TED2004
Virginia Postrel: On glamour
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
421,899 views
In a timely talk, cultural critic Virginia Postrel muses on the true meaning, and the powerful uses, of glamour -- which she defines as any calculated, carefully polished image designed to impress and persuade.
Virginia Postrel - Journalist
Virginia Postrel is a writer and cultural critic who examines the hidden economics of modern society, poking at the unexamined ideas behind the march of progress. Full bio
Virginia Postrel is a writer and cultural critic who examines the hidden economics of modern society, poking at the unexamined ideas behind the march of progress. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:18
You might be wondering why I'm wearing sunglasses,
0
0
2000
00:20
and one answer to that is, because I'm here to talk about glamour.
1
2000
5000
00:25
So, we all think we know what glamour is. Here it is.
2
7000
3000
00:28
It's glamorous movie stars, like Marlene Dietrich.
3
10000
3000
00:31
And it comes in a male form, too --
4
13000
2000
00:33
very glamorous.
5
15000
2000
00:35
Not only can he shoot, drive, drink -- you know, he drinks wine,
6
17000
4000
00:39
there actually is a little wine in there --
7
21000
2000
00:41
and of course, always wears a tuxedo.
8
23000
3000
00:44
But I think that glamour actually has a much broader meaning --
9
26000
4000
00:48
one that is true for the movie stars and the fictional characters,
10
30000
4000
00:52
but also comes in other forms.
11
34000
2000
00:54
A magazine?
12
36000
2000
00:56
Well, it's certainly not this one.
13
38000
2000
00:58
This is the least glamorous magazine on the newsstand -- it's all about sex tips.
14
40000
3000
01:01
Sex tips are not glamorous.
15
43000
2000
01:03
And Drew Barrymore, for all her wonderful charm,
16
45000
3000
01:06
is not glamorous either.
17
48000
2000
01:08
But there is a glamour of industry.
18
50000
2000
01:10
This is Margaret Bourke-White's --
19
52000
2000
01:12
one of her pictures she did.
20
54000
2000
01:14
Fantastic, glamorous pictures
21
56000
3000
01:17
of steel mills and paper mills and all kinds of glamorous industrial places.
22
59000
4000
01:21
And there's the mythic glamour
23
63000
2000
01:23
of the garage entrepreneur.
24
65000
2000
01:25
This is the Hewlett-Packard garage.
25
67000
2000
01:27
We know everyone who starts a business in a garage
26
69000
3000
01:30
ends up founding Hewlett-Packard.
27
72000
3000
01:33
There's the glamour of physics.
28
75000
2000
01:35
What could be more glamorous than understanding the entire universe,
29
77000
2000
01:37
grand unification? And, by the way, it helps if you're Brian Greene --
30
79000
4000
01:41
he has other kinds of glamour.
31
83000
2000
01:43
And there is, of course, this glamour.
32
85000
2000
01:45
This is very, very glamorous: the glamour of outer space --
33
87000
3000
01:48
and not the alien-style glamour,
34
90000
3000
01:51
but the nice, clean, early '60s version.
35
93000
3000
01:54
So what do we mean by glamour?
36
96000
2000
01:56
Well, one thing you can do if you want to know what glamour means
37
98000
4000
02:00
is you can look in the dictionary.
38
102000
2000
02:02
And it actually helps a lot more if you look in a very old dictionary,
39
104000
3000
02:05
in this case the 1913 dictionary.
40
107000
2000
02:07
Because for centuries, glamour had a very particular meaning,
41
109000
5000
02:12
and the word was actually used differently from the way we think of it.
42
114000
5000
02:17
You had "a" glamour.
43
119000
2000
02:19
It wasn't glamour as a quality -- you "cast a glamour."
44
121000
2000
02:21
Glamour was a literal magic spell.
45
123000
3000
02:24
Not a metaphorical one, the way we use it today,
46
126000
2000
02:26
but a literal magic spell associated with witches and gypsies
47
128000
4000
02:30
and to some extent, Celtic magic.
48
132000
3000
02:33
And over the years, around the turn of the 20th century,
49
135000
3000
02:36
it started to take on this other kind of deception --
50
138000
6000
02:42
this definition for any artificial interest in, or association with,
51
144000
5000
02:47
an object through which it appears delusively magnified or glorified.
52
149000
5000
02:52
But still, glamour is an illusion.
53
154000
2000
02:54
Glamour is a magic spell.
54
156000
3000
02:57
And there's something dangerous about glamour
55
159000
2000
02:59
throughout most of history. When the witches cast a magic spell
56
161000
4000
03:03
on you, it was not in your self-interest --
57
165000
2000
03:05
it was to get you to act against your interest.
58
167000
2000
03:07
Well of course, in the 20th century,
59
169000
2000
03:09
glamour came to have this different meaning associated with Hollywood.
60
171000
4000
03:13
And this is Hedy Lamarr.
61
175000
2000
03:15
Hedy Lamarr said, "Anyone can look glamorous,
62
177000
2000
03:17
all you have to do is sit there and look stupid." (Laughter)
63
179000
3000
03:20
But in fact, with all due respect to Hedy --
64
182000
5000
03:25
about whom we'll hear more later -- there's a lot more to it.
65
187000
4000
03:29
There was a tremendous amount of technical achievement
66
191000
3000
03:32
associated with creating this Hollywood glamour.
67
194000
2000
03:34
There were scores of retouchers and lighting experts and make-up experts.
68
196000
4000
03:38
You can go to the museum of Hollywood history in Hollywood
69
200000
3000
03:41
and see Max Factor's special rooms that he painted different colors
70
203000
3000
03:44
depending on the complexion of the star he was going to make up.
71
206000
4000
03:48
So you've got this highly stylized portrait of something
72
210000
3000
03:51
that was not entirely of this earth -- it was a portrait of a star.
73
213000
3000
03:54
And actually, we see glamorized photos of stars all the time --
74
216000
4000
03:58
they call them false color.
75
220000
2000
04:00
Glamour is a form of falsification,
76
222000
4000
04:04
but falsification to achieve a particular purpose.
77
226000
3000
04:07
It may be to illuminate the star; it may be to sell a film.
78
229000
4000
04:11
And it involves a great deal of technique.
79
233000
2000
04:13
It's not -- glamour is not something --
80
235000
2000
04:15
you don't wake up in the morning glamorous. I don't care who you are.
81
237000
3000
04:18
Even Nicole Kidman doesn't wake up in the morning glamorous.
82
240000
3000
04:21
There is a process of "idealization, glorification and dramatization,"
83
243000
4000
04:25
and it's not just the case for people.
84
247000
2000
04:27
Glamour doesn't have to be people.
85
249000
2000
04:29
Architectural photography --
86
251000
2000
04:31
Julius Schulman, who has talked about transfiguration,
87
253000
3000
04:34
took this fabulous, famous picture of the Kauffman House.
88
256000
3000
04:37
Architectural photography is extremely glamorous.
89
259000
3000
04:40
It puts you into this special, special world.
90
262000
4000
04:44
This is Alex Ross's comic book art,
91
266000
3000
04:47
which appears to be extremely realistic,
92
269000
2000
04:49
as part of his style is he gives you a kind of realism in his comic art.
93
271000
5000
04:54
Except that light doesn't work this way in the real world.
94
276000
3000
04:57
When you stack people in rows,
95
279000
2000
04:59
the ones in the background look smaller than the ones in the foreground --
96
281000
3000
05:02
but not in the world of glamour.
97
284000
3000
05:05
What glamour is all about -- I took this from a blurb
98
287000
3000
05:08
in the table of contents of New York magazine,
99
290000
3000
05:11
which was telling us that glamour is back --
100
293000
2000
05:13
glamour is all about transcending the everyday.
101
295000
3000
05:16
And I think that that's starting to get at what the core
102
298000
3000
05:19
that combines all sorts of glamour is.
103
301000
3000
05:22
This is Filippino Lippi's 1543 portrait of Saint Apollonia.
104
304000
5000
05:27
And I don't know who she is either,
105
309000
2000
05:29
but this is the [16th] century equivalent of a supermodel.
106
311000
3000
05:32
It's a very glamorous portrait.
107
314000
2000
05:34
Why is it glamorous?
108
316000
2000
05:36
It's glamorous, first, because she is beautiful --
109
318000
2000
05:38
but that does not make you glamorous,
110
320000
2000
05:40
that only makes you beautiful.
111
322000
2000
05:42
She is graceful, she is mysterious and she is transcendent,
112
324000
5000
05:47
and those are the central qualities of glamour.
113
329000
2000
05:49
You don't see her eyes; they're looking downward.
114
331000
4000
05:53
She's not looking away from you exactly,
115
335000
2000
05:55
but you have to mentally imagine her world.
116
337000
4000
05:59
She's encouraging you to contemplate this higher world
117
341000
4000
06:03
to which she belongs, where she can be completely tranquil
118
345000
3000
06:06
while holding the iron instruments of her death by torture.
119
348000
4000
06:10
Mel Gibson's "Passion Of The Christ" -- not glamorous.
120
352000
3000
06:13
That's glamour:
121
355000
2000
06:15
that's Michelangelo's "Pieta," where Mary is the same age as Jesus
122
357000
3000
06:18
and they're both awfully happy and pleasant.
123
360000
3000
06:21
Glamour invites us to live in a different world.
124
363000
3000
06:24
It has to simultaneously be mysterious, a little bit distant --
125
366000
4000
06:28
that's why, often in these glamour shots,
126
370000
2000
06:30
the person is not looking at the audience,
127
372000
2000
06:32
it's why sunglasses are glamorous --
128
374000
3000
06:35
but also not so far above us that we can't identify with the person.
129
377000
4000
06:39
In some sense, there has to be something like us.
130
381000
4000
06:43
So as I say, in religious art, you know, God is not glamorous.
131
385000
3000
06:46
God cannot be glamorous because God is omnipotent,
132
388000
3000
06:49
omniscient -- too far above us.
133
391000
2000
06:51
And yet you will see in religious art, saints or the Virgin Mary
134
393000
3000
06:54
will often be portrayed -- not always -- in glamorous forms.
135
396000
3000
06:57
As I said earlier, glamour does not have to be about people,
136
399000
4000
07:01
but it has to have this transcendent quality.
137
403000
3000
07:04
What is it about Superman?
138
406000
2000
07:06
Aside from Alex Ross's style, which is very glamorous,
139
408000
2000
07:08
one thing about Superman is he makes you believe that a man can fly.
140
410000
4000
07:12
Glamour is all about transcending this world
141
414000
3000
07:15
and getting to an idealized, perfect place.
142
417000
4000
07:19
And this is one reason that modes of transportation
143
421000
4000
07:23
tend to be extremely glamorous.
144
425000
2000
07:25
The less experience we have with them,
145
427000
2000
07:27
the more glamorous they are.
146
429000
2000
07:29
So you can do a glamorized picture of a car,
147
431000
3000
07:32
but you can't do a glamorized picture of traffic.
148
434000
2000
07:34
You can do a glamorized picture of an airplane, but not the inside.
149
436000
4000
07:38
The notion is that it's going to transport you,
150
440000
2000
07:40
and the story is not about, you know, the guy in front of you in the airplane,
151
442000
4000
07:44
who has this nasty little kid, or the big cough.
152
446000
4000
07:48
The story is about where you're arriving,
153
450000
2000
07:50
or thinking about where you're arriving.
154
452000
2000
07:52
And this sense of being transported
155
454000
2000
07:54
is one reason that we have glamour styling.
156
456000
4000
07:58
This sort of streamlining styling is not just glamorous
157
460000
4000
08:02
because we associate it with movies of that period, but because,
158
464000
4000
08:06
in it's streamlining, it transports us from the everyday.
159
468000
3000
08:09
The same thing -- arches are very glamorous.
160
471000
3000
08:12
Arches with stained glass -- even more glamorous.
161
474000
3000
08:15
Staircases that curve away from you are glamorous.
162
477000
3000
08:18
I happen to find that particular staircase picture very glamorous
163
480000
3000
08:21
because, to me, it captures the whole promise
164
483000
2000
08:23
of the academic contemplative life --
165
485000
3000
08:26
but maybe that's because I went to Princeton.
166
488000
2000
08:28
Anyway, skylines are super glamorous,
167
490000
3000
08:31
city streets -- not so glamorous.
168
493000
2000
08:33
You know, when you get, actually to this town it has reality.
169
495000
3000
08:36
The horizon, the open road, is very, very glamorous.
170
498000
4000
08:40
There are few things more glamorous than the horizon --
171
502000
3000
08:43
except, possibly, multiple horizons.
172
505000
4000
08:47
Of course, here you don't feel the cold, or the heat --
173
509000
5000
08:52
you just see the possibilities.
174
514000
2000
08:54
In order to pull glamour off, you need this Renaissance quality
175
516000
4000
08:58
of sprezzatura, which is a term coined by Castiglione
176
520000
4000
09:03
in his book, "The Book Of The Courtier."
177
525000
2000
09:05
There's the not-glamorous version of what it looks like today,
178
527000
3000
09:08
after a few centuries.
179
530000
2000
09:10
And sprezzatura is the art that conceals art.
180
532000
4000
09:14
It makes things look effortless.
181
536000
2000
09:16
You don't think about how Nicole Kidman is maneuvering that dress --
182
538000
4000
09:20
she just looks completely natural.
183
542000
2000
09:22
And I remember reading, after the Lara Croft movies,
184
544000
3000
09:25
how Angelina Jolie would go home completely black and blue.
185
547000
4000
09:29
Of course, they covered that with make-up,
186
551000
2000
09:31
because Lara Croft did all those same stunts --
187
553000
2000
09:33
but she doesn't get black and blue, because she has sprezzatura.
188
555000
4000
09:37
"To conceal all art and make whatever is done or said appear to be without effort":
189
559000
5000
09:42
And this is one of the critical aspects of glamour.
190
564000
3000
09:45
Glamour is about editing.
191
567000
2000
09:47
How do you create the sense of transcendence,
192
569000
2000
09:49
the sense of evoking a perfect world?
193
571000
3000
09:52
The sense of, you know, life could be better, I could join this --
194
574000
4000
09:56
I could be a perfect person, I could join this perfect world.
195
578000
2000
09:58
We don't tell you all the grubby details.
196
580000
3000
10:01
Now, this was kindly lent to me by Jeff Bezos, from last year.
197
583000
4000
10:05
This is underneath Jeff's desk.
198
587000
2000
10:07
This is what the real world of computers,
199
589000
3000
10:10
lamps, electrical appliances of all kinds, looks like.
200
592000
4000
10:14
But if you look in a catalog --
201
596000
2000
10:16
particularly a catalog of modern, beautiful objects for your home --
202
598000
3000
10:19
it looks like this.
203
601000
2000
10:21
There are no cords.
204
603000
2000
10:23
Look next time you get these catalogs in your mail --
205
605000
3000
10:26
you can usually figure out where they hid the cord.
206
608000
3000
10:29
But there's always this illusion that if you buy this lamp,
207
611000
3000
10:32
you will live in a world without cords. (Laughter)
208
614000
3000
10:35
And the same thing is true of, if you buy this laptop
209
617000
3000
10:38
or you buy this computer -- and even in these wireless eras,
210
620000
3000
10:41
you don't get to live in the world without cords.
211
623000
2000
10:43
You have to have mystery and you have to have grace.
212
625000
4000
10:47
And there she is -- Grace.
213
629000
2000
10:49
This is the most glamorous picture, I think, ever.
214
631000
2000
10:51
Part of the thing is that, in "Rear Window,"
215
633000
3000
10:54
the question is, is she too glamorous to live in his world?
216
636000
3000
10:57
And the answer is no, but of course it's really just a movie.
217
639000
3000
11:00
Here's Hedy Lamarr again.
218
642000
2000
11:02
And, you know, this kind of head covering is extremely glamorous
219
644000
3000
11:05
because, like sunglasses, it conceals and reveals at the same time.
220
647000
4000
11:09
Translucence is glamorous --
221
651000
2000
11:11
that's why all these people wear pearls.
222
653000
2000
11:13
It's why barware is glamorous. Glamour is translucent --
223
655000
4000
11:17
not transparent, not opaque.
224
659000
2000
11:19
It invites us into the world
225
661000
2000
11:21
but it doesn't give us a completely clear picture.
226
663000
4000
11:25
And I think if Grace Kelly is the most glamorous person,
227
667000
3000
11:28
maybe a spiral staircase with glass block may be the most glamorous interior shot,
228
670000
6000
11:34
because a spiral staircase is incredibly glamorous.
229
676000
3000
11:37
It has that sense of going up and away,
230
679000
4000
11:41
and yet you never think about how you would really trip
231
683000
3000
11:44
if you were -- particularly going down.
232
686000
2000
11:46
And of course glass block has that sense of translucence.
233
688000
3000
11:49
So, this session's supposed to be about pure pleasure
234
691000
4000
11:53
but glamour's really partly about meaning.
235
695000
3000
11:56
All individuals and all cultures have ideals
236
698000
3000
11:59
that cannot possibly be realized in reality.
237
701000
4000
12:03
They have contradictions,
238
705000
2000
12:05
they uphold principles that are incommensurable with each other --
239
707000
3000
12:08
whatever it is -- and yet these ideals give meaning and purpose
240
710000
3000
12:11
to our lives as cultures and as individuals.
241
713000
3000
12:14
And the way we deal with that is we displace them --
242
716000
4000
12:18
we put them into a golden world, an imagined world,
243
720000
3000
12:21
an age of heroes, the world to come.
244
723000
3000
12:24
And in the life of an individual, we often associate that with some object.
245
726000
4000
12:28
The white picket fence, the perfect house.
246
730000
4000
12:32
The perfect kitchen -- no bills on the counter in the perfect kitchen.
247
734000
3000
12:35
You know, you buy that Viking range, this is what your kitchen will look like.
248
737000
3000
12:38
The perfect love life -- symbolized by the perfect necklace,
249
740000
3000
12:41
the perfect diamond ring.
250
743000
2000
12:43
The perfect getaway in your perfect car.
251
745000
2000
12:45
This is an interior design firm that is literally called Utopia.
252
747000
4000
12:49
The perfect office --
253
751000
2000
12:51
again, no cords, as far as I can tell.
254
753000
2000
12:53
And certainly, no, it doesn't look a thing like my office.
255
755000
3000
12:56
I mean, there's no paper on the desk.
256
758000
2000
12:58
We want this golden world.
257
760000
2000
13:00
And some people get rich enough,
258
762000
2000
13:02
and if they have their ideals -- in a sort of domestic sense,
259
764000
3000
13:06
they get to acquire their perfect world.
260
768000
2000
13:08
Dean Koontz built this fabulous home theater, which is --
261
770000
3000
13:11
I don't think accidentally -- in Art Deco style.
262
773000
4000
13:15
That symbolizes this sense of being safe and at home.
263
777000
3000
13:18
This is not always good, because what is your perfect world?
264
780000
3000
13:21
What is your ideal, and also, what has been edited out?
265
783000
3000
13:24
Is it something important?
266
786000
2000
13:26
"The Matrix" is a movie that is all about glamour.
267
788000
3000
13:29
I could do a whole talk on "The Matrix" and glamour.
268
791000
2000
13:31
It was criticized for glamorizing violence,
269
793000
4000
13:35
because, look -- sunglasses and those long coats, and, of course,
270
797000
5000
13:40
they could walk up walls and do all these kinds of things
271
802000
2000
13:42
that are impossible in the real world.
272
804000
2000
13:44
This is another Margaret Bourke-White photo.
273
806000
2000
13:46
This is from Soviet Union. Attractive.
274
808000
2000
13:48
I mean, look how happy the people are, and good-looking too.
275
810000
4000
13:52
You know, we're marching toward Utopia.
276
814000
3000
13:55
I'm not a fan of PETA, but I think this is a great ad.
277
817000
3000
13:58
Because what they're doing is they're saying,
278
820000
2000
14:00
your coat's not so glamorous, what's been edited out is something important.
279
822000
4000
14:04
But actually, what's even more important
280
826000
2000
14:06
than remembering what's been edited out is thinking, are the ideals good?
281
828000
4000
14:10
Because glamour can be very totalitarian and deceptive.
282
832000
4000
14:14
And it's not just a matter of glamorizing cleaning your floor.
283
836000
3000
14:17
This is from "Triumph Of The Will" --
284
839000
2000
14:19
brilliant editing to cut together things.
285
841000
2000
14:21
There's a glamour shot.
286
843000
2000
14:23
National Socialism is all about glamour.
287
845000
2000
14:25
It was a very aesthetic ideology.
288
847000
2000
14:27
It was all about cleaning up Germany, and the West, and the world,
289
849000
3000
14:30
and ridding it of anything unglamorous.
290
852000
2000
14:32
So glamour can be dangerous.
291
854000
2000
14:34
I think glamour has a genuine appeal, has a genuine value.
292
856000
3000
14:37
I'm not against glamour.
293
859000
2000
14:39
But there's a kind of wonder in the stuff that gets edited away in the cords of life.
294
861000
5000
14:44
And there is both a way to avoid the dangers of glamour
295
866000
4000
14:48
and a way to broaden your appreciation of it.
296
870000
2000
14:50
And that's to take Isaac Mizrahi's advice
297
872000
3000
14:53
and confront the manipulation of it all,
298
875000
2000
14:55
and sort of admit that manipulation is something that we enjoy,
299
877000
5000
15:00
but also enjoy how it happens.
300
882000
2000
15:02
And here's Hedy Lamarr.
301
884000
2000
15:04
She's very glamorous but, you know, she invented spread-spectrum technology.
302
886000
3000
15:07
So she's even more glamorous if you know that she really wasn't stupid,
303
889000
3000
15:10
even though she thought she could look stupid.
304
892000
2000
15:12
David Hockney talks about how the appreciation of this
305
894000
4000
15:16
very glamorous painting is heightened if you think about
306
898000
3000
15:19
the fact that it takes two weeks to paint this splash,
307
901000
4000
15:23
which only took a fraction of a second to happen.
308
905000
2000
15:25
There is a book out in the bookstore --
309
907000
2000
15:28
it's called "Symphony In Steel,"
310
910000
2000
15:30
and it's about the stuff that's hidden under the skin of the Disney Center.
311
912000
3000
15:33
And that has a fascination.
312
915000
2000
15:35
It's not necessarily glamorous, but unveiling the glamour has an appeal.
313
917000
3000
15:38
There's a wonderful book called "Crowns"
314
920000
3000
15:41
that's all these glamour pictures of black women in their church hats.
315
923000
4000
15:45
And there's a quote from one of these women, and she talks about,
316
927000
3000
15:48
"As a little girl, I'd admire women at church with beautiful hats.
317
930000
3000
15:51
They looked like beautiful dolls, like they'd just stepped out of a magazine.
318
933000
4000
15:55
But I also knew how hard they worked all week.
319
937000
3000
15:58
Sometimes under those hats there's a lot of joy and a lot of sorrow."
320
940000
4000
16:02
And, actually, you get more appreciation for glamour
321
944000
3000
16:05
when you realize what went into creating it.
322
947000
3000
16:08
Thank you.
323
950000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Virginia Postrel - JournalistVirginia Postrel is a writer and cultural critic who examines the hidden economics of modern society, poking at the unexamined ideas behind the march of progress.
Why you should listen
Virginia Postrel looks at culture through the lens of economics, and vice versa -- looking for the hidden actors and attitudes that drive us to make the choices we do. She writes frequently for the Atlantic and Forbes, and is the author of several books, including The Substance of Style and The Future and Its Enemies.
Her next book will be about glamour; she's exploring the topic on the witty blog Deep Glamour. Her own blog, frequently updated and fascinatingly wide-ranging, is the Dynamist.
Virginia Postrel | Speaker | TED.com