TED@BCG San Francisco
Yves Morieux: As work gets more complex, 6 rules to simplify
Filmed:
Readability: 4.7
3,677,731 views
Why do people feel so miserable and disengaged at work? Because today's businesses are increasingly and dizzyingly complex -- and traditional pillars of management are obsolete, says Yves Morieux. So, he says, it falls to individual employees to navigate the rabbit's warren of interdependencies. In this energetic talk, Morieux offers six rules for "smart simplicity." (Rule one: Understand what your colleagues actually do.)
Yves Morieux - Consultant
BCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape. Full bio
BCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I have spent the last years
0
739
2000
00:14
trying to resolve two enigmas:
1
2739
2659
00:17
Why is productivity so disappointing
2
5398
4361
00:21
in all the companies where I work?
3
9759
1882
00:23
I have worked with more than 500 companies.
4
11641
3694
00:27
Despite all the technological advances --
5
15335
2445
00:29
computers, I.T., communications, telecommunications,
6
17780
3292
00:33
the Internet.
7
21072
2361
00:35
Enigma number two:
8
23433
1398
00:37
Why is there so little engagement at work?
9
24831
3032
00:40
Why do people feel so miserable,
10
27863
2104
00:42
even actively disengaged?
11
29967
3650
00:45
Disengaging their colleagues.
12
33617
1524
00:47
Acting against the interest of their company.
13
35141
4731
00:52
Despite all the affiliation events,
14
39872
4104
00:56
the celebration, the people initiatives,
15
43976
3997
01:00
the leadership development programs to train
16
47973
2599
01:02
managers on how to better motivate their teams.
17
50572
4384
01:07
At the beginning, I thought there was
18
54956
1738
01:08
a chicken and egg issue:
19
56694
1969
01:10
Because people are less engaged,
they are less productive.
they are less productive.
20
58663
2552
01:13
Or vice versa, because they are less productive,
21
61215
2237
01:15
we put more pressure and they are less engaged.
22
63452
2191
01:17
But as we were doing our analysis
23
65643
1868
01:19
we realized that there was a common root cause
24
67511
1921
01:21
to these two issues
25
69432
1383
01:23
that relates, in fact, to the basic
pillars of management.
pillars of management.
26
70815
4556
01:27
The way we organize is based on two pillars.
27
75371
3170
01:30
The hard -- structure, processes, systems.
28
78541
2753
01:33
The soft --
29
81294
1224
01:34
feelings, sentiments, interpersonal
relationships, traits, personality.
relationships, traits, personality.
30
82518
5455
01:40
And whenever a company
31
87973
1472
01:41
reorganizes, restructures, reengineers,
32
89445
3710
01:45
goes through a cultural transformation program,
33
93155
2448
01:47
it chooses these two pillars.
34
95603
2030
01:49
Now, we try to refine them,
35
97633
2049
01:51
we try to combine them.
36
99682
1896
01:53
The real issue is --
37
101578
1628
01:55
and this is the answer to the two enigmas --
38
103206
2037
01:57
these pillars are obsolete.
39
105243
2934
02:00
Everything you read in business books is based
40
108177
2682
02:03
either on one or the other
41
110859
1665
02:04
or their combination.
42
112524
1267
02:05
They are obsolete.
43
113791
1314
02:07
How do they work
44
115105
2297
02:09
when you try to use these approaches
45
117402
2287
02:11
in front of the new complexity of business?
46
119689
2148
02:14
The hard approach, basically
is that you start from strategy,
is that you start from strategy,
47
121837
2997
02:17
requirements, structures, processes,
systems, KPIs, scorecards,
systems, KPIs, scorecards,
48
124834
3629
02:20
committees, headquarters, hubs, clusters,
49
128463
2877
02:23
you name it.
50
131340
1110
02:24
I forgot all the metrics, incentives, committees,
middle offices and interfaces.
middle offices and interfaces.
51
132450
5431
02:30
What happens basically on the left,
52
137881
1995
02:32
you have more complexity, the
new complexity of business.
new complexity of business.
53
139876
3264
02:35
We need quality, cost, reliability, speed.
54
143140
4287
02:39
And every time there is a new requirement,
55
147427
2386
02:42
we use the same approach.
56
149813
1479
02:43
We create dedicated structure processed systems,
57
151292
3113
02:46
basically to deal with the
new complexity of business.
new complexity of business.
58
154405
3238
02:49
The hard approach creates just complicatedness
59
157643
3739
02:53
in the organization.
60
161382
1838
02:55
Let's take an example.
61
163220
1578
02:56
An automotive company, the engineering division
62
164798
2896
02:59
is a five-dimensional matrix.
63
167694
1792
03:01
If you open any cell of the matrix,
64
169486
2032
03:03
you find another 20-dimensional matrix.
65
171518
3013
03:06
You have Mr. Noise, Mr. Petrol Consumption,
66
174531
2863
03:09
Mr. Anti-Collision Properties.
67
177394
1958
03:11
For any new requirement,
68
179352
1830
03:13
you have a dedicated function
69
181182
1875
03:15
in charge of aligning engineers against
70
183057
2789
03:18
the new requirement.
71
185846
1548
03:19
What happens when the new
requirement emerges?
requirement emerges?
72
187394
2599
03:22
Some years ago, a new requirement
73
189993
2092
03:24
appeared on the marketplace:
74
192085
1847
03:26
the length of the warranty period.
75
193932
2151
03:28
So therefore the new requirement is repairability,
76
196083
2935
03:31
making cars easy to repair.
77
199018
1500
03:32
Otherwise when you bring the car
to the garage to fix the light,
to the garage to fix the light,
78
200518
4006
03:36
if you have to remove the engine
79
204524
2257
03:38
to access the lights,
80
206781
1329
03:40
the car will have to stay one week in the garage
81
208110
2439
03:42
instead of two hours, and the
warranty budget will explode.
warranty budget will explode.
82
210549
2887
03:45
So, what was the solution using the hard approach?
83
213436
2945
03:48
If repairability is the new requirement,
84
216381
3050
03:51
the solution is to create a new function,
85
219431
2089
03:53
Mr. Repairability.
86
221520
2173
03:55
And Mr. Repairability creates
the repairability process.
the repairability process.
87
223693
3943
03:59
With a repairability scorecard,
with a repairability metric
with a repairability metric
88
227636
3858
04:03
and eventually repairability incentive.
89
231494
2814
04:06
That came on top of 25 other KPIs.
90
234308
3764
04:10
What percentage of these people is variable compensation?
91
238072
3506
04:13
Twenty percent at most, divided by 26 KPIs,
92
241578
3827
04:17
repairability makes a difference of 0.8 percent.
93
245405
4097
04:21
What difference did it make in their actions,
94
249502
2060
04:23
their choices to simplify? Zero.
95
251562
2622
04:26
But what occurs for zero impact?
Mr. Repairability, process,
Mr. Repairability, process,
96
254184
3665
04:30
scorecard, evaluation, coordination
with the 25 other coordinators
with the 25 other coordinators
97
257849
4673
04:34
to have zero impact.
98
262522
1896
04:36
Now, in front of the new complexity of business,
99
264418
2541
04:39
the only solution is not drawing boxes
100
266959
2937
04:42
with reporting lines.
101
269896
2426
04:44
It is basically the interplay.
102
272322
3085
04:47
How the parts work together.
103
275407
2571
04:50
The connections, the interactions, the synapses.
104
277978
4732
04:54
It is not the skeleton of boxes,
it is the nervous system
it is the nervous system
105
282710
4503
04:59
of adaptiveness and intelligence.
106
287213
3037
05:02
You know, you could call it cooperation, basically.
107
290250
2900
05:05
Whenever people cooperate,
108
293150
2539
05:07
they use less resources. In everything.
109
295689
3928
05:11
You know, the repairability issue
110
299617
2532
05:14
is a cooperation problem.
111
302149
2752
05:17
When you design cars, please take into account
112
304901
3221
05:20
the needs of those who will repair the cars
113
308122
2708
05:23
in the after sales garages.
114
310830
3107
05:26
When we don't cooperate we need more time,
115
313937
2617
05:28
more equipment, more systems, more teams.
116
316554
3782
05:32
We need -- When procurement, supply
chain, manufacturing don't cooperate
chain, manufacturing don't cooperate
117
320336
5091
05:37
we need more stock, more inventories,
more working capital.
more working capital.
118
325427
2778
05:40
Who will pay for that?
119
328205
1941
05:42
Shareholders? Customers?
120
330146
1962
05:44
No, they will refuse.
121
332108
1331
05:45
So who is left?
The employees,
The employees,
122
333439
2809
05:48
who have to compensate through their super
123
336248
2708
05:51
individual efforts for the lack of cooperation.
124
338956
3320
05:54
Stress, burnout, they are
overwhelmed, accidents.
overwhelmed, accidents.
125
342276
3668
05:58
No wonder they disengage.
126
345944
2824
06:00
How do the hard and the soft
try to foster cooperation?
try to foster cooperation?
127
348768
3797
06:04
The hard: In banks, when there is a problem
128
352565
4630
06:09
between the back office and the front office,
129
357195
3060
06:12
they don't cooperate. What is the solution?
130
360255
2090
06:14
They create a middle office.
131
362345
3095
06:17
What happens one year later?
132
365440
2036
06:19
Instead of one problem
between the back and the front,
between the back and the front,
133
367476
2008
06:21
now I have two problems.
134
369484
1354
06:23
Between the back and the middle
135
370838
1123
06:24
and between the middle and the front.
136
371961
2216
06:26
Plus I have to pay for the middle office.
137
374177
2465
06:28
The hard approach is unable to foster cooperation.
138
376642
3258
06:32
It can only add new boxes,
new bones in the skeleton.
new bones in the skeleton.
139
379900
4436
06:36
The soft approach:
140
384336
1635
06:38
To make people cooperate, we need
to make them like each other.
to make them like each other.
141
385971
3829
06:42
Improve interpersonal feelings,
142
389800
1694
06:43
the more people like each other,
the more they will cooperate.
the more they will cooperate.
143
391494
2956
06:46
It is totally wrong.
144
394450
1771
06:48
It is even counterproductive.
145
396221
2400
06:50
Look, at home I have two TVs. Why?
146
398621
2416
06:53
Precisely not to have to cooperate with my wife.
147
401037
2872
06:56
(Laughter)
148
403909
1640
06:57
Not to have to impose tradeoffs to my wife.
149
405549
2904
07:00
And why I try not to impose tradeoffs to my wife
150
408453
4010
07:04
is precisely because I love my wife.
151
412463
2667
07:07
If I didn't love my wife, one TV would be enough:
152
415130
3225
07:10
You will watch my favorite football game,
153
418355
2495
07:13
if you are not happy, how is the book or the door?
154
420850
2555
07:15
(Laughter)
155
423405
1203
07:16
The more we like each other,
156
424608
1881
07:18
the more we avoid the real cooperation
157
426489
2613
07:21
that would strain our relationships
by imposing tough tradeoffs.
by imposing tough tradeoffs.
158
429102
4174
07:25
And we go for a second TV or we escalate
159
433276
3007
07:28
the decision above for arbitration.
160
436283
2924
07:31
Definitely, these approaches are obsolete.
161
439207
4709
07:36
To deal with complexity, to enhance the nervous system,
162
443916
3783
07:39
we have created what we call
the smart simplicity approach
the smart simplicity approach
163
447699
3262
07:43
based on simple rules.
164
450961
1520
07:44
Simple rule number one:
165
452481
2262
07:46
Understand what others do.
166
454743
3025
07:49
What is their real work?
167
457768
1897
07:51
We need to go beyond the boxes,
168
459665
3635
07:55
the job descriptions, beyond the surface
169
463300
4018
07:59
of the container, to understand the real content.
170
467318
3505
08:03
Me, designer, if I put a wire here,
171
470823
2708
08:05
I know that it will mean that we will have to
172
473531
2003
08:07
remove the engine to access the lights.
173
475534
2566
08:10
Second, you need to reenforce integrators.
174
478100
2848
08:13
Integrators are not middle
offices, they are managers,
offices, they are managers,
175
480948
3860
08:17
existing managers that you reinforce
176
484808
1761
08:18
so that they have power and interest
177
486569
2434
08:21
to make others cooperate.
178
489003
2163
08:23
How can you reinforce your
managers as integrators?
managers as integrators?
179
491166
3732
08:27
By removing layers.
180
494898
1475
08:28
When there are too many layers
181
496373
1364
08:29
people are too far from the action,
182
497737
1550
08:31
therefore they need KPIs, metrics,
183
499287
2114
08:33
they need poor proxies for reality.
184
501401
4328
08:37
They don't understand reality
185
505729
1602
08:39
and they add the complicatedness of metrics, KPIs.
186
507331
3100
08:42
By removing rules -- the bigger we are,
187
510431
2452
08:45
the more we need integrators,
188
512883
1633
08:46
therefore the less rules we must have,
189
514516
2321
08:49
to give discretionary power to managers.
190
516837
3894
08:52
And we do the opposite --
191
520731
1127
08:54
the bigger we are, the more rules we create.
192
521858
2186
08:56
And we end up with the Encyclopedia
Britannica of rules.
Britannica of rules.
193
524044
3250
08:59
You need to increase the quanitity of power
194
527294
2100
09:01
so that you can empower everybody
195
529394
1728
09:03
to use their judgment, their intelligence.
196
531122
2986
09:06
You must give more cards to people
197
534108
2151
09:08
so that they have the critical mass of cards
198
536259
3357
09:11
to take the risk to cooperate,
199
539616
1959
09:13
to move out of insulation.
200
541575
1755
09:15
Otherwise, they will withdraw. They will disengage.
201
543330
2364
09:17
These rules, they come from game theory
202
545694
2246
09:20
and organizational sociology.
203
547940
2228
09:22
You can increase the shadow of the future.
204
550168
2852
09:25
Create feedback loops that expose people
205
553020
2901
09:28
to the consequences of their actions.
206
555921
2601
09:30
This is what the automotive company did
207
558522
1944
09:32
when they saw that Mr. Repairability had no impact.
208
560466
2790
09:35
They said to the design engineers:
209
563256
1635
09:37
Now, in three years, when the new
car is launched on the market,
car is launched on the market,
210
564891
4695
09:41
you will move to the after sales
network, and become in charge
network, and become in charge
211
569586
2944
09:44
of the warranty budget,
212
572530
2375
09:47
and if the warranty budget explodes,
213
574905
3379
09:50
it will explode in your face. (Laughter)
214
578284
2667
09:53
Much more powerful than 0.8
percent variable compensation.
percent variable compensation.
215
580951
5941
09:59
You need also to increase reciprocity,
216
586892
3722
10:02
by removing the buffers that make us self-sufficient.
217
590614
3715
10:06
When you remove these buffers,
218
594329
2472
10:09
you hold me by the nose, I hold you by the ear.
219
596801
2997
10:11
We will cooperate.
220
599798
1382
10:13
Remove the second TV.
221
601180
1540
10:14
There are many second TVs at work
222
602720
2244
10:17
that don't create value,
223
604964
1301
10:18
they just provide dysfunctional self-sufficiency.
224
606265
4688
10:23
You need to reward those who cooperate
225
610953
2429
10:25
and blame those who don't cooperate.
226
613382
1679
10:27
The CEO of The Lego Group,
227
615061
3069
10:30
Jorgen Vig Knudstorp, has a great way to use it.
228
618130
2823
10:33
He says, blame is not for failure,
229
620953
2905
10:36
it is for failing to help or ask for help.
230
623858
4535
10:40
It changes everything.
231
628393
2379
10:42
Suddenly it becomes in my
interest to be transparent
interest to be transparent
232
630772
2520
10:45
on my real weaknesses, my real forecast,
233
633292
2040
10:47
because I know I will not be blamed if I fail,
234
635332
2086
10:49
but if I fail to help or ask for help.
235
637418
3868
10:53
When you do this, it has a lot of implications
236
641286
2927
10:56
on organizational design.
237
644213
2945
10:59
You stop drawing boxes, dotted lines, full lines;
238
647158
2418
11:01
you look at their interplay.
239
649576
1390
11:03
It has a lot of implications on financial policies
240
650966
2979
11:06
that we use.
241
653945
1214
11:07
On human resource management practices.
242
655159
2622
11:09
When you do that, you can manage complexity,
243
657781
2424
11:12
the new complexity of business,
244
660205
1593
11:13
without getting complicated.
245
661798
2933
11:16
You create more value with lower cost.
246
664731
3650
11:20
You simultaneously improve
performance and satisfaction at work
performance and satisfaction at work
247
668381
4574
11:25
because you have removed the common root cause
248
672955
2729
11:27
that hinders both.
249
675684
1616
11:29
Complicatedness: This is your
battle, business leaders.
battle, business leaders.
250
677300
4710
11:34
The real battle is not against competitors.
251
682010
2827
11:37
This is rubbish, very abstract.
252
684837
2421
11:39
When do we meet competitors to fight them?
253
687258
2663
11:42
The real battle is against ourselves,
254
689921
2901
11:45
against our bureaucracy, our complicatedness.
255
692822
3354
11:48
Only you can fight, can do it.
256
696176
3157
11:51
Thank you.
257
699333
2087
11:53
(Applause)
258
701420
2692
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Yves Morieux - ConsultantBCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape.
Why you should listen
Yves Morieux thinks deeply about what makes organizations work effectively. A senior partner in BCG’s Washington D.C. office and director of the BCG Institute for Organization, Morieux considers how overarching changes in structure can improve motivation for all who work there. His calls his approach "Smart Simplicity." Using six key rules, it encourages employees to cooperate in order to solve long-term problems. It isn’t just about reducing costs and increasing profit -- it’s about maximizing engagement through all levels of a company. Morieux has been featured in articles on organizational evolution in Harvard Business Review, The Economist, The Wall Street Journal, Fast Company and Le Monde.
Yves Morieux | Speaker | TED.com