TEDxDublin
Aris Venetikidis: Making sense of maps
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
715,612 views
Aris Venetikidis is fascinated by the maps we draw in our minds as we move around a city -- less like street maps, more like schematics or wiring diagrams, abstract images of relationships between places. How can we learn from these mental maps to make better real ones? As a test case, he remakes the notorious Dublin bus map.
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:15
What I do is I organize information. I'm a graphic designer.
0
0
3216
00:19
Professionally, I try to make sense
1
3216
2743
00:21
often of things that don't make much sense themselves.
2
5959
3844
00:25
So my father might not understand what it is
3
9803
2233
00:27
that I do for a living.
4
12036
1690
00:29
His part of my ancestry has been farmers.
5
13726
2277
00:31
He's part of this ethnic minority called the Pontic Greeks.
6
16003
3124
00:35
They lived in Asia Minor, and fled to Greece
7
19127
4386
00:39
after a genocide about a hundred years ago,
8
23513
2470
00:41
and ever since that, migration has somewhat been
9
25983
2925
00:44
a theme in my family.
10
28908
1589
00:46
My father moved to Germany, studied there, and married,
11
30497
4447
00:50
and as a result, I now have this half-German brain
12
34944
4264
00:55
with all the analytical thinking
13
39208
2276
00:57
and that slight dorky demeanor that comes with that.
14
41484
3375
01:00
And of course it meant that I was a foreigner in both countries,
15
44859
3112
01:03
and that of course made it pretty easy for me
16
47971
2538
01:06
to migrate as well, in good family tradition, if you like.
17
50509
4875
01:11
But of course, most journeys that we undertake
18
55384
2337
01:13
from day to day are within a city, and especially
19
57721
3638
01:17
if you know the city, getting from A to B
20
61359
3000
01:20
may seem pretty obvious, right?
21
64359
3425
01:23
But the question is, why is it obvious?
22
67784
3750
01:27
How do we know where we're going?
23
71534
2524
01:29
So I washed up on a Dublin ferry port
24
74058
2184
01:32
about 12 years ago, a professional foreigner, if you like,
25
76242
3656
01:35
and I'm sure you've all had this experience before, yeah?
26
79898
3491
01:39
You arrive in a new city, and your brain is trying
27
83389
3721
01:43
to make sense of this new place.
28
87110
2369
01:45
Once you find your base, your home,
29
89479
3056
01:48
you start to built this cognitive map of your environment.
30
92535
4600
01:53
It's essentially this virtual map that only exists
31
97135
2800
01:55
in your brain. All animal species do it,
32
99935
2976
01:58
even though we all use slightly different tools.
33
102911
3037
02:01
Us humans, of course, we don't move around
34
105948
2776
02:04
marking our territory by scent, like dogs.
35
108724
3174
02:07
We don't run around emitting ultrasonic squeaks, like bats.
36
111898
5576
02:13
We just don't do that,
37
117474
1515
02:14
although a night in the Temple Bar district can get pretty wild. (Laughter)
38
118989
5222
02:20
No, we do two important things to make a place our own.
39
124211
3864
02:23
First, we move along linear routes.
40
128075
2858
02:26
Typically we find a main street, and this main street
41
130933
3529
02:30
becomes a linear strip map in our minds.
42
134462
2763
02:33
But our mind keeps it pretty simple, yeah?
43
137225
2400
02:35
Every street is generally perceived as a straight line,
44
139625
3128
02:38
and we kind of ignore the little twists and turns that the streets make.
45
142753
4284
02:42
When we do, however, make a turn into a side street,
46
147037
2551
02:45
our mind tends to adjust that turn to a 90-degree angle.
47
149588
4712
02:50
This of course makes for some funny moments
48
154300
2701
02:52
when you're in some old city layout that follows some sort of
49
157001
4513
02:57
circular city logic, yeah?
50
161514
3122
03:00
Maybe you've had that experience as well, right?
51
164636
1858
03:02
Let's say you're on some spot on a side street that projects
52
166494
3269
03:05
from a main cathedral square, and you want to get to
53
169763
3620
03:09
another point on a side street just like that.
54
173383
3643
03:12
The cognitive map in your mind may tell you, "Aris,
55
177026
5226
03:18
go back to the main cathedral square, take
56
182252
2704
03:20
a 90-degree turn, and walk down that other side street."
57
184956
3085
03:23
But somehow you feel adventurous that day,
58
188041
2277
03:26
and you suddenly discover that the two spots
59
190318
4606
03:30
were actually only a single building apart.
60
194924
2856
03:33
Now, I don't know about you, but I always feel like I find
61
197780
2345
03:36
this wormhole or this inter-dimensional portal.
62
200125
4661
03:40
So we move along linear routes
63
204786
3245
03:43
and our mind straightens streets and perceives turns
64
208031
5000
03:48
as 90-degree angles.
65
213031
1578
03:50
The second thing that we do to make a place our own
66
214609
2851
03:53
is we attach meaning and emotions to the things
67
217460
4496
03:57
that we see along those lines.
68
221956
2615
04:00
If you go to the Irish countryside, and you ask an old lady
69
224571
4337
04:04
for directions, brace yourself for some elaborate
70
228908
3924
04:08
Irish storytelling about all the landmarks. Yeah?
71
232832
3961
04:12
She'll tell you the pub where her sister used to work,
72
236793
3230
04:15
and go past the church where I got married, that kind of thing.
73
240023
3283
04:19
So we fill our cognitive maps with these markers of meaning.
74
243306
4176
04:23
What's more, we abstract,
75
247482
3177
04:26
repeat patterns, and recognize them.
76
250659
2685
04:29
We recognize them by the experiences,
77
253344
3124
04:32
and we abstract them into symbols.
78
256468
2917
04:35
And of course, we are all capable
79
259385
2896
04:38
of understanding these symbols. (Laughter)
80
262281
2976
04:41
What's more, we're all capable of understanding
81
265257
3261
04:44
the cognitive maps, and you are all capable
82
268518
3838
04:48
of creating these cognitive maps yourselves.
83
272356
3599
04:51
So next time, when you want to tell your friend how to get to your place,
84
275955
2939
04:54
you grab a beermat, grab a napkin,
85
278894
2900
04:57
and you just observe yourself create this awesome piece
86
281794
4525
05:02
of communication design. It's got straight lines.
87
286319
3747
05:05
It's got 90 degree corners.
88
290066
2466
05:08
You might add little symbols along the way.
89
292532
2097
05:10
And when you look at what you've just drawn,
90
294629
3678
05:14
you realize it does not resemble a street map.
91
298307
5200
05:19
If you were to put an actual street map
92
303507
2313
05:21
on top of what you've just drawn, you'd realize your streets
93
305820
3575
05:25
and the distances, they'd be way off.
94
309395
3475
05:28
No, what you've just drawn
95
312870
1891
05:30
is more like a diagram or a schematic.
96
314761
4099
05:34
It's a visual construct of lines, dots, letters,
97
318860
4415
05:39
designed in the language of our brains.
98
323275
3094
05:42
So it's no big surprise that the big information design icon
99
326369
5055
05:47
of the last century, the pinnacle of showing everybody
100
331424
4704
05:52
how to get from A to B, the London Underground map,
101
336128
3496
05:55
was not designed by a cartographer or a city planner.
102
339624
4763
06:00
It was designed by an engineering draftsman.
103
344387
4238
06:04
In the 1930s, Harry Beck applied the principles of
104
348625
4027
06:08
schematic diagram design, and changed
105
352652
4252
06:12
the way public transport maps are designed forever.
106
356904
4185
06:16
Now the very key to the success of this map
107
361089
3550
06:20
is in the omission of less important information
108
364639
4312
06:24
and in the extreme simplification.
109
368951
2491
06:27
So straightened streets, corners of 90 and 45 degrees,
110
371442
4278
06:31
but also the extreme geographic distortion in that map.
111
375720
5826
06:37
If you were to look at the actual locations of these stations,
112
381546
4270
06:41
you'd see they're very different. Yeah?
113
385816
2637
06:44
But this is all for the clarity of the public tube map.
114
388453
4414
06:48
Yeah? If you, say, wanted to get from Regent's Park Station
115
392867
3225
06:51
to Great Portland Street, the tube map would tell you,
116
396092
3315
06:55
take the tube, go to Baker Street, change over, take another tube.
117
399407
4892
07:00
Of course, what you don't know is that the two stations
118
404299
3365
07:03
are only about a hundred meters apart.
119
407664
3074
07:06
Now we've reached the subject of public transport,
120
410738
3125
07:09
and public transport here in Dublin
121
413863
2514
07:12
is a somewhat touchy subject. (Laughter)
122
416377
4286
07:16
For everybody who does not know the public transport here in Dublin,
123
420663
3489
07:20
essentially we have this system of local buses
124
424152
2909
07:22
that grew with the city. For every outskirt that was added,
125
427061
3765
07:26
there was another bus route added running
126
430826
2312
07:29
from the outskirt all the way to the city center,
127
433138
3970
07:33
and as these local buses approach the city center,
128
437108
4685
07:37
they all run side by side, and converge in pretty much
129
441793
2921
07:40
one main street.
130
444714
2938
07:43
So when I stepped off the boat 12 years ago,
131
447652
3124
07:46
I tried to make sense of that,
132
450776
3651
07:50
because exploring a city on foot only gets you so far.
133
454427
5474
07:55
But when you explore a foreign and new public transport system,
134
459901
4752
08:00
you will build a cognitive map in your mind
135
464653
3100
08:03
in pretty much the same way.
136
467753
2999
08:06
Typically, you choose yourself a rapid transport route,
137
470752
5114
08:11
and in your mind this route is perceived as a straight line,
138
475866
4079
08:15
and like a pearl necklace, all the stations and stops
139
479945
3021
08:18
are nicely and neatly aligned along the line,
140
482966
4273
08:23
and only then you start to discover some local bus routes
141
487239
4967
08:28
that would fill in the gaps and that allow you for those
142
492206
4324
08:32
wormhole, inter-dimensional portal shortcuts.
143
496530
4568
08:36
So I tried to make sense, and when I arrived,
144
501098
3655
08:40
I was looking for some information leaflets that would
145
504753
3287
08:43
help me crack this system and understand it,
146
508040
3112
08:47
and I found those brochures. (Laughter)
147
511152
5838
08:52
They were not geographically distorted.
148
516990
3503
08:56
They were having a lot of omission of information,
149
520493
4285
09:00
but unfortunately the wrong information, say, in the city center.
150
524778
4088
09:04
There were never actually any lines that showed the routes.
151
528866
4638
09:09
There are actually not even any stations with names.
152
533504
5955
09:15
Now the maps of Dublin transport, have gotten better,
153
539459
4189
09:19
and after I finished the project, they got a good bit better,
154
543648
6713
09:26
but still no station names, still no routes.
155
550361
3157
09:29
So, being naive, and being half-German, I decided,
156
553518
5968
09:35
"Aris, why don't you build your own map?"
157
559486
2502
09:37
So that's what I did. I researched how each
158
561988
2768
09:40
and every bus route moved through the city,
159
564756
3316
09:43
nice and logical, every bus route a separate line,
160
568072
3991
09:47
and I plotted it into my own map of Dublin,
161
572063
3074
09:51
and in the city center,
162
575137
2762
09:53
I got a nice spaghetti plate. (Laughter)
163
577899
4137
09:57
Now this is a bit of a mess, so I decided, of course,
164
582036
5914
10:03
you're going to apply the rules of schematic design,
165
587950
3725
10:07
cleaning up the corridors, widening the streets
166
591675
2659
10:10
where there were loads of buses, and making the streets
167
594334
3516
10:13
at straight, 90-degree corners, 45-degree corners, or fractions of that,
168
597850
4542
10:18
and filled it in with the bus routes. And I built this city center
169
602392
4822
10:23
bus map of the system, how it was five years ago.
170
607214
4323
10:27
I'll zoom in again so that you get the full impact of
171
611537
2492
10:29
the quays and Westmoreland Street. (Laughter)
172
614029
4354
10:34
Now I can proudly say — (Applause) —
173
618383
8410
10:42
I can proudly say, as a public transport map,
174
626793
4288
10:46
this diagram is an utter failure — (Laughter) —
175
631081
5784
10:52
except probably in one aspect:
176
636865
2059
10:54
I now had a great visual representation
177
638924
3053
10:57
of just how clogged up and overrun the city center really was.
178
641977
4188
11:02
Now call me old-fashioned, right, but I think
179
646165
2935
11:05
a public transport route map should have lines,
180
649100
3428
11:08
because that's what they are. Yeah?
181
652528
1776
11:10
They're little pieces of string that wrap their way
182
654304
3611
11:13
through the city center, or through the city.
183
657915
2760
11:16
If you will, the Greek guy inside of me feels, if I don't
184
660675
3896
11:20
get a line, it's like entering the Labyrinth of the Minotaur
185
664571
4532
11:25
without having Ariadne giving you the string to find your way.
186
669103
3182
11:28
So the outcome of my academic research,
187
672285
4106
11:32
loads of questionnaires, case studies,
188
676391
3506
11:35
and looking at a lot of maps, was that a lot of the problems
189
679897
5046
11:40
and shortcomings of the public transport system here in Dublin
190
684943
3076
11:43
was the lack of a coherent public transport map --
191
688019
2710
11:46
a simplified, coherent public transport map --
192
690729
2274
11:48
because I think this is the crucial step to understanding
193
693003
3439
11:52
a public transport network on a physical level,
194
696442
3498
11:55
but it's also the crucial step to make
195
699940
2465
11:58
a public transport network mappable on a visual level.
196
702405
3750
12:02
So I teamed up with a gentleman called James Leahy,
197
706155
3650
12:05
a civil engineer and a recent Master's graduate of
198
709805
3625
12:09
the Sustainable Development Program at DIT,
199
713430
3563
12:12
and together we drafted this simplified model network
200
716993
3926
12:16
which I could then go ahead and visualize.
201
720919
3437
12:20
So here's what we did.
202
724356
2115
12:22
We distributed these rapid transport corridors
203
726471
4685
12:27
throughout the city center, and extended them into the outskirts.
204
731156
4649
12:31
Rapid, because we wanted them to be served
205
735805
2738
12:34
by rapid transport vehicles, yeah?
206
738543
3426
12:37
They would get exclusive road use, where possible,
207
741969
2943
12:40
and it would be high-quantity, high-quality transport.
208
744912
3530
12:44
James wanted to use bus rapid transport for that,
209
748442
2896
12:47
rather than light rail. For me, it was important
210
751338
3030
12:50
that the vehicles that would run on those rapid transport corridors
211
754368
4090
12:54
would be visibly distinguishable from local buses on the street.
212
758458
6048
13:00
Now we could take out all the local buses
213
764506
3243
13:03
that ran alongside those rapid transport means.
214
767749
3207
13:06
Any gaps that appeared in the outskirts were filled again.
215
770956
3499
13:10
So, in other words, if there was a street in an outskirt
216
774455
3163
13:13
where there had been a bus, we put a bus back in,
217
777618
2963
13:16
only now these buses wouldn't run all the way to the city center
218
780581
4563
13:21
but connect to the nearest rapid transport mode,
219
785144
3482
13:24
one of these thick lines over there.
220
788626
1944
13:26
So the rest was merely a couple of months of work,
221
790570
3389
13:29
and a couple of fights with my girlfriend of our place
222
793959
3042
13:32
constantly being clogged up with maps,
223
797001
3293
13:36
and the outcome, one of the outcomes, was this map
224
800294
2600
13:38
of the Greater Dublin Area. I'll zoom in a little bit.
225
802894
5113
13:43
This map only shows the rapid transport connections,
226
808007
3576
13:47
no local bus, very much in the Metro map style
227
811583
3286
13:50
that was so successful in London, and that since
228
814869
3939
13:54
has been exported to so many other major cities,
229
818808
3344
13:58
and therefore is the language that we should use
230
822152
2492
14:00
for public transport maps.
231
824644
2869
14:03
What's also important is, with a simplified network like this,
232
827513
5304
14:08
it now would become possible for me
233
832817
2700
14:11
to tackle the ultimate challenge,
234
835517
3213
14:14
and make a public transport map for the city center,
235
838730
3513
14:18
one where it wouldn't just show rapid transport connections
236
842243
3274
14:21
but also all the local bus routes, streets and the likes,
237
845517
3560
14:24
and this is what a map like this could like.
238
849077
2176
14:27
I'll zoom in a little bit.
239
851253
3399
14:30
In this map, I'm including each transport mode,
240
854652
6233
14:36
so rapid transport, bus, DART, tram and the likes.
241
860885
5221
14:42
Each individual route is represented by a separate line.
242
866106
6323
14:48
The map shows each and every station,
243
872429
4874
14:53
each and every station name,
244
877303
3089
14:56
and I'm also displaying side streets,
245
880392
4687
15:00
in fact, most of the side streets even with their name,
246
885079
3987
15:04
and for good measure, also a couple of landmarks,
247
889066
4312
15:09
some of them signified by little symbols,
248
893378
2814
15:12
others by these isometric three-dimensional
249
896192
3114
15:15
bird's-eye-view drawings.
250
899306
1569
15:16
The map is relatively small in overall size,
251
900875
3193
15:19
so something that you could still hold as a fold-out map,
252
904068
3048
15:23
or display in a reasonably-sized display box on a bus shelter.
253
907116
3702
15:26
I think it tries to be the best balance
254
910818
4500
15:31
between actual representation
255
915318
3165
15:34
and simplification, the language of way-finding in our brain.
256
918483
5586
15:39
So straightened lines, cleaned-up corners,
257
924069
3448
15:43
and, of course, that very, very important
258
927517
1951
15:45
geographic distortion that makes public transport maps possible.
259
929468
5180
15:50
If you, for example, have a look at the two main
260
934648
1961
15:52
corridors that run through the city,
261
936609
2348
15:54
the yellow and orange one over here, this is how
262
938957
2148
15:57
they look in an actual, accurate street map,
263
941105
3323
16:00
and this is how they would look in my distorted,
264
944428
3684
16:04
simplified public transport map.
265
948112
3261
16:07
So for a successful public transport map,
266
951373
3134
16:10
we should not stick to accurate representation,
267
954507
1993
16:12
but design them in the way our brains work.
268
956500
2819
16:15
The reactions I got were tremendous. It was really good to see.
269
959319
3223
16:18
And of course, for my own self, I was very happy to see
270
962542
3624
16:22
that my folks in Germany and Greece finally have an idea
271
966166
3422
16:25
what I do for a living. (Laughter) Thank you. (Applause)
272
969588
5978
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Aris Venetikidis - MapmakerAris Venetikidis imagines how maps work with our minds.
Why you should listen
Aris Venetikidis is a graphic designer with a passion for map design and public transport network visualisation. His project “Designing an integrated map for a visionary public transport network in Dublin” earned him the IDI Graduate Masters Award and IDI Graduate Grand Prix in 2010, as well as press coverage in major Irish and Greek newspapers. Aris studied at the National College of Art and Design ind Dublin and has been working as a designer in agencies or as an independent designer and photographer since.
Aris Venetikidis | Speaker | TED.com