TEDGlobal 2009
Cynthia Schneider: The surprising spread of Idol TV
Filmed:
Readability: 5
557,661 views
Cynthia Schneider looks at two international "American Idol"-style shows -- one in Afghanistan, and one in the United Arab Emirates -- and shows the surprising effect that these reality-TV competitions are creating in their societies.
Cynthia Schneider - Cultural diplomacy expert
Cynthia Schneider studies culture and politics -- watching how novels, TV shows and cultural engagement around the globe (and especially within the Muslim world) might lead to political change. She was the US ambassador to the Netherlands from 1998 to 2001. Full bio
Cynthia Schneider studies culture and politics -- watching how novels, TV shows and cultural engagement around the globe (and especially within the Muslim world) might lead to political change. She was the US ambassador to the Netherlands from 1998 to 2001. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:15
I'd like to ask you,
0
0
2000
00:17
what do these three people have in common?
1
2000
5000
00:22
Well, you probably recognize the first person.
2
7000
2000
00:24
I'm sure you're all avid "American Idol" watchers.
3
9000
3000
00:27
But you might not recognize Aydah Al Jahani,
4
12000
3000
00:30
who is a contestant, indeed a finalist,
5
15000
3000
00:33
in the Poet of the Millions competition,
6
18000
3000
00:36
which is broadcast out of Abu Dhabi,
7
21000
2000
00:38
and seen throughout the Arab world.
8
23000
2000
00:40
In this contest
9
25000
2000
00:42
people have to write and recite
10
27000
3000
00:45
original poetry, in the Nabati form of poetry,
11
30000
3000
00:48
which is the traditional Bedouin form.
12
33000
3000
00:51
And Lima Sahar was a finalist
13
36000
3000
00:54
in the Afghan Star singing competition.
14
39000
4000
00:58
Now, before I go any further,
15
43000
2000
01:00
yes, I know it all began with "Britain's Got Talent."
16
45000
4000
01:04
But my point in discussing this
17
49000
3000
01:07
is to show you -- I hope I'll be able to show you
18
52000
3000
01:10
how these merit-based competitions,
19
55000
4000
01:14
with equal access to everyone,
20
59000
3000
01:17
with the winner selected via voting by SMS,
21
62000
3000
01:20
are changing tribal societies.
22
65000
3000
01:23
And I'm going to focus on Afghanistan
23
68000
2000
01:25
and the Arab world with the UAE,
24
70000
3000
01:28
how they're changing tribal societies,
25
73000
3000
01:31
not by introducing Western ideas,
26
76000
2000
01:33
but by being integrated into the language in those places.
27
78000
4000
01:37
It all begins with enjoyment.
28
82000
3000
01:42
Video: We are late to watch "Afghan Star."
29
87000
3000
01:45
We are going to watch "Afghan Star." We are late.
30
90000
3000
01:48
We are running late.
31
93000
3000
01:51
We must go to watch "Afghan Star."
32
96000
3000
01:56
Cynthia Schneider: These programs are reaching incredibly deeply into society.
33
101000
5000
02:01
In Afghanistan, people go to extraordinary lengths
34
106000
3000
02:04
to be able to watch this program.
35
109000
2000
02:06
And you don't necessarily have to have your own TV set.
36
111000
3000
02:09
People watch it all over the country
37
114000
2000
02:11
also in public places.
38
116000
3000
02:14
But it goes beyond watching,
39
119000
3000
02:17
because also, part of this
40
122000
3000
02:20
is campaigning.
41
125000
2000
02:22
People become so engaged
42
127000
2000
02:24
that they have volunteers, just like political volunteers anyway,
43
129000
4000
02:28
who fan out over the countryside,
44
133000
3000
02:31
campaigning for their candidate.
45
136000
3000
02:34
Contestants also put themselves forward.
46
139000
3000
02:37
Now, of course there is a certain degree of ethnic allegiance, but not entirely.
47
142000
4000
02:41
Because each year the winner has come from a different tribal group.
48
146000
5000
02:46
This has opened up the door,
49
151000
2000
02:48
particularly for women.
50
153000
2000
02:50
And in the last season there were two women in the finalists.
51
155000
3000
02:53
One of them, Lima Sahar, is a Pashtun from Kandahar,
52
158000
3000
02:56
a very conservative part of the country.
53
161000
3000
02:59
And here she relates, in the documentary film "Afghan Star,"
54
164000
4000
03:03
how her friends urged her not to do this
55
168000
3000
03:06
and told her that she was leaving them for democracy.
56
171000
3000
03:09
But she also confides that
57
174000
3000
03:12
she knows that members of the Taliban
58
177000
2000
03:14
are actually SMS-ing votes in for her.
59
179000
5000
03:19
Aydah Al Jahnani also took risks
60
184000
3000
03:22
and put herself out, to compete
61
187000
2000
03:24
in the Poet of the Millions competition.
62
189000
3000
03:27
I have to say, her husband backed her from the start.
63
192000
4000
03:31
But her tribe and family urged her not to compete
64
196000
3000
03:34
and were very much against it.
65
199000
2000
03:36
But, once she started to win,
66
201000
3000
03:39
then they got behind her again.
67
204000
2000
03:41
It turns out that competition and winning is a universal human value.
68
206000
6000
03:47
And she's out there.
69
212000
2000
03:49
Her poetry is about women,
70
214000
3000
03:52
and the life of women in society.
71
217000
3000
03:55
So just by presenting herself
72
220000
2000
03:57
and being in competition with men --
73
222000
2000
03:59
this shows the voting on the program --
74
224000
2000
04:01
it sets a very important example for young women --
75
226000
3000
04:04
these are young women in the audience of the program --
76
229000
3000
04:07
in Abu Dhabi, but also people in the viewing audience.
77
232000
4000
04:11
Now you'd think that "American Idol"
78
236000
2000
04:13
would introduce a measure of Americanization.
79
238000
3000
04:16
But actually, just the opposite is happening.
80
241000
3000
04:19
By using this engaging popular format
81
244000
3000
04:22
for traditional, local culture,
82
247000
3000
04:25
it actually, in the Gulf, is precipitating a revival
83
250000
3000
04:28
of interest in Nabati poetry,
84
253000
2000
04:30
also in traditional dress and dance and music.
85
255000
4000
04:34
And for Afghanistan,
86
259000
2000
04:36
where the Taliban banned music for many years,
87
261000
4000
04:40
it is reintroducing their traditional music.
88
265000
2000
04:42
They don't sing pop songs,
89
267000
2000
04:44
they sing Afghan music.
90
269000
3000
04:47
And they also have learned how to lose gracefully,
91
272000
3000
04:50
without avenging the winner.
92
275000
2000
04:52
(Laughter)
93
277000
2000
04:54
No small thing.
94
279000
2000
04:56
And the final, sort of, formulation
95
281000
6000
05:02
of this "American Idol" format,
96
287000
3000
05:05
which has just appeared in Afghanistan,
97
290000
2000
05:07
is a new program called "The Candidate."
98
292000
3000
05:10
And in this program, people present
99
295000
2000
05:12
policy platforms that are then voted on.
100
297000
3000
05:15
Many of them are too young to run for president,
101
300000
3000
05:18
but by putting the issues out there,
102
303000
2000
05:20
they are influencing the presidential race.
103
305000
2000
05:22
So for me, the substance of things unseen
104
307000
3000
05:25
is how reality TV is driving reality.
105
310000
4000
05:29
Thank you.
106
314000
2000
05:31
(Applause)
107
316000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Cynthia Schneider - Cultural diplomacy expertCynthia Schneider studies culture and politics -- watching how novels, TV shows and cultural engagement around the globe (and especially within the Muslim world) might lead to political change. She was the US ambassador to the Netherlands from 1998 to 2001.
Why you should listen
Cynthia P. Schneider is a Fellow at the Brookings Institution, where she leads the Arts and Culture Initiative within the Saban Center for Middle East Policy. In her work, she looks at the Muslim world through its cultural products (movies, films, books and shows), and searches for clues to deeper social change.
Cynthia Schneider | Speaker | TED.com