TEDWomen 2016
Caroline Paul: To raise brave girls, encourage adventure
Filmed:
Readability: 3.2
1,958,625 views
Gutsy girls skateboard, climb trees, clamber around, fall down, scrape their knees, get right back up -- and grow up to be brave women. Learn how to spark a little productive risk-taking and raise confident girls with stories and advice from firefighter, paraglider and all-around adventurer Caroline Paul.
Caroline Paul - Author
Brimming with insights gained on her picaresque journey from firefighter to best-selling author, Caroline Paul’s "The Gutsy Girl: Escapades for Your Life of Epic Adventure" is a revolutionary guide for raising brave young women. Full bio
Brimming with insights gained on her picaresque journey from firefighter to best-selling author, Caroline Paul’s "The Gutsy Girl: Escapades for Your Life of Epic Adventure" is a revolutionary guide for raising brave young women. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
When I was a kid, I was obsessed
with the Guinness Book of World Records,
with the Guinness Book of World Records,
0
760
4536
00:17
and I really wanted
to set a world record myself.
to set a world record myself.
1
5320
3456
00:20
But there was just one small problem:
2
8800
2696
00:23
I had absolutely no talent.
3
11520
2160
00:26
So I decided to set
a world record in something
a world record in something
4
14520
3416
00:29
that demanded absolutely no skill at all.
5
17960
2880
00:33
I decided to set a world record
6
21840
2736
00:36
in crawling.
7
24600
1200
00:39
(Laughter)
8
27680
2976
00:42
Now, the record at the time
was 12 and a half miles,
was 12 and a half miles,
9
30680
3520
00:47
and for some reason,
this seemed totally manageable.
this seemed totally manageable.
10
35840
3176
00:51
(Laughter)
11
39040
2160
00:54
I recruited my friend Anne,
12
42640
1496
00:56
and together we decided,
we didn't even need to train.
we didn't even need to train.
13
44160
3576
00:59
(Laughter)
14
47760
3256
01:03
And on the day of our record attempt,
15
51040
1816
01:04
we put furniture pads
on the outside of our good luck jeans
on the outside of our good luck jeans
16
52880
3656
01:08
and we set off,
17
56560
1400
01:10
and right away, we were in trouble,
18
58720
3056
01:13
because the denim was against our skin
19
61800
2096
01:15
and it began to chafe,
20
63920
1575
01:17
and soon our knees were being chewed up.
21
65519
2641
01:20
Hours in,
22
68920
1200
01:23
it began to rain.
23
71160
1200
01:25
Then, Anne dropped out.
24
73520
2440
01:29
Then, it got dark.
25
77400
1960
01:32
Now, by now, my knees
were bleeding through my jeans,
were bleeding through my jeans,
26
80680
2816
01:35
and I was hallucinating from the cold
27
83520
2216
01:37
and the pain and the monotony.
28
85760
2696
01:40
And to give you an idea
of the suffer-fest that I was undergoing,
of the suffer-fest that I was undergoing,
29
88480
3520
01:45
the first lap around
the high school track took 10 minutes.
the high school track took 10 minutes.
30
93120
4120
01:49
The last lap took almost 30.
31
97880
2800
01:54
After 12 hours of crawling,
32
102000
4416
01:58
I stopped,
33
106440
1336
01:59
and I had gone eight and a half miles.
34
107800
2880
02:03
So I was short of
the 12-and-a-half-mile record.
the 12-and-a-half-mile record.
35
111880
3656
02:07
Now, for many years, I thought
this was a story of abject failure,
this was a story of abject failure,
36
115560
4536
02:12
but today I see it differently,
37
120120
2496
02:14
because when I was
attempting the world record,
attempting the world record,
38
122640
2856
02:17
I was doing three things.
39
125520
1496
02:19
I was getting outside my comfort zone,
40
127040
2336
02:21
I was calling upon my resilience,
41
129400
2256
02:23
and I was finding confidence in myself
42
131680
2736
02:26
and my own decisions.
43
134440
1400
02:28
I didn't know it then,
44
136440
1256
02:29
but those are not
the attributes of failure.
the attributes of failure.
45
137720
2920
02:33
Those are the attributes of bravery.
46
141480
2600
02:37
Now, in 1989, at the age of 26,
47
145280
2576
02:39
I became a San Francisco firefighter,
48
147880
2240
02:42
and I was the 15th woman
in a department of 1,500 men.
in a department of 1,500 men.
49
150800
4176
02:47
(Applause)
50
155000
3760
02:53
And as you can imagine, when I arrived
51
161240
1856
02:55
there were many doubts
about whether we could do the job.
about whether we could do the job.
52
163120
2696
02:57
So even though I was a 5'10",
150-pound collegiate rower,
150-pound collegiate rower,
53
165840
5336
03:03
and someone who could endure
12 hours of searing knee pain --
12 hours of searing knee pain --
54
171200
4376
03:07
(Laughter)
55
175600
1616
03:09
I knew I still had to prove
my strength and fitness.
my strength and fitness.
56
177240
3016
03:12
So one day a call came in for a fire,
57
180280
1816
03:14
and sure enough,
when my engine group pulled up,
when my engine group pulled up,
58
182120
2239
03:16
there was black smoke billowing
from a building off an alleyway.
from a building off an alleyway.
59
184383
4033
03:20
And I was with a big guy named Skip,
60
188440
2216
03:22
and he was on the nozzle,
and I was right behind,
and I was right behind,
61
190680
2736
03:25
and it was a typical sort of fire.
62
193440
1816
03:27
It was smoky, it was hot,
63
195280
2880
03:30
and all of a sudden,
64
198680
1696
03:32
there was an explosion,
65
200400
1776
03:34
and Skip and I were blown backwards,
66
202200
2176
03:36
my mask was knocked sideways,
67
204400
2136
03:38
and there was this moment of confusion.
68
206560
2256
03:40
And then I picked myself up,
69
208840
3416
03:44
I groped for the nozzle,
70
212280
1816
03:46
and I did what a firefighter
was supposed to do:
was supposed to do:
71
214120
2496
03:48
I lunged forward,
72
216640
1736
03:50
opened up the water
73
218400
1456
03:51
and I tackled the fire myself.
74
219880
1880
03:54
The explosion had been caused
by a water heater,
by a water heater,
75
222720
2256
03:57
so nobody was hurt,
and ultimately it was not a big deal,
and ultimately it was not a big deal,
76
225000
2696
03:59
but later Skip came up to me and said,
77
227720
3256
04:03
"Nice job, Caroline,"
78
231000
1736
04:04
in this surprised sort of voice.
79
232760
2296
04:07
(Laughter)
80
235080
1600
04:09
And I was confused, because
the fire hadn't been difficult physically,
the fire hadn't been difficult physically,
81
237600
3816
04:13
so why was he looking at me
with something like astonishment?
with something like astonishment?
82
241440
4320
04:18
And then it became clear:
83
246480
1656
04:20
Skip, who was by the way a really nice guy
84
248160
3136
04:23
and an excellent firefighter,
85
251320
2216
04:25
not only thought
that women could not be strong,
that women could not be strong,
86
253560
3375
04:28
he thought that they
could not be brave either.
could not be brave either.
87
256959
3041
04:32
And he wasn't the only one.
88
260760
1600
04:35
Friends, acquaintances and strangers,
89
263560
2256
04:37
men and women throughout my career
90
265840
2056
04:39
ask me over and over,
91
267920
1456
04:41
"Caroline, all that fire, all that danger,
92
269400
3936
04:45
aren't you scared?"
93
273360
1240
04:47
Honestly, I never heard
a male firefighter asked this.
a male firefighter asked this.
94
275320
2880
04:50
And I became curious.
95
278920
1520
04:53
Why wasn't bravery expected of women?
96
281200
3160
04:57
Now, the answer began to come
97
285760
1776
04:59
when a friend of mine lamented to me
98
287560
1736
05:01
that her young daughter
was a big scaredy-cat,
was a big scaredy-cat,
99
289320
2456
05:03
and so I began to notice,
100
291800
1936
05:05
and yes, the daughter was anxious,
101
293760
2696
05:08
but more than that,
the parents were anxious.
the parents were anxious.
102
296480
2760
05:12
Most of what they said to her
when she was outside began with,
when she was outside began with,
103
300120
3256
05:15
"Be careful," "Watch out," or "No."
104
303400
3600
05:20
Now, my friends were not bad parents.
105
308920
2656
05:23
They were just doing what most parents do,
106
311600
2696
05:26
which is cautioning their daughters
much more than they caution their sons.
much more than they caution their sons.
107
314320
4000
05:31
There was a study involving
a playground fire pole, ironically,
a playground fire pole, ironically,
108
319440
4080
05:36
in which researchers saw that little girls
were very likely to be warned
were very likely to be warned
109
324480
4096
05:40
by both their moms and dads
about the fire pole's risk,
about the fire pole's risk,
110
328600
3696
05:44
and if the little girls
still wanted to play on the fire pole,
still wanted to play on the fire pole,
111
332320
3456
05:47
a parent was very likely to assist her.
112
335800
2720
05:51
But the little boys?
113
339280
1280
05:53
They were encouraged
to play on the fire pole
to play on the fire pole
114
341160
2776
05:55
despite any trepidations
that they might have,
that they might have,
115
343960
2936
05:58
and often the parents offered
guidance on how to use it on their own.
guidance on how to use it on their own.
116
346920
5120
06:05
So what message does this send
to both boys and girls?
to both boys and girls?
117
353480
3960
06:09
Well, that girls are fragile
and more in need of help,
and more in need of help,
118
357920
3936
06:13
and that boys can and should
master difficult tasks by themselves.
master difficult tasks by themselves.
119
361880
4040
06:18
It says that girls should be fearful
120
366520
2736
06:21
and boys should be gutsy.
121
369280
2320
06:25
Now, the irony is that at this young age,
122
373160
2496
06:27
girls and boys are actually
very alike physically.
very alike physically.
123
375680
2496
06:30
In fact, girls are often
stronger until puberty,
stronger until puberty,
124
378200
2656
06:32
and more mature.
125
380880
1240
06:34
And yet we adults act
126
382480
1976
06:36
as if girls are more fragile
127
384480
2336
06:38
and more in need of help,
128
386840
1936
06:40
and they can't handle as much.
129
388800
1680
06:43
This is the message
that we absorb as kids,
that we absorb as kids,
130
391160
2576
06:45
and this is the message
that fully permeates as we grow up.
that fully permeates as we grow up.
131
393760
3696
06:49
We women believe it, men believe it,
132
397480
2456
06:51
and guess what?
133
399960
1536
06:53
As we become parents,
we pass it on to our children,
we pass it on to our children,
134
401520
3336
06:56
and so it goes.
135
404880
1320
06:58
Well, so now I had my answer.
136
406720
2496
07:01
This is why women, even firewomen,
137
409240
2576
07:03
were expected to be scared.
138
411840
2096
07:05
This is why women often are scared.
139
413960
3080
07:09
Now, I know some of you
won't believe me when I tell you this,
won't believe me when I tell you this,
140
417920
3136
07:13
but I am not against fear.
141
421080
2480
07:16
I know it's an important emotion,
and it's there to keep us safe.
and it's there to keep us safe.
142
424200
3816
07:20
But the problem is
when fear is the primary reaction
when fear is the primary reaction
143
428040
3176
07:23
that we teach and encourage in girls
144
431240
2336
07:25
whenever they face something
outside their comfort zone.
outside their comfort zone.
145
433600
2640
07:29
So I was a paraglider pilot
for many years --
for many years --
146
437760
2640
07:33
(Applause)
147
441800
1896
07:35
and a paraglider is a parachute-like wing,
148
443720
2416
07:38
and it does fly very well,
149
446160
3736
07:41
but to many people I realize
it looks just like a bedsheet
it looks just like a bedsheet
150
449920
2896
07:44
with strings attached.
151
452840
1496
07:46
(Laughter)
152
454360
1176
07:47
And I spent a lot of time on mountaintops
153
455560
2456
07:50
inflating this bedsheet,
154
458040
1576
07:51
running off and flying.
155
459640
1680
07:54
And I know what you're thinking.
156
462560
1576
07:56
You're like, Caroline,
a little fear would make sense here.
a little fear would make sense here.
157
464160
3280
08:00
And you're right, it does.
158
468800
1856
08:02
I assure you, I did feel fear.
159
470680
2496
08:05
But on that mountaintop,
160
473200
1256
08:06
waiting for the wind
to come in just right,
to come in just right,
161
474480
2056
08:08
I felt so many other things, too:
162
476560
2216
08:10
exhilaration, confidence.
163
478800
2280
08:14
I knew I was a good pilot.
164
482000
1776
08:15
I knew the conditions were good,
or I wouldn't be there.
or I wouldn't be there.
165
483800
3016
08:18
I knew how great it was going to be
a thousand feet in the air.
a thousand feet in the air.
166
486840
3536
08:22
So yes, fear was there,
167
490400
2616
08:25
but I would take a good hard look at it,
168
493040
2176
08:27
assess just how relevant it was
169
495240
2656
08:29
and then put it where it belonged,
170
497920
2336
08:32
which was more often than not
171
500280
1416
08:33
behind my exhilaration, my anticipation
172
501720
3976
08:37
and my confidence.
173
505720
1200
08:39
So I'm not against fear.
174
507400
2016
08:41
I'm just pro-bravery.
175
509440
2520
08:46
Now, I'm not saying
your girls must be firefighters
your girls must be firefighters
176
514520
3216
08:49
or that they should be paragliders,
177
517760
2216
08:52
but I am saying that we are raising
our girls to be timid, even helpless,
our girls to be timid, even helpless,
178
520000
4760
08:57
and it begins when we caution them
against physical risk.
against physical risk.
179
525600
3616
09:01
The fear we learn
and the experiences we don't
and the experiences we don't
180
529240
2616
09:03
stay with us as we become women
181
531880
1816
09:05
and morphs into all those things
that we face and try to shed:
that we face and try to shed:
182
533720
4256
09:10
our hesitation in speaking out,
183
538000
2296
09:12
our deference so that we can be liked
184
540320
2656
09:15
and our lack of confidence
in our own decisions.
in our own decisions.
185
543000
2720
09:18
So how do we become brave?
186
546960
2320
09:22
Well, here's the good news.
187
550440
1776
09:24
Bravery is learned,
188
552240
1976
09:26
and like anything learned,
189
554240
1416
09:27
it just needs to be practiced.
190
555680
1840
09:30
So first,
191
558040
1576
09:31
we have to take a deep breath
192
559640
1696
09:33
and encourage our girls
193
561360
2056
09:35
to skateboard, climb trees
194
563440
2696
09:38
and clamber around
on that playground fire pole.
on that playground fire pole.
195
566160
2560
09:41
This is what my own mother did.
196
569480
2176
09:43
She didn't know it then,
197
571680
1776
09:45
but researchers have a name for this.
198
573480
2296
09:47
They call it risky play,
199
575800
2096
09:49
and studies show that risky play
is really important for kids, all kids,
is really important for kids, all kids,
200
577920
4456
09:54
because it teaches hazard assessment,
201
582400
2576
09:57
it teaches delayed gratification,
202
585000
2176
09:59
it teaches resilience,
203
587200
1776
10:01
it teaches confidence.
204
589000
1320
10:03
In other words,
205
591080
1456
10:04
when kids get outside
and practice bravery,
and practice bravery,
206
592560
3296
10:07
they learn valuable life lessons.
207
595880
3160
10:12
Second, we have to stop
cautioning our girls willy-nilly.
cautioning our girls willy-nilly.
208
600600
4736
10:17
So notice next time you say,
209
605360
2416
10:19
"Watch out, you're going to get hurt,"
210
607800
1856
10:21
or, "Don't do that, it's dangerous."
211
609680
2080
10:24
And remember that often
what you're really telling her
what you're really telling her
212
612480
3576
10:28
is that she shouldn't be pushing herself,
213
616080
2416
10:30
that she's really not good enough,
214
618520
2176
10:32
that she should be afraid.
215
620720
1800
10:36
Third,
216
624320
1200
10:38
we women have to start
practicing bravery, too.
practicing bravery, too.
217
626080
3000
10:41
We cannot teach our girls
until we teach ourselves.
until we teach ourselves.
218
629880
3160
10:45
So here's another thing:
219
633960
1896
10:47
fear and exhilaration
220
635880
3096
10:51
feel very similar --
221
639000
1760
10:53
the shaky hands,
the heightened heart rate,
the heightened heart rate,
222
641760
2576
10:56
the nervous tension,
223
644360
1376
10:57
and I'm betting that for many of you
224
645760
1736
10:59
the last time you thought
you were scared out of your wits,
you were scared out of your wits,
225
647520
2816
11:02
you may have been feeling
mostly exhilaration,
mostly exhilaration,
226
650360
2936
11:05
and now you've missed an opportunity.
227
653320
1960
11:07
So practice.
228
655720
1200
11:09
And while girls should be getting
outside to learn to be gutsy,
outside to learn to be gutsy,
229
657560
2976
11:12
I get that adults don't want
to get on hoverboards or climb trees,
to get on hoverboards or climb trees,
230
660560
6096
11:18
so we all should be practicing
231
666680
3456
11:22
at home, in the office
232
670160
2216
11:24
and even right here getting up the guts
233
672400
2096
11:26
to talk to someone that you really admire.
234
674520
2360
11:30
Finally, when your girl is, let's say,
235
678360
4016
11:34
on her bike on the top of the steep hill
236
682400
2096
11:36
that she insists
she's too scared to go down,
she's too scared to go down,
237
684520
3416
11:39
guide her to access her bravery.
238
687960
2120
11:42
Ultimately, maybe that hill
really is too steep,
really is too steep,
239
690720
4256
11:47
but she'll come to that conclusion
through courage, not fear.
through courage, not fear.
240
695000
3920
11:51
Because this is not
about the steep hill in front of her.
about the steep hill in front of her.
241
699920
3896
11:55
This is about the life ahead of her
242
703840
1880
11:58
and that she has the tools
243
706400
1776
12:00
to handle and assess
244
708200
2096
12:02
all the dangers
that we cannot protect her from,
that we cannot protect her from,
245
710320
3256
12:05
all the challenges that we won't
be there to guide her through,
be there to guide her through,
246
713600
3880
12:10
everything that our girls here
247
718160
2456
12:12
and around the world
248
720640
1376
12:14
face in their future.
249
722040
1800
12:18
So by the way,
250
726200
1240
12:20
the world record for crawling today --
251
728400
2776
12:23
(Laughter)
252
731200
2376
12:25
is 35.18 miles,
253
733600
3040
12:30
and I would really love
to see a girl go break that.
to see a girl go break that.
254
738520
3456
12:34
(Applause)
255
742000
6356
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Caroline Paul - AuthorBrimming with insights gained on her picaresque journey from firefighter to best-selling author, Caroline Paul’s "The Gutsy Girl: Escapades for Your Life of Epic Adventure" is a revolutionary guide for raising brave young women.
Why you should listen
Before launching her career as a writer, Caroline Paul embarked on a long list of unlikely adventures, ranging from flying experimental planes to whitewater rafting unexplored rivers in Borneo and Australia.
Paul was one of the first women to work for the San Francisco Fire Department -- a job that inspired her first work of nonfiction, Fighting Fire. Her latest book, The Gutsy Girl, uses stories from her own life as a gutsy woman to inspire girls to break the rules, take risks and accept seemingly insurmountable challenges.
Caroline Paul | Speaker | TED.com