TEDGlobal 2012
Maurizio Seracini: The secret lives of paintings
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
778,034 views
Art history is far from set in stone. Engineer Maurizio Seracini spent 30 years searching for Leonardo da Vinci's lost fresco "The Battle of Anghiari," and in the process discovered that many paintings have layers of history hidden underneath. Should they be part of the viewing experience too?
Maurizio Seracini - Art diagnostician
Maurizio Seracini uses advanced tools common in engineering and medical labs to unravel centuries-old mysteries of art. Full bio
Maurizio Seracini uses advanced tools common in engineering and medical labs to unravel centuries-old mysteries of art. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
In 1975, I met in Florence a professor, Carlo Pedretti,
0
975
4072
00:20
my former professor of art history, and today
1
5047
3330
00:24
a world-renowned scholar of Leonardo da Vinci.
2
8377
4186
00:28
Well, he asked me if I could find some technological way
3
12563
3971
00:32
to unfold a five-centuries-old mystery related to
4
16534
3788
00:36
a lost masterpiece by Leonardo da Vinci,
5
20322
2813
00:39
the "Battle of Anghiari," which is supposed to be located
6
23135
2627
00:41
in the Hall of the 500 in Palazzo Vecchio, in Florence.
7
25762
2946
00:44
Well, in the mid-'70s, there were not great opportunities
8
28708
3103
00:47
for a bioengineer like me, especially in Italy, and so
9
31811
3927
00:51
I decided, with some researchers from the United States
10
35738
3870
00:55
and the University of Florence, to start probing the murals
11
39608
4211
00:59
decorated by Vasari on the long walls of the Hall of the 500
12
43819
4119
01:03
searching for the lost Leonardo.
13
47938
2677
01:06
Unfortunately, at that time we did not know that
14
50615
3454
01:09
that was not exactly where we should be looking,
15
54069
4342
01:14
because we had to go much deeper in, and so the research
16
58411
4138
01:18
came to a halt, and it was only taken up in 2000
17
62549
4335
01:22
thanks to the interest and the enthusiasm of the Guinness family.
18
66884
4231
01:27
Well, this time, we focused on trying to reconstruct
19
71115
3239
01:30
the way the Hall of the 500 was before the remodeling,
20
74354
2856
01:33
and the so-called Sala Grande, which was built in 1494,
21
77210
3805
01:36
and to find out the original doors, windows,
22
81015
2880
01:39
and in order to do that, we first created a 3D model,
23
83895
4759
01:44
and then, with thermography, we went on to discover
24
88654
3102
01:47
hidden windows. These are the original windows of the hall
25
91756
3231
01:50
of the Sala Grande. We also found out about the height
26
94987
3578
01:54
of the ceiling, and we managed to reconstruct, therefore,
27
98565
3313
01:57
all the layout of this original hall
28
101878
2648
02:00
the way it was before there came Vasari,
29
104526
3555
02:03
and restructured the whole thing,
30
108081
2595
02:06
including a staircase that was very important
31
110676
3336
02:09
in order to precisely place "The Battle of Anghiari"
32
114012
4139
02:14
on a specific area of one of the two walls.
33
118151
4264
02:18
Well, we also learned that Vasari, who was commissioned
34
122415
3241
02:21
to remodel the Hall of the 500 between 1560 and 1574
35
125656
4488
02:26
by the Grand Duke Cosimo I of the Medici family,
36
130144
4332
02:30
we have at least two instances when he saved masterpieces
37
134476
3441
02:33
specifically by placing a brick wall in front of it
38
137917
3257
02:37
and leaving a small air gap.
39
141174
2365
02:39
One that we [see] here, Masaccio, the church of Santa Maria Novella in Florence,
40
143539
3688
02:43
so we just said, well maybe, Visari has done something
41
147227
3118
02:46
like that in the case of this great work of art by Leonardo,
42
150345
3386
02:49
since he was a great admirer of Leonardo da Vinci.
43
153731
2485
02:52
And so we built some very sophisticated radio antennas
44
156216
4507
02:56
just for probing both walls and searching for an air gap.
45
160723
5228
03:01
And we did find many on the right panel of the east wall,
46
165951
4835
03:06
an air gap, and that's where
47
170786
2622
03:09
we believe "The Battle of Anghiari,"
48
173408
1550
03:10
or at least the part that we know has been painted,
49
174958
1966
03:12
which is called "The Fight for the Standard," should be located.
50
176924
3328
03:16
Well, from there, unfortunately,
51
180252
3593
03:19
in 2004, the project
52
183845
2654
03:22
came to a halt. Many political reasons.
53
186499
3147
03:25
So I decided to go back to my alma mater,
54
189646
2334
03:27
and, at the University of California, San Diego,
55
191980
2672
03:30
and I proposed to open up a research center
56
194652
2366
03:32
for engineering sciences for cultural heritage.
57
197018
2812
03:35
And in 2007, we created CISA3 as a research center
58
199830
4523
03:40
for cultural heritage, specifically art, architecture
59
204353
2813
03:43
and archaeology. So students started to flow in,
60
207166
2763
03:45
and we started to build technologies, because that's
61
209929
2134
03:47
basically what we also needed in order to move forward
62
212063
2649
03:50
and go and do fieldwork.
63
214712
2760
03:53
We came back in the Hall of the 500 in 2011,
64
217472
4398
03:57
and this time, with a great group of students,
65
221870
3631
04:01
and my colleague, Professor Falko Kuester,
66
225501
2440
04:03
who is now the director at CISA3, and we
67
227941
2702
04:06
came back just since we knew already where to look for
68
230643
4173
04:10
to find out if there was still something left.
69
234816
2980
04:13
Well, we were confined though, limited, I should rather say,
70
237796
4133
04:17
for several reasons that it's not worth explaining,
71
241929
2997
04:20
to endoscopy only, of the many other options we had,
72
244926
3746
04:24
and with a 4mm camera attached to it,
73
248672
3795
04:28
we were successful in documenting and taking
74
252467
4789
04:33
some fragments of what it turns out to be
75
257256
4804
04:37
a reddish color, black color, and there is some
76
262060
3600
04:41
beige fragments that later on
77
265660
3397
04:44
we ran a much more sophisticated exams,
78
269057
2994
04:47
XRF, X-ray diffraction, and the results are very positive
79
272051
5240
04:53
so far. It seems to indicate that indeed
80
277291
2663
04:55
we have found some pigments, and since we know for sure
81
279954
3056
04:58
that no other artist has painted on that wall
82
283010
2301
05:01
before Vasari came in about 60 years later, well,
83
285311
3519
05:04
those pigments are therefore firmly related to mural painting
84
288830
2861
05:07
and most likely to Leonardo.
85
291691
2615
05:10
Well, we are searching for the highest and highly praised
86
294306
4823
05:15
work of art ever achieved by mankind.
87
299129
3241
05:18
As a matter of fact, this is by far the most important
88
302370
3205
05:21
commission that Leonardo has ever had,
89
305575
2836
05:24
and for doing this great masterpiece, he was named
90
308411
4613
05:28
the number one artist influence at the time.
91
313024
4805
05:33
I had also had the privilege since the last 37 years
92
317829
3607
05:37
to work on several masterpieces as you can see behind me,
93
321436
3660
05:40
but basically to do what? Well, to assess, for example,
94
325096
3071
05:44
the state of conservation. See here the face of the
95
328167
2556
05:46
Madonna of the Chair that when just shining a UV light on it
96
330723
4724
05:51
you suddenly see another, different lady,
97
335447
2688
05:54
aged lady, I should rather say.
98
338135
2295
05:56
There is a lot of varnish still sitting there, several retouches,
99
340430
3589
05:59
and some over cleaning. It becomes very visible.
100
344019
2847
06:02
But also, technology has helped to write new pages
101
346866
3757
06:06
of our history, or at least to update pages of our histories.
102
350623
2922
06:09
For example, the "Lady with the Unicorn,"
103
353545
2138
06:11
another painting by Rafael, well, you see the unicorn.
104
355683
2478
06:14
A lot has been said and written about the unicorn, but
105
358161
2472
06:16
if you take an X-ray of the unicorn, it becomes a puppy dog.
106
360633
3677
06:20
And — (Laughter) — no problem, but, unfortunately,
107
364310
4359
06:24
continuing with the scientific examination of this painting
108
368669
2778
06:27
came out that Rafael did not paint the unicorn,
109
371447
3000
06:30
did not paint the puppy dog, actually left the painting
110
374447
2657
06:33
unfinished, so all this writing about the exotic symbol
111
377104
4736
06:37
of the unicorn — (Laughter) — unfortunately,
112
381840
2891
06:40
is not very reliable. (Laughter)
113
384731
3160
06:43
Well, also, authenticity. Just think for a moment
114
387891
2600
06:46
if science really could move in the field of authenticity
115
390491
4095
06:50
of works of art. There would be a cultural revolution
116
394586
3388
06:53
to say the least, but also, I would say, a market revolution,
117
397974
3161
06:57
let me add. Take this example:
118
401135
2392
06:59
Otto Marseus, nice painting, which is "Still Life"
119
403527
3694
07:03
at the Pitti Gallery, and just have an infrared camera peering through,
120
407221
4095
07:07
and luckily for art historians, it just was confirmed
121
411316
3735
07:10
that there is a signature of Otto Marseus. It even says
122
415051
2600
07:13
when it was made and also the location.
123
417651
3015
07:16
So that was a good result. Sometimes, it's not that good,
124
420666
4399
07:20
and so, again, authenticity and science could go together
125
425065
5164
07:26
and change the way, not attributions being made,
126
430229
4297
07:30
but at least lay the ground for a more objective,
127
434526
3843
07:34
or, I should rather say, less subjective attribution,
128
438369
3721
07:37
as it is done today.
129
442090
2748
07:40
But I would say the discovery that really caught
130
444838
3294
07:44
my imagination, my admiration, is the incredibly vivid
131
448132
4107
07:48
drawing under this layer, brown layer,
132
452239
3612
07:51
of "The Adoration of the Magi." Here you see
133
455851
3252
07:55
a handmade setting XYZ scanner with an infrared camera put on it,
134
459103
4430
07:59
and just peering through this brown layer
135
463533
3207
08:02
of this masterpiece to reveal
136
466740
2751
08:05
what could have been underneath.
137
469491
2700
08:08
Well, this happens to be the most important painting
138
472191
2352
08:10
we have in Italy by Leonardo da Vinci, and
139
474543
2857
08:13
look at the wonderful images of faces that nobody has seen
140
477400
4736
08:18
for five centuries. Look at these portraits.
141
482136
3691
08:21
They're magnificent. You see Leonardo at work.
142
485827
2373
08:24
You see the geniality of his creation, right directly
143
488200
3657
08:27
on the ground layer of the panel, and see
144
491857
2907
08:30
this cool thing, finding, I should rather say,
145
494764
6072
08:36
an elephant. (Laughter) Because of this elephant,
146
500836
3262
08:39
over 70 new images came out, never seen for centuries.
147
504098
3769
08:43
This was an epiphany. We came to understand
148
507867
3330
08:47
and to prove that the brown coating that we see today
149
511197
3726
08:50
was not done by Leonardo da Vinci, which left us
150
514923
2767
08:53
only the other drawing that for five centuries
151
517690
2507
08:56
we were not able to see, so thanks only to technology.
152
520197
5210
09:01
Well, the tablet. Well, we thought, well, if we all have
153
525407
4376
09:05
this pleasure, this privilege to see all this,
154
529783
2778
09:08
to find all these discoveries, what about for everybody else?
155
532561
3538
09:11
So we thought of an augmented reality application
156
536099
2842
09:14
using a tablet. Let me show you just simulating
157
538941
4288
09:19
what we could be doing, any of us could be doing,
158
543229
3589
09:22
in a museum environment.
159
546818
2175
09:24
So let's say that we go to a museum with a tablet, okay?
160
548993
4462
09:29
And we just aim the camera of the tablet
161
553455
3296
09:32
to the painting that we are interested to see, like this.
162
556751
6131
09:38
Okay? And I will just click on it, we pause,
163
562882
5874
09:44
and now let me turn to you so the moment the image,
164
568756
4162
09:48
or, I should say, the camera, has locked in the painting,
165
572918
3353
09:52
then the images you just saw up there in the drawing
166
576271
2666
09:54
are being loaded. And so, see.
167
578937
3757
09:58
We can, as we said, we can zoom in. Then we can scroll.
168
582694
3803
10:02
Okay? Let's go and find the elephant.
169
586497
4945
10:07
So all we need is one finger. Just wipe off
170
591442
3257
10:10
and we see the elephant. (Applause)
171
594699
4541
10:15
(Applause)
172
599240
3544
10:18
Okay? And then if we want,
173
602784
2712
10:21
we can continue the scroll to find out, for example,
174
605496
2780
10:24
on the staircase, the whole iconography is going
175
608276
4095
10:28
to be changed. There are a lot of laymen reconstructing
176
612371
2328
10:30
from the ruins of an old temple a new temple,
177
614699
2631
10:33
and there are a lot of figures showing up. See?
178
617330
3788
10:37
This is not just a curiosity, because it changes
179
621118
3206
10:40
not just the iconography as you see it, but the iconology,
180
624324
3048
10:43
the meaning of the painting,
181
627372
2351
10:45
and we believe this is a cool way, easy way,
182
629723
2790
10:48
that everybody could have access to, to become more
183
632513
3140
10:51
the protagonist of your own discovery, and not just
184
635653
3093
10:54
be so passive about it, as we are when we walk through
185
638746
3374
10:58
endless rooms of museums.
186
642120
4194
11:02
(Applause)
187
646314
5336
11:07
Another concept is the digital clinical chart, which sounds
188
651650
3757
11:11
very obvious if we were to talk about real patients,
189
655407
2475
11:13
but when we talk about works of art, unfortunately,
190
657882
2256
11:16
it's never been tapped as an idea.
191
660138
2132
11:18
Well, we believe, again, that this should be the beginning,
192
662270
2555
11:20
the very first step, to do real conservation,
193
664825
2485
11:23
and allowing us to really explore and to understand
194
667310
3488
11:26
everything related to the state of our conservation,
195
670798
2791
11:29
the technique, materials, and also if, when, and why
196
673589
3374
11:32
we should restore, or, rather, to intervene on
197
676963
4591
11:37
the environment surrounding the painting.
198
681554
3531
11:40
Well, our vision is to rediscover
199
685085
3410
11:44
the spirit of the Renaissance, create a new discipline
200
688495
2409
11:46
where engineering for cultural heritage is actually
201
690904
3609
11:50
a symbol of blending art and science together.
202
694513
2702
11:53
We definitely need a new breed of engineers
203
697215
2430
11:55
that will go out and do this kind of work and
204
699645
2733
11:58
rediscover for us these values, these cultural values
205
702378
4342
12:02
that we badly need, especially today.
206
706720
2554
12:05
And if you want to summarize in one just single word,
207
709274
3734
12:08
well, this is what we're trying to do.
208
713008
2916
12:11
We're trying to give a future to our past
209
715924
2238
12:14
in order to have a future.
210
718162
2402
12:16
As long as we live a life of curiosity and passion,
211
720564
3068
12:19
there is a bit of Leonardo in all of us. Thank you. (Applause)
212
723632
4186
12:23
(Applause)
213
727818
5777
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Maurizio Seracini - Art diagnosticianMaurizio Seracini uses advanced tools common in engineering and medical labs to unravel centuries-old mysteries of art.
Why you should listen
It’s surprising to hear of a former engineer and medical student who has dedicated his career to the analysis of more than 2,500 works of art. But Maurizio Seracini is not your typical art connoisseur. He uses technologies from both of his worlds, such as multispectral imaging, sonogram and x-ray, to peer through the layers of paintings and reveal their secrets.
Most famous is Seracini’s more-than-30-year quest to find Leonardo Da Vinci’s missing painting The Battle of Anghiari. Seracini suspects the piece is behind another giant fresco painted by Giorgio Vasari in the Sala dei Cinquecento in Florence, Italy. To find it, Seracini must find a way to look beneath Vasari’s masterpiece while keeping it intact.
Maurizio Seracini | Speaker | TED.com