TEDGlobal 2012
Susan Solomon: The promise of research with stem cells
Filmed:
Readability: 4.9
927,801 views
Calling them "our bodies' own repair kits," Susan Solomon advocates research using lab-grown stem cells. By growing individual pluripotent stem cell lines, her team creates testbeds that could accelerate research into curing diseases -- and perhaps lead to individualized treatment, targeted not just to a particular disease but a particular person.
Susan Solomon - Stem cell research advocate
Susan Solomon enables support for human stem cell research, aiming to cure major diseases and empower more personalized medicine. Full bio
Susan Solomon enables support for human stem cell research, aiming to cure major diseases and empower more personalized medicine. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:17
So, embryonic stem cells
0
1121
2989
00:20
are really incredible cells.
1
4110
3300
00:23
They are our body's own repair kits,
2
7410
2788
00:26
and they're pluripotent, which means they can morph into
3
10198
2964
00:29
all of the cells in our bodies.
4
13162
2432
00:31
Soon, we actually will be able to use stem cells
5
15594
2688
00:34
to replace cells that are damaged or diseased.
6
18282
2985
00:37
But that's not what I want to talk to you about,
7
21267
2431
00:39
because right now there are some really
8
23698
2678
00:42
extraordinary things that we are doing with stem cells
9
26376
3946
00:46
that are completely changing
10
30322
1607
00:47
the way we look and model disease,
11
31929
2899
00:50
our ability to understand why we get sick,
12
34828
2519
00:53
and even develop drugs.
13
37347
2431
00:55
I truly believe that stem cell research is going to allow
14
39778
4313
00:59
our children to look at Alzheimer's and diabetes
15
44091
4505
01:04
and other major diseases the way we view polio today,
16
48596
4391
01:08
which is as a preventable disease.
17
52987
3201
01:12
So here we have this incredible field, which has
18
56188
3223
01:15
enormous hope for humanity,
19
59411
4387
01:19
but much like IVF over 35 years ago,
20
63798
3520
01:23
until the birth of a healthy baby, Louise,
21
67318
2334
01:25
this field has been under siege politically and financially.
22
69652
5069
01:30
Critical research is being challenged instead of supported,
23
74721
4272
01:34
and we saw that it was really essential to have
24
78993
4360
01:39
private safe haven laboratories where this work
25
83353
3531
01:42
could be advanced without interference.
26
86884
2830
01:45
And so, in 2005,
27
89714
2531
01:48
we started the New York Stem Cell Foundation Laboratory
28
92245
2612
01:50
so that we would have a small organization that could
29
94857
3589
01:54
do this work and support it.
30
98446
3312
01:57
What we saw very quickly is the world of both medical
31
101758
3385
02:01
research, but also developing drugs and treatments,
32
105143
3376
02:04
is dominated by, as you would expect, large organizations,
33
108519
3713
02:08
but in a new field, sometimes large organizations
34
112232
3119
02:11
really have trouble getting out of their own way,
35
115351
2168
02:13
and sometimes they can't ask the right questions,
36
117519
2436
02:15
and there is an enormous gap that's just gotten larger
37
119955
3356
02:19
between academic research on the one hand
38
123311
3211
02:22
and pharmaceutical companies and biotechs
39
126522
2701
02:25
that are responsible for delivering all of our drugs
40
129223
3266
02:28
and many of our treatments, and so we knew that
41
132489
2390
02:30
to really accelerate cures and therapies, we were going
42
134879
3946
02:34
to have to address this with two things:
43
138825
2807
02:37
new technologies and also a new research model.
44
141632
3222
02:40
Because if you don't close that gap, you really are
45
144854
3759
02:44
exactly where we are today.
46
148613
1607
02:46
And that's what I want to focus on.
47
150220
1667
02:47
We've spent the last couple of years pondering this,
48
151887
3550
02:51
making a list of the different things that we had to do,
49
155437
2391
02:53
and so we developed a new technology,
50
157828
2631
02:56
It's software and hardware,
51
160459
1251
02:57
that actually can generate thousands and thousands of
52
161710
3503
03:01
genetically diverse stem cell lines to create
53
165213
3170
03:04
a global array, essentially avatars of ourselves.
54
168383
3787
03:08
And we did this because we think that it's actually going
55
172170
3434
03:11
to allow us to realize the potential, the promise,
56
175604
3415
03:14
of all of the sequencing of the human genome,
57
179019
3080
03:17
but it's going to allow us, in doing that,
58
182099
2504
03:20
to actually do clinical trials in a dish with human cells,
59
184603
5008
03:25
not animal cells, to generate drugs and treatments
60
189611
4159
03:29
that are much more effective, much safer,
61
193770
3249
03:32
much faster, and at a much lower cost.
62
197019
3256
03:36
So let me put that in perspective for you
63
200275
2384
03:38
and give you some context.
64
202659
1416
03:39
This is an extremely new field.
65
204075
4832
03:44
In 1998, human embryonic stem cells
66
208907
2832
03:47
were first identified, and just nine years later,
67
211739
3512
03:51
a group of scientists in Japan were able to take skin cells
68
215251
4305
03:55
and reprogram them with very powerful viruses
69
219556
3195
03:58
to create a kind of pluripotent stem cell
70
222751
4242
04:02
called an induced pluripotent stem cell,
71
226993
2090
04:04
or what we refer to as an IPS cell.
72
229083
3008
04:07
This was really an extraordinary advance, because
73
232091
3198
04:11
although these cells are not human embryonic stem cells,
74
235289
2544
04:13
which still remain the gold standard,
75
237833
1794
04:15
they are terrific to use for modeling disease
76
239627
3470
04:18
and potentially for drug discovery.
77
243097
2730
04:21
So a few months later, in 2008, one of our scientists
78
245827
3040
04:24
built on that research. He took skin biopsies,
79
248867
3200
04:27
this time from people who had a disease,
80
252067
2028
04:29
ALS, or as you call it in the U.K., motor neuron disease.
81
254095
2914
04:32
He turned them into the IPS cells
82
257009
1698
04:34
that I've just told you about, and then he turned those
83
258707
2686
04:37
IPS cells into the motor neurons that actually
84
261393
2704
04:39
were dying in the disease.
85
264097
1461
04:41
So basically what he did was to take a healthy cell
86
265558
3019
04:44
and turn it into a sick cell,
87
268577
1714
04:46
and he recapitulated the disease over and over again
88
270291
3558
04:49
in the dish, and this was extraordinary,
89
273849
3360
04:53
because it was the first time that we had a model
90
277209
2248
04:55
of a disease from a living patient in living human cells.
91
279457
4188
04:59
And as he watched the disease unfold, he was able
92
283645
3120
05:02
to discover that actually the motor neurons were dying
93
286765
3011
05:05
in the disease in a different way than the field
94
289776
2127
05:07
had previously thought. There was another kind of cell
95
291903
2494
05:10
that actually was sending out a toxin
96
294397
2201
05:12
and contributing to the death of these motor neurons,
97
296598
2511
05:15
and you simply couldn't see it
98
299109
1358
05:16
until you had the human model.
99
300467
1790
05:18
So you could really say that
100
302257
2667
05:20
researchers trying to understand the cause of disease
101
304924
3906
05:24
without being able to have human stem cell models
102
308830
4152
05:28
were much like investigators trying to figure out
103
312982
2760
05:31
what had gone terribly wrong in a plane crash
104
315742
3241
05:34
without having a black box, or a flight recorder.
105
318983
3997
05:38
They could hypothesize about what had gone wrong,
106
322980
2602
05:41
but they really had no way of knowing what led
107
325582
3112
05:44
to the terrible events.
108
328694
2172
05:46
And stem cells really have given us the black box
109
330866
4183
05:50
for diseases, and it's an unprecedented window.
110
335049
3968
05:54
It really is extraordinary, because you can recapitulate
111
339017
3245
05:58
many, many diseases in a dish, you can see
112
342262
3247
06:01
what begins to go wrong in the cellular conversation
113
345509
3536
06:04
well before you would ever see
114
349045
2424
06:07
symptoms appear in a patient.
115
351469
2536
06:09
And this opens up the ability,
116
354005
2523
06:12
which hopefully will become something that
117
356528
2814
06:15
is routine in the near term,
118
359342
2647
06:17
of using human cells to test for drugs.
119
361989
4146
06:22
Right now, the way we test for drugs is pretty problematic.
120
366135
5464
06:27
To bring a successful drug to market, it takes, on average,
121
371599
3318
06:30
13 years — that's one drug —
122
374917
2186
06:33
with a sunk cost of 4 billion dollars,
123
377103
3388
06:36
and only one percent of the drugs that start down that road
124
380491
4867
06:41
are actually going to get there.
125
385358
2248
06:43
You can't imagine other businesses
126
387606
2125
06:45
that you would think of going into
127
389731
1449
06:47
that have these kind of numbers.
128
391180
1755
06:48
It's a terrible business model.
129
392935
1802
06:50
But it is really a worse social model because of
130
394737
3989
06:54
what's involved and the cost to all of us.
131
398726
3328
06:57
So the way we develop drugs now
132
402054
3752
07:01
is by testing promising compounds on --
133
405806
3200
07:04
We didn't have disease modeling with human cells,
134
409006
1880
07:06
so we'd been testing them on cells of mice
135
410886
3464
07:10
or other creatures or cells that we engineer,
136
414350
3667
07:13
but they don't have the characteristics of the diseases
137
418017
3061
07:16
that we're actually trying to cure.
138
421078
2336
07:19
You know, we're not mice, and you can't go into
139
423414
3046
07:22
a living person with an illness
140
426460
2418
07:24
and just pull out a few brain cells or cardiac cells
141
428878
2928
07:27
and then start fooling around in a lab to test
142
431806
2289
07:29
for, you know, a promising drug.
143
434095
3561
07:33
But what you can do with human stem cells, now,
144
437656
3585
07:37
is actually create avatars, and you can create the cells,
145
441241
4337
07:41
whether it's the live motor neurons
146
445578
1967
07:43
or the beating cardiac cells or liver cells
147
447545
3010
07:46
or other kinds of cells, and you can test for drugs,
148
450555
4109
07:50
promising compounds, on the actual cells
149
454664
3125
07:53
that you're trying to affect, and this is now,
150
457789
3631
07:57
and it's absolutely extraordinary,
151
461420
2814
08:00
and you're going to know at the beginning,
152
464234
3156
08:03
the very early stages of doing your assay development
153
467390
3744
08:07
and your testing, you're not going to have to wait 13 years
154
471134
3389
08:10
until you've brought a drug to market, only to find out
155
474523
3319
08:13
that actually it doesn't work, or even worse, harms people.
156
477842
5056
08:18
But it isn't really enough just to look at
157
482898
4340
08:23
the cells from a few people or a small group of people,
158
487238
3782
08:26
because we have to step back.
159
491020
1644
08:28
We've got to look at the big picture.
160
492664
1851
08:30
Look around this room. We are all different,
161
494515
3136
08:33
and a disease that I might have,
162
497651
2740
08:36
if I had Alzheimer's disease or Parkinson's disease,
163
500391
2877
08:39
it probably would affect me differently than if
164
503268
3766
08:42
one of you had that disease,
165
507034
1641
08:44
and if we both had Parkinson's disease,
166
508675
4345
08:48
and we took the same medication,
167
513020
2268
08:51
but we had different genetic makeup,
168
515288
2747
08:53
we probably would have a different result,
169
518035
2285
08:56
and it could well be that a drug that worked wonderfully
170
520320
3731
08:59
for me was actually ineffective for you,
171
524051
3579
09:03
and similarly, it could be that a drug that is harmful for you
172
527630
4692
09:08
is safe for me, and, you know, this seems totally obvious,
173
532322
4302
09:12
but unfortunately it is not the way
174
536624
2728
09:15
that the pharmaceutical industry has been developing drugs
175
539352
3186
09:18
because, until now, it hasn't had the tools.
176
542538
3986
09:22
And so we need to move away
177
546524
2292
09:24
from this one-size-fits-all model.
178
548816
2954
09:27
The way we've been developing drugs is essentially
179
551770
3177
09:30
like going into a shoe store,
180
554947
1379
09:32
no one asks you what size you are, or
181
556326
2283
09:34
if you're going dancing or hiking.
182
558609
2210
09:36
They just say, "Well, you have feet, here are your shoes."
183
560819
2808
09:39
It doesn't work with shoes, and our bodies are
184
563627
3600
09:43
many times more complicated than just our feet.
185
567227
3472
09:46
So we really have to change this.
186
570699
2541
09:49
There was a very sad example of this in the last decade.
187
573240
5184
09:54
There's a wonderful drug, and a class of drugs actually,
188
578424
2648
09:56
but the particular drug was Vioxx, and
189
581072
2680
09:59
for people who were suffering from severe arthritis pain,
190
583752
4376
10:04
the drug was an absolute lifesaver,
191
588128
3392
10:07
but unfortunately, for another subset of those people,
192
591520
5080
10:12
they suffered pretty severe heart side effects,
193
596600
4769
10:17
and for a subset of those people, the side effects were
194
601369
2728
10:19
so severe, the cardiac side effects, that they were fatal.
195
604097
3897
10:23
But imagine a different scenario,
196
607994
4042
10:27
where we could have had an array, a genetically diverse array,
197
612036
4302
10:32
of cardiac cells, and we could have actually tested
198
616338
3626
10:35
that drug, Vioxx, in petri dishes, and figured out,
199
619964
5081
10:40
well, okay, people with this genetic type are going to have
200
625045
3744
10:44
cardiac side effects, people with these genetic subgroups
201
628789
5000
10:49
or genetic shoes sizes, about 25,000 of them,
202
633789
5144
10:54
are not going to have any problems.
203
638933
2760
10:57
The people for whom it was a lifesaver
204
641693
2615
11:00
could have still taken their medicine.
205
644308
1677
11:01
The people for whom it was a disaster, or fatal,
206
645985
4386
11:06
would never have been given it, and
207
650371
2091
11:08
you can imagine a very different outcome for the company,
208
652462
2583
11:10
who had to withdraw the drug.
209
655045
2768
11:13
So that is terrific,
210
657813
2816
11:16
and we thought, all right,
211
660629
1834
11:18
as we're trying to solve this problem,
212
662463
2759
11:21
clearly we have to think about genetics,
213
665222
2197
11:23
we have to think about human testing,
214
667419
2834
11:26
but there's a fundamental problem,
215
670253
1579
11:27
because right now, stem cell lines,
216
671832
2699
11:30
as extraordinary as they are,
217
674531
1710
11:32
and lines are just groups of cells,
218
676241
1744
11:33
they are made by hand, one at a time,
219
677985
4332
11:38
and it takes a couple of months.
220
682317
2224
11:40
This is not scalable, and also when you do things by hand,
221
684541
4366
11:44
even in the best laboratories,
222
688907
1543
11:46
you have variations in techniques,
223
690450
3161
11:49
and you need to know, if you're making a drug,
224
693611
3181
11:52
that the Aspirin you're going to take out of the bottle
225
696792
1898
11:54
on Monday is the same as the Aspirin
226
698690
2440
11:57
that's going to come out of the bottle on Wednesday.
227
701130
2081
11:59
So we looked at this, and we thought, okay,
228
703211
3791
12:02
artisanal is wonderful in, you know, your clothing
229
707002
3152
12:06
and your bread and crafts, but
230
710154
2944
12:08
artisanal really isn't going to work in stem cells,
231
713098
2983
12:11
so we have to deal with this.
232
716081
2390
12:14
But even with that, there still was another big hurdle,
233
718471
3920
12:18
and that actually brings us back to
234
722391
3564
12:21
the mapping of the human genome, because
235
725955
2384
12:24
we're all different.
236
728339
2711
12:26
We know from the sequencing of the human genome
237
731050
2832
12:29
that it's shown us all of the A's, C's, G's and T's
238
733882
2557
12:32
that make up our genetic code,
239
736439
2468
12:34
but that code, by itself, our DNA,
240
738907
4269
12:39
is like looking at the ones and zeroes of the computer code
241
743176
4599
12:43
without having a computer that can read it.
242
747775
2825
12:46
It's like having an app without having a smartphone.
243
750600
3288
12:49
We needed to have a way of bringing the biology
244
753888
3884
12:53
to that incredible data,
245
757772
2209
12:55
and the way to do that was to find
246
759981
3115
12:58
a stand-in, a biological stand-in,
247
763096
2687
13:01
that could contain all of the genetic information,
248
765783
4025
13:05
but have it be arrayed in such a way
249
769808
2528
13:08
as it could be read together
250
772336
2864
13:11
and actually create this incredible avatar.
251
775200
3256
13:14
We need to have stem cells from all the genetic sub-types
252
778456
3704
13:18
that represent who we are.
253
782160
2952
13:21
So this is what we've built.
254
785112
2760
13:23
It's an automated robotic technology.
255
787872
3320
13:27
It has the capacity to produce thousands and thousands
256
791192
2608
13:29
of stem cell lines. It's genetically arrayed.
257
793800
4239
13:33
It has massively parallel processing capability,
258
798039
3749
13:37
and it's going to change the way drugs are discovered,
259
801788
3320
13:41
we hope, and I think eventually what's going to happen
260
805108
3835
13:44
is that we're going to want to re-screen drugs,
261
808943
2199
13:47
on arrays like this, that already exist,
262
811142
2491
13:49
all of the drugs that currently exist,
263
813633
1871
13:51
and in the future, you're going to be taking drugs
264
815504
2911
13:54
and treatments that have been tested for side effects
265
818415
2872
13:57
on all of the relevant cells,
266
821287
2303
13:59
on brain cells and heart cells and liver cells.
267
823590
3153
14:02
It really has brought us to the threshold
268
826743
3329
14:05
of personalized medicine.
269
830072
2214
14:08
It's here now, and in our family,
270
832286
4441
14:12
my son has type 1 diabetes,
271
836727
2938
14:15
which is still an incurable disease,
272
839665
2648
14:18
and I lost my parents to heart disease and cancer,
273
842313
3442
14:21
but I think that my story probably sounds familiar to you,
274
845755
3733
14:25
because probably a version of it is your story.
275
849488
4230
14:29
At some point in our lives, all of us,
276
853718
3944
14:33
or people we care about, become patients,
277
857662
2736
14:36
and that's why I think that stem cell research
278
860398
2609
14:38
is incredibly important for all of us.
279
863007
3383
14:42
Thank you. (Applause)
280
866390
3668
14:45
(Applause)
281
870058
7108
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Susan Solomon - Stem cell research advocateSusan Solomon enables support for human stem cell research, aiming to cure major diseases and empower more personalized medicine.
Why you should listen
Susan Solomon’s health care advocacy stems from personal medical trials—namely, her son’s Type 1 diabetes and her mother’s fatal cancer. Following a successful career as a lawyer and business entrepreneur, Solomon, frustrated by the slow pace of medical research, was inspired to use those skills to follow another passion: accelerating medical research with real-world results as a social entrepreneur. And through her own research and conversations with medical experts, she decided that stem cells (cells that have the ability to morph into any other kind of cell) had the greatest potential to impact peoples’ health.
In 2005, Solomon founded the New York Stem Cell Foundation, now one of the largest nonprofit research institutions and laboratories in this field in the world. The NYSCF Research Institute conducts all facets of stem cell research from growing the cells to drug discovery.
At TEDGlobal 2012, Solomon announced the NYSCF Global Stem Cell Array, the new technology to create thousands of stem cell avatars and genetically array them to functionalize the data from the human genome to revolutionize the way we develop cures and treatments so they are better, safer, less expensive and happen much more quickly.
Susan Solomon | Speaker | TED.com