
that are currently at war,
96
336246
4384
05:53
and the number of people
who have either died
who have either died
97
341266
2334
05:55
or have been displaced
as a result of that violence.
as a result of that violence.
98
343624
2468
05:58
It is a staggering number --
99
346116
1396
05:59
more than 40 million people.
100
347536
2697
06:02
But you will also notice
something else about this map.
something else about this map.
101
350764
2667
06:05
You will notice
that most of those countries
that most of those countries
102
353455
2120
06:07
are in the Global South.
103
355599
1354
06:09
Now, let's look at the countries
104
357453
2290
06:11
that are the world's top 20 exporters
of small arms in the world.
of small arms in the world.
105
359767
4855
06:17
And what do we notice?
106
365559
1242
06:19
Well, you see them in green.
107
367331
1463
06:20
You will notice that those are mostly
countries in the Global North,
countries in the Global North,
108
368818
3890
06:24
primarily Western countries.
109
372732
1698
06:26
What does this tell us?
110
374454
1216
06:27
This tells us that most of the people
who are dying in war
who are dying in war
111
375694
3491
06:31
are living in poor countries,
112
379209
1903
06:33
and yet most of the people
who are profiting from war
who are profiting from war
113
381136
2814
06:36
are living in rich countries --
people like you and me.
people like you and me.
114
384609
4362
06:41
And then what if we go
beyond small arms for a second.
beyond small arms for a second.
115
389804
2802
06:44
What if we look at all weapons
in circulation in the world?
in circulation in the world?
116
392630
3224
06:47
Who does the biggest business?
117
395878
1784
06:49
Well, roughly 80 percent of those weapons
118
397686
2475
06:52
come from none other
than the five permanent members
than the five permanent members
119
400185
3542
06:55
of the United Nations Security Council,
120
403751
1891
06:57
plus Germany.
121
405666
1428
06:59
It's shocking, isn't it?
122
407769
1278
07:01
Now, some of you might be saying
at this moment in time,
at this moment in time,
123
409515
2676
07:04
"Oh yeah, but OK,
hang on a second there ... Nutt."
hang on a second there ... Nutt."
124
412215
3251
07:07
(Laughter)
125
415490
2205
07:10
Grade school was spectacular for me.
126
418267
1813
07:12
It was, really, a wonderful experience.
127
420104
1944
07:14
(Laughter)
128
422072
2954
07:17
But you might be saying to yourselves,
129
425420
1842
07:19
You know, all of these weapons
in war zones -- they're not a cause,
in war zones -- they're not a cause,
130
427286
3348
07:22
but an effect of the violence
that plagues them
that plagues them
131
430658
2422
07:25
each and every single day.
132
433104
1484
07:26
You know, places like Iraq
and Afghanistan,
and Afghanistan,
133
434612
2183
07:28
where they need these weapons
to be able to maintain law and order,
to be able to maintain law and order,
134
436819
3414
07:32
promote peace and security,
to combat terror groups --
to combat terror groups --
135
440257
3621
07:35
surely this is a good thing.
136
443902
2495
07:38
Let's take a look at that assumption
for just one moment,
for just one moment,
137
446773
2688
07:41
because you see there has been
a boom in the small-arms trade
a boom in the small-arms trade
138
449485
3786
07:45
since the start of the War on Terror.
139
453295
1784
07:47
In fact, it is a business
that has grown threefold
that has grown threefold
140
455103
3198
07:50
over the past 15 years.
141
458325
1943
07:52
And now let's compare that
to the number of people
to the number of people
142
460688
3557
07:56
who have directly died
in armed conflict around the world
in armed conflict around the world
143
464269
3826
08:00
in that same period.
144
468119
1175
08:01
What do you notice?
145
469627
1445
08:03
Well, you notice that, in fact,
that also goes up
that also goes up
146
471096
2357
08:05
roughly three- to fourfold.
147
473477
1611
08:07
They basically go up
and end at the same point.
and end at the same point.
148
475112
3665
08:11
Now, we can have a circular argument here
149
479310
2770
08:14
about whether this increase
in fatalities is a response
in fatalities is a response
150
482104
4072
08:18
to the increase of small arms,
or the other way around.
or the other way around.
151
486200
3909
08:22
But here's what we should
really take away from this.
really take away from this.
152
490133
2496
08:24
What we should take away from this
153
492653
1660
08:26
is that this is a relationship
worth scrutinizing,
worth scrutinizing,
154
494337
4418
08:31
especially when you consider
that small arms that were shipped to Iraq
that small arms that were shipped to Iraq
155
499447
4866
08:36
for use by the Iraqi Army,
156
504337
1794
08:38
or to Syria for so-called
moderate opposition fighters,
moderate opposition fighters,
157
506155
3247
08:41
that those arms, many of them,
are now in the hands of ISIS;
are now in the hands of ISIS;
158
509426
4193
08:46
or when you consider that arms
that were shipped to Libya
that were shipped to Libya
159
514096
2740
08:48
are now actively drifting
across the Sahel,
across the Sahel,
160
516860
2713
08:51
and ending up with groups
like Boko Haram and al Qaeda
like Boko Haram and al Qaeda
161
519597
4743
08:56
and other militant groups.
162
524364
2705
08:59
And therein lies the problem.
163
527950
1834
09:02
Because, you see,
164
530466
1152
09:03
small arms anywhere
are a menace everywhere,
are a menace everywhere,
165
531642
5519
09:09
because their first stop
is rarely their last.
is rarely their last.
166
537831
4343
09:14
Spending on war per person per year
167
542904
2416
09:17
now amounts to about 249 dollars --
168
545344
4045
09:21
249 dollars per person,
169
549413
2401
09:23
which is roughly 12 times
what we spend on foreign aid,
what we spend on foreign aid,
170
551838
4939
09:28
money that is used to educate
and vaccinate children
and vaccinate children
171
556801
3437
09:32
and combat malnutrition
in the Global South.
in the Global South.
172
560262
2863
09:35
But we can shift that balance.
173
563814
3297
09:39
How do we do this?
174
567604
1151
09:40
Well, it is essentially a problem
of both supply and demand,
of both supply and demand,
175
568779
2842
09:43
so we can tackle it from both sides.
176
571645
1943
09:45
On the supply side,
177
573993
1670
09:47
we can push our governments
178
575687
3174
09:50
to adopt international arms
transparency mechanisms
transparency mechanisms
179
578885
3063
09:53
like the Arms Trade Treaty,
180
581972
1801
09:55
which makes it so that rich countries
have to be more accountable
have to be more accountable
181
583797
3767
09:59
for where their arms are going
182
587588
1675
10:01
and what their arms might be used for.
183
589287
2399
10:03
Here in the United States,
184
591710
1265
10:04
the largest arms-exporting country
in the world by far,
in the world by far,
185
592999
4617
10:09
President Obama has rightly signed
the Arms Trade Treaty,
the Arms Trade Treaty,
186
597640
3925
10:13
but none of it takes effect,
it isn't binding,
it isn't binding,
187
601589
2561
10:16
until it is approved
and ratified by the Senate.
and ratified by the Senate.
188
604174
3509
10:20
This is where we need
to make our voices heard.
to make our voices heard.
189
608865
2954
10:23
You know, the curbing of small arms --
190
611843
3714
10:27
it's not going to solve
the problem of war.
the problem of war.
191
615581
2802
10:30
Increased control mechanisms
won't solve that problem.
won't solve that problem.
192
618407
3282
10:33
But it's an important step
in the right direction.
in the right direction.
193
621713
3247
10:36
And it's up to all of us
who live in those rich countries
who live in those rich countries
194
624984
2873
10:39
to make change here.
195
627881
1810
10:41
What about on the demand side?
196
629994
3209
10:45
You know, there are generations
around the world
around the world
197
633227
2753
10:48
who are being lost to war.
198
636004
2056
10:51
It is possible to disrupt
that cycle of violence
that cycle of violence
199
639202
2991
10:54
with investments in education,
in strengthening the rule of law
in strengthening the rule of law
200
642217
3993
10:58
and in economic development,
especially for women.
especially for women.
201
646234
2381
11:00
I have personally seen
202
648639
1628
11:02
just how incredibly powerful
those kinds of efforts can be
those kinds of efforts can be
203
650291
3041
11:05
around the world.
204
653356
1334
11:07
But here's the thing:
205
655458
1376
11:08
they take time,
206
656858
1408
11:10
which means for you as individuals,
if you want to give,
if you want to give,
207
658290
4039
11:14
please, by all means do it.
208
662353
1707
11:16
But know that how you give
is just as important
is just as important
209
664084
3563
11:19
as how much you give.
210
667671
2007
11:22
Regular contributions
like monthly contributions
like monthly contributions
211
670147
2445
11:24
are a far more effective way of giving,
212
672616
3288
11:27
because they allow
humanitarian organizations
humanitarian organizations
213
675928
2713
11:30
to properly plan and be invested
over the long term,
over the long term,
214
678665
4325
11:35
and to be present in the lives of families
who have been affected by war,
who have been affected by war,
215
683014
5625
11:40
wars that many of us, frankly,
all too quickly forget.
all too quickly forget.
216
688663
4236
11:45
When I first got on that plane
for Somalia as a young doctor,
for Somalia as a young doctor,
217
693939
5360
11:52
I had no idea what it meant
to live with war.
to live with war.
218
700942
3297
11:57
But I can tell you that I know
what it means now.
what it means now.
219
705519
2402
12:00
And I know what it means
220
708636
2345
12:03
to lie in bed in the pitch-black night
221
711529
4175
12:08
and listen to that haunting
"pop-pop-pop-pop-pop!"
"pop-pop-pop-pop-pop!"
222
716684
3643
12:13
of automatic gunfire,
223
721295
1619
12:16
and wonder with absolute dread
224
724002
2423
12:19
how many minutes I have left
until it will be right on top of me.
until it will be right on top of me.
225
727298
3587
12:23
I can tell you that it is a terrifying
and agonizing fear,
and agonizing fear,
226
731556
5037
12:28
one that millions of people
around the world are forced to confront
around the world are forced to confront
227
736617
4357
12:32
each and every single day,
228
740998
2166
12:35
especially children.
229
743188
1333
12:37
Over the years of doing this work,
230
745417
2740
12:40
unfortunately, war has killed
far too many people close to me.
far too many people close to me.
231
748181
5112
12:46
And on at least a couple of occasions,
232
754277
2976
12:49
war has very nearly killed me as well.
233
757277
2770
12:53
But I firmly believe,
234
761309
4874
12:58
which is why I get up and do
what I do every single day,
what I do every single day,
235
766207
2777
13:01
that we can make different choices here.
236
769786
2728
13:05
Because you see, war is ours,
237
773284
2819
13:08
as human beings.
238
776127
1579
13:09
We buy it, sell it, spread it and wage it.
239
777730
3612
13:13
We are therefore
not powerless to solve it.
not powerless to solve it.
240
781960
3699
13:18
On the contrary,
241
786569
1671
13:20
we are the only ones who can.
242
788264
2951
13:23
Thank you very much, and I want
to wish you the greatest success.
to wish you the greatest success.
243
791731
3110
13:26
(Applause)
244
794865
6874
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Samantha Nutt - Doctor, writer and humanitarianSamantha Nutt envisions a world where no child knows war.
Why you should listen
Samantha Nutt is a leading authority on the civilian impact of war and a bestselling author. A medical doctor and the founder of the international humanitarian organizations War Child USA and War Child Canada, Dr. Nutt has worked with children and their families at the frontline of many of the world's major crises -- from Iraq to Afghanistan, Somalia to the Democratic Republic of Congo, and Sierra Leone to Darfur, Sudan. With a career that has spanned more than two decades and dozens of conflict zones, her international work has benefited millions of war-affected children globally.
Dr. Nutt writes and speaks about war, international aid and foreign policy. Her work has been published by a variety of print and online media, including the Globe and Mail, Huffington Post, Reuters, Maclean's Magazine and many others. She regularly appears on news shows discussing foreign affairs and is a panelist on CBC's flagship news program, The National. Dr. Nutt's critically-acclaimed book, Damned Nations: Greed, Guns, Armies and Aid, was a bestseller.
Dr. Nutt is a recipient of the Order of Canada, Canada's highest civilian honour, and has been recognized as a Young Global Leader by the World Economic Forum. She is a staff physician at Women's College Hospital in Toronto and an assistant professor of Medicine at the University of Toronto. She holds a degree in medicine from McMaster University and post graduate degrees from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (University of London) and the University of Toronto. Dr. Nutt is also a member of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, as well as the Canadian College of Family Practice.
Samantha Nutt | Speaker | TED.com