TED2007
Laurie Garrett: Lessons from the 1918 flu
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
544,419 views
In 2007, as the world worried about a possible avian flu epidemic, Laurie Garrett, author of "The Coming Plague," gave this powerful talk to a small TED University audience. Her insights from past pandemics are suddenly more relevant than ever.
Laurie Garrett - Science journalist
Pulitzer winner Laurie Garrett studies global health and disease prevention. Her books include "The Coming Plague" and "Betrayal of Trust," about the crisis in global public health. Full bio
Pulitzer winner Laurie Garrett studies global health and disease prevention. Her books include "The Coming Plague" and "Betrayal of Trust," about the crisis in global public health. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
So the first question is, why do we need to
0
0
2000
00:14
even worry about a pandemic threat?
1
2000
3000
00:17
What is it that we're concerned about?
2
5000
2000
00:19
When I say "we," I'm at the Council on Foreign Relations.
3
7000
3000
00:22
We're concerned in the national security community,
4
10000
2000
00:24
and of course in the biology community and the public health community.
5
12000
3000
00:27
While globalization has increased travel,
6
15000
2000
00:29
it's made it necessary that everybody be everywhere,
7
17000
3000
00:32
all the time, all over the world.
8
20000
2000
00:34
And that means that your microbial hitchhikers are moving with you.
9
22000
3000
00:37
So a plague outbreak in Surat, India
10
25000
2000
00:39
becomes not an obscure event, but a globalized event --
11
27000
3000
00:42
a globalized concern that has changed the risk equation.
12
30000
3000
00:45
Katrina showed us
13
33000
2000
00:47
that we cannot completely depend on government
14
35000
2000
00:49
to have readiness in hand, to be capable of handling things.
15
37000
3000
00:52
Indeed, an outbreak would be multiple Katrinas at once.
16
40000
4000
00:56
Our big concern at the moment is a virus called H5N1 flu --
17
44000
3000
00:59
some of you call it bird flu --
18
47000
2000
01:01
which first emerged in southern China, in the mid-1990s,
19
49000
3000
01:04
but we didn't know about it until 1997.
20
52000
3000
01:07
At the end of last Christmas only 13 countries had seen H5N1.
21
55000
4000
01:11
But we're now up to 55 countries in the world,
22
59000
2000
01:13
have had this virus emerge,
23
61000
2000
01:15
in either birds, or people or both.
24
63000
3000
01:18
In the bird outbreaks we now can see
25
66000
2000
01:20
that pretty much the whole world has seen this virus
26
68000
3000
01:23
except the Americas.
27
71000
2000
01:25
And I'll get into why we've so far been spared in a moment.
28
73000
4000
01:29
In domestic birds, especially chickens,
29
77000
2000
01:31
it's 100 percent lethal.
30
79000
2000
01:33
It's one of the most lethal things we've seen
31
81000
2000
01:35
in circulation in the world
32
83000
2000
01:37
in any recent centuries.
33
85000
2000
01:39
And we've dealt with it by killing off lots and lots and lots of chickens,
34
87000
3000
01:42
and unfortunately often not reimbursing the peasant farmers
35
90000
3000
01:45
with the result that there's cover-up.
36
93000
2000
01:47
It's also carried on migration patterns
37
95000
2000
01:49
of wild migratory aquatic birds.
38
97000
3000
01:52
There has been this centralized event
39
100000
2000
01:54
in a place called Lake Chenghai, China.
40
102000
2000
01:56
Two years ago the migrating birds
41
104000
2000
01:58
had a multiple event
42
106000
2000
02:00
where thousands died because of a mutation occurring
43
108000
2000
02:02
in the virus,
44
110000
2000
02:04
which made the species range broaden dramatically.
45
112000
3000
02:07
So that birds going to Siberia, to Europe, and to Africa
46
115000
3000
02:10
carried the virus, which had not previously been possible.
47
118000
3000
02:13
We're now seeing outbreaks in human populations --
48
121000
4000
02:17
so far, fortunately, small events,
49
125000
3000
02:20
tiny outbreaks, occasional clusters.
50
128000
3000
02:23
The virus has mutated dramatically in the last two years
51
131000
3000
02:26
to form two distinct families, if you will,
52
134000
3000
02:29
of the H5N1 viral tree
53
137000
2000
02:31
with branches in them,
54
139000
2000
02:33
and with different attributes that are worrying.
55
141000
2000
02:35
So what's concerning us? Well, first of all,
56
143000
2000
02:37
at no time in history have we succeeded in making
57
145000
3000
02:40
in a timely fashion, a specific vaccine
58
148000
2000
02:42
for more than 260 million people.
59
150000
3000
02:45
It's not going to do us very much good in a global pandemic.
60
153000
3000
02:48
You've heard about the vaccine we're stockpiling.
61
156000
3000
02:51
But nobody believes it will actually be particularly effective
62
159000
2000
02:53
if we have a real outbreak.
63
161000
2000
02:55
So one thought is:
64
163000
2000
02:57
after 9/11, when the airports closed,
65
165000
2000
02:59
our flu season was delayed by two weeks.
66
167000
2000
03:01
So the thought is, hey, maybe what we should do is just
67
169000
2000
03:03
immediately -- we hear there is H5N1 spreading from human to human,
68
171000
4000
03:07
the virus has mutated to be a human-to-human transmitter --
69
175000
2000
03:09
let's shut down the airports.
70
177000
2000
03:11
However, huge supercomputer analyses,
71
179000
4000
03:15
done of the likely effectiveness of this,
72
183000
2000
03:17
show that it won't buy us much time at all.
73
185000
2000
03:19
And of course it will be hugely disruptive in preparation plans.
74
187000
4000
03:23
For example, all masks are made in China.
75
191000
3000
03:26
How do you get them mobilized around the world
76
194000
2000
03:28
if you've shut all the airports down?
77
196000
2000
03:30
How do you get the vaccines moved around the world
78
198000
2000
03:32
and the drugs moved, and whatever may or not be available that would work.
79
200000
3000
03:35
So it turns out that shutting down the airports is counterproductive.
80
203000
4000
03:39
We're worried because this virus, unlike any other flu
81
207000
3000
03:42
we've ever studied, can be transmitted by eating raw meat
82
210000
4000
03:46
of the infected animals.
83
214000
2000
03:48
We've seen transmission to wild cats and domestic cats,
84
216000
3000
03:51
and now also domestic pet dogs.
85
219000
3000
03:54
And in experimental feedings to rodents and ferrets,
86
222000
3000
03:57
we found that the animals exhibit symptoms never seen with flu:
87
225000
4000
04:01
seizures, central nervous system disorders, partial paralysis.
88
229000
3000
04:04
This is not your normal garden-variety flu.
89
232000
3000
04:07
It mimics what we now understand
90
235000
2000
04:09
about reconstructing the 1918 flu virus,
91
237000
2000
04:11
the last great pandemic,
92
239000
2000
04:13
in that it also jumped directly from birds to people.
93
241000
2000
04:15
We had evolution over time,
94
243000
2000
04:17
and this unbelievable mortality rate in human beings:
95
245000
4000
04:21
55 percent of people who have become infected
96
249000
2000
04:23
with H5N1 have, in fact, succumbed.
97
251000
4000
04:27
And we don't have a huge number of people
98
255000
2000
04:29
who got infected and never developed disease.
99
257000
3000
04:32
In experimental feeding in monkeys
100
260000
2000
04:34
you can see that it actually downregulates
101
262000
2000
04:36
a specific immune system modulator.
102
264000
2000
04:38
The result is that what kills you
103
266000
2000
04:40
is not the virus directly, but your own immune system overreacting, saying,
104
268000
3000
04:43
"Whatever this is so foreign I'm going berserk."
105
271000
3000
04:46
The result: most of the deaths
106
274000
2000
04:48
have been in people under 30 years of age,
107
276000
2000
04:50
robustly healthy young adults.
108
278000
3000
04:53
We have seen human-to-human transmission
109
281000
2000
04:55
in at least three clusters --
110
283000
2000
04:57
fortunately involving very intimate contact,
111
285000
3000
05:00
still not putting the world at large at any kind of risk.
112
288000
3000
05:03
Alright, so I've got you nervous.
113
291000
2000
05:05
Now you probably assume, well the governments are going to do something.
114
293000
3000
05:08
And we have spent a lot of money.
115
296000
2000
05:10
Most of the spending in the Bush administration
116
298000
2000
05:12
has actually been more related to the anthrax results
117
300000
4000
05:16
and bio-terrorism threat.
118
304000
2000
05:18
But a lot of money has been thrown out at the local level and at the federal level
119
306000
3000
05:21
to look at infectious diseases.
120
309000
2000
05:23
End result: only 15 states
121
311000
2000
05:25
have been certified to be able to do mass distribution
122
313000
2000
05:27
of vaccine and drugs in a pandemic.
123
315000
3000
05:30
Half the states would run out of hospital beds
124
318000
2000
05:32
in the first week, maybe two weeks.
125
320000
2000
05:34
And 40 states already have an acute nursing shortage.
126
322000
3000
05:37
Add on pandemic threat, you're in big trouble.
127
325000
2000
05:39
So what have people been doing with this money?
128
327000
2000
05:41
Exercises, drills, all over the world.
129
329000
2000
05:43
Let's pretend there's a pandemic.
130
331000
2000
05:45
Let's everybody run around and play your role.
131
333000
2000
05:47
Main result is that there is tremendous confusion.
132
335000
3000
05:50
Most of these people don't actually know what their job will be.
133
338000
3000
05:53
And the bottom line, major thing that has come through
134
341000
2000
05:55
in every single drill: nobody knows who's in charge.
135
343000
3000
05:58
Nobody knows the chain of command.
136
346000
2000
06:00
If it were Los Angeles, is it the mayor, the governor,
137
348000
3000
06:03
the President of the United States, the head of Homeland Security?
138
351000
3000
06:06
In fact, the federal government says it's a guy called
139
354000
2000
06:08
the Principle Federal Officer,
140
356000
3000
06:11
who happens to be with TSA.
141
359000
2000
06:13
The government says
142
361000
1000
06:14
the federal responsibility will basically be
143
362000
3000
06:17
about trying to keep the virus out, which we all know is impossible,
144
365000
3000
06:20
and then to mitigate the impact
145
368000
2000
06:22
primarily on our economy.
146
370000
3000
06:25
The rest is up to your local community.
147
373000
2000
06:27
Everything is about your town, where you live.
148
375000
3000
06:30
Well how good a city council you have,
149
378000
2000
06:32
how good a mayor you have -- that's who's going to be in charge.
150
380000
4000
06:36
Most local facilities would all be competing
151
384000
2000
06:38
to try and get their hands on their piece
152
386000
2000
06:40
of the federal stockpile of a drug called Tamiflu,
153
388000
3000
06:43
which may or may not be helpful -- I'll get into that --
154
391000
2000
06:45
of available vaccines, and any other treatments,
155
393000
3000
06:48
and masks, and anything that's been stockpiled.
156
396000
3000
06:51
And you'll have massive competition.
157
399000
3000
06:54
Now we did purchase a vaccine, you've probably all heard about it,
158
402000
2000
06:56
made by Sanofi-Aventis.
159
404000
2000
06:58
Unfortunately it's made against the current form of H5N1.
160
406000
3000
07:01
We know the virus will mutate. It will be a different virus.
161
409000
3000
07:04
The vaccine will probably be useless.
162
412000
3000
07:07
So here's where the decisions come in.
163
415000
2000
07:09
You're the mayor of your local town.
164
417000
2000
07:11
Let's see, should we order that all pets be kept indoors?
165
419000
3000
07:14
Germany did that when H5N1 appeared in Germany last year,
166
422000
3000
07:17
in order to minimize the spread
167
425000
2000
07:19
between households by household cats, dogs and so on.
168
427000
4000
07:23
What do we do when we don't have any containment rooms
169
431000
4000
07:27
with reverse air that will allow the healthcare workers
170
435000
2000
07:29
to take care of patients?
171
437000
2000
07:31
These are in Hong Kong; we have nothing like that here.
172
439000
2000
07:33
What about quarantine?
173
441000
2000
07:35
During the SARS epidemic in Beijing quarantine did seem to help.
174
443000
3000
07:38
We have no uniform policies
175
446000
2000
07:40
regarding quarantine across the United States.
176
448000
2000
07:42
And some states have differential policies, county by county.
177
450000
4000
07:46
But what about the no-brainer things? Should we close all the schools?
178
454000
3000
07:49
Well then what about all the workers? They won't go to work
179
457000
2000
07:51
if their kids aren't in school.
180
459000
2000
07:53
Encouraging telecommuting? What works?
181
461000
2000
07:55
Well the British government did a model of telecommuting.
182
463000
3000
07:58
Six weeks they had all people in the banking industry
183
466000
3000
08:01
pretend a pandemic was underway.
184
469000
2000
08:03
What they found was, the core functions --
185
471000
2000
08:05
you know you still sort of had banks,
186
473000
2000
08:07
but you couldn't get people to put money in the ATM machines.
187
475000
3000
08:10
Nobody was processing the credit cards.
188
478000
2000
08:12
Your insurance payments didn't go through.
189
480000
2000
08:14
And basically the economy would be in a disaster state of affairs.
190
482000
3000
08:17
And that's just office workers, bankers.
191
485000
4000
08:21
We don't know how important hand washing is for flu --
192
489000
3000
08:24
shocking. One assumes it's a good idea to wash your hands a lot.
193
492000
3000
08:27
But actually in scientific community there is great debate
194
495000
2000
08:29
about what percentage of flu transmission between people
195
497000
3000
08:32
is from sneezing and coughing
196
500000
2000
08:34
and what percentage is on your hands.
197
502000
2000
08:36
The Institute of Medicine tried to look at the masking question.
198
504000
4000
08:40
Can we figure out a way, since we know we won't have enough masks
199
508000
2000
08:42
because we don't make them in America anymore,
200
510000
2000
08:44
they're all made in China --
201
512000
2000
08:46
do we need N95? A state-of-the-art, top-of-the-line,
202
514000
3000
08:49
must-be-fitted-to-your-face mask?
203
517000
3000
08:52
Or can we get away with some different kinds of masks?
204
520000
3000
08:55
In the SARS epidemic, we learned in Hong Kong
205
523000
2000
08:57
that most of transmission was because
206
525000
2000
08:59
people were removing their masks improperly.
207
527000
2000
09:01
And their hand got contaminated with the outside of the mask,
208
529000
2000
09:03
and then they rubbed their nose. Bingo! They got SARS.
209
531000
3000
09:06
It wasn't flying microbes.
210
534000
3000
09:09
If you go online right now, you'll get so much phony-baloney information.
211
537000
3000
09:12
You'll end up buying -- this is called an N95 mask. Ridiculous.
212
540000
5000
09:17
We don't actually have a standard
213
545000
2000
09:19
for what should be the protective gear for the first responders,
214
547000
3000
09:22
the people who will actually be there on the front lines.
215
550000
3000
09:25
And Tamiflu. You've probably heard of this drug,
216
553000
2000
09:27
made by Hoffmann-La Roche, patented drug.
217
555000
3000
09:30
There is some indication
218
558000
2000
09:32
that it may buy you some time in the midst of an outbreak.
219
560000
3000
09:35
Should you take Tamiflu for a long period of time,
220
563000
2000
09:37
well, one of the side effects is suicidal ideations.
221
565000
3000
09:40
A public health survey analyzed the effect
222
568000
4000
09:44
that large-scale Tamiflu use would have,
223
572000
2000
09:46
actually shows it counteractive
224
574000
2000
09:48
to public health measures, making matters worse.
225
576000
3000
09:51
And here is the other interesting thing:
226
579000
2000
09:53
when a human being ingests Tamiflu, only 20 percent
227
581000
2000
09:55
is metabolized appropriately
228
583000
2000
09:57
to be an active compound in the human being.
229
585000
2000
09:59
The rest turns into a stable compound,
230
587000
4000
10:03
which survives filtration into the water systems,
231
591000
3000
10:06
thereby exposing the very aquatic birds that would carry flu
232
594000
3000
10:09
and providing them a chance
233
597000
2000
10:11
to breed resistant strains.
234
599000
2000
10:13
And we now have seen Tamiflu-resistant strains
235
601000
3000
10:16
in both Vietnam in person-to-person transmission,
236
604000
3000
10:19
and in Egypt in person-to-person transmission.
237
607000
2000
10:21
So I personally think that our life expectancy
238
609000
3000
10:24
for Tamiflu as an effective drug
239
612000
3000
10:27
is very limited -- very limited indeed.
240
615000
2000
10:29
Nevertheless most of the governments
241
617000
2000
10:31
have based their whole flu policies
242
619000
2000
10:33
on building stockpiles of Tamiflu.
243
621000
2000
10:35
Russia has actually stockpiled enough
244
623000
2000
10:37
for 95 percent of all Russians.
245
625000
2000
10:39
We've stockpiled enough for 30 percent.
246
627000
2000
10:41
When I say enough, that's two weeks worth.
247
629000
2000
10:43
And then you're on your own because
248
631000
2000
10:45
the pandemic is going to last for 18 to 24 months.
249
633000
2000
10:47
Some of the poorer countries
250
635000
2000
10:49
that have had the most experience with H5N1 have built up stockpiles;
251
637000
3000
10:52
they're already expired. They are already out of date.
252
640000
3000
10:55
What do we know from 1918,
253
643000
2000
10:57
the last great pandemic?
254
645000
2000
10:59
The federal government abdicated most responsibility.
255
647000
3000
11:02
And so we ended up with this wild patchwork of regulations
256
650000
3000
11:05
all over America.
257
653000
2000
11:07
Every city, county, state did their own thing.
258
655000
2000
11:09
And the rules
259
657000
2000
11:11
and the belief systems were wildly disparate.
260
659000
3000
11:14
In some cases all schools, all churches,
261
662000
3000
11:17
all public venues were closed.
262
665000
2000
11:19
The pandemic circulated three times in 18 months
263
667000
3000
11:22
in the absence of commercial air travel.
264
670000
2000
11:24
The second wave was the mutated, super-killer wave.
265
672000
3000
11:27
And in the first wave we had enough healthcare workers.
266
675000
3000
11:30
But by the time the second wave hit
267
678000
2000
11:32
it took such a toll among the healthcare workers
268
680000
3000
11:35
that we lost most of our doctors and nurses that were on the front lines.
269
683000
4000
11:39
Overall we lost 700,000 people.
270
687000
2000
11:41
The virus was 100 percent lethal to pregnant women
271
689000
3000
11:44
and we don't actually know why.
272
692000
2000
11:46
Most of the death toll was 15 to 40 year-olds --
273
694000
3000
11:49
robustly healthy young adults.
274
697000
2000
11:51
It was likened to the plague.
275
699000
2000
11:53
We don't actually know how many people died.
276
701000
2000
11:55
The low-ball estimate is 35 million.
277
703000
3000
11:58
This was based on European and North American data.
278
706000
3000
12:01
A new study by Chris Murray at Harvard
279
709000
2000
12:03
shows that if you look at the databases that were kept
280
711000
2000
12:05
by the Brits in India,
281
713000
2000
12:07
there was a 31-fold greater death rate among the Indians.
282
715000
4000
12:11
So there is a strong belief that in places of poverty
283
719000
3000
12:14
the death toll was far higher.
284
722000
2000
12:16
And that a more likely toll
285
724000
2000
12:18
is somewhere in the neighborhood of 80 to 100 million people
286
726000
2000
12:20
before we had commercial air travel.
287
728000
3000
12:23
So are we ready?
288
731000
2000
12:25
As a nation, no we're not.
289
733000
2000
12:27
And I think even those in the leadership
290
735000
2000
12:29
would say that is the case,
291
737000
2000
12:31
that we still have a long ways to go.
292
739000
2000
12:33
So what does that mean for you? Well the first thing is,
293
741000
2000
12:35
I wouldn't start building up personal stockpiles of anything --
294
743000
3000
12:38
for yourself, your family, or your employees --
295
746000
4000
12:42
unless you've really done your homework.
296
750000
3000
12:45
What mask works, what mask doesn't work.
297
753000
2000
12:47
How many masks do you need?
298
755000
2000
12:49
The Institute of Medicine study felt that
299
757000
2000
12:51
you could not recycle masks.
300
759000
2000
12:53
Well if you think it's going to last 18 months,
301
761000
3000
12:56
are you going to buy 18 months worth of masks
302
764000
2000
12:58
for every single person in your family?
303
766000
3000
13:01
We don't know -- again with Tamiflu,
304
769000
4000
13:05
the number one side effect of Tamiflu is
305
773000
2000
13:07
flu-like symptoms.
306
775000
2000
13:09
So then how can you tell
307
777000
2000
13:11
who in your family has the flu
308
779000
2000
13:13
if everybody is taking Tamiflu?
309
781000
3000
13:16
If you expand that out to think of a whole community,
310
784000
3000
13:19
or all your employees in your company,
311
787000
3000
13:22
you begin to realize how limited
312
790000
2000
13:24
the Tamiflu option might be.
313
792000
2000
13:26
Everybody has come up to me and said,
314
794000
2000
13:28
well I'll stockpile water or, I'll stockpile food, or what have you.
315
796000
4000
13:32
But really? Do you really have a place
316
800000
3000
13:35
to stockpile 18 months worth of food? Twenty-four months worth of food?
317
803000
3000
13:38
Do you want to view the pandemic threat
318
806000
2000
13:40
the way back in the 1950s
319
808000
2000
13:42
people viewed the civil defense issue,
320
810000
2000
13:44
and build your own little bomb shelter for pandemic flu?
321
812000
3000
13:47
I don't think that's rational.
322
815000
2000
13:49
I think it's about having to be prepared
323
817000
2000
13:51
as communities, not as individuals --
324
819000
2000
13:53
being prepared as nation,
325
821000
2000
13:55
being prepared as state, being prepared as town.
326
823000
3000
13:58
And right now most of the preparedness
327
826000
2000
14:00
is deeply flawed.
328
828000
2000
14:02
And I hope I've convinced you of that,
329
830000
2000
14:04
which means that the real job is go out and
330
832000
2000
14:06
say to your local leaders,
331
834000
2000
14:08
and your national leaders,
332
836000
2000
14:10
"Why haven't you solved these problems?
333
838000
2000
14:12
Why are you still thinking that
334
840000
2000
14:14
the lessons of Katrina do not apply to flu?"
335
842000
3000
14:17
And put the pressure where the pressure needs to be put.
336
845000
4000
14:21
But I guess the other thing to add is,
337
849000
2000
14:23
if you do have employees, and you do have a company,
338
851000
2000
14:25
I think you have certain responsibilities
339
853000
3000
14:28
to demonstrate that you are thinking ahead for them,
340
856000
2000
14:30
and you are trying to plan.
341
858000
2000
14:32
At a minimum the British banking plan showed that
342
860000
4000
14:36
telecommuting can be helpful.
343
864000
2000
14:38
It probably does reduce exposure
344
866000
2000
14:40
because people are not coming into the office and coughing on each other,
345
868000
3000
14:43
or touching common objects
346
871000
3000
14:46
and sharing things via their hands.
347
874000
2000
14:48
But can you sustain your company that way?
348
876000
4000
14:52
Well if you have a dot-com, maybe you can.
349
880000
3000
14:55
Otherwise you're in trouble.
350
883000
3000
14:58
Happy to take your questions.
351
886000
2000
15:00
(Applause)
352
888000
4000
15:04
Audience member: What factors determine the duration of a pandemic?
353
892000
5000
15:09
Laurie Garret: What factors determine the duration of a pandemic, we don't really know.
354
897000
4000
15:13
I could give you a bunch of flip, this, that, and the other.
355
901000
3000
15:16
But I would say that honestly we don't know.
356
904000
3000
15:19
Clearly the bottom line is
357
907000
2000
15:21
the virus eventually attenuates,
358
909000
3000
15:24
and ceases to be a lethal virus to humanity,
359
912000
5000
15:29
and finds other hosts.
360
917000
2000
15:31
But we don't really know how and why that happens.
361
919000
2000
15:33
It's a very complicated ecology.
362
921000
3000
15:36
Audience member: What kind of triggers are you looking for?
363
924000
3000
15:39
You know way more than any of us.
364
927000
2000
15:41
To say ahh, if this happens then we are going to have a pandemic?
365
929000
4000
15:45
LG: The moment that you see any evidence
366
933000
2000
15:47
of serious human-to-human to transmission.
367
935000
3000
15:50
Not just intimately between family members
368
938000
2000
15:52
who took care of an ailing sister or brother,
369
940000
4000
15:56
but a community infected --
370
944000
2000
15:58
spread within a school,
371
946000
2000
16:00
spread within a dormitory, something of that nature.
372
948000
3000
16:03
Then I think that there is universal agreement
373
951000
3000
16:06
now, at WHO all the way down:
374
954000
2000
16:08
Send out the alert.
375
956000
4000
16:12
Audience member: Some research has indicated that statins can be helpful.
376
960000
4000
16:16
Can you talk about that?
377
964000
2000
16:18
LG: Yeah. There is some evidence that taking Lipitor
378
966000
2000
16:20
and other common statins for cholesterol control
379
968000
3000
16:23
may decrease your vulnerability
380
971000
4000
16:27
to influenza.
381
975000
2000
16:29
But we do not completely understand why.
382
977000
3000
16:32
The mechanism isn't clear.
383
980000
2000
16:34
And I don't know that there is any way
384
982000
5000
16:39
responsibly for someone to start
385
987000
3000
16:42
medicating their children
386
990000
2000
16:44
with their personal supply of Lipitor or something of that nature.
387
992000
4000
16:48
We have absolutely no idea what that would do.
388
996000
2000
16:50
You might be causing some very dangerous outcomes
389
998000
3000
16:53
in your children, doing such a thing.
390
1001000
3000
16:56
Audience member: How far along are we in being able to determine
391
1004000
2000
16:58
whether someone is actually carrying, whether somebody has this
392
1006000
2000
17:00
before the symptoms are full-blown?
393
1008000
2000
17:02
LG: Right. So I have for a long time said
394
1010000
3000
17:05
that what we really needed was a rapid diagnostic.
395
1013000
3000
17:08
And our Centers for Disease Control
396
1016000
3000
17:11
has labeled a test they developed
397
1019000
3000
17:14
a rapid diagnostic.
398
1022000
2000
17:16
It takes 24 hours in a very highly developed laboratory,
399
1024000
4000
17:20
in highly skilled hands.
400
1028000
2000
17:22
I'm thinking dipstick.
401
1030000
2000
17:24
You could do it to your own kid. It changes color.
402
1032000
2000
17:26
It tells you if you have H5N1.
403
1034000
2000
17:28
In terms of where we are in science
404
1036000
4000
17:32
with DNA identification capacities and so on,
405
1040000
4000
17:36
it's not that far off.
406
1044000
2000
17:38
But we're not there. And there hasn't been the kind of investment to get us there.
407
1046000
5000
17:43
Audience member: In the 1918 flu I understand that
408
1051000
3000
17:46
they theorized that there was some attenuation
409
1054000
4000
17:50
of the virus when it made the leap into humans.
410
1058000
2000
17:52
Is that likely, do you think, here?
411
1060000
2000
17:54
I mean 100 percent death rate
412
1062000
4000
17:58
is pretty severe.
413
1066000
2000
18:00
LG: Um yeah. So we don't actually know
414
1068000
4000
18:04
what the lethality was
415
1072000
3000
18:07
of the 1918 strain to wild birds
416
1075000
4000
18:11
before it jumped from birds to humans.
417
1079000
2000
18:13
It's curious that there is no evidence
418
1081000
2000
18:15
of mass die-offs of chickens
419
1083000
2000
18:17
or household birds across America
420
1085000
3000
18:20
before the human pandemic happened.
421
1088000
2000
18:22
That may be because those events
422
1090000
2000
18:24
were occurring on the other side of the world
423
1092000
2000
18:26
where nobody was paying attention.
424
1094000
2000
18:28
But the virus clearly
425
1096000
4000
18:32
went through one round around the world
426
1100000
2000
18:34
in a mild enough form
427
1102000
2000
18:36
that the British army in World War I
428
1104000
3000
18:39
actually certified that it was not a threat
429
1107000
3000
18:42
and would not affect the outcome of the war.
430
1110000
3000
18:45
And after circulating around the world
431
1113000
2000
18:47
came back in a form that was tremendously lethal.
432
1115000
5000
18:52
What percentage of infected people were killed by it?
433
1120000
3000
18:55
Again we don't really know for sure.
434
1123000
3000
18:58
It's clear that if you were malnourished to begin with,
435
1126000
2000
19:00
you had a weakened immune system,
436
1128000
2000
19:02
you lived in poverty in India or Africa,
437
1130000
3000
19:05
your likelihood of dying was far greater.
438
1133000
3000
19:08
But we don't really know.
439
1136000
3000
19:11
Audience member: One of the things I've heard is that
440
1139000
2000
19:13
the real death cause when you get a flu is the associated pneumonia,
441
1141000
3000
19:16
and that a pneumonia vaccine
442
1144000
2000
19:18
may offer you 50 percent better chance of survival.
443
1146000
4000
19:22
LG: For a long time, researchers in emerging diseases
444
1150000
4000
19:26
were kind of dismissive of the pandemic flu threat
445
1154000
2000
19:28
on the grounds that
446
1156000
2000
19:30
back in 1918 they didn't have antibiotics.
447
1158000
2000
19:32
And that most people who die of regular flu --
448
1160000
3000
19:35
which in regular flu years
449
1163000
2000
19:37
is about 360,000 people worldwide,
450
1165000
3000
19:40
most of them senior citizens --
451
1168000
2000
19:42
and they die not of the flu but because the flu gives an assault to their immune system.
452
1170000
4000
19:46
And along comes pneumococcus
453
1174000
2000
19:48
or another bacteria, streptococcus
454
1176000
2000
19:50
and boom, they get a bacterial pneumonia.
455
1178000
2000
19:52
But it turns out that in 1918 that was not the case at all.
456
1180000
3000
19:55
And so far in the H5N1 cases in people,
457
1183000
3000
19:58
similarly bacterial infection
458
1186000
2000
20:00
has not been an issue at all.
459
1188000
2000
20:02
It's this absolutely phenomenal disruption of the immune system
460
1190000
5000
20:07
that is the key to why people die of this virus.
461
1195000
3000
20:10
And I would just add
462
1198000
2000
20:12
we saw the same thing with SARS.
463
1200000
2000
20:14
So what's going on here is your body says,
464
1202000
3000
20:17
your immune system sends out all its sentinels and says,
465
1205000
4000
20:21
"I don't know what the heck this is.
466
1209000
2000
20:23
We've never seen anything even remotely like this before."
467
1211000
3000
20:26
It won't do any good to bring in the sharpshooters
468
1214000
3000
20:29
because those antibodies aren't here.
469
1217000
2000
20:31
And it won't do any good to bring in the tanks and the artillery
470
1219000
3000
20:34
because those T-cells don't recognize it either.
471
1222000
3000
20:37
So we're going to have to go all-out thermonuclear response,
472
1225000
3000
20:40
stimulate the total cytokine cascade.
473
1228000
3000
20:43
The whole immune system swarms into the lungs.
474
1231000
3000
20:46
And yes they die, drowning in their own fluids, of pneumonia.
475
1234000
3000
20:49
But it's not bacterial pneumonia.
476
1237000
2000
20:51
And it's not a pneumonia that would respond to a vaccine.
477
1239000
4000
20:55
And I think my time is up. I thank you all for your attention.
478
1243000
3000
20:58
(Applause)
479
1246000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Laurie Garrett - Science journalistPulitzer winner Laurie Garrett studies global health and disease prevention. Her books include "The Coming Plague" and "Betrayal of Trust," about the crisis in global public health.
Why you should listen
Laurie Garrett has made a career of uncovering science and policy news that is almost too depressing to know: emerging and re-emerging diseases, and the world's general inability to deal with them. In the process, she has uncovered gaping lapses in public health and policy.
Garrett is the author of The Coming Plague: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance and Betrayal of Trust: The Collapse of Global Public Health. As a science writer for Newsday, Garrett won a Pulitzer, a Peabody and two Polk awards; in 2004, she joined the Council on Foreign Relations as Senior Fellow for Global Health. She is an expert on public health -- and the fascinating ways that health policy affects foreign policy and national security.
Laurie Garrett | Speaker | TED.com