TEDxKrakow
Srdja Popovic: How to topple a dictator
Filmed:
Readability: 4
369,967 views
People-powered resistance: can it work? Srdja Popovic led the nonviolent movement that took down Milosevic in Serbia in 2000; he lays out the plans, skills and tools that a people-powered movement needs -- from nonviolent tactics to a sense of humor.
Srdja Popovic - Organizer
Srdja Popovic was a founder and leader of the student movement that brought down the Milosovic regime. Now, he helps other nonviolent movements learn and grow. Full bio
Srdja Popovic was a founder and leader of the student movement that brought down the Milosovic regime. Now, he helps other nonviolent movements learn and grow. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
Good afternoon. I am proud to be here at TEDxKrakow.
0
1236
3080
00:16
I'll try to speak a little bit today about a phenomenon
1
4316
3052
00:19
which can and is actually changing the world,
2
7368
2926
00:22
and whose name is people power.
3
10294
1990
00:24
I'll start with the anecdote, or for those of you
4
12284
2752
00:27
who are Monty Python lovers, a Monty Python type of sketch.
5
15036
3576
00:30
Here it is. It is December 15, 2010.
6
18612
4000
00:34
Somebody gives you a bet. You will look at a crystal ball
7
22612
3272
00:37
and you will see the future. The future will be accurate.
8
25884
2744
00:40
But you need to share it with the world. Okay?
9
28628
2696
00:43
Curiosity killed the cat. You take the bet.
10
31324
2618
00:45
You look at the crystal ball. One hour later,
11
33942
2430
00:48
you are sitting in a building on the national TV
12
36372
2683
00:51
in a talkshow, and you tell the story.
13
39055
2645
00:53
"Before the end of 2011, Ben Ali and Mubarak
14
41700
4842
00:58
and Gaddafi will be down and prosecuted.
15
46542
3762
01:02
Saleh of Yemen and Assad of Syria
16
50304
2892
01:05
would be either challenged or already on their knees.
17
53196
3288
01:08
Osama bin Laden will be dead,
18
56484
2208
01:10
and Ratko Mladic will be in the Hague."
19
58692
2656
01:13
Now, the anchor watches you with a strange gaze on his face,
20
61348
3522
01:16
and then on the top of it you add,
21
64870
1791
01:18
"And thousands of the young people from Athens, Madrid
22
66661
2705
01:21
and New York will demonstrate for social justice,
23
69366
3134
01:24
claiming that they are inspired with Arabs."
24
72500
2856
01:27
Next thing you know, two guys in white appear.
25
75356
3129
01:30
They give you the strange t-shirt,
26
78485
2277
01:32
take you to the nearest mental institution.
27
80762
1939
01:34
So I would like to speak a little bit about the phenomenon
28
82701
2933
01:37
which is behind what already seems to be the very bad year
29
85634
3784
01:41
for bad guys, and this phenomenon is called people power.
30
89418
4707
01:46
Well, people power has been there for a while.
31
94125
2780
01:48
It helped Gandhi kick the Brits from India.
32
96905
2744
01:51
It helped Martin Luther King win a historic racial struggle.
33
99649
3913
01:55
It helped local Lech Walesa to kick out
34
103562
3374
01:58
one million Soviet troops from Poland
35
106936
2989
02:01
and beginning the end of the Soviet Union as we know it.
36
109925
2833
02:04
So what's new in it? What seems to be very new,
37
112758
3698
02:08
which is the idea I would like to share with you today,
38
116456
2581
02:11
that there is a set of rules and skills which can be learned
39
119037
4085
02:15
and taught in order to perform successful nonviolent struggle.
40
123122
4484
02:19
If this is true, we can help these movements.
41
127606
3520
02:23
Well, first one, analytic skills.
42
131126
3008
02:26
I'll try where it all started in the Middle East,
43
134134
2875
02:29
and for so many years we were living with completely the wrong
44
137009
3784
02:32
perception of the Middle East.
45
140793
2413
02:35
It was looking like the frozen region, literally a refrigerator,
46
143206
3417
02:38
and there are only two types of meals there:
47
146623
2351
02:40
steak, which stands for a Mubarak, Ben Ali-type of
48
148974
3263
02:44
military police dictatorship, or a potato,
49
152237
4078
02:48
which stands for Tehran types of theocracies.
50
156315
2739
02:51
And everybody was amazed when the refrigerator opened
51
159054
2968
02:54
and millions of young, mainly secular people step out
52
162022
3632
02:57
to do the change. Guess what? They didn't watch the demographics.
53
165654
4796
03:02
What is the average age of Egyptians? 24.
54
170450
2580
03:05
How long was Mubarak in power? 31.
55
173030
2472
03:07
So this system: just obsolete. They expired,
56
175502
3768
03:11
and young people of the Arab World have awakened
57
179270
2513
03:13
one morning and understood that power lies in their hands.
58
181783
4439
03:18
The rest is the year in front of us. And guess what?
59
186222
2984
03:21
The same Generation Epsilon with their rules,
60
189206
2706
03:23
with their tools, with their games and with their language,
61
191912
2759
03:26
which sounds a little bit strange to me. I am 38 now.
62
194671
3885
03:30
And can you look at the age of the people on the streets of Europe?
63
198556
3916
03:34
It seems that Generation Epsilon is coming.
64
202472
4107
03:38
Now let me set another example.
65
206579
3130
03:41
I'm meeting different people throughout the world,
66
209709
2038
03:43
and they are, you know, academics and professors
67
211747
2625
03:46
and doctors, and they will always talk conditions.
68
214372
2760
03:49
They will say, "People power will work only if the regime is not too oppressive."
69
217132
4000
03:53
They will say, "People power will work if the annual income
70
221132
3037
03:56
of the country is between X and Z."
71
224169
2707
03:58
They will say, "People power will work only if there is a foreign pressure."
72
226876
3600
04:02
They will say, "People power will work only if there is no oil."
73
230476
2936
04:05
And, I mean, there is a set of conditions.
74
233412
1966
04:07
Well, the news here is that your skills [that you] bring in the conflict
75
235378
4960
04:12
seem to be more important than the conditions,
76
240338
3052
04:15
namely skills of unity, planning,
77
243390
2646
04:18
and maintaining nonviolent discipline.
78
246036
1907
04:19
Let me give you the example.
79
247943
1627
04:21
I am coming from a country called Serbia.
80
249570
1901
04:23
It took us 10 years to unite 18 opposition party leaders,
81
251471
4748
04:28
with their big egos, behind one single candidate
82
256219
3047
04:31
against Balkan dictator Slobodan Milosevic.
83
259266
2738
04:34
Guess what? That was the day of his defeat.
84
262004
2688
04:36
You look at the Egyptians, they fire on Tahrir Square,
85
264692
2816
04:39
they get rid of their individual symbols.
86
267508
2304
04:41
They appear on the street only with the flag of Egypt.
87
269812
3072
04:44
I will give you a counter-example.
88
272884
2215
04:47
You see nine presidential candidates running against Lukashenko.
89
275099
3497
04:50
You will know the outcome.
90
278596
1403
04:51
So unity is a big thing, and this can be achieved.
91
279999
3477
04:55
Same with planning. Somebody has lied to you
92
283476
2440
04:57
about the successful and spontaneous nonviolent revolution?
93
285916
3867
05:01
That thing doesn't exist in the world.
94
289783
2261
05:04
Whenever you see young people in front of the road
95
292044
2755
05:06
trying to fraternize with the police or military,
96
294799
2485
05:09
somebody was thinking about it before.
97
297284
2512
05:11
Now, at the end, nonviolent discipline,
98
299796
2360
05:14
and this is probably the game-changer.
99
302156
2211
05:16
If you maintain nonviolent discipline, you will exclusively win.
100
304367
4205
05:20
You have 100,000 people in a nonviolent march,
101
308572
2848
05:23
and one idiot or agent provocateur is throwing stones,
102
311420
2650
05:26
guess what takes all the cameras? That one guy.
103
314070
2902
05:28
One single act of violence can literally
104
316972
2179
05:31
destroy your movement.
105
319151
2461
05:33
Now let me move to another place.
106
321612
2656
05:36
It's selection of strategies and tactics.
107
324268
1579
05:37
There are certain rules in nonviolent struggle you may follow.
108
325847
3924
05:41
First, you start small.
109
329771
1419
05:43
Second, you pick the battles you can win.
110
331190
3154
05:46
It's only 200 of us in this room.
111
334344
2754
05:49
We won't call for the March of Millions.
112
337098
2075
05:51
But what if we organize spraying graffiti throughout the night
113
339173
3289
05:54
all over Krakow city? The city will know.
114
342462
3030
05:57
So we pick the tactics which accommodates to the event,
115
345492
3304
06:00
especially this thing we call the small tactics of dispersion.
116
348796
4106
06:04
They're very useful in a violent oppression.
117
352902
3790
06:08
We are actually witnessing the picture
118
356692
1978
06:10
of one of the best tactics ever used.
119
358670
2446
06:13
It was on Tahrir Square, where the international community
120
361116
3284
06:16
was constantly frightened that the Islamists
121
364400
3516
06:19
will overtake the revolution. Well, they've organized
122
367916
2405
06:22
Christians protecting Muslims, who are there praying,
123
370321
3131
06:25
Coptic wedding cheered by thousands of Muslims.
124
373452
2720
06:28
The world has just changed the picture,
125
376172
1990
06:30
but somebody was thinking about this previously.
126
378162
3018
06:33
So there are so many things you can do instead of
127
381180
2320
06:35
getting into one place, shouting and
128
383500
3295
06:38
showing off in front of the security forces.
129
386795
3452
06:42
Now there is also another very important dynamic,
130
390247
3693
06:45
and this is a dynamic normally analytics don't see.
131
393940
3133
06:49
This is dynamics between fear and apathy on one side
132
397073
3502
06:52
and enthusiasm and humor on another side.
133
400575
3093
06:55
So it works like in a video game.
134
403668
2008
06:57
You have a fear high, you have status quo.
135
405676
2272
06:59
You have enthusiasm higher, you see fear starting to melt.
136
407948
4006
07:03
Day two, you see people running towards police
137
411954
2410
07:06
instead of from the police.
138
414364
2294
07:08
In Egypt, you can tell that something is happening there.
139
416658
3006
07:11
And then it's about humor. Humor is such a powerful
140
419664
3807
07:15
game-changer, and of course it was very big in Poland.
141
423471
2435
07:17
And you know, we were just a small group of crazy students
142
425906
3026
07:20
in Serbia when we made this big skit.
143
428932
3192
07:24
We put the big petrol barrel with a
144
432124
3081
07:27
portrait picture of Mr. President on it
145
435205
2760
07:29
in the middle of the Main Street. There was a hole on the top
146
437965
2449
07:32
so you could literally come, put a coin in,
147
440414
2998
07:35
get a baseball bat, and pow, hit his face.
148
443412
3440
07:38
Sounds loud. And within the minutes, we were sitting
149
446852
3430
07:42
in a nearby cafe having coffee, and there was
150
450282
2498
07:44
a queue of people waiting to do this lovely thing.
151
452780
3648
07:48
Well, that's just the beginning of the show.
152
456428
2312
07:50
The real show starts when the police appears.
153
458740
2464
07:53
What will they do? Arrest us? We are nowhere to be seen.
154
461204
3736
07:56
We are three blocks away observing it from our espresso bar.
155
464940
3704
08:00
Arrest the shoppers with kids? Doesn't make sense.
156
468644
3328
08:03
Of course, you could bet they have done the most stupid thing:
157
471972
2792
08:06
They arrested the barrel. And now the picture
158
474764
2608
08:09
of the smashed face on the barrel with the policeman
159
477372
2712
08:12
dragging them to the police car, that was the best day
160
480084
3080
08:15
for the photographers from newspapers that they ever will have.
161
483164
3168
08:18
So, I mean, these are the things you can do,
162
486332
2616
08:20
and you can always use the humor.
163
488948
1271
08:22
There is also one big thing about the humor: It really hurts,
164
490219
3777
08:25
because these guys really are taking themselves too seriously.
165
493996
4112
08:30
When you start to mock them, it hurts.
166
498108
2371
08:32
Now, everybody is talking about His Majesty, the Internet,
167
500479
4173
08:36
and it is also a very useful skill, but don't rush
168
504652
3984
08:40
to label things like Facebook Revolution, Twitter Revolution.
169
508636
3792
08:44
Don't mix tools with the substance.
170
512428
3162
08:47
It is true that the Internet and new media are very useful
171
515590
3494
08:51
in making things faster and cheaper.
172
519084
2866
08:53
They make it also a bit safer for the participants
173
521950
2610
08:56
because they give the part of anonymity.
174
524560
2676
08:59
We are watching the great example of something else the Internet can do.
175
527236
3318
09:02
It can put the price tag of state-sponsored violence over nonviolent protesters.
176
530554
5129
09:07
This is a famous group, We are all Khaled Said,
177
535683
2665
09:10
made by Wael Ghonim in Egypt and his friend.
178
538348
2398
09:12
This is the mutilated face of the guy who was beaten by the police.
179
540746
3702
09:16
This is how he became the public, and this is what probably
180
544448
3018
09:19
became the straw which broke the camel's back.
181
547466
3150
09:22
But here is also the bad news.
182
550616
1760
09:24
The nonviolent struggle is won in the real world,
183
552376
2613
09:26
in the streets. You will never change your society
184
554989
3683
09:30
towards democracy or economics
185
558672
3184
09:33
if you sit down and click.
186
561856
1729
09:35
There are risks to be taken and there are living people
187
563585
2498
09:38
who are winning the struggle.
188
566083
2348
09:40
Well, million dollar question: What will happen in the Arab World?
189
568431
4035
09:44
And though young people from the Arab World
190
572466
2206
09:46
were pretty successful in bringing down three dictators,
191
574672
2954
09:49
shaking the region, kind of persuading clever kings
192
577626
4511
09:54
from Jordan and Morocco doing substantial reforms,
193
582137
2904
09:57
it is yet to be seen what will be the outcome,
194
585041
4447
10:01
whether the Egyptians and Tunisians will make it through the transition
195
589488
3448
10:04
or this will end in bloody ethnic and religious conflict,
196
592936
4023
10:08
whether the Syrians will maintain nonviolent discipline,
197
596959
3882
10:12
faced with the brutal daily violence
198
600841
3420
10:16
which kills thousands already,
199
604261
1887
10:18
or they will slip into violent struggle
200
606148
1857
10:20
and make ugly civil war.
201
608005
3797
10:23
Will these revolutions be whole like through the transitions
202
611802
3816
10:27
to democracy or be overtaken by military
203
615618
2382
10:30
or extremists of all kinds? We cannot tell.
204
618000
4362
10:34
Same works for the Western sector, where you can see
205
622362
2947
10:37
all of these excited young people protesting around the world,
206
625309
3029
10:40
occupying this, occupying that.
207
628338
2697
10:43
Are they going to become the world wave?
208
631035
3191
10:46
Are they going to find their skills, their enthusiasm,
209
634226
3554
10:49
and their strategy to find what they really want
210
637780
3437
10:53
and push for the reform, or will they just stay
211
641217
3033
10:56
complaining about the endless list of the things they hate?
212
644250
5264
11:01
This is the difference between two towns.
213
649514
3328
11:04
Now, what [do] the statistics have?
214
652842
2696
11:07
My friend's book, Maria Stephan's book,
215
655538
2385
11:09
talks a lot about violent and nonviolent struggle,
216
657923
2847
11:12
and there are some shocking data.
217
660770
2743
11:15
If you look at the last 35 years
218
663513
2489
11:18
and different social transitions from dictatorship to democracy,
219
666002
3265
11:21
you will see that out of 67 different cases,
220
669267
3586
11:24
in 50 of these cases it was nonviolent struggle
221
672853
3293
11:28
which was the key power.
222
676146
3376
11:31
This is one more reason to look at this phenomenon.
223
679522
2920
11:34
This is one more reason to look at the Generation Epsilon,
224
682442
2736
11:37
enough for me to give them credit and hope
225
685178
3480
11:40
that they will find their skills and their courage
226
688658
3927
11:44
to use the nonviolent struggle
227
692585
1985
11:46
and thus fix at least a part of the mess
228
694570
2481
11:49
our generation is making in this world.
229
697051
2409
11:51
Thank you. (Applause)
230
699460
3663
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Srdja Popovic - OrganizerSrdja Popovic was a founder and leader of the student movement that brought down the Milosovic regime. Now, he helps other nonviolent movements learn and grow.
Why you should listen
Srdja Popovic was one of the founders and key organizers of the Serbian nonviolent resistance group Otpor! Otpor!’s campaign to unseat Serbian president Slobodan Milosovic found success in October 2000 when hundreds of thousands of protestors converged upon and took over the Serbian Parliament, effectively ending Milosevic’s rule. After the revolution, Popovic served a term as a member of the Serbian National Assembly 2000-2003.
In 2003, Popovic and other ex-Otpor! activists started the nonprofit educational institution the Centre for Applied Nonviolent Action and Strategies (CANVAS) (www.canvasopedia.org). CANVAS has worked with people from 37 countries, including Zimbabwe, Burma, Iran and Venezuela, spreading knowledge on nonviolent strategies and tactics that was used by the Serbian pro-democracy movement to other non-democratic countries. CANVAS has worked with the activists responsible for successful movements such as the Georgian “Rose Revolution” of 2003 and the Ukrainian “Orange Revolution” of 2004-2005. It also transferred knowledge to Lebanese activists in 2004 to address the crisis after the assassination of Prime Minister Harriri, and assisted participants in the Maldives’ revolution in 2008. Recently CANVAS has worked with April 6th, a key group in the Egyptian nonviolent uprising, as well as other groups from the Middle East.
CANVAS’ teachings are available in a documentary, "Bringing Down a Dictator," featuring Otpor strategies to topple Milosevic. Its manual "Nonviolent Struggle: 50 Crucial Points" was translated into 16 languages, including Farsi and Arabic, and was downloaded 17,000 times from Iran during that country's 2009 protests.
Srdja Popovic | Speaker | TED.com