TEDxBeaconStreet
Tyler DeWitt: Hey science teachers -- make it fun
Filmed:
Readability: 3.9
1,826,726 views
High school science teacher Tyler DeWitt was ecstatic about his new lesson plan on bacteria (how cool!) -- and devastated when his students hated it. The problem was the textbook: it was impossible to understand. He delivers a rousing call for science teachers to ditch the jargon and extreme precision, and instead make science sing through stories and demonstrations.
Tyler DeWitt - Science enthusiast
Tyler DeWitt recognizes that textbooks are not the way to get young people interested in science. Instead, he teaches science by making it fun and fantastical. Full bio
Tyler DeWitt recognizes that textbooks are not the way to get young people interested in science. Instead, he teaches science by making it fun and fantastical. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Let me tell you a story.
0
779
1856
00:18
It's my first year as a new high school science teacher,
1
2635
4104
00:22
and I'm so eager.
2
6739
1320
00:23
I'm so excited, I'm pouring myself into my lesson plans.
3
8059
4200
00:28
But I'm slowly coming to this horrifying realization
4
12259
5152
00:33
that my students just might not be learning anything.
5
17411
5032
00:38
This happens one day:
6
22443
2704
00:41
I'd just assigned my class to read this textbook chapter
7
25147
3214
00:44
about my favorite subject in all of biology:
8
28361
3458
00:47
viruses and how they attack.
9
31819
3472
00:51
And so I'm so excited to discuss this with them,
10
35291
2386
00:53
and I come in and I say, "Can somebody please explain
11
37677
3464
00:57
the main ideas and why this is so cool?"
12
41141
4009
01:01
There's silence.
13
45150
2631
01:03
Finally, my favorite student, she looks me straight in the eye,
14
47781
4273
01:07
and she says, "The reading sucked."
15
52054
3543
01:11
And then she clarified. She said, "You know what,
16
55597
3528
01:15
I don't mean that it sucks. It means that I didn't understand a word of it.
17
59125
3929
01:18
It's boring. Um, who cares, and it sucks."
18
63054
4375
01:23
These sympathetic smiles
19
67429
4044
01:27
spread all throughout the room now,
20
71473
2405
01:29
and I realize that all of my other students are in the same boat,
21
73878
4639
01:34
that maybe they took notes or they memorized definitions from the textbook,
22
78517
3912
01:38
but not one of them really understood the main ideas.
23
82429
5403
01:43
Not one of them can tell me why this stuff is so cool,
24
87832
2733
01:46
why it's so important.
25
90565
2358
01:48
I'm totally clueless.
26
92923
2962
01:51
I have no idea what to do next.
27
95885
3264
01:55
So the only thing I can think of is say,
28
99149
2464
01:57
"Listen. Let me tell you a story.
29
101613
4192
02:01
The main characters in the story are bacteria and viruses.
30
105805
6208
02:07
These guys are blown up a couple million times.
31
112013
3168
02:11
The real bacteria and viruses are so small
32
115181
3057
02:14
we can't see them without a microscope,
33
118238
2832
02:16
and you guys might know bacteria and viruses
34
121070
1704
02:18
because they both make us sick.
35
122774
2591
02:21
But what a lot of people don't know is that viruses
36
125365
3520
02:24
can also make bacteria sick."
37
128885
2880
02:27
Now, the story that I start telling my kids,
38
131765
2152
02:29
it starts out like a horror story.
39
133917
4624
02:34
Once upon a time there's this happy little bacterium.
40
138541
3363
02:37
Don't get too attached to him.
41
141904
2285
02:40
Maybe he's floating around in your stomach
42
144189
4136
02:44
or in some spoiled food somewhere,
43
148325
1808
02:46
and all of a sudden he starts to not feel so good.
44
150133
4080
02:50
Maybe he ate something bad for lunch,
45
154213
2057
02:52
and then things get really horrible,
46
156270
2847
02:55
as his skin rips apart, and he sees a virus
47
159117
2872
02:57
coming out from his insides.
48
161989
2136
03:00
And then it gets horrible
49
164125
3184
03:03
when he bursts open and an army of viruses
50
167309
3024
03:06
floods out from his insides.
51
170333
3081
03:09
If -- Ouch is right! --
52
173414
3183
03:12
If you see this, and you're a bacterium,
53
176597
3217
03:15
this is like your worst nightmare.
54
179814
3215
03:18
But if you're a virus and you see this,
55
183029
2617
03:21
you cross those little legs of yours and you think,
56
185646
2391
03:23
"We rock."
57
188037
2560
03:26
Because it took a lot of crafty work to infect this bacterium.
58
190597
4784
03:31
Here's what had to happen.
59
195381
2313
03:33
A virus grabbed onto a bacterium
60
197694
3119
03:36
and it slipped its DNA into it.
61
200813
3697
03:40
The next thing is, that virus DNA made stuff
62
204510
3031
03:43
that chopped up the bacteria DNA.
63
207541
4144
03:47
And now that we've gotten rid of the bacteria DNA,
64
211685
2888
03:50
the virus DNA takes control of the cell
65
214573
4207
03:54
and it tells it to start making more viruses.
66
218780
3993
03:58
Because, you see, DNA is like a blueprint
67
222773
3712
04:02
that tells living things what to make.
68
226485
3224
04:05
So this is kind of like going into a car factory
69
229709
3232
04:08
and replacing the blueprints with blueprints for killer robots.
70
232941
6056
04:14
The workers still come the next day, they do their job,
71
238997
2976
04:17
but they're following different instructions.
72
241973
3225
04:21
So replacing the bacteria DNA with virus DNA
73
245198
3295
04:24
turns the bacteria into a factory for making viruses --
74
248493
5528
04:29
that is, until it's so filled with viruses that it bursts.
75
254021
3904
04:33
But that's not the only way that viruses infect bacteria.
76
257925
4900
04:38
Some are much more crafty.
77
262825
6166
04:44
When a secret agent virus infects a bacterium,
78
268991
3846
04:48
they do a little espionage.
79
272837
3000
04:51
Here, this cloaked, secret agent virus is slipping his DNA into the bacterial cell,
80
275837
7272
04:59
but here's the kicker: It doesn't do anything harmful -- not at first.
81
283109
5733
05:04
Instead, it silently slips into the bacteria's own DNA,
82
288842
5400
05:10
and it just stays there like a terrorist sleeper cell,
83
294242
4632
05:14
waiting for instructions.
84
298874
3025
05:17
And what's interesting about this is now whenever this bacteria has babies,
85
301899
5871
05:23
the babies also have the virus DNA in them.
86
307770
5424
05:29
So now we have a whole extended bacteria family,
87
313194
3767
05:32
filled with virus sleeper cells.
88
316961
4145
05:37
They're just happily living together until a signal happens
89
321106
4639
05:41
and -- BAM! -- all of the DNA pops out.
90
325745
4032
05:45
It takes control of these cells, turns them into virus-making factories,
91
329777
4072
05:49
and they all burst,
92
333849
1976
05:51
a huge, extended bacteria family,
93
335825
2376
05:54
all dying with viruses spilling out of their guts,
94
338201
3383
05:57
the viruses taking over the bacterium.
95
341584
4990
06:02
So now you understand how viruses can attack cells.
96
346574
3979
06:06
There are two ways: On the left is what we call the lytic way,
97
350553
4368
06:10
where the viruses go right in and take over the cells.
98
354921
4270
06:15
On the [right] is the lysogenic way
99
359191
2762
06:17
that uses secret agent viruses.
100
361953
3337
06:21
So this stuff is not that hard, right?
101
365290
2767
06:23
And now all of you understand it.
102
368057
2016
06:25
But if you've graduated from high school,
103
370073
1768
06:27
I can almost guarantee you've seen this information before.
104
371841
3408
06:31
But I bet it was presented in a way
105
375249
2784
06:33
that it didn't exactly stick in your mind.
106
378033
4086
06:38
So when my students were first learning this,
107
382119
2690
06:40
why did they hate it so much?
108
384809
2920
06:43
Well, there were a couple of reasons.
109
387729
1987
06:45
First of all, I can guarantee you that their textbooks
110
389716
3345
06:48
didn't have secret agent viruses, and they didn't have horror stories.
111
393061
5242
06:54
You know, in the communication of science
112
398303
2837
06:57
there is this obsession with seriousness.
113
401140
4254
07:01
It kills me. I'm not kidding.
114
405394
1890
07:03
I used to work for an educational publisher,
115
407284
2312
07:05
and as a writer, I was always told never to use stories
116
409596
3745
07:09
or fun, engaging language,
117
413341
1839
07:11
because then my work might not be viewed
118
415180
2240
07:13
as "serious" and "scientific."
119
417420
3288
07:16
Right? I mean, because God forbid somebody have fun
120
420708
2776
07:19
when they're learning science.
121
423484
2192
07:21
So we have this field of science that's all about slime,
122
425676
4703
07:26
and color changes. Check this out.
123
430379
4028
07:39
And then we have, of course, as any good scientist has to have,
124
443700
4952
07:44
explosions!
125
448652
3442
07:47
But if a textbook seems too much fun,
126
452094
4150
07:52
it's somehow unscientific.
127
456244
3752
07:55
Now another problem was that
128
459996
3856
07:59
the language in their textbook was truly incomprehensible.
129
463852
5640
08:05
If we want to summarize that story that I told you earlier,
130
469492
2689
08:08
we could start by saying something like,
131
472181
1319
08:09
"These viruses make copies of themselves
132
473500
2378
08:11
by slipping their DNA into a bacterium."
133
475878
2742
08:14
The way this showed up in the textbook, it looked like this:
134
478620
3441
08:17
"Bacteriophage replication is initiated
135
482061
3295
08:21
through the introduction of viral nucleic acid
136
485356
3067
08:24
into a bacterium."
137
488423
2542
08:26
That's great, perfect for 13-year-olds.
138
490965
4695
08:31
But here's the thing. There are plenty of people
139
495660
2640
08:34
in science education who would look at this and say there's no way
140
498300
3207
08:37
that we could ever give that to students,
141
501507
2945
08:40
because it contains some language that isn't completely accurate.
142
504452
4920
08:45
For example, I told you that viruses have DNA.
143
509372
2456
08:47
Well, a very tiny fraction of them don't.
144
511828
3129
08:50
They have something called RNA instead.
145
514957
2415
08:53
So a professional science writer would circle that
146
517372
2352
08:55
and say, "That has to go.
147
519724
1146
08:56
We have to change it to something much more technical."
148
520870
2150
08:58
And after a team of professional science editors
149
523020
2566
09:01
went over this really simple explanation,
150
525586
3666
09:05
they'd find fault with almost every word I've used,
151
529252
4944
09:10
and they'd have to change anything that wasn't serious enough,
152
534196
2368
09:12
and they'd have to change everything
153
536564
1768
09:14
that wasn't 100 percent perfect.
154
538332
3776
09:18
Then it would be accurate,
155
542108
1816
09:19
but it would be completely impossible to understand.
156
543924
5136
09:24
This is horrifying.
157
549060
2192
09:27
You know, I keep talking about this idea
158
551252
1992
09:29
of telling a story,
159
553244
2544
09:31
and it's like science communication has taken on this idea
160
555788
5127
09:36
of what I call the tyranny of precision,
161
560915
2977
09:39
where you can't just tell a story.
162
563892
1920
09:41
It's like science has become that horrible storyteller
163
565812
4948
09:46
that we all know, who gives us all the details nobody cares about,
164
570760
3420
09:50
where you're like, "Oh, I met my friend for lunch the other day,
165
574180
3944
09:54
and she was wearing these ugly jeans.
166
578124
1936
09:55
I mean, they weren't really jeans, they were more kind of, like, leggings,
167
580060
2624
09:58
but, like, I guess they're actually kind of more like jeggings,
168
582684
2520
10:01
like, but I think — " and you're just like, "Oh my God.
169
585204
2784
10:03
What is the point?"
170
587988
2594
10:06
Or even worse, science education is becoming
171
590582
4036
10:10
like that guy who always says, "Actually."
172
594618
3506
10:14
Right? You want to be like, "Oh, dude,
173
598124
3080
10:17
we had to get up in the middle of the night
174
601204
1400
10:18
and drive a hundred miles in total darkness."
175
602604
3616
10:22
And that guy's like, "Actually, it was 87.3 miles."
176
606220
4588
10:26
And you're like, "Actually, shut up!
177
610808
2388
10:29
I'm just trying to tell a story."
178
613196
4231
10:33
Because good storytelling is all about emotional connection.
179
617427
6297
10:39
We have to convince our audience
180
623724
2400
10:42
that what we're talking about matters.
181
626124
3120
10:45
But just as important is knowing
182
629244
2664
10:47
which details we should leave out
183
631908
2488
10:50
so that the main point still comes across.
184
634396
3520
10:53
I'm reminded of what the architect Mies van der Rohe said,
185
637916
3232
10:57
and I paraphrase, when he said that sometimes
186
641148
2984
11:00
you have to lie in order to tell the truth.
187
644132
3909
11:03
I think this sentiment is particularly relevant
188
648041
2643
11:06
to science education.
189
650684
3374
11:09
Now, finally,
190
654058
2722
11:12
I am often so disappointed
191
656780
4376
11:17
when people think that I'm advocating
192
661156
2856
11:19
a dumbing down of science.
193
664012
2640
11:22
That's not true at all.
194
666652
1776
11:24
I'm currently a Ph.D. student at MIT,
195
668428
2981
11:27
and I absolutely understand the importance of detailed,
196
671409
4989
11:32
specific scientific communication between experts,
197
676398
4639
11:36
but not when we're trying to teach 13-year-olds.
198
681037
4095
11:41
If a young learner thinks that all viruses have DNA,
199
685132
5296
11:46
that's not going to ruin their chances of success in science.
200
690428
5120
11:51
But if a young learner can't understand anything in science
201
695548
4363
11:55
and learns to hate it because it all sounds like this,
202
699911
4093
11:59
that will ruin their chances of success.
203
704004
3552
12:03
This needs to stop,
204
707556
3037
12:06
and I wish that the change could come from the institutions
205
710593
3310
12:09
at the top that are perpetuating these problems,
206
713903
2768
12:12
and I beg them, I beseech them to just stop it.
207
716671
3966
12:16
But I think that's unlikely.
208
720637
2519
12:19
So we are so lucky that we have resources
209
723156
3544
12:22
like the Internet, where we can circumvent these institutions
210
726700
3120
12:25
from the bottom up.
211
729820
3154
12:28
There's a growing number of online resources
212
732974
3318
12:32
that are dedicated to just explaining science
213
736292
3128
12:35
in simple, understandable ways.
214
739420
3296
12:38
I dream of a Wikipedia-like website that would explain
215
742716
3056
12:41
any scientific concept you can think of
216
745772
2752
12:44
in simple language any middle schooler can understand.
217
748524
4680
12:49
And I myself spend most of my free time
218
753204
3272
12:52
making these science videos that I put on YouTube.
219
756476
4161
12:56
I explain chemical equilibrium using analogies
220
760637
2967
12:59
to awkward middle school dances,
221
763604
2488
13:01
and I talk about fuel cells with stories
222
766092
2384
13:04
about boys and girls at a summer camp.
223
768476
3376
13:07
The feedback that I get is sometimes misspelled
224
771852
3760
13:11
and it's often written in LOLcats,
225
775612
2216
13:13
but nonetheless
226
777828
2496
13:16
it's so appreciative, so thankful
227
780324
4439
13:20
that I know this is the right way
228
784763
3554
13:24
we should be communicating science.
229
788317
3567
13:27
There's still so much work left to be done, though,
230
791884
2936
13:30
and if you're involved with science in any way
231
794820
3208
13:33
I urge you to join me.
232
798028
2864
13:36
Pick up a camera, start to write a blog, whatever,
233
800892
5056
13:41
but leave out the seriousness, leave out the jargon.
234
805948
4160
13:46
Make me laugh. Make me care.
235
810108
3616
13:49
Leave out those annoying details that nobody cares about
236
813724
3152
13:52
and just get to the point.
237
816876
3896
13:56
How should you start?
238
820772
2142
13:58
Why don't you say, "Listen, let me tell you a story"?
239
822914
4274
14:03
Thank you.
240
827188
2050
14:05
(Applause)
241
829238
881
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tyler DeWitt - Science enthusiastTyler DeWitt recognizes that textbooks are not the way to get young people interested in science. Instead, he teaches science by making it fun and fantastical.
Why you should listen
Tyler DeWitt has taught Biology, Chemistry and English at high schools in both the United States and South Korea, and believes that science could be every student’s favorite class if it weren’t for the long words and overly technical presentation. Instead, DeWitt focuses on creating engaging lessons that evoke a sense of wonder in kids and that encourage them to think critically.
Currently a Ph.D. student in Microbiology at MIT, DeWitt studies how bacteria transfer pieces of DNA to their neighbors. He is also a coordinator for the MIT+K12 video outreach project, which encourages MIT students to create educational videos for students of all ages in all subjects. DeWitt also has a full YouTube library of videos that teach everything from valence electrons to the chemistry of acids, all with an eye toward fun.
Tyler DeWitt | Speaker | TED.com