TEDGlobal 2014
Bruno Torturra: Got a smartphone? Start broadcasting
Filmed:
Readability: 4.7
1,329,421 views
In 2011, journalist Bruno Torturra covered a protest in São Paulo which turned ugly. His experience of being teargassed had a profound effect on the way he thought about his work, and he quit his job to focus on broadcasting raw, unedited experiences online. In this fascinating talk, he shares some of the ways in which he's experimented with livestreaming on the web, and how in the process he has helped to create a very modern media network.
Bruno Torturra - Livestreaming activist
Journalist and photographer Bruno Torturra is the face of Media Ninja, a Brazilian digital collective making headlines for its ability to cover big news as it happens. Full bio
Journalist and photographer Bruno Torturra is the face of Media Ninja, a Brazilian digital collective making headlines for its ability to cover big news as it happens. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Has anyone among you
ever been exposed to tear gas?
ever been exposed to tear gas?
0
739
4579
00:17
Tear gas? Anyone?
1
5318
3115
00:20
I'm sorry to hear that, so you might know
that it's a very toxic substance,
that it's a very toxic substance,
2
8433
4571
00:25
but you might not know
that it's a very simple molecule
that it's a very simple molecule
3
13004
3424
00:28
with an unpronouncable name:
4
16428
2214
00:30
it's called chlorobenzalmalononitrile.
5
18642
3120
00:33
I made it.
6
21762
2017
00:35
It's decades old, but it's becoming
very trendy among police forces
very trendy among police forces
7
23779
5358
00:41
around the planet lately, it seems,
8
29137
2879
00:44
and according to my experience
as a non-voluntary breather of it,
as a non-voluntary breather of it,
9
32016
4737
00:48
tear gas has two main
but quite opposite effects.
but quite opposite effects.
10
36753
4273
00:53
One, it can really burn your eyes,
11
41026
3142
00:56
and two, it can also
help you to open them.
help you to open them.
12
44168
3275
01:00
Tear gas definitely helped
to open mine to something
to open mine to something
13
48603
3589
01:04
that I want to share
with you this afternoon:
with you this afternoon:
14
52192
3740
01:07
that livestreaming the power
of independent broadcasts through the web
of independent broadcasts through the web
15
55932
5294
01:13
can be a game-changer in journalism,
16
61226
3181
01:16
in activism, and as I see it,
in the political discourse as well.
in the political discourse as well.
17
64407
6342
01:22
That idea started
to dawn on me in early 2011
to dawn on me in early 2011
18
70749
4773
01:27
when I was covering
a protest in São Paulo.
a protest in São Paulo.
19
75522
3538
01:31
It was the marijuana march,
20
79060
1988
01:33
a gathering of people asking
for the legalization of cannabis.
for the legalization of cannabis.
21
81048
3962
01:37
When that group started to move,
22
85010
2465
01:39
the riot police came from the back
with rubber bullets, bombs,
with rubber bullets, bombs,
23
87475
4310
01:43
and then the gas.
24
91785
1759
01:46
But to make a long story short,
25
94184
2018
01:48
I had entered that protest
as the editor-in-chief
as the editor-in-chief
26
96202
3889
01:52
of a well-established printed magazine
where I'd worked for 11 years,
where I'd worked for 11 years,
27
100091
4773
01:56
and thanks to this unsolicited
effects of tear gas,
effects of tear gas,
28
104864
4912
02:01
I left it as a journalist that was now
committed to new ways
committed to new ways
29
109776
4933
02:06
of sharing the raw experience
of what it's like to be there, actually.
of what it's like to be there, actually.
30
114709
5943
02:12
So in the following week,
I was back in the streets,
I was back in the streets,
31
120652
3840
02:16
but that time, I wasn't a member
of any media outlet anymore.
of any media outlet anymore.
32
124492
4063
02:20
I was there as an independent
livestreamer, and all I had with me
livestreamer, and all I had with me
33
128555
4621
02:25
was basically borrowed equipment.
34
133176
2136
02:27
I had a very simple camera
and a backpack with 3G modems.
and a backpack with 3G modems.
35
135312
6054
02:33
And I had this weblink
that could be shared through social media,
that could be shared through social media,
36
141366
5625
02:38
could be put in any website,
37
146991
2877
02:41
and that time,
the protest went along fine.
the protest went along fine.
38
149868
3029
02:44
There was no violence.
39
152897
1849
02:46
There was no action scenes.
40
154746
2089
02:48
But there was something really exciting,
41
156835
2439
02:51
because I could see at a distance
the TV channels covering it,
the TV channels covering it,
42
159274
4850
02:56
and they had these big vans
and the teams and the cameras,
and the teams and the cameras,
43
164124
4024
03:00
and I was basically doing the same thing
44
168148
2479
03:02
and all I had was a backpack.
45
170627
2776
03:05
And that was really
exciting to a journalist,
exciting to a journalist,
46
173403
3275
03:08
but the most interesting part
was when I got back home, actually,
was when I got back home, actually,
47
176678
4381
03:13
because I learned that I had been watched
48
181059
2827
03:15
by more than 90,000 people,
49
183886
3104
03:18
and I got hundreds of emails and messages
of people asking me, basically,
of people asking me, basically,
50
186990
4905
03:23
how did I do it,
51
191895
1400
03:25
how it was possible to do such a thing.
52
193295
3316
03:28
And I learned something else,
that that was actually the first time
that that was actually the first time
53
196611
3273
03:31
that somebody had ever done
a livestreaming in a street protest
a livestreaming in a street protest
54
199884
5138
03:37
in the country.
55
205022
1574
03:39
And that really shocked me,
56
207216
2542
03:41
because I was no geek,
I was no technology guy,
I was no technology guy,
57
209758
3778
03:45
and all the equipment needed
was already there,
was already there,
58
213536
2759
03:48
was easily available.
59
216295
2206
03:50
And I realized that
we had a frontier here,
we had a frontier here,
60
218501
3116
03:53
a very important one,
61
221617
1463
03:55
that it was just a matter
of changing the perspective,
of changing the perspective,
62
223080
3157
03:58
and the web could be actually used,
63
226237
2229
04:00
already used, as a colossal
and uncontrollable
and uncontrollable
64
228466
3442
04:03
and highly anarchical TV channel,
TV network,
TV network,
65
231908
3813
04:07
and anyone with very basic skills
and very basic equipment,
and very basic equipment,
66
235721
5184
04:12
even someone like me who had this
little stuttering issue,
little stuttering issue,
67
240905
5843
04:18
so if it happens, bear with me please,
68
246748
4125
04:22
even someone like me
could become a broadcaster.
could become a broadcaster.
69
250873
4519
04:27
And that sounded revolutionary in my mind.
70
255392
2192
04:29
So for the next couple of years,
71
257584
1578
04:31
I started to experiment with
livestreaming in different ways,
livestreaming in different ways,
72
259162
4047
04:35
not only in the streets
but mostly in studios and in homes,
but mostly in studios and in homes,
73
263209
3606
04:38
until the beginning of 2013, last year,
74
266815
3308
04:42
when I became the cofounder of a group
called Mídia NINJA.
called Mídia NINJA.
75
270123
4180
04:46
NINJA is an acronym
76
274303
1449
04:47
that stands for Narrativas Independentes
Jornalismo e Ação,
Jornalismo e Ação,
77
275752
3830
04:51
or in English, independent narratives,
journalism, and action.
journalism, and action.
78
279582
3911
04:55
It was a media group
that had little media plan.
that had little media plan.
79
283493
3922
04:59
We didn't have any financial structure.
80
287415
2049
05:01
We were not planning
to make money out of this,
to make money out of this,
81
289464
3180
05:04
which was wise, because you shouldn't
try to make money out of journalism now.
try to make money out of journalism now.
82
292644
4610
05:10
But we had a very solid
and clear conviction,
and clear conviction,
83
298484
2704
05:13
that we knew that the hyperconnected
environment of social media
environment of social media
84
301188
4954
05:18
could maybe allow us to consolidate
85
306142
2631
05:20
a network of experimental journalists
throughout the country.
throughout the country.
86
308773
5344
05:26
So we launched a Facebook page first,
and then a manifesto,
and then a manifesto,
87
314117
5137
05:31
and started to cover the streets
in a very simple way.
in a very simple way.
88
319254
3738
05:34
But then something happened,
something that wasn't predicted,
something that wasn't predicted,
89
322992
4318
05:39
that no one could have anticipated.
90
327310
2507
05:41
Street protests started
to erupt in São Paulo.
to erupt in São Paulo.
91
329817
2920
05:44
They began as very local and specific.
92
332737
2180
05:46
They were against the bus fare hike
that had just happened in the city.
that had just happened in the city.
93
334917
5310
05:52
This is a bus.
94
340227
1911
05:54
It's written there, "Theft."
95
342138
2964
05:57
But those kind of manifestations
started to grow,
started to grow,
96
345102
5059
06:02
and they kept happening.
97
350161
1835
06:03
So the police violence against them
started to grow as well.
started to grow as well.
98
351996
4807
06:08
But there was another conflict,
99
356803
1709
06:10
the one I believe that's
more important here
more important here
100
358512
2504
06:13
to make my point that
it was a narrative conflict.
it was a narrative conflict.
101
361016
3960
06:16
There was this mainstream media
version of the facts
version of the facts
102
364976
3030
06:20
that anyone who was on the streets
could easily challenge
could easily challenge
103
368006
4286
06:24
if they presented their own vision
of what was actually happening there.
of what was actually happening there.
104
372292
6269
06:30
And it was this clash of visions,
this clash of narratives,
this clash of narratives,
105
378561
3080
06:33
that I think turned those protests
106
381641
3342
06:36
into a long period in the country
of political reckoning
of political reckoning
107
384983
3841
06:40
where hundreds of thousands of people,
108
388824
3508
06:44
probably more than a million people
109
392332
1818
06:46
took to the streets in the whole country.
110
394150
2358
06:49
But it wasn't about
the bus fare hike anymore.
the bus fare hike anymore.
111
397638
2614
06:52
It was about everything.
112
400252
3544
06:55
The people's demands, their expectations,
113
403796
2450
06:58
the reasons why they were on the streets
114
406246
2150
07:00
could be as diverse as they could
be contradictory in many cases.
be contradictory in many cases.
115
408396
4839
07:05
If you could read it,
you would understand me.
you would understand me.
116
413235
4108
07:09
But it was in this environment
of political catharsis
of political catharsis
117
417343
4395
07:13
that the country was going through
118
421738
2949
07:16
that it had to do with politics, indeed,
119
424687
3297
07:19
but it had to do also
with a new way of organizing,
with a new way of organizing,
120
427984
4033
07:24
through a new way of communicating.
121
432017
2933
07:26
It was in that environment
that Mídia NINJA emerged
that Mídia NINJA emerged
122
434950
2802
07:29
from almost anonymity
to become a national phenomenon,
to become a national phenomenon,
123
437752
4683
07:34
because we did have the right equipment.
124
442435
2853
07:37
We are not using big cameras.
125
445288
2200
07:39
We are using basically this.
126
447488
2624
07:42
We are using smartphones.
127
450112
1999
07:44
And that, actually, allowed us to become
invisible in the middle of the protests,
invisible in the middle of the protests,
128
452111
4908
07:49
but it allowed us to do something else:
129
457019
2682
07:51
to show what it was like
to be in the protests,
to be in the protests,
130
459701
3824
07:55
to present to people at home
a subjective perspective.
a subjective perspective.
131
463525
5754
08:01
But there was something
that is more important,
that is more important,
132
469279
2336
08:03
I think, than the equipment.
133
471615
1356
08:04
It was our mindset,
134
472971
2728
08:07
because we are not behaving
as a media outlet.
as a media outlet.
135
475699
3171
08:10
We are not competing for news.
136
478870
1938
08:12
We are trying to encourage people,
137
480808
2321
08:15
to invite people,
and to actually teach people
and to actually teach people
138
483129
2856
08:17
how to do this, how they also
could become broadcasters.
could become broadcasters.
139
485985
4210
08:22
And that was crucial to turn Mídia NINJA
from a small group of people,
from a small group of people,
140
490195
6070
08:28
and in a matter of weeks,
141
496265
1650
08:29
we multiplied and we grew
exponentially throughout the country.
exponentially throughout the country.
142
497915
4577
08:34
So in a matter of a week or two,
as the protests kept happening,
as the protests kept happening,
143
502492
4677
08:39
we were hundreds of young people
144
507169
2212
08:41
connected in this network
throughout the country.
throughout the country.
145
509381
2805
08:44
We were covering more than
50 cities at the same time.
50 cities at the same time.
146
512186
3140
08:47
That's something that
no TV channel could ever do.
no TV channel could ever do.
147
515326
3654
08:50
That was responsible
for turning us suddenly, actually,
for turning us suddenly, actually,
148
518980
3413
08:54
into kind of the mainstream
media of social media.
media of social media.
149
522393
4926
08:59
So we had a couple of thousands
of followers on our Facebook page,
of followers on our Facebook page,
150
527319
4051
09:03
and soon we had a quarter
of a million followers.
of a million followers.
151
531370
3236
09:06
Our posts and our videos
152
534606
1684
09:08
were being seen by more than
11 million timelines a week.
11 million timelines a week.
153
536290
3979
09:12
It was way more than any newspaper
or any magazine could ever do.
or any magazine could ever do.
154
540269
5721
09:17
And that turned Mídia NINJA
into something else,
into something else,
155
545990
3244
09:21
more than a media outlet,
than a media project.
than a media project.
156
549234
3441
09:24
It became almost like a public service
157
552675
2759
09:27
to the citizen, to the protester,
158
555434
2527
09:29
to the activist,
159
557961
1734
09:31
because they had a very simple
and efficient and peaceful tool
and efficient and peaceful tool
160
559695
3428
09:35
to confront both police
and media authority.
and media authority.
161
563123
4891
09:41
Many of our images started
to be used in regular TV channels.
to be used in regular TV channels.
162
569644
3991
09:45
Our livestreams started to be broadcast
even in regular televisions
even in regular televisions
163
573643
4831
09:50
when things got really rough.
164
578474
1949
09:52
Some our images were responsible
to take some people out of jail,
to take some people out of jail,
165
580433
5297
09:57
people who were being arrested unfairly
166
585730
2839
10:00
under false accusations,
and we could prove them innocent.
and we could prove them innocent.
167
588569
3769
10:04
And that also turned Mídia NINJA very soon
168
592338
3241
10:07
to be seen as almost
an enemy of cops, unfortunately,
an enemy of cops, unfortunately,
169
595579
4011
10:11
and we started to be severely beaten,
and eventually arrested on the streets.
and eventually arrested on the streets.
170
599590
5073
10:16
It happened in many cases.
171
604663
1914
10:18
But that was also useful,
because we were still at the web,
because we were still at the web,
172
606577
4332
10:22
so that helped to trigger
an important debate in the country
an important debate in the country
173
610909
5185
10:28
on the role of the media itself
174
616094
2449
10:30
and the state of the freedom
of the press in the country.
of the press in the country.
175
618543
3599
10:34
So Mídia NINJA now evolved
176
622142
1951
10:36
and finally consolidated itself
in what we hoped it would become:
in what we hoped it would become:
177
624093
6050
10:42
a national network
of hundreds of young people,
of hundreds of young people,
178
630143
3284
10:45
self-organizing themselves locally
179
633427
3877
10:49
to cover social, human rights issues,
180
637304
3761
10:53
and expressing themselves
not only politically
not only politically
181
641065
2768
10:55
but journalistically.
182
643833
2902
11:00
What I started to do
in the beginning of this year,
in the beginning of this year,
183
648665
4335
11:05
as Mídia NINJA is already
a self-organizing network,
a self-organizing network,
184
653000
4156
11:09
I'm dedicating myself to another project.
185
657156
3433
11:12
It's called Fluxo,
which is Portuguese for "stream."
which is Portuguese for "stream."
186
660589
3246
11:15
It's a journalism studio
in São Paulo downtown,
in São Paulo downtown,
187
663835
2807
11:18
where I used livestream to experiment
188
666642
3327
11:21
with what I call post-television formats.
189
669969
3505
11:25
But I'm also trying to come up with ways
to finance independent journalism
to finance independent journalism
190
673474
5378
11:30
through a direct relationship
with an audience,
with an audience,
191
678852
2812
11:33
with an active audience,
192
681664
1962
11:35
because now I really want
to try to make a living
to try to make a living
193
683626
2670
11:38
out of my tear gas resolution back then.
194
686296
3762
11:42
But there's something
more significant here,
more significant here,
195
690058
2290
11:44
something that I believe is more important
and more crucial than my personal example.
and more crucial than my personal example.
196
692348
5446
11:49
I said that livestream could turn the web
into a colossal TV network,
into a colossal TV network,
197
697794
4835
11:54
but I believe it does something else,
198
702629
2037
11:56
because after watching people using it,
199
704666
2961
11:59
not only to cover things but to express,
to organize themselves politically,
to organize themselves politically,
200
707627
6024
12:05
I believe livestream can turn cyberspace
into a global political arena
into a global political arena
201
713651
6754
12:12
where everyone might have a voice,
202
720419
2384
12:14
a proper voice,
203
722803
1544
12:16
because livestream takes the monopoly
of the broadcast political discourse,
of the broadcast political discourse,
204
724347
5485
12:21
of the verbal aspect
of the political dialogue
of the political dialogue
205
729832
2753
12:24
out of the mouths of just politicians
and political pundits alone,
and political pundits alone,
206
732585
5609
12:30
and it empowers the citizen
through this direct and non-mediated power
through this direct and non-mediated power
207
738194
5470
12:35
of exchanging experiences and dialogue,
208
743664
2983
12:38
empowers them to question
and to influence authorities
and to influence authorities
209
746647
4050
12:42
in ways in which we are about to see.
210
750697
3529
12:46
And I believe it does something else
that might be even more important,
that might be even more important,
211
754226
4554
12:50
that the simplicity of the technology
can merge objectivity and subjectivity
can merge objectivity and subjectivity
212
758780
6690
12:57
in a very political way, as I see it,
213
765470
2663
13:00
because it really helps the audience,
214
768133
5169
13:05
the citizen, to see the world
through somebody else's eye,
through somebody else's eye,
215
773302
4494
13:09
so it helps the citizen
to put him- or herself
to put him- or herself
216
777796
3434
13:13
in other people's place.
217
781230
2672
13:15
And that idea, I think,
should be the intention,
should be the intention,
218
783902
3268
13:19
should be the goal of any good journalism,
any good activism,
any good activism,
219
787170
4715
13:23
but most of all, any good politics.
220
791885
2652
13:26
Thank you very much. It was an honor.
221
794537
2528
13:29
(Applause)
222
797065
5643
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Bruno Torturra - Livestreaming activistJournalist and photographer Bruno Torturra is the face of Media Ninja, a Brazilian digital collective making headlines for its ability to cover big news as it happens.
Why you should listen
After 11 years as a correspondent and chief editor for Trip Magazine (“Dedicated to the exploration of psychedelic and visionary drug subculture”), São Paolo writer and photographer Bruno Torturra founded two experimental livestreaming networks: first PosTV, then Media Ninja. The latter drew global attention for its collective coverage of the 2013 protests in Brazil, and the questions it raises about the role of traditional journalism and the power of livestreaming technology.
More profile about the speakerBruno Torturra | Speaker | TED.com