TEDCity2.0
Chris Downey: Design with the blind in mind
Filmed:
Readability: 3.6
1,081,680 views
What would a city designed for the blind be like? Chris Downey is an architect who went suddenly blind in 2008; he contrasts life in his beloved San Francisco before and after -- and shows how the thoughtful designs that enhance his life now might actually make everyone's life better, sighted or not.
Chris Downey - Architect
Chris Downey is an architect who lost his sight and gained a new way of seeing the world. Full bio
Chris Downey is an architect who lost his sight and gained a new way of seeing the world. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:15
So, stepping down out of the bus,
0
3170
2981
00:18
I headed back to the corner
1
6151
1745
00:19
to head west en route to a braille training session.
2
7896
3388
00:23
It was the winter of 2009,
3
11284
2110
00:25
and I had been blind for about a year.
4
13394
2421
00:27
Things were going pretty well.
5
15815
2133
00:29
Safely reaching the other side,
6
17948
1907
00:31
I turned to the left,
7
19855
1461
00:33
pushed the auto-button for
the audible pedestrian signal,
the audible pedestrian signal,
8
21316
2604
00:35
and waited my turn.
9
23920
1924
00:37
As it went off, I took off
10
25844
2089
00:39
and safely got to the other side.
11
27933
1673
00:41
Stepping onto the sidewalk,
12
29606
2096
00:43
I then heard the sound of a steel chair
13
31702
2694
00:46
slide across the concrete sidewalk in front of me.
14
34396
4156
00:50
I know there's a cafe on the corner,
15
38552
1917
00:52
and they have chairs out in front,
16
40469
1646
00:54
so I just adjusted to the left
17
42115
1396
00:55
to get closer to the street.
18
43511
1844
00:57
As I did, so slid the chair.
19
45355
3640
01:00
I just figured I'd made a mistake,
20
48995
2081
01:03
and went back to the right,
21
51076
1838
01:04
and so slid the chair in perfect synchronicity.
22
52914
3495
01:08
Now I was getting a little anxious.
23
56409
2365
01:10
I went back to the left,
24
58774
1613
01:12
and so slid the chair,
25
60387
1289
01:13
blocking my path of travel.
26
61676
2608
01:16
Now, I was officially freaking out.
27
64284
3002
01:19
So I yelled,
28
67286
1585
01:20
"Who the hell's out there? What's going on?"
29
68871
3261
01:24
Just then, over my shout,
30
72132
2252
01:26
I heard something else, a familiar rattle.
31
74384
2685
01:29
It sounded familiar,
32
77069
1846
01:30
and I quickly considered another possibility,
33
78915
1863
01:32
and I reached out with my left hand,
34
80778
1931
01:34
as my fingers brushed against something fuzzy,
35
82709
3404
01:38
and I came across an ear,
36
86113
2551
01:40
the ear of a dog, perhaps a golden retriever.
37
88664
4262
01:44
Its leash had been tied to the chair
38
92926
1989
01:46
as her master went in for coffee,
39
94915
1737
01:48
and she was just persistent in her efforts
40
96652
1792
01:50
to greet me, perhaps get a scratch behind the ear.
41
98444
3338
01:53
Who knows, maybe she was volunteering for service.
42
101782
2612
01:56
(Laughter)
43
104394
2379
01:58
But that little story is really about
44
106773
2409
02:01
the fears and misconceptions that come along
45
109182
3199
02:04
with the idea of moving through the city
46
112381
2903
02:07
without sight,
47
115284
1323
02:08
seemingly oblivious to the environment
48
116607
2961
02:11
and the people around you.
49
119568
2900
02:14
So let me step back and set the stage a little bit.
50
122468
3901
02:18
On St. Patrick's Day of 2008,
51
126369
2559
02:20
I reported to the hospital for surgery
52
128928
2587
02:23
to remove a brain tumor.
53
131515
2194
02:25
The surgery was successful.
54
133709
2087
02:27
Two days later, my sight started to fail.
55
135796
3169
02:30
On the third day, it was gone.
56
138965
3522
02:34
Immediately, I was struck by an incredible sense
57
142487
2097
02:36
of fear, of confusion, of vulnerability,
58
144584
3889
02:40
like anybody would.
59
148473
2449
02:42
But as I had time to stop and think,
60
150922
2492
02:45
I actually started to realize
61
153414
1751
02:47
I had a lot to be grateful for.
62
155165
2924
02:50
In particular, I thought about my dad,
63
158089
2996
02:53
who had passed away from complications
64
161085
2197
02:55
from brain surgery.
65
163282
2103
02:57
He was 36. I was seven at the time.
66
165385
5091
03:02
So although I had every reason
67
170476
2693
03:05
to be fearful of what was ahead,
68
173169
2232
03:07
and had no clue quite what was going to happen,
69
175401
2634
03:10
I was alive.
70
178035
1758
03:11
My son still had his dad.
71
179793
2712
03:14
And besides, it's not like I was the first person
72
182505
1887
03:16
ever to lose their sight.
73
184392
1613
03:18
I knew there had to be all sorts of systems
74
186005
2149
03:20
and techniques and training to have
75
188154
2317
03:22
to live a full and meaningful, active life
76
190471
2562
03:25
without sight.
77
193033
1602
03:26
So by the time I was discharged from the hospital
78
194635
2147
03:28
a few days later, I left with a mission,
79
196782
2704
03:31
a mission to get out and get the best training
80
199486
2130
03:33
as quickly as I could and get on to rebuilding my life.
81
201616
5164
03:38
Within six months, I had returned to work.
82
206780
4048
03:42
My training had started.
83
210828
1602
03:44
I even started riding a tandem bike
84
212430
1660
03:46
with my old cycling buddies,
85
214090
1625
03:47
and was commuting to work on my own,
86
215715
2697
03:50
walking through town and taking the bus.
87
218412
2475
03:52
It was a lot of hard work.
88
220887
2763
03:55
But what I didn't anticipate
89
223650
2267
03:57
through that rapid transition
90
225917
2972
04:00
was the incredible experience of the juxtaposition
91
228889
3748
04:04
of my sighted experience
up against my unsighted experience
up against my unsighted experience
92
232637
3940
04:08
of the same places and the same people
93
236577
2673
04:11
within such a short period of time.
94
239250
3503
04:14
From that came a lot of insights,
95
242753
1896
04:16
or outsights, as I called them,
96
244649
1497
04:18
things that I learned since losing my sight.
97
246146
3389
04:21
These outsights ranged from the trival
98
249535
2967
04:24
to the profound,
99
252502
1665
04:26
from the mundane to the humorous.
100
254167
2568
04:28
As an architect, that stark juxtaposition
101
256735
3017
04:31
of my sighted and unsighted experience
102
259752
2514
04:34
of the same places and the same cities
103
262266
2285
04:36
within such a short period of time
104
264551
2013
04:38
has given me all sorts of wonderful outsights
105
266564
2206
04:40
of the city itself.
106
268770
3174
04:43
Paramount amongst those
107
271944
1874
04:45
was the realization that, actually,
108
273818
1994
04:47
cities are fantastic places for the blind.
109
275812
3940
04:51
And then I was also surprised
110
279752
2321
04:54
by the city's propensity for kindness and care
111
282073
3368
04:57
as opposed to indifference or worse.
112
285441
3480
05:00
And then I started to realize that
113
288921
1763
05:02
it seemed like the blind seemed to have
114
290684
1989
05:04
a positive influence on the city itself.
115
292673
4069
05:08
That was a little curious to me.
116
296742
3254
05:11
Let me step back and take a look
117
299996
2560
05:14
at why the city is so good for the blind.
118
302556
5362
05:19
Inherent with the training for recovery from sight loss
119
307918
3622
05:23
is learning to rely on all your non-visual senses,
120
311540
3871
05:27
things that you would otherwise maybe ignore.
121
315411
3226
05:30
It's like a whole new world of sensory information
122
318637
2545
05:33
opens up to you.
123
321182
1449
05:34
I was really struck by the symphony
124
322631
1528
05:36
of subtle sounds all around me in the city
125
324159
2976
05:39
that you can hear and work with
126
327135
1292
05:40
to understand where you are,
127
328427
1882
05:42
how you need to move, and where you need to go.
128
330309
2805
05:45
Similarly, just through the grip of the cane,
129
333114
2724
05:47
you can feel contrasting textures in the floor below,
130
335838
3914
05:51
and over time you build a pattern of where you are
131
339752
2434
05:54
and where you're headed.
132
342186
1542
05:55
Similarly, just the sun warming one side of your face
133
343728
2892
05:58
or the wind at your neck
134
346620
2829
06:01
gives you clues about your alignment
135
349449
2200
06:03
and your progression through a block
136
351649
1693
06:05
and your movement through time and space.
137
353342
3505
06:08
But also, the sense of smell.
138
356847
2433
06:11
Some districts and cities have their own smell,
139
359280
2701
06:13
as do places and things around you,
140
361981
3041
06:17
and if you're lucky, you can even follow your nose
141
365022
1792
06:18
to that new bakery that you've been looking for.
142
366814
3429
06:22
All this really surprised me,
143
370243
1709
06:23
because I started to realize that
144
371952
3005
06:26
my unsighted experienced
145
374957
2553
06:29
was so far more multi-sensory
146
377510
2435
06:31
than my sighted experience ever was.
147
379945
3025
06:34
What struck me also was how much the city
148
382970
2740
06:37
was changing around me.
149
385710
1632
06:39
When you're sighted,
150
387342
1737
06:41
everybody kind of sticks to themselves,
151
389079
2189
06:43
you mind your own business.
152
391268
1813
06:45
Lose your sight, though,
153
393081
1267
06:46
and it's a whole other story.
154
394348
2799
06:49
And I don't know who's watching who,
155
397147
1479
06:50
but I have a suspicion that
a lot of people are watching me.
a lot of people are watching me.
156
398626
3549
06:54
And I'm not paranoid, but everywhere I go,
157
402175
2148
06:56
I'm getting all sorts of advice:
158
404323
3029
06:59
Go here, move there, watch out for this.
159
407352
2320
07:01
A lot of the information is good.
160
409672
2077
07:03
Some of it's helpful. A lot of it's kind of reversed.
161
411749
2486
07:06
You've got to figure out what they actually meant.
162
414235
3569
07:09
Some of it's kind of wrong and not helpful.
163
417804
3553
07:13
But it's all good in the grand scheme of things.
164
421357
3011
07:16
But one time I was in Oakland
165
424368
1536
07:17
walking along Broadway, and came to a corner.
166
425904
2887
07:20
I was waiting for an audible pedestrian signal,
167
428791
2807
07:23
and as it went off, I was just about
to step out into the street,
to step out into the street,
168
431598
2486
07:26
when all of a sudden, my right hand
169
434084
2032
07:28
was just gripped by this guy,
170
436116
1680
07:29
and he yanked my arm
and pulled me out into the crosswalk
and pulled me out into the crosswalk
171
437796
2412
07:32
and was dragging me out across the street,
172
440208
1674
07:33
speaking to me in Mandarin.
173
441882
2252
07:36
(Laughter)
174
444134
1408
07:37
It's like, there was no escape
from this man's death grip,
from this man's death grip,
175
445542
4139
07:41
but he got me safely there.
176
449681
1723
07:43
What could I do?
177
451404
2350
07:45
But believe me, there are more polite ways
178
453754
1796
07:47
to offer assistance.
179
455550
2173
07:49
We don't know you're there,
180
457723
1522
07:51
so it's kind of nice to say "Hello" first.
181
459245
1980
07:53
"Would you like some help?"
182
461225
2136
07:55
But while in Oakland, I've really been struck by
183
463361
3051
07:58
how much the city of Oakland changed
184
466412
2618
08:01
as I lost my sight.
185
469030
2502
08:03
I liked it sighted. It was fine.
186
471532
2167
08:05
It's a perfectly great city.
187
473699
2576
08:08
But once I lost my sight
188
476275
1269
08:09
and was walking along Broadway,
189
477544
2315
08:11
I was blessed every block of the way.
190
479859
3211
08:15
"Bless you, man."
191
483070
1554
08:16
"Go for it, brother."
192
484624
2263
08:18
"God bless you."
193
486887
1750
08:20
I didn't get that sighted.
194
488637
1860
08:22
(Laughter)
195
490497
1336
08:23
And even without sight,
I don't get that in San Francisco.
I don't get that in San Francisco.
196
491833
6325
08:30
And I know it bothers some of my blind friends,
197
498158
2992
08:33
it's not just me.
198
501150
1593
08:34
Often it's thought that
199
502743
2049
08:36
that's an emotion that comes up out of pity.
200
504792
3144
08:39
I tend to think that it comes
out of our shared humanity,
out of our shared humanity,
201
507936
3113
08:43
out of our togetherness, and I think it's pretty cool.
202
511049
3110
08:46
In fact, if I'm feeling down,
203
514159
1860
08:48
I just go to Broadway in downtown Oakland,
204
516019
1908
08:49
I go for a walk, and I feel better like that,
205
517927
2659
08:52
in no time at all.
206
520586
3271
08:55
But also that it illustrates how
207
523857
2035
08:57
disability and blindness
208
525892
1782
08:59
sort of cuts across ethnic, social,
209
527674
2720
09:02
racial, economic lines.
210
530394
2726
09:05
Disability is an equal-opportunity provider.
211
533120
3835
09:08
Everybody's welcome.
212
536955
2443
09:11
In fact, I've heard it said in the disability community
213
539398
2561
09:13
that there are really only two types of people:
214
541959
2502
09:16
There are those with disabilities,
215
544461
1759
09:18
and there are those that haven't
quite found theirs yet.
quite found theirs yet.
216
546220
4662
09:22
It's a different way of thinking about it,
217
550882
2121
09:25
but I think it's kind of beautiful,
218
553003
2249
09:27
because it is certainly far more inclusive
219
555252
2176
09:29
than the us-versus-them
220
557428
2105
09:31
or the abled-versus-the-disabled,
221
559533
2568
09:34
and it's a lot more honest and respectful
222
562101
2778
09:36
of the fragility of life.
223
564879
3304
09:40
So my final takeaway for you is
224
568183
1925
09:42
that not only is the city good for the blind,
225
570108
4068
09:46
but the city needs us.
226
574176
3179
09:49
And I'm so sure of that that
227
577355
2038
09:51
I want to propose to you today
228
579393
1596
09:52
that the blind be taken as
the prototypical city dwellers
the prototypical city dwellers
229
580989
3440
09:56
when imagining new and wonderful cities,
230
584429
3285
09:59
and not the people that are thought about
231
587714
1861
10:01
after the mold has already been cast.
232
589575
2233
10:03
It's too late then.
233
591808
3053
10:06
So if you design a city with the blind in mind,
234
594861
3184
10:10
you'll have a rich, walkable network of sidewalks
235
598045
4585
10:14
with a dense array of options and choices
236
602630
2114
10:16
all available at the street level.
237
604744
3432
10:20
If you design a city with the blind in mind,
238
608176
2322
10:22
sidewalks will be predictable and will be generous.
239
610498
3120
10:25
The space between buildings will be well-balanced
240
613618
2353
10:27
between people and cars.
241
615971
3439
10:31
In fact, cars, who needs them?
242
619410
4057
10:35
If you're blind, you don't drive. (Laughter)
243
623467
3085
10:38
They don't like it when you drive. (Laughter)
244
626552
3363
10:41
If you design a city with the blind in mind,
245
629915
2710
10:44
you design a city with a robust,
246
632625
2643
10:47
accessible, well-connected mass transit system
247
635268
3692
10:50
that connects all parts of the city
248
638960
1602
10:52
and the region all around.
249
640562
3019
10:55
If you design a city with the blind in mind,
250
643581
2066
10:57
there'll be jobs, lots of jobs.
251
645647
2819
11:00
Blind people want to work too.
252
648466
1330
11:01
They want to earn a living.
253
649796
2439
11:04
So, in designing a city for the blind,
254
652235
2756
11:06
I hope you start to realize
255
654991
2069
11:09
that it actually would be a more inclusive,
256
657060
2878
11:11
a more equitable, a more just city for all.
257
659938
3606
11:15
And based on my prior sighted experience,
258
663544
2220
11:17
it sounds like a pretty cool city,
259
665764
1978
11:19
whether you're blind, whether you have a disability,
260
667742
3347
11:23
or you haven't quite found yours yet.
261
671089
2484
11:25
So thank you.
262
673573
2612
11:28
(Applause)
263
676185
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Chris Downey - ArchitectChris Downey is an architect who lost his sight and gained a new way of seeing the world.
Why you should listen
Chris Downey is an architect, planner, and consultant. Working with design teams and clients, he draws on his unique perspective as a seasoned architect without sight, helping to realize environments that offer not only greater physical accessibility, but also a dimension of delight in architecture experienced through other senses.
Downey enjoyed 20 years of distinguished practice on award-winning custom residences and cultural institutions before losing his sight. One of the few practicing blind architects in the world, Downey has been featured in many media stories and speaks regularly about issues relative to visual impairments and architectural design.
Chris Downey | Speaker | TED.com