TEDGlobal 2013
Didier Sornette: How we can predict the next financial crisis
Filmed:
Readability: 5.1
1,527,005 views
The 2007-2008 financial crisis, you might think, was an unpredictable one-time crash. But Didier Sornette and his Financial Crisis Observatory have plotted a set of early warning signs for unstable, growing systems, tracking the moment when any bubble is about to pop. (And he's seeing it happen again, right now.)
Didier Sornette - Risk economist
Didier Sornette studies whether it is possible to anticipate big changes or predict crises in complex systems. Full bio
Didier Sornette studies whether it is possible to anticipate big changes or predict crises in complex systems. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Once upon a time
0
818
1510
00:14
we lived in an economy of financial growth and prosperity.
1
2328
6651
00:20
This was called the Great Moderation,
2
8979
3695
00:24
the misguided belief by most economists,
3
12674
3406
00:28
policymakers and central banks
4
16080
3303
00:31
that we have transformed into a new world
5
19383
3331
00:34
of never-ending growth and prosperity.
6
22714
3857
00:38
This was seen by robust and steady GDP growth,
7
26571
4743
00:43
by low and controlled inflation,
8
31314
3000
00:46
by low unemployment,
9
34314
2239
00:48
and controlled and low financial volatility.
10
36553
3906
00:52
But the Great Recession in 2007 and 2008,
11
40459
6632
00:59
the great crash, broke this illusion.
12
47091
3479
01:02
A few hundred billion dollars of losses in the financial sector
13
50570
5024
01:07
cascaded into five trillion dollars
14
55594
4080
01:11
of losses in world GDP
15
59674
1884
01:13
and almost $30 trillion losses
16
61558
3803
01:17
in the global stock market.
17
65361
3945
01:21
So the understanding of this Great Recession
18
69306
5195
01:26
was that this was completely surprising,
19
74501
5361
01:31
this came out of the blue,
20
79862
1346
01:33
this was like the wrath of the gods.
21
81208
2917
01:36
There was no responsibility.
22
84125
1791
01:37
So, as a reflection of this,
23
85916
1923
01:39
we started the Financial Crisis Observatory.
24
87839
3609
01:43
We had the goal to diagnose in real time
25
91448
3938
01:47
financial bubbles
26
95386
2371
01:49
and identify in advance their critical time.
27
97757
5857
01:55
What is the underpinning, scientifically, of this financial observatory?
28
103614
3358
01:58
We developed a theory called "dragon-kings."
29
106972
4626
02:03
Dragon-kings represent extreme events
30
111598
3206
02:06
which are of a class of their own.
31
114804
3272
02:10
They are special. They are outliers.
32
118076
2843
02:12
They are generated by specific mechanisms
33
120919
3440
02:16
that may make them predictable,
34
124359
2886
02:19
perhaps controllable.
35
127245
2898
02:22
Consider the financial price time series,
36
130143
3827
02:25
a given stock, your perfect stock,
37
133970
2173
02:28
or a global index.
38
136143
2352
02:30
You have these up-and-downs.
39
138495
2054
02:32
A very good measure of the risk of this financial market
40
140549
3562
02:36
is the peaks-to-valleys that represent
41
144111
2422
02:38
a worst case scenario
42
146533
2296
02:40
when you bought at the top and sold at the bottom.
43
148829
3673
02:44
You can look at the statistics, the frequency of the occurrence
44
152502
3749
02:48
of peak-to-valleys of different sizes,
45
156251
2355
02:50
which is represented in this graph.
46
158606
2551
02:53
Now, interestingly, 99 percent
47
161157
3032
02:56
of the peak-to-valleys of different amplitudes
48
164189
3793
02:59
can be represented by a universal power law
49
167982
3460
03:03
represented by this red line here.
50
171442
3451
03:06
More interestingly, there are outliers, there are exceptions
51
174893
4146
03:11
which are above this red line,
52
179039
1903
03:12
occur 100 times more frequently, at least,
53
180942
3759
03:16
than the extrapolation would predict them to occur
54
184701
4153
03:20
based on the calibration of the 99 percent remaining
55
188854
3937
03:24
peak-to-valleys.
56
192791
2249
03:27
They are due to trenchant dependancies
57
195040
4600
03:31
such that a loss is followed by a loss
58
199640
3512
03:35
which is followed by a loss which is followed by a loss.
59
203152
2963
03:38
These kinds of dependencies
60
206115
3111
03:41
are largely missed by standard risk management tools,
61
209226
5612
03:46
which ignore them and see lizards
62
214838
2929
03:49
when they should see dragon-kings.
63
217767
3819
03:53
The root mechanism of a dragon-king
64
221586
3917
03:57
is a slow maturation towards instability,
65
225503
3136
04:00
which is the bubble,
66
228639
1622
04:02
and the climax of the bubble is often the crash.
67
230261
2630
04:04
This is similar to the slow heating of water
68
232891
3625
04:08
in this test tube reaching the boiling point,
69
236516
2903
04:11
where the instability of the water occurs
70
239419
2490
04:13
and you have the phase transition to vapor.
71
241909
3337
04:17
And this process, which is absolutely non-linear --
72
245246
3677
04:20
cannot be predicted by standard techniques --
73
248923
2280
04:23
is the reflection of a collective emergent behavior
74
251203
4176
04:27
which is fundamentally endogenous.
75
255379
2379
04:29
So the cause of the crash, the cause of the crisis
76
257758
3213
04:32
has to be found in an inner instability of the system,
77
260971
3184
04:36
and any tiny perturbation will make this instability occur.
78
264155
6036
04:42
Now, some of you may have come to the mind
79
270191
3700
04:45
that is this not related to the black swan concept
80
273891
2625
04:48
you have heard about frequently?
81
276516
2935
04:51
Remember, black swan is this rare bird
82
279451
2417
04:53
that you see once and suddenly shattered your belief
83
281868
3409
04:57
that all swans should be white,
84
285277
2474
04:59
so it has captured the idea of unpredictability,
85
287751
3544
05:03
unknowability, that the extreme events
86
291295
1509
05:04
are fundamentally unknowable.
87
292804
2831
05:07
Nothing can be further
88
295635
1725
05:09
from the dragon-king concept I propose,
89
297360
2638
05:11
which is exactly the opposite, that most extreme events
90
299998
3718
05:15
are actually knowable and predictable.
91
303716
3223
05:18
So we can be empowered and take responsibility
92
306939
3505
05:22
and make predictions about them.
93
310444
2219
05:24
So let's have my dragon-king burn this black swan concept.
94
312663
3200
05:27
(Laughter)
95
315863
1626
05:29
There are many early warning signals
96
317489
2940
05:32
that are predicted by this theory.
97
320429
1879
05:34
Let me just focus on one of them:
98
322308
2367
05:36
the super-exponential growth with positive feedback.
99
324675
3152
05:39
What does it mean?
100
327827
1160
05:40
Imagine you have an investment
101
328987
2173
05:43
that returns the first year five percent,
102
331160
3154
05:46
the second year 10 percent, the third year 20 percent,
103
334314
3155
05:49
the next year 40 percent. Is that not marvelous?
104
337469
2542
05:52
This is a super-exponential growth.
105
340011
3398
05:55
A standard exponential growth corresponds
106
343409
1937
05:57
to a constant growth rate, let's say, of 10 percent
107
345346
3744
06:01
The point is that, many times during bubbles,
108
349090
3481
06:04
there are positive feedbacks which can be of many times,
109
352571
3597
06:08
such that previous growths enhance,
110
356168
3699
06:11
push forward, increase the next growth
111
359867
3488
06:15
through this kind of super-exponential growth,
112
363355
2502
06:17
which is very trenchant, not sustainable.
113
365857
3114
06:20
And the key idea is that the mathematical solution
114
368971
3057
06:24
of this class of models exhibit finite-time singularities,
115
372028
3638
06:27
which means that there is a critical time
116
375666
3353
06:31
where the system will break, will change regime.
117
379019
3204
06:34
It may be a crash. It may be just a plateau, something else.
118
382223
3276
06:37
And the key idea is that the critical time,
119
385499
2267
06:39
the information about the critical time is contained
120
387766
2529
06:42
in the early development of this super-exponential growth.
121
390295
5484
06:47
We have applied this theory early on, that was our first success,
122
395779
4360
06:52
to the diagnostic of the rupture of key elements
123
400139
3559
06:55
on the iron rocket.
124
403698
2529
06:58
Using acoustic emission, you know, this little noise
125
406227
2822
07:01
that you hear a structure emit, sing to you
126
409049
2297
07:03
when they are stressed, and reveal the damage going on,
127
411346
3691
07:07
there's a collective phenomenon of positive feedback,
128
415037
2440
07:09
the more damage gives the more damage,
129
417477
1697
07:11
so you can actually predict,
130
419174
2475
07:13
within, of course, a probability band,
131
421649
2140
07:15
when the rupture will occur.
132
423789
1913
07:17
So this is now so successful that it is used
133
425702
2435
07:20
in the initial phase of [unclear] the flight.
134
428137
4365
07:24
Perhaps more surprisingly, the same type of theory
135
432502
2807
07:27
applies to biology and medicine,
136
435309
2728
07:30
parturition, the act of giving birth, epileptic seizures.
137
438037
3696
07:33
From seven months of pregnancy, a mother
138
441733
3624
07:37
starts to feel episodic precursory contractions of the uterus
139
445357
5664
07:43
that are the sign of these maturations
140
451021
4104
07:47
toward the instability, giving birth to the baby,
141
455125
3424
07:50
the dragon-king.
142
458549
2371
07:52
So if you measure the precursor signal,
143
460920
2606
07:55
you can actually identify pre- and post-maturity problems
144
463526
6225
08:01
in advance.
145
469751
1471
08:03
Epileptic seizures also come in a large variety of size,
146
471222
3760
08:06
and when the brain goes to a super-critical state,
147
474982
3280
08:10
you have dragon-kings which have a degree of predictability
148
478262
3573
08:13
and this can help the patient to deal with this illness.
149
481835
5507
08:19
We have applied this theory to many systems,
150
487342
2185
08:21
landslides, glacier collapse,
151
489527
2855
08:24
even to the dynamics of prediction of success:
152
492382
3567
08:27
blockbusters, YouTube videos, movies, and so on.
153
495949
4386
08:32
But perhaps the most important application
154
500335
3136
08:35
is for finance, and this theory
155
503471
2366
08:37
illuminates, I believe, the deep reason
156
505837
3439
08:41
for the financial crisis that we have gone through.
157
509276
2696
08:43
This is rooted in 30 years of history of bubbles,
158
511972
4048
08:48
starting in 1980, with the global bubble
159
516020
3712
08:51
crashing in 1987,
160
519732
2087
08:53
followed by many other bubbles.
161
521819
2369
08:56
The biggest one was the "new economy" Internet bubble
162
524188
2712
08:58
in 2000, crashing in 2000,
163
526900
1925
09:00
the real estate bubbles in many countries,
164
528825
2048
09:02
financial derivative bubbles everywhere,
165
530873
2780
09:05
stock market bubbles also everywhere,
166
533653
2289
09:07
commodity and all bubbles, debt and credit bubbles --
167
535942
3951
09:11
bubbles, bubbles, bubbles.
168
539893
2713
09:14
We had a global bubble.
169
542606
2639
09:17
This is a measure of global overvaluation
170
545245
4241
09:21
of all markets, expressing what I call
171
549486
4006
09:25
an illusion of a perpetual money machine
172
553508
3169
09:28
that suddenly broke in 2007.
173
556677
3952
09:32
The problem is that we see the same process,
174
560629
4234
09:36
in particular through quantitative easing,
175
564863
2731
09:39
of a thinking of a perpetual money machine nowadays
176
567594
3184
09:42
to tackle the crisis since 2008 in the U.S., in Europe,
177
570778
4403
09:47
in Japan.
178
575181
2288
09:49
This has very important implications
179
577469
2390
09:51
to understand the failure of quantitative easing
180
579859
4078
09:55
as well as austerity measures
181
583937
1876
09:57
as long as we don't attack the core,
182
585813
2809
10:00
the structural cause of this perpetual money machine thinking.
183
588622
5191
10:05
Now, these are big claims.
184
593813
2616
10:08
Why would you believe me?
185
596429
2882
10:11
Well, perhaps because, in the last 15 years
186
599311
2880
10:14
we have come out of our ivory tower,
187
602191
3192
10:17
and started to publish ex ante --
188
605383
2736
10:20
and I stress the term ex ante, it means "in advance" —
189
608119
3328
10:23
before the crash confirmed
190
611447
2138
10:25
the existence of the bubble or the financial excesses.
191
613585
2686
10:28
These are a few of the major bubbles
192
616271
3722
10:31
that we have lived through in recent history.
193
619993
4478
10:36
Again, many interesting stories for each of them.
194
624471
2840
10:39
Let me tell you just one or two stories
195
627311
2714
10:42
that deal with massive bubbles.
196
630025
2046
10:44
We all know the Chinese miracle.
197
632071
2336
10:46
This is the expression of the stock market
198
634407
3070
10:49
of a massive bubble, a factor of three,
199
637477
2880
10:52
300 percent in just a few years.
200
640357
2170
10:54
In September 2007,
201
642527
3202
10:57
I was invited as a keynote speaker of a macro hedge fund
202
645729
3647
11:01
management conference,
203
649376
2449
11:03
and I showed to the conference a prediction
204
651825
4055
11:07
that by the end of 2007, this bubble
205
655880
4193
11:12
would change regime.
206
660073
1969
11:14
There might be a crash. Certainly not sustainable.
207
662042
3085
11:17
Now, how do you believe the very smart,
208
665127
5242
11:22
very motivated, very informed macro hedge fund managers
209
670369
5430
11:27
reacted to this prediction?
210
675799
1956
11:29
You know, they had made billions
211
677755
1956
11:31
just surfing this bubble until now.
212
679711
2835
11:34
They told me, "Didier,
213
682546
1584
11:36
yeah, the market might be overvalued,
214
684130
3037
11:39
but you forget something.
215
687167
1896
11:41
There is the Beijing Olympic Games coming
216
689063
2352
11:43
in August 2008, and it's very clear that
217
691415
2264
11:45
the Chinese government is controlling the economy
218
693679
3192
11:48
and doing what it takes
219
696871
1353
11:50
to also avoid any wave and control the stock market."
220
698224
4447
11:54
Three weeks after my presentation,
221
702671
2471
11:57
the markets lost 20 percent
222
705142
2126
11:59
and went through a phase of volatility,
223
707268
2261
12:01
upheaval, and a total market loss of
224
709529
2726
12:04
70 percent until the end of the year.
225
712255
2268
12:06
So how can we be so collectively wrong
226
714523
2876
12:09
by misreading or ignoring the science
227
717399
4142
12:13
of the fact that when an instability has developed,
228
721541
2831
12:16
and the system is ripe, any perturbation
229
724372
2451
12:18
makes it essentially impossible to control?
230
726823
3681
12:22
The Chinese market collapsed, but it rebounded.
231
730504
4705
12:27
In 2009, we also identified that this new bubble,
232
735209
4756
12:31
a smaller one, was unsustainable,
233
739965
2586
12:34
so we published again a prediction, in advance,
234
742551
3632
12:38
stating that by August 2009, the market will correct,
235
746183
4327
12:42
will not continue on this track.
236
750510
2681
12:45
Our critics, reading the prediction,
237
753191
3152
12:48
said, "No, it's not possible.
238
756343
3913
12:52
The Chinese government is there.
239
760256
1494
12:53
They have learned their lesson. They will control.
240
761750
2682
12:56
They want to benefit from the growth."
241
764432
1807
12:58
Perhaps these critics have not learned their lesson previously.
242
766239
3656
13:01
So the crisis did occur. The market corrected.
243
769895
3832
13:05
The same critics then said, "Ah, yes,
244
773727
2336
13:08
but you published your prediction.
245
776063
1849
13:09
You influenced the market.
246
777912
1656
13:11
It was not a prediction."
247
779568
3133
13:14
Maybe I am very powerful then.
248
782701
3357
13:18
Now, this is interesting.
249
786058
2044
13:20
It shows that it's essentially impossible until now
250
788102
2937
13:23
to develop a science of economics
251
791039
2128
13:25
because we are sentient beings who anticipate
252
793167
3143
13:28
and there is a problem of self-fulfilling prophesies.
253
796310
4063
13:32
So we invented a new way of doing science.
254
800373
3733
13:36
We created the Financial Bubble Experiment.
255
804106
2712
13:38
The idea is the following. We monitor the markets.
256
806818
2672
13:41
We identify excesses, bubbles.
257
809490
4168
13:45
We do our work. We write a report
258
813658
3304
13:48
in which we put our prediction of the critical time.
259
816962
4272
13:53
We don't release the report. It's kept secret.
260
821234
2575
13:55
But with modern encrypting techniques,
261
823809
2865
13:58
we have a hash, we publish a public key,
262
826674
4022
14:02
and six months later, we release the report,
263
830696
3955
14:06
and there is authentication.
264
834651
2399
14:09
And all this is done on an international archive
265
837050
4768
14:13
so that we cannot be accused of just releasing the successes.
266
841818
4200
14:18
Let me tease you with a very recent analysis.
267
846018
3392
14:21
17th of May, 2013, just two weeks ago,
268
849410
3258
14:24
we identified that the U.S. stock market
269
852668
1678
14:26
was on an unsustainable path
270
854346
2392
14:28
and we released this on our website on the 21st of May
271
856738
3802
14:32
that there will be a change of regime.
272
860540
2045
14:34
The next day, the market started to change regime, course.
273
862585
4784
14:39
This is not a crash.
274
867369
1491
14:40
This is just the third or fourth act
275
868860
2599
14:43
of a massive bubble in the making.
276
871459
2863
14:46
Scaling up the discussion at the size of the planet,
277
874322
3096
14:49
we see the same thing.
278
877418
1025
14:50
Wherever we look, it's observable:
279
878443
2921
14:53
in the biosphere, in the atmosphere, in the ocean,
280
881364
3230
14:56
showing these super-exponential trajectories
281
884594
3904
15:00
characterizing an unsustainable path
282
888498
2631
15:03
and announcing a phase transition.
283
891129
2617
15:05
This diagram on the right
284
893746
1704
15:07
shows a very beautiful compilation of studies
285
895450
3000
15:10
suggesting indeed that there is a nonlinear -- possibility
286
898450
3710
15:14
for a nonlinear transition just in the next few decades.
287
902160
4149
15:18
So there are bubbles everywhere.
288
906309
3622
15:21
From one side, this is exciting
289
909931
1964
15:23
for me, as a professor who chases bubbles
290
911895
2760
15:26
and slays dragons, as the media has sometimes called me.
291
914655
4758
15:31
But can we really slay the dragons?
292
919413
3051
15:34
Very recently, with collaborators,
293
922464
2144
15:36
we studied a dynamical system
294
924608
2703
15:39
where you see the dragon-king as these big loops
295
927311
2904
15:42
and we were able to apply tiny perturbations at the right times
296
930215
3921
15:46
that removed, when control is on, these dragons.
297
934136
4935
15:51
"Gouverner, c'est prévoir."
298
939071
2934
15:54
Governing is the art of planning and predicting.
299
942005
5794
15:59
But is it not the case that this is probably
300
947799
2753
16:02
one of the biggest gaps of mankind,
301
950552
3900
16:06
which has the responsibility to steer
302
954452
3260
16:09
our societies and our planet toward sustainability
303
957712
2703
16:12
in the face of growing challenges and crises?
304
960428
4844
16:17
But the dragon-king theory gives hope.
305
965272
4495
16:21
We learn that most systems have pockets of predictability.
306
969767
3568
16:25
It is possible to develop advance diagnostics of crises
307
973335
4900
16:30
so that we can be prepared, we can take measures,
308
978235
3559
16:33
we can take responsibility,
309
981794
2755
16:36
and so that never again will
310
984549
2747
16:39
extremes and crises like the Great Recession
311
987296
3854
16:43
or the European crisis take us by surprise.
312
991150
4410
16:47
Thank you.
313
995560
1475
16:49
(Applause)
314
997035
6293
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Didier Sornette - Risk economistDidier Sornette studies whether it is possible to anticipate big changes or predict crises in complex systems.
Why you should listen
While financial crashes, recessions, earthquakes and other extreme events appear chaotic, Didier Sornette's research is focused on finding out whether they are, in fact, predictable. They may happen often as a surprise, he suggests, but they don't come out of the blue: the most extreme risks (and gains) are what he calls "dragon kings" that almost always result from a visible drift toward a critical instability. In his hypothesis, this instability has measurable technical and/or socio-economical precursors. As he says: "Crises are not external shocks."
An expert on complex systems, Sornette is the chair of entrepreneurial risk at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, and director of the Financial Crisis Observatory, a project to test the hypothesis that markets can be predictable, especially during bubbles. He's the author of Why Stock Markets Crash: Critical Events in Complex Financial Systems.
Didier Sornette | Speaker | TED.com