TEDGlobal 2013
George Monbiot: For more wonder, rewild the world
Filmed:
Readability: 4.6
1,093,408 views
Wolves were once native to the US' Yellowstone National Park -- until hunting wiped them out. But when, in 1995, the wolves began to come back (thanks to an aggressive management program), something interesting happened: the rest of the park began to find a new, more healthful balance. In a bold thought experiment, George Monbiot imagines a wilder world in which humans work to restore the complex, lost natural food chains that once surrounded us.
George Monbiot - Rewilding campaigner
As George Monbiot puts it: "I spend my life looking for ways to untangle the terrible mess we’ve got ourselves into." Full bio
As George Monbiot puts it: "I spend my life looking for ways to untangle the terrible mess we’ve got ourselves into." Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
When I was a young man, I spent six years
0
212
2073
00:14
of wild adventure in the tropics
1
2285
2113
00:16
working as an investigative journalist
2
4398
2128
00:18
in some of the most bewitching parts of the world.
3
6526
3385
00:21
I was as reckless and foolish as only young men can be.
4
9911
3199
00:25
This is why wars get fought.
5
13110
1538
00:26
But I also felt more alive than I've ever done since.
6
14648
4227
00:30
And when I came home, I found the scope of my existence
7
18875
3893
00:34
gradually diminishing
8
22768
1983
00:36
until loading the dishwasher seemed like an interesting challenge.
9
24751
4446
00:41
And I found myself sort of
10
29197
2140
00:43
scratching at the walls of life,
11
31337
2057
00:45
as if I was trying to find a way out
12
33394
2038
00:47
into a wider space beyond.
13
35432
1887
00:49
I was, I believe, ecologically bored.
14
37319
4531
00:53
Now, we evolved in rather more challenging times than these,
15
41850
4481
00:58
in a world of horns and tusks and fangs and claws.
16
46331
4826
01:03
And we still possess the fear and the courage
17
51157
2596
01:05
and the aggression required to navigate those times.
18
53753
3193
01:08
But in our comfortable, safe, crowded lands,
19
56946
4684
01:13
we have few opportunities to exercise them
20
61630
2983
01:16
without harming other people.
21
64613
3152
01:19
And this was the sort of constraint that I found myself
22
67765
4138
01:23
bumping up against.
23
71903
2250
01:26
To conquer uncertainty,
24
74153
2612
01:28
to know what comes next,
25
76765
3318
01:32
that's almost been the dominant aim of industrialized societies,
26
80083
4570
01:36
and having got there, or almost got there,
27
84653
3600
01:40
we have just encountered a new set of unmet needs.
28
88253
3363
01:43
We've privileged safety over experience
29
91616
3002
01:46
and we've gained a lot in doing so,
30
94618
2504
01:49
but I think we've lost something too.
31
97122
3008
01:52
Now, I don't romanticize evolutionary time.
32
100130
2802
01:54
I'm already beyond the lifespan of most hunter-gatherers,
33
102932
3518
01:58
and the outcome of a mortal combat between me
34
106450
3229
02:01
myopically stumbling around with a stone-tipped spear
35
109679
2913
02:04
and an enraged giant aurochs
36
112592
2482
02:07
isn't very hard to predict.
37
115074
2482
02:09
Nor was it authenticity that I was looking for.
38
117556
2996
02:12
I don't find that a useful or even intelligible concept.
39
120552
3140
02:15
I just wanted a richer and rawer life
40
123692
3926
02:19
than I've been able to lead in Britain, or, indeed,
41
127618
2496
02:22
that we can lead in most parts of the industrialized world.
42
130114
3412
02:25
And it was only when I stumbled across an unfamiliar word
43
133526
5506
02:31
that I began to understand what I was looking for.
44
139032
3605
02:34
And as soon as I found that word,
45
142637
2654
02:37
I realized that I wanted to devote
46
145291
2028
02:39
much of the rest of my life to it.
47
147319
3755
02:43
The word is "rewilding,"
48
151074
3501
02:46
and even though rewilding is a young word,
49
154575
2782
02:49
it already has several definitions.
50
157357
1867
02:51
But there are two in particular that fascinate me.
51
159224
4036
02:55
The first one is the mass restoration
52
163260
3951
02:59
of ecosystems.
53
167211
2655
03:01
One of the most exciting scientific findings
54
169866
2970
03:04
of the past half century
55
172836
1770
03:06
has been the discovery of widespread trophic cascades.
56
174606
4746
03:11
A trophic cascade is an ecological process
57
179352
3178
03:14
which starts at the top of the food chain
58
182530
2375
03:16
and tumbles all the way down to the bottom,
59
184905
3295
03:20
and the classic example is what happened
60
188200
2343
03:22
in the Yellowstone National Park in the United States
61
190543
2811
03:25
when wolves were reintroduced in 1995.
62
193354
4089
03:29
Now, we all know that wolves kill various species of animals,
63
197443
4435
03:33
but perhaps we're slightly less aware
64
201878
2399
03:36
that they give life to many others.
65
204277
3838
03:40
It sounds strange, but just follow me for a while.
66
208115
3113
03:43
Before the wolves turned up,
67
211228
1826
03:45
they'd been absent for 70 years.
68
213054
1659
03:46
The numbers of deer, because there was nothing to hunt them,
69
214713
3065
03:49
had built up and built up in the Yellowstone Park,
70
217778
2754
03:52
and despite efforts by humans to control them,
71
220532
3091
03:55
they'd managed to reduce much of the vegetation there
72
223623
2695
03:58
to almost nothing, they'd just grazed it away.
73
226318
3421
04:01
But as soon as the wolves arrived,
74
229739
2195
04:03
even though they were few in number,
75
231934
1827
04:05
they started to have the most remarkable effects.
76
233761
3899
04:09
First, of course, they killed some of the deer,
77
237660
2171
04:11
but that wasn't the major thing.
78
239831
1812
04:13
Much more significantly,
79
241643
2031
04:15
they radically changed the behavior of the deer.
80
243674
3199
04:18
The deer started avoiding certain parts of the park,
81
246873
2913
04:21
the places where they could be trapped most easily,
82
249786
2223
04:24
particularly the valleys and the gorges,
83
252009
2739
04:26
and immediately those places started to regenerate.
84
254748
3189
04:29
In some areas, the height of the trees
85
257937
2399
04:32
quintupled in just six years.
86
260336
3012
04:35
Bare valley sides quickly became forests of aspen
87
263348
4067
04:39
and willow and cottonwood.
88
267415
2271
04:41
And as soon as that happened,
89
269686
1778
04:43
the birds started moving in.
90
271464
2158
04:45
The number of songbirds, of migratory birds,
91
273622
2421
04:48
started to increase greatly.
92
276043
2074
04:50
The number of beavers started to increase,
93
278117
2057
04:52
because beavers like to eat the trees.
94
280174
2681
04:54
And beavers, like wolves, are ecosystem engineers.
95
282855
3228
04:58
They create niches for other species.
96
286083
2879
05:00
And the dams they built in the rivers
97
288962
2212
05:03
provided habitats for otters and muskrats
98
291174
2934
05:06
and ducks and fish and reptiles and amphibians.
99
294108
4181
05:10
The wolves killed coyotes, and as a result of that,
100
298289
4105
05:14
the number of rabbits and mice began to rise,
101
302394
2462
05:16
which meant more hawks, more weasels,
102
304856
2910
05:19
more foxes, more badgers.
103
307766
2399
05:22
Ravens and bald eagles came down to feed
104
310165
2487
05:24
on the carrion that the wolves had left.
105
312652
2236
05:26
Bears fed on it too, and their population began to rise as well,
106
314888
3709
05:30
partly also because there were more berries
107
318597
2343
05:32
growing on the regenerating shrubs,
108
320940
2312
05:35
and the bears reinforced the impact of the wolves
109
323252
3231
05:38
by killing some of the calves of the deer.
110
326483
4399
05:42
But here's where it gets really interesting.
111
330882
3676
05:46
The wolves changed the behavior of the rivers.
112
334558
5285
05:51
They began to meander less.
113
339843
1687
05:53
There was less erosion. The channels narrowed.
114
341530
3623
05:57
More pools formed, more riffle sections,
115
345153
2395
05:59
all of which were great for wildlife habitats.
116
347548
2231
06:01
The rivers changed
117
349779
2202
06:03
in response to the wolves,
118
351981
2212
06:06
and the reason was that the regenerating forests
119
354193
3645
06:09
stabilized the banks so that they collapsed less often,
120
357838
3691
06:13
so that the rivers became more fixed in their course.
121
361529
3320
06:16
Similarly, by driving the deer out of some places
122
364849
3727
06:20
and the vegetation recovering on the valley sides,
123
368576
4356
06:24
there was less soil erosion,
124
372932
1413
06:26
because the vegetation stabilized that as well.
125
374345
3536
06:29
So the wolves, small in number,
126
377881
3361
06:33
transformed not just the ecosystem
127
381242
2963
06:36
of the Yellowstone National Park, this huge area of land,
128
384205
3102
06:39
but also its physical geography.
129
387307
4218
06:43
Whales in the southern oceans
130
391525
1624
06:45
have similarly wide-ranging effects.
131
393149
2503
06:47
One of the many post-rational excuses
132
395652
2867
06:50
made by the Japanese government for killing whales
133
398519
2990
06:53
is that they said, "Well, the number of fish and krill will rise
134
401509
3134
06:56
and then there'll be more for people to eat."
135
404643
2238
06:58
Well, it's a stupid excuse, but it sort of
136
406881
2011
07:00
kind of makes sense, doesn't it,
137
408892
1369
07:02
because you'd think that whales eat huge amounts
138
410261
2124
07:04
of fish and krill, so obviously take the whales away,
139
412385
2162
07:06
there'll be more fish and krill.
140
414547
2062
07:08
But the opposite happened.
141
416609
2393
07:11
You take the whales away,
142
419002
1329
07:12
and the number of krill collapses.
143
420331
2851
07:15
Why would that possibly have happened?
144
423182
2093
07:17
Well, it now turns out that the whales are crucial
145
425275
3140
07:20
to sustaining that entire ecosystem,
146
428415
3313
07:23
and one of the reasons for this
147
431728
1729
07:25
is that they often feed at depth
148
433457
2100
07:27
and then they come up to the surface and produce
149
435557
1782
07:29
what biologists politely call large fecal plumes,
150
437339
4186
07:33
huge explosions of poop right across the surface waters,
151
441525
4433
07:37
up in the photic zone, where there's enough light
152
445958
3316
07:41
to allow photosynthesis to take place,
153
449274
3172
07:44
and those great plumes of fertilizer
154
452446
2944
07:47
stimulate the growth of phytoplankton,
155
455390
1992
07:49
the plant plankton at the bottom of the food chain,
156
457382
1914
07:51
which stimulate the growth of zooplankton,
157
459296
2098
07:53
which feed the fish and the krill and all the rest of it.
158
461394
2297
07:55
The other thing that whales do is that,
159
463691
2134
07:57
as they're plunging up and down through the water column,
160
465825
2729
08:00
they're kicking the phytoplankton
161
468554
2368
08:02
back up towards the surface
162
470922
1450
08:04
where it can continue to survive and reproduce.
163
472372
3114
08:07
And interestingly, well, we know
164
475486
2628
08:10
that plant plankton in the oceans
165
478114
2937
08:13
absorb carbon from the atmosphere --
166
481051
1807
08:14
the more plant plankton there are,
167
482858
1543
08:16
the more carbon they absorb --
168
484401
1679
08:18
and eventually they filter down into the abyss
169
486080
3082
08:21
and remove that carbon from the atmospheric system.
170
489162
3380
08:24
Well, it seems that when whales were at their historic populations,
171
492542
4301
08:28
they were probably responsible for sequestering
172
496843
3009
08:31
some tens of millions of tons of carbon
173
499852
3793
08:35
every year from the atmosphere.
174
503645
2689
08:38
And when you look at it like that, you think,
175
506334
3227
08:41
wait a minute, here are the wolves
176
509561
1859
08:43
changing the physical geography of the Yellowstone National Park.
177
511420
3017
08:46
Here are the whales changing
178
514437
1859
08:48
the composition of the atmosphere.
179
516296
2640
08:50
You begin to see that possibly,
180
518936
2310
08:53
the evidence supporting James Lovelock's Gaia hypothesis,
181
521246
3681
08:56
which conceives of the world as a coherent,
182
524927
2587
08:59
self-regulating organism,
183
527514
1930
09:01
is beginning, at the ecosystem level, to accumulate.
184
529444
5734
09:07
Trophic cascades
185
535178
2268
09:09
tell us that the natural world
186
537446
2061
09:11
is even more fascinating and complex than we thought it was.
187
539507
4746
09:16
They tell us that when you take away the large animals,
188
544253
3732
09:19
you are left with a radically different ecosystem
189
547985
3192
09:23
to one which retains its large animals.
190
551177
3172
09:26
And they make, in my view, a powerful case
191
554349
3281
09:29
for the reintroduction of missing species.
192
557630
4153
09:33
Rewilding, to me,
193
561783
2076
09:35
means bringing back some of the missing plants and animals.
194
563859
3298
09:39
It means taking down the fences,
195
567157
1312
09:40
it means blocking the drainage ditches,
196
568469
2024
09:42
it means preventing commercial fishing in some large areas of sea,
197
570493
3264
09:45
but otherwise stepping back.
198
573757
3414
09:49
It has no view as to what a right ecosystem
199
577171
3810
09:52
or a right assemblage of species looks like.
200
580981
2701
09:55
It doesn't try to produce a heath or a meadow
201
583682
3779
09:59
or a rain forest or a kelp garden or a coral reef.
202
587461
4686
10:04
It lets nature decide,
203
592147
2017
10:06
and nature, by and large, is pretty good at deciding.
204
594164
3819
10:09
Now, I mentioned that there are two definitions
205
597983
2275
10:12
of rewilding that interest me.
206
600258
1846
10:14
The other one
207
602104
1257
10:15
is the rewilding of human life.
208
603361
3023
10:18
And I don't see this as an alternative
209
606384
2063
10:20
to civilization.
210
608447
1924
10:22
I believe we can enjoy the benefits of advanced technology,
211
610371
3400
10:25
as we're doing now, but at the same time, if we choose,
212
613771
3839
10:29
have access to a richer and wilder life of adventure
213
617610
5016
10:34
when we want to because
214
622626
1583
10:36
there would be wonderful, rewilded habitats.
215
624209
4396
10:40
And the opportunities for this
216
628605
1784
10:42
are developing more rapidly than you might think possible.
217
630389
4991
10:47
There's one estimate which suggests that in the United States,
218
635380
2979
10:50
two thirds of the land which was once forested and then cleared
219
638359
3685
10:54
has become reforested as loggers and farmers have retreated,
220
642044
3503
10:57
particularly from the eastern half of the country.
221
645547
3013
11:00
There's another one which suggests
222
648560
1657
11:02
that 30 million hectares of land in Europe,
223
650217
3463
11:05
an area the size of Poland,
224
653680
2507
11:08
will be vacated by farmers
225
656187
1831
11:10
between 2000 and 2030.
226
658018
3322
11:13
Now, faced with opportunities like that,
227
661340
3536
11:16
does it not seem a little unambitious
228
664876
2171
11:19
to be thinking only of bringing back wolves, lynx,
229
667047
3714
11:22
bears, beavers, bison, boar, moose,
230
670761
3599
11:26
and all the other species which are already beginning
231
674360
1825
11:28
to move quite rapidly across Europe?
232
676185
3264
11:31
Perhaps we should also start thinking
233
679449
2524
11:33
about the return of some of our lost megafauna.
234
681973
3989
11:37
What megafauna, you say?
235
685962
1932
11:39
Well, every continent had one,
236
687894
2569
11:42
apart from Antarctica.
237
690463
1481
11:43
When Trafalgar Square in London was excavated,
238
691944
3638
11:47
the river gravels there were found
239
695582
1755
11:49
to be stuffed with the bones of hippopotamus,
240
697337
3550
11:52
rhinos, elephants, hyenas, lions.
241
700887
4088
11:56
Yes, ladies and gentlemen,
242
704975
1374
11:58
there were lions in Trafalgar Square
243
706349
2196
12:00
long before Nelson's Column was built.
244
708545
3206
12:03
All these species lived here
245
711751
2251
12:06
in the last interglacial period,
246
714002
2652
12:08
when temperatures were pretty similar to our own.
247
716654
2861
12:11
It's not climate, largely,
248
719515
2073
12:13
which has got rid of the world's megafaunas.
249
721588
3547
12:17
It's pressure from the human population
250
725135
2104
12:19
hunting and destroying their habitats
251
727239
1836
12:21
which has done so.
252
729075
2051
12:23
And even so, you can still see the shadows
253
731126
3788
12:26
of these great beasts in our current ecosystems.
254
734914
2708
12:29
Why is it that so many deciduous trees
255
737622
2953
12:32
are able to sprout from whatever point the trunk is broken?
256
740575
4558
12:37
Why is it that they can withstand the loss
257
745133
2069
12:39
of so much of their bark?
258
747202
1607
12:40
Why do understory trees,
259
748809
2943
12:43
which are subject to lower sheer forces from the wind
260
751752
5093
12:48
and have to carry less weight
261
756845
1731
12:50
than the big canopy trees,
262
758576
2402
12:52
why are they so much tougher and harder to break
263
760978
3119
12:56
than the canopy trees are?
264
764097
4409
13:00
Elephants.
265
768506
1972
13:02
They are elephant-adapted.
266
770478
2169
13:04
In Europe, for example,
267
772647
2288
13:06
they evolved to resist the straight-tusked elephant,
268
774935
3143
13:10
elephas antiquus, which was a great beast.
269
778078
2288
13:12
It was related to the Asian elephant,
270
780366
2176
13:14
but it was a temperate animal, a temperate forest creature.
271
782542
2569
13:17
It was a lot bigger than the Asian elephant.
272
785111
2530
13:19
But why is it that some of our common shrubs
273
787641
2817
13:22
have spines which seem to be over-engineered
274
790458
3184
13:25
to resist browsing by deer?
275
793642
2663
13:28
Perhaps because they evolved
276
796305
1814
13:30
to resist browsing by rhinoceros.
277
798119
3263
13:33
Isn't it an amazing thought
278
801382
1924
13:35
that every time you wander into a park
279
803306
2728
13:38
or down an avenue or through a leafy street,
280
806034
2847
13:40
you can see the shadows of these great beasts?
281
808881
3611
13:44
Paleoecology, the study of past ecosystems,
282
812492
3800
13:48
crucial to an understanding of our own,
283
816292
4058
13:52
feels like a portal through which you may pass
284
820350
3577
13:55
into an enchanted kingdom.
285
823927
2932
13:58
And if we really are looking at areas of land
286
826859
3813
14:02
of the sort of sizes I've been talking about becoming available,
287
830672
4245
14:06
why not reintroduce some of our lost megafauna,
288
834917
2715
14:09
or at least species closely related to those
289
837632
1950
14:11
which have become extinct everywhere?
290
839582
2961
14:14
Why shouldn't all of us
291
842543
2309
14:16
have a Serengeti on our doorsteps?
292
844852
2953
14:19
And perhaps this is the most important thing
293
847805
2966
14:22
that rewilding offers us,
294
850771
1475
14:24
the most important thing that's missing from our lives:
295
852246
3594
14:27
hope.
296
855840
2117
14:29
In motivating people to love and defend the natural world,
297
857957
4397
14:34
an ounce of hope is worth a ton of despair.
298
862354
4810
14:39
The story rewilding tells us
299
867164
2639
14:41
is that ecological change need not always proceed
300
869803
3640
14:45
in one direction.
301
873443
2463
14:47
It offers us the hope
302
875906
2436
14:50
that our silent spring
303
878342
2141
14:52
could be replaced by a raucous summer.
304
880483
2331
14:54
Thank you.
305
882814
1220
14:56
(Applause)
306
884034
6011
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
George Monbiot - Rewilding campaignerAs George Monbiot puts it: "I spend my life looking for ways to untangle the terrible mess we’ve got ourselves into."
Why you should listen
As a young man, George Monbiot spent six years working as an investigative journalist in West Papua, Brazil and East Africa, during which time he was shot at, shipwrecked, beaten up, stung into a poisoned coma by hornets, became lost for days in a rainforest, where he ate rats and insects to avert starvation and was (incorrectly) pronounced clinically dead in a hospital in northern Kenya. Today, he leads a less adventurous life as an author, columnist for the Guardian newspaper and environmental campaigner. Among his books and projects are Feral: Rewilding the Land, the Sea and Human Life; The Age of Consent and Heat: How to Stop the Planet from Burning, as well as the concept album Breaking the Spell of Loneliness. His latest book is Out of the Wreckage: A New Politics for an Age of Crisis. He has made a number of viral videos. One of them, How Wolves Change Rivers, has been watched 30m times on YouTube.
George Monbiot | Speaker | TED.com