TED@UPS
Wanis Kabbaj: How nationalism and globalism can coexist
溫尼斯·卡巴許: 國家主義和全球主義能夠並存
Filmed:
Readability: 5.1
1,547,024 views
我們為什麼必須在國家主義和全球主義之間做選擇，在愛國家和關心世界之間做選擇呢？這場演說有一些給公開承認是國家主義者及全球主義者的課題。在演說中，溫尼斯·卡巴許解釋了我們如何能挑戰這種兩極化的二元思維——同時做驕傲的國家公民和世界公民。
Wanis Kabbaj - Transportation geek
UPS's Wanis Kabbaj works at the intersection of biology and transportation. Full bio
UPS's Wanis Kabbaj works at the intersection of biology and transportation. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
So two weeks ago, I searched
the word "nationalist" on Twitter.
the word "nationalist" on Twitter.
0
1692
4015
兩個星期前，我在推特上
搜索了「國家主義者」這個詞。
搜索了「國家主義者」這個詞。
00:18
The results were quite colorful,
1
6109
1841
搜尋結果的描述五花八門，例如：
00:19
with expressions like,
"Emboldened Racist Moron," --
"Emboldened Racist Moron," --
2
7974
3353
「有種的種族主義蠢蛋」、
00:23
(Laughter)
3
11351
1010
（笑聲）
「白人至上主義白痴」、
00:24
"White Supremacist Idiot,"
4
12385
2125
00:26
"Fascist Sock Puppets," --
5
14534
1946
「法西斯的傀儡」、
（笑聲）
00:28
(Laughter)
6
16504
1008
「歐威爾主義的、
希特勒式的、讓人恐懼的。」
希特勒式的、讓人恐懼的。」
00:29
"Orwellian, Hitlerian, Terrifying."
7
17536
2813
00:32
I then searched the word "globalist"
8
20373
2167
接著，我搜尋了「全球主義者」，
00:34
and got things like,
"Socialist Sell-Outs,"
"Socialist Sell-Outs,"
9
22564
3202
找到像這樣的詞：
「社會主義背叛者」、
「社會主義背叛者」、
00:37
"Disgusting Corporate Propaganda,"
10
25790
2960
「讓人作嘔的企業宣傳」、
00:40
"Elitist Financial Overlords,"
11
28774
3015
「精英財務超載」、
00:43
"Ruthless Cosmopolitan Rats."
12
31813
2112
「無情的世界主義鼠輩」。
00:45
(Laughter)
13
33949
1066
（笑聲）
就算是用社交媒體標準來看，
這些字眼也很殘酷且讓人反感。
這些字眼也很殘酷且讓人反感。
00:47
Even by social media standards,
the words are cruel and disgusting.
the words are cruel and disgusting.
14
35039
3873
00:51
But they reflect the intensity
of one of the most fundamental questions
of one of the most fundamental questions
15
39379
4722
但它反映出我們這個時代對於
最根本的問題之一的強烈程度：
00:56
of our times:
16
44125
1199
00:57
Nationalism or globalism --
what is the best path forward?
what is the best path forward?
17
45348
3676
國家主義或全球主義——
哪條路向前行才是最好的？
哪條路向前行才是最好的？
01:01
This question impacts
everything we care about:
everything we care about:
18
49494
2431
這個問題會影響我們在乎的一切：
01:03
our cultural identity,
19
51949
1841
我們的文化身分、
01:05
our prosperity,
20
53814
1815
我們的興盛、
01:07
our political systems --
21
55653
2131
我們的政治體制——
01:09
everything -- the health
of our planet -- everything.
of our planet -- everything.
22
57808
3119
一切——地球的健康——一切。
01:13
So on the one hand, we have nationalism.
23
61550
2653
所以，一方面，我們有國家主義。
01:16
Collins defines it as
a "devotion to one's nation,"
a "devotion to one's nation,"
24
64620
3312
柯林斯字典將之定義為
「對自己國家的忠誠」，
「對自己國家的忠誠」，
01:19
but also, a "doctrine that puts
national interests
national interests
25
67956
2764
還有「將國家利益
放在國際考量之上的一種主義」。
01:22
above international considerations."
26
70744
2147
01:25
For nationalists, our modern societies
are built on national grounds:
are built on national grounds:
27
73364
5020
對國家主義者而言，
我們的現代社會是
建立在國家的基礎上：
建立在國家的基礎上：
01:30
we share a land, a history, a culture,
and we defend each other.
and we defend each other.
28
78408
4856
我們的土地、歷史、
文化都是共有的，
文化都是共有的，
而且我們保衛彼此。
01:35
In a big and chaotic world,
29
83288
2355
在一個大而混亂的世界裡，
01:37
they see nationalism as the only
sensible way to maintain social stability.
sensible way to maintain social stability.
30
85667
4755
他們認為國家主義是唯一可以
維持社會穩定的明智方式。
維持社會穩定的明智方式。
01:43
But alarmed globalists warn us:
31
91597
2435
但憂心的全球主義者警告我們：
01:46
self-centered nationalism
can easily turn ugly.
can easily turn ugly.
32
94056
3273
自我中心的國家主義
很容易就會變得很醜惡。
很容易就會變得很醜惡。
01:49
We've seen it with 20th-century fascisms:
33
97803
2708
二十世紀法西斯主義
就是如此，我們已見識過：
就是如此，我們已見識過：
01:52
bloody wars, millions of deaths,
immeasurable destruction.
immeasurable destruction.
34
100535
4485
殺戮的戰爭、數百萬人喪命、
無法衡量的毀滅。
無法衡量的毀滅。
01:57
On the other hand, we have globalism.
35
105390
1941
另一方面，我們有全球主義。
01:59
The Oxford Living Dictionary
defines it as:
defines it as:
36
107744
2264
牛津生活字典將它定義為：
02:02
"the operation or planning
of economic and foreign policy
of economic and foreign policy
37
110032
3351
「以全球為基礎的
經濟和外交政策操作或規劃。」
02:05
on a global basis."
38
113407
1422
02:07
For nationalists, globalism
is rapidly deconstructing
is rapidly deconstructing
39
115574
3412
國家主義者認為
全球主義者正在快速地瓦解
全球主義者正在快速地瓦解
02:11
what our ancestors took decades to build.
40
119010
2628
我們的祖先花了數十年
所建立的一切。
所建立的一切。
02:13
It's like spitting on our soldiers' tombs;
41
121662
2386
它就像是在對著
我們士兵的墳墓吐口水；
我們士兵的墳墓吐口水；
02:16
it's eroding our national solidarities
42
124072
3000
它在侵蝕我們國家的團結，
02:19
and opening the doors
to foreign invasions.
to foreign invasions.
43
127096
3115
並打開門讓其他國家入侵。
02:22
But globalists make the case
that reinforcing our global governance
that reinforcing our global governance
44
130705
4760
但全球主義者則主張
強化我們的全球治理
02:27
is the only way to tackle
big supernational problems,
big supernational problems,
45
135489
3727
是處理國際性的大問題的唯一方式，
02:31
like nuclear proliferation,
46
139240
2771
比如核子武器擴張、
02:34
the global refugee crisis,
47
142035
2166
全球難民危機、
02:36
climate change or terrorism
48
144225
2716
氣候變遷、恐怖主義，
02:38
or even the consequences of superhuman AI.
49
146965
3180
或甚至超人類人工智慧的後果。
02:42
So we are at the crossroads,
50
150970
2085
所以，我們正處於十字路口，
02:45
and we are asked to choose:
51
153079
1847
我們被要求要做選擇：
02:46
nationalism or globalism?
52
154950
2338
國家主義或全球主義？
02:51
Having lived in four continents,
53
159301
1583
我曾經在四大洲住過，
02:52
I've always been interested
in this question.
in this question.
54
160908
2324
我一直對這個問題很感興趣。
02:55
But it took a whole new level
when I saw this happening:
when I saw this happening:
55
163256
3572
但當我看到以下的狀況時，
它已在完全不同的層級了：
它已在完全不同的層級了：
02:58
the biggest surge in nationalist votes
in Western democracies
in Western democracies
56
166852
4269
在西方民主國家裡，
國家主義者的選票達到
國家主義者的選票達到
自第二次世界大戰以來最大的激增。
03:03
since World War II.
57
171145
1498
03:05
All of a sudden,
this isn't theory anymore.
this isn't theory anymore.
58
173413
2975
突然間，國家主義不再只是理論了。
03:08
I mean, these political movements
have built their success with ideas
have built their success with ideas
59
176412
3986
我的意思是，這些政治運動的
成功所立基的理念
成功所立基的理念
03:12
that could mean, down the road,
losing my French citizenship
losing my French citizenship
60
180422
3110
可能意味著一段時間後
我會失去我的法國公民資格，
我會失去我的法國公民資格，
03:15
because I'm North African
61
183556
1690
因為我是北非人，
03:17
or not being able to come
back home to the US
back home to the US
62
185270
2552
或意味著我會無法回到美國，
03:19
because I come from
a Muslim-majority country.
a Muslim-majority country.
63
187846
2309
因為我來自多數人信奉回教的國家。
03:22
You know, when you live in a democracy,
64
190895
2121
當你生活在民主國家裡，
03:25
you live with this idea that
your government will always protect you,
your government will always protect you,
65
193040
3909
你抱著你的政府
永遠都會保護你的理念，
永遠都會保護你的理念，
03:28
as long as you abide by the laws.
66
196973
2021
只要你守法即可。
03:31
With the rise of national populism,
67
199509
2784
隨著國家民粹主義的興起，
03:34
despite being the best citizen I can,
68
202317
2432
儘管我盡可能做最好的公民 ，
03:36
I now have to live with the idea
that my government can hurt me
that my government can hurt me
69
204773
3578
現在，我也必須要接受，
我的政府有可能會傷害我，
我的政府有可能會傷害我，
03:40
for reasons I cannot control.
70
208375
1751
基於我無法控制的理由。
03:42
It's very unsettling.
71
210579
1919
這很讓人不安。
03:44
But it forced me to rethink
72
212522
1460
但這也迫使我重新思考這個問題，
03:46
and rethink this question
and try to think deeper.
and try to think deeper.
73
214006
3388
並試著想得更深入。
03:49
And the more I thought about it,
74
217418
1678
我越去想它，
03:51
the more I started
questioning the question.
questioning the question.
75
219120
2440
我越會開始質疑這個問題本身。
03:54
Why would we have to choose
between nationalism and globalism,
between nationalism and globalism,
76
222191
3390
我們為什麼必須要在國家主義
和全球主義之間做選擇？
和全球主義之間做選擇？
03:57
between loving our country
and caring for the world?
and caring for the world?
77
225605
3215
在愛自己的國家和
關心全世界之間做出選擇？
關心全世界之間做出選擇？
04:02
There's no reason for that.
78
230143
1305
沒有理由要這麼做。
我們沒必要在家庭和國家之間，
我們沒必要在家庭和國家之間，
04:03
We don't have to choose
between family and country
between family and country
79
231472
2370
04:05
or region or religion and country.
80
233866
2049
或地區或宗教和國家之間做出選擇。
我們已經有多種身分，
而且我們以這些身分過得很好。
而且我們以這些身分過得很好。
04:07
We already have multiple identities,
and we live with them very well.
and we live with them very well.
81
235939
4489
04:12
Why would we have to choose
between country and world?
between country and world?
82
240798
3095
為什麼我們必須要在國家
和世界之間做出選擇呢？
和世界之間做出選擇呢？
04:16
What if, instead of accepting
this absurd choice,
this absurd choice,
83
244491
3213
若是我們拒絕接受這種荒謬的選擇，
04:19
we took it on ourselves to fight
this dangerous, binary thinking?
this dangerous, binary thinking?
84
247728
4171
我們自己擔起對抗這種危險的
二元思考的責任，會如何呢？
二元思考的責任，會如何呢？
04:24
So for all the globalists in the audience,
85
252764
2341
對在座所有的全球主義者，
04:27
I want to ask:
86
255129
1317
我想要問：
04:28
When I say the word "nationalist,"
what image comes to your mind?
what image comes to your mind?
87
256470
3843
當我說「國家主義者」這個詞時，
你們的腦中出現的是什麼畫面？
你們的腦中出現的是什麼畫面？
04:33
Something like this?
88
261031
1465
像這樣嗎？
04:34
Believe me, I think of that, too.
89
262520
1976
相信我，我也會這樣想。
04:36
But I'd like you to remember
that for most people,
that for most people,
90
264823
2997
但我希望你們能記得，
對大部分人來說，
對大部分人來說，
04:39
nationalism feels more like this.
91
267844
2015
國家主義感覺比較像是這樣。
04:42
Or maybe like that.
92
270313
1505
或許像這樣。
04:44
You know, it's that thing inside you
93
272418
1924
它就是當你不小心在電視上看到
04:46
when you accidentally watch
an obscure Olympic sport on TV --
an obscure Olympic sport on TV --
94
274366
4685
難懂的奧運時，內在的感受——
04:51
(Laughter)
95
279075
2232
（笑聲）
等等——
04:53
wait --
96
281331
1061
04:54
and the mere sight of an unknown athlete
wearing your national colors
wearing your national colors
97
282416
3907
你不過是看到不認識的運動員
穿著你的國家的顏色，
穿著你的國家的顏色，
04:58
gets you all excited.
98
286347
1733
就讓你興奮起來。
05:00
Your heartbeat goes up,
99
288104
1714
你的心跳加速，
05:01
your stress level goes up,
100
289842
1831
你的壓力等級提高，
05:03
and you're standing in front of the TV
101
291697
1823
你站在電視機前面，
05:05
and screaming with passion
for that athlete to win.
for that athlete to win.
102
293544
2631
帶著熱情大叫，
希望那位運動員獲勝。
希望那位運動員獲勝。
05:08
That's nationalism.
103
296638
1150
那就是國家主義。
它使人們很高興在一起，
它使人們很高興在一起，
05:09
It's people happy to be together,
104
297812
1734
05:11
happy to belong to a large
national community.
national community.
105
299570
2814
很高興屬於一個大的國家共同體。
05:14
Why would it be wrong?
106
302901
1385
那怎麼會是錯的？
05:17
You know, globalists,
you may think of nationalism
you may think of nationalism
107
305421
2349
全球主義者們，
你們可能會認為國家主義是
你們可能會認為國家主義是
05:19
as an old, 19th-century idea
that is destined to fade.
that is destined to fade.
108
307794
3802
十九世紀的古老想法，
注定會逐漸消失。
注定會逐漸消失。
05:23
But I'm sorry to tell you
that the facts are not on your side.
that the facts are not on your side.
109
311620
3736
但，我很遺憾要告訴你們，
事實並不是在你們那一邊。
事實並不是在你們那一邊。
05:27
When the World Values Survey
asked more than 89,000 people
asked more than 89,000 people
110
315976
3828
當「世界價值觀調查」
向六十個國家的至少八萬九千人
05:31
across 60 countries
111
319828
1478
05:33
how proud they felt about their country,
112
321330
2652
詢問他們對於自己國家
感到多驕傲時，
感到多驕傲時，
05:36
88.5 percent said "very proud"
or "quite proud" --
or "quite proud" --
113
324006
3923
88.5% 的人說「非常驕傲」
或「相當驕傲」——
或「相當驕傲」——
05:39
88.5 percent.
114
327953
1707
88.5%。
05:41
Nationalism is not
going away anytime soon.
going away anytime soon.
115
329989
2857
國家主義在近期內不會消失。
05:45
It's a powerful feeling
that, according to another study,
that, according to another study,
116
333580
4193
它是一種很強烈的感覺。
另一項研究指出，
05:49
is a strong predictor
of individual happiness.
of individual happiness.
117
337797
3215
它是用來預測個人幸福感的
重要預測指數。
重要預測指數。
聽起來很扯，但你的幸福感
05:53
It's crazy, but your happiness is more
correlated with national satisfaction
correlated with national satisfaction
118
341431
5155
與你對國家的滿意度
有很強的關聯性，
有很強的關聯性，
05:58
than with things you would expect,
like household income
like household income
119
346610
3281
勝過你預期的其他因素，
例如家庭收入、
例如家庭收入、
06:01
or your job satisfaction
120
349915
2004
你的工作滿意度、
06:03
or your health satisfaction.
121
351943
1599
或你的健康滿意度。
06:05
So if nationalism makes people happy,
122
353955
2612
所以，如果國家主義讓人民幸福，
06:08
why would anybody take it away from them?
123
356591
2202
為什麼會有人要將它奪走呢？
06:11
Fellow globalists, if you are like me,
124
359666
2708
全球主義朋友們，
如果你們和我一樣，
如果你們和我一樣，
06:14
you may be attached to globalization
for humanistic reasons.
for humanistic reasons.
125
362398
3535
你們依戀全球化的背後原因
可能和人性有關。
可能和人性有關。
06:17
And you may take great joy
in some of its accomplishments since 1945.
in some of its accomplishments since 1945.
126
365957
4683
1945 年以後的一些全球化的成就
可能讓你感到很大的喜悅。
可能讓你感到很大的喜悅。
06:22
After all, major regions of the world
have been exceptionally peaceful;
have been exceptionally peaceful;
127
370664
3599
畢竟，世界上的主要地區
都一直非常和平；
都一直非常和平；
06:26
extreme poverty rates around
the globe are trending down;
the globe are trending down;
128
374664
3818
全球的貧窮比率呈現下降趨勢；
06:30
and more than two billion people,
most notably in Asia,
most notably in Asia,
129
378506
3176
超過二十億人，最明顯是在亞洲，
06:33
show spectacular improvements
in their standards of living.
in their standards of living.
130
381706
2901
在生活水準上有驚人的改善。
06:37
But studies also show
that globalization has a dark side.
that globalization has a dark side.
131
385266
4301
但研究也顯示，
全球化有一個黑暗面。
全球化有一個黑暗面。
06:41
And left on the side of the road
132
389591
2912
數億名西方中產階級的人被遺忘了，
06:44
are hundreds of millions of people
in Western middle classes
in Western middle classes
133
392527
3765
06:48
with anemic income growth
for more than two decades,
for more than two decades,
134
396316
2785
他們的收入在二十多年以來
幾乎沒有增加，
幾乎沒有增加，
06:51
possibly three decades,
according to some studies.
according to some studies.
135
399125
2558
根據一些研究，甚至長達三十年。
06:54
We cannot ignore
this elephant in our room.
this elephant in our room.
136
402031
2960
我們不能忽略這麼大的問題。
06:57
If anything, our collective energy
would be better used
would be better used
137
405015
2633
如果可以的話，
我們集體的能量最好能用來
我們集體的能量最好能用來
尋找解決全球化問題的方法，
06:59
finding ways to fix this aspect
of globalization,
of globalization,
138
407672
3397
07:03
instead of fighting this polarizing battle
against nationalism.
against nationalism.
139
411093
4817
而不是用來打這場對抗
國家主義的兩極化戰爭。
國家主義的兩極化戰爭。
07:08
So now, the nationalists in the audience,
140
416547
2285
現在，在座的國家主義者，
07:10
I have some crusty,
nonbinary nuggets for you.
nonbinary nuggets for you.
141
418856
3304
我有一些有殼的
非二元金塊要給你們。
非二元金塊要給你們。
07:14
(Laughter)
142
422184
1282
（笑聲）
07:16
When I say the word "globalist,"
what comes to your mind?
what comes to your mind?
143
424211
2667
當我說「全球主義者」
這個詞時，你們想到什麼？
這個詞時，你們想到什麼？
07:19
Out-of-touch, one-percent plutocrats?
144
427496
2323
不諳時勢、百分之一的富豪？
07:21
(Laughter)
145
429843
1403
（笑聲）
07:23
Or maybe the heartless,
greedy Wall Street type, right?
greedy Wall Street type, right?
146
431270
2821
或者，也許是沒心肝又貪心的
華爾街類型，對嗎？
華爾街類型，對嗎？
07:26
Or maybe people like me,
with multiple origins,
with multiple origins,
147
434402
2458
或者，像我這樣的人，
有多重身分來源，
有多重身分來源，
07:28
living in a big, cosmopolitan metropolis.
148
436884
2863
住在世界性的大都市中。
07:32
Well, you remember that World
Values Survey that I mentioned earlier?
Values Survey that I mentioned earlier?
149
440696
3301
你們還記得我剛才提到的
世界價值觀調查嗎？
世界價值觀調查嗎？
07:36
It showed another fascinating finding:
150
444428
2622
它還有另一項很迷人的發現：
07:39
71 percent of the world population
agreed with the statement,
agreed with the statement,
151
447074
4319
世界人口中有 71%
同意「我是世界公民」這項陳述。
07:43
"I am a citizen of the world."
152
451417
1821
07:45
Do you know what it means?
153
453262
1256
你們知道它意味著什麼嗎？
07:47
Most of us are simultaneously
proud of our country
proud of our country
154
455094
3229
我們大部分人不但
對自己的國家感到驕傲，
對自己的國家感到驕傲，
07:50
and citizens of the world.
155
458347
1814
同時也是世界公民。
07:52
And it gets even better.
156
460185
1532
更好的還在後面。
07:53
The citizens of the world in the survey
show a higher level of national pride
show a higher level of national pride
157
461741
4441
在調查中的世界公民
對於自己國家的驕傲程度
對於自己國家的驕傲程度
07:58
than the ones that rejected that label.
158
466206
1984
比排斥這個標籤的人還高。
08:00
So once and for all, being a globalist
doesn't mean betraying your country.
doesn't mean betraying your country.
159
468754
3751
所以我再強調最後一次，
身為全球主義者
並不表示背叛你的國家。
並不表示背叛你的國家。
08:04
It just means that you have
enough social empathy,
enough social empathy,
160
472529
2397
它只表示你有足夠的社會同理心，
08:06
and you project some of it outside
your national borders.
your national borders.
161
474950
3044
你把一部分同理心
擴展到你的國家之外。
擴展到你的國家之外。
08:11
Now, I know that when I dig
into my own nationalist feelings,
into my own nationalist feelings,
162
479248
3484
我知道當我深入探究
我的國家主義感受時，
我的國家主義感受時，
08:14
one of my anxieties versus
the globalized world
the globalized world
163
482756
3038
我對於全球化世界的焦慮之一
08:17
is national identity:
164
485818
1911
就是國家身分：
08:19
How are we going to preserve
what makes us special,
what makes us special,
165
487753
3195
我們要如何保有我們的獨特性？
我們的差異性？我們的團結性？
08:22
what makes us different,
166
490972
1286
08:24
what brings us together?
167
492282
1634
08:25
And as I started thinking about it,
I realized something really strange,
I realized something really strange,
168
493940
3982
當我開始思考這問題時，
我發現了一件非常奇怪的事，
我發現了一件非常奇怪的事，
08:29
which is that a lot of the key ingredients
of our national identities
of our national identities
169
497946
3910
那就是，我們的國家身分
其實有許多關鍵組成要素
其實有許多關鍵組成要素
08:33
actually come from outside
our national borders.
our national borders.
170
501880
2705
都來自於我們的國界之外。
08:37
Like, think of the letters
that we use every day.
that we use every day.
171
505032
2313
比如，想想我們每天使用的字母，
08:39
I don't know if you realize,
172
507705
1392
不知道你們是否有發現，但，
08:41
but the Latin script, the Latin
alphabet that we use
alphabet that we use
173
509121
3812
我們使用的拉丁字母
源自於數千年前的尼羅河附近。
08:44
has its origins thousands of years ago,
174
512957
2359
08:47
near the Nile River.
175
515340
1295
08:49
It all started with a cow just like this,
176
517082
3330
它是從像這樣的一隻牛開始，
08:52
that was captured by a scribe
into an elegant hieroglyph.
into an elegant hieroglyph.
177
520436
4249
牠被抄寫員畫成優雅的象形文字。
08:57
That hieroglyph was transcribed
by a Semite in the Sinai
by a Semite in the Sinai
178
525233
3563
那象形文字被西奈山的
一名閃米特人抄寫，
一名閃米特人抄寫，
09:00
into the letter aleph.
179
528820
1448
成為原始迦南文字的第一個字母。
09:02
Aleph traveled with Phoenicians
and reached the European shores in Greece,
and reached the European shores in Greece,
180
530972
5040
這個字母被腓尼基人
帶到了歐洲海岸的希臘，
帶到了歐洲海岸的希臘，
在那裡，它演變成了 α，
後來成為我們的字母 A。
後來成為我們的字母 A。
09:08
where it became alpha,
181
536036
1438
09:09
the mother of our letter A.
182
537498
1550
09:11
So that's how an Egyptian cow
became our letter A.
became our letter A.
183
539555
3335
埃及的牛就這樣
變成了我們的字母 A。
變成了我們的字母 A。
09:14
(Laughter)
184
542914
1321
（笑聲）
09:16
And same thing with the Egyptian house
that became bet, beta and B.
that became bet, beta and B.
185
544865
6062
同樣的，埃及的房子變成了
第二個字母，及後來的 β 和 B。
09:22
And the Egyptian fish
that became daleth, delta and D.
that became daleth, delta and D.
186
550951
4222
埃及的魚變成了
第四個字母，及 δ 和 D。
第四個字母，及 δ 和 D。
09:27
Our most fundamental texts
are full of Egyptian cows,
are full of Egyptian cows,
187
555681
3401
我們的基礎文本中充滿了
埃及的牛、房子，和魚。
09:31
houses and fish.
188
559106
1507
09:32
(Laughter)
189
560637
1285
（笑聲）
09:34
And there are so many other examples.
190
562565
2223
還有許多其他的例子。
09:36
Take the United Kingdom and its monarchy.
191
564812
2760
比如英國和它的君主政體。
09:39
Queen Elizabeth II?
192
567596
1987
伊莉莎白二世？
09:41
German ancestry.
193
569607
1362
德國血統。
09:43
The mottos on the royal coat of arms?
194
571384
2313
英國皇家徽章上的格言？
09:45
All written in French,
not a single word of English.
not a single word of English.
195
573721
2677
都是用法文寫的，沒有一個英文字。
09:49
Take France and it's iconic Eiffel Tower.
196
577117
3779
比如法國和它標誌性的艾菲爾鐵塔。
09:52
The inspiration?
197
580920
1362
靈感來自哪裡呢？
09:54
The United States of America --
198
582754
1996
美國——
我不是指拉斯維加斯，
我是指十九世紀的紐約市。
我是指十九世紀的紐約市。
09:56
and I don't mean Las Vegas,
199
584774
1294
09:58
I mean 19th-century New York.
200
586092
1758
09:59
(Laughter)
201
587874
1087
（笑聲）
10:00
This was the tallest building
in New York in the mid-19th century.
in New York in the mid-19th century.
202
588985
3517
這是十九世紀中期
紐約市最高的建築物。
紐約市最高的建築物。
10:04
Does it remind you of something?
203
592526
1621
它有沒有讓你想到什麼？
10:07
And you may think of China
as a self-contained civilization,
as a self-contained civilization,
204
595147
3439
你們可能認為中國
是獨立自足的文明，
是獨立自足的文明，
10:10
protected behind its Great Wall.
205
598610
2129
被長城保護在裡面。
10:12
But think twice.
206
600763
1518
再想一下。
10:14
The Chinese official ideology?
207
602305
2046
中國官方的意識形態？
10:16
Marxism, made in Germany.
208
604375
2747
馬克思主義，德國製造。
10:20
One of China's biggest religions?
209
608064
1645
中國最大的宗教之一？
10:21
Buddhism, imported from India.
210
609733
2608
佛教，印度進口。
10:24
India's favorite pastime?
211
612365
2285
印度最愛的消遣娛樂？
10:26
Cricket.
212
614674
1216
板球。
10:28
I really love this quote from Ashis Nandy,
213
616222
2418
我真的很喜歡阿細斯·南迪
講的這句話，他說：
講的這句話，他說：
10:30
who said, "Cricket is an Indian game
accidentally discovered by the British."
accidentally discovered by the British."
214
618664
4877
「板球是一項印度運動，
不小心被英國人發現的。」
10:35
(Laughter)
215
623565
1558
（笑聲）
10:37
So these are good reminders that a lot
of what we love in our national traditions
of what we love in our national traditions
216
625147
6545
所以，這些都是很好的提醒，
讓我們知道，
很多我們喜愛的國家傳統
很多我們喜愛的國家傳統
10:43
actually come from previous
waves of globalization.
waves of globalization.
217
631716
2666
其實是來自前幾波的全球化。
10:46
And beyond individual symbols,
there are whole national traditions
there are whole national traditions
218
634835
3704
除了個別符號之外，
還有非常多的國家傳統，
還有非常多的國家傳統，
10:50
that could not have existed
without globalization.
without globalization.
219
638563
3058
若沒有全球化是不可能存在的。
10:54
And the example that comes to my mind
is a world-beloved national tradition:
is a world-beloved national tradition:
220
642070
4305
我想到的一個例子是
受到全世界喜愛的一項國家傳統：
受到全世界喜愛的一項國家傳統：
10:58
Italian cuisine.
221
646399
1286
意大利美食。
11:00
My friends, if you ever have a chance
222
648056
1804
朋友們，如果你曾經有機會
11:01
to go to a superauthentic
Italian restaurant
Italian restaurant
223
649884
2564
去一間超級道地的義大利餐廳，
11:04
that only serves ancient Roman recipes,
224
652472
2645
只提供古早的羅馬食譜，
11:07
my advice for you is: don't go.
225
655141
2486
我給你的建議是：別去。
11:09
(Laughter)
226
657651
1427
（笑聲）
11:11
You'd get very, very disappointed.
227
659102
1823
你會非常非常失望。
11:13
No spaghetti, no pasta --
228
661353
1864
沒有義大利麵——
11:15
that really started in Sicily
in the eighth century,
in the eighth century,
229
663241
2864
它其實是第八世紀
從西西里島發展出來的，
從西西里島發展出來的，
11:18
when it was under Arabian rule.
230
666129
1702
當時是受到阿拉伯人統治。
11:20
No perfect espresso,
no creamy cappuccino --
no creamy cappuccino --
231
668407
2637
沒有完美的濃縮咖啡，
沒有加奶的卡普奇諾——
沒有加奶的卡普奇諾——
11:23
that came from Abyssinia
via Yemen in the 17th century.
via Yemen in the 17th century.
232
671068
3833
那是十七世紀從阿比西尼亞
經過葉門傳來的。
經過葉門傳來的。
11:26
And of course,
no perfect pizza Napoletana --
no perfect pizza Napoletana --
233
674925
2509
當然，也沒有完美的
拿坡里披薩——
拿坡里披薩——
11:29
how would you make it without
the tomatoes of the New World?
the tomatoes of the New World?
234
677458
3191
沒有新世界的蕃茄怎麼
可能做出拿坡里披薩？
可能做出拿坡里披薩？
11:33
No, instead, you would be served
probably a lot of porridge,
probably a lot of porridge,
235
681736
4039
不可能，你反而可能會吃到很多粥、
11:37
some vegetable -- mostly
cabbage -- some cheese,
cabbage -- some cheese,
236
685799
3657
一些蔬菜——大部分是高麗菜——
一些起士，
11:41
and maybe if you're lucky,
237
689480
1706
如果你幸運的話，
11:43
the absolute delicacy of that time --
238
691210
3122
還有當時絕對的佳餚——
11:46
mmm, perfectly cooked fattened dormice.
239
694356
3531
嗯，完美地烹調過的養肥的睡鼠。
11:49
(Laughter)
240
697911
1217
（笑聲）
11:52
Thankfully, it was not a close tradition
preserved by fanatic watchdogs.
preserved by fanatic watchdogs.
241
700115
4292
謝天謝地，不是由狂熱監視者
來保留封閉的傳統。
來保留封閉的傳統。
11:56
No, it was an open process,
242
704431
1653
不，它是一個開放的過程，
11:58
nourished by explorers, traders,
street sellers and innovative home cooks.
street sellers and innovative home cooks.
243
706108
5889
由探索家、商人、攤販，
和創新的家庭廚師所滋養。
12:04
And in many ways,
globalization is a chance
globalization is a chance
244
712021
2066
就許多方面來說，
全球化是一個機會，
全球化是一個機會，
12:06
for our national traditions to be
questioned, regenerated, reinterpreted,
questioned, regenerated, reinterpreted,
245
714111
5263
讓我們的國家傳統可以
被質疑、再生、重新詮釋，
12:11
to attract new converts
to stay vibrant and relevant over time.
to stay vibrant and relevant over time.
246
719398
3963
吸引新的愛好者，隨著時間的推移
仍然保持生氣、仍然存在。
仍然保持生氣、仍然存在。
12:15
So just remember this:
247
723841
1293
所以，記住這一點：
12:17
most of us nationalists
in the world are globalists,
in the world are globalists,
248
725480
2698
全世界大部分的國家主義者
都是全球主義者，
都是全球主義者，
12:20
and most of us globalists
in the world are nationalists.
in the world are nationalists.
249
728202
2820
世界上大部分的全球主義者
都是國家主義者。
都是國家主義者。
12:23
A lot of what we like
in our national traditions
in our national traditions
250
731046
3065
許多我們喜愛的國家傳統
12:26
come from outside our national borders.
251
734135
2316
都來自我們國界以外的地方。
12:28
And the reason we venture
outside our national borders
outside our national borders
252
736475
2722
而我們冒險到
國界以外的地方的原因就是
國界以外的地方的原因就是
12:31
is to discover these other
national traditions.
national traditions.
253
739221
2696
去發掘這些其他的國家傳統。
12:33
So the real question should not be
254
741941
1719
所以，真正的問題應該不是
12:35
to choose between
nationalism and globalism.
nationalism and globalism.
255
743684
2686
在國家主義和全球主義之間做選擇。
12:38
The real questions is:
How can we do both better?
How can we do both better?
256
746394
3514
真正的問題是：
我們能把兩者都做更好嗎？
我們能把兩者都做更好嗎？
12:41
It's a complex question
for a complex world
for a complex world
257
749932
2851
這是一個複雜世界的複雜問題，
12:44
that calls for creative,
nonbinary solutions.
nonbinary solutions.
258
752807
3503
需要創意、非二元的解決方案。
12:48
What are you waiting for?
259
756334
1357
你們還在等什麼？
12:49
Thank you.
260
757715
1151
謝謝。
12:50
(Applause)
261
758890
1800
（掌聲）
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Wanis Kabbaj - Transportation geekUPS's Wanis Kabbaj works at the intersection of biology and transportation.
Why you should listen
As the director of global strategy for healthcare logistics at UPS, Wanis Kabbaj finds ways for organizations to transport their temperature-sensitive medicines and biotechnologies safely around the world. For more than 16 years, Kabbaj's professional engagements have always revolved around transportation and innovation. Some of his ventures involved helping EADS Astrium use its satellite space transportation expertise in unexpected markets or participating in the global launch of Logan, a revolutionary low-cost vehicle, that helped Renault-Nissan harness a surprising growth in emerging markets.
Kabbaj is a dual citizen of Morocco and France and lived in four continents. Experiencing constant cultural transitions throughout his life gave him a real taste for analyzing problems through non-traditional lenses and blending disciplines that are usually kept separate.
Wanis Kabbaj | Speaker | TED.com