TEDGlobal 2009
James Balog: Time-lapse proof of extreme ice loss
Filmed:
Readability: 4
1,068,812 views
Photographer James Balog shares new image sequences from the Extreme Ice Survey, a network of time-lapse cameras recording glaciers receding at an alarming rate, some of the most vivid evidence yet of climate change.
James Balog - Photographer
James Balog's latest work, the Extreme Ice Survey, captures the twisting, soaring forms of threatened wild ice. Full bio
James Balog's latest work, the Extreme Ice Survey, captures the twisting, soaring forms of threatened wild ice. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:18
Most of the time, art and science stare at each other
0
0
4000
00:22
across a gulf of mutual incomprehension.
1
4000
3000
00:25
There is great confusion when the two look at each other.
2
7000
5000
00:30
Art, of course, looks at the world through the psyche,
3
12000
4000
00:34
the emotions -- the unconscious at times -- and of course the aesthetic.
4
16000
4000
00:38
Science tends to look at the world through the rational, the quantitative --
5
20000
5000
00:43
things that can be measured and described --
6
25000
3000
00:46
but it gives art a terrific context of understanding.
7
28000
4000
00:50
In the Extreme Ice Survey,
8
32000
4000
00:54
we're dedicated to bringing those two parts of human understanding together,
9
36000
5000
00:59
to merging the art and science
10
41000
2000
01:01
to the end of helping us understand nature
11
43000
3000
01:04
and humanity's relationship with nature better.
12
46000
4000
01:08
Specifically, I as a person
13
50000
2000
01:10
who's been a professional nature photographer my whole adult life,
14
52000
4000
01:14
am firmly of the belief that photography, video, film
15
56000
4000
01:18
have tremendous powers for helping us understand
16
60000
4000
01:22
and shape the way we think about nature
17
64000
3000
01:25
and about ourselves in relationship to nature.
18
67000
3000
01:28
In this project, we're specifically interested, of course, in ice.
19
70000
4000
01:32
I'm fascinated by the beauty of it, the mutability of it,
20
74000
4000
01:36
the malleability of it,
21
78000
2000
01:38
and the fabulous shapes in which it can carve itself.
22
80000
3000
01:41
These first images are from Greenland.
23
83000
2000
01:43
But ice has another meaning.
24
85000
2000
01:45
Ice is the canary in the global coal mine.
25
87000
3000
01:48
It's the place where we can see and touch and hear and feel climate change in action.
26
90000
6000
01:54
Climate change is a really abstract thing in most of the world.
27
96000
4000
01:58
Whether or not you believe in it is based on your sense of
28
100000
3000
02:01
is it raining more or is it raining less?
29
103000
2000
02:03
Is it getting hotter or is it getting colder?
30
105000
2000
02:05
What do the computer models say about this, that and the other thing?
31
107000
5000
02:10
All of that, strip it away. In the world of the arctic and alpine environments,
32
112000
4000
02:14
where the ice is, it's real and it's present.
33
116000
3000
02:17
The changes are happening. They're very visible.
34
119000
3000
02:20
They're photographable. They're measurable.
35
122000
3000
02:23
95 percent of the glaciers in the world are retreating or shrinking.
36
125000
5000
02:28
That's outside Antarctica.
37
130000
2000
02:30
95 percent of the glaciers in the world are retreating or shrinking,
38
132000
3000
02:33
and that's because the precipitation patterns and the temperature patterns are changing.
39
135000
4000
02:37
There is no significant scientific dispute about that.
40
139000
4000
02:41
It's been observed, it's measured, it's bomb-proof information.
41
143000
3000
02:44
And the great irony and tragedy of our time
42
146000
2000
02:46
is that a lot of the general public thinks that science is still arguing about that.
43
148000
5000
02:51
Science is not arguing about that.
44
153000
2000
02:53
In these images we see ice from enormous glaciers,
45
155000
5000
02:58
ice sheets that are hundreds of thousands of years old
46
160000
2000
03:00
breaking up into chunks, and chunk by chunk by chunk,
47
162000
4000
03:04
iceberg by iceberg, turning into global sea level rise.
48
166000
3000
03:07
So, having seen all of this in the course of a 30-year career,
49
169000
4000
03:11
I was still a skeptic about climate change until about 10 years ago,
50
173000
3000
03:14
because I thought the story of climate change was based on computer models.
51
176000
6000
03:20
I hadn't realized it was based on concrete measurements
52
182000
4000
03:24
of what the paleoclimates -- the ancient climates -- were,
53
186000
3000
03:27
as recorded in the ice sheets, as recorded in deep ocean sediments,
54
189000
6000
03:33
as recorded in lake sediments, tree rings,
55
195000
2000
03:35
and a lot of other ways of measuring temperature.
56
197000
4000
03:39
When I realized that climate change was real, and it was not based on computer models,
57
201000
5000
03:44
I decided that one day I would do a project
58
206000
2000
03:46
looking at trying to manifest climate change photographically.
59
208000
4000
03:50
And that led me to this project.
60
212000
3000
03:53
Initially, I was working on a National Geographic assignment --
61
215000
3000
03:56
conventional, single frame, still photography.
62
218000
2000
03:58
And one crazy day, I got the idea that I should --
63
220000
4000
04:02
after that assignment was finished --
64
224000
2000
04:04
I got the idea that I should shoot in time-lapse photography,
65
226000
4000
04:08
that I should station a camera or two at a glacier
66
230000
4000
04:12
and let it shoot every 15 minutes, or every hour or whatever
67
234000
3000
04:15
and watch the progression of the landscape over time.
68
237000
3000
04:18
Well, within about three weeks,
69
240000
3000
04:21
I incautiously turned that idea of a couple of time-lapse cameras
70
243000
3000
04:24
into 25 time-lapse cameras.
71
246000
2000
04:26
And the next six months of my life were the hardest time in my career,
72
248000
5000
04:31
trying to design, build and deploy out in the field these 25 time-lapse cameras.
73
253000
6000
04:37
They are powered by the sun. Solar panels power them.
74
259000
4000
04:41
Power goes into a battery. There is a custom made computer
75
263000
3000
04:44
that tells the camera when to fire.
76
266000
3000
04:47
And these cameras are positioned on rocks on the sides of the glaciers,
77
269000
4000
04:51
and they look in on the glacier from permanent, bedrock positions,
78
273000
3000
04:54
and they watch the evolution of the landscape.
79
276000
3000
04:57
We just had a number of cameras out on the Greenland Ice Sheet.
80
279000
3000
05:00
We actually drilled holes into the ice, way deep down below the thawing level,
81
282000
5000
05:05
and had some cameras out there for the past month and a half or so.
82
287000
3000
05:08
Actually, there's still a camera out there right now.
83
290000
2000
05:10
In any case, the cameras shoot roughly every hour.
84
292000
3000
05:13
Some of them shoot every half hour, every 15 minutes, every five minutes.
85
295000
4000
05:17
Here's a time lapse of one of the time-lapse units being made.
86
299000
3000
05:20
(Laughter)
87
302000
2000
05:22
I personally obsessed about every nut, bolt and washer in these crazy things.
88
304000
4000
05:26
I spent half my life at our local hardware store
89
308000
2000
05:28
during the months when we built these units originally.
90
310000
3000
05:33
We're working in most of the major glaciated regions of the northern hemisphere.
91
315000
6000
05:39
Our time-lapse units are in Alaska, the Rockies, Greenland and Iceland,
92
321000
4000
05:43
and we have repeat photography positions,
93
325000
2000
05:45
that is places we just visit on an annual basis,
94
327000
3000
05:48
in British Columbia, the Alps and Bolivia.
95
330000
3000
05:51
It's a big undertaking. I stand here before you tonight
96
333000
2000
05:53
as an ambassador for my whole team.
97
335000
3000
05:56
There's a lot of people working on this right now.
98
338000
2000
05:58
We've got 33 cameras out this moment.
99
340000
3000
06:01
We just had 33 cameras shoot about half an hour ago
100
343000
4000
06:05
all across the northern hemisphere, watching what's happened.
101
347000
3000
06:08
And we've spent a lot of time in the field. It's been a fantastic amount of work.
102
350000
4000
06:12
We've been out for two and a half years,
103
354000
2000
06:14
and we've got about another two and a half years yet to go.
104
356000
2000
06:16
That's only half our job.
105
358000
2000
06:18
The other half of our job is to tell the story to the global public.
106
360000
4000
06:22
You know, scientists have collected this kind of information
107
364000
5000
06:27
off and on over the years, but a lot of it stays within the science community.
108
369000
5000
06:32
Similarly, a lot of art projects stay in the art community,
109
374000
4000
06:36
and I feel very much a responsibility through mechanisms like TED,
110
378000
6000
06:42
and like our relationship with the Obama White House,
111
384000
3000
06:45
with the Senate, with John Kerry, to influence policy
112
387000
4000
06:49
as much as possible with these pictures as well.
113
391000
2000
06:51
We've done films. We've done books. We have more coming.
114
393000
4000
06:55
We have a site on Google Earth
115
397000
2000
06:57
that Google Earth was generous enough to give us,
116
399000
3000
07:00
and so forth, because we feel very much the need to tell this story,
117
402000
4000
07:04
because it is such an immediate evidence of ongoing climate change right now.
118
406000
5000
07:11
Now, one bit of science before we get into the visuals.
119
413000
3000
07:14
If everybody in the developed world understood this graph,
120
416000
4000
07:18
and emblazoned it on the inside of their foreheads,
121
420000
3000
07:21
there would be no further societal argument about climate change
122
423000
4000
07:25
because this is the story that counts.
123
427000
3000
07:28
Everything else you hear is just propaganda and confusion.
124
430000
4000
07:32
Key issues: this is a 400,000 year record.
125
434000
3000
07:35
This exact same pattern is seen going back now
126
437000
2000
07:37
almost a million years before our current time.
127
439000
3000
07:40
And several things are important.
128
442000
3000
07:43
Number one: temperature and carbon dioxide in the atmosphere
129
445000
3000
07:46
go up and down basically in sync.
130
448000
2000
07:48
You can see that from the orange line and the blue line.
131
450000
3000
07:51
Nature naturally has allowed carbon dioxide to go up to 280 parts per million.
132
453000
7000
07:58
That's the natural cycle.
133
460000
2000
08:00
Goes up to 280 and then drops
134
462000
2000
08:02
for various reasons that aren't important to discuss right here.
135
464000
3000
08:05
But 280 is the peak.
136
467000
2000
08:07
Right now, if you look at the top right part of that graph,
137
469000
3000
08:10
we're at 385 parts per million.
138
472000
2000
08:12
We are way, way outside the normal, natural variability.
139
474000
5000
08:17
Earth is having a fever.
140
479000
2000
08:19
In the past hundred years, the temperature of the Earth
141
481000
3000
08:22
has gone up 1.3 degrees Fahrenheit, .75 degrees Celsius,
142
484000
5000
08:27
and it's going to keep going up
143
489000
2000
08:29
because we keep dumping fossil fuels into the atmosphere.
144
491000
3000
08:32
At the rate of about two and a half parts per million per year.
145
494000
3000
08:35
It's been a remorseless, steady increase.
146
497000
3000
08:38
We have to turn that around.
147
500000
2000
08:40
That's the crux, and someday I hope to emblazon that
148
502000
3000
08:43
across Times Square in New York and a lot of other places.
149
505000
3000
08:46
But anyway, off to the world of ice.
150
508000
2000
08:48
We're now at the Columbia Glacier in Alaska.
151
510000
2000
08:50
This is a view of what's called the calving face.
152
512000
3000
08:53
This is what one of our cameras saw over the course of a few months.
153
515000
3000
08:56
You see the glacier flowing in from the right,
154
518000
4000
09:00
dropping off into the sea, camera shooting every hour.
155
522000
3000
09:03
If you look in the middle background,
156
525000
2000
09:05
you can see the calving face bobbing up and down like a yo-yo.
157
527000
4000
09:09
That means that glacier's floating and it's unstable,
158
531000
3000
09:12
and you're about to see the consequences of that floating.
159
534000
3000
09:15
To give you a little bit of a sense of scale,
160
537000
3000
09:18
that calving face in this picture
161
540000
2000
09:20
is about 325 feet tall. That's 32 stories.
162
542000
5000
09:25
This is not a little cliff. This is like a major office building in an urban center.
163
547000
5000
09:30
The calving face is the wall where the visible ice breaks off,
164
552000
5000
09:35
but in fact, it goes down below sea level another couple thousand feet.
165
557000
5000
09:40
So there's a wall of ice a couple thousand feet deep
166
562000
4000
09:44
going down to bedrock if the glacier's grounded on bedrock,
167
566000
4000
09:48
and floating if it isn't.
168
570000
2000
09:52
Here's what Columbia's done. This is in south central Alaska.
169
574000
4000
09:56
This was an aerial picture I did one day in June three years ago.
170
578000
5000
10:01
This is an aerial picture we did this year.
171
583000
3000
10:04
That's the retreat of this glacier.
172
586000
3000
10:07
The main stem, the main flow of the glacier is coming from the right
173
589000
4000
10:11
and it's going very rapidly up that stem.
174
593000
3000
10:14
We're going to be up there in just a few more weeks,
175
596000
4000
10:18
and we expect that it's probably retreated another half a mile,
176
600000
3000
10:21
but if I got there and discovered that it had collapsed
177
603000
3000
10:24
and it was five miles further back, I wouldn't be the least bit surprised.
178
606000
5000
10:29
Now it's really hard to grasp the scale of these places,
179
611000
3000
10:32
because as the glaciers --
180
614000
2000
10:34
one of the things is that places like Alaska and Greenland are huge,
181
616000
3000
10:37
they're not normal landscapes --
182
619000
2000
10:39
but as the glaciers are retreating, they're also deflating,
183
621000
4000
10:43
like air is being let out of a balloon.
184
625000
3000
10:46
And so, there are features on this landscape.
185
628000
3000
10:49
There's a ridge right in the middle of the picture, up above where that arrow comes in,
186
631000
4000
10:53
that shows you that a little bit.
187
635000
2000
10:55
There's a marker line called the trim line
188
637000
3000
10:58
above our little red illustration there.
189
640000
4000
11:02
This is something no self-respecting photographer would ever do --
190
644000
2000
11:04
you put some cheesy illustration on your shot, right? --
191
646000
3000
11:07
and yet you have to do it sometimes to narrate these points.
192
649000
4000
11:11
But, in any case, the deflation of this glacier since 1984
193
653000
4000
11:15
has been higher than the Eiffel Tower, higher than the Empire State Building.
194
657000
5000
11:20
A tremendous amount of ice has been let out of these valleys
195
662000
3000
11:23
as it's retreated and deflated, gone back up valley.
196
665000
5000
11:28
These changes in the alpine world are accelerating.
197
670000
3000
11:31
It's not static.
198
673000
2000
11:33
Particularly in the world of sea ice,
199
675000
3000
11:36
the rate of natural change is outstripping predictions of just a few years ago,
200
678000
4000
11:40
and the processes either are accelerating
201
682000
3000
11:43
or the predictions were too low to begin with.
202
685000
2000
11:45
But in any case, there are big, big changes happening as we speak.
203
687000
5000
11:50
So, here's another time-lapse shot of Columbia.
204
692000
4000
11:54
And you see where it ended in these various spring days,
205
696000
3000
11:57
June, May, then October.
206
699000
2000
11:59
Now we turn on our time lapse.
207
701000
2000
12:01
This camera was shooting every hour.
208
703000
2000
12:03
Geologic process in action here.
209
705000
2000
12:05
And everybody says, well don't they advance in the winter time?
210
707000
3000
12:08
No. It was retreating through the winter because it's an unhealthy glacier.
211
710000
3000
12:11
Finally catches up to itself, it advances.
212
713000
3000
12:18
And you can look at these pictures over and over again
213
720000
2000
12:20
because there's such a strange, bizarre fascination in seeing
214
722000
4000
12:24
these things you don't normally get to see come alive.
215
726000
3000
12:27
We've been talking about "seeing is believing "
216
729000
2000
12:29
and seeing the unseen at TED Global.
217
731000
3000
12:32
That's what you see with these cameras.
218
734000
3000
12:35
The images make the invisible visible.
219
737000
4000
12:42
These huge crevasses open up.
220
744000
2000
12:44
These great ice islands break off --
221
746000
3000
12:47
and now watch this.
222
749000
2000
12:49
This has been the springtime this year --
223
751000
3000
12:57
a huge collapse. That happened in about a month,
224
759000
2000
12:59
the loss of all that ice.
225
761000
2000
13:11
So that's where we started three years ago,
226
773000
2000
13:13
way out on the left, and that's where we were a few months ago, the
227
775000
2000
13:15
last time we went into Columbia.
228
777000
3000
13:18
To give you a feeling for the scale of the retreat,
229
780000
2000
13:20
we did another cheesy illustration,
230
782000
2000
13:22
with British double-decker buses.
231
784000
3000
13:25
If you line up 295 of those nose to tail, that's about how far back that was.
232
787000
5000
13:30
It's a long way.
233
792000
2000
13:35
On up to Iceland.
234
797000
2000
13:37
One of my favorite glaciers, the Sólheimajökull.
235
799000
3000
13:43
And here, if you watch, you can see the terminus retreating.
236
805000
3000
13:46
You can see this river being formed.
237
808000
2000
13:48
You can see it deflating.
238
810000
3000
13:56
Without the photographic process, you would never see this. This is invisible.
239
818000
4000
14:00
You can stand up there your whole life and you would never see this,
240
822000
3000
14:03
but the camera records it.
241
825000
3000
14:09
So we wind time backwards now.
242
831000
2000
14:13
We go back a couple years in time.
243
835000
2000
14:15
That's where it started.
244
837000
3000
14:23
That's where it ended a few months ago.
245
845000
3000
14:28
And on up to Greenland.
246
850000
3000
14:31
The smaller the ice mass, the faster it responds to climate.
247
853000
4000
14:35
Greenland took a little while to start reacting
248
857000
3000
14:38
to the warming climate of the past century,
249
860000
3000
14:41
but it really started galloping along about 20 years ago.
250
863000
4000
14:45
And there's been a tremendous increase in the temperature up there.
251
867000
3000
14:48
It's a big place. That's all ice.
252
870000
2000
14:50
All those colors are ice and it goes up to about two miles thick,
253
872000
4000
14:54
just a gigantic dome that comes in from the coast and rises in the middle.
254
876000
4000
14:58
The one glacier up in Greenland
255
880000
2000
15:00
that puts more ice into the global ocean
256
882000
2000
15:02
than all the other glaciers in the northern hemisphere combined
257
884000
3000
15:05
is the Ilulissat Glacier.
258
887000
2000
15:07
We have some cameras on the south edge of the Ilulissat,
259
889000
3000
15:10
watching the calving face as it goes through this dramatic retreat.
260
892000
4000
15:14
Here's a two-year record of what that looks like.
261
896000
2000
15:16
Helicopter in front of the calving face for scale, quickly dwarfed.
262
898000
5000
15:21
The calving face is four and a half miles across,
263
903000
2000
15:23
and in this shot, as we pull back, you're only seeing about a mile and a half.
264
905000
3000
15:26
So, imagine how big this is
265
908000
2000
15:28
and how much ice is charging out.
266
910000
2000
15:30
The interior of Greenland is to the right.
267
912000
2000
15:32
It's flowing out to the Atlantic Ocean on the left.
268
914000
3000
15:35
Icebergs, many, many, many, many times the size of this building, are roaring out to sea.
269
917000
6000
15:41
We just downloaded these pictures a couple weeks ago,
270
923000
2000
15:43
as you can see. June 25th,
271
925000
3000
15:47
monster calving events happened.
272
929000
2000
15:49
I'll show you one of those in a second.
273
931000
2000
15:51
This glacier has doubled its flow speed in the past 15 years.
274
933000
5000
15:56
It now goes at 125 feet a day, dumping all this ice into the ocean.
275
938000
5000
16:01
It tends to go in these pulses, about every three days,
276
943000
2000
16:03
but on average, 125 feet a day,
277
945000
2000
16:05
twice the rate it did 20 years ago.
278
947000
3000
16:09
Okay. We had a team out watching this glacier,
279
951000
4000
16:13
and we recorded the biggest calving event that's ever been put on film.
280
955000
3000
16:16
We had nine cameras going.
281
958000
2000
16:18
This is what a couple of the cameras saw.
282
960000
4000
16:22
A 400-foot-tall calving face breaking off.
283
964000
3000
16:26
Huge icebergs rolling over.
284
968000
2000
17:13
Okay, how big was that? It's hard to get it.
285
1015000
3000
17:16
So an illustration again, gives you a feeling for scale.
286
1018000
3000
17:19
A mile of retreat in 75 minutes
287
1021000
3000
17:22
across the calving face, in that particular event, three miles wide.
288
1024000
4000
17:26
The block was three-fifths of a mile deep,
289
1028000
2000
17:28
and if you compare the expanse of the calving face
290
1030000
3000
17:31
to the Tower Bridge in London, about 20 bridges wide.
291
1033000
3000
17:34
Or if you take an American reference, to the U.S. Capitol Building
292
1036000
4000
17:38
and you pack 3,000 Capitol Buildings into that block,
293
1040000
4000
17:42
it would be equivalent to how large that block was.
294
1044000
3000
17:47
75 minutes.
295
1049000
2000
17:51
Now I've come to the conclusion
296
1053000
2000
17:53
after spending a lot of time in this climate change world
297
1055000
3000
17:56
that we don't have a problem of economics, technology and public policy.
298
1058000
4000
18:00
We have a problem of perception.
299
1062000
3000
18:03
The policy and the economics and the technology are serious enough issues,
300
1065000
3000
18:06
but we actually can deal with them.
301
1068000
2000
18:08
I'm certain that we can.
302
1070000
3000
18:11
But what we have is a perception problem
303
1073000
2000
18:13
because not enough people really get it yet.
304
1075000
4000
18:17
You're an elite audience. You get it.
305
1079000
2000
18:19
Fortunately, a lot of the political leaders in the major countries of the world
306
1081000
4000
18:23
are an elite audience that for the most part gets it now.
307
1085000
4000
18:27
But we still need to bring a lot of people along with us.
308
1089000
3000
18:30
And that's where I think organizations like TED,
309
1092000
4000
18:34
like the Extreme Ice Survey can have a terrific impact
310
1096000
3000
18:37
on human perception and bring us along.
311
1099000
3000
18:40
Because I believe we have an opportunity right now.
312
1102000
2000
18:42
We are nearly on the edge of a crisis,
313
1104000
3000
18:45
but we still have an opportunity to face the greatest challenge
314
1107000
4000
18:49
of our generation and, in fact, of our century.
315
1111000
3000
18:52
This is a terrific, terrific call to arms
316
1114000
4000
18:56
to do the right thing for ourselves and for the future.
317
1118000
3000
18:59
I hope that we have the wisdom to let the angels of our better nature
318
1121000
3000
19:02
rise to the occasion and do what needs to be done. Thank you.
319
1124000
4000
19:06
(Applause)
320
1128000
8000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
James Balog - PhotographerJames Balog's latest work, the Extreme Ice Survey, captures the twisting, soaring forms of threatened wild ice.
Why you should listen
To see the natural world through James Balog's lens is to see it as an artist would -- through fresh eyes, as if for the first time, with no preconceived notions. His photos of jungle animals, for instance, are arresting in their directness, simplicity, even sensuality. His subjects assume the same weight and importance as a human portrait sitter, and demand (as a human subject would) that the viewer engage with them rather than simply spectate.
His newest work is no less powerful, no less engaging -- and it carries an urgent message. For several years, Balog has been going up north to shoot the half-alive ice of the mammoth glaciers for his Extreme Ice Survey, a look at the shocking effects of abrupt climate change in Alaska, Greenland and Iceland. Soaring, dripping, glowing and crumbling, arctic ice under Balog's eye requires the viewer to engage.
A new Nova/PBS TV special and a new book, Extreme Ice Now, are helping him spread the word that this glorious world is degrading at a speed we couldn't imagine until we saw it through his eyes.
James Balog | Speaker | TED.com