TEDGlobal 2012
Beth Noveck: Demand a more open-source government
Filmed:
Readability: 4.9
571,499 views
What can governments learn from the open-data revolution? In this stirring talk, Beth Noveck, the former deputy CTO at the White House, shares a vision of practical openness -- connecting bureaucracies to citizens, sharing data, creating a truly participatory democracy. Imagine the "writable society" ...
Beth Noveck - Open-government expert
A lawyer by training and a techie by inclination, Beth Noveck works to build data transparency into government. Full bio
A lawyer by training and a techie by inclination, Beth Noveck works to build data transparency into government. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
So when the White House was built
0
795
1820
00:18
in the early 19th century, it was an open house.
1
2615
2993
00:21
Neighbors came and went. Under President Adams,
2
5608
3136
00:24
a local dentist happened by.
3
8744
1369
00:26
He wanted to shake the President's hand.
4
10113
2591
00:28
The President dismissed the Secretary of State,
5
12704
2150
00:30
whom he was conferring with, and asked the dentist
6
14854
1918
00:32
if he would remove a tooth.
7
16772
1810
00:34
Later, in the 1850s, under President Pierce,
8
18582
3058
00:37
he was known to have remarked
9
21640
1588
00:39
— probably the only thing he's known for —
10
23228
2569
00:41
when a neighbor passed by and said, "I'd love to see
11
25797
2751
00:44
the beautiful house," and Pierce said to him,
12
28548
2265
00:46
"Why my dear sir, of course you may come in.
13
30813
2615
00:49
This isn't my house. It is the people's house."
14
33428
3725
00:53
Well, when I got to the White House in the beginning
15
37153
2072
00:55
of 2009, at the start of the Obama Administration,
16
39225
3220
00:58
the White House was anything but open.
17
42445
2872
01:01
Bomb blast curtains covered my windows.
18
45317
2528
01:03
We were running Windows 2000.
19
47845
2179
01:05
Social media were blocked at the firewall.
20
50024
2183
01:08
We didn't have a blog, let alone a dozen twitter accounts
21
52207
2540
01:10
like we have today.
22
54747
2023
01:12
I came in to become the head of Open Government,
23
56770
2613
01:15
to take the values and the practices of transparency,
24
59383
2798
01:18
participation and collaboration, and instill them
25
62181
3413
01:21
into the way that we work, to open up government,
26
65594
2826
01:24
to work with people.
27
68420
1520
01:25
Now one of the things that we know
28
69940
2694
01:28
is that companies are very good at getting people to work
29
72634
3016
01:31
together in teams and in networks to make
30
75650
2248
01:33
very complex products, like cars and computers,
31
77898
3642
01:37
and the more complex the products are a society creates,
32
81540
3688
01:41
the more successful the society is over time.
33
85228
2855
01:43
Companies make goods, but governments,
34
88083
2745
01:46
they make public goods. They work on the cure for cancer
35
90828
3120
01:49
and educating our children and making roads,
36
93948
2808
01:52
but we don't have institutions that are particularly good
37
96756
3641
01:56
at this kind of complexity. We don't have institutions
38
100397
2536
01:58
that are good at bringing our talents to bear,
39
102933
3117
02:01
at working with us in this kind of open and collaborative way.
40
106050
4462
02:06
So when we wanted to create our Open Government policy,
41
110512
2261
02:08
what did we do? We wanted, naturally, to ask public sector
42
112773
2576
02:11
employees how we should open up government.
43
115349
2944
02:14
Turns out that had never been done before.
44
118293
3232
02:17
We wanted to ask members of the public to help us
45
121525
2619
02:20
come up with a policy, not after the fact, commenting
46
124144
3278
02:23
on a rule after it's written, the way is typically the case,
47
127422
3383
02:26
but in advance. There was no legal precedent,
48
130805
3320
02:30
no cultural precedent, no technical way of doing this.
49
134125
3142
02:33
In fact, many people told us it was illegal.
50
137267
2841
02:36
Here's the crux of the obstacle.
51
140108
3113
02:39
Governments exist to channel the flow of two things,
52
143221
2601
02:41
really, values and expertise to and from government
53
145822
3494
02:45
and to and from citizens to the end of making decisions.
54
149316
3849
02:49
But the way that our institutions are designed,
55
153165
2393
02:51
in our rather 18th-century, centralized model,
56
155558
3051
02:54
is to channel the flow of values through voting,
57
158609
3684
02:58
once every four years, once every two years, at best,
58
162293
2200
03:00
once a year. This is a rather anemic and thin way, in this
59
164493
3561
03:03
era of social media, for us to actually express our values.
60
168054
4005
03:07
Today we have technology that lets us express ourselves
61
172059
2612
03:10
a great deal, perhaps a little too much.
62
174671
3004
03:13
Then in the 19th century, we layer on
63
177675
2274
03:15
the concept of bureaucracy and the administrative state
64
179949
2407
03:18
to help us govern complex and large societies.
65
182356
3143
03:21
But we've centralized these bureaucracies.
66
185499
3232
03:24
We've entrenched them. And we know that
67
188731
2445
03:27
the smartest person always works for someone else.
68
191176
2712
03:29
We need to only look around this room to know that
69
193888
2680
03:32
expertise and intelligence is widely distributed in society,
70
196568
3597
03:36
and not limited simply to our institutions.
71
200165
4171
03:40
Scientists have been studying in recent years
72
204336
2266
03:42
the phenomenon that they often describe as flow,
73
206602
2534
03:45
that the design of our systems, whether natural or social,
74
209136
3264
03:48
channel the flow of whatever runs through them.
75
212400
2683
03:50
So a river is designed to channel the flow of water,
76
215083
3277
03:54
and the lightning bolt that comes out of a cloud channels
77
218360
2470
03:56
the flow of electricity, and a leaf is designed to channel
78
220830
3504
04:00
the flow of nutrients to the tree,
79
224334
2020
04:02
sometimes even having to route around an obstacle,
80
226354
3004
04:05
but to get that nutrition flowing.
81
229358
2720
04:07
The same can be said for our social systems, for our
82
232078
2337
04:10
systems of government, where, at the very least,
83
234415
2488
04:12
flow offers us a helpful metaphor for understanding
84
236903
3015
04:15
what the problem is, what's really broken,
85
239918
2656
04:18
and the urgent need that we have, that we all feel today,
86
242574
3685
04:22
to redesign the flow of our institutions.
87
246259
3280
04:25
We live in a Cambrian era of big data, of social networks,
88
249539
4523
04:29
and we have this opportunity to redesign these institutions
89
254062
4269
04:34
that are actually quite recent.
90
258331
2885
04:37
Think about it: What other business do you know,
91
261216
3240
04:40
what other sector of the economy, and especially one
92
264456
2400
04:42
as big as the public sector, that doesn't seek to reinvent
93
266856
3787
04:46
its business model on a regular basis?
94
270643
2904
04:49
Sure, we invest plenty in innovation. We invest
95
273547
3091
04:52
in broadband and science education and science grants,
96
276638
3964
04:56
but we invest far too little in reinventing and redesigning
97
280602
3351
04:59
the institutions that we have.
98
283953
2600
05:02
Now, it's very easy to complain, of course, about
99
286553
2336
05:04
partisan politics and entrenched bureaucracy, and we love
100
288889
3464
05:08
to complain about government. It's a perennial pastime,
101
292353
2916
05:11
especially around election time, but
102
295269
2652
05:13
the world is complex. We soon will have 10 billion people,
103
297921
3386
05:17
many of whom will lack basic resources.
104
301307
2873
05:20
So complain as we might, what actually can replace
105
304180
3318
05:23
what we have today?
106
307498
2311
05:25
What comes the day after the Arab Spring?
107
309809
4107
05:29
Well, one attractive alternative that obviously presents itself
108
313916
3886
05:33
to us is that of networks. Right? Networks
109
317802
2760
05:36
like Facebook and Twitter. They're lean. They're mean.
110
320562
2712
05:39
You've got 3,000 employees at Facebook
111
323274
2504
05:41
governing 900 million inhabitants.
112
325778
2946
05:44
We might even call them citizens, because they've recently
113
328724
2743
05:47
risen up to fight against legislative incursion,
114
331467
3375
05:50
and the citizens of these networks work together
115
334842
2535
05:53
to serve each other in great ways.
116
337377
3241
05:56
But private communities, private, corporate,
117
340618
2792
05:59
privatizing communities, are not bottom-up democracies.
118
343410
3140
06:02
They cannot replace government.
119
346550
2010
06:04
Friending someone on Facebook is not complex enough
120
348560
3102
06:07
to do the hard work of you and I collaborating
121
351662
2653
06:10
with each other and doing the hard work of governance.
122
354315
3892
06:14
But social media do teach us something.
123
358207
2938
06:17
Why is Twitter so successful? Because it opens up its platform.
124
361145
4474
06:21
It opens up the API to allow hundreds of thousands
125
365619
2937
06:24
of new applications to be built on top of it, so that we can
126
368556
3471
06:27
read and process information in new and exciting ways.
127
372027
4334
06:32
We need to think about how to open up the API
128
376361
2337
06:34
of government, and the way that we're going to do that,
129
378698
4061
06:38
the next great superpower is going to be the one
130
382759
3248
06:41
who can successfully combine the hierarchy of institution --
131
386007
5983
06:47
because we have to maintain those public values,
132
391990
2353
06:50
we have to coordinate the flow -- but with the diversity
133
394343
2919
06:53
and the pulsating life and the chaos and the excitement
134
397262
2665
06:55
of networks, all of us working together to build
135
399927
3096
06:58
these new innovations on top of our institutions,
136
403023
3701
07:02
to engage in the practice of governance.
137
406724
2218
07:04
We have a precedent for this. Good old Henry II here,
138
408942
3133
07:07
in the 12th century, invented the jury.
139
412075
3852
07:11
Powerful, practical, palpable model for handing power
140
415927
4225
07:16
from government to citizens.
141
420152
2701
07:18
Today we have the opportunity, and we have
142
422853
3388
07:22
the imperative, to create thousands of new ways
143
426241
3501
07:25
of interconnecting between networks and institutions,
144
429742
3239
07:28
thousands of new kinds of juries: the citizen jury,
145
432981
2664
07:31
the Carrotmob, the hackathon, we are just beginning
146
435645
3677
07:35
to invent the models by which we can cocreate
147
439322
3054
07:38
the process of governance.
148
442376
1748
07:40
Now, we don't fully have a picture of what this will look like
149
444124
2615
07:42
yet, but we're seeing pockets of evolution
150
446739
2622
07:45
emerging all around us -- maybe not even evolution,
151
449361
2982
07:48
I'd even start to call it a revolution -- in the way that we govern.
152
452343
3809
07:52
Some of it's very high-tech,
153
456152
1484
07:53
and some of it is extremely low-tech,
154
457636
2054
07:55
such as the project that MKSS is running in Rajasthan,
155
459690
3370
07:58
India, where they take the spending data of the state
156
463060
3544
08:02
and paint it on 100,000 village walls,
157
466604
3443
08:05
and then invite the villagers to come and comment
158
470047
2295
08:08
who is on the government payroll, who's actually died,
159
472342
2488
08:10
what are the bridges that have been built to nowhere,
160
474830
2624
08:13
and to work together through civic engagement to save
161
477454
2344
08:15
real money and participate and have access to that budget.
162
479798
3763
08:19
But it's not just about policing government.
163
483561
2398
08:21
It's also about creating government.
164
485959
1727
08:23
Spacehive in the U.K. is engaging in crowd-funding,
165
487686
3118
08:26
getting you and me to raise the money to build
166
490804
2685
08:29
the goalposts and the park benches that will actually
167
493489
2658
08:32
allow us to deliver better services in our communities.
168
496147
3562
08:35
No one is better at this activity of actually getting us
169
499709
3638
08:39
to engage in delivering services,
170
503347
3240
08:42
sometimes where none exist, than Ushahidi.
171
506587
3151
08:45
Created after the post-election riots in Kenya in 2008,
172
509738
4353
08:49
this crisis-mapping website and community is actually able
173
514091
3936
08:53
to crowdsource and target the delivery of
174
518027
2645
08:56
better rescue services to people trapped under the rubble,
175
520672
3091
08:59
whether it's after the earthquakes in Haiti,
176
523763
2456
09:02
or more recently in Italy.
177
526219
2525
09:04
And the Red Cross too is training volunteers and Twitter
178
528744
3131
09:07
is certifying them, not simply to supplement existing
179
531875
2868
09:10
government institutions, but in many cases, to replace them.
180
534743
4036
09:14
Now what we're seeing lots of examples of, obviously,
181
538779
3008
09:17
is the opening up of government data,
182
541787
1687
09:19
not enough examples of this yet, but we're starting
183
543474
3000
09:22
to see this practice of people creating and generating
184
546474
3529
09:25
innovative applications on top of government data.
185
550003
3469
09:29
There's so many examples I could have picked, and I
186
553472
2331
09:31
selected this one of Jon Bon Jovi. Some of you
187
555803
3166
09:34
may or may not know that he runs a soup kitchen
188
558969
2266
09:37
in New Jersey, where he caters to and serves the homeless
189
561235
2761
09:39
and particularly homeless veterans.
190
563996
1693
09:41
In February, he approached the White House, and said,
191
565689
2778
09:44
"I would like to fund a prize to create scalable national
192
568467
3845
09:48
applications, apps, that will help not only the homeless
193
572312
3527
09:51
but those who deliver services [to] them to do so better."
194
575839
3435
09:55
February 2012 to June of 2012,
195
579274
3240
09:58
the finalists are announced in the competition.
196
582514
2988
10:01
Can you imagine, in the bureaucratic world of yesteryear,
197
585502
2989
10:04
getting anything done in a four-month period of time?
198
588491
2746
10:07
You can barely fill out the forms in that amount of time,
199
591237
2136
10:09
let alone generate real, palpable innovations
200
593373
2864
10:12
that improve people's lives.
201
596237
1891
10:14
And I want to be clear to mention that this open government
202
598128
3233
10:17
revolution is not about privatizing government,
203
601361
3777
10:21
because in many cases what it can do when we have
204
605138
2898
10:23
the will to do so is to deliver more progressive
205
608036
3096
10:27
and better policy than the regulations and the legislative
206
611132
4123
10:31
and litigation-oriented strategies
207
615255
2960
10:34
by which we make policy today.
208
618215
2600
10:36
In the State of Texas, they regulate 515 professions,
209
620815
3727
10:40
from well-driller to florist.
210
624542
2064
10:42
Now, you can carry a gun into a church in Dallas,
211
626606
3223
10:45
but do not make a flower arrangement without a license,
212
629829
3159
10:48
because that will land you in jail.
213
632988
2616
10:51
So what is Texas doing? They're asking you and me,
214
635604
4017
10:55
using online policy wikis, to help not simply get rid of
215
639621
4088
10:59
burdensome regulations that impede entrepreneurship,
216
643709
3561
11:03
but to replace those regulations with more innovative
217
647270
2999
11:06
alternatives, sometimes using transparency in the creation
218
650269
2864
11:09
of new iPhone apps that will allows us
219
653133
1982
11:11
both to protect consumers and the public
220
655115
2273
11:13
and to encourage economic development.
221
657388
3511
11:16
That is a nice sideline of open government.
222
660899
3154
11:19
It's not only the benefits that we've talked about with regard
223
664053
2711
11:22
to development. It's the economic benefits and the
224
666764
3457
11:26
job creation that's coming from this open innovation work.
225
670221
4626
11:30
Sberbank, the largest and oldest bank in Russia,
226
674847
2820
11:33
largely owned by the Russian government,
227
677667
1800
11:35
has started practicing crowdsourcing, engaging
228
679467
3000
11:38
its employees and citizens in the public in developing innovations.
229
682467
3352
11:41
Last year they saved a billion dollars, 30 billion rubles,
230
685819
4420
11:46
from open innovation, and they're pushing radically
231
690239
2757
11:48
the extension of crowdsourcing, not only from banking,
232
692996
2659
11:51
but into the public sector.
233
695655
2043
11:53
And we see lots of examples of these innovators using
234
697698
2741
11:56
open government data, not simply to make apps,
235
700439
2850
11:59
but then to make companies and to hire people
236
703289
2062
12:01
to build them working with the government.
237
705351
2301
12:03
So a lot of these innovations are local.
238
707652
2130
12:05
In San Ramon, California, they published an iPhone app
239
709782
3106
12:08
in which they allow you or me to say we are certified
240
712888
3557
12:12
CPR-trained, and then when someone has a heart attack,
241
716445
3567
12:15
a notification goes out so that you
242
720012
2240
12:18
can rush over to the person over here and deliver CPR.
243
722252
3956
12:22
The victim who receives bystander CPR
244
726208
2304
12:24
is more than twice as likely to survive.
245
728512
2465
12:26
"There is a hero in all of us," is their slogan.
246
730977
3675
12:30
But it's not limited to the local.
247
734652
2543
12:33
British Columbia, Canada, is publishing a catalogue
248
737195
2661
12:35
of all the ways that its residents and citizens can engage
249
739856
3084
12:38
with the state in the cocreation of governance.
250
742940
3718
12:42
Let me be very clear,
251
746658
3061
12:45
and perhaps controversial,
252
749719
1469
12:47
that open government is not
253
751188
2789
12:49
about transparent government.
254
753977
1973
12:51
Simply throwing data over the transom doesn't change
255
755950
2918
12:54
how government works.
256
758868
1412
12:56
It doesn't get anybody to do anything with that data
257
760280
2567
12:58
to change lives, to solve problems, and it doesn't change
258
762847
3709
13:02
government.
259
766556
1272
13:03
What it does is it creates an adversarial relationship
260
767828
3019
13:06
between civil society and government
261
770847
1728
13:08
over the control and ownership of information.
262
772575
3043
13:11
And transparency, by itself, is not reducing the flow
263
775618
2584
13:14
of money into politics, and arguably,
264
778202
2412
13:16
it's not even producing accountability as well as it might
265
780614
2733
13:19
if we took the next step of combining participation and
266
783347
3463
13:22
collaboration with transparency to transform how we work.
267
786810
4111
13:26
We're going to see this evolution really in two phases,
268
790921
2737
13:29
I think. The first phase of the open government revolution
269
793658
3289
13:32
is delivering better information from the crowd
270
796947
3776
13:36
into the center.
271
800723
1394
13:38
Starting in 2005, and this is how this open government
272
802117
2947
13:40
work in the U.S. really got started,
273
805064
1954
13:42
I was teaching a patent law class to my students and
274
807018
2256
13:45
explaining to them how a single person in the bureaucracy
275
809274
3771
13:48
has the power to make a decision
276
813045
2131
13:51
about which patent application becomes the next patent,
277
815176
4485
13:55
and therefore monopolizes for 20 years the rights
278
819661
2742
13:58
over an entire field of inventive activity.
279
822403
3007
14:01
Well, what did we do? We said, we can make a website,
280
825410
2912
14:04
we can make an expert network, a social network,
281
828322
2393
14:06
that would connect the network to the institution
282
830715
2272
14:08
to allow scientists and technologists to get
283
832987
2381
14:11
better information to the patent office
284
835368
2635
14:13
to aid in making those decisions.
285
838003
2463
14:16
We piloted the work in the U.S. and the U.K. and Japan
286
840466
2632
14:18
and Australia, and now I'm pleased to report
287
843098
2793
14:21
that the United States Patent Office will be rolling out
288
845891
2256
14:24
universal, complete, and total openness,
289
848147
4465
14:28
so that all patent applications will now be open
290
852612
3046
14:31
for citizen participation, beginning this year.
291
855658
3668
14:35
The second phase of this evolution — Yeah. (Applause)
292
859326
2936
14:38
They deserve a hand. (Applause)
293
862262
2953
14:41
The first phase is in getting better information in.
294
865215
2535
14:43
The second phase is in getting decision-making power out.
295
867750
3857
14:47
Participatory budgeting has long been practiced
296
871607
2615
14:50
in Porto Alegre, Brazil.
297
874222
1419
14:51
They're just starting it in the 49th Ward in Chicago.
298
875641
2982
14:54
Russia is using wikis to get citizens writing law together,
299
878623
3536
14:58
as is Lithuania. When we start to see
300
882159
2352
15:00
power over the core functions of government
301
884511
2304
15:02
— spending, legislation, decision-making —
302
886815
3620
15:06
then we're well on our way to an open government revolution.
303
890435
4061
15:10
There are many things that we can do to get us there.
304
894496
3831
15:14
Obviously opening up the data is one,
305
898327
2663
15:16
but the important thing is to create lots more --
306
900990
2363
15:19
create and curate -- lots more participatory opportunities.
307
903353
4230
15:23
Hackathons and mashathons and working with data
308
907583
2698
15:26
to build apps is an intelligible way for people to engage
309
910281
3709
15:29
and participate, like the jury is,
310
913990
2500
15:32
but we're going to need lots more things like it.
311
916490
3024
15:35
And that's why we need to start with our youngest people.
312
919514
4651
15:40
We've heard talk here at TED about people
313
924165
2616
15:42
biohacking and hacking their plants with Arduino,
314
926781
4069
15:46
and Mozilla is doing work around the world in getting
315
930850
3044
15:49
young people to build websites and make videos.
316
933894
3359
15:53
When we start by teaching young people that we live,
317
937253
2736
15:55
not in a passive society, a read-only society,
318
939989
3518
15:59
but in a writable society, where we have the power
319
943507
2567
16:01
to change our communities, to change our institutions,
320
946074
3624
16:05
that's when we begin to really put ourselves on the pathway
321
949698
3136
16:08
towards this open government innovation,
322
952834
3211
16:11
towards this open government movement,
323
956045
1709
16:13
towards this open government revolution.
324
957754
2523
16:16
So let me close by saying that I think the important thing
325
960277
2246
16:18
for us to do is to talk about and demand this revolution.
326
962523
5859
16:24
We don't have words, really, to describe it yet.
327
968382
3295
16:27
Words like equality and fairness and the traditional
328
971677
2225
16:29
elections, democracy, these are not really great terms yet.
329
973902
4367
16:34
They're not fun enough. They're not exciting enough
330
978269
2748
16:36
to get us engaged in this tremendous opportunity
331
981017
3319
16:40
that awaits us. But I would argue that if we want to see
332
984336
3408
16:43
the kinds of innovations, the hopeful and exciting
333
987744
2703
16:46
innovations that we hear talked about here at TED,
334
990447
2664
16:49
in clean energy, in clean education,
335
993111
2177
16:51
in development, if we want to see those adopted
336
995288
2591
16:53
and we want to see those scaled,
337
997879
2256
16:56
we want to see them become the governance of tomorrow,
338
1000135
2792
16:58
then we must all participate,
339
1002927
1705
17:00
then we must get involved.
340
1004632
1498
17:02
We must open up our institutions, and like the leaf,
341
1006130
3210
17:05
we must let the nutrients flow throughout our body politic,
342
1009340
4194
17:09
throughout our culture, to create open institutions
343
1013534
3200
17:12
to create a stronger democracy, a better tomorrow.
344
1016734
2669
17:15
Thank you. (Applause)
345
1019403
2903
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Beth Noveck - Open-government expertA lawyer by training and a techie by inclination, Beth Noveck works to build data transparency into government.
Why you should listen
How can our data strengthen our democracies? In her work, Beth Noveck explores what "opengov" really means--not just freeing data from databases, but creating meaningful ways for citizens to collaborate with their governments.
As the US's first Deputy CTO, Beth Noveck founded the White House Open Government Initiative, which developed administration policy on transparency, participation, and collaboration. Among other projects, she designed and built Peer-to-Patent, the U.S. government’s first expert network. She's now working on the design for ORGPedia, a platform for mashing up and visualizing public and crowdsourced data about corporations. Her book The Networked State will appear in 2013.
Must-read: Noveck's 2012 essay Open Data -- The Democratic Imperative.
Beth Noveck | Speaker | TED.com