TED2008
Samantha Power: A complicated hero in the war on dictatorship
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
572,298 views
Would you negotiate with someone you knew to be evil, to save lives? Samantha Power tells a story of a complicated hero, Sergio Vieira de Mello. This UN diplomat walked a thin moral line, negotiating with the world's worst dictators to help their people survive crisis. It's a compelling story told with a fiery passion.
Samantha Power - Political scientist and journalist
Samantha Power studies US foreign policy, especially as it relates to war and human rights. Her books take on the world's worst problems: genocide, civil war and brutal dictatorships. Full bio
Samantha Power studies US foreign policy, especially as it relates to war and human rights. Her books take on the world's worst problems: genocide, civil war and brutal dictatorships. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:18
I spent the better part of a decade
0
0
3000
00:21
looking at American responses to mass atrocity and genocide.
1
3000
6000
00:27
And I'd like to start by sharing with you one moment
2
9000
6000
00:33
that to me sums up what there is to know
3
15000
3000
00:36
about American and democratic responses to mass atrocity.
4
18000
3000
00:39
And that moment came on April 21, 1994.
5
21000
6000
00:45
So 14 years ago, almost, in the middle of the Rwandan genocide,
6
27000
4000
00:49
in which 800,000 people would be systematically exterminated
7
31000
5000
00:54
by the Rwandan government and some extremist militia.
8
36000
5000
00:59
On April 21, in the New York Times,
9
41000
4000
01:03
the paper reported that somewhere between 200,000 and 300,000 people
10
45000
3000
01:06
had already been killed in the genocide.
11
48000
3000
01:09
It was in the paper -- not on the front page.
12
51000
3000
01:12
It was a lot like the Holocaust coverage,
13
54000
2000
01:14
it was buried in the paper.
14
56000
2000
01:16
Rwanda itself was not seen as newsworthy,
15
58000
2000
01:18
and amazingly, genocide itself was not seen as newsworthy.
16
60000
4000
01:22
But on April 21, a wonderfully honest moment occurred.
17
64000
4000
01:26
And that was that an American congresswoman
18
68000
3000
01:29
named Patricia Schroeder from Colorado
19
71000
2000
01:31
met with a group of journalists.
20
73000
2000
01:33
And one of the journalists said to her, what's up?
21
75000
4000
01:37
What's going on in the U.S. government?
22
79000
2000
01:39
Two to 300,000 people have just been exterminated
23
81000
2000
01:41
in the last couple of weeks in Rwanda.
24
83000
2000
01:43
It's two weeks into the genocide at that time,
25
85000
2000
01:45
but of course, at that time you don't know how long it's going to last.
26
87000
3000
01:48
And the journalist said, why is there so little response out of Washington?
27
90000
5000
01:53
Why no hearings, no denunciations,
28
95000
3000
01:56
no people getting arrested in front of the Rwandan embassy
29
98000
3000
01:59
or in front of the White House? What's the deal?
30
101000
4000
02:03
And she said -- she was so honest -- she said, "It's a great question.
31
105000
5000
02:08
All I can tell you is that in my congressional office in Colorado
32
110000
4000
02:12
and my office in Washington,
33
114000
2000
02:14
we're getting hundreds and hundreds of calls
34
116000
3000
02:17
about the endangered ape and gorilla population in Rwanda,
35
119000
5000
02:22
but nobody is calling about the people.
36
124000
3000
02:25
The phones just aren't ringing about the people."
37
127000
3000
02:28
And the reason I give you this moment is there's a deep truth in it.
38
130000
5000
02:33
And that truth is, or was, in the 20th century,
39
135000
4000
02:37
that while we were beginning to develop endangered species movements,
40
139000
5000
02:42
we didn't have an endangered people's movement.
41
144000
2000
02:44
We had Holocaust education in the schools.
42
146000
4000
02:48
Most of us were groomed not only on images of nuclear catastrophe,
43
150000
4000
02:52
but also on images and knowledge of the Holocaust.
44
154000
4000
02:57
There's a museum, of course, on the Mall in Washington,
45
159000
3000
03:00
right next to Lincoln and Jefferson.
46
162000
2000
03:02
I mean, we have owned Never Again culturally,
47
164000
4000
03:06
appropriately, interestingly.
48
168000
4000
03:10
And yet the politicization of Never Again,
49
172000
4000
03:14
the operationalization of Never Again,
50
176000
2000
03:16
had never occurred in the 20th century.
51
178000
3000
03:19
And that's what that moment with Patricia Schroeder I think shows:
52
181000
3000
03:22
that if we are to bring about an end to the world's worst atrocities,
53
184000
7000
03:29
we have to make it such.
54
191000
2000
03:31
There has to be a role --
55
193000
2000
03:33
there has to be the creation of political noise and political costs
56
195000
3000
03:36
in response to massive crimes against humanity, and so forth.
57
198000
3000
03:39
So that was the 20th century.
58
201000
2000
03:41
Now here -- and this will be a relief to you at this point in the afternoon --
59
203000
4000
03:45
there is good news, amazing news, in the 21st century,
60
207000
4000
03:49
and that is that, almost out of nowhere, there has come into being
61
211000
7000
03:56
an anti-genocide movement, an anti-genocide constituency,
62
218000
3000
03:59
and one that looks destined, in fact, to be permanent.
63
221000
4000
04:03
It grew up in response to the atrocities in Darfur.
64
225000
3000
04:06
It is comprised of students. There are something like 300 anti-genocide chapters
65
228000
6000
04:12
on college campuses around the country.
66
234000
3000
04:15
It's bigger than the anti-apartheid movement.
67
237000
2000
04:17
There are something like 500 high school chapters
68
239000
4000
04:21
devoted to stopping the genocide in Darfur.
69
243000
3000
04:24
Evangelicals have joined it. Jewish groups have joined it.
70
246000
4000
04:28
"Hotel Rwanda" watchers have joined it. It is a cacophonous movement.
71
250000
4000
04:32
To call it a movement, as with all movements, perhaps, is a little misleading.
72
254000
3000
04:35
It's diverse. It's got a lot of different approaches.
73
257000
3000
04:38
It's got all the ups and the downs of movements.
74
260000
2000
04:40
But it has been amazingly successful in one regard,
75
262000
4000
04:44
in that it has become,
76
266000
2000
04:46
it has congealed into this endangered people's movement
77
268000
3000
04:49
that was missing in the 20th century.
78
271000
2000
04:51
It sees itself, such as it is, the it,
79
273000
3000
04:54
as something that will create the impression that there will be political cost,
80
276000
5000
04:59
there will be a political price to be paid,
81
281000
3000
05:02
for allowing genocide, for not having an heroic imagination,
82
284000
4000
05:06
for not being an upstander but for being, in fact, a bystander.
83
288000
4000
05:10
Now because it's student-driven,
84
292000
4000
05:14
there's some amazing things that the movement has done.
85
296000
2000
05:16
They have launched a divestment campaign
86
298000
2000
05:18
that has now convinced, I think, 55 universities in 22 states
87
300000
4000
05:22
to divest their holdings of stocks
88
304000
2000
05:24
with regard to companies doing business in Sudan.
89
306000
4000
05:28
They have a 1-800-GENOCIDE number --
90
310000
2000
05:30
this is going to sound very kitsch,
91
312000
2000
05:32
but for those of you who may not be, I mean, may be apolitical,
92
314000
4000
05:36
but interested in doing something about genocide,
93
318000
2000
05:38
you dial 1-800-GENOCIDE and you type in your zip code,
94
320000
3000
05:41
and you don't even have to know who your congressperson is.
95
323000
2000
05:43
It will refer you directly to your congressperson, to your U.S. senator,
96
325000
4000
05:47
to your governor where divestment legislation is pending.
97
329000
3000
05:50
They've lowered the transaction costs of stopping genocide.
98
332000
4000
05:54
I think the most innovative thing they've introduced recently
99
336000
3000
05:57
are genocide grades.
100
339000
3000
06:00
And it takes students to introduce genocide grades.
101
342000
3000
06:03
So what you now have when a Congress is in session
102
345000
3000
06:06
is members of Congress calling up these 19-year-olds or 24-year-olds
103
348000
5000
06:11
and saying, I'm just told I have a D minus on genocide;
104
353000
3000
06:14
what do I do to get a C? I just want to get a C. Help me.
105
356000
4000
06:18
And the students and the others
106
360000
2000
06:20
who are part of this incredibly energized base
107
362000
2000
06:22
are there to answer that, and there's always something to do.
108
364000
4000
06:26
Now, what this movement has done is it has extracted from the Bush administration
109
368000
5000
06:31
from the United States,
110
373000
2000
06:33
at a time of massive over-stretch -- military, financial, diplomatic --
111
375000
5000
06:38
a whole series of commitments to Darfur
112
380000
2000
06:40
that no other country in the world is making.
113
382000
3000
06:43
For instance, the referral of the crimes in Darfur
114
385000
2000
06:45
to the International Criminal Court,
115
387000
2000
06:47
which the Bush administration doesn't like.
116
389000
2000
06:49
The expenditure of 3 billion dollars in refugee camps to try to keep,
117
391000
4000
06:53
basically, the people who've been displaced from their homes
118
395000
2000
06:55
by the Sudanese government, by the so-called Janjaweed, the militia,
119
397000
3000
06:58
to keep those people alive
120
400000
2000
07:00
until something more durable can be achieved.
121
402000
4000
07:04
And recently, or now not that recently,
122
406000
2000
07:06
about six months ago, the authorization of a peacekeeping force
123
408000
3000
07:09
of 26,000 that will go.
124
411000
2000
07:11
And that's all the Bush administration's leadership,
125
413000
2000
07:13
and it's all because of this bottom-up pressure
126
415000
2000
07:15
and the fact that the phones haven't stopped ringing
127
417000
3000
07:18
from the beginning of this crisis.
128
420000
2000
07:20
The bad news, however, to this question of will evil prevail,
129
422000
3000
07:23
is that evil lives on.
130
425000
2000
07:25
The people in those camps are surrounded on all sides
131
427000
4000
07:29
by so-called Janjaweed, these men on horseback
132
431000
2000
07:31
with spears and Kalashnikovs.
133
433000
2000
07:33
Women who go to get firewood in order to heat the humanitarian aid
134
435000
4000
07:37
in order to feed their families -- humanitarian aid,
135
439000
3000
07:40
the dirty secret of it is it has to be heated, really, to be edible --
136
442000
3000
07:43
are themselves subjected to rape,
137
445000
2000
07:45
which is a tool of the genocide that is being used.
138
447000
2000
07:47
And the peacekeepers I've mentioned, the force has been authorized,
139
449000
3000
07:50
but almost no country on Earth has stepped forward since the authorization
140
452000
5000
07:55
to actually put its troops or its police in harm's way.
141
457000
3000
07:58
So we have achieved an awful lot relative to the 20th century,
142
460000
5000
08:03
and yet far too little relative to the gravity of the crime that is unfolding
143
465000
4000
08:07
as we sit here, as we speak.
144
469000
2000
08:09
Why the limits to the movement?
145
471000
3000
08:12
Why is what has been achieved, or what the movement has done,
146
474000
4000
08:16
been necessary but not sufficient to the crime?
147
478000
2000
08:18
I think there are a couple -- there are many reasons --
148
480000
2000
08:20
but a couple just to focus on briefly.
149
482000
2000
08:22
The first is that the movement, such as it is,
150
484000
4000
08:26
stops at America's borders.
It is not a global movement.
It is not a global movement.
151
488000
4000
08:30
It does not have too many compatriots abroad who themselves
152
492000
4000
08:34
are asking their governments to do more to stop genocide.
153
496000
4000
08:38
And the Holocaust culture that we have in this country
154
500000
2000
08:40
makes Americans, sort of, more prone to, I think,
155
502000
3000
08:43
want to bring Never Again to life.
156
505000
3000
08:46
The guilt that the Clinton administration expressed,
157
508000
4000
08:50
that Bill Clinton expressed over Rwanda,
158
512000
2000
08:52
created a space in our society for a consensus
159
514000
2000
08:54
that Rwanda was bad and wrong
160
516000
2000
08:56
and we wish we had done more, and that is something
161
518000
2000
08:58
that the movement has taken advantage of.
162
520000
2000
09:00
European governments, for the most part,
163
522000
1000
09:01
haven't acknowledged responsibility, and there's nothing to kind of
164
523000
3000
09:04
to push back and up against.
165
526000
4000
09:08
So this movement, if it's to be durable and global,
166
530000
4000
09:12
will have to cross borders, and you will have to see
167
534000
3000
09:15
other citizens in democracies, not simply resting on the assumption
168
537000
4000
09:19
that their government would do something in the face of genocide,
169
541000
3000
09:22
but actually making it such.
170
544000
2000
09:24
Governments will never gravitate towards crimes of this magnitude
171
546000
3000
09:27
naturally or eagerly.
172
549000
2000
09:29
As we saw, they haven't even gravitated towards protecting our ports
173
551000
2000
09:31
or reigning in loose nukes.
174
553000
2000
09:33
Why would we expect in a bureaucracy that it would orient itself
175
555000
4000
09:37
towards distant suffering?
176
559000
2000
09:39
So one reason is it hasn't gone global.
177
561000
2000
09:41
The second is, of course, that at this time in particular in America's history,
178
563000
4000
09:45
we have a credibility problem,
179
567000
2000
09:47
a legitimacy problem in international institutions.
180
569000
2000
09:49
It is structurally really, really hard to do,
181
571000
3000
09:52
as the Bush administration rightly does,
182
574000
2000
09:54
which is to denounce genocide on a Monday
183
576000
4000
09:58
and then describe water boarding on a Tuesday as a no-brainer
184
580000
3000
10:01
and then turn up on Wednesday and look for troop commitments.
185
583000
4000
10:05
Now, other countries have their own reasons for not wanting to get involved.
186
587000
3000
10:08
Let me be clear.
187
590000
2000
10:10
They're in some ways using the Bush administration as an alibi.
188
592000
3000
10:13
But it is essential for us to be a leader in this sphere,
189
595000
4000
10:17
of course to restore our standing and our leadership in the world.
190
599000
4000
10:21
The recovery's going to take some time.
191
603000
2000
10:23
We have to ask ourselves, what now? What do we do going forward
192
605000
3000
10:26
as a country and as citizens in relationship to the world's worst places,
193
608000
4000
10:30
the world's worst suffering, killers, and the kinds of killers
194
612000
5000
10:35
that could come home to roost sometime in the future?
195
617000
5000
10:40
The place that I turned to answer that question was to a man
196
622000
6000
10:46
that many of you may not have ever heard of,
197
628000
3000
10:49
and that is a Brazilian named Sergio Vieira de Mello who,
198
631000
5000
10:54
as Chris said, was blown up in Iraq in 2003.
199
636000
6000
11:00
He was the victim of the first-ever suicide bomb in Iraq.
200
642000
3000
11:03
It's hard to remember, but there was actually a time in the summer of 2003,
201
645000
3000
11:06
even after the U.S. invasion, where,
202
648000
3000
11:09
apart from looting, civilians were relatively safe in Iraq.
203
651000
4000
11:13
Now, who was Sergio? Sergio Vieira de Mello was his name.
204
655000
3000
11:16
In addition to being Brazilian, he was described to me
205
658000
3000
11:19
before I met him in 1994 as someone who was a cross between
206
661000
3000
11:22
James Bond on the one hand and Bobby Kennedy on the other.
207
664000
4000
11:26
And in the U.N., you don't get that many people
208
668000
3000
11:29
who actually manage to merge those qualities.
209
671000
3000
11:32
He was James Bond-like in that he was ingenious.
210
674000
4000
11:36
He was drawn to the flames, he chased the flames,
211
678000
3000
11:39
he was like a moth to the flames. Something of an adrenalin junkie.
212
681000
3000
11:42
He was successful with women.
213
684000
4000
11:47
He was Bobby Kennedy-like because in some ways one could never tell
214
689000
4000
11:51
if he was a realist masquerading as an idealist
215
693000
2000
11:53
or an idealist masquerading as a realist, as people always wondered
216
695000
4000
11:57
about Bobby Kennedy and John Kennedy in that way.
217
699000
3000
12:00
What he was was a decathlete of nation-building, of problem-solving,
218
702000
4000
12:04
of troubleshooting in the world's worst places
219
706000
3000
12:07
and in the world's most broken places.
220
709000
3000
12:10
In failing states, genocidal states, under-governed states,
221
712000
4000
12:14
precisely the kinds of places that threats to this country exist
222
716000
5000
12:19
on the horizon, and precisely the kinds of places
223
721000
3000
12:22
where most of the world's suffering tends to get concentrated.
224
724000
4000
12:26
These are the places he was drawn to.
225
728000
2000
12:28
He moved with the headlines.
226
730000
2000
12:30
He was in the U.N. for 34 years. He joined at the age of 21.
227
732000
5000
12:35
Started off when the causes in the wars du jour in the '70s
228
737000
3000
12:38
were wars of independence and decolonization.
229
740000
2000
12:40
He was there in Bangladesh
230
742000
2000
12:42
dealing with the outflow of millions of refugees --
231
744000
2000
12:44
the largest refugee flow in history up to that point.
232
746000
3000
12:47
He was in Sudan when the civil war broke out there.
233
749000
3000
12:50
He was in Cyprus right after the Turkish invasion.
234
752000
3000
12:53
He was in Mozambique for the War of Independence.
235
755000
2000
12:55
He was in Lebanon. Amazingly, he was in Lebanon -- the U.N. base was used --
236
757000
3000
12:58
Palestinians staged attacks out from behind the U.N. base.
237
760000
4000
13:02
Israel then invaded and overran the U.N. base.
238
764000
3000
13:05
Sergio was in Beirut when the U.S. Embassy was hit
239
767000
2000
13:07
by the first-ever suicide attack against the United States.
240
769000
3000
13:10
People date the beginning of this new era to 9/11, but surely 1983,
241
772000
5000
13:15
with the attack on the US Embassy and the Marine barracks --
242
777000
2000
13:17
which Sergio witnessed -- those are, in fact, in some ways,
243
779000
3000
13:20
the dawning of the era that we find ourselves in today.
244
782000
4000
13:24
From Lebanon he went to Bosnia in the '90s.
245
786000
3000
13:27
The issues were, of course, ethnic sectarian violence.
246
789000
4000
13:31
He was the first person to negotiate with the Khmer Rouge.
247
793000
3000
13:34
Talk about evil prevailing. I mean, here he was in the room
248
796000
3000
13:37
with the embodiment of evil in Cambodia.
249
799000
2000
13:39
He negotiates with the Serbs.
250
801000
2000
13:41
He actually crosses so far into this realm of talking to evil
251
803000
4000
13:45
and trying to convince evil that it doesn't need to prevail
252
807000
3000
13:48
that he earns the nickname -- not Sergio but Serbio
253
810000
3000
13:51
while he's living in the Balkans and conducting these kinds of negotiations.
254
813000
5000
13:56
He then goes to Rwanda and to Congo in the aftermath of the genocide,
255
818000
3000
13:59
and he's the guy who has to decide -- huh, OK, the genocide is over;
256
821000
3000
14:02
800,000 people have been killed; the people responsible are fleeing
257
824000
4000
14:06
into neighboring countries -- into Congo, into Tanzania.
258
828000
3000
14:09
I'm Sergio, I'm a humanitarian, and I want to feed those --
259
831000
3000
14:12
well, I don't want to feed the killers
260
834000
2000
14:14
but I want to feed the two million people who are with them, so we're going to go,
261
836000
3000
14:17
we're going to set up camps,
262
839000
2000
14:19
and we're going to supply humanitarian aid.
263
841000
2000
14:21
But, uh-oh, the killers are within the camps.
264
843000
3000
14:24
Well, I'd like to separate the sheep from the wolves.
265
846000
2000
14:26
Let me go door-to-door to the international community
266
848000
2000
14:28
and see if anybody will give me police or troops to do the separation.
267
850000
3000
14:31
And their response, of course, was no more than we wanted
268
853000
3000
14:34
to stop the genocide and put our troops in harm's way to do that,
269
856000
3000
14:37
nor do we now want to get in the way and pluck genocidaires from camps.
270
859000
5000
14:42
So then you have to make the decision.
271
864000
2000
14:44
Do you turn off the international spigot of life support
272
866000
2000
14:46
and risk two million civilian lives?
273
868000
4000
14:50
Or do you continue feeding the civilians, knowing that the genocidaires
274
872000
3000
14:53
are in the camps, literally sharpening their knives for future battle?
275
875000
4000
14:57
What do you do?
276
879000
1000
14:58
It's all lesser-evil terrain in these broken places.
277
880000
3000
15:01
Late '90s: nation-building is the cause du jour.
278
883000
3000
15:04
He's the guy put in charge. He's the Paul Bremer or the Jerry Bremer
279
886000
4000
15:08
of first Kosovo and then East Timor. He governs the places.
280
890000
3000
15:11
He's the viceroy. He has to decide on tax policy, on currency,
281
893000
4000
15:15
on border patrol, on policing. He has to make all these judgments.
282
897000
4000
15:19
He's a Brazilian in these places. He speaks seven languages.
283
901000
3000
15:22
He's been up to that point in 14 war zones
284
904000
2000
15:24
so he's positioned to make better judgments, perhaps,
285
906000
3000
15:27
than people who have never done that kind of work.
286
909000
2000
15:29
But nonetheless, he is the cutting edge of our experimentation
287
911000
4000
15:33
with doing good with very few resources being brought to bear in,
288
915000
3000
15:36
again, the world's worst places.
289
918000
2000
15:38
And then after Timor, 9/11 has happened,
290
920000
3000
15:41
he's named U.N. Human Rights Commissioner,
291
923000
2000
15:43
and he has to balance liberty and security and figure out,
292
925000
3000
15:46
what do you do when the most powerful country in the United Nations
293
928000
3000
15:49
is bowing out of the Geneva Conventions,
294
931000
3000
15:52
bowing out of international law? Do you denounce?
295
934000
2000
15:54
Well, if you denounce,
296
936000
1000
15:55
you're probably never going to get back in the room.
297
937000
2000
15:57
Maybe you stay reticent. Maybe you try to charm President Bush --
298
939000
5000
16:02
and that's what he did. And in so doing he earned himself,
299
944000
3000
16:05
unfortunately, his final and tragic appointment to Iraq --
300
947000
3000
16:08
the one that resulted in his death.
301
950000
2000
16:10
One note on his death, which is so devastating,
302
952000
3000
16:13
is that despite predicating the war on Iraq
303
955000
2000
16:15
on a link between Saddam Hussein and terrorism in 9/11,
304
957000
5000
16:20
believe it or not, the Bush administration or the invaders
305
962000
3000
16:23
did no planning, no pre-war planning, to respond to terrorism.
306
965000
4000
16:27
So Sergio -- this receptacle of all of this learning on how to deal with evil
307
969000
4000
16:31
and how to deal with brokenness,
308
973000
2000
16:33
lay under the rubble for three and a half hours without rescue.
309
975000
4000
16:37
Stateless. The guy who tried to help the stateless people his whole career.
310
979000
4000
16:41
Like a refugee. Because he represents the U.N.
311
983000
2000
16:43
If you represent everyone, in some ways you represent no one.
312
985000
3000
16:46
You're un-owned.
313
988000
2000
16:48
And what the American -- the most powerful military in the history of mankind
314
990000
3000
16:51
was able to muster for his rescue,
315
993000
2000
16:53
believe it or not, was literally these heroic two American soldiers
316
995000
4000
16:57
went into the shaft. Building was shaking.
317
999000
2000
16:59
One of them had been at 9/11 and lost his buddies on September 11th,
318
1001000
4000
17:03
and yet went in and risked his life in order to save Sergio.
319
1005000
2000
17:05
But all they had was a woman's handbag --
320
1007000
4000
17:09
literally one of those basket handbags --
321
1011000
2000
17:11
and they tied it to a curtain rope from one of the offices at U.N. headquarters,
322
1013000
4000
17:15
and created a pulley system into this shaft in this quivering building
323
1017000
5000
17:20
in the interests of rescuing this person,
324
1022000
3000
17:23
the person we most need to turn to now, this shepherd,
325
1025000
3000
17:26
at a time when so many of us feel like we're lacking guidance.
326
1028000
3000
17:29
And this was the pulley system. This was what we were able to muster for Sergio.
327
1031000
3000
17:32
The good news, for what it's worth,
328
1034000
2000
17:34
is after Sergio and 21 others were killed that day in the attack on the U.N.,
329
1036000
4000
17:38
the military created a search and rescue unit
330
1040000
2000
17:40
that had the cutting equipment, the shoring wood, the cranes,
331
1042000
4000
17:44
the things that you would have needed to do the rescue.
332
1046000
2000
17:46
But it was too late for Sergio.
333
1048000
2000
17:48
I want to wrap up, but I want to close
334
1050000
2000
17:50
with what I take to be the four lessons from Sergio's life
335
1052000
4000
17:54
on this question of how do we prevent evil from prevailing,
336
1056000
3000
17:57
which is how I would have framed the question.
337
1059000
3000
18:00
Here's this guy who got a 34-year head start
338
1062000
3000
18:03
thinking about the kinds of questions we as a country are grappling with,
339
1065000
4000
18:07
we as citizens are grappling with now. What do we take away?
340
1069000
5000
18:12
First, I think, is his relationship to, in fact, evil is something to learn from.
341
1074000
5000
18:17
He, over the course of his career, changed a great deal.
342
1079000
3000
18:20
He had a lot of flaws, but he was very adaptive.
343
1082000
2000
18:22
I think that was his greatest quality.
344
1084000
2000
18:24
He started as somebody who would denounce harmdoers,
345
1086000
4000
18:28
he would charge up to people who were violating international law,
346
1090000
3000
18:31
and he would say, you're violating, this is the U.N. Charter.
347
1093000
2000
18:33
Don't you see it's unacceptable what you're doing?
348
1095000
2000
18:35
And they would laugh at him because he didn't have the power of states,
349
1097000
3000
18:38
the power of any military or police.
350
1100000
2000
18:40
He just had the rules, he had the norms, and he tried to use them.
351
1102000
3000
18:43
And in Lebanon, Southern Lebanon in '82,
352
1105000
3000
18:46
he said to himself and to everybody else,
353
1108000
3000
18:49
I will never use the word "unacceptable" again.
354
1111000
3000
18:52
I will never use it. I will try to make it such,
355
1114000
2000
18:54
but I will never use that word again.
356
1116000
2000
18:56
But he lunged in the opposite direction.
357
1118000
2000
18:58
He started, as I mentioned, to get in the room with evil,
358
1120000
3000
19:01
to not denounce, and became almost obsequious
359
1123000
4000
19:05
when he won the nickname Serbio, for instance,
360
1127000
3000
19:08
and even when he negotiated with the Khmer Rouge
361
1130000
2000
19:10
would black-box what had occurred prior to entering the room.
362
1132000
4000
19:14
But by the end of his life, I think he had struck a balance
363
1136000
3000
19:17
that we as a country can learn from.
364
1139000
2000
19:19
Be in the room, don't be afraid of talking to your adversaries,
365
1141000
4000
19:23
but don't bracket what happened before you entered the room.
366
1145000
4000
19:27
Don't black-box history. Don't check your principles at the door.
367
1149000
5000
19:32
And I think that's something that we have to be in the room,
368
1154000
3000
19:35
whether it's Nixon going to China or Khrushchev and Kennedy
369
1157000
4000
19:39
or Reagan and Gorbachev.
370
1161000
2000
19:41
All the great progress in this country with relation to our adversaries
371
1163000
4000
19:45
has come by going into the room.
372
1167000
2000
19:47
And it doesn't have to be an act of weakness.
373
1169000
3000
19:50
You can actually do far more to build an international coalition
374
1172000
3000
19:53
against a harmdoer or a wrongdoer by being in the room
375
1175000
3000
19:56
and showing to the rest of the world that that person, that regime,
376
1178000
3000
19:59
is the problem and that you, the United States, are not the problem.
377
1181000
3000
20:02
Second take-away from Sergio's life, briefly.
378
1184000
4000
20:06
What I take away, and this in some ways is the most important,
379
1188000
2000
20:08
he espoused and exhibited a reverence for dignity
380
1190000
6000
20:14
that was really, really unusual.
381
1196000
2000
20:16
At a micro level, the individuals around him were visible.
382
1198000
4000
20:20
He saw them.
383
1202000
1000
20:21
At a macro level, he thought, you know,
384
1203000
2000
20:23
we talk about democracy promotion, but we do it in a way sometimes
385
1205000
3000
20:26
that's an affront to people's dignity.
386
1208000
3000
20:29
We put people on humanitarian aid
387
1211000
2000
20:31
and we boast about it because we've spent three billion.
388
1213000
2000
20:33
It's incredibly important,
389
1215000
1000
20:34
those people would no longer be alive if the United States, for instance,
390
1216000
2000
20:36
hadn't spent that money in Darfur,
391
1218000
3000
20:39
but it's not a way to live.
392
1221000
1000
20:40
If we think about dignity in our conduct as citizens
393
1222000
3000
20:43
and as individuals with relation to the people around us,
394
1225000
3000
20:46
and as a country, if we could inject a regard for dignity
395
1228000
2000
20:48
into our dealings with other countries,
396
1230000
3000
20:51
it would be something of a revolution.
397
1233000
2000
20:53
Third point, very briefly. He talked a lot about freedom from fear.
398
1235000
4000
20:57
And I recognize there is so much to be afraid of.
399
1239000
3000
21:00
There are so many genuine threats in the world.
400
1242000
2000
21:02
But what Sergio was talking about is,
401
1244000
2000
21:04
let's calibrate our relationship to the threat.
402
1246000
2000
21:06
Let's not hype the threat; let's actually see it clearly.
403
1248000
3000
21:09
We have reason to be afraid of melting ice caps.
404
1251000
3000
21:12
We have reason to be afraid that we haven't secured
405
1254000
3000
21:15
loose nuclear material in the former Soviet Union.
406
1257000
3000
21:18
Let's focus on what are the legitimate challenges and threats,
407
1260000
4000
21:22
but not lunge into bad decisions because of a panic, of a fear.
408
1264000
5000
21:27
In times of fear, for instance, one of the things Sergio used to say
409
1269000
2000
21:29
is, fear is a bad advisor.
410
1271000
2000
21:31
We lunge towards the extremes
411
1273000
2000
21:33
when we aren't operating and trying to, again,
412
1275000
2000
21:35
calibrate our relationship to the world around us.
413
1277000
2000
21:37
Fourth and final point: he somehow, because he was working
414
1279000
3000
21:40
in all the world's worst places and all lesser evils,
415
1282000
3000
21:43
had a humility, of course,
416
1285000
2000
21:45
and an awareness of the complexity of the world around him.
417
1287000
3000
21:48
I mean, such an acute awareness of how hard it was.
418
1290000
2000
21:50
How Sisyphean this task was of mending,
419
1292000
4000
21:54
and yet aware of that complexity,
420
1296000
2000
21:56
humbled by it, he wasn't paralyzed by it.
421
1298000
3000
21:59
And we as citizens, as we go through this experience of the kind of,
422
1301000
5000
22:04
the crisis of confidence, crisis of competence, crisis of legitimacy,
423
1306000
4000
22:08
I think there's a temptation to pull back from the world and say,
424
1310000
3000
22:11
ah, Katrina, Iraq -- we don't know what we're doing.
425
1313000
2000
22:13
We can't afford to pull back from the world.
426
1315000
3000
22:16
It's a question of how to be in the world.
427
1318000
3000
22:19
And the lesson, I think,
428
1321000
1000
22:20
of the anti-genocide movement that I mentioned,
429
1322000
2000
22:22
that is a partial success but by no means
430
1324000
2000
22:24
has it achieved what it has set out to do --
431
1326000
3000
22:27
it'll be many decades, probably, before that happens --
432
1329000
3000
22:30
but is that if we want to see change, we have to become the change.
433
1332000
4000
22:34
We can't rely upon our institutions to do the work
434
1336000
4000
22:38
of necessarily talking to adversaries on their own
435
1340000
4000
22:42
without us creating a space for that to happen,
436
1344000
2000
22:44
for having respect for dignity,
437
1346000
2000
22:46
and for bringing that combination of humility
438
1348000
2000
22:48
and a sort of emboldened sense of responsibility
439
1350000
3000
22:51
to our dealings with the rest of the world.
440
1353000
2000
22:53
So will evil prevail? Is that the question?
441
1355000
2000
22:55
I think the short answer is: no, not unless we let it.
442
1357000
4000
22:59
Thank you.
443
1361000
1000
23:00
(Applause)
444
1362000
3000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Samantha Power - Political scientist and journalistSamantha Power studies US foreign policy, especially as it relates to war and human rights. Her books take on the world's worst problems: genocide, civil war and brutal dictatorships.
Why you should listen
Samantha Power is head of Harvard's Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, where she studies US policy as it relates to human rights, genocide and war. She's the author of a famous memo (in policy circles) suggesting that US foreign policy is utterly broken -- that the United States must return to a human rights-centered foreign policy or risk its prestige and respect in the world community. Her latest book is about Sergio Vieira de Mello, a UN diplomat who worked with the world's worst dictators to help protect the human rights of their people.
Power is also a journalist of fearless reputation. She spent 1993 to '96 reporting in the former Yugoslavia, and now contributes reportage and commentary to the New Yorker and Time. Her other books include A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide.
Samantha Power | Speaker | TED.com