TEDMED 2017
Mark Tyndall: The harm reduction model of drug addiction treatment
Filmed:
Readability: 5.4
1,341,450 views
Why do we still think that drug use is a law-enforcement issue? Making drugs illegal does nothing to stop people from using them, says public health expert Mark Tyndall. So, what might work? Tyndall shares community-based research that shows how harm-reduction strategies, like safe-injection sites, are working to address the drug overdose crisis.
Mark Tyndall - Epidemiologist, physician, public health expert
Mark Tyndall has dedicated his career to studying HIV, poverty and drug use in multiple places around the world, starting with Nairobi, and now in Vancouver. Full bio
Mark Tyndall has dedicated his career to studying HIV, poverty and drug use in multiple places around the world, starting with Nairobi, and now in Vancouver. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I remember the first time
that I saw people injecting drugs.
that I saw people injecting drugs.
0
810
4309
00:18
I had just arrived in Vancouver
to lead a research project
to lead a research project
1
6090
3526
00:21
in HIV prevention in the
infamous Downtown East Side.
infamous Downtown East Side.
2
9640
4832
00:27
It was in the lobby of the Portland Hotel,
3
15100
2526
00:29
a supportive housing
project that gave rooms
project that gave rooms
4
17650
2886
00:32
to the most marginalized
people in the city,
people in the city,
5
20560
2376
00:34
the so-called "difficult to house."
6
22960
2746
00:38
I'll never forget the young woman
standing on the stairs
standing on the stairs
7
26800
3390
00:42
repeatedly jabbing herself with a needle,
and screaming,
and screaming,
8
30214
4055
00:46
"I can't find a vein,"
9
34293
1453
00:47
as blood splattered on the wall.
10
35770
2634
00:52
In response to the desperate
state of affairs, the drug use,
state of affairs, the drug use,
11
40140
3936
00:56
the poverty, the violence,
the soaring rates of HIV,
the soaring rates of HIV,
12
44100
4656
01:00
Vancouver declared a public
health emergency in 1997.
health emergency in 1997.
13
48780
4626
01:05
This opened the door to
expanding harm reduction services,
expanding harm reduction services,
14
53430
3396
01:08
distributing more needles,
15
56850
1656
01:10
increasing access to methadone,
16
58530
1770
01:12
and, finally, opening
a supervised injection site.
a supervised injection site.
17
60324
3732
01:16
Things that make injecting
drugs less hazardous.
drugs less hazardous.
18
64080
3761
01:20
But today, 20 years later,
19
68910
2539
01:23
harm reduction is still viewed
as some sort of radical concept.
as some sort of radical concept.
20
71473
4313
01:27
In some places, it's still illegal
to carry a clean needle.
to carry a clean needle.
21
75810
3906
01:31
Drug users are far more likely
to be arrested
to be arrested
22
79740
2737
01:34
than to be offered methadone therapy.
23
82501
2388
01:37
Recent proposals for
supervised injection sites
supervised injection sites
24
85440
2796
01:40
in cities like Seattle,
Baltimore and New York
Baltimore and New York
25
88260
3396
01:43
have been met with stiff opposition:
26
91680
2333
01:46
opposition that goes against
everything we know about addiction.
everything we know about addiction.
27
94800
4833
01:52
Why is that?
28
100149
1460
01:53
Why are we still stuck on the idea
29
101633
2595
01:56
that the only option is to stop using --
that any drug use will not be tolerated?
that any drug use will not be tolerated?
30
104252
5880
02:03
Why do we ignore
countless personal stories
countless personal stories
31
111060
3696
02:06
and overwhelming scientific evidence
32
114780
2496
02:09
that harm reduction works?
33
117300
2003
02:12
Critics say that harm
reduction doesn't stop people
reduction doesn't stop people
34
120980
3786
02:16
from using illegal drugs.
35
124790
1649
02:19
Well, actually, that is the whole point.
36
127034
2712
02:21
After every criminal and societal sanction
37
129770
2856
02:24
that we can come up with,
38
132650
1325
02:26
people still use drugs,
and far too many die.
and far too many die.
39
134396
3515
02:31
Critics also say that
we are giving up on people
we are giving up on people
40
139100
2796
02:33
by not focusing our attention
on treatment and recovery.
on treatment and recovery.
41
141920
4396
02:38
In fact, it is just the opposite.
42
146951
1765
02:40
We are not giving up on people.
43
148740
1477
02:42
We know that if recovery
is ever going to happen
is ever going to happen
44
150241
2275
02:44
we must keep people alive.
45
152540
2166
02:46
Offering someone a clean needle
or a safe place to inject
or a safe place to inject
46
154730
3576
02:50
is the first step to
treatment and recovery.
treatment and recovery.
47
158330
2569
02:54
Critics also claim that harm reduction
48
162950
2436
02:57
gives the wrong message to
our children about drug users.
our children about drug users.
49
165410
3454
03:01
The last time I looked,
these drug users are our children.
these drug users are our children.
50
169864
4380
03:06
The message of harm reduction
is that while drugs can hurt you,
is that while drugs can hurt you,
51
174268
4048
03:10
we still must reach out to
people who are addicted.
people who are addicted.
52
178340
2886
03:13
A needle exchange is not an
advertisement for drug use.
advertisement for drug use.
53
181250
4476
03:17
Neither is a methadone clinic
or a supervised injection site.
or a supervised injection site.
54
185750
3996
03:21
What you see there are
people sick and hurting,
people sick and hurting,
55
189770
2900
03:25
hardly an endorsement for drug use.
56
193160
2883
03:28
Let's take supervised
injection sites, for example.
injection sites, for example.
57
196876
3020
03:31
Probably the most misunderstood
health intervention ever.
health intervention ever.
58
199920
3626
03:35
All we are saying is that allowing people
59
203570
2676
03:38
to inject in a clean, dry space
with fresh needles,
with fresh needles,
60
206270
3837
03:42
surrounded by people who care
61
210131
2198
03:44
is a lot better than
injecting in a dingy alley,
injecting in a dingy alley,
62
212726
3142
03:47
sharing contaminated needles
and hiding out from police.
and hiding out from police.
63
215892
3261
03:51
It's better for everybody.
64
219470
1747
03:54
The first supervised injection site
in Vancouver was at 327 Carol Street,
in Vancouver was at 327 Carol Street,
65
222810
5468
04:00
a narrow room with a concrete floor,
a few chairs and a box of clean needles.
a few chairs and a box of clean needles.
66
228794
5332
04:06
The police would often lock it down,
67
234150
2286
04:08
but somehow it always
mysteriously reopened,
mysteriously reopened,
68
236460
3730
04:12
often with the aid of a crowbar.
69
240493
2101
04:15
I would go down there some evenings
70
243720
1746
04:17
to provide medical care
for people who were injecting drugs.
for people who were injecting drugs.
71
245490
3235
04:20
I was always struck with the
commitment and compassion
commitment and compassion
72
248749
3167
04:23
of the people who operated
and used the site.
and used the site.
73
251940
2856
04:27
No judgment, no hassles, no fear,
74
255240
3186
04:30
lots of profound conversation.
75
258450
1981
04:32
I learned that despite
unimaginable trauma,
unimaginable trauma,
76
260455
3341
04:35
physical pain and mental illness,
77
263820
3079
04:38
that everyone there thought
that things would get better.
that things would get better.
78
266923
3111
04:42
Most were convinced that, someday,
they'd stop using drugs altogether.
they'd stop using drugs altogether.
79
270630
5944
04:50
That room was the forerunner
to North America's
to North America's
80
278580
3366
04:53
first government-sanctioned
supervised injection site, called INSITE.
supervised injection site, called INSITE.
81
281970
4536
04:58
It opened in September of 2003
as a three-year research project.
as a three-year research project.
82
286530
4926
05:03
The conservative government was intent on
closing it down at the end of the study.
closing it down at the end of the study.
83
291480
4563
05:08
After eight years,
the battle to close INSITE
the battle to close INSITE
84
296580
3846
05:12
went all the way up to
Canada's Supreme Court.
Canada's Supreme Court.
85
300450
2496
05:14
It pitted the government of Canada
86
302970
1776
05:16
against two people with a
long history of drug use
long history of drug use
87
304770
3336
05:20
who knew the benefits of INSITE firsthand:
88
308130
2463
05:22
Dean Wilson and Shelley Tomic.
89
310982
2158
05:26
The court ruled in favor
of keeping INSITE open by nine to zero.
of keeping INSITE open by nine to zero.
90
314370
5136
05:31
The justices were scathing in
their response to the government's case.
their response to the government's case.
91
319530
4817
05:36
And I quote:
92
324720
1285
05:38
"The effect of denying the services
of INSITE to the population that it serves
of INSITE to the population that it serves
93
326029
4635
05:42
and the correlative increase in the risk
of death and disease
of death and disease
94
330689
3206
05:45
to injection drug users
is grossly disproportionate to any benefit
is grossly disproportionate to any benefit
95
333920
4958
05:50
that Canada might derive
96
338902
2102
05:53
from presenting a uniform stance
on the possession of narcotics."
on the possession of narcotics."
97
341028
4469
05:59
This was a hopeful moment
for harm reduction.
for harm reduction.
98
347540
2373
06:02
Yet, despite this strong message
from the Supreme Court,
from the Supreme Court,
99
350390
3412
06:06
it was, until very recently,
100
354290
2715
06:09
impossible to open up
any new sites in Canada.
any new sites in Canada.
101
357029
3180
06:12
There was one interesting thing
that happened in December of 2016,
that happened in December of 2016,
102
360800
5055
06:17
when due to the overdose crisis,
103
365879
3056
06:20
the government of British Columbia allowed
the opening of overdose prevention sites.
the opening of overdose prevention sites.
104
368960
5253
06:27
Essentially ignoring the
federal approval process,
federal approval process,
105
375117
3389
06:30
community groups opened up
about 22 of these de facto illegal
about 22 of these de facto illegal
106
378530
4371
06:34
supervised injection sites
across the province.
across the province.
107
382925
2769
06:38
Virtually overnight,
108
386600
1389
06:40
thousands of people could
use drugs under supervision.
use drugs under supervision.
109
388013
3123
06:43
Hundreds of overdoses were reversed
by Naloxone, and nobody died.
by Naloxone, and nobody died.
110
391160
4865
06:48
In fact, this is what's happened
at INSITE over the last 14 years:
at INSITE over the last 14 years:
111
396530
4317
06:53
75,000 different individuals
have injected illegal drugs
have injected illegal drugs
112
401363
4953
06:58
more than three and a half million times,
113
406340
3216
07:01
and not one person has died.
114
409580
2553
07:04
Nobody has ever died at INSITE.
115
412157
3904
07:10
So there you have it.
116
418950
1176
07:12
We have scientific evidence
and successes from needle exchanges
and successes from needle exchanges
117
420150
5618
07:17
methadone and supervised injection sites.
118
425792
3034
07:20
These are common-sense,
compassionate approaches to drug use
compassionate approaches to drug use
119
428850
4293
07:25
that improve health, bring connection
120
433167
2612
07:27
and greatly reduce suffering and death.
121
435803
3031
07:32
So why haven't harm reduction
programs taken off?
programs taken off?
122
440540
3066
07:35
Why do we still think
that drug use is law enforcement issue?
that drug use is law enforcement issue?
123
443630
5253
07:42
Our disdain for drugs and
drug users goes very deep.
drug users goes very deep.
124
450720
3642
07:46
We are bombarded with
images and media stories
images and media stories
125
454386
3400
07:49
about the horrible impacts of drugs.
126
457810
2444
07:52
We have stigmatized entire communities.
127
460600
3336
07:55
We applaud military-inspired operations
that bring down drug dealers.
that bring down drug dealers.
128
463960
5825
08:01
And we appear unfazed
by building more jails
by building more jails
129
469809
3337
08:05
to incarcerate people whose
only crime is using drugs.
only crime is using drugs.
130
473170
5396
08:10
Virtually millions of people are caught up
131
478960
2921
08:13
in a hopeless cycle
of incarceration, violence and poverty
of incarceration, violence and poverty
132
481905
4134
08:18
that has been created by our drug laws
and not the drugs themselves.
and not the drugs themselves.
133
486063
5794
08:24
How do I explain to people
that drug users deserve care and support
that drug users deserve care and support
134
492900
4127
08:29
and the freedom to live their lives
135
497051
1675
08:30
when all we see are images of guns
and handcuffs and jail cells?
and handcuffs and jail cells?
136
498750
5539
08:37
Let's be clear:
137
505710
1391
08:39
criminalization is just a way
to institutionalize stigma.
to institutionalize stigma.
138
507736
4476
08:45
Making drugs illegal does nothing
to stop people from using them.
to stop people from using them.
139
513000
5420
08:53
Our paralysis to see things differently
140
521888
3368
08:57
is also based on an entirely
false narrative about drug use.
false narrative about drug use.
141
525280
4536
09:01
We have been led to believe
that drug users
that drug users
142
529840
2247
09:04
are irresponsible people who just
want to get high,
want to get high,
143
532111
3778
09:07
and then through their
own personal failings
own personal failings
144
535913
2515
09:10
spiral down into a life
of crime and poverty,
of crime and poverty,
145
538452
3664
09:14
losing their jobs, their families
and, ultimately, their lives.
and, ultimately, their lives.
146
542140
3936
09:19
In reality, most drug users have a story,
147
547190
3531
09:22
whether it's childhood trauma,
sexual abuse, mental illness
sexual abuse, mental illness
148
550745
4401
09:27
or a personal tragedy.
149
555170
1446
09:28
The drugs are used to numb the pain.
150
556640
2815
09:34
We must understand that
as we approach people with so much trauma.
as we approach people with so much trauma.
151
562130
6111
09:41
At its core, our drug policies
are really a social justice issue.
are really a social justice issue.
152
569167
5019
09:46
While the media may focus on overdose
deaths like Prince and Michael Jackson,
deaths like Prince and Michael Jackson,
153
574210
5087
09:51
the majority of the suffering
154
579900
1499
09:53
happens to people who are
living on the margins,
living on the margins,
155
581423
3548
09:56
the poor and the dispossessed.
156
584995
2126
09:59
They don't vote; they are often alone.
157
587570
2909
10:02
They are society's disposable people.
158
590920
2892
10:07
Even within health care,
drug use is highly stigmatized.
drug use is highly stigmatized.
159
595040
4906
10:11
People using drugs avoid
the health care system.
the health care system.
160
599970
3086
10:15
They know that once
engaged in clinical care
engaged in clinical care
161
603080
2566
10:17
or admitted to hospital,
they will be treated poorly.
they will be treated poorly.
162
605670
3110
10:20
And their supply line, be it heroin,
cocaine or crystal meth
cocaine or crystal meth
163
608804
3523
10:24
will be interrupted.
164
612351
1515
10:26
On top of that, they will be asked
a barrage of questions
a barrage of questions
165
614700
3436
10:30
that only serve
to expose their losses and shame.
to expose their losses and shame.
166
618160
4166
10:34
"What drugs do you use?"
167
622350
1383
10:35
"How long have you been
living on the street?"
living on the street?"
168
623757
2167
10:37
"Where are your children?"
169
625948
1690
10:40
"When were you last in jail?"
170
628320
1746
10:42
Essentially: "Why the hell
don't you stop using drugs?"
don't you stop using drugs?"
171
630580
4285
10:47
In fact, our entire medical
approach to drug use is upside down.
approach to drug use is upside down.
172
635826
5040
10:52
For some reason,
173
640890
1151
10:54
we have decided that abstinence
is the best way to treat this.
is the best way to treat this.
174
642065
5253
10:59
If you're lucky enough,
you may get into a detox program.
you may get into a detox program.
175
647970
3426
11:03
If you live in a community
with Suboxone or methadone,
with Suboxone or methadone,
176
651420
3066
11:06
you may get on a substitution program.
177
654510
2404
11:09
Hardly ever would we offer people
what they desperately need to survive:
what they desperately need to survive:
178
657480
3968
11:13
a safe prescription for opioids.
179
661472
3420
11:18
Starting with abstinence is
like asking a new diabetic to quit sugar
like asking a new diabetic to quit sugar
180
666040
4833
11:22
or a severe asthmatic
to start running marathons
to start running marathons
181
670897
3231
11:26
or a depressed person to just be happy.
182
674152
2304
11:28
For any other medical condition,
183
676480
1563
11:30
we would never start with
the most extreme option.
the most extreme option.
184
678067
3023
11:33
What makes us think that strategy
185
681400
2286
11:35
would work for something
as complex as addiction?
as complex as addiction?
186
683710
3547
11:40
While unintentional overdoses are not new,
187
688570
2436
11:43
the scale of the current
crisis is unprecedented.
crisis is unprecedented.
188
691030
3096
11:46
The Center for Disease Control estimated
189
694150
2794
11:48
that 64,000 Americans died
of a drug overdose in 2016,
of a drug overdose in 2016,
190
696968
5143
11:54
far exceeding car crashes or homicides.
191
702135
2682
11:57
Drug-related mortality is now
the leading cause of death
the leading cause of death
192
705700
4071
12:01
among men and women between
20 and 50 years old in North America
20 and 50 years old in North America
193
709795
4515
12:07
Think about that.
194
715199
1183
12:09
How did we get to this point, and why now?
195
717133
4484
12:14
There is a kind of perfect
storm around opioids.
storm around opioids.
196
722290
2646
12:16
Drugs like Oxycontin,
Percocet and Dilaudid
Percocet and Dilaudid
197
724960
3756
12:20
have been liberally distributed
for decades for all kinds of pain.
for decades for all kinds of pain.
198
728740
5333
12:26
It is estimated that two million
Americans are daily opioid users,
Americans are daily opioid users,
199
734890
3873
12:31
and over 60 million people
200
739159
2517
12:33
received at least one prescription
for opioids last year.
for opioids last year.
201
741700
3746
12:38
This massive dump of
prescription drugs into communities
prescription drugs into communities
202
746140
3587
12:41
has provided a steady source
for people wanting to self-medicate.
for people wanting to self-medicate.
203
749751
4563
12:47
In response to this prescription epidemic,
204
755160
2932
12:50
people have been cut off, and this
has greatly reduced the street supply
has greatly reduced the street supply
205
758490
4492
12:55
The unintended but predictable consequence
206
763860
2642
12:58
is an overdose epidemic.
207
766526
1810
13:00
Many people who were reliant on
a steady supply of prescription drugs
a steady supply of prescription drugs
208
768360
4325
13:05
turned to heroin.
209
773010
1151
13:06
And now the illegal drug market
has tragically switched
has tragically switched
210
774185
3532
13:09
to synthetic drugs, mainly fentanyl.
211
777741
2426
13:13
These new drugs are cheap,
potent and extremely hard to dose.
potent and extremely hard to dose.
212
781140
4894
13:18
People are literally being poisoned.
213
786450
2722
13:23
Can you imagine if this was
any other kind of poisoning epidemic?
any other kind of poisoning epidemic?
214
791470
4206
13:27
What if thousands of people started dying
215
795700
2333
13:30
from poisoned meat
or baby formula or coffee?
or baby formula or coffee?
216
798057
3634
13:34
We would be treating
this as a true emergency.
this as a true emergency.
217
802041
2275
13:36
We would immediately be
supplying safer alternatives.
supplying safer alternatives.
218
804340
3636
13:40
There would be changes in legislation,
219
808000
1996
13:42
and we would be supporting
the victims and their families.
the victims and their families.
220
810020
3246
13:46
But for the drug overdose epidemic,
221
814356
2010
13:48
we have done none of that.
222
816390
1352
13:50
We continue to demonize the drugs
and the people who use them
and the people who use them
223
818430
4229
13:54
and blindly pour even more resources
into law enforcement.
into law enforcement.
224
822683
5809
14:02
So where should we go from here?
225
830890
1928
14:05
First, we should fully embrace,
fund and scale up
fund and scale up
226
833763
4134
14:09
harm reduction programs
across North America.
across North America.
227
837921
2545
14:12
I know that in places like Vancouver,
228
840490
2896
14:15
harm reduction has been a
lifeline to care and treatment.
lifeline to care and treatment.
229
843410
3532
14:19
I know that the number of overdose deaths
230
847426
2370
14:21
would be far higher
without harm reduction.
without harm reduction.
231
849820
2976
14:25
And I personally know hundreds
of people who are alive today
of people who are alive today
232
853180
4833
14:30
because of harm reduction.
233
858810
1846
14:33
But harm reduction is just the start.
234
861810
1916
14:35
If we truly want to make
an impact on this drug crisis,
an impact on this drug crisis,
235
863750
4296
14:40
we need to have a serious
conversation about prohibition
conversation about prohibition
236
868070
3846
14:43
and criminal punishment.
237
871940
1546
14:46
We need to recognize that drug use is
first and foremost a public health issue
first and foremost a public health issue
238
874454
5817
14:53
and turn to comprehensive social
and health solutions.
and health solutions.
239
881358
6357
15:00
We already have a model
for how this can work.
for how this can work.
240
888900
2151
15:03
In 2001, Portugal was
having its own drug crisis.
having its own drug crisis.
241
891075
3291
15:06
Lots of people using
drugs, high crime rates
drugs, high crime rates
242
894390
3186
15:09
and an overdose epidemic.
243
897600
1866
15:11
They defied global conventions
and decriminalized all drug possession.
and decriminalized all drug possession.
244
899490
4784
15:16
Money that was spent on drug enforcement
245
904830
2436
15:19
was redirected to health
and rehabilitation programs.
and rehabilitation programs.
246
907290
3293
15:23
The results are in.
247
911060
1309
15:25
Overall drug use is down dramatically.
248
913050
3230
15:29
Overdoses are uncommon.
249
917240
2572
15:31
Many more people are in treatment.
250
919836
2706
15:36
And people have been
given their lives back.
given their lives back.
251
924115
2667
15:41
We have come so far down the road
of prohibition, punishment and prejudice
of prohibition, punishment and prejudice
252
929330
5801
15:47
that we have become
indifferent to the suffering
indifferent to the suffering
253
935155
2589
15:49
that we have inflicted on the
most vulnerable people in our society.
most vulnerable people in our society.
254
937768
4158
15:54
This year even more
people will get caught up
people will get caught up
255
942320
3576
15:57
in the illegal drug trade.
256
945920
1622
16:00
Thousands of children will learn
that their mother or father
that their mother or father
257
948620
4296
16:04
has been sent to jail for using drugs.
258
952940
3378
16:09
And far too many parents will be notified
259
957840
3036
16:12
that their son or daughter
has died of a drug overdose.
has died of a drug overdose.
260
960900
4642
16:18
It doesn't have to be this way.
261
966454
2096
16:22
Thank you.
262
970444
1150
16:23
(Applause)
263
971618
5294
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Mark Tyndall - Epidemiologist, physician, public health expertMark Tyndall has dedicated his career to studying HIV, poverty and drug use in multiple places around the world, starting with Nairobi, and now in Vancouver.
Why you should listen
Mark Tyndall is an epidemiologist, physician and public health expert. An early advocate for harm reduction programs, Tyndall was at the forefront of North America's first legally sanctioned supervised injection facility, INSITE, established in Vancouver in 2003. Since then, studies have shown that safe injection sites save lives, reduce transmission of disease and help people access addiction treatment and other medical services. A proponent of evidence-based public health policy and interventions, Tyndall has authored more than 250 academic papers and has received multiple honors for his work. He is currently the Director of the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control and a professor at the School of Population and Public Health at the University of British Columbia.
Mark Tyndall | Speaker | TED.com