TED2014
Mellody Hobson: Color blind or color brave?
Filmed:
Readability: 3.6
3,917,414 views
The subject of race can be very touchy. As finance executive Mellody Hobson says, it's a "conversational third rail." But, she says, that's exactly why we need to start talking about it. In this engaging, persuasive talk, Hobson makes the case that speaking openly about race — and particularly about diversity in hiring -- makes for better businesses and a better society.
Mellody Hobson - Investment expert
Mellody Hobson is president of Ariel Investments, a value-driven money management firm -- and an advocate for financial literacy and investor education. Full bio
Mellody Hobson is president of Ariel Investments, a value-driven money management firm -- and an advocate for financial literacy and investor education. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
So it's 2006.
0
739
2030
00:14
My friend Harold Ford calls me.
1
2769
2130
00:16
He's running for U.S. Senate in Tennessee,
2
4899
3665
00:20
and he says, "Mellody, I desperately need some national press. Do you have any ideas?"
3
8564
4587
00:25
So I had an idea. I called a friend
4
13151
1979
00:27
who was in New York
5
15130
1152
00:28
at one of the most successful
media companies in the world,
media companies in the world,
6
16282
3389
00:31
and she said, "Why don't we host
7
19671
2086
00:33
an editorial board lunch for Harold?
8
21757
2246
00:36
You come with him."
9
24003
1595
00:37
Harold and I arrive in New York.
10
25598
1745
00:39
We are in our best suits.
11
27343
2015
00:41
We look like shiny new pennies.
12
29358
2215
00:43
And we get to the receptionist, and we say,
13
31573
2521
00:46
"We're here for the lunch."
14
34094
1380
00:47
She motions for us to follow her.
15
35474
2204
00:49
We walk through a series of corridors,
16
37678
2442
00:52
and all of a sudden we find ourselves
17
40120
1254
00:53
in a stark room,
18
41374
1666
00:55
at which point she looks at us and she says,
19
43040
3090
00:58
"Where are your uniforms?"
20
46130
4285
01:02
Just as this happens,
21
50415
1246
01:03
my friend rushes in.
22
51661
2329
01:05
The blood drains from her face.
23
53990
2448
01:08
There are literally no words, right?
24
56438
2382
01:10
And I look at her, and I say,
25
58820
1019
01:11
"Now, don't you think we need
26
59839
1890
01:13
more than one black person in the U.S. Senate?"
27
61729
4071
01:17
Now Harold and I --
28
65800
2028
01:19
(Applause) —
29
67828
2518
01:22
we still laugh about that story,
30
70346
3089
01:25
and in many ways, the moment caught me off guard,
31
73435
3436
01:28
but deep, deep down inside,
32
76871
3020
01:31
I actually wasn't surprised.
33
79891
2124
01:34
And I wasn't surprised because of something
34
82015
1423
01:35
my mother taught me about 30 years before.
35
83438
3136
01:38
You see, my mother was ruthlessly realistic.
36
86574
3415
01:41
I remember one day coming
home from a birthday party
home from a birthday party
37
89989
1992
01:43
where I was the only black kid invited,
38
91981
1839
01:45
and instead of asking me the
normal motherly questions
normal motherly questions
39
93820
2677
01:48
like, "Did you have fun?" or "How was the cake?"
40
96497
2984
01:51
my mother looked at me and she said,
41
99481
2177
01:53
"How did they treat you?"
42
101658
2232
01:55
I was seven. I did not understand.
43
103890
2767
01:58
I mean, why would anyone treat me differently?
44
106657
3283
02:01
But she knew.
45
109940
1125
02:03
And she looked me right in the eye and she said,
46
111065
2672
02:05
"They will not always treat you well."
47
113737
3175
02:08
Now, race is one of those topics in America
48
116912
2346
02:11
that makes people extraordinarily uncomfortable.
49
119258
3478
02:14
You bring it up at a dinner party
50
122736
1654
02:16
or in a workplace environment,
51
124390
1645
02:18
it is literally the conversational equivalent
52
126035
3180
02:21
of touching the third rail.
53
129215
1875
02:23
There is shock,
54
131090
1175
02:24
followed by a long silence.
55
132265
2965
02:27
And even coming here today,
56
135230
1654
02:28
I told some friends and colleagues
57
136884
1151
02:30
that I planned to talk about race,
58
138035
1566
02:31
and they warned me, they told me, don't do it,
59
139601
2659
02:34
that there'd be huge risks
60
142260
1887
02:36
in me talking about this topic,
61
144147
1530
02:37
that people might think I'm a militant black woman
62
145677
2491
02:40
and I would ruin my career.
63
148168
2184
02:42
And I have to tell you,
64
150352
1291
02:43
I actually for a moment was a bit afraid.
65
151643
2457
02:46
Then I realized,
66
154100
2070
02:48
the first step to solving any problem
67
156170
2479
02:50
is to not hide from it,
68
158649
1791
02:52
and the first step to any form of action
69
160440
3982
02:56
is awareness.
70
164422
2055
02:58
And so I decided to actually talk about race.
71
166477
3440
03:01
And I decided that if I came
here and shared with you
here and shared with you
72
169917
2873
03:04
some of my experiences,
73
172790
2184
03:06
that maybe we could all be a little less anxious
74
174974
2688
03:09
and a little more bold
75
177662
1546
03:11
in our conversations about race.
76
179208
2902
03:14
Now I know there are people out there who will say
77
182110
1990
03:16
that the election of Barack Obama meant
78
184100
1626
03:17
that it was the end of racial discrimination
79
185726
2799
03:20
for all eternity, right?
80
188525
2022
03:22
But I work in the investment business,
81
190547
1643
03:24
and we have a saying:
82
192190
1460
03:25
The numbers do not lie.
83
193650
2055
03:27
And here, there are significant,
84
195705
2614
03:30
quantifiable racial disparities
85
198319
2721
03:33
that cannot be ignored,
86
201040
1519
03:34
in household wealth, household income,
87
202559
3583
03:38
job opportunities, healthcare.
88
206142
2999
03:41
One example from corporate America:
89
209141
2487
03:43
Even though white men
90
211628
2005
03:45
make up just 30 percent of the U.S. population,
91
213633
3791
03:49
they hold 70 percent of all corporate board seats.
92
217424
4399
03:53
Of the Fortune 250,
93
221823
2278
03:56
there are only seven CEOs that are minorities,
94
224101
3843
03:59
and of the thousands of publicly
traded companies today, thousands,
traded companies today, thousands,
95
227944
4266
04:04
only two are chaired by black women,
96
232210
2826
04:07
and you're looking at one of them,
97
235036
1805
04:08
the same one who, not too long ago,
98
236841
2152
04:10
was nearly mistaken for kitchen help.
99
238993
2857
04:13
So that is a fact.
100
241850
1174
04:15
Now I have this thought experiment
101
243024
2188
04:17
that I play with myself, when I say,
102
245212
2527
04:19
imagine if I walked you into a room
103
247739
2259
04:21
and it was of a major corporation, like ExxonMobil,
104
249998
3259
04:25
and every single person around
the boardroom were black,
the boardroom were black,
105
253257
3610
04:28
you would think that were weird.
106
256867
2533
04:31
But if I walked you into a Fortune 500 company,
107
259400
2804
04:34
and everyone around the table is a white male,
108
262204
2123
04:36
when will it be that we think that's weird too?
109
264327
3099
04:39
And I know how we got here.
110
267426
1714
04:41
(Applause)
111
269140
4163
04:45
I know how we got here.
112
273303
1768
04:47
You know, there was institutionalized,
113
275071
2686
04:49
at one time legalized, discrimination in our country.
114
277757
3109
04:52
There's no question about it.
115
280866
2294
04:55
But still, as I grapple with this issue,
116
283160
2825
04:57
my mother's question hangs in the air for me:
117
285985
2525
05:00
How did they treat you?
118
288510
2083
05:02
Now, I do not raise this issue to complain
119
290593
2476
05:05
or in any way to elicit any kind of sympathy.
120
293069
2246
05:07
I have succeeded in my life
121
295315
1983
05:09
beyond my wildest expectations,
122
297298
2842
05:12
and I have been treated well by people of all races
123
300140
2965
05:15
more often than I have not.
124
303105
2236
05:17
I tell the uniform story because it happened.
125
305341
2813
05:20
I cite those statistics around
corporate board diversity
corporate board diversity
126
308154
2620
05:22
because they are real,
127
310774
1664
05:24
and I stand here today
128
312438
1664
05:26
talking about this issue of racial discrimination
129
314102
2590
05:28
because I believe it threatens to rob
130
316692
2495
05:31
another generation of all the opportunities
131
319187
3286
05:34
that all of us want for all of our children,
132
322473
2585
05:37
no matter what their color
133
325058
1763
05:38
or where they come from.
134
326821
1799
05:40
And I think it also threatens to hold back businesses.
135
328620
3578
05:44
You see, researchers have coined this term
136
332198
2801
05:46
"color blindness"
137
334999
1835
05:48
to describe a learned behavior where we pretend
138
336834
2675
05:51
that we don't notice race.
139
339509
1845
05:53
If you happen to be surrounded by a bunch of people
140
341354
2160
05:55
who look like you, that's purely accidental.
141
343514
3776
05:59
Now, color blindness, in my view,
142
347290
2100
06:01
doesn't mean that there's no racial discrimination,
143
349390
2858
06:04
and there's fairness.
144
352248
1695
06:05
It doesn't mean that at all. It doesn't ensure it.
145
353943
2147
06:08
In my view, color blindness is very dangerous
146
356090
2398
06:10
because it means we're ignoring the problem.
147
358488
2757
06:13
There was a corporate study that said that,
148
361245
2530
06:15
instead of avoiding race,
149
363775
1777
06:17
the really smart corporations
actually deal with it head on.
actually deal with it head on.
150
365552
3972
06:21
They actually recognize that embracing diversity
151
369524
2784
06:24
means recognizing all races,
152
372308
2999
06:27
including the majority one.
153
375307
2362
06:29
But I'll be the first one to tell you,
154
377669
1796
06:31
this subject matter can be hard,
155
379465
2841
06:34
awkward, uncomfortable -- but that's kind of the point.
156
382306
4052
06:38
In the spirit of debunking racial stereotypes,
157
386358
3022
06:41
the one that black people don't like to swim,
158
389380
2175
06:43
I'm going to tell you how much I love to swim.
159
391555
3230
06:46
I love to swim so much
160
394785
2287
06:49
that as an adult, I swim with a coach.
161
397072
2132
06:51
And one day my coach had me do a drill
162
399204
2837
06:54
where I had to swim to one end of a 25-meter pool
163
402041
2611
06:56
without taking a breath.
164
404652
1888
06:58
And every single time I failed,
165
406540
2141
07:00
I had to start over.
166
408681
1337
07:02
And I failed a lot.
167
410018
1513
07:03
By the end, I got it, but when I got out of the pool,
168
411531
1867
07:05
I was exasperated and tired and annoyed,
169
413398
2623
07:08
and I said, "Why are we doing
breath-holding exercises?"
breath-holding exercises?"
170
416021
3938
07:11
And my coach looked me
at me, and he said, "Mellody,
at me, and he said, "Mellody,
171
419959
2166
07:14
that was not a breath-holding exercise.
172
422125
2991
07:17
That drill was to make you comfortable
173
425116
2349
07:19
being uncomfortable,
174
427465
1793
07:21
because that's how most of us spend our days."
175
429258
3131
07:24
If we can learn to deal with our discomfort,
176
432389
2266
07:26
and just relax into it,
177
434655
2034
07:28
we'll have a better life.
178
436689
2224
07:30
So I think it's time for us to be comfortable
179
438913
2553
07:33
with the uncomfortable conversation about race:
180
441466
3246
07:36
black, white, Asian, Hispanic,
181
444712
2676
07:39
male, female, all of us,
182
447388
2273
07:41
if we truly believe in equal rights
183
449661
2276
07:43
and equal opportunity in America,
184
451937
2011
07:45
I think we have to have real conversations
185
453948
3003
07:48
about this issue.
186
456951
1252
07:50
We cannot afford to be color blind.
187
458203
2772
07:52
We have to be color brave.
188
460975
3247
07:56
We have to be willing, as teachers and parents
189
464222
4038
08:00
and entrepreneurs and scientists,
190
468260
1830
08:02
we have to be willing to have
191
470090
1283
08:03
proactive conversations about race
192
471373
2837
08:06
with honesty and understanding and courage,
193
474210
3139
08:09
not because it's the right thing to do,
194
477349
3539
08:12
but because it's the smart thing to do,
195
480888
2273
08:15
because our businesses and our products
196
483161
2383
08:17
and our science, our research,
197
485544
2054
08:19
all of that will be better with greater diversity.
198
487598
3637
08:23
Now, my favorite example of color bravery
199
491235
2955
08:26
is a guy named John Skipper.
200
494190
1458
08:27
He runs ESPN.
201
495648
1852
08:29
He's a North Carolina native,
202
497500
2330
08:31
quintessential Southern gentleman, white.
203
499830
3047
08:34
He joined ESPN, which already had a culture
204
502877
2411
08:37
of inclusion and diversity, but he took it up a notch.
205
505288
2773
08:40
He demanded that every open position
206
508061
2588
08:42
have a diverse slate of candidates.
207
510649
2950
08:45
Now he says the senior people
208
513599
1799
08:47
in the beginning bristled,
209
515398
1812
08:49
and they would come to him and say,
210
517210
2050
08:51
"Do you want me to hire the minority,
211
519260
2608
08:53
or do you want me to hire
the best person for the job?"
the best person for the job?"
212
521868
3618
08:57
And Skipper says his answers were always the same:
213
525486
3659
09:01
"Yes."
214
529145
1675
09:02
And by saying yes to diversity,
215
530820
1810
09:04
I honestly believe that ESPN
216
532630
2362
09:06
is the most valuable cable franchise in the world.
217
534992
2490
09:09
I think that's a part of the secret sauce.
218
537482
2446
09:11
Now I can tell you, in my own industry,
219
539928
2042
09:13
at Ariel Investments, we actually view our diversity
220
541970
2175
09:16
as a competitive advantage,
221
544145
2160
09:18
and that advantage can extend
way beyond business.
way beyond business.
222
546305
3321
09:21
There's a guy named Scott Page
at the University of Michigan.
at the University of Michigan.
223
549626
2184
09:23
He is the first person to develop
224
551810
1729
09:25
a mathematical calculation for diversity.
225
553539
3040
09:28
He says, if you're trying to
solve a really hard problem,
solve a really hard problem,
226
556579
2291
09:30
really hard,
227
558870
1161
09:32
that you should have a diverse group of people,
228
560031
2829
09:34
including those with diverse intellects.
229
562860
3010
09:37
The example that he gives is the smallpox epidemic.
230
565870
2853
09:40
When it was ravaging Europe,
231
568723
2925
09:43
they brought together all these scientists,
232
571648
1380
09:45
and they were stumped.
233
573028
1462
09:46
And the beginnings of the cure to the disease
234
574490
3092
09:49
came from the most unlikely source,
235
577582
2193
09:51
a dairy farmer who noticed that the milkmaids
236
579775
4380
09:56
were not getting smallpox.
237
584155
1909
09:58
And the smallpox vaccination is bovine-based
238
586064
3354
10:01
because of that dairy farmer.
239
589418
2402
10:03
Now I'm sure you're sitting here and you're saying,
240
591820
2412
10:06
I don't run a cable company,
241
594232
2095
10:08
I don't run an investment firm,
242
596327
2122
10:10
I am not a dairy farmer.
243
598449
1451
10:11
What can I do?
244
599900
1450
10:13
And I'm telling you, you can be color brave.
245
601350
3516
10:16
If you're part of a hiring process
246
604866
1884
10:18
or an admissions process,
247
606750
1640
10:20
you can be color brave.
248
608390
1667
10:22
If you are trying to solve a really hard problem,
249
610057
2844
10:24
you can speak up and be color brave.
250
612901
2779
10:27
Now I know people will say,
251
615680
3249
10:30
but that doesn't add up to a lot,
252
618929
2150
10:33
but I'm actually asking you
to do something really simple:
to do something really simple:
253
621079
2971
10:36
observe your environment,
254
624050
2218
10:38
at work, at school, at home.
255
626268
3802
10:42
I'm asking you to look at the people around you
256
630080
2349
10:44
purposefully and intentionally.
257
632429
2621
10:47
Invite people into your life
258
635050
1443
10:48
who don't look like you, don't think like you,
259
636493
2836
10:51
don't act like you,
260
639329
1295
10:52
don't come from where you come from,
261
640624
1961
10:54
and you might find that they
will challenge your assumptions
will challenge your assumptions
262
642585
2650
10:57
and make you grow as a person.
263
645235
1756
10:58
You might get powerful new insights
264
646991
2340
11:01
from these individuals,
265
649331
1623
11:02
or, like my husband, who happens to be white,
266
650954
3186
11:06
you might learn that black people,
267
654140
2070
11:08
men, women, children,
268
656210
1557
11:09
we use body lotion every single day.
269
657767
2889
11:12
Now, I also think that this is very important
270
660656
4622
11:17
so that the next generation really understands
271
665278
2972
11:20
that this progress will help them,
272
668250
1510
11:21
because they're expecting
us to be great role models.
us to be great role models.
273
669760
3134
11:24
Now, I told you, my mother,
274
672894
1477
11:26
she was ruthlessly realistic.
275
674371
1571
11:27
She was an unbelievable role model.
276
675942
3240
11:31
She was the kind of person
277
679182
1131
11:32
who got to be the way she was
278
680313
1322
11:33
because she was a single mom
279
681635
1976
11:35
with six kids in Chicago.
280
683611
1672
11:37
She was in the real estate business,
281
685283
1792
11:39
where she worked extraordinarily hard
282
687075
2750
11:41
but oftentimes had a hard time making ends meet.
283
689825
3268
11:45
And that meant sometimes we got
284
693093
1847
11:46
our phone disconnected,
285
694940
1380
11:48
or our lights turned off,
286
696320
868
11:49
or we got evicted.
287
697188
1941
11:51
When we got evicted, sometimes we lived
288
699129
1541
11:52
in these small apartments that she owned,
289
700670
1806
11:54
sometimes in only one or two rooms,
290
702476
1599
11:56
because they weren't completed,
291
704075
1757
11:57
and we would heat our bathwater on hot plates.
292
705832
4711
12:02
But she never gave up hope, ever,
293
710543
2512
12:05
and she never allowed us to give up hope either.
294
713055
2680
12:07
This brutal pragmatism that she had,
295
715735
1577
12:09
I mean, I was four and she told me,
296
717312
1794
12:11
"Mommy is Santa." (Laughter)
297
719106
2323
12:13
She was this brutal pragmatism.
298
721429
2483
12:15
She taught me so many lessons,
299
723912
2373
12:18
but the most important lesson
300
726285
1833
12:20
was that every single day she told me,
301
728118
3226
12:23
"Mellody, you can be anything."
302
731344
5336
12:28
And because of those words,
303
736680
1858
12:30
I would wake up at the crack of dawn,
304
738538
2105
12:32
and because of those words,
305
740643
1816
12:34
I would love school more than anything,
306
742459
3012
12:37
and because of those words, when I was on a bus
307
745471
1933
12:39
going to school, I dreamed the biggest dreams.
308
747404
3253
12:42
And it's because of those words
that I stand here right now
that I stand here right now
309
750657
3103
12:45
full of passion,
310
753760
1956
12:47
asking you to be brave for the kids
311
755716
2408
12:50
who are dreaming those dreams today.
312
758124
2310
12:52
(Applause)
313
760434
5421
12:57
You see, I want them to look at a CEO on television
314
765855
4189
13:02
and say, "I can be like her,"
315
770044
2187
13:04
or, "He looks like me."
316
772231
2507
13:06
And I want them to know
317
774738
1741
13:08
that anything is possible,
318
776479
1695
13:10
that they can achieve the highest level
319
778174
1516
13:11
that they ever imagined,
320
779690
1754
13:13
that they will be welcome
in any corporate boardroom,
in any corporate boardroom,
321
781444
3095
13:16
or they can lead any company.
322
784539
2891
13:19
You see this idea of being the land
323
787430
1938
13:21
of the free and the home of the brave,
324
789368
1674
13:23
it's woven into the fabric of America.
325
791042
3448
13:26
America, when we have a challenge,
326
794490
2008
13:28
we take it head on, we don't shrink away from it.
327
796498
2876
13:31
We take a stand. We show courage.
328
799374
2859
13:34
So right now, what I'm asking you to do,
329
802233
2009
13:36
I'm asking you to show courage.
330
804242
1978
13:38
I'm asking you to be bold.
331
806220
2268
13:40
As business leaders, I'm asking you
332
808488
1821
13:42
not to leave anything on the table.
333
810309
2203
13:44
As citizens, I'm asking you
not to leave any child behind.
not to leave any child behind.
334
812512
4040
13:48
I'm asking you not to be color blind,
335
816552
2455
13:51
but to be color brave,
336
819007
2103
13:53
so that every child knows that their future matters
337
821110
3157
13:56
and their dreams are possible.
338
824267
1632
13:57
Thank you.
339
825899
2530
14:00
(Applause)
340
828429
5488
14:05
Thank you. Thanks. Thanks. (Applause)
341
833917
3951
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Mellody Hobson - Investment expertMellody Hobson is president of Ariel Investments, a value-driven money management firm -- and an advocate for financial literacy and investor education.
Why you should listen
Mellody Hobson handles strategic planning for the Chicago-based Ariel Investments, one of the largest African-American-owned money management firms in the United States. Beyond her work at Ariel, Hobson has become a nationally recognized voice on financial literacy and investor education. She is a regular contributor and analyst on finance, the markets and economic trends for CBS News, contributes weekly money tips on the Tom Joyner Morning Show and writes a column for Black Enterprise magazine. As a passionate advocate for investor education, she is a spokesperson for the Ariel/Hewitt study, 401(k) Plans in Living Color and the Ariel Black Investor Survey, both of which examine investing patterns among minorities.
Hobson is chair of the board for DreamWorks Animation. Her community outreach includes serving as chairman of After School Matters, providing Chicago teens with high quality out-of-school-time programs.
Mellody Hobson | Speaker | TED.com