TEDxNewy
Peter Saul: Let's talk about dying
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
1,072,759 views
We can't control if we'll die, but we can "occupy death," in the words of Peter Saul, an emergency doctor. He asks us to think about the end of our lives -- and to question the modern model of slow, intubated death in hospital. Two big questions can help you start this tough conversation.
Peter Saul - Doctor, intensive care specialist
Over the past 35 years Peter Saul has been intimately involved in the dying process for over 4,000 patients. He is passionate about improving the ways we die. Full bio
Over the past 35 years Peter Saul has been intimately involved in the dying process for over 4,000 patients. He is passionate about improving the ways we die. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Look, I had second thoughts, really,
0
578
2023
00:18
about whether I could talk about this
1
2601
2035
00:20
to such a vital and alive audience as you guys.
2
4636
3040
00:23
Then I remembered the quote from Gloria Steinem,
3
7676
2590
00:26
which goes,
4
10266
1639
00:27
"The truth will set you free,
5
11905
1931
00:29
but first it will piss you off." (Laughter)
6
13836
3959
00:33
So -- (Laughter)
7
17795
2268
00:35
So with that in mind, I'm going to set about
8
20063
2124
00:38
trying to do those things here,
9
22187
1591
00:39
and talk about dying in the 21st century.
10
23778
1862
00:41
Now the first thing that will piss you off, undoubtedly,
11
25640
2400
00:43
is that all of us are, in fact, going to die
12
28040
2619
00:46
in the 21st century.
13
30659
1074
00:47
There will be no exceptions to that.
14
31733
2390
00:50
There are, apparently, about one in eight of you
15
34123
2657
00:52
who think you're immortal, on surveys, but --
16
36780
2524
00:55
(Laughter)
17
39304
2178
00:57
Unfortunately, that isn't going to happen.
18
41482
4613
01:01
While I give this talk, in the next 10 minutes,
19
46095
1653
01:03
a hundred million of my cells will die,
20
47748
3496
01:07
and over the course of today, 2,000 of my brain cells
21
51244
2594
01:09
will die and never come back,
22
53838
2141
01:11
so you could argue that the dying process
23
55979
2081
01:13
starts pretty early in the piece.
24
58060
2078
01:16
Anyway, the second thing I want to say about dying in the
25
60138
2114
01:18
21st century, apart from it's going to happen to everybody,
26
62252
2365
01:20
is it's shaping up to be a bit of a train wreck
27
64617
2616
01:23
for most of us,
28
67233
2345
01:25
unless we do something to try and reclaim this process
29
69578
2969
01:28
from the rather inexorable trajectory that it's currently on.
30
72547
3717
01:32
So there you go. That's the truth.
31
76264
1808
01:33
No doubt that will piss you off, and now let's see
32
78072
1431
01:35
whether we can set you free. I don't promise anything.
33
79503
2976
01:38
Now, as you heard in the intro, I work in intensive care,
34
82479
2583
01:40
and I think I've kind of lived through the heyday
35
85062
3104
01:44
of intensive care. It's been a ride, man.
36
88166
2007
01:46
This has been fantastic.
37
90173
1200
01:47
We have machines that go ping.
38
91373
1155
01:48
There's many of them up there.
39
92528
2310
01:50
And we have some wizard technology which I think
40
94838
2744
01:53
has worked really well, and over the course of the time
41
97582
2512
01:55
I've worked in intensive care, the death rate
42
100094
2072
01:58
for males in Australia has halved,
43
102166
2370
02:00
and intensive care has had something to do with that.
44
104536
1619
02:02
Certainly, a lot of the technologies that we use
45
106155
2008
02:04
have got something to do with that.
46
108163
2220
02:06
So we have had tremendous success, and we kind of
47
110383
2504
02:08
got caught up in our own success quite a bit,
48
112887
2354
02:11
and we started using expressions like "lifesaving."
49
115241
3624
02:14
I really apologize to everybody for doing that,
50
118865
2134
02:16
because obviously, we don't.
51
120999
1230
02:18
What we do is prolong people's lives,
52
122229
2528
02:20
and delay death,
53
124757
2101
02:22
and redirect death, but we can't, strictly speaking,
54
126858
2845
02:25
save lives on any sort of permanent basis.
55
129703
2855
02:28
And what's really happened over the period of time
56
132558
1985
02:30
that I've been working in intensive care is that
57
134543
2639
02:33
the people whose lives we started saving back in the '70s,
58
137182
3570
02:36
'80s, and '90s, are now coming to die in the 21st century
59
140752
4478
02:41
of diseases that we no longer have the answers to
60
145230
3600
02:44
in quite the way we did then.
61
148830
2510
02:47
So what's happening now is there's been a big shift
62
151340
1875
02:49
in the way that people die,
63
153215
1807
02:50
and most of what they're dying of now isn't as amenable
64
155022
2271
02:53
to what we can do as what it used to be like
65
157293
2826
02:56
when I was doing this in the '80s and '90s.
66
160119
3911
02:59
So we kind of got a bit caught up with this,
67
164030
2864
03:02
and we haven't really squared with you guys about
68
166894
3033
03:05
what's really happening now, and it's about time we did.
69
169927
4055
03:09
I kind of woke up to this bit in the late '90s
70
173982
3391
03:13
when I met this guy.
71
177373
2094
03:15
This guy is called Jim, Jim Smith, and he looked like this.
72
179467
4357
03:19
I was called down to the ward to see him.
73
183824
2303
03:22
His is the little hand.
74
186127
2245
03:24
I was called down to the ward to see him
75
188372
1386
03:25
by a respiratory physician.
76
189758
1094
03:26
He said, "Look, there's a guy down here.
77
190852
2176
03:28
He's got pneumonia,
78
193028
1600
03:30
and he looks like he needs intensive care.
79
194628
2505
03:33
His daughter's here and she wants everything possible
80
197133
2074
03:35
to be done."
81
199207
2531
03:37
Which is a familiar phrase to us.
82
201738
2619
03:40
So I go down to the ward and see Jim,
83
204357
1831
03:42
and his skin his translucent like this.
84
206188
1685
03:43
You can see his bones through the skin.
85
207873
2250
03:46
He's very, very thin,
86
210123
1538
03:47
and he is, indeed, very sick with pneumonia,
87
211661
3382
03:50
and he's too sick to talk to me,
88
215043
1481
03:52
so I talk to his daughter Kathleen, and I say to her,
89
216524
5150
03:57
"Did you and Jim ever talk about
90
221674
2964
04:00
what you would want done
91
224638
1683
04:02
if he ended up in this kind of situation?"
92
226321
2014
04:04
And she looked at me and said, "No, of course not!"
93
228335
3729
04:07
I thought, "Okay. Take this steady."
94
232064
5060
04:13
And I got talking to her, and after a while, she said to me,
95
237124
2844
04:15
"You know, we always thought there'd be time."
96
239968
3003
04:18
Jim was 94. (Laughter)
97
242971
3766
04:22
And I realized that something wasn't happening here.
98
246737
2534
04:25
There wasn't this dialogue going on
99
249271
1324
04:26
that I imagined was happening.
100
250595
2653
04:29
So a group of us started doing survey work,
101
253248
3007
04:32
and we looked at four and a half thousand nursing home
102
256255
2220
04:34
residents in Newcastle, in the Newcastle area,
103
258475
3340
04:37
and discovered that only one in a hundred of them
104
261815
2947
04:40
had a plan about what to do when their hearts stopped beating.
105
264762
3065
04:43
One in a hundred.
106
267827
1139
04:44
And only one in 500 of them had plan about what to do
107
268966
3341
04:48
if they became seriously ill.
108
272307
3097
04:51
And I realized, of course, this dialogue
109
275404
2760
04:54
is definitely not occurring in the public at large.
110
278164
4636
04:58
Now, I work in acute care.
111
282800
1478
05:00
This is John Hunter Hospital.
112
284278
2105
05:02
And I thought, surely, we do better than that.
113
286383
4001
05:06
So a colleague of mine from nursing called Lisa Shaw and I
114
290384
2996
05:09
went through hundreds and hundreds of sets of notes
115
293380
2516
05:11
in the medical records department
116
295896
1273
05:13
looking at whether there was any sign at all
117
297169
2621
05:15
that anybody had had any conversation about
118
299790
2428
05:18
what might happen to them if the treatment they were
119
302218
1853
05:19
receiving was unsuccessful to the point that they would die.
120
304071
3344
05:23
And we didn't find a single record of any preference
121
307415
2941
05:26
about goals, treatments or outcomes from any
122
310356
3844
05:30
of the sets of notes initiated by a doctor or by a patient.
123
314200
4570
05:34
So we started to realize
124
318770
2717
05:37
that we had a problem,
125
321487
2201
05:39
and the problem is more serious because of this.
126
323688
5023
05:44
What we know is that obviously we are all going to die,
127
328711
3302
05:47
but how we die is actually really important,
128
332013
2665
05:50
obviously not just to us, but also to how that
129
334678
3555
05:54
features in the lives of all the people who live on afterwards.
130
338233
3134
05:57
How we die lives on in the minds of everybody
131
341367
2321
05:59
who survives us, and
132
343688
3117
06:02
the stress created in families by dying is enormous,
133
346805
3732
06:06
and in fact you get seven times as much stress by dying
134
350537
2686
06:09
in intensive care as by dying just about anywhere else,
135
353223
2737
06:11
so dying in intensive care is not your top option
136
355960
3078
06:14
if you've got a choice.
137
359038
2458
06:17
And, if that wasn't bad enough, of course,
138
361496
2169
06:19
all of this is rapidly progressing towards the fact that
139
363665
2648
06:22
many of you, in fact, about one in 10 of you at this point,
140
366313
2352
06:24
will die in intensive care.
141
368665
1450
06:26
In the U.S., it's one in five.
142
370115
1334
06:27
In Miami, it's three out of five people die in intensive care.
143
371449
3750
06:31
So this is the sort of momentum
144
375199
2065
06:33
that we've got at the moment.
145
377264
2288
06:35
The reason why this is all happening is due to this,
146
379552
2545
06:37
and I do have to take you through what this is about.
147
382097
1302
06:39
These are the four ways to go.
148
383399
1965
06:41
So one of these will happen to all of us.
149
385364
2865
06:44
The ones you may know most about are the ones
150
388229
2530
06:46
that are becoming increasingly of historical interest:
151
390759
2846
06:49
sudden death.
152
393605
1417
06:50
It's quite likely in an audience this size
153
395022
1445
06:52
this won't happen to anybody here.
154
396467
2551
06:54
Sudden death has become very rare.
155
399018
1730
06:56
The death of Little Nell and Cordelia and all that sort of stuff
156
400748
2455
06:59
just doesn't happen anymore.
157
403203
1673
07:00
The dying process of those with terminal illness
158
404876
2417
07:03
that we've just seen
159
407293
1032
07:04
occurs to younger people.
160
408325
1615
07:05
By the time you've reached 80, this is unlikely to happen to you.
161
409940
2850
07:08
Only one in 10 people who are over 80 will die of cancer.
162
412790
3415
07:12
The big growth industry are these.
163
416205
4835
07:16
What you die of is increasing organ failure,
164
421040
3251
07:20
with your respiratory, cardiac, renal,
165
424291
2235
07:22
whatever organs packing up. Each of these
166
426526
1780
07:24
would be an admission to an acute care hospital,
167
428306
2603
07:26
at the end of which, or at some point during which,
168
430909
1969
07:28
somebody says, enough is enough, and we stop.
169
432878
2176
07:30
And this one's the biggest growth industry of all,
170
435054
2568
07:33
and at least six out of 10 of the people in this room
171
437622
2575
07:36
will die in this form, which is
172
440197
2562
07:38
the dwindling of capacity
173
442759
3894
07:42
with increasing frailty,
174
446653
2319
07:44
and frailty's an inevitable part of aging,
175
448972
2250
07:47
and increasing frailty is in fact the main thing
176
451222
2553
07:49
that people die of now,
177
453775
1049
07:50
and the last few years, or the last year of your life
178
454824
2128
07:52
is spent with a great deal of disability, unfortunately.
179
456952
4015
07:56
Enjoying it so far? (Laughs)
180
460967
3384
08:00
(Laughter)
181
464351
3153
08:03
Sorry, I just feel such a, I feel such a Cassandra here.
182
467504
3428
08:06
(Laughter)
183
470932
5158
08:11
What can I say that's positive? What's positive is
184
476090
1059
08:13
that this is happening at very great age, now.
185
477149
2415
08:15
We are all, most of us, living to reach this point.
186
479564
2745
08:18
You know, historically, we didn't do that.
187
482309
1888
08:20
This is what happens to you
188
484197
1469
08:21
when you live to be a great age,
189
485666
2523
08:24
and unfortunately, increasing longevity does mean
190
488189
1889
08:25
more old age, not more youth.
191
490078
1927
08:27
I'm sorry to say that. (Laughter)
192
492005
6093
08:33
What we did, anyway, look, what we did,
193
498098
1797
08:35
we didn't just take this lying down
194
499895
1527
08:37
at John Hunter Hospital and elsewhere.
195
501422
1502
08:38
We've started a whole series of projects
196
502924
1622
08:40
to try and look about whether we could, in fact, involve
197
504546
2996
08:43
people much more in the way that things happen to them.
198
507542
3494
08:46
But we realized, of course, that we are dealing
199
511036
1232
08:48
with cultural issues,
200
512268
2344
08:50
and this is, I love this Klimt painting,
201
514612
1859
08:52
because the more you look at it, the more you kind of get
202
516471
2205
08:54
the whole issue that's going on here,
203
518676
2019
08:56
which is clearly the separation of death from the living,
204
520695
3518
09:00
and the fear — Like, if you actually look,
205
524213
1880
09:01
there's one woman there
206
526093
1175
09:03
who has her eyes open.
207
527268
1919
09:05
She's the one he's looking at,
208
529187
1685
09:06
and [she's] the one he's coming for. Can you see that?
209
530872
3228
09:10
She looks terrified.
210
534100
1526
09:11
It's an amazing picture.
211
535626
1693
09:13
Anyway, we had a major cultural issue.
212
537319
2221
09:15
Clearly, people didn't want us to talk about death,
213
539540
1984
09:17
or, we thought that.
214
541524
1495
09:18
So with loads of funding from the Federal Government
215
543019
1947
09:20
and the local Health Service, we introduced a thing
216
544966
1420
09:22
at John Hunter called Respecting Patient Choices.
217
546386
2898
09:25
We trained hundreds of people to go to the wards
218
549284
2849
09:28
and talk to people about the fact that they would die,
219
552133
3143
09:31
and what would they prefer under those circumstances.
220
555276
2286
09:33
They loved it. The families and the patients, they loved it.
221
557562
3519
09:36
Ninety-eight percent of people really thought
222
561081
2460
09:39
this just should have been normal practice,
223
563541
1454
09:40
and that this is how things should work.
224
564995
2383
09:43
And when they expressed wishes,
225
567378
1938
09:45
all of those wishes came true, as it were.
226
569316
1973
09:47
We were able to make that happen for them.
227
571289
1980
09:49
But then, when the funding ran out,
228
573269
2250
09:51
we went back to look six months later,
229
575519
2085
09:53
and everybody had stopped again,
230
577604
2267
09:55
and nobody was having these conversations anymore.
231
579871
3193
09:58
So that was really kind of heartbreaking for us,
232
583064
2053
10:01
because we thought this was going to really take off.
233
585117
2717
10:03
The cultural issue had reasserted itself.
234
587834
3971
10:07
So here's the pitch:
235
591805
1155
10:08
I think it's important that we don't just get on this freeway
236
592960
4086
10:12
to ICU without thinking hard about whether or not
237
597046
2499
10:15
that's where we all want to end up,
238
599545
1793
10:17
particularly as we become older and increasingly frail
239
601338
2136
10:19
and ICU has less and less and less to offer us.
240
603474
3654
10:23
There has to be a little side road
241
607128
2330
10:25
off there for people who don't want to go on that track.
242
609458
4475
10:29
And I have one small idea,
243
613933
2636
10:32
and one big idea about what could happen.
244
616569
4449
10:36
And this is the small idea.
245
621018
1061
10:37
The small idea is, let's all of us
246
622079
2781
10:40
engage more with this in the way that Jason has illustrated.
247
624860
3936
10:44
Why can't we have these kinds of conversations
248
628796
2053
10:46
with our own elders
249
630849
1321
10:48
and people who might be approaching this?
250
632170
2790
10:50
There are a couple of things you can do.
251
634960
1834
10:52
One of them is, you can,
252
636794
2131
10:54
just ask this simple question. This question never fails.
253
638925
2914
10:57
"In the event that you became too sick to speak for yourself,
254
641839
3755
11:01
who would you like to speak for you?"
255
645594
2933
11:04
That's a really important question to ask people,
256
648527
1914
11:06
because giving people the control over who that is
257
650441
2023
11:08
produces an amazing outcome.
258
652464
3308
11:11
The second thing you can say is,
259
655772
1146
11:12
"Have you spoken to that person
260
656918
1498
11:14
about the things that are important to you
261
658416
1920
11:16
so that we've got a better idea of what it is we can do?"
262
660336
4154
11:20
So that's the little idea.
263
664490
2522
11:22
The big idea, I think, is more political.
264
667012
1494
11:24
I think we have to get onto this.
265
668506
1951
11:26
I suggested we should have Occupy Death.
266
670457
3062
11:29
(Laughter)
267
673519
2785
11:32
My wife said, "Yeah, right, sit-ins in the mortuary.
268
676304
2570
11:34
Yeah, yeah. Sure." (Laughter)
269
678874
2579
11:37
So that one didn't really run,
270
681453
1865
11:39
but I was very struck by this.
271
683318
1670
11:40
Now, I'm an aging hippie.
272
684988
1713
11:42
I don't know, I don't think I look like that anymore, but
273
686701
2497
11:45
I had, two of my kids were born at home in the '80s
274
689198
2500
11:47
when home birth was a big thing, and we baby boomers
275
691698
3468
11:51
are used to taking charge of the situation,
276
695166
2696
11:53
so if you just replace all these words of birth,
277
697862
3398
11:57
I like "Peace, Love, Natural Death" as an option.
278
701260
3081
12:00
I do think we have to get political
279
704341
1516
12:01
and start to reclaim this process from
280
705857
2598
12:04
the medicalized model in which it's going.
281
708455
1967
12:06
Now, listen, that sounds like a pitch for euthanasia.
282
710422
2040
12:08
I want to make it absolutely crystal clear to you all,
283
712462
2192
12:10
I hate euthanasia. I think it's a sideshow.
284
714654
2664
12:13
I don't think euthanasia matters.
285
717318
2187
12:15
I actually think that,
286
719505
2151
12:17
in places like Oregon,
287
721656
2549
12:20
where you can have physician-assisted suicide,
288
724205
3472
12:23
you take a poisonous dose of stuff,
289
727677
2217
12:25
only half a percent of people ever do that.
290
729894
1876
12:27
I'm more interested in what happens to the 99.5 percent
291
731770
2706
12:30
of people who don't want to do that.
292
734476
1756
12:32
I think most people don't want to be dead,
293
736232
2334
12:34
but I do think most people want to have some control
294
738566
2097
12:36
over how their dying process proceeds.
295
740663
2742
12:39
So I'm an opponent of euthanasia,
296
743405
1140
12:40
but I do think we have to give people back some control.
297
744545
2653
12:43
It deprives euthanasia of its oxygen supply.
298
747198
3473
12:46
I think we should be looking at stopping
299
750671
1352
12:47
the want for euthanasia,
300
752023
1039
12:48
not for making it illegal or legal or worrying about it at all.
301
753062
4695
12:53
This is a quote from Dame Cicely Saunders,
302
757757
3576
12:57
whom I met when I was a medical student.
303
761333
1369
12:58
She founded the hospice movement.
304
762702
2879
13:01
And she said, "You matter because you are,
305
765581
2191
13:03
and you matter to the last moment of your life."
306
767772
2522
13:06
And I firmly believe that
307
770294
2257
13:08
that's the message that we have to carry forward.
308
772551
3086
13:11
Thank you. (Applause)
309
775637
3019
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Peter Saul - Doctor, intensive care specialistOver the past 35 years Peter Saul has been intimately involved in the dying process for over 4,000 patients. He is passionate about improving the ways we die.
Why you should listen
Dr. Peter Saul is a Senior Intensive Care specialist in the adult and pediatric ICU at John Hunter Hospital, and Director of Intensive Care at Newcastle Private Hospital in Australia. After spending time as the Head of Discipline for Medical Ethics at Newcastle University, he is now a leading adviser to the State and Federal health departments.
Peter Saul | Speaker | TED.com