ABOUT THE SPEAKER
James Green - Space physicist
James Green leads NASA's solar system exploration and astrobiology research.

Why you should listen

Dr. James Green began his career at NASA 35 years ago at the Marshall Space Flight Center, where he developed and managed the Space Physics Analysis Network. It provided scientists all over the world rapid access to data and resources. As NASA's Director of Planetary Science he leads NASA's solar system exploration and astrobiology research.

Green received his Ph.D. in Space Physics from the University of Iowa in 1979 and began working in the Magnetospheric Physics Branch at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) in 1980. At Marshall, Green developed and managed the Space Physics Analysis Network that provided scientists all over the world with rapid access to data, to other scientists, and to specific NASA computer and information resources. In addition, Green was a Safety Diver in the Neutral Buoyancy tank making over 150 dives until left MSFC in 1985.

From 1985 to 1992 Green was the head of the National Space Science Data Center (NSSDC) at Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC). The NSSDC is NASA's largest space science data archive. In 1992, he became the Chief of the Space Science Data Operations Office until 2005, when he became the Chief of the Science Proposal Support Office. While at GSFC, Green was a co-investigator and the Deputy Project Scientist on the Imager for Magnetopause-to-Aurora Global Exploration (IMAGE) mission. He has written over 100 scientific articles in refereed journals involving various aspects of the Earth's and Jupiter's magnetospheres and over 50 technical articles on various aspects of data systems and networks.

In August 2006, Green became the Director of the Planetary Science Division at NASA Headquarters. Over his career, Green has received numerous awards. In 1988, he received the Arthur S. Flemming award given for outstanding individual performance in the federal government and was awarded Japan's Kotani Prize in 1996 in recognition of his international science data management activities.

More profile about the speaker
James Green | Speaker | TED.com
TED Talks Live

James Green: 3 moons and a planet that could have alien life

Filmed:
1,837,212 views

Is there life beyond Earth? Join NASA's director of planetary science James Green for a survey of the places in our solar system that are most likely to harbor alien life.
- Space physicist
James Green leads NASA's solar system exploration and astrobiology research. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
Is there life beyond Earth
in our solar system?
0
880
3720
00:17
Wow, what a powerful question.
1
5280
2320
00:20
You know, as a scientist --
2
8960
1696
00:22
planetary scientist --
3
10680
1216
00:23
we really didn't take that
very seriously until recently.
4
11920
3560
00:28
Carl Sagan always said,
5
16400
2096
00:30
"It takes extraordinary evidence
for extraordinary claims."
6
18520
5400
00:36
And the claims of having life beyond Earth
7
24960
3520
00:41
need to be definitive,
8
29240
2296
00:43
they need to be loud
9
31560
1616
00:45
and they need to be everywhere
for us to be able to believe it.
10
33200
4560
00:50
So how do we make this journey?
11
38760
2600
00:54
What we decided to do
12
42040
1656
00:55
is first look for
those ingredients for life.
13
43720
4200
01:00
The ingredients of life are:
14
48680
2256
01:02
liquid water --
15
50960
1216
01:04
we have to have a solvent,
16
52200
1696
01:05
can't be ice, has to be liquid.
17
53920
2080
01:08
We also have to have energy.
18
56800
1936
01:10
We also have to have organic material --
19
58760
3016
01:13
things that make us up,
20
61800
2296
01:16
but also things that we need to consume.
21
64120
2520
01:19
So we have to have these elements
22
67600
2816
01:22
in environments for long periods of time
23
70440
2816
01:25
for us to be able
to be confident that life,
24
73280
3536
01:28
in that moment when it starts,
25
76840
2296
01:31
can spark and then grow and evolve.
26
79160
2880
01:35
Well, I have to tell you
that early in my career,
27
83080
3680
01:39
when we looked at those three elements,
28
87520
2256
01:41
I didn't believe
that they were beyond Earth
29
89800
2256
01:44
in any length of time
and for any real quantity.
30
92080
4096
01:48
Why? We look at the inner planets.
31
96200
2256
01:50
Venus is way too hot -- it's got no water.
32
98480
2976
01:53
Mars -- dry and arid.
33
101480
2016
01:55
It's got no water.
34
103520
1536
01:57
And beyond Mars,
35
105080
1776
01:58
the water in the solar system
is all frozen.
36
106880
2960
02:03
But recent observations
have changed all that.
37
111120
4136
02:07
It's now turning our attention
to the right places
38
115280
3896
02:11
for us to take a deeper look
39
119200
2536
02:13
and really start to answer
our life question.
40
121760
3560
02:18
So when we look out into the solar system,
41
126160
2936
02:21
where are the possibilities?
42
129120
1639
02:23
We're concentrating our attention
on four locations.
43
131200
3400
02:27
The planet Mars
44
135320
1360
02:29
and then three moons of the outer planets:
45
137440
3200
02:33
Titan, Europa and small Enceladus.
46
141240
4240
02:38
So what about Mars?
47
146880
1736
02:40
Let's go through the evidence.
48
148640
1800
02:43
Well, Mars we thought
was initially moon-like:
49
151880
3576
02:47
full of craters, arid and a dead world.
50
155480
4360
02:52
And so about 15 years ago,
51
160880
2216
02:55
we started a series
of missions to go to Mars
52
163120
3616
02:58
and see if water existed
on Mars in its past
53
166760
4616
03:03
that changed its geology.
54
171400
2256
03:05
We ought to be able to notice that.
55
173680
1720
03:08
And indeed we started
to be surprised right away.
56
176040
3456
03:11
Our higher resolution images
show deltas and river valleys and gulleys
57
179520
5136
03:16
that were there in the past.
58
184680
1680
03:19
And in fact,
59
187320
1216
03:20
Curiosity --
60
188560
1216
03:21
which has been roving on the surface
now for about three years --
61
189800
4296
03:26
has really shown us that it's sitting
in an ancient river bed,
62
194120
5176
03:31
where water flowed rapidly.
63
199320
2400
03:34
And not for a little while,
64
202280
1456
03:35
perhaps hundreds of millions of years.
65
203760
2480
03:39
And if everything was there,
66
207000
1416
03:40
including organics,
67
208440
1336
03:41
perhaps life had started.
68
209800
1856
03:43
Curiosity has also
drilled in that red soil
69
211680
2896
03:46
and brought up other material.
70
214600
1976
03:48
And we were really excited
when we saw that.
71
216600
2656
03:51
Because it wasn't red Mars,
72
219280
2016
03:53
it was gray material,
73
221320
1616
03:54
it's gray Mars.
74
222960
1296
03:56
We brought it into the rover,
75
224280
1456
03:57
we tasted it,
76
225760
1616
03:59
and guess what?
77
227400
1456
04:00
We tasted organics --
78
228880
2016
04:02
carbon, hydrogen, oxygen,
79
230920
2376
04:05
nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur --
80
233320
2496
04:07
they were all there.
81
235840
1376
04:09
So Mars in its past,
82
237240
2496
04:11
with a lot of water,
83
239760
1336
04:13
perhaps plenty of time,
84
241120
1976
04:15
could have had life,
85
243120
1416
04:16
could have had that spark,
86
244560
1240
04:18
could have grown.
87
246560
1736
04:20
And is that life still there?
88
248320
2296
04:22
We don't know that.
89
250640
1976
04:24
But a few years ago
90
252640
1416
04:26
we started to look at a number of craters.
91
254080
3336
04:29
During the summer,
92
257440
1216
04:30
dark lines would appear
down the sides of these craters.
93
258680
4016
04:34
The more we looked,
94
262720
1256
04:36
the more craters we saw,
95
264000
1456
04:37
the more of these features.
96
265480
1336
04:38
We now know more than a dozen of them.
97
266840
1880
04:42
A few months ago the fairy tale came true.
98
270200
4336
04:46
We announced to the world
that we know what these streaks are.
99
274560
4096
04:50
It's liquid water.
100
278680
1600
04:53
These craters are weeping
during the summer.
101
281040
3536
04:56
Liquid water is flowing
down these craters.
102
284600
3936
05:00
So what are we going to do now --
103
288560
1736
05:02
now that we see the water?
104
290320
1440
05:04
Well, it tells us that Mars has
all the ingredients necessary for life.
105
292400
5336
05:09
In its past it had perhaps
two-thirds of its northern hemisphere --
106
297760
4576
05:14
there was an ocean.
107
302360
1496
05:15
It has weeping water right now.
108
303880
1896
05:17
Liquid water on its surface.
109
305800
1776
05:19
It has organics.
110
307600
1616
05:21
It has all the right conditions.
111
309240
2240
05:24
So what are we going to do next?
112
312103
1913
05:26
We're going to launch a series of missions
113
314040
2416
05:28
to begin that search for life on Mars.
114
316480
3776
05:32
And now it's more appealing
than ever before.
115
320280
2480
05:35
As we move out into the solar system,
116
323680
2616
05:38
here's the tiny moon Enceladus.
117
326320
2976
05:41
This is not in what we call
the traditional habitable zone,
118
329320
3376
05:44
this area around the sun.
119
332720
2216
05:46
This is much further out.
120
334960
1856
05:48
This object should be
ice over a silicate core.
121
336840
4680
05:54
But what did we find?
122
342200
1616
05:55
Cassini was there since 2006,
123
343840
2936
05:58
and after a couple years
looked back after it flew by Enceladus
124
346800
4376
06:03
and surprised us all.
125
351200
1696
06:04
Enceladus is blasting sheets of water
out into the solar system
126
352920
5776
06:10
and sloshing back down onto the moon.
127
358720
2280
06:13
What a fabulous environment.
128
361680
2256
06:15
Cassini just a few months ago
also flew through the plume,
129
363960
4816
06:20
and it measured silicate particles.
130
368800
2400
06:23
Where does the silica come from?
131
371720
1936
06:25
It must come from the ocean floor.
132
373680
2360
06:28
The tidal energy is generated by Saturn,
133
376800
3136
06:31
pulling and squeezing this moon --
134
379960
2136
06:34
is melting that ice,
135
382120
1656
06:35
creating an ocean.
136
383800
1456
06:37
But it's also doing that to the core.
137
385280
2320
06:40
Now, the only thing that we can think of
138
388280
2176
06:42
that does that here on Earth
as an analogy ...
139
390480
2840
06:46
are hydrothermal vents.
140
394040
2200
06:49
Hydrothermal vents deep in our ocean
were discovered in 1977.
141
397000
6056
06:55
Oceanographers were completely surprised.
142
403080
2760
06:58
And now there are thousands
of these below the ocean.
143
406560
3280
07:03
What do we find?
144
411200
1256
07:04
The oceanographers, when they go
and look at these hydrothermal vents,
145
412480
3336
07:07
they're teeming with life,
146
415840
1296
07:09
regardless of whether the water
is acidic or alkaline --
147
417160
4536
07:13
doesn't matter.
148
421720
1536
07:15
So hydrothermal vents are
a fabulous abode for life here on Earth.
149
423280
4720
07:20
So what about Enceladus?
150
428760
1680
07:23
Well, we believe because it has water
151
431080
2976
07:26
and has had it for
a significant period of time,
152
434080
2760
07:29
and we believe it has hydrothermal vents
153
437560
3816
07:33
with perhaps the right organic material,
154
441400
2360
07:36
it is a place where life could exist.
155
444480
4136
07:40
And not just microbial --
156
448640
1896
07:42
maybe more complex
because it's had time to evolve.
157
450560
4720
07:47
Another moon, very similar,
158
455920
2696
07:50
is Europa.
159
458640
1536
07:52
Galileo visited Jupiter's system in 1996
160
460200
5816
07:58
and made fabulous observations of Europa.
161
466040
2840
08:01
Europa, we also know,
has an under-the-ice crust ocean.
162
469600
5256
08:06
Galileo mission told us that,
but we never saw any plumes.
163
474880
4376
08:11
But we didn't look for them.
164
479280
1720
08:13
Hubble,
165
481720
1216
08:14
just a couple years ago,
166
482960
1816
08:16
observing Europa,
167
484800
2976
08:19
saw plumes of water
168
487800
1536
08:21
spraying from the cracks
in the southern hemisphere,
169
489360
2976
08:24
just exactly like Enceladus.
170
492360
3760
08:29
These moons,
171
497520
1936
08:31
which are not in what we call
a traditional habitable zone,
172
499480
3776
08:35
that are out in the solar system,
173
503280
1976
08:37
have liquid water.
174
505280
1776
08:39
And if there are organics there,
175
507080
1976
08:41
there may be life.
176
509080
1200
08:43
This is a fabulous set of discoveries
177
511000
2775
08:45
because these moons
have been in this environment like that
178
513799
4216
08:50
for billions of years.
179
518039
2201
08:53
Life started here on Earth, we believe,
after about the first 500 million,
180
521120
5240
08:58
and look where we are.
181
526920
1200
09:01
These moons are fabulous moons.
182
529280
2520
09:04
Another moon that we're
looking at is Titan.
183
532600
3280
09:08
Titan is a huge moon of Saturn.
184
536640
2096
09:10
It perhaps is much larger
than the planet Mercury.
185
538760
3520
09:14
It has an extensive atmosphere.
186
542920
2056
09:17
It's so extensive --
187
545000
1616
09:18
and it's mostly nitrogen
with a little methane and ethane --
188
546640
4576
09:23
that you have to peer
through it with radar.
189
551240
2416
09:25
And on the surface,
Cassini has found liquid.
190
553680
3480
09:29
We see lakes ...
191
557880
1480
09:32
actually almost the size
of our Black Sea in some places.
192
560200
4096
09:36
And this area is not liquid water;
193
564320
3096
09:39
it's methane.
194
567440
1240
09:41
If there's any place in the solar system
where life is not like us,
195
569920
5160
09:47
where the substitute of water
is another solvent --
196
575760
2856
09:50
and it could be methane --
197
578640
1376
09:52
it could be Titan.
198
580040
1280
09:54
Well, is there life beyond Earth
in the solar system?
199
582560
4336
09:58
We don't know yet,
200
586920
1256
10:00
but we're hot on the pursuit.
201
588200
2056
10:02
The data that we're receiving
is really exciting
202
590280
2616
10:04
and telling us --
203
592920
1376
10:06
forcing us to think about this
in new and exciting ways.
204
594320
3960
10:10
I believe we're on the right track.
205
598800
2456
10:13
That in the next 10 years,
we will answer that question.
206
601280
3856
10:17
And if we answer it,
207
605160
1936
10:19
and it's positive,
208
607120
1856
10:21
then life is everywhere
in the solar system.
209
609000
3760
10:25
Just think about that.
210
613720
1856
10:27
We may not be alone.
211
615600
1600
10:30
Thank you.
212
618240
1216
10:31
(Applause)
213
619480
7157

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
James Green - Space physicist
James Green leads NASA's solar system exploration and astrobiology research.

Why you should listen

Dr. James Green began his career at NASA 35 years ago at the Marshall Space Flight Center, where he developed and managed the Space Physics Analysis Network. It provided scientists all over the world rapid access to data and resources. As NASA's Director of Planetary Science he leads NASA's solar system exploration and astrobiology research.

Green received his Ph.D. in Space Physics from the University of Iowa in 1979 and began working in the Magnetospheric Physics Branch at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) in 1980. At Marshall, Green developed and managed the Space Physics Analysis Network that provided scientists all over the world with rapid access to data, to other scientists, and to specific NASA computer and information resources. In addition, Green was a Safety Diver in the Neutral Buoyancy tank making over 150 dives until left MSFC in 1985.

From 1985 to 1992 Green was the head of the National Space Science Data Center (NSSDC) at Goddard Space Flight Center (GSFC). The NSSDC is NASA's largest space science data archive. In 1992, he became the Chief of the Space Science Data Operations Office until 2005, when he became the Chief of the Science Proposal Support Office. While at GSFC, Green was a co-investigator and the Deputy Project Scientist on the Imager for Magnetopause-to-Aurora Global Exploration (IMAGE) mission. He has written over 100 scientific articles in refereed journals involving various aspects of the Earth's and Jupiter's magnetospheres and over 50 technical articles on various aspects of data systems and networks.

In August 2006, Green became the Director of the Planetary Science Division at NASA Headquarters. Over his career, Green has received numerous awards. In 1988, he received the Arthur S. Flemming award given for outstanding individual performance in the federal government and was awarded Japan's Kotani Prize in 1996 in recognition of his international science data management activities.

More profile about the speaker
James Green | Speaker | TED.com