TEDGlobal 2012
Jason McCue: Terrorism is a failed brand
Filmed:
Readability: 4.1
827,870 views
In this gripping talk, lawyer Jason McCue urges for a new way to attack terrorism, to weaken its credibility with those who are buying the product -- the recruits. He shares stories of real cases where he and other activists used this approach to engage and create change.
Jason McCue - Lawyer
Jason McCue litigates against terrorists, dictators and others who seem above the law, using the legal and judicial system in innovative ways. Full bio
Jason McCue litigates against terrorists, dictators and others who seem above the law, using the legal and judicial system in innovative ways. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
We most certainly do talk to terrorists, no question about it.
0
521
4835
00:21
We are at war with a new form of terrorism.
1
5356
5886
00:27
It's sort of the good old, traditional form of terrorism,
2
11242
3502
00:30
but it's sort of been packaged for the 21st century.
3
14744
3462
00:34
One of the big things about countering terrorism
4
18206
4448
00:38
is, how do you perceive it?
5
22654
3332
00:41
Because perception leads to your response to it.
6
25986
3496
00:45
So if you have a traditional perception of terrorism,
7
29482
4228
00:49
it would be that it's one of criminality, one of war.
8
33710
3948
00:53
So how are you going to respond to it?
9
37658
1613
00:55
Naturally, it would follow that you meet kind with kind.
10
39271
3634
00:58
You fight it. If you have a more modernist approach,
11
42905
3831
01:02
and your perception of terrorism is almost cause-and-effect,
12
46736
4256
01:06
then naturally from that, the responses that come out of it
13
50992
3963
01:10
are much more asymmetrical.
14
54955
3648
01:14
We live in a modern, global world.
15
58603
4107
01:18
Terrorists have actually adapted to it.
16
62710
3482
01:22
It's something we have to, too, and that means the people
17
66192
3749
01:25
who are working on counterterrorism responses
18
69941
3140
01:28
have to start, in effect, putting on
19
73081
2824
01:31
their Google-tinted glasses, or whatever.
20
75905
4254
01:36
For my part, what I wanted us to do was just to look at
21
80159
4793
01:40
terrorism as though it was a global brand,
22
84952
3504
01:44
say, Coca-Cola.
23
88456
1629
01:45
Both are fairly bad for your health. (Laughter)
24
90085
6017
01:52
If you look at it as a brand in those ways,
25
96102
4030
01:56
what you'll come to realize is, it's a pretty flawed product.
26
100132
3264
01:59
As we've said, it's pretty bad for your health,
27
103396
3093
02:02
it's bad for those who it affects,
28
106489
2006
02:04
and it's not actually good if you're a suicide bomber either.
29
108495
3033
02:07
It doesn't actually do what it says on the tin.
30
111528
3616
02:11
You're not really going to get 72 virgins in heaven.
31
115144
4992
02:16
It's not going to happen, I don't think.
32
120136
2470
02:18
And you're not really going to, in the '80s, end capitalism
33
122606
3978
02:22
by supporting one of these groups. It's a load of nonsense.
34
126584
2921
02:25
But what you realize, it's got an Achilles' heel.
35
129505
3278
02:28
The brand has an Achilles' heel.
36
132783
2753
02:31
We've mentioned the health,
37
135536
1767
02:33
but it needs consumers to buy into it.
38
137303
3680
02:36
The consumers it needs are the terrorist constituency.
39
140983
4080
02:40
They're the people who buy into the brand, support them,
40
145063
2701
02:43
facilitate them, and they're the people
41
147764
3308
02:46
we've got to reach out to.
42
151072
2515
02:49
We've got to attack that brand in front of them.
43
153587
2860
02:52
There's two essential ways of doing that, if we carry on this brand theme.
44
156447
4253
02:56
One is reducing their market. What I mean is,
45
160700
3278
02:59
it's their brand against our brand. We've got to compete.
46
163978
4776
03:04
We've got to show we're a better product.
47
168754
2252
03:06
If I'm trying to show we're a better product,
48
171006
3157
03:10
I probably wouldn't do things like Guantanamo Bay.
49
174163
4931
03:14
We've talked there about curtailing the underlying need
50
179094
3665
03:18
for the product itself. You could be looking there at
51
182759
3648
03:22
poverty, injustice, all those sorts of things
52
186407
3585
03:25
which feed terrorism.
53
189992
1529
03:27
The other thing to do is to knock the product,
54
191521
3732
03:31
attack the brand myth, as we've said.
55
195253
2195
03:33
You know, there's nothing heroic about killing a young kid.
56
197448
3359
03:36
Perhaps we need to focus on that and get that message back across.
57
200807
4696
03:41
We've got to reveal the dangers in the product.
58
205503
3094
03:44
Our target audience, it's not just the producers of terrorism,
59
208597
3649
03:48
as I've said, the terrorists.
60
212246
1201
03:49
It's not just the marketeers of terrorism,
61
213447
2387
03:51
which is those who finance, those who facilitate it,
62
215834
4807
03:56
but it's the consumers of terrorism.
63
220641
1913
03:58
We've got to get in to those homelands.
64
222554
3234
04:01
That's where they recruit from. That's where they get their power and strength.
65
225788
3469
04:05
That's where their consumers come from.
66
229257
2352
04:07
And we have to get our messaging in there.
67
231609
3912
04:11
So the essentials are, we've got to have interaction
68
235521
3849
04:15
in those areas, with the terrorists, the facilitators, etc.
69
239370
3343
04:18
We've got to engage, we've got to educate,
70
242713
3135
04:21
and we've got to have dialogue.
71
245848
2803
04:24
Now, staying on this brand thing for just a few more seconds,
72
248651
4151
04:28
think about delivery mechanisms.
73
252802
3252
04:31
How are we going to do these attacks?
74
256054
1633
04:33
Well, reducing the market is really one for governments
75
257687
3009
04:36
and civil society. We've got to show we're better.
76
260696
3518
04:40
We've got to show our values.
77
264214
3842
04:43
We've got to practice what we preach.
78
268056
2302
04:46
But when it comes to knocking the brand,
79
270358
2213
04:48
if the terrorists are Coca-Cola and we're Pepsi,
80
272571
4472
04:52
I don't think, being Pepsi, anything we say about Coca-Cola,
81
277043
4014
04:56
anyone's going to believe us.
82
281057
1882
04:58
So we've got to find a different mechanism,
83
282939
2325
05:01
and one of the best mechanisms I've ever come across
84
285264
2392
05:03
is the victims of terrorism.
85
287656
2657
05:06
They are somebody who can actually stand there and say,
86
290313
2913
05:09
"This product's crap. I had it and I was sick for days.
87
293226
4428
05:13
It burnt my hand, whatever." You believe them.
88
297654
3446
05:17
You can see their scars. You trust them.
89
301100
2643
05:19
But whether it's victims, whether it's governments,
90
303743
5265
05:24
NGOs, or even the Queen yesterday, in Northern Ireland,
91
309008
5705
05:30
we have to interact and engage with those different
92
314713
4102
05:34
layers of terrorism, and, in effect,
93
318815
4595
05:39
we do have to have a little dance with the devil.
94
323410
4047
05:43
This is my favorite part of my speech.
95
327457
2983
05:46
I wanted to blow you all up to try and make a point,
96
330440
3256
05:49
but — (Laughter) —
97
333696
3722
05:53
TED, for health and safety reasons, have told me
98
337418
2788
05:56
I've got to do a countdown, so
99
340206
1506
05:57
I feel like a bit of an Irish or Jewish terrorist,
100
341712
3298
06:00
sort of a health and safety terrorist, and I — (Laughter) —
101
345010
5414
06:06
I've got to count 3, 2, 1, and
102
350424
3309
06:09
it's a bit alarming, so thinking of what my motto would be,
103
353733
3327
06:12
and it would be, "Body parts, not heart attacks."
104
357060
2758
06:15
So 3, 2, 1. (Explosion sound)
105
359818
5491
06:21
Very good. (Laughter)
106
365309
4947
06:26
Now, lady in 15J was a suicide bomber amongst us all.
107
370256
7809
06:33
We're all victims of terrorism.
108
378065
2125
06:36
There's 625 of us in this room. We're going to be scarred for life.
109
380190
4901
06:40
There was a father and a son who sat in that seat over there.
110
385091
4075
06:45
The son's dead. The father lives.
111
389166
2484
06:47
The father will probably kick himself for years to come
112
391650
5921
06:53
that he didn't take that seat instead of his kid.
113
397571
4239
06:57
He's going to take to alcohol, and he's probably
114
401810
2013
06:59
going to kill himself in three years. That's the stats.
115
403823
4360
07:04
There's a very young, attractive lady over here,
116
408183
3744
07:07
and she has something which I think's the worst form
117
411927
3028
07:10
of psychological, physical injury I've ever seen
118
414955
2796
07:13
out of a suicide bombing: It's human shrapnel.
119
417751
3696
07:17
What it means is, when she sat in a restaurant
120
421447
2153
07:19
in years to come, 10 years to come, 15 years to come,
121
423600
3005
07:22
or she's on the beach, every so often she's going to start
122
426605
2482
07:24
rubbing her skin, and out of there will come
123
429087
2973
07:27
a piece of that shrapnel.
124
432060
2234
07:30
And that is a hard thing for the head to take.
125
434294
5232
07:35
There's a lady over there as well who lost her legs
126
439526
2928
07:38
in this bombing.
127
442454
3512
07:41
She's going to find out that she gets a pitiful amount
128
445966
4084
07:45
of money off our government
129
450050
4107
07:50
for looking after what's happened to her.
130
454157
3292
07:53
She had a daughter who was going to go to one of the best
131
457449
2140
07:55
universities. She's going to give up university
132
459589
2701
07:58
to look after Mum.
133
462290
3729
08:01
We're all here, and all of those who watch it
134
466019
2532
08:04
are going to be traumatized by this event,
135
468551
2639
08:07
but all of you here who are victims are going to learn
136
471190
3148
08:10
some hard truths.
137
474338
1582
08:11
That is, our society, we sympathize, but after a while,
138
475920
4721
08:16
we start to ignore. We don't do enough as a society.
139
480641
3888
08:20
We do not look after our victims, and we do not enable them,
140
484529
3577
08:24
and what I'm going to try and show is that actually,
141
488106
3008
08:27
victims are the best weapon we have
142
491114
2784
08:29
against more terrorism.
143
493898
3176
08:32
How would the government at the turn of the millennium
144
497074
4216
08:37
approach today? Well, we all know.
145
501290
2225
08:39
What they'd have done then is an invasion.
146
503515
2604
08:42
If the suicide bomber was from Wales,
147
506119
3178
08:45
good luck to Wales, I'd say.
148
509297
2345
08:47
Knee-jerk legislation, emergency provision legislation --
149
511642
3752
08:51
which hits at the very basis of our society, as we all know --
150
515394
3699
08:54
it's a mistake.
151
519093
3173
08:58
We're going to drive prejudice throughout Edinburgh,
152
522266
3455
09:01
throughout the U.K., for Welsh people.
153
525721
4430
09:06
Today's approach, governments have learned from their mistakes.
154
530151
5645
09:11
They are looking at what I've started off on,
155
535796
2238
09:13
on these more asymmetrical approaches to it,
156
538034
3554
09:17
more modernist views, cause and effect.
157
541588
2702
09:20
But mistakes of the past are inevitable.
158
544290
2777
09:22
It's human nature.
159
547067
1500
09:24
The fear and the pressure to do something on them
160
548567
3736
09:28
is going to be immense. They are going to make mistakes.
161
552303
2280
09:30
They're not just going to be smart.
162
554583
3645
09:34
There was a famous Irish terrorist who once summed up
163
558228
3314
09:37
the point very beautifully. He said,
164
561542
3055
09:40
"The thing is, about the British government, is, is that it's got
165
564597
2112
09:42
to be lucky all the time, and we only have to be lucky once."
166
566709
4464
09:47
So what we need to do is we have to effect it.
167
571173
3240
09:50
We've got to start thinking about being more proactive.
168
574413
2756
09:53
We need to build an arsenal of noncombative weapons
169
577169
4688
09:57
in this war on terrorism.
170
581857
1621
09:59
But of course, it's ideas -- is not something that governments do very well.
171
583478
8448
10:07
I want to go back just to before the bang, to this idea of
172
591926
4179
10:12
brand, and I was talking about Coke and Pepsi, etc.
173
596105
4194
10:16
We see it as terrorism versus democracy in that brand war.
174
600299
3911
10:20
They'll see it as freedom fighters and truth
175
604210
2021
10:22
against injustice, imperialism, etc.
176
606231
7223
10:29
We do have to see this as a deadly battlefield.
177
613454
3991
10:33
It's not just [our] flesh and blood they want.
178
617445
3174
10:36
They actually want our cultural souls, and that's why
179
620619
2873
10:39
the brand analogy is a very interesting way of looking at this.
180
623492
4011
10:43
If we look at al Qaeda. Al Qaeda was essentially
181
627503
4580
10:47
a product on a shelf in a souk somewhere
182
632083
4540
10:52
which not many people had heard of.
183
636623
2139
10:54
9/11 launched it. It was its big marketing day,
184
638762
4164
10:58
and it was packaged for the 21st century. They knew what they were doing.
185
642926
4869
11:03
They were effectively [doing] something in this brand image
186
647795
3928
11:07
of creating a brand which can be franchised around
187
651723
3184
11:10
the world, where there's poverty, ignorance and injustice.
188
654907
5660
11:16
We, as I've said, have got to hit that market,
189
660567
4063
11:20
but we've got to use our heads rather than our might.
190
664630
3459
11:23
If we perceive it in this way as a brand, or other ways of thinking at it like this,
191
668089
3774
11:27
we will not resolve or counter terrorism.
192
671863
4439
11:32
What I'd like to do is just briefly go through a few examples
193
676302
3360
11:35
from my work on areas where we try and approach these things differently.
194
679662
5431
11:40
The first one has been dubbed "lawfare,"
195
685093
3689
11:44
for want of a better word.
196
688782
2442
11:47
When we originally looked at bringing civil actions against terrorists,
197
691224
4200
11:51
everyone thought we were a bit mad and mavericks
198
695424
2366
11:53
and crackpots. Now it's got a title. Everyone's doing it.
199
697790
3764
11:57
There's a bomb, people start suing.
200
701554
1613
11:59
But one of the first early cases on this was the Omagh Bombing.
201
703167
3691
12:02
A civil action was brought from 1998.
202
706858
3739
12:06
In Omagh, bomb went off, Real IRA,
203
710597
3408
12:09
middle of a peace process.
204
714005
2215
12:12
That meant that the culprits couldn't really be prosecuted
205
716220
4143
12:16
for lots of reasons, mostly to do with the peace process
206
720363
3248
12:19
and what was going on, the greater good.
207
723611
2217
12:21
It also meant, then, if you can imagine this,
208
725828
2495
12:24
that the people who bombed your children
209
728323
2303
12:26
and your husbands were walking around the supermarket
210
730626
5357
12:31
that you lived in.
211
735983
1684
12:33
Some of those victims said enough is enough.
212
737667
3762
12:37
We brought a private action, and thank God, 10 years later,
213
741429
3434
12:40
we actually won it. There is a slight appeal on
214
744863
2595
12:43
at the moment so I have to be a bit careful,
215
747458
1815
12:45
but I'm fairly confident.
216
749273
2102
12:47
Why was it effective?
217
751390
1619
12:48
It was effective not just because justice was seen to be done
218
753009
2637
12:51
where there was a huge void.
219
755646
1739
12:53
It was because the Real IRA and other terrorist groups,
220
757385
4626
12:57
their whole strength is from the fact that they are
221
762011
2079
12:59
an underdog. When we put the victims as the underdog
222
764090
4746
13:04
and flipped it, they didn't know what to do.
223
768836
3140
13:07
They were embarrassed. Their recruitment went down.
224
771976
4251
13:12
The bombs actually stopped -- fact -- because of this action.
225
776227
4288
13:16
We became, or those victims became, more importantly,
226
780515
3705
13:20
a ghost that haunted the terrorist organization.
227
784220
3976
13:24
There's other examples. We have a case called Almog
228
788196
2799
13:26
which is to do with a bank that was,
229
790995
4192
13:31
allegedly, from our point of view,
230
795187
3006
13:34
giving rewards to suicide bombers.
231
798193
3915
13:38
Just by bringing the very action,
232
802108
3008
13:41
that bank has stopped doing it, and indeed,
233
805116
2511
13:43
the powers that be around the world, which for real politic
234
807627
2404
13:45
reasons before, couldn't actually deal with this issue,
235
810031
3343
13:49
because there was lots of competing interests,
236
813374
1530
13:50
have actually closed down those loopholes in the banking system.
237
814904
2984
13:53
There's another case called the McDonald case,
238
817888
2715
13:56
where some victims of Semtex, of the Provisional IRA bombings,
239
820603
4322
14:00
which were supplied by Gaddafi, sued,
240
824925
6619
14:07
and that action has led to amazing things for new Libya.
241
831544
4937
14:12
New Libya has been compassionate towards those victims,
242
836481
2953
14:15
and started taking it -- so it started a whole new dialogue there.
243
839434
3632
14:18
But the problem is, we need more and more support
244
843066
4283
14:23
for these ideas and cases.
245
847349
2802
14:26
Civil affairs and civil society initiatives.
246
850151
4426
14:30
A good one is in Somalia. There's a war on piracy.
247
854577
2527
14:33
If anyone thinks you can have a war on piracy
248
857104
1806
14:34
like a war on terrorism and beat it, you're wrong.
249
858910
2626
14:37
What we're trying to do there is turn pirates to fisherman.
250
861536
2987
14:40
They used to be fisherman, of course,
251
864523
2224
14:42
but we stole their fish and dumped a load of toxic waste
252
866747
3196
14:45
in their water, so what we're trying to do is create
253
869943
3295
14:49
security and employment by bringing a coastguard
254
873238
2486
14:51
along with the fisheries industry, and I can guarantee you,
255
875724
3337
14:54
as that builds, al Shabaab and such likes will not have
256
879061
2864
14:57
the poverty and injustice any longer to prey on those people.
257
881925
3824
15:01
These initiatives cost less than a missile,
258
885749
3875
15:05
and certainly less than any soldier's life,
259
889624
2967
15:08
but more importantly, it takes the war to their homelands,
260
892591
2855
15:11
and not onto our shore,
261
895446
2298
15:13
and we're looking at the causes.
262
897744
1444
15:15
The last one I wanted to talk about was dialogue.
263
899188
3449
15:18
The advantages of dialogue are obvious.
264
902637
2806
15:21
It self-educates both sides, enables a better understanding,
265
905443
4302
15:25
reveals the strengths and weaknesses,
266
909745
2222
15:27
and yes, like some of the speakers before,
267
911967
2601
15:30
the shared vulnerability does lead to trust, and
268
914568
3889
15:34
it does then become, that process, part of normalization.
269
918457
2905
15:37
But it's not an easy road. After the bomb,
270
921362
4673
15:41
the victims are not into this.
271
926035
3129
15:45
There's practical problems.
272
929164
1894
15:46
It's politically risky for the protagonists
273
931058
2896
15:49
and for the interlocutors. On one occasion
274
933954
2735
15:52
I was doing it, every time I did a point that they didn't like,
275
936689
2441
15:55
they actually threw stones at me,
276
939130
1861
15:56
and when I did a point they liked,
277
940991
1987
15:58
they starting shooting in the air, equally not great. (Laughter)
278
942978
4595
16:03
Whatever the point, it gets to the heart of the problem,
279
947573
3202
16:06
you're doing it, you're talking to them.
280
950775
2116
16:08
Now, I just want to end with saying, if we follow reason,
281
952891
3743
16:12
we realize that I think we'd all say that we want to
282
956634
5362
16:17
have a perception of terrorism which is not just a pure
283
961996
2682
16:20
military perception of it.
284
964678
3749
16:24
We need to foster more
285
968446
2457
16:26
modern and asymmetrical responses to it.
286
970903
2785
16:29
This isn't about being soft on terrorism.
287
973688
2555
16:32
It's about fighting them on contemporary battlefields.
288
976243
3720
16:35
We must foster innovation, as I've said.
289
979963
2951
16:38
Governments are receptive. It won't come from those dusty corridors.
290
982914
3872
16:42
The private sector has a role.
291
986786
2213
16:44
The role we could do right now is going away
292
988999
2573
16:47
and looking at how we can support victims around the world
293
991572
3725
16:51
to bring initiatives.
294
995297
1472
16:52
If I was to leave you with some big questions here which
295
996769
2803
16:55
may change one's perception to it, and who knows what
296
999572
3475
16:58
thoughts and responses will come out of it,
297
1003047
2379
17:01
but did myself and my terrorist group actually need
298
1005426
3955
17:05
to blow you up to make our point?
299
1009381
3236
17:08
We have to ask ourselves these questions, however unpalatable.
300
1012617
4382
17:12
Have we been ignoring an injustice or a humanitarian
301
1016999
3134
17:16
struggle somewhere in the world?
302
1020133
2765
17:18
What if, actually, engagement on poverty and injustice
303
1022898
2650
17:21
is exactly what the terrorists wanted us to do?
304
1025548
2415
17:23
What if the bombs are just simply wake-up calls for us?
305
1027963
3105
17:26
What happens if that bomb went off
306
1031068
3199
17:30
because we didn't have any thoughts and things in place
307
1034267
3307
17:33
to allow dialogue to deal with these things and interaction?
308
1037574
4679
17:38
What is definitely uncontroversial
309
1042253
3167
17:41
is that, as I've said, we've got to stop being reactive,
310
1045420
1807
17:43
and more proactive, and I just want to leave you
311
1047227
3617
17:46
with one idea, which is that
312
1050844
3408
17:50
it's a provocative question for you to think about,
313
1054252
3160
17:53
and the answer will require sympathy with the devil.
314
1057412
4121
17:57
It's a question that's been tackled by many great thinkers
315
1061533
2717
18:00
and writers: What if society actually needs crisis to change?
316
1064250
4917
18:05
What if society actually needs terrorism
317
1069167
4303
18:09
to change and adapt for the better?
318
1073470
1543
18:10
It's those Bulgakov themes, it's that picture of Jesus
319
1075013
4551
18:15
and the Devil hand in hand in Gethsemane
320
1079564
3204
18:18
walking into the moonlight.
321
1082768
2280
18:20
What it would mean is that humans,
322
1085048
2848
18:23
in order to survive in development,
323
1087896
2656
18:26
quite Darwinian spirit here,
324
1090552
2075
18:28
inherently must dance with the devil.
325
1092627
4330
18:32
A lot of people say that communism was defeated
326
1096957
4259
18:37
by the Rolling Stones. It's a good theory.
327
1101216
3994
18:41
Maybe the Rolling Stones has a place in this.
328
1105210
2836
18:43
Thank you.
329
1108046
2587
18:46
(Music) (Applause)
330
1110633
8870
18:55
Bruno Giussani: Thank you. (Applause)
331
1119503
2578
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jason McCue - LawyerJason McCue litigates against terrorists, dictators and others who seem above the law, using the legal and judicial system in innovative ways.
Why you should listen
Jason McCue uses the legal system of the UK (and increasingly the world) to fight for human rights. In 2009, he won a landmark civil case at the high court in Belfast that resulted in a settlement for victims of the 1998 Omagh bombing by the Real IRA -- after attempts to prosecute the group in criminal courts had failed. It was a bold legal strategy now being copied for other victims, such as those of Libyan-supported terrorism and of the attacks in London and Mumbai. In September 2011 he and his firm launched another strategy for prosecuting Alexander Lukashenko, the dictator of Belarus, on counts of torture and hostage-taking: creating a "prosecution kit" to be sent to courts around the world. Wherever Lukashenko travels, he now faces the prospect of prosecution.
McCue is also a partner, with his wife, TV star Mariella Frostrup, of the GREAT Initiative: the Gender Rights and Equality Action Trust.
Jason McCue | Speaker | TED.com