TED2004
Joseph Pine: What consumers want
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
1,171,407 views
Customers want to feel what they buy is authentic, but "Mass Customization" author Joseph Pine says selling authenticity is tough because, well, there's no such thing. He talks about a few experiences that may be artificial but make millions anyway.
Joseph Pine - Writer
A writer and veteran consultant to entrepreneurs and executives alike, Joseph Pine's books and workshops help businesses create what modern consumers really want: authentic experiences. Full bio
A writer and veteran consultant to entrepreneurs and executives alike, Joseph Pine's books and workshops help businesses create what modern consumers really want: authentic experiences. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I'm going to talk about a very fundamental change that is going on
0
0
3000
00:15
in the very fabric of the modern economy.
1
3000
3000
00:18
And to talk about that, I'm going to go back to the beginning,
2
6000
3000
00:21
because in the beginning were commodities.
3
9000
3000
00:25
Commodities are things that you grow in the ground, raise on the ground or pull out of the ground:
4
13000
3000
00:28
basically, animal, mineral, vegetable.
5
16000
2000
00:30
And then you extract them out of the ground,
6
18000
2000
00:32
and sell them on the open marketplace.
7
20000
2000
00:34
Commodities were the basis of the agrarian economy
8
22000
2000
00:36
that lasted for millennia.
9
24000
3000
00:39
But then along came the industrial revolution,
10
27000
2000
00:42
and then goods became the predominant economic offering,
11
30000
3000
00:45
where we used commodities as a raw material
12
33000
3000
00:48
to be able to make or manufacture goods.
13
36000
3000
00:51
So, we moved from an agrarian economy to an industrial economy.
14
39000
3000
00:54
Well, what then happened over the last 50 or 60 years,
15
42000
3000
00:57
is that goods have become commoditized.
16
45000
2000
00:59
Commoditized: where they're treated like a commodity,
17
47000
2000
01:02
where people don't care who makes them.
18
50000
2000
01:04
They just care about three things and three things only:
19
52000
2000
01:06
price, price and price.
20
54000
3000
01:09
Now, there's an antidote to commoditization,
21
57000
3000
01:12
and that is customization.
22
60000
2000
01:14
My first book was called "Mass Customization" --
23
62000
2000
01:16
it came up a couple of times yesterday --
24
64000
2000
01:18
and how I discovered this progression of economic value
25
66000
2000
01:20
was realizing that customizing a good
26
68000
2000
01:22
automatically turned it into a service,
27
70000
2000
01:24
because it was done just for a particular person,
28
72000
2000
01:26
because it wasn't inventoried,
29
74000
2000
01:28
it was delivered on demand to that individual person.
30
76000
3000
01:31
So, we moved from an industrial economy to a service-based economy.
31
79000
3000
01:35
But over the past 10 or 20 years, what's happened is that
32
83000
2000
01:37
services are being commoditized as well.
33
85000
3000
01:40
Long-distance telephone service sold on price, price, price;
34
88000
2000
01:42
fast-food restaurants with all their value pricing;
35
90000
3000
01:45
and even the Internet is commoditizing not just goods,
36
93000
2000
01:47
but services as well.
37
95000
4000
01:52
What that means is that it's time
38
100000
2000
01:54
to move to a new level of economic value.
39
102000
3000
01:57
Time to go beyond the goods and the services,
40
105000
2000
01:59
and use, in that same heuristic, what happens when you customize a service?
41
107000
3000
02:02
What happens when you design a service that is so appropriate for a particular person --
42
110000
4000
02:06
that's exactly what they need at this moment in time?
43
114000
2000
02:08
Then you can't help but make them go "wow";
44
116000
2000
02:10
you can't help but turn it into a memorable event --
45
118000
2000
02:12
you can't help but turn it into an experience.
46
120000
4000
02:16
So we're shifting to an experience economy,
47
124000
2000
02:18
where experiences are becoming the predominant economic offering.
48
126000
4000
02:22
Now most places that I talk to,
49
130000
2000
02:24
when I talk about experience, I talk about Disney --
50
132000
2000
02:26
the world's premier experience-stager.
51
134000
2000
02:28
I talk about theme restaurants, and experiential retail,
52
136000
2000
02:30
and boutique hotels, and Las Vegas --
53
138000
3000
02:33
the experience capital of the world.
54
141000
3000
02:36
But here, when you think about experiences,
55
144000
2000
02:38
think about Thomas Dolby and his group, playing music.
56
146000
3000
02:41
Think about meaningful places.
57
149000
2000
02:43
Think about drinking wine,
58
151000
3000
02:46
about a journey to the Clock of the Long Now.
59
154000
3000
02:49
Those are all experiences. Think about TED itself.
60
157000
4000
02:53
The experience capital in the world of conferences.
61
161000
4000
02:57
All of these are experiences.
62
165000
2000
02:59
Now, over the last several years I spent a lot of time in Europe,
63
167000
2000
03:01
and particularly in the Netherlands,
64
169000
2000
03:03
and whenever I talk about the experience economy there,
65
171000
2000
03:05
I'm always greeted at the end with one particular question,
66
173000
3000
03:08
almost invariably.
67
176000
2000
03:10
And the question isn't really so much a question
68
178000
3000
03:13
as an accusation.
69
181000
2000
03:15
And the Dutch, when they usually put it,
70
183000
2000
03:17
it always starts with the same two words.
71
185000
2000
03:19
You know the words I mean?
72
187000
2000
03:21
You Americans.
73
189000
3000
03:24
They say, you Americans.
74
192000
2000
03:26
You like your fantasy environments,
75
194000
2000
03:28
your fake, your Disneyland experiences.
76
196000
3000
03:31
They say, we Dutch, we like real,
77
199000
2000
03:33
natural, authentic experiences.
78
201000
4000
03:37
So much has that happened that I've developed a fairly praticed response,
79
205000
4000
03:41
which is: I point out that first of all,
80
209000
2000
03:43
you have to understand that there is no such thing
81
211000
2000
03:45
as an inauthentic experience.
82
213000
3000
03:48
Why? Because the experience happens inside of us.
83
216000
3000
03:51
It's our reaction to the events that are staged in front of us.
84
219000
2000
03:54
So, as long as we are in any sense authentic human beings,
85
222000
2000
03:56
then every experience we have is authentic.
86
224000
3000
03:59
Now, there may be more or less natural or artificial
87
227000
2000
04:01
stimuli for the experience,
88
229000
2000
04:03
but even that is a matter of degree, not kind.
89
231000
4000
04:07
And there's no such thing as a 100 percent natural experience.
90
235000
2000
04:09
Even if you go for a walk in the proverbial woods,
91
237000
3000
04:12
there is a company that manufactured the car
92
240000
2000
04:14
that delivered you to the edge of the woods;
93
242000
2000
04:16
there's a company that manufactured the shoes that you have
94
244000
2000
04:18
to protect yourself from the ground of the woods.
95
246000
2000
04:20
There's a company that provides a cell phone service you have
96
248000
2000
04:22
in case you get lost in the woods.
97
250000
2000
04:25
Right? All of those are man-made,
98
253000
2000
04:27
artificiality brought into the woods by you,
99
255000
3000
04:30
and by the very nature of being there.
100
258000
3000
04:34
And then I always finish off
101
262000
3000
04:37
by talking about -- the thing that amazes me the most about this question,
102
265000
3000
04:40
particularly coming from the Dutch,
103
268000
2000
04:42
is that the Netherlands
104
270000
2000
04:44
is every bit as manufactured as Disneyland.
105
272000
3000
04:47
(Laughter)
106
275000
2000
04:49
And the Dutch, they always go ...
107
277000
2000
04:51
and they realize, I'm right!
108
279000
2000
04:53
There isn't a square meter of ground in the entire country
109
281000
2000
04:55
that hasn't been reclaimed from the sea,
110
283000
2000
04:57
or otherwise moved, modified and manicured
111
285000
3000
05:00
to look as if it had always been there.
112
288000
2000
05:02
It's the only place you ever go for a walk in the woods and all the trees are lined up in rows.
113
290000
3000
05:05
(Laughter)
114
293000
4000
05:09
But nonetheless, not just the Dutch,
115
297000
2000
05:11
but everyone has this desire for the authentic.
116
299000
2000
05:13
And authenticity is therefore
117
301000
2000
05:15
becoming the new consumer sensibility --
118
303000
3000
05:18
the buying criteria by which consumers
119
306000
2000
05:20
are choosing who are they going to buy from,
120
308000
2000
05:22
and what they're going to buy.
121
310000
2000
05:24
Becoming the basis of the economy.
122
312000
2000
05:26
In fact, you can look at how each of these economies developed,
123
314000
3000
05:29
that each one has their own business imperative,
124
317000
3000
05:32
matched with a consumer sensibility.
125
320000
2000
05:34
We're the agrarian economy, and we're supplying commodities.
126
322000
2000
05:36
It's about supply and availability.
127
324000
2000
05:38
Getting the commodities to market.
128
326000
3000
05:41
With the industrial economy, it is about controlling costs --
129
329000
3000
05:44
getting the costs down as low as possible
130
332000
2000
05:46
so we can offer them to the masses.
131
334000
2000
05:48
With the service economy, it is about
132
336000
3000
05:51
improving quality.
133
339000
2000
05:53
That has -- the whole quality movement has risen
134
341000
2000
05:55
with the service economy over the past 20 or 30 years.
135
343000
3000
05:58
And now, with the experience economy,
136
346000
2000
06:00
it's about rendering authenticity.
137
348000
3000
06:03
Rendering authenticity -- and the keyword is "rendering."
138
351000
3000
06:07
Right? Rendering, because you have to get your consumers --
139
355000
2000
06:09
as business people --
140
357000
2000
06:11
to percieve your offerings as authentic.
141
359000
3000
06:14
Because there is a basic paradox:
142
362000
2000
06:16
no one can have an inauthentic experience,
143
364000
2000
06:19
but no business can supply one.
144
367000
1000
06:22
Because all businesses are man-made objects; all business is involved with money;
145
370000
4000
06:26
all business is a matter of using machinery,
146
374000
3000
06:29
and all those things make something inauthentic.
147
377000
4000
06:34
So, how do you render authenticity,
148
382000
3000
06:37
is the question.
149
385000
2000
06:39
Are you rendering authenticity?
150
387000
2000
06:42
When you think about that, let me go back to
151
390000
2000
06:44
what Lionel Trilling, in his seminal book on authenticity,
152
392000
3000
06:47
"Sincerity and Authenticity" -- came out in 1960 --
153
395000
3000
06:50
points to as the seminal point
154
398000
2000
06:52
at which authenticity entered the lexicon,
155
400000
2000
06:54
if you will.
156
402000
2000
06:56
And that is, to no surprise, in Shakespeare,
157
404000
3000
06:59
and in his play, Hamlet.
158
407000
2000
07:01
And there is one part in this play, Hamlet,
159
409000
2000
07:03
where the most fake of all the characters in Hamlet, Polonius,
160
411000
3000
07:06
says something profoundly real.
161
414000
2000
07:08
At the end of a laundry list of advice
162
416000
2000
07:10
he's giving to his son, Laertes,
163
418000
2000
07:12
he says this:
164
420000
2000
07:15
And this above all: to thine own self be true.
165
423000
4000
07:19
And it doth follow, as night the day,
166
427000
2000
07:21
that thou canst not then be false to any man.
167
429000
3000
07:25
And those three verses are the core of authenticity.
168
433000
4000
07:29
There are two dimensions to authenticity:
169
437000
3000
07:32
one, being true to yourself, which is very self-directed.
170
440000
3000
07:36
Two, is other-directed:
171
444000
2000
07:38
being what you say you are to others.
172
446000
3000
07:41
And I don't know about you, but whenever I encounter two dimensions,
173
449000
2000
07:43
I immediately go, ahh, two-by-two!
174
451000
2000
07:45
All right? Anybody else like that, no?
175
453000
2000
07:47
Well, if you think about that, you do, in fact, get
176
455000
2000
07:50
a two-by-two.
177
458000
2000
07:52
Where, on one dimension it's a matter of being true to yourself.
178
460000
4000
07:56
As businesses, are the economic offerings you are providing --
179
464000
2000
07:58
are they true to themselves?
180
466000
3000
08:01
And the other dimension is:
181
469000
2000
08:03
are they what they say they are to others?
182
471000
3000
08:07
If not, you have,
183
475000
2000
08:09
"is not true to itself," and "is not what it says it is,"
184
477000
4000
08:13
yielding a two-by-two matrix.
185
481000
2000
08:15
And of course, if you are both true to yourself,
186
483000
2000
08:17
and are what you say you are, then you're real real!
187
485000
2000
08:19
(Laughter)
188
487000
3000
08:22
The opposite, of course, is -- fake fake.
189
490000
3000
08:26
All right, now, there is value for fake.
190
494000
2000
08:28
There will always be companies around to supply the fake,
191
496000
2000
08:30
because there will always be desire for the fake.
192
498000
2000
08:32
Fact is, there's a general rule: if you don't like it, it's fake;
193
500000
2000
08:34
if you do like it, it's faux.
194
502000
3000
08:37
(Laughter)
195
505000
3000
08:43
Now, the other two sides of the coin are:
196
511000
3000
08:46
being a real fake --
197
514000
2000
08:48
is what it says it is,
198
516000
2000
08:50
but is not true to itself,
199
518000
2000
08:52
or being a fake real:
200
520000
2000
08:54
is true to itself, but not what it says it is.
201
522000
3000
08:57
You can think about those two -- you know, both of these
202
525000
2000
08:59
better than being fake fake -- not quite as good as being real real.
203
527000
3000
09:02
You can contrast them by thinking about
204
530000
2000
09:05
Universal City Walk versus
205
533000
2000
09:07
Disney World, or Disneyland.
206
535000
2000
09:09
Universal City Walk is a real fake --
207
537000
2000
09:11
in fact, we got this very term
208
539000
2000
09:13
from Ada Louise Huxtable's book, "The Unreal America."
209
541000
2000
09:16
A wonderful book, where she talks about Universal City Walk as --
210
544000
3000
09:19
you know, she decries the fake, but she says, at least that's a real fake,
211
547000
3000
09:22
right, because you can see behind the facade, right?
212
550000
3000
09:25
It is what it says it is: It's Universal Studio;
213
553000
2000
09:27
it's in the city of Los Angeles; you're going to walk a lot.
214
555000
3000
09:30
Right? You don't tend to walk a lot in Los Angeles,
215
558000
2000
09:32
well, here's a place where you are going to walk a lot,
216
560000
2000
09:34
outside in this city.
217
562000
2000
09:36
But is it really true to itself?
218
564000
3000
09:39
Right? Is it really in the city?
219
567000
2000
09:41
Is it --
220
569000
3000
09:44
you can see behind all of it,
221
572000
2000
09:46
and see what is going on in the facades of it.
222
574000
2000
09:48
So she calls it a real fake.
223
576000
2000
09:50
Disney World, on the other hand, is a fake real,
224
578000
2000
09:52
or a fake reality.
225
580000
2000
09:54
Right? It's not what it says it is. It's not really the magic kingdom.
226
582000
3000
09:58
(Laughter)
227
586000
4000
10:02
But it is -- oh, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to --
228
590000
2000
10:04
(Laughter)
229
592000
1000
10:05
-- sorry.
230
593000
2000
10:07
We won't talk about Santa Claus then.
231
595000
2000
10:09
(Laughter)
232
597000
1000
10:10
But Disney World is wonderfully true to itself.
233
598000
3000
10:13
Right? Just wonderfully true to itself.
234
601000
2000
10:15
When you are there you are just immersed
235
603000
2000
10:17
in this wonderful environment.
236
605000
3000
10:20
So, it's a fake real.
237
608000
2000
10:23
Now the easiest way
238
611000
2000
10:25
to fall down in this,
239
613000
2000
10:27
and not be real real,
240
615000
2000
10:29
right, the easiest way not to be true to yourself
241
617000
2000
10:31
is not to understand your heritage,
242
619000
2000
10:34
and thereby repudiate that heritage.
243
622000
2000
10:36
Right, the key of being true to yourself is knowing who you are as a business.
244
624000
4000
10:40
Knowing where your heritage is: what you have done in the past.
245
628000
3000
10:43
And what you have done in the past limits what you can do,
246
631000
3000
10:46
what you can get away with, essentially, in the future.
247
634000
3000
10:49
So, you have to understand that past.
248
637000
3000
10:52
Think about Disney again.
249
640000
2000
10:54
Disney,
250
642000
2000
10:56
10 or 15 years ago, right,
251
644000
2000
10:58
the Disney -- the company that is probably
252
646000
2000
11:00
best-known for family values out there,
253
648000
3000
11:03
Disney bought the ABC network.
254
651000
3000
11:06
The ABC network, affectionately known in the trade
255
654000
2000
11:08
as the T&A network, right --
256
656000
2000
11:10
that's not too much jargon, is it?
257
658000
2000
11:12
Right, the T&A network. Then it bought Miramax,
258
660000
2000
11:14
known for its NC-17 fare,
259
662000
2000
11:16
and all of a sudden, families everywhere
260
664000
2000
11:18
couldn't really trust what they were getting from Disney.
261
666000
2000
11:20
It was no longer true to its heritage;
262
668000
2000
11:22
no longer true to Walt Disney.
263
670000
2000
11:24
That's one of the reasons why they're having such trouble today,
264
672000
2000
11:26
and why Roy Disney is out to get Michael Eisner.
265
674000
3000
11:30
Because it is no longer true to itself.
266
678000
3000
11:33
So, understand what -- your past limits what you can do in the future.
267
681000
4000
11:38
When it comes to being what you say you are, the easiest mistake that companies make
268
686000
3000
11:41
is that they advertise
269
689000
2000
11:43
things that they are not.
270
691000
3000
11:47
That's when you're perceived as fake, as a phony company --
271
695000
2000
11:49
advertizing things that you're not.
272
697000
2000
11:51
Think about any hotel, any airline,
273
699000
2000
11:53
any hospital.
274
701000
2000
11:55
Right, if you could check into the ads, you'd have a great experience.
275
703000
3000
11:58
(Laughter)
276
706000
2000
12:00
But unfortunately, you have to experience the actual hotel,
277
708000
3000
12:03
airline and hospital, and then you have that disconnect.
278
711000
3000
12:06
Then you have that perception that you are phony.
279
714000
3000
12:09
So, the number one thing to do when it comes to being what you say you are,
280
717000
3000
12:13
is to provide places for people to experience
281
721000
3000
12:16
who you are.
282
724000
2000
12:18
For people to experience who you are.
283
726000
2000
12:20
Right, it's not advertising does it.
284
728000
2000
12:22
That's why you have companies like Starbucks,
285
730000
3000
12:26
right, that doesn't advertise at all.
286
734000
3000
12:29
They said, you want to know who we are, you have to come experience us.
287
737000
3000
12:33
And think about the economic value they have provided
288
741000
2000
12:35
by that experience.
289
743000
3000
12:38
Right? Coffee, at its core, is what?
290
746000
2000
12:41
Right? It's beans; right? It's coffee beans.
291
749000
3000
12:44
You know how much coffee is worth, when treated as a commodity as a bean?
292
752000
3000
12:48
Two or three cents per cup -- that's what coffee is worth.
293
756000
3000
12:51
But grind it, roast it, package it, put it on a grocery store shelf,
294
759000
3000
12:54
and now it'll cost five, 10, 15 cents,
295
762000
2000
12:56
when you treat it as a good.
296
764000
2000
12:59
Take that same good,
297
767000
2000
13:01
and perform the service of actually brewing it for a customer,
298
769000
3000
13:04
in a corner diner, in a bodega, a kiosk somewhere,
299
772000
2000
13:06
you get 50 cents, maybe a buck
300
774000
2000
13:08
per cup of coffee.
301
776000
2000
13:10
But surround the brewing of that coffee
302
778000
2000
13:12
with the ambiance of a Starbucks,
303
780000
2000
13:14
with the authentic cedar that goes inside of there,
304
782000
3000
13:17
and now, because of that authentic experience,
305
785000
2000
13:19
you can charge two, three, four, five dollars
306
787000
3000
13:22
for a cup of coffee.
307
790000
2000
13:26
So, authenticity is becoming
308
794000
2000
13:28
the new consumer sensibility.
309
796000
3000
13:31
Let me summarize it, for the business people in the audience,
310
799000
3000
13:34
with three rules, three basic rules.
311
802000
3000
13:37
One, don't say you're authentic
312
805000
2000
13:40
unless you really are authentic.
313
808000
3000
13:44
Two, it's easier to be authentic
314
812000
2000
13:46
if you don't say you're authentic.
315
814000
2000
13:50
And three, if you say you're authentic,
316
818000
2000
13:53
you better be authentic.
317
821000
3000
13:56
And then for the consumers, for everyone else in the audience,
318
824000
3000
13:59
let me simply summarize it by saying, increasingly,
319
827000
2000
14:01
what we -- what will make us happy,
320
829000
4000
14:05
is spending our time and our money
321
833000
3000
14:09
satisfying the desire for authenticity.
322
837000
3000
14:12
Thank you.
323
840000
2000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Joseph Pine - WriterA writer and veteran consultant to entrepreneurs and executives alike, Joseph Pine's books and workshops help businesses create what modern consumers really want: authentic experiences.
Why you should listen
Joseph Pine's career as a business coach began at IBM when he did something truly unorthodox: he brought business partners and customers into the development process of a new computer. Taking from this the lesson that every customer is unique, he wrote a book called Mass Customization on businesses that serve customers' unique needs. Later he discovered what he would coin the "Experience Economy" -- consumers buying experiences rather than goods or commodities -- and wrote a book of the same name.
Pine and his friend Jim Gilmore have since turned their focus to authenticity, which they argue is the main criterion people use when deciding what to buy. (The idea was featured in TIME's "10 Ideas That Are Changing the World," and also became a book.) They joke that their company, Strategic Horizons, ought to be called "Frameworks 'R' Us," after their specialty in helping others see business differently.
Joseph Pine | Speaker | TED.com