TEDSalon London Fall 2012
Hadyn Parry: Re-engineering mosquitos to fight disease
Filmed:
Readability: 3.9
1,019,989 views
In a single year, there are 200-300 million cases of malaria and 50-100 million cases of dengue fever worldwide. So: Why haven't we found a way to effectively kill mosquitos yet? Hadyn Parry presents a fascinating solution: genetically engineering male mosquitos to make them sterile, and releasing the insects into the wild, to cut down on disease-carrying species.
Hadyn Parry - Biotechnology entrepreneur
Biotech entrepreneur Hadyn Parry leads a science start-up that develops GM insects to fight dengue fever. Full bio
Biotech entrepreneur Hadyn Parry leads a science start-up that develops GM insects to fight dengue fever. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
So I'd like to start by focusing on
0
658
2736
00:19
the world's most dangerous animal.
1
3394
2536
00:21
Now, when you talk about dangerous animals,
2
5930
2160
00:23
most people might think of lions or tigers or sharks.
3
8090
3047
00:27
But of course the most dangerous animal
4
11137
1677
00:28
is the mosquito.
5
12814
1863
00:30
The mosquito has killed more humans
6
14677
2159
00:32
than any other creature in human history.
7
16836
2989
00:35
In fact, probably adding them all together,
8
19825
1990
00:37
the mosquito has killed more humans.
9
21815
2186
00:39
And the mosquito has killed more humans than wars
10
24001
2659
00:42
and plague.
11
26660
1699
00:44
And you would think, would you not,
12
28359
2573
00:46
that with all our science, with all our advances in society,
13
30932
3947
00:50
with better towns, better civilizations, better sanitation,
14
34879
4896
00:55
wealth, that we would get better at controlling mosquitos,
15
39791
3200
00:58
and hence reduce this disease.
16
42991
2693
01:01
And that's not really the case.
17
45684
3342
01:04
If it was the case, we wouldn't have
18
49026
2120
01:07
between 200 and 300 million cases of malaria every year,
19
51146
4587
01:11
and we wouldn't have
20
55733
1725
01:13
a million and a half deaths from malaria,
21
57458
3942
01:17
and we wouldn't have a disease
22
61400
2700
01:20
that was relatively unknown 50 years ago
23
64100
2536
01:22
now suddenly turned into
24
66636
2832
01:25
the largest mosquito-borne virus threat that we have,
25
69468
3232
01:28
and that's called dengue fever.
26
72700
2693
01:31
So 50 years ago, pretty much no one had heard of it,
27
75393
2731
01:34
no one certainly in the European environment.
28
78124
2992
01:37
But dengue fever now, according to the World Health Organization,
29
81116
3633
01:40
infects between 50 and 100 million people every year,
30
84749
3487
01:44
so that's equivalent to the whole of the population
31
88236
2336
01:46
of the U.K. being infected every year.
32
90572
2928
01:49
Other estimates put that number at roughly double
33
93500
3112
01:52
that number of infections.
34
96612
3958
01:56
And dengue fever has grown in speed quite phenomenally.
35
100570
4435
02:00
In the last 50 years, the incidence of dengue
36
105005
3050
02:03
has grown thirtyfold.
37
108055
2218
02:06
Now let me tell you a little bit about what dengue fever is,
38
110273
2503
02:08
for those who don't know.
39
112776
1588
02:10
Now let's assume you go on holiday.
40
114364
2209
02:12
Let's assume you go to the Caribbean,
41
116573
1762
02:14
or you might go to Mexico. You might go to Latin America,
42
118335
2393
02:16
Asia, Africa, anywhere in Saudi Arabia.
43
120728
3959
02:20
You might go to India, the Far East.
44
124687
1723
02:22
It doesn't really matter. It's the same mosquito,
45
126410
2613
02:24
and it's the same disease. You're at risk.
46
129023
2912
02:27
And let's assume you're bitten by a mosquito
47
131935
2676
02:30
that's carrying that virus.
48
134611
1561
02:32
Well, you could develop flu-like symptoms.
49
136172
2995
02:35
They could be quite mild.
50
139167
1778
02:36
You could develop nausea, headache,
51
140945
2101
02:38
your muscles could feel like they're contracting,
52
143046
2439
02:41
and you could actually feel like your bones are breaking.
53
145485
4086
02:45
And that's the nickname given to this disease.
54
149571
2224
02:47
It's called breakbone fever,
55
151795
1593
02:49
because that's how you can feel.
56
153388
2344
02:51
Now the odd thing is, is that once you've been bitten
57
155732
2937
02:54
by this mosquito, and you've had this disease,
58
158669
2262
02:56
your body develops antibodies,
59
160931
2622
02:59
so if you're bitten again with that strain,
60
163553
4414
03:03
it doesn't affect you.
61
167967
1716
03:05
But it's not one virus, it's four,
62
169683
2920
03:08
and the same protection that gives you the antibodies
63
172603
2976
03:11
and protects you from the same virus that you had before
64
175579
3312
03:14
actually makes you much more susceptible to the other three.
65
178891
3066
03:17
So the next time you get dengue fever,
66
181957
2735
03:20
if it's a different strain, you're more susceptible,
67
184692
2640
03:23
you're likely to get worse symptoms,
68
187332
2631
03:25
and you're more likely to get the more severe forms,
69
189963
2601
03:28
hemorrhagic fever or shock syndrome.
70
192564
3262
03:31
So you don't want dengue once,
71
195826
1419
03:33
and you certainly don't want it again.
72
197245
2741
03:35
So why is it spreading so fast?
73
199986
3283
03:39
And the answer is this thing.
74
203269
2096
03:41
This is Aedes aegypti.
75
205365
1774
03:43
Now this is a mosquito that came, like its name suggests,
76
207139
3210
03:46
out of North Africa, and it's spread round the world.
77
210349
3442
03:49
Now, in fact, a single mosquito will only travel
78
213791
3128
03:52
about 200 yards in its entire life. They don't travel very far.
79
216919
3729
03:56
What they're very good at doing is hitchhiking,
80
220648
2385
03:58
particularly the eggs.
81
223033
1410
04:00
They will lay their eggs in clear water, any pool, any puddle,
82
224443
4697
04:05
any birdbath, any flower pot,
83
229140
1950
04:06
anywhere there's clear water, they'll lay their eggs,
84
231090
2740
04:09
and if that clear water is near freight, it's near a port,
85
233830
3622
04:13
if it's anywhere near transport,
86
237452
2649
04:16
those eggs will then get transported around the world.
87
240101
3184
04:19
And that's what's happened. Mankind has transported
88
243285
2423
04:21
these eggs all the way around the world,
89
245708
2006
04:23
and these insects have infested over 100 countries,
90
247714
3698
04:27
and there's now 2.5 billion people living in countries
91
251412
2698
04:30
where this mosquito resides.
92
254110
2992
04:33
To give you just a couple of examples
93
257102
1584
04:34
how fast this has happened,
94
258686
2516
04:37
in the mid-'70s, Brazil declared, "We have no Aedes aegypti,"
95
261202
5516
04:42
and currently they spend about a billion dollars now
96
266718
2350
04:44
a year trying to get rid of it, trying to control it,
97
269068
2800
04:47
just one species of mosquito.
98
271868
5101
04:52
Two days ago, or yesterday, I can't remember which,
99
276969
3543
04:56
I saw a Reuters report that said
100
280512
1964
04:58
Madeira had had their first cases of dengue,
101
282476
2634
05:01
about 52 cases, with about 400 probable cases.
102
285110
3820
05:04
That's two days ago.
103
288930
1814
05:06
Interestingly, Madeira first got the insect in 2005,
104
290744
5181
05:11
and here we are, a few years later,
105
295925
2057
05:13
first cases of dengue.
106
297982
1327
05:15
So the one thing you'll find is that where the mosquito goes,
107
299309
3359
05:18
dengue will follow.
108
302668
2314
05:20
Once you've got the mosquito in your area,
109
304982
2191
05:23
anyone coming into that area with dengue,
110
307173
2369
05:25
mosquito will bite them, mosquito will bite somewhere else,
111
309542
2943
05:28
somewhere else, somewhere else,
112
312485
964
05:29
and you'll get an epidemic.
113
313449
4115
05:33
So we must be good at killing mosquitos.
114
317564
1908
05:35
I mean, that can't be very difficult.
115
319472
1897
05:37
Well, there's two principle ways.
116
321369
2820
05:40
The first way is that you use larvicides.
117
324189
3372
05:43
You use chemicals. You put them into water where they breed.
118
327561
2812
05:46
Now in an urban environment, that's extraordinarily difficult.
119
330373
2800
05:49
You've got to get your chemical into every puddle,
120
333173
2185
05:51
every birdbath, every tree trunk.
121
335358
2248
05:53
It's just not practical.
122
337606
3042
05:56
The second way you can do it
123
340648
1516
05:58
is actually trying to kill the insects as they fly around.
124
342164
3314
06:01
This is a picture of fogging.
125
345478
2226
06:03
Here what someone is doing
126
347704
2445
06:06
is mixing up chemical in a smoke
127
350149
2914
06:08
and basically spreading that through the environment.
128
353063
3014
06:11
You could do the same with a space spray.
129
356077
2960
06:14
This is really unpleasant stuff,
130
359037
1568
06:16
and if it was any good, we wouldn't have this massive increase
131
360605
2402
06:18
in mosquitos and we wouldn't have this massive increase in dengue fever.
132
363007
4656
06:23
So it's not very effective, but it's probably
133
367663
2089
06:25
the best thing we've got at the moment.
134
369752
2895
06:28
Having said that, actually, your best form of protection
135
372647
2152
06:30
and my best form of protection is a long-sleeve shirt
136
374799
2385
06:33
and a little bit of DEET to go with it.
137
377184
3424
06:36
So let's start again. Let's design a product,
138
380608
3689
06:40
right from the word go, and decide what we want.
139
384297
3276
06:43
Well we clearly need something that is effective
140
387573
2595
06:46
at reducing the mosquito population.
141
390168
2308
06:48
There's no point in just killing the odd mosquito here and there.
142
392476
2432
06:50
We want something that gets that population right the way down
143
394908
3092
06:53
so it can't get the disease transmission.
144
398000
3016
06:56
Clearly the product you've got has got to be safe to humans.
145
401016
3304
07:00
We are going to use it in and around humans.
146
404320
2176
07:02
It has to be safe.
147
406496
1563
07:03
We don't want to have a lasting impact on the environment.
148
408059
2230
07:06
We don't want to do anything that you can't undo.
149
410289
3234
07:09
Maybe a better product comes along in 20, 30 years.
150
413523
5093
07:14
Fine. We don't want a lasting environmental impact.
151
418616
2874
07:17
We want something that's relatively cheap, or cost-effective,
152
421490
3272
07:20
because there's an awful lot of countries involved,
153
424762
1953
07:22
and some of them are emerging markets,
154
426715
2006
07:24
some of them emerging countries, low-income.
155
428721
3562
07:28
And finally, you want something that's species-specific.
156
432283
2375
07:30
You want to get rid of this mosquito that spreads dengue,
157
434658
2788
07:33
but you don't really want to get all the other insects.
158
437446
2988
07:36
Some are quite beneficial. Some are important to your ecosystem.
159
440434
3216
07:39
This one's not. It's invaded you.
160
443650
1838
07:41
But you don't want to get all of the insects.
161
445488
2682
07:44
You just want to get this one.
162
448170
1659
07:45
And most of the time, you'll find this insect
163
449829
2859
07:48
lives in and around your home,
164
452688
1435
07:50
so this -- whatever we do has got to get to that insect.
165
454123
3924
07:53
It's got to get into people's houses, into the bedrooms,
166
458047
2383
07:56
into the kitchens.
167
460430
1794
07:58
Now there are two features of mosquito biology
168
462224
3645
08:01
that really help us in this project,
169
465869
1900
08:03
and that is, firstly, males don't bite.
170
467769
3872
08:07
It's only the female mosquito that will actually bite you.
171
471641
3109
08:10
The male can't bite you, won't bite you,
172
474750
2401
08:13
doesn't have the mouth parts to bite you.
173
477151
2303
08:15
It's just the female.
174
479454
1659
08:17
And the second is a phenomenon
175
481113
1973
08:18
that males are very, very good at finding females.
176
483086
4216
08:23
If there's a male mosquito that you release,
177
487302
2648
08:25
and if there's a female around, that male will find the female.
178
489950
4843
08:30
So basically, we've used those two factors.
179
494793
3818
08:34
So here's a typical situation,
180
498611
1668
08:36
male meets female, lots of offspring.
181
500279
2568
08:38
A single female will lay about
182
502847
1729
08:40
up to 100 eggs at a time,
183
504576
1795
08:42
up to about 500 in her lifetime.
184
506371
2484
08:44
Now if that male is carrying a gene
185
508855
3021
08:47
which causes the death of the offspring,
186
511876
2618
08:50
then the offspring don't survive,
187
514494
2681
08:53
and instead of having 500 mosquitos running around,
188
517175
3431
08:56
you have none.
189
520606
2621
08:59
And if you can put more, I'll call them sterile,
190
523227
3119
09:02
that the offspring will actually die at different stages,
191
526346
2873
09:05
but I'll call them sterile for now.
192
529219
1589
09:06
If you put more sterile males out into the environment,
193
530808
3556
09:10
then the females are more likely to find a sterile male
194
534364
3288
09:13
than a fertile one, and you will bring that population down.
195
537652
5839
09:19
So the males will go out, they'll look for females,
196
543491
2395
09:21
they'll mate. If they mate successfully, then no offspring.
197
545886
3824
09:25
If they don't find a female, then they'll die anyway.
198
549710
3003
09:28
They only live a few days.
199
552713
3734
09:32
And that's exactly where we are.
200
556447
2234
09:34
So this is technology that was developed
201
558681
1630
09:36
in Oxford University a few years ago.
202
560311
2552
09:38
The company itself, Oxitec, we've been working
203
562863
2421
09:41
for the last 10 years, very much on a sort of similar
204
565284
2549
09:43
development pathway that you'd get with a pharmaceutical company.
205
567833
3442
09:47
So about 10 years of internal evaluation, testing,
206
571275
4110
09:51
to get this to a state where we think it's actually ready.
207
575385
3392
09:54
And then we've gone out into the big outdoors,
208
578777
2487
09:57
always with local community consent,
209
581264
1601
09:58
always with the necessary permits.
210
582865
2185
10:00
So we've done field trials now in the Cayman Islands,
211
585050
3063
10:04
a small one in Malaysia,
212
588113
1546
10:05
and two more now in Brazil.
213
589659
4335
10:09
And what's the result?
214
593994
1733
10:11
Well, the result has been very good.
215
595727
3308
10:14
In about four months of release,
216
599035
2824
10:17
we've brought that population of mosquitos
217
601859
2296
10:20
— in most cases we're dealing with villages here
218
604155
2543
10:22
of about 2,000, 3,000 people, that sort of size,
219
606698
3272
10:25
starting small —
220
609970
1438
10:27
we've taken that mosquito population down
221
611408
2191
10:29
by about 85 percent in about four months.
222
613599
3224
10:32
And in fact, the numbers after that get,
223
616823
1999
10:34
those get very difficult to count, because there just aren't any left.
224
618822
3740
10:38
So that's been what we've seen in Cayman,
225
622562
1656
10:40
it's been what we've seen in Brazil
226
624218
3262
10:43
in those trials.
227
627480
1986
10:45
And now what we're doing is we're going through a process
228
629466
2312
10:47
to scale up to a town of about 50,000,
229
631778
2833
10:50
so we can see this work at big scale.
230
634611
2373
10:52
And we've got a production unit in Oxford,
231
636984
2787
10:55
or just south of Oxford, where we actually produce these mosquitos.
232
639771
3491
10:59
We can produce them,
233
643262
1204
11:00
in a space a bit more than this red carpet,
234
644466
2156
11:02
I can produce about 20 million a week.
235
646622
2524
11:05
We can transport them around the world.
236
649146
2166
11:07
It's not very expensive, because it's a coffee cup --
237
651312
3022
11:10
something the size of a coffee cup
238
654334
1289
11:11
will hold about three million eggs.
239
655623
3327
11:14
So freight costs aren't our biggest problem. (Laughter)
240
658950
3818
11:18
So we've got that. You could call it a mosquito factory.
241
662768
3304
11:21
And for Brazil, where we've been doing some trials,
242
666072
3096
11:25
the Brazilian government themselves have now built
243
669168
1888
11:26
their own mosquito factory, far bigger than ours,
244
671056
2432
11:29
and we'll use that for scaling up in Brazil.
245
673488
5475
11:34
There you are. We've sent mosquito eggs.
246
678963
2373
11:37
We've separated the males from the females.
247
681336
2632
11:39
The males have been put in little pots
248
683968
3650
11:43
and the truck is going down the road
249
687618
2084
11:45
and they are releasing males as they go.
250
689702
2964
11:48
It's actually a little bit more precise than that.
251
692666
1650
11:50
You want to release them so that
252
694316
1481
11:51
you get good coverage of your area.
253
695797
2081
11:53
So you take a Google Map, you divide it up,
254
697878
2791
11:56
work out how far they can fly,
255
700669
1884
11:58
and make sure you're releasing such that you get
256
702553
1975
12:00
coverage of the area, and then you go back,
257
704528
2898
12:03
and within a very short space of time,
258
707426
1774
12:05
you're bringing that population right the way down.
259
709200
3576
12:08
We've also done this in agriculture.
260
712776
2432
12:11
We've got several different species of agriculture coming along,
261
715208
4072
12:15
and I'm hoping that soon
262
719280
1908
12:17
we'll be able to get some funding together so we can get back
263
721188
2796
12:19
and start looking at malaria.
264
723984
3082
12:22
So that's where we stand at the moment,
265
727066
2049
12:25
and I've just got a few final thoughts,
266
729115
2529
12:27
which is that this is another way in which biology
267
731644
3444
12:30
is now coming in to supplement chemistry
268
735088
3989
12:34
in some of our societal advances in this area,
269
739077
3743
12:38
and these biological approaches are coming in
270
742820
2288
12:41
in very different forms,
271
745108
2401
12:43
and when you think about genetic engineering,
272
747509
2322
12:45
we've now got enzymes for industrial processing,
273
749831
3006
12:48
enzymes, genetically engineered enzymes in food.
274
752837
2934
12:51
We have G.M. crops, we have pharmaceuticals,
275
755771
2802
12:54
we have new vaccines,
276
758573
1316
12:55
all using roughly the same technology, but with very different outcomes.
277
759889
4084
12:59
And I'm in favor, actually. Of course I am.
278
763973
3513
13:03
I'm in favor of particularly where the older technologies
279
767486
2896
13:06
don't work well or have become unacceptable.
280
770382
3072
13:09
And although the techniques are similar,
281
773454
3357
13:12
the outcomes are very, very different,
282
776811
1541
13:14
and if you take our approach, for example,
283
778352
1514
13:15
and you compare it to, say, G.M. crops,
284
779866
2425
13:18
both techniques are trying to produce a massive benefit.
285
782291
4292
13:22
Both have a side benefit,
286
786583
2143
13:24
which is that we reduce pesticide use tremendously.
287
788726
3709
13:28
But whereas a G.M. crop is trying to protect the plant,
288
792435
3961
13:32
for example, and give it an advantage,
289
796396
2744
13:35
what we're actually doing is taking the mosquito
290
799140
3095
13:38
and giving it the biggest disadvantage it can possibly have,
291
802235
4089
13:42
rendering it unable to reproduce effectively.
292
806324
2984
13:45
So for the mosquito, it's a dead end.
293
809308
3600
13:48
Thank you very much. (Applause)
294
812908
3807
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Hadyn Parry - Biotechnology entrepreneurBiotech entrepreneur Hadyn Parry leads a science start-up that develops GM insects to fight dengue fever.
Why you should listen
"We have reached a moment of truth," says biotech entrepreneur Hadyn Parry. He believes it's a pivotal time for the science industry and it's the moment for the public to wake up and rethink its position on GM technologies and trials. Parry, who is the CEO of Oxitec, a biotech company devoted to innovative insect control, believes the debate over GM crops and animals has become too political, and people are not stopping to evaluate the technologies' true promises and efficacies. In his eyes, GM can be used responsibly for important goals, like the control of extremely harmful diseases like dengue fever.
Hadyn Parry | Speaker | TED.com