TED2008
Karen Armstrong: My wish: The Charter for Compassion
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
1,787,721 views
People want to be religious, says scholar Karen Armstrong; we should help make religion a force for harmony. She asks the TED community to help build a Charter for Compassion -- to restore the Golden Rule as the central global religious doctrine.
Karen Armstrong - Religious scholar
Karen Armstrong -- winner of the 2008 TED Prize -- is a provocative, original thinker on the role of religion in the modern world. Full bio
Karen Armstrong -- winner of the 2008 TED Prize -- is a provocative, original thinker on the role of religion in the modern world. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Well, this is such an honor. And it's wonderful to be
0
0
6000
00:18
in the presence of an organization that is really making a difference in the world.
1
6000
6000
00:24
And I'm intensely grateful for the opportunity to speak to you today.
2
12000
5000
00:30
And I'm also rather surprised, because when I look back on my life
3
18000
7000
00:37
the last thing I ever wanted to do was write, or be in any way involved in religion.
4
25000
9000
00:46
After I left my convent, I'd finished with religion, frankly.
5
34000
4000
00:50
I thought that was it.
6
38000
1000
00:51
And for 13 years I kept clear of it. I wanted to be an English literature professor.
7
39000
8000
00:59
And I certainly didn't even want to be a writer, particularly.
8
47000
4000
01:03
But then I suffered a series of career catastrophes,
9
51000
5000
01:08
one after the other, and finally found myself in television. (Laughter)
10
56000
6000
01:18
I said that to Bill Moyers, and he said, "Oh, we take anybody." (Laughter)
11
66000
4000
01:22
And I was doing some rather controversial religious programs.
12
70000
5000
01:27
This went down very well in the U.K., where religion is extremely unpopular.
13
75000
7000
01:34
And so, for once, for the only time in my life, I was finally in the mainstream.
14
82000
5000
01:39
But I got sent to Jerusalem to make a film about early Christianity.
15
87000
7000
01:46
And there, for the first time, I encountered the other religious traditions:
16
94000
5000
01:51
Judaism and Islam, the sister religions of Christianity.
17
99000
5000
01:56
And while I found I knew nothing about these faiths at all --
18
104000
4000
02:00
despite my own intensely religious background,
19
108000
5000
02:05
I'd seen Judaism only as a kind of prelude to Christianity,
20
113000
3000
02:08
and I knew nothing about Islam at all.
21
116000
3000
02:11
But in that city, that tortured city,
22
119000
3000
02:14
where you see the three faiths jostling so uneasily together,
23
122000
6000
02:20
you also become aware of the profound connection between them.
24
128000
3000
02:23
And it has been the study of other religious traditions that brought me back
25
131000
5000
02:28
to a sense of what religion can be, and actually enabled me
26
136000
4000
02:32
to look at my own faith in a different light.
27
140000
3000
02:35
And I found some astonishing things in the course of my study
28
143000
4000
02:39
that had never occurred to me. Frankly, in the days when I thought I'd had it with religion,
29
147000
7000
02:46
I just found the whole thing absolutely incredible.
30
154000
3000
02:49
These doctrines seemed unproven, abstract.
31
157000
5000
02:55
And to my astonishment, when I began seriously studying other traditions,
32
163000
7000
03:02
I began to realize that belief -- which we make such a fuss about today --
33
170000
6000
03:08
is only a very recent religious enthusiasm
34
176000
5000
03:13
that surfaced only in the West, in about the 17th century.
35
181000
6000
03:19
The word "belief" itself originally meant to love, to prize, to hold dear.
36
187000
7000
03:26
In the 17th century, it narrowed its focus,
37
194000
4000
03:30
for reasons that I'm exploring in a book I'm writing at the moment,
38
198000
3000
03:33
to include -- to mean an intellectual assent to a set of propositions, a credo.
39
201000
9000
03:42
"I believe:" it did not mean, "I accept certain creedal articles of faith."
40
210000
6000
03:48
It meant: "I commit myself. I engage myself."
41
216000
4000
03:52
Indeed, some of the world traditions think very little of religious orthodoxy.
42
220000
7000
03:59
In the Quran, religious opinion -- religious orthodoxy -- is dismissed as "zanna:"
43
227000
6000
04:05
self-indulgent guesswork about matters that nobody can be certain of one way or the other,
44
233000
6000
04:11
but which makes people quarrelsome and stupidly sectarian. (Laughter)
45
239000
3000
04:14
So if religion is not about believing things, what is it about?
46
242000
7000
04:21
What I've found, across the board, is that religion is about behaving differently.
47
249000
5000
04:26
Instead of deciding whether or not you believe in God, first you do something.
48
254000
6000
04:32
You behave in a committed way,
49
260000
1000
04:33
and then you begin to understand the truths of religion.
50
261000
4000
04:37
And religious doctrines are meant to be summons to action;
51
265000
7000
04:44
you only understand them when you put them into practice.
52
272000
4000
04:48
Now, pride of place in this practice is given to compassion.
53
276000
8000
04:56
And it is an arresting fact that right across the board,
54
284000
5000
05:01
in every single one of the major world faiths, compassion --
55
289000
4000
05:05
the ability to feel with the other in the way we've been thinking about this evening --
56
293000
5000
05:10
is not only the test of any true religiosity, it is also what will bring us
57
298000
8000
05:18
into the presence of what Jews, Christians and Muslims call "God" or the "Divine."
58
306000
5000
05:23
It is compassion, says the Buddha, which brings you to Nirvana.
59
311000
6000
05:29
Why? Because in compassion, when we feel with the other,
60
317000
4000
05:33
we dethrone ourselves from the center of our world and we put
61
321000
5000
05:38
another person there. And once we get rid of ego, then we're ready to see the Divine.
62
326000
8000
05:46
And in particular, every single one of the major world traditions has highlighted -- has said --
63
334000
8000
05:54
and put at the core of their tradition what's become known as the Golden Rule.
64
342000
5000
05:59
First propounded by Confucius five centuries before Christ:
65
347000
4000
06:03
"Do not do to others what you would not like them to do to you."
66
351000
4000
06:07
That, he said, was the central thread which ran through all his teaching
67
355000
4000
06:11
and that his disciples should put into practice all day and every day.
68
359000
5000
06:16
And it was -- the Golden Rule would bring them to the transcendent value that he called "ren,"
69
364000
5000
06:21
human-heartedness, which was a transcendent experience in itself.
70
369000
6000
06:27
And this is absolutely crucial to the monotheisms, too.
71
375000
5000
06:34
There's a famous story about the great rabbi, Hillel, the older contemporary of Jesus.
72
382000
3000
06:37
A pagan came to him and offered to convert to Judaism if the rabbi could
73
385000
5000
06:42
recite the whole of Jewish teaching while he stood on one leg.
74
390000
3000
06:45
Hillel stood on one leg and said, "That which is hateful to you,
75
393000
4000
06:49
do not do to your neighbor. That is the Torah. The rest is commentary.
76
397000
5000
06:54
Go and study it." (Laughter)
77
402000
2000
06:56
And "go and study it" was what he meant.
78
404000
4000
07:00
He said, "In your exegesis, you must make it clear
79
408000
4000
07:04
that every single verse of the Torah is a commentary, a gloss upon the Golden Rule."
80
412000
7000
07:12
The great Rabbi Meir said that any interpretation of Scripture which
81
420000
7000
07:19
led to hatred and disdain, or contempt of other people --
82
427000
5000
07:24
any people whatsoever -- was illegitimate.
83
432000
3000
07:27
Saint Augustine made exactly the same point.
84
435000
3000
07:30
Scripture, he says, "teaches nothing but charity, and we must not leave
85
438000
6000
07:36
an interpretation of Scripture until we have found a compassionate interpretation of it."
86
444000
7000
07:43
And this struggle to find compassion in some of these rather rebarbative texts
87
451000
6000
07:49
is a good dress rehearsal for doing the same in ordinary life. (Applause)
88
457000
6000
07:55
But now look at our world. And we are living in a world that is --
89
463000
7000
08:02
where religion has been hijacked. Where terrorists cite Quranic verses to justify their atrocities.
90
470000
11000
08:13
Where instead of taking Jesus' words, "Love your enemies.
91
481000
7000
08:20
Don't judge others," we have the spectacle of Christians endlessly judging other people,
92
488000
7000
08:27
endlessly using Scripture as a way of arguing with other people,
93
495000
6000
08:33
putting other people down. Throughout the ages, religion has been used to oppress others,
94
501000
8000
08:41
and this is because of human ego, human greed.
95
509000
4000
08:45
We have a talent as a species for messing up wonderful things.
96
513000
5000
08:50
So the traditions also insisted -- and this is an important point, I think --
97
518000
7000
08:57
that you could not and must not confine your compassion
98
525000
3000
09:00
to your own group: your own nation, your own co-religionists,
99
528000
7000
09:07
your own fellow countrymen. You must have what one of the Chinese sages called "jian ai":
100
535000
5000
09:12
concern for everybody. Love your enemies. Honor the stranger.
101
540000
6000
09:18
We formed you, says the Quran, into tribes and nations so that you may know one another.
102
546000
6000
09:24
And this, again -- this universal outreach -- is getting subdued in the strident use of religion --
103
552000
10000
09:34
abuse of religion -- for nefarious gains.
104
562000
6000
09:40
Now, I've lost count of the number of taxi drivers who,
105
568000
4000
09:44
when I say to them what I do for a living, inform me that religion
106
572000
5000
09:49
has been the cause of all the major world wars in history. Wrong.
107
577000
4000
09:53
The causes of our present woes are political.
108
581000
5000
09:58
But, make no mistake about it, religion is a kind of fault line,
109
586000
6000
10:09
and when a conflict gets ingrained in a region, religion can get sucked in
110
597000
4000
10:13
and become part of the problem. Our modernity has been exceedingly violent.
111
601000
5000
10:18
Between 1914 and 1945, 70 million people died in Europe alone as a result of armed conflict.
112
606000
10000
10:28
And so many of our institutions, even football, which used to be a pleasant pastime,
113
616000
9000
10:37
now causes riots where people even die.
114
625000
5000
10:42
And it's not surprising that religion, too, has been affected by this violent ethos.
115
630000
7000
10:49
There's also a great deal, I think, of religious illiteracy around.
116
637000
6000
10:57
People seem to think, now equate religious faith with believing things.
117
645000
5000
11:02
As though that -- we call religious people often believers,
118
650000
5000
11:07
as though that were the main thing that they do. And very often, secondary goals
119
655000
7000
11:14
get pushed into the first place, in place of compassion and the Golden Rule.
120
662000
6000
11:20
Because the Golden Rule is difficult. I sometimes -- when I'm speaking to
121
668000
6000
11:26
congregations about compassion, I sometimes see
122
674000
4000
11:30
a mutinous expression crossing some of their faces because
123
678000
7000
11:37
a lot of religious people prefer to be right, rather than compassionate. (Laughter)
124
685000
6000
11:43
Now -- but that's not the whole story.
125
691000
4000
11:47
Since September the 11th, when my work on Islam suddenly propelled me
126
695000
6000
11:53
into public life, in a way that I'd never imagined, I've been able to sort of go all over the world,
127
701000
7000
12:00
and finding, everywhere I go, a yearning for change.
128
708000
6000
12:06
I've just come back from Pakistan, where literally thousands of people came to my lectures,
129
714000
8000
12:14
because they were yearning, first of all, to hear a friendly Western voice.
130
722000
4000
12:18
And especially the young people were coming. And were asking me --
131
726000
7000
12:25
the young people were saying, "What can we do? What can we do to change things?"
132
733000
5000
12:30
And my hosts in Pakistan said, "Look, don't be too polite to us.
133
738000
7000
12:37
Tell us where we're going wrong. Let's talk together about where religion is failing."
134
745000
6000
12:43
Because it seems to me that with -- our current situation is so serious
135
751000
7000
12:50
at the moment that any ideology that doesn't promote a sense of global understanding
136
758000
9000
12:59
and global appreciation of each other is failing the test of the time.
137
767000
6000
13:05
And religion, with its wide following ... Here in the United States,
138
773000
6000
13:11
people may be being religious in a different way, as a report has just shown --
139
779000
6000
13:17
but they still want to be religious. It's only Western Europe that has retained its secularism,
140
785000
8000
13:25
which is now beginning to look rather endearingly old-fashioned.
141
793000
3000
13:28
But people want to be religious, and religion should be made
142
796000
7000
13:35
to be a force for harmony in the world, which it can and should be --
143
803000
5000
13:40
because of the Golden Rule.
144
808000
3000
13:43
"Do not do to others what you would not have them do to you":
145
811000
4000
13:47
an ethos that should now be applied globally.
146
815000
3000
13:50
We should not treat other nations as we would not wish to be treated ourselves.
147
818000
7000
13:57
And these -- whatever our wretched beliefs -- is a religious matter, it's a spiritual matter.
148
825000
8000
14:05
It's a profound moral matter that engages and should engage us all.
149
833000
5000
14:10
And as I say, there is a hunger for change out there.
150
838000
4000
14:14
Here in the United States, I think you see it in this election campaign: a longing for change.
151
842000
6000
14:20
And people in churches all over and mosques all over this continent after September the 11th,
152
848000
10000
14:30
coming together locally to create networks of understanding.
153
858000
6000
14:36
With the mosque, with the synagogue, saying, "We must start to speak to one another."
154
864000
5000
14:41
I think it's time that we moved beyond the idea of toleration and move toward appreciation of the other.
155
869000
11000
14:52
I'd -- there's one story I'd just like to mention.
156
880000
5000
14:57
This comes from "The Iliad." But it tells you what this spirituality should be.
157
885000
6000
15:03
You know the story of "The Iliad," the 10-year war between Greece and Troy.
158
891000
5000
15:08
In one incident, Achilles, the famous warrior of Greece, takes his troops out of the war,
159
896000
5000
15:13
and the whole war effort suffers. And in the course of the ensuing muddle,
160
901000
6000
15:19
his beloved friend, Patroclus, is killed -- and killed in single combat
161
907000
6000
15:25
by one of the Trojan princes, Hector. And Achilles goes mad with grief and rage and revenge,
162
913000
5000
15:30
and he mutilates the body. He kills Hector, he mutilates his body
163
918000
9000
15:40
and then he refuses to give the body back for burial to the family,
164
928000
4000
15:44
which means that, in Greek ethos, Hector's soul will wander eternally, lost.
165
932000
7000
15:51
And then one night, Priam, king of Troy, an old man,
166
939000
4000
15:55
comes into the Greek camp incognito, makes his way to Achilles' tent
167
943000
5000
16:00
to ask for the body of his son.
168
948000
3000
16:03
And everybody is shocked when the old man takes off his head covering and shows himself.
169
951000
7000
16:10
And Achilles looks at him and thinks of his father. And he starts to weep.
170
958000
6000
16:18
And Priam looks at the man who has murdered so many of his sons,
171
966000
4000
16:22
and he, too, starts to weep. And the sound of their weeping filled the house.
172
970000
5000
16:27
The Greeks believed that weeping together created a bond between people.
173
975000
5000
16:32
And then Achilles takes the body of Hector, he hands it very tenderly to the father,
174
980000
8000
16:40
and the two men look at each other, and see each other as divine.
175
988000
4000
16:45
That is the ethos found, too, in all the religions.
176
993000
6000
16:53
It's what is meant by overcoming the horror that we feel when we are under threat of our enemies,
177
1001000
6000
16:59
and beginning to appreciate the other.
178
1007000
3000
17:02
It's of great importance that the word for "holy" in Hebrew, applied to God, is "Kadosh": separate, other.
179
1010000
9000
17:11
And it is often, perhaps, the very otherness of our enemies which can
180
1019000
6000
17:17
give us intimations of that utterly mysterious transcendence which is God.
181
1025000
5000
17:23
And now, here's my wish:
182
1031000
3000
17:26
I wish that you would help with the creation,
183
1034000
6000
17:32
launch and propagation of a Charter for Compassion,
184
1040000
6000
17:38
crafted by a group of inspirational thinkers from
185
1046000
6000
17:44
the three Abrahamic traditions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam,
186
1052000
4000
17:48
and based on the fundamental principle of the Golden Rule.
187
1056000
5000
17:53
We need to create a movement among all these people that I meet in my travels --
188
1061000
8000
18:01
you probably meet, too -- who want to join up, in some way,
189
1069000
4000
18:05
and reclaim their faith, which they feel, as I say, has been hijacked.
190
1073000
5000
18:10
We need to empower people to remember the compassionate ethos,
191
1078000
6000
18:16
and to give guidelines. This Charter would not be a massive document.
192
1084000
4000
18:20
I'd like to see it -- to give guidelines as to how to interpret the Scriptures,
193
1088000
8000
18:28
these texts that are being abused. Remember what the rabbis and what Augustine
194
1096000
6000
18:34
said about how Scripture should be governed by the principle of charity.
195
1102000
3000
18:37
Let's get back to that. And the idea, too, of Jews, Christians and Muslims --
196
1105000
6000
18:43
these traditions now so often at loggerheads -- working together to
197
1111000
5000
18:48
create a document which we hope will be signed by a thousand, at least,
198
1116000
7000
18:55
of major religious leaders from all the traditions of the world.
199
1123000
4000
18:59
And you are the people. I'm just a solitary scholar.
200
1127000
4000
19:03
Despite the idea that I love a good time, which I was rather amazed to see coming up on me
201
1131000
6000
19:09
-- I actually spend a great deal of time alone, studying, and I'm not very --
202
1137000
6000
19:15
you're the people with media knowledge to explain to me how we can get this to everybody,
203
1143000
7000
19:22
everybody on the planet. I've had some preliminary talks,
204
1150000
4000
19:26
and Archbishop Desmond Tutu, for example,
205
1154000
3000
19:29
is very happy to give his name to this, as is Imam Feisal Rauf, the Imam in New York City.
206
1157000
10000
19:39
Also, I would be working with the Alliance of Civilizations at the United Nations.
207
1167000
8000
19:47
I was part of that United Nations initiative called the Alliance of Civilizations,
208
1175000
8000
19:55
which was asked by Kofi Annan to diagnose the causes of extremism,
209
1183000
6000
20:01
and to give practical guidelines to member states about how to avoid the escalation of further extremism.
210
1189000
9000
20:10
And the Alliance has told me that they are very happy to work with it.
211
1198000
4000
20:14
The importance of this is that this is -- I can see some of you starting to look worried,
212
1202000
6000
20:20
because you think it's a slow and cumbersome body --
213
1208000
3000
20:23
but what the United Nations can do is give us some neutrality,
214
1211000
3000
20:26
so that this isn't seen as a Western or a Christian initiative, but that it's coming,
215
1214000
6000
20:32
as it were, from the United Nations, from the world --
216
1220000
3000
20:35
who would help with the sort of bureaucracy of this.
217
1223000
6000
20:41
And so I do urge you to join me in making -- in this charter --
218
1229000
6000
20:47
to building this charter, launching it and propagating it so that it becomes --
219
1235000
8000
20:55
I'd like to see it in every college, every church, every mosque, every synagogue in the world,
220
1243000
9000
21:04
so that people can look at their tradition, reclaim it, and make religion a source of peace in the world,
221
1252000
9000
21:13
which it can and should be. Thank you very much. (Applause)
222
1261000
5000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Karen Armstrong - Religious scholarKaren Armstrong -- winner of the 2008 TED Prize -- is a provocative, original thinker on the role of religion in the modern world.
Why you should listen
Religious thinker Karen Armstrong has written more than 20 books on faith and the major religions, studying what Islam, Judaism and Christianity have in common, and how our faiths shaped world history and drive current events.
A former nun, Armstrong has written two books about this experience: Through the Narrow Gate, about her seven years in the convent, and The Spiral Staircase, about her subsequent spiritual awakening, when she developed her iconoclastic take on the major monotheistic religions -- and on the strains of fundamentalism common to all. She is a powerful voice for ecumenical understanding.
Armstrong's 2008 TED Prize wish asked the world to help her create the Charter for Compassion, a document based on the Golden Rule: that we should treat others how we would want to be treated. In fall 2008, the first draft of the charter was written by the world, via a multilingual website that allowed all to comment. In February 2009, the words were given to the Council of Conscience, a gathering of religious leaders and thinkers, who crafted the final document based on global input. The Charter was officially launched in November 2009. It has been signed by notable world leaders including Pope Benedict XVI, the Dalai Lama, Desmond Tutu, Deepak Chopra and Muhammad Ali. The Charter has led to the creation of the Charter for Compassion International (CCI) organization, the Compassionate Communities campaign, and Global Compassion Council -- a group of leaders continuing the movement around the the world.
Karen Armstrong | Speaker | TED.com