TEDxPerth
Hamish Jolly: A shark-deterrent wetsuit (and it's not what you think)
Filmed:
Readability: 5.4
2,723,690 views
Hamish Jolly, an ocean swimmer in Australia, wanted a wetsuit that would deter a curious shark from mistaking him for a potential source of nourishment. (Which, statistically, is rare, but certainly a fate worth avoiding.) Working with a team of scientists, he and his friends came up with a fresh approach — not a shark cage, not a suit of chain-mail, but a sleek suit that taps our growing understanding of shark vision.
Hamish Jolly - Inventor, ocean swimmer
Hamish Jolly brings his entrepreneurial eye to the rare but viscerally terrifying issue of shark attacks. Full bio
Hamish Jolly brings his entrepreneurial eye to the rare but viscerally terrifying issue of shark attacks. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
Scientific breakthrough,
0
1202
1509
00:14
the kind that can potentially save lives,
1
2711
2613
00:17
can sometimes be lying right out in the open
2
5324
2064
00:19
for us to discover,
3
7388
1562
00:20
in the evolved, accumulated body
4
8950
2206
00:23
of human anecdote, for example,
5
11156
2592
00:25
or in the time-tested adaptations
6
13748
2026
00:27
that we observe in the natural world around us.
7
15774
3462
00:31
Science starts with observation,
8
19236
2620
00:33
but the trick is to identify the patterns and signatures
9
21856
3396
00:37
that we might otherwise dismiss
10
25252
1945
00:39
as myth or coincidence,
11
27197
1867
00:41
isolate them, and test them with scientific rigor.
12
29064
3853
00:44
And when we do, the results will often surprise.
13
32917
4058
00:48
Western Australia has had a particular problem
14
36975
1880
00:50
with shark attacks over the last three years,
15
38855
3215
00:54
unfortunately and tragically culminating
16
42070
2181
00:56
in five fatal shark attacks in a 10-month period
17
44251
3080
00:59
during that time.
18
47331
1760
01:01
But Western Australia is not alone in this.
19
49091
2129
01:03
The incident of shark engagements on humans
20
51220
2905
01:06
is escalating worldwide.
21
54125
2344
01:08
And so it's not surprising, perhaps,
22
56469
1744
01:10
that in July of this year,
23
58213
1643
01:11
Shark Attack Mitigation Systems in collaboration
24
59856
2479
01:14
with the University of Western
Australia Oceans Institute
Australia Oceans Institute
25
62335
3064
01:17
made an announcement which captured the attention
26
65399
2774
01:20
of the worldwide media and of ocean users
27
68173
2236
01:22
worldwide,
28
70409
1791
01:24
and that was around the development of technology
29
72200
1731
01:25
to mitigate or reduce the risk of shark attack
30
73931
2641
01:28
based on the science of what sharks can see.
31
76572
3148
01:31
And I have for you today
32
79720
1589
01:33
the story of that journey,
33
81309
1867
01:35
but also the notion that science can be
34
83176
2340
01:37
as powerful as a translator
35
85516
2465
01:39
as it can be for invention.
36
87981
3359
01:43
When we began this process,
37
91340
1706
01:45
we were looking, it was about three years ago,
38
93046
3182
01:48
and we'd just had the first two fatal shark attacks
39
96228
3422
01:51
in Western Australia,
40
99650
1771
01:53
and by chance, in a previous role,
41
101421
2207
01:55
I happened to be having dinner with Harry Butler.
42
103628
2923
01:58
Now Harry Butler, who most Australians
would know is a famous naturalist,
would know is a famous naturalist,
43
106551
3707
02:02
had spent a lot of time in the marine environment.
44
110258
2335
02:04
Harry Butler is a precursor, if you like,
45
112593
2106
02:06
to the late Steve Irwin.
46
114699
1911
02:08
When I asked him about
47
116610
1311
02:09
what the solution to the problem might be,
48
117921
3298
02:13
the answer was quite surprising.
49
121219
1512
02:14
He said, "Take a black wetsuit,
50
122731
1875
02:16
band it in yellow stripes like a bumblebee,
51
124606
2765
02:19
and you'll be mimicking the warning systems
52
127371
2288
02:21
of most marine species."
53
129659
2309
02:23
I didn't think about that much at the time,
54
131968
1898
02:25
and it wasn't until the next three
fatal shark attacks happened,
fatal shark attacks happened,
55
133866
3590
02:29
and it caused me to think,
56
137456
1434
02:30
maybe there's some merit to this idea.
57
138890
2131
02:33
And I turned to the web
58
141021
1465
02:34
to see if there might be some clues.
59
142486
2255
02:36
And it turns out the web is awash
60
144741
2277
02:39
with this sort of evidence that supports
61
147018
2396
02:41
this sort of thinking.
62
149414
1562
02:42
So biologically, there are plenty of species
63
150976
1984
02:44
that display banding or patterns, warning patterns,
64
152960
2596
02:47
to either be cryptical in the water
65
155556
1702
02:49
or warn against being attacked,
66
157258
2584
02:51
not the least of which is the pilot fish
67
159842
2113
02:53
which spends a big slab of its life
68
161955
2156
02:56
around the business end of a shark.
69
164111
2279
02:58
On the human side, Walter Starck, an oceanographer,
70
166390
3091
03:01
has been painting his wetsuit since the 1970s,
71
169481
2862
03:04
and anthropologically,
72
172343
1622
03:05
Pacific island tribes painted themselves in bands
73
173965
3630
03:09
in a sea snake ceremony
74
177595
1781
03:11
to ward off the shark god.
75
179376
2594
03:13
So what's going on here?
76
181970
1442
03:15
Is this an idea lying wide out in the open
77
183412
2878
03:18
for us to consider and define?
78
186290
3131
03:21
We know that sharks use a range of sensors
79
189421
4369
03:25
when they engage, particularly for attack,
80
193790
3372
03:29
but the sight sensor is the one that they use
81
197162
1960
03:31
to identify the target, and particularly
82
199122
1564
03:32
in the last number of meters before the attack.
83
200686
3734
03:36
It makes sense to pay attention
to the biological anecdote
to the biological anecdote
84
204420
2958
03:39
because that's time-tested evolution
85
207378
1852
03:41
over many millennia.
86
209230
2473
03:43
But isn't human anecdote also an evolution of sorts,
87
211703
3477
03:47
the idea that there's a kernel of truth
88
215180
1731
03:48
thought to be important,
89
216911
1592
03:50
passed down from generation to generation,
90
218503
3285
03:53
so that it actually ends up shaping human behavior?
91
221788
3315
03:57
I wanted to test this idea.
92
225103
1660
03:58
I wanted to put some science
93
226763
1218
03:59
to this anecdotal evidence,
94
227981
2336
04:02
because if science could support this concept,
95
230317
1956
04:04
then we might have at least part of the solution
96
232273
2095
04:06
to shark attack right under our very nose.
97
234368
3058
04:09
To do that, I needed some experts
98
237426
1795
04:11
in shark vision and shark neurology,
99
239221
1853
04:13
and a worldwide search, again,
100
241074
1809
04:14
led to the University of W.A.
101
242883
1439
04:16
on the doorstep here, with the Oceans Institute.
102
244322
2403
04:18
And professor Nathan Hart and his team
103
246725
2597
04:21
had just written a paper which tells us,
104
249322
2660
04:23
confirms that predatory sharks see
105
251982
2352
04:26
in black and white, or grayscale.
106
254334
2863
04:29
So I called up Nathan,
107
257197
1803
04:31
a little bit sheepishly, actually, about this idea
108
259000
1866
04:32
that maybe we could use these patterns and shapes
109
260866
1881
04:34
to produce a wetsuit to try and
mitigate the risk of shark attack,
mitigate the risk of shark attack,
110
262747
3506
04:38
and fortunately, he thought that was a good idea.
111
266253
2172
04:40
So what ensued is a collaborative bit of research
112
268425
2462
04:42
supported by the West Australian State Government.
113
270887
2624
04:45
And we did three key things.
114
273511
2559
04:48
The first is that we mapped the characteristics,
115
276070
2720
04:50
the physical characteristics of the eyes
116
278790
2020
04:52
of the three main predatory sharks,
117
280810
1938
04:54
so the great white, tiger and bull shark.
118
282748
3718
04:58
We did that genetically
119
286466
1554
05:00
and we did that anatomically.
120
288020
2900
05:02
The next thing we did was to understand,
121
290920
1842
05:04
using complex computer modeling,
122
292762
1435
05:06
what that eye can see
123
294197
2054
05:08
at different depths, distances,
124
296251
1769
05:10
light conditions, and water clarity in the ocean.
125
298020
4241
05:14
And from there, we were able to pinpoint
126
302261
1190
05:15
two key characteristics:
127
303451
1800
05:17
what patterns and shapes would present the wearer
128
305251
3033
05:20
as hidden or hard to make out in the water, cryptic,
129
308284
3232
05:23
and what patterns and shapes might provide
130
311516
1496
05:25
the greatest contrast but provide the greatest
131
313012
2921
05:27
breakup of profile
132
315933
1457
05:29
so that that person wasn't confused for shark prey
133
317390
3644
05:33
or shark food.
134
321034
2353
05:35
The next thing we needed to do was to convert this
135
323387
2192
05:37
into wetsuits that people might actually wear,
136
325579
2749
05:40
and to that end, I invited Ray Smith,
137
328328
2622
05:42
a surfer, industrial designer, wetsuit designer,
138
330950
3230
05:46
and in fact the guy that designed
the original Quiksilver logo,
the original Quiksilver logo,
139
334180
2362
05:48
to come over and sit with the science team
140
336542
2285
05:50
and interpret that science
141
338827
3596
05:54
into aesthetic wetsuits that
people might actually wear.
people might actually wear.
142
342423
3142
05:57
And here's an example of one of the first drawings.
143
345565
2456
06:00
So this is what I call a "don't eat me" wetsuit.
144
348021
3004
06:03
So this takes that banding idea,
145
351025
4269
06:07
takes that banding idea, it's highly visible,
146
355294
2586
06:09
provides a highly disruptive profile,
147
357880
2005
06:11
and is intended to prevent the shark
148
359885
1827
06:13
from considering that you would be ordinary food,
149
361712
2668
06:16
and potentially even create confusion for the shark.
150
364380
3346
06:19
And this one's configured to go with a surfboard.
151
367726
3775
06:23
You can see that dark, opaque panel on the front,
152
371501
2613
06:26
and it's particularly better for the surface,
153
374114
2727
06:28
where being backlit and providing a silhouette
154
376841
2848
06:31
is problematic.
155
379689
1612
06:33
Second iteration is the cryptic wetsuit,
156
381301
2908
06:36
or the one which attempts to hide the wearer
157
384209
1611
06:37
in the water column.
158
385820
1490
06:39
There are three panels on this suit,
159
387310
1690
06:41
and in any given conditions,
160
389000
1624
06:42
one or more of those panels
161
390624
1355
06:43
will match the reflective spectra of the water
162
391979
2590
06:46
so as to disappear fully or partially,
163
394569
2599
06:49
leaving the last panel or panels
164
397168
2192
06:51
to create a disruptive profile in the water column.
165
399360
2887
06:54
And this one's particularly well-suited
166
402247
2165
06:56
to the dive configuration,
167
404412
2447
06:58
so when you're deeper under the water.
168
406859
3068
07:01
So we knew that we had
169
409927
1710
07:03
some really solid science here.
170
411637
1770
07:05
We knew, if you wanted to stand out,
171
413407
1626
07:07
you needed to look stripy,
172
415033
1172
07:08
and we knew if you wanted to be cryptic,
173
416205
1424
07:09
you needed to look like this.
174
417629
1552
07:11
But the acid test is always going to be,
175
419181
1826
07:13
how would sharks really behave
176
421007
1332
07:14
in the context of these patterns and shapes.
177
422339
2731
07:17
And testing to simulate a person in a wetsuit
178
425070
3311
07:20
in the water with a predatory shark
179
428381
1548
07:21
in a natural environment
180
429929
1366
07:23
is actually a lot harder than you might think.
181
431295
1952
07:25
(Laughter)
182
433247
3351
07:28
So we have to bait the rig,
183
436598
2566
07:31
because we need to get the statistical number
184
439164
1544
07:32
of samples through to get the scientific evidence,
185
440708
3024
07:35
and by baiting the rig,
186
443732
789
07:36
we're obviously changing shark behavior.
187
444521
2229
07:38
We can't put humans in the water.
188
446750
1817
07:40
We're ethically precluded from even using
189
448567
2886
07:43
humanoid shapes and baiting them up in the water.
190
451453
2647
07:46
But nevertheless, we started the testing process
191
454100
2272
07:48
in January of this year,
192
456372
1848
07:50
initially with tiger sharks
193
458220
1136
07:51
and subsequently with great white sharks.
194
459356
3339
07:54
The way we did that
195
462695
1435
07:56
was to get a perforated drum which is full of bait,
196
464130
4755
08:00
wrap it in a neoprene skin,
197
468885
1896
08:02
and then run two stereo underwater cameras
198
470781
2563
08:05
to watch how the shark
actually engages with that rig.
actually engages with that rig.
199
473344
3349
08:08
And because we use stereo,
200
476693
1688
08:10
we can capture all the statistics
on how big the shark is,
on how big the shark is,
201
478381
2792
08:13
what angle it comes in at, how quickly it leaves,
202
481173
2256
08:15
and what its behavior is
203
483429
1856
08:17
in an empirical rather than a subjective way.
204
485285
3206
08:20
Because we needed to
preserve the scientific method,
preserve the scientific method,
205
488491
2488
08:22
we ran a control rig
206
490979
1698
08:24
which was a black neoprene rig
207
492677
3712
08:28
just like a normal black wetsuit
208
496389
1809
08:30
against the, what we call,
209
498198
1479
08:31
SAMS technology rig.
210
499677
2128
08:33
And the results were not just exciting,
211
501805
2728
08:36
but very encouraging,
212
504533
1438
08:37
and today I would like to just give you a snapshot
213
505971
2548
08:40
of two of those engagements.
214
508519
3662
08:44
So here we've got a four-meter tiger shark
215
512181
2120
08:46
engaging the black control rig,
216
514301
3087
08:49
which it had encountered about
217
517388
1341
08:50
a minute and a half before.
218
518729
3960
09:11
Now that exact same shark had engaged,
219
539780
2430
09:14
or encountered this SAMS rig,
220
542210
1830
09:16
which is the Elude SAMS rig,
221
544040
1612
09:17
about eight minutes before,
222
545652
1179
09:18
and spent six minutes circling it, hunting for it,
223
546831
3143
09:21
looking for what it could
smell and sense but not see,
smell and sense but not see,
224
549974
2805
09:24
and this was the final engagement.
225
552779
2472
09:29
Great white sharks are more
confident than the tigers,
confident than the tigers,
226
557734
2953
09:32
and here you see great white shark
227
560687
2048
09:34
engaging a control rig,
228
562735
1407
09:36
so a black neoprene wetsuit,
229
564142
1833
09:37
and going straight to the bottom,
230
565975
1584
09:39
coming up
231
567559
2551
09:42
and engaging.
232
570110
3037
09:46
In contrast to the SAMS technology rig,
233
574257
2683
09:48
this is the banded one,
234
576940
1469
09:50
where it's more tactile,
235
578409
1941
09:52
it's more investigative,
236
580350
1510
09:53
it's more apprehensive,
237
581860
1634
09:55
and shows a reluctance to come straight in and go.
238
583494
4005
10:08
(Applause)
239
596297
7303
10:18
So, it's important for us that all
the testing is done independently,
the testing is done independently,
240
606601
4276
10:22
and the University of W.A. is doing the testing.
241
610877
2318
10:25
It'll be an ongoing process.
242
613195
1752
10:26
It's subject to peer review and subject to publication.
243
614947
2409
10:29
It's so important that this concept
244
617356
2343
10:31
is led with the science.
245
619699
1798
10:33
From the perspective of Shark
Attack Mitigation Systems,
Attack Mitigation Systems,
246
621497
2244
10:35
we're a biotechnology licensing company,
247
623741
2405
10:38
so we don't make wetsuits ourselves.
248
626146
2287
10:40
We'll license others to do that.
249
628433
2280
10:42
But I thought you might be interested
250
630713
959
10:43
in seeing what SAMS technology looks like
251
631672
2001
10:45
embedded in a wetsuit, and to that end,
252
633673
2999
10:48
for the first time, live, worldwide --
253
636672
3216
10:51
(Laughter) —
254
639888
1974
10:53
I can show you what biological adaptation,
255
641862
2896
10:56
science and design looks like in real life.
256
644758
3527
11:00
So I can welcome Sam, the surfer,
257
648285
1897
11:02
from this side. Where are you, Sam?
258
650182
2708
11:04
(Applause)
259
652890
1796
11:06
And Eduardo.
260
654686
1670
11:08
(Applause)
261
656356
1816
11:10
Cheers, mate.
262
658172
2694
11:12
Cheers.
263
660866
2090
11:14
Thanks, gentlemen. (Applause)
264
662956
4964
11:21
So what have we done here?
265
669656
1287
11:22
Well, to my mind, rather than take a blank sheet
266
670943
3017
11:25
and use science as a tool for invention,
267
673960
3320
11:29
we've paid attention to the biological evidence,
268
677280
2856
11:32
we've put importance to the
269
680136
1690
11:33
human anecdotal evidence,
270
681826
1710
11:35
and we've used science as a tool
271
683536
3082
11:38
for translation,
272
686618
1403
11:40
translation of something that was already there
273
688021
2227
11:42
into something that we can
use for the benefit of mankind.
use for the benefit of mankind.
274
690248
3571
11:45
And it strikes me that this idea of science
275
693819
1924
11:47
as a tool for translation rather than invention
276
695743
3056
11:50
is one that we can apply much more widely than this
277
698799
2664
11:53
in the pursuit of innovation.
278
701463
1947
11:55
After all, did the Wright brothers
279
703410
2325
11:57
discover manned flight,
280
705735
2052
11:59
or did they observe the biological fact of flight
281
707787
3189
12:02
and translate that mechanically, replicate it
282
710976
3192
12:06
in a way that humans could use?
283
714168
2517
12:08
As for the humble wetsuit,
284
716685
1534
12:10
who knows what oceanwear will look like
285
718219
1941
12:12
in two years' time, in five years' time
286
720160
2951
12:15
or in 50 years' time, but with this new thinking,
287
723111
3092
12:18
I'm guessing there's a fair chance
288
726203
1266
12:19
it won't be pure black.
289
727469
1721
12:21
Thank you.
290
729190
2169
12:23
(Applause)
291
731359
3911
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Hamish Jolly - Inventor, ocean swimmerHamish Jolly brings his entrepreneurial eye to the rare but viscerally terrifying issue of shark attacks.
Why you should listen
Hamish Jolly is an ocean swimmer and kitesurfer who's committed to creating sustainable businesses through innovation management, business development, business management, program management, investment analysis and finance. In 2006, Jolly was listed in Western Australian Business News' 40 Under 40 business leaders.
Formerly Director of Strategy and Ventures at BankWest, Jolly was responsible for group strategy and mergers and acquisitions. He is a qualified Chartered Accountant and fulfils a number of Board positions including Botanic Gardens and Parks Authority Board of Management (Kings Park). He most recently consulted as the Chief Executive Officer of Greening Australia, Australia’s largest environmental not-for-profit organisation and formerly a Director of Ajilon, where he was part of the leadership team for one of the top-3 management and technology consulting firms in Western Australia.
Hamish Jolly | Speaker | TED.com