TEDGlobal 2013
Tom Wujec: Got a wicked problem? First, tell me how you make toast
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
3,176,900 views
Making toast doesn’t sound very complicated -- until someone asks you to draw the process, step by step. Tom Wujec loves asking people and teams to draw how they make toast, because the process reveals unexpected truths about how we can solve our biggest, most complicated problems at work. Learn how to run this exercise yourself, and hear Wujec’s surprising insights from watching thousands of people draw toast.
Tom Wujec - Designer
Tom Wujec studies how we share and absorb information. He's an innovative practitioner of business visualization -- using design and technology to help groups solve problems and understand ideas. He is a Fellow at Autodesk. Full bio
Tom Wujec studies how we share and absorb information. He's an innovative practitioner of business visualization -- using design and technology to help groups solve problems and understand ideas. He is a Fellow at Autodesk. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Some years ago,
0
140
1591
00:13
I stumbled across a simple design exercise
1
1731
3444
00:17
that helps people understand
and solve complex problems,
and solve complex problems,
2
5175
3605
00:20
and like many of these design exercises,
it kind of seems trivial at first,
it kind of seems trivial at first,
3
8780
4087
00:24
but under deep inspection,
4
12867
1744
00:26
it turns out that it reveals
unexpected truths
unexpected truths
5
14611
2720
00:29
about the way that we collaborate
and make sense of things.
and make sense of things.
6
17331
3331
00:32
The exercise has three parts
7
20662
1602
00:34
and begins with something
that we all know how to do,
that we all know how to do,
8
22264
2485
00:36
which is how to make toast.
9
24749
2400
00:39
It begins with a clean sheet of paper,
a felt marker,
a felt marker,
10
27489
3320
00:42
and without using any words,
you begin to draw how to make toast.
you begin to draw how to make toast.
11
30809
4131
00:46
And most people draw something like this.
12
34940
2178
00:49
They draw a loaf of bread,
which is sliced, then put into a toaster.
which is sliced, then put into a toaster.
13
37118
3380
00:52
The toast is then deposited for some time.
14
40498
2246
00:54
It pops up, and then voila!
After two minutes, toast and happiness.
After two minutes, toast and happiness.
15
42744
5551
01:01
Now, over the years, I've collected
many hundreds of drawings of these toasts,
many hundreds of drawings of these toasts,
16
49045
4598
01:05
and some of them are very good,
17
53643
1760
01:07
because they really illustrate
the toast-making process quite clearly.
the toast-making process quite clearly.
18
55403
3466
01:10
And then there are some that are,
well, not so good.
well, not so good.
19
58869
3297
01:14
They really suck, actually, because
you don't know what they're trying to say.
you don't know what they're trying to say.
20
62166
5178
01:19
Under close inspection,
21
67344
1927
01:21
some reveal some aspects of toast-making
while hiding others.
while hiding others.
22
69271
3483
01:24
So there's some
that are all about the toast,
that are all about the toast,
23
72754
2670
01:27
and all about the transformation of toast.
24
75424
2740
01:30
And there's others
that are all about the toaster,
that are all about the toaster,
25
78164
2600
01:32
and the engineers love to draw
the mechanics of this.
the mechanics of this.
26
80764
3330
01:36
(Laughter)
27
84094
1410
01:37
And then there are others
that are about people.
that are about people.
28
85504
2371
01:39
It's about visualizing
the experience that people have.
the experience that people have.
29
87875
3848
01:43
And then there are others that are about
the supply chain of making toast
the supply chain of making toast
30
91723
3513
01:47
that goes all the way back to the store.
31
95236
1990
01:49
It goes through the supply chain
networks of teleportation
networks of teleportation
32
97226
3437
01:52
and all the way back
to the field and wheat,
to the field and wheat,
33
100663
3227
01:55
and one all actually goes
all the way back to the Big Bang.
all the way back to the Big Bang.
34
103890
2810
01:58
So it's crazy stuff.
35
106700
2204
02:00
But I think it's obvious
36
108904
1853
02:02
that even though these drawings
are really wildly different,
are really wildly different,
37
110757
3506
02:06
they share a common quality,
and I'm wondering if you can see it.
and I'm wondering if you can see it.
38
114263
3103
02:09
Do you see it? What's common about these?
39
117366
2377
02:11
Most drawings have nodes and links.
40
119743
3375
02:15
So nodes represent the tangible objects
like the toaster and people,
like the toaster and people,
41
123118
5350
02:20
and links represent
the connections between the nodes.
the connections between the nodes.
42
128468
3506
02:23
And it's the combination
of links and nodes
of links and nodes
43
131974
2833
02:26
that produces a full systems model,
44
134807
2113
02:28
and it makes our private
mental models visible
mental models visible
45
136920
2925
02:31
about how we think something works.
46
139845
3033
02:34
So that's the value of these things.
47
142878
1831
02:36
What's interesting about
these systems models
these systems models
48
144709
2108
02:38
is how they reveal
our various points of view.
our various points of view.
49
146817
2185
02:41
So for example, Americans
make toast with a toaster.
make toast with a toaster.
50
149002
3621
02:44
That seems obvious.
51
152623
1521
02:46
Whereas many Europeans
make toast with a frying pan, of course,
make toast with a frying pan, of course,
52
154144
3970
02:50
and many students make toast with a fire.
53
158114
4277
02:54
I don't really understand this.
A lot of MBA students do this.
A lot of MBA students do this.
54
162391
3219
02:57
So you can measure the complexity
by counting the number of nodes,
by counting the number of nodes,
55
165610
3765
03:01
and the average illustration
has between four and eight nodes.
has between four and eight nodes.
56
169375
3922
03:05
Less than that, the drawing seems trivial,
57
173297
2995
03:08
but it's quick to understand,
58
176292
2253
03:10
and more than 13, the drawing
produces a feeling of map shock.
produces a feeling of map shock.
59
178545
5073
03:15
It's too complex.
60
183618
1503
03:17
So the sweet spot is between 5 and 13.
61
185121
2543
03:19
So if you want to communicate
something visually,
something visually,
62
187664
2630
03:22
have between five and 13 nodes
in your diagram.
in your diagram.
63
190294
3727
03:26
So though we may not
be skilled at drawing,
be skilled at drawing,
64
194021
2704
03:28
the point is that we intuitively know
how to break down complex things
how to break down complex things
65
196725
4131
03:32
into simple things and then
bring them back together again.
bring them back together again.
66
200856
3260
03:36
So this brings us to our second part of
the exercise,
the exercise,
67
204116
3221
03:39
which is how to make toast,
68
207337
1576
03:40
but now with sticky notes
or with cards.
or with cards.
69
208913
2800
03:43
So what happens then?
70
211713
1428
03:46
Well, with cards, most people
tend to draw clear, more detailed,
tend to draw clear, more detailed,
71
214041
3421
03:49
and more logical nodes.
72
217462
2278
03:51
You can see the step by step
analysis that takes place,
analysis that takes place,
73
219740
3577
03:55
and as they build up their model,
they move their nodes around,
they move their nodes around,
74
223317
3232
03:58
rearranging them like Lego blocks.
75
226549
2580
04:01
Now, though this might seem trivial,
it's actually really important.
it's actually really important.
76
229129
4055
04:05
This rapid iteration of expressing
and then reflecting and analyzing
and then reflecting and analyzing
77
233184
4728
04:09
is really the only way
in which we get clarity.
in which we get clarity.
78
237912
3351
04:13
It's the essence of the design process.
79
241263
2648
04:15
And systems theorists do tell us
80
243911
1709
04:17
that the ease with which
we can change a representation
we can change a representation
81
245620
3562
04:21
correlates to our willingness
to improve the model.
to improve the model.
82
249182
3585
04:25
So sticky note systems
are not only more fluid,
are not only more fluid,
83
253447
3792
04:29
they generally produce
way more nodes than static drawings.
way more nodes than static drawings.
84
257239
4040
04:33
The drawings are much richer.
85
261279
1731
04:35
And this brings us
to our third part of the exercise,
to our third part of the exercise,
86
263010
2565
04:37
which is to draw how to make toast,
but this time in a group.
but this time in a group.
87
265575
3934
04:41
So what happens then?
88
269509
1762
04:43
Well, here's what happens.
89
271271
1612
04:44
It starts out messy,
and then it gets really messy,
and then it gets really messy,
90
272883
3617
04:48
and then it gets messier,
91
276500
1625
04:50
but as people refine the models,
92
278125
1927
04:52
the best nodes become more prominent,
93
280052
2531
04:54
and with each iteration,
the model becomes clearer
the model becomes clearer
94
282583
2577
04:57
because people build
on top of each other's ideas.
on top of each other's ideas.
95
285160
3274
05:00
What emerges is a unified systems model
96
288434
3483
05:03
that integrates the diversity
of everyone's individual points of view,
of everyone's individual points of view,
97
291917
4140
05:08
so that's a really different outcome
98
296057
1920
05:09
from what usually happens
in meetings, isn't it?
in meetings, isn't it?
99
297977
2671
05:12
So these drawings can contain
20 or more nodes,
20 or more nodes,
100
300648
2972
05:15
but participants don't feel map shock
101
303620
2229
05:17
because they participate in the building
of their models themselves.
of their models themselves.
102
305849
4225
05:22
Now, what's also really interesting,
that the groups spontaneously mix
that the groups spontaneously mix
103
310074
3321
05:25
and add additional layers
of organization to it.
of organization to it.
104
313395
3459
05:28
To deal with contradictions, for example,
105
316854
2010
05:30
they add branching patterns
and parallel patterns.
and parallel patterns.
106
318864
2820
05:33
Oh, and by the way,
if they do it in complete silence,
if they do it in complete silence,
107
321684
3223
05:36
they do it much better
and much more quickly.
and much more quickly.
108
324907
2756
05:39
Really interesting --
talking gets in the way.
talking gets in the way.
109
327663
2542
05:42
So here's some key lessons
that can emerge from this.
that can emerge from this.
110
330205
3692
05:45
First, drawing helps us
understand the situations
understand the situations
111
333897
2579
05:48
as systems with nodes
and their relationships.
and their relationships.
112
336476
3272
05:51
Movable cards produce
better systems models,
better systems models,
113
339748
3640
05:55
because we iterate much more fluidly.
114
343388
2730
05:58
And then the group notes produce
the most comprehensive models
the most comprehensive models
115
346118
3214
06:01
because we synthesize
several points of view.
several points of view.
116
349332
3357
06:04
So that's interesting.
117
352689
1586
06:06
When people work together
under the right circumstances,
under the right circumstances,
118
354275
3306
06:09
group models are much better
than individual models.
than individual models.
119
357581
3111
06:12
So this approach works really great
for drawing how to make toast,
for drawing how to make toast,
120
360692
4947
06:17
but what if you wanted to draw
something more relevant or pressing,
something more relevant or pressing,
121
365639
3889
06:21
like your organizational vision,
or customer experience,
or customer experience,
122
369528
5108
06:26
or long-term sustainability?
123
374636
2304
06:28
There's a visual revolution
that's taking place
that's taking place
124
376940
3506
06:32
as more organizations
are addressing their wicked problems
are addressing their wicked problems
125
380446
3413
06:35
by collaboratively drawing them out.
126
383859
2786
06:38
And I'm convinced that those who see
their world as movable nodes and links
their world as movable nodes and links
127
386645
4622
06:43
really have an edge.
128
391267
2124
06:45
And the practice is really pretty simple.
129
393391
2078
06:47
You start with a question,
you collect the nodes,
you collect the nodes,
130
395469
2902
06:50
you refine the nodes,
you do it over again,
you do it over again,
131
398371
3088
06:53
you refine and refine and refine,
and the patterns emerge,
and the patterns emerge,
132
401459
5309
06:58
and the group gets clarity
and you answer the question.
and you answer the question.
133
406768
4352
07:05
So this simple act of visualizing
and doing over and over again
and doing over and over again
134
413070
6042
07:11
produces some really remarkable outcomes.
135
419112
2582
07:13
What's really important to know
136
421694
1887
07:15
is that it's the conversations
that are the important aspects,
that are the important aspects,
137
423581
3690
07:19
not just the models themselves.
138
427271
2325
07:21
And these visual frames of reference
139
429596
1788
07:23
can grow to several hundreds
or even thousands of nodes.
or even thousands of nodes.
140
431384
4598
07:27
So, one example is from
an organization called Rodale.
an organization called Rodale.
141
435982
3018
07:31
Big publishing company.
142
439000
1486
07:32
They lost a bunch of money one year,
143
440486
2136
07:34
and their executive team for three days
visualized their entire practice.
visualized their entire practice.
144
442622
4342
07:38
And what's interesting is that
after visualizing the entire business,
after visualizing the entire business,
145
446964
5922
07:44
systems upon systems,
146
452886
1764
07:46
they reclaimed
50 million dollars of revenue,
50 million dollars of revenue,
147
454650
3066
07:49
and they also moved from a D rating
to an A rating from their customers.
to an A rating from their customers.
148
457716
5018
07:54
Why? Because there's
alignment from the executive team.
alignment from the executive team.
149
462734
3595
07:58
So I'm now on a mission
to help organizations
to help organizations
150
466329
3413
08:01
solve their wicked problems
by using collaborative visualization,
by using collaborative visualization,
151
469742
4714
08:06
and on a site that I've produced
called drawtoast.com,
called drawtoast.com,
152
474456
3018
08:09
I've collected a bunch of best practices.
153
477474
3204
08:12
and so you can learn
how to run a workshop here,
how to run a workshop here,
154
480678
2763
08:15
you can learn more about
the visual language
the visual language
155
483441
2143
08:17
and the structure of links and nodes that
you can apply to general problem-solving,
you can apply to general problem-solving,
156
485584
4916
08:22
and download examples of various templates
157
490500
3205
08:25
for unpacking the thorny problems
that we all face in our organizations.
that we all face in our organizations.
158
493705
5293
08:30
So the seemingly trivial
design exercise of drawing toast
design exercise of drawing toast
159
498998
3622
08:34
helps us get clear, engaged and aligned.
160
502620
4041
08:38
So next time you're confronted
with an interesting challenge,
with an interesting challenge,
161
506661
2948
08:41
remember what design has to teach us.
162
509609
2334
08:43
Make your ideas visible,
tangible, and consequential.
tangible, and consequential.
163
511943
3831
08:47
It's simple, it's fun, it's powerful,
164
515774
3158
08:50
and I believe it's an idea
worth celebrating.
worth celebrating.
165
518932
3150
08:54
Thank you.
166
522082
1820
08:55
(Applause)
167
523902
4480
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tom Wujec - DesignerTom Wujec studies how we share and absorb information. He's an innovative practitioner of business visualization -- using design and technology to help groups solve problems and understand ideas. He is a Fellow at Autodesk.
Why you should listen
Tom Wujec is a Fellow at Autodesk, the makers of design software for engineers, filmmakers, designers. At Autodesk, he has worked on software including SketchBook Pro, PortfolioWall and Maya (which won an Academy Award for its contribution to the film industry). As a Fellow, he helps companies work in the emerging field of business visualization, the art of using images, sketches and infographics to help teams solve complex problems as a group.
He's the author of several books, including Five-Star Mind: Games and Puzzles to Stimulate Your Creativity and Imagination.
Tom Wujec | Speaker | TED.com