TEDxProvidence
Alyson McGregor: Why medicine often has dangerous side effects for women
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
1,594,282 views
You might not know this: Many of the medicines we take -- common drugs like Ambien and everyday aspirin -- were only ever tested on men. And the unknown side effects for women can be dangerous, even deadly. Alyson McGregor studies the differences between male and female patients; in this fascinating talk she explains how the male model became our framework for medical research ... and what women and men need to ask their doctors to get the right care for their bodies.
Alyson McGregor - Women's health pioneer
Alyson McGregor studies women's health, especially as it relates to emergency care -- when time-sensitive, life-or-death decisions are made using drugs and treatments mainly tested on men. Full bio
Alyson McGregor studies women's health, especially as it relates to emergency care -- when time-sensitive, life-or-death decisions are made using drugs and treatments mainly tested on men. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
We all go to doctors.
0
816
2572
00:16
And we do so with trust and blind faith
1
4944
4338
00:21
that the test they are ordering
and the medications they're prescribing
and the medications they're prescribing
2
9306
3858
00:25
are based upon evidence --
3
13188
3175
00:28
evidence that's designed to help us.
4
16387
2927
00:32
However, the reality is that that hasn't
always been the case for everyone.
always been the case for everyone.
5
20338
5843
00:39
What if I told you
6
27086
1295
00:40
that the medical science discovered
over the past century
over the past century
7
28405
3946
00:44
has been based on only
half the population?
half the population?
8
32375
3667
00:48
I'm an emergency medicine doctor.
9
36066
2294
00:50
I was trained to be prepared
in a medical emergency.
in a medical emergency.
10
38749
3651
00:54
It's about saving lives. How cool is that?
11
42940
4449
01:00
OK, there's a lot of runny noses
and stubbed toes,
and stubbed toes,
12
48492
3160
01:03
but no matter who walks
through the door to the ER,
through the door to the ER,
13
51676
3665
01:07
we order the same tests,
14
55365
2452
01:09
we prescribe the same medication,
15
57841
2134
01:11
without ever thinking about the sex
or gender of our patients.
or gender of our patients.
16
59999
4402
01:17
Why would we?
17
65370
1254
01:19
We were never taught that there were
any differences between men and women.
any differences between men and women.
18
67053
3741
01:22
A recent Government Accountability study
revealed that 80 percent of the drugs
revealed that 80 percent of the drugs
19
70818
4559
01:27
withdrawn from the market
20
75401
2151
01:29
are due to side effects on women.
21
77576
2393
01:33
So let's think about that for a minute.
22
81080
2311
01:35
Why are we discovering
side effects on women
side effects on women
23
83415
3874
01:39
only after a drug has been
released to the market?
released to the market?
24
87313
3286
01:43
Do you know that it takes years
for a drug to go from an idea
for a drug to go from an idea
25
91496
5660
01:49
to being tested on cells in a laboratory,
26
97180
3157
01:52
to animal studies,
27
100361
1968
01:54
to then clinical trials on humans,
28
102353
2127
01:56
finally to go through
a regulatory approval process,
a regulatory approval process,
29
104504
3871
02:00
to be available for your doctor
to prescribe to you?
to prescribe to you?
30
108399
4336
02:06
Not to mention the millions and billions
of dollars of funding
of dollars of funding
31
114170
3370
02:09
it takes to go through that process.
32
117564
2382
02:13
So why are we discovering
unacceptable side effects
unacceptable side effects
33
121597
2952
02:16
on half the population
after that has gone through?
after that has gone through?
34
124573
4451
02:23
What's happening?
35
131163
1264
02:24
Well, it turns out that those cells
used in that laboratory,
used in that laboratory,
36
132777
4104
02:28
they're male cells,
37
136905
1930
02:30
and the animals used
in the animal studies were male animals,
in the animal studies were male animals,
38
138859
3402
02:34
and the clinical trials have been
performed almost exclusively on men.
performed almost exclusively on men.
39
142285
5090
02:41
How is it that the male model became
our framework for medical research?
our framework for medical research?
40
149176
5354
02:46
Let's look at an example that has been
popularized in the media,
popularized in the media,
41
154554
4071
02:50
and it has to do
with the sleep aid Ambien.
with the sleep aid Ambien.
42
158649
3206
02:53
Ambien was released on the market
over 20 years ago,
over 20 years ago,
43
161879
4764
02:58
and since then, hundreds of millions
of prescriptions have been written,
of prescriptions have been written,
44
166667
4813
03:03
primarily to women, because women
suffer more sleep disorders than men.
suffer more sleep disorders than men.
45
171504
4448
03:09
But just this past year,
46
177047
2176
03:11
the Food and Drug Administration
recommended cutting the dose in half
recommended cutting the dose in half
47
179247
3424
03:14
for women only,
48
182695
2887
03:17
because they just realized
that women metabolize the drug
that women metabolize the drug
49
185606
2837
03:20
at a slower rate than men,
50
188467
2913
03:23
causing them to wake up in the morning
51
191404
2039
03:25
with more of the active drug
in their system.
in their system.
52
193467
3194
03:28
And then they're drowsy and they're
getting behind the wheel of the car,
getting behind the wheel of the car,
53
196685
3930
03:32
and they're at risk
for motor vehicle accidents.
for motor vehicle accidents.
54
200639
2967
03:36
And I can't help but think,
as an emergency physician,
as an emergency physician,
55
204955
3944
03:40
how many of my patients
that I've cared for over the years
that I've cared for over the years
56
208923
4793
03:45
were involved in a motor vehicle accident
57
213740
2806
03:48
that possibly could have been prevented
58
216570
3452
03:52
if this type of analysis was performed
and acted upon 20 years ago
and acted upon 20 years ago
59
220046
5115
03:57
when this drug was first released.
60
225185
2008
04:01
How many other things need
to be analyzed by gender?
to be analyzed by gender?
61
229089
3195
04:05
What else are we missing?
62
233197
1682
04:09
World War II changed a lot of things,
63
237555
3676
04:13
and one of them was this need
to protect people
to protect people
64
241255
2881
04:16
from becoming victims of medical research
without informed consent.
without informed consent.
65
244160
4340
04:21
So some much-needed guidelines
or rules were set into place,
or rules were set into place,
66
249467
3676
04:25
and part of that was this desire
to protect women of childbearing age
to protect women of childbearing age
67
253167
5022
04:30
from entering into any
medical research studies.
medical research studies.
68
258213
2951
04:34
There was fear: what if something
happened to the fetus during the study?
happened to the fetus during the study?
69
262016
4563
04:39
Who would be responsible?
70
267366
1549
04:41
And so the scientists
at this time actually thought
at this time actually thought
71
269999
2489
04:44
this was a blessing in disguise,
72
272512
2616
04:47
because let's face it -- men's bodies
are pretty homogeneous.
are pretty homogeneous.
73
275152
5213
04:52
They don't have the constantly
fluctuating levels of hormones
fluctuating levels of hormones
74
280867
3446
04:56
that could disrupt clean data
they could get if they had only men.
they could get if they had only men.
75
284337
3744
05:01
It was easier. It was cheaper.
76
289210
2710
05:05
Not to mention, at this time,
there was a general assumption
there was a general assumption
77
293651
2833
05:08
that men and women
were alike in every way,
were alike in every way,
78
296508
4225
05:12
apart from their reproductive organs
and sex hormones.
and sex hormones.
79
300757
3443
05:17
So it was decided:
80
305211
2817
05:21
medical research was performed on men,
81
309117
3516
05:24
and the results were later
applied to women.
applied to women.
82
312657
2757
05:29
What did this do to the notion
of women's health?
of women's health?
83
317203
3541
05:32
Women's health became synonymous
with reproduction:
with reproduction:
84
320768
4256
05:37
breasts, ovaries, uterus, pregnancy.
85
325048
4545
05:42
It's this term we now refer
to as "bikini medicine."
to as "bikini medicine."
86
330355
3032
05:46
And this stayed this way
until about the 1980s,
until about the 1980s,
87
334461
2644
05:49
when this concept was challenged
by the medical community
by the medical community
88
337129
3485
05:52
and by the public health policymakers
when they realized that
when they realized that
89
340638
4141
05:56
by excluding women
from all medical research studies
from all medical research studies
90
344803
4303
06:01
we actually did them a disservice,
91
349130
3489
06:04
in that apart from reproductive issues,
92
352643
2332
06:06
virtually nothing was known
about the unique needs
about the unique needs
93
354999
2564
06:09
of the female patient.
94
357587
1718
06:12
Since that time, an overwhelming amount
of evidence has come to light
of evidence has come to light
95
360999
5514
06:18
that shows us just how different
men and women are in every way.
men and women are in every way.
96
366537
5511
06:29
You know, we have this saying in medicine:
97
377297
2753
06:32
children are not just little adults.
98
380074
2948
06:36
And we say that to remind ourselves
99
384810
1937
06:38
that children actually have
a different physiology than normal adults.
a different physiology than normal adults.
100
386771
4677
06:44
And it's because of this that the medical
specialty of pediatrics came to light.
specialty of pediatrics came to light.
101
392678
4957
06:49
And we now conduct research on children
in order to improve their lives.
in order to improve their lives.
102
397659
6246
06:57
And I know the same thing
can be said about women.
can be said about women.
103
405039
2897
06:59
Women are not just men
with boobs and tubes.
with boobs and tubes.
104
407960
5061
07:06
But they have their own
anatomy and physiology
anatomy and physiology
105
414561
3556
07:10
that deserves to be studied
with the same intensity.
with the same intensity.
106
418141
3530
07:15
Let's take the cardiovascular
system, for example.
system, for example.
107
423381
2931
07:18
This area in medicine has done the most
to try to figure out
to try to figure out
108
426999
3707
07:22
why it seems men and women have
completely different heart attacks.
completely different heart attacks.
109
430730
4149
07:27
Heart disease is the number one killer
for both men and women,
for both men and women,
110
435999
5090
07:33
but more women die within the first year
of having a heart attack than men.
of having a heart attack than men.
111
441113
4436
07:39
Men will complain
of crushing chest pain --
of crushing chest pain --
112
447049
4014
07:43
an elephant is sitting on their chest.
113
451087
2482
07:46
And we call this typical.
114
454455
1540
07:49
Women have chest pain, too.
115
457622
3090
07:52
But more women than men
will complain of "just not feeling right,"
will complain of "just not feeling right,"
116
460736
6697
08:00
"can't seem to get enough air in,"
117
468898
2869
08:03
"just so tired lately."
118
471791
1974
08:07
And for some reason we call this atypical,
119
475000
2903
08:09
even though, as I mentioned,
women do make up half the population.
women do make up half the population.
120
477927
3927
08:15
And so what is some of the evidence
to help explain some of these differences?
to help explain some of these differences?
121
483537
5771
08:21
If we look at the anatomy,
122
489999
2531
08:24
the blood vessels that surround the heart
are smaller in women compared to men,
are smaller in women compared to men,
123
492554
6015
08:30
and the way that those blood vessels
develop disease is different
develop disease is different
124
498593
4480
08:35
in women compared to men.
125
503097
2055
08:37
And the test that we use to determine
if someone is at risk for a heart attack,
if someone is at risk for a heart attack,
126
505875
5152
08:43
well, they were initially designed
and tested and perfected in men,
and tested and perfected in men,
127
511051
4572
08:47
and so aren't as good
at determining that in women.
at determining that in women.
128
515647
3134
08:52
And then if we think
about the medications --
about the medications --
129
520305
2937
08:55
common medications
that we use, like aspirin.
that we use, like aspirin.
130
523266
3247
08:59
We give aspirin to healthy men to help
prevent them from having a heart attack,
prevent them from having a heart attack,
131
527767
4527
09:04
but do you know that if you
give aspirin to a healthy woman,
give aspirin to a healthy woman,
132
532318
4234
09:08
it's actually harmful?
133
536576
1586
09:12
What this is doing is merely telling us
134
540376
2382
09:14
that we are scratching the surface.
135
542782
2752
09:19
Emergency medicine
is a fast-paced business.
is a fast-paced business.
136
547145
3426
09:23
In how many life-saving areas of medicine,
137
551563
3353
09:26
like cancer and stroke,
138
554940
3976
09:30
are there important differences between
men and women that we could be utilizing?
men and women that we could be utilizing?
139
558940
4133
09:36
Or even, why is it that some people
get those runny noses
get those runny noses
140
564252
4804
09:41
more than others,
141
569080
2185
09:43
or why the pain medication that we give
to those stubbed toes
to those stubbed toes
142
571289
3327
09:46
work in some and not in others?
143
574640
3205
09:53
The Institute of Medicine has said
every cell has a sex.
every cell has a sex.
144
581288
5230
09:59
What does this mean?
145
587820
1413
10:02
Sex is DNA.
146
590532
2398
10:04
Gender is how someone
presents themselves in society.
presents themselves in society.
147
592954
4341
10:09
And these two may not always match up,
148
597883
2540
10:12
as we can see with our
transgendered population.
transgendered population.
149
600447
3166
10:16
But it's important to realize
that from the moment of conception,
that from the moment of conception,
150
604740
4915
10:21
every cell in our bodies --
151
609679
2122
10:23
skin, hair, heart and lungs --
152
611825
3301
10:27
contains our own unique DNA,
153
615150
3287
10:30
and that DNA contains
the chromosomes that determine
the chromosomes that determine
154
618461
3751
10:34
whether we become
male or female, man or woman.
male or female, man or woman.
155
622236
5061
10:40
It used to be thought
156
628400
1588
10:42
that those sex-determining
chromosomes pictured here --
chromosomes pictured here --
157
630012
4328
10:46
XY if you're male, XX if you're female --
158
634364
3373
10:49
merely determined whether you
would be born with ovaries or testes,
would be born with ovaries or testes,
159
637761
5214
10:54
and it was the sex hormones
that those organs produced
that those organs produced
160
642999
3741
10:58
that were responsible for the differences
we see in the opposite sex.
we see in the opposite sex.
161
646764
4565
11:04
But we now know that
that theory was wrong --
that theory was wrong --
162
652757
4834
11:09
or it's at least a little incomplete.
163
657615
2445
11:12
And thankfully, scientists like Dr. Page
from the Whitehead Institute,
from the Whitehead Institute,
164
660084
4778
11:16
who works on the Y chromosome,
165
664886
1974
11:18
and Doctor Yang from UCLA,
166
666884
2167
11:21
they have found evidence that tells us
that those sex-determining chromosomes
that those sex-determining chromosomes
167
669075
5659
11:26
that are in every cell in our bodies
168
674758
2597
11:29
continue to remain active
for our entire lives
for our entire lives
169
677379
5359
11:36
and could be what's responsible
for the differences we see
for the differences we see
170
684517
3575
11:40
in the dosing of drugs,
171
688116
2215
11:42
or why there are differences
between men and women
between men and women
172
690355
2966
11:45
in the susceptibility
and severity of diseases.
and severity of diseases.
173
693345
3516
11:51
This new knowledge is the game-changer,
174
699032
2920
11:57
and it's up to those scientists
that continue to find that evidence,
that continue to find that evidence,
175
705425
3374
12:00
but it's up to the clinicians
to start translating this data
to start translating this data
176
708823
4153
12:05
at the bedside, today.
177
713000
2999
12:09
Right now.
178
717168
1156
12:13
And to help do this, I'm a co-founder
of a national organization
of a national organization
179
721450
3024
12:16
called Sex and Gender
Women's Health Collaborative,
Women's Health Collaborative,
180
724498
2983
12:19
and we collect all of this data
so that it's available for teaching
so that it's available for teaching
181
727505
4620
12:24
and for patient care.
182
732149
1405
12:26
And we're working to bring together
the medical educators to the table.
the medical educators to the table.
183
734380
4368
12:31
That's a big job.
184
739756
1468
12:34
It's changing the way medical training
has been done since its inception.
has been done since its inception.
185
742162
5139
12:41
But I believe in them.
186
749039
1843
12:43
I know they're going to see the value
of incorporating the gender lens
of incorporating the gender lens
187
751882
5597
12:49
into the current curriculum.
188
757503
1722
12:52
It's about training the future
health care providers correctly.
health care providers correctly.
189
760598
4618
13:00
And regionally,
190
768437
1151
13:01
I'm a co-creator of a division within
the Department of Emergency Medicine
the Department of Emergency Medicine
191
769612
3861
13:05
here at Brown University,
192
773497
1720
13:07
called Sex and Gender
in Emergency Medicine,
in Emergency Medicine,
193
775241
2610
13:09
and we conduct the research to determine
the differences between men and women
the differences between men and women
194
777875
4626
13:14
in emergent conditions,
195
782525
2158
13:16
like heart disease and stroke
and sepsis and substance abuse,
and sepsis and substance abuse,
196
784707
5268
13:21
but we also believe
that education is paramount.
that education is paramount.
197
789999
4377
13:27
We've created a 360-degree
model of education.
model of education.
198
795304
4001
13:31
We have programs for the doctors,
for the nurses, for the students
for the nurses, for the students
199
799329
5958
13:37
and for the patients.
200
805311
1706
13:39
Because this cannot just be left up
to the health care leaders.
to the health care leaders.
201
807511
4058
13:44
We all have a role in making a difference.
202
812315
3477
13:48
But I must warn you: this is not easy.
203
816650
3857
13:53
In fact, it's hard.
204
821840
1592
13:57
It's essentially changing the way
we think about medicine
we think about medicine
205
825146
4392
14:01
and health and research.
206
829562
2997
14:05
It's changing our relationship
to the health care system.
to the health care system.
207
833711
3136
14:09
But there's no going back.
208
837760
2888
14:13
We now know just enough
209
841339
3699
14:17
to know that we weren't doing it right.
210
845062
2356
14:21
Martin Luther King, Jr. has said,
211
849672
2318
14:24
"Change does not roll in
on the wheels of inevitability,
on the wheels of inevitability,
212
852014
4649
14:28
but comes through continuous struggle."
213
856687
2174
14:32
And the first step
towards change is awareness.
towards change is awareness.
214
860314
2730
14:36
This is not just about improving
medical care for women.
medical care for women.
215
864116
4078
14:40
This is about personalized,
individualized health care for everyone.
individualized health care for everyone.
216
868702
4959
14:47
This awareness has the power to transform
medical care for men and women.
medical care for men and women.
217
875090
6102
14:54
And from now on, I want you
to ask your doctors
to ask your doctors
218
882827
5688
15:00
whether the treatments you are receiving
are specific to your sex and gender.
are specific to your sex and gender.
219
888539
4277
15:06
They may not know the answer --
220
894246
2689
15:08
yet.
221
896959
1166
15:11
But the conversation has begun,
and together we can all learn.
and together we can all learn.
222
899101
3862
15:15
Remember, for me
and my colleagues in this field,
and my colleagues in this field,
223
903797
4377
15:20
your sex and gender matter.
224
908198
2277
15:23
Thank you.
225
911379
1152
15:24
(Applause)
226
912555
4444
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alyson McGregor - Women's health pioneerAlyson McGregor studies women's health, especially as it relates to emergency care -- when time-sensitive, life-or-death decisions are made using drugs and treatments mainly tested on men.
Why you should listen
Alyson J. McGregor MD is co-founder and director for the Sex and Gender in Emergency Medicine (SGEM) Division (formerly Women’s Health in Emergency Care) within the Department of Emergency Medicine at Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University.
Her group's aim is to establish research and educational endeavors that promote sex- and gender-specific medicine and women’s health as they relate to emergency care. Dr. McGregor received her medical degree at Boston University School of Medicine and residency training at Brown, where she continues to work as an attending physician at RI Hospital Emergency Department. Dr. McGregor is an Associate Professor of Emergency Medicine and also serves as co-director for the SGEM Fellowship and co-founder of the national organization Sex and Gender Women’s Health Collaborative.
Alyson McGregor | Speaker | TED.com