ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Emma Marris - Environmental writer
Emma Marris is a writer focusing on environmental science, policy and culture, with an approach that she paints as being "more interested in finding and describing solutions than delineating problems, and more interested in joy than despair."

Why you should listen

Emma Marris has written among others for Nature, Discover and the New York Times. She challenges the notion that nature can only be preserved in its pristine, pre-human state, a too-narrow characterization "that thwarts bold new plans to save the environment and prevents us from having a fuller relationship with nature." Humans have changed the landscape they inhabit since prehistory, and climate change means even the remotest places now bear the fingerprints of humanity. In her book Rambunctious Garden: Saving Nature in the Post-Wild World, she argues that we need different strategies for saving nature and champions a blurring of the lines between nature and people for a responsible care of our humanized planet.

More profile about the speaker
Emma Marris | Speaker | TED.com
TEDSummit

Emma Marris: Nature is everywhere -- we just need to learn to see it

Filmed:
1,313,413 views

How do you define "nature?" If we define it as that which is untouched by humans, then we won't have any left, says environmental writer Emma Marris. She urges us to consider a new definition of nature -- one that includes not only pristine wilderness but also the untended patches of plants growing in urban spaces -- and encourages us to bring our children out to touch and tinker with it, so that one day they might love and protect it.
- Environmental writer
Emma Marris is a writer focusing on environmental science, policy and culture, with an approach that she paints as being "more interested in finding and describing solutions than delineating problems, and more interested in joy than despair." Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
We are stealing nature from our children.
0
560
3280
00:16
Now, when I say this, I don't mean
that we are destroying nature
1
4840
3056
00:19
that they will have wanted us to preserve,
2
7920
2376
00:22
although that is
unfortunately also the case.
3
10320
2656
00:25
What I mean here is that we've started
to define nature in a way
4
13000
3816
00:28
that's so purist and so strict
5
16840
3016
00:31
that under the definition
we're creating for ourselves,
6
19880
2736
00:34
there won't be any nature
left for our children
7
22640
2376
00:37
when they're adults.
8
25040
1200
00:39
But there's a fix for this.
9
27120
2536
00:41
So let me explain.
10
29680
1240
00:43
Right now, humans use half of the world
11
31680
3456
00:47
to live, to grow their crops
and their timber,
12
35160
2696
00:49
to pasture their animals.
13
37880
1896
00:51
If you added up all the human beings,
14
39800
1816
00:53
we would weigh 10 times as much
as all the wild mammals put together.
15
41640
4240
00:58
We cut roads through the forest.
16
46800
2320
01:01
We have added little plastic particles
to the sand on ocean beaches.
17
49680
4336
01:06
We've changed the chemistry of the soil
with our artificial fertilizers.
18
54040
5096
01:11
And of course, we've changed
the chemistry of the air.
19
59160
3216
01:14
So when you take your next breath,
20
62400
1856
01:16
you'll be breathing in
42 percent more carbon dioxide
21
64280
3856
01:20
than if you were breathing in 1750.
22
68160
2200
01:23
So all of these changes, and many others,
23
71280
2456
01:25
have come to be kind of lumped together
under this rubric of the "Anthropocene."
24
73760
4080
01:30
And this is a term
that some geologists are suggesting
25
78480
2536
01:33
we should give to our current epoch,
26
81040
1816
01:34
given how pervasive
human influence has been over it.
27
82880
2760
01:38
Now, it's still just a proposed epoch,
but I think it's a helpful way
28
86320
3856
01:42
to think about the magnitude
of human influence on the planet.
29
90200
3680
01:46
So where does this put nature?
30
94800
1696
01:48
What counts as nature in a world
where everything is influenced by humans?
31
96520
3720
01:53
So 25 years ago, environmental writer
Bill McKibben said
32
101400
4176
01:57
that because nature
was a thing apart from man
33
105600
4496
02:02
and because climate change meant
34
110120
1576
02:03
that every centimeter of the Earth
was altered by man,
35
111720
3616
02:07
then nature was over.
36
115360
2096
02:09
In fact, he called his book
"The End of Nature."
37
117480
2360
02:14
I disagree with this.
I just disagree with this.
38
122000
2256
02:16
I disagree with this definition of nature,
because, fundamentally, we are animals.
39
124280
4336
02:20
Right? Like, we evolved on this planet
40
128639
2817
02:23
in the context of all the other animals
with which we share a planet,
41
131480
4096
02:27
and all the other plants,
and all the other microbes.
42
135600
2576
02:30
And so I think that nature
43
138200
2296
02:32
is not that which is untouched
by humanity, man or woman.
44
140520
4056
02:36
I think that nature
is anywhere where life thrives,
45
144600
4136
02:40
anywhere where there are
multiple species together,
46
148760
3016
02:43
anywhere that's green and blue
and thriving and filled with life
47
151800
3216
02:47
and growing.
48
155040
1200
02:49
And under that definition,
49
157600
1896
02:51
things look a little bit different.
50
159520
2536
02:54
Now, I understand that there
are certain parts of this nature
51
162080
3696
02:57
that speak to us in a special way.
52
165800
2616
03:00
Places like Yellowstone,
53
168440
1656
03:02
or the Mongolian steppe,
54
170120
1696
03:03
or the Great Barrier Reef
55
171840
1336
03:05
or the Serengeti.
56
173200
1496
03:06
Places that we think of
as kind of Edenic representations
57
174720
4016
03:10
of a nature before
we screwed everything up.
58
178760
2600
03:14
And in a way, they are less impacted
by our day to day activities.
59
182560
4016
03:18
Many of these places
have no roads or few roads,
60
186600
2696
03:21
so on, like such.
61
189320
1576
03:22
But ultimately, even these Edens
are deeply influenced by humans.
62
190920
5776
03:28
Now, let's just take
North America, for example,
63
196720
2256
03:31
since that's where we're meeting.
64
199000
1616
03:32
So between about 15,000 years ago
when people first came here,
65
200640
3416
03:36
they started a process
of interacting with the nature
66
204080
2496
03:38
that led to the extinction
of a big slew of large-bodied animals,
67
206600
4376
03:43
from the mastodon
to the giant ground sloth,
68
211000
2256
03:45
saber-toothed cats,
69
213280
1256
03:46
all of these cool animals
that unfortunately are no longer with us.
70
214560
3616
03:50
And when those animals went extinct,
71
218200
1816
03:52
you know, the ecosystems
didn't stand still.
72
220040
2576
03:54
Massive ripple effects
changed grasslands into forests,
73
222640
3616
03:58
changed the composition of forest
from one tree to another.
74
226280
2800
04:02
So even in these Edens,
75
230000
1656
04:03
even in these perfect-looking places
76
231680
1816
04:05
that seem to remind us
of a past before humans,
77
233520
3496
04:09
we're essentially looking
at a humanized landscape.
78
237040
3080
04:12
Not just these prehistoric humans,
but historical humans, indigenous people
79
240960
3576
04:16
all the way up until the moment
when the first colonizers showed up.
80
244560
3240
04:20
And the case is the same
for the other continents as well.
81
248480
2776
04:23
Humans have just been involved in nature
82
251280
2816
04:26
in a very influential way
for a very long time.
83
254120
2880
04:30
Now, just recently, someone told me,
84
258440
1776
04:32
"Oh, but there are still wild places."
85
260240
1856
04:34
And I said, "Where? Where? I want to go."
86
262120
2216
04:36
And he said, "The Amazon."
87
264360
1896
04:38
And I was like, "Oh, the Amazon.
I was just there.
88
266280
3456
04:41
It's awesome. National Geographic
sent me to Manú National Park,
89
269760
3136
04:44
which is in the Peruvian Amazon,
90
272920
1576
04:46
but it's a big chunk of rainforest,
uncleared, no roads,
91
274520
3656
04:50
protected as a national park,
92
278200
1616
04:51
one of the most, in fact,
biodiverse parks in the world.
93
279840
2696
04:54
And when I got in there with my canoe,
what did I find, but people.
94
282560
4120
04:59
People have been living there
for hundreds and thousands of years.
95
287640
3816
05:03
People live there, and they don't
just float over the jungle.
96
291480
2856
05:06
They have a meaningful relationship
with the landscape.
97
294360
2600
05:09
They hunt. They grow crops.
98
297480
2296
05:11
They domesticate crops.
99
299800
1496
05:13
They use the natural resources
to build their houses,
100
301320
2896
05:16
to thatch their houses.
101
304240
1256
05:17
They even make pets out of animals
that we consider to be wild animals.
102
305520
4016
05:21
These people are there
103
309560
2096
05:23
and they're interacting
with the environment
104
311680
2096
05:25
in a way that's really meaningful
and that you can see in the environment.
105
313800
3496
05:29
Now, I was with
an anthropologist on this trip,
106
317320
2216
05:31
and he told me, as we were
floating down the river,
107
319560
2856
05:34
he said, "There are
no demographic voids in the Amazon."
108
322440
4656
05:39
This statement has really stuck with me,
109
327120
1936
05:41
because what it means
is that the whole Amazon is like this.
110
329080
2856
05:43
There's people everywhere.
111
331960
1280
05:45
And many other
tropical forests are the same,
112
333880
2336
05:48
and not just tropical forests.
113
336240
1576
05:49
People have influenced
ecosystems in the past,
114
337840
3216
05:53
and they continue
to influence them in the present,
115
341080
2776
05:55
even in places where
they're harder to notice.
116
343880
3160
05:59
So, if all of the definitions of nature
that we might want to use
117
347720
5216
06:04
that involve it being
untouched by humanity
118
352960
2976
06:07
or not having people in it,
119
355960
1336
06:09
if all of those actually give us
a result where we don't have any nature,
120
357320
5336
06:14
then maybe they're the wrong definitions.
121
362680
2416
06:17
Maybe we should define it
by the presence of multiple species,
122
365120
3496
06:20
by the presence of a thriving life.
123
368640
2040
06:23
Now, if we do it that way,
124
371440
2016
06:25
what do we get?
125
373480
1456
06:26
Well, it's this kind of miracle.
126
374960
2376
06:29
All of a sudden,
there's nature all around us.
127
377360
2280
06:32
All of a sudden,
we see this Monarch caterpillar
128
380160
2696
06:34
munching on this plant,
129
382880
1856
06:36
and we realize that there it is,
130
384760
1816
06:38
and it's in this empty lot in Chattanooga.
131
386600
2800
06:42
And look at this empty lot.
132
390320
1336
06:43
I mean, there's, like, probably,
133
391680
1776
06:45
a dozen, minimum,
plant species growing there,
134
393480
2936
06:48
supporting all kinds of insect life,
135
396440
2256
06:50
and this is a completely unmanaged space,
a completely wild space.
136
398720
4336
06:55
This is a kind of wild nature
right under our nose,
137
403080
2976
06:58
that we don't even notice.
138
406080
1480
07:00
And there's an interesting
little paradox, too.
139
408760
2216
07:03
So this nature,
140
411000
1816
07:04
this kind of wild, untended part
141
412840
2656
07:07
of our urban, peri-urban,
suburban agricultural existence
142
415520
3776
07:11
that flies under the radar,
143
419320
2376
07:13
it's arguably more wild
than a national park,
144
421720
3680
07:18
because national parks
are very carefully managed
145
426160
2416
07:20
in the 21st century.
146
428600
1736
07:22
Crater Lake in southern Oregon,
which is my closest national park,
147
430360
3576
07:25
is a beautiful example of a landscape
that seems to be coming out of the past.
148
433960
5176
07:31
But they're managing it carefully.
149
439160
1736
07:32
One of the issues they have now
is white bark pine die-off.
150
440920
3576
07:36
White bark pine
is a beautiful, charismatic --
151
444520
2496
07:39
I'll say it's a charismatic megaflora
152
447040
3016
07:42
that grows up at high altitude --
153
450080
1656
07:43
and it's got all these problems
right now with disease.
154
451760
2976
07:46
There's a blister rust
that was introduced,
155
454760
2136
07:48
bark beetle.
156
456920
1496
07:50
So to deal with this,
the park service has been planting
157
458440
3576
07:54
rust-resistant white bark
pine seedlings in the park,
158
462040
3720
07:58
even in areas that they are
otherwise managing as wilderness.
159
466560
3040
08:02
And they're also putting out
beetle repellent in key areas
160
470200
2816
08:05
as I saw last time I went hiking there.
161
473040
1880
08:07
And this kind of thing is really
much more common than you would think.
162
475640
3336
08:11
National parks are heavily managed.
163
479000
1696
08:12
The wildlife is kept to a certain
population size and structure.
164
480720
3056
08:15
Fires are suppressed.
165
483800
1536
08:17
Fires are started.
166
485360
1296
08:18
Non-native species are removed.
167
486680
2176
08:20
Native species are reintroduced.
168
488880
1696
08:22
And in fact, I took a look,
169
490600
1336
08:23
and Banff National Park
is doing all of the things I just listed:
170
491960
3056
08:27
suppressing fire, having fire,
171
495040
1456
08:28
radio-collaring wolves,
reintroducing bison.
172
496520
2216
08:30
It takes a lot of work to make
these places look untouched.
173
498760
3216
08:34
(Laughter)
174
502000
3056
08:37
(Applause)
175
505080
3400
08:43
And in a further irony,
these places that we love the most
176
511080
4455
08:47
are the places that we love
a little too hard, sometimes.
177
515559
2697
08:50
A lot of us like to go there,
178
518280
1416
08:51
and because we're managing
them to be stable
179
519720
2536
08:54
in the face of a changing planet,
180
522280
2056
08:56
they often are becoming
more fragile over time.
181
524360
2400
08:59
Which means that they're
the absolute worst places
182
527440
2456
09:01
to take your children on vacation,
183
529920
1936
09:03
because you can't do anything there.
184
531880
1896
09:05
You can't climb the trees.
185
533800
1296
09:07
You can't fish the fish.
186
535120
1216
09:08
You can't make a campfire
out in the middle of nowhere.
187
536360
2616
09:11
You can't take home the pinecones.
188
539000
1656
09:12
There are so many rules and restrictions
189
540680
1905
09:14
that from a child's point of view,
190
542609
1967
09:16
this is, like, the worst nature ever.
191
544600
1800
09:19
Because children don't want to hike
192
547320
2616
09:21
through a beautiful landscape
for five hours
193
549960
2336
09:24
and then look at a beautiful view.
194
552320
1856
09:26
That's maybe what we want to do as adults,
195
554200
2000
09:28
but what kids want to do
is hunker down in one spot
196
556224
2912
09:31
and just tinker with it,
just work with it,
197
559160
2216
09:33
just pick it up, build a house,
build a fort, do something like that.
198
561400
3560
09:38
Additionally, these sort of Edenic places
199
566160
2536
09:40
are often distant from where people live.
200
568720
3256
09:44
And they're expensive to get to.
They're hard to visit.
201
572000
2936
09:46
So this means that they're
only available to the elites,
202
574960
2776
09:49
and that's a real problem.
203
577760
1600
09:53
The Nature Conservancy
did a survey of young people,
204
581000
3376
09:56
and they asked them, how often
do you spend time outdoors?
205
584400
3200
10:00
And only two out of five
spent time outdoors
206
588120
2536
10:02
at least once a week.
207
590680
1216
10:03
The other three out of five
were just staying inside.
208
591920
3016
10:06
And when they asked them why,
what are the barriers to going outside,
209
594960
4096
10:11
the response of 61 percent was,
210
599080
2976
10:14
"There are no natural areas near my home."
211
602080
3080
10:18
And this is crazy.
This is just patently false.
212
606200
3696
10:21
I mean, 71 percent of people in the US
213
609920
2976
10:24
live within a 10-minute walk
of a city park.
214
612920
2776
10:27
And I'm sure the figures
are similar in other countries.
215
615720
2656
10:30
And that doesn't even count
your back garden,
216
618400
2136
10:32
the urban creek, the empty lot.
217
620560
1960
10:35
Everybody lives near nature.
218
623160
1896
10:37
Every kid lives near nature.
219
625080
2656
10:39
We've just somehow
forgotten how to see it.
220
627760
2056
10:41
We've spent too much time
watching David Attenborough documentaries
221
629840
3176
10:45
where the nature is really sexy --
222
633040
1656
10:46
(Laughter)
223
634720
1016
10:47
and we've forgotten how to see the nature
that is literally right outside our door,
224
635760
3936
10:51
the nature of the street tree.
225
639720
1936
10:53
So here's an example: Philadelphia.
226
641680
2776
10:56
There's this cool elevated railway
227
644480
2376
10:58
that you can see from the ground,
that's been abandoned.
228
646880
2416
11:01
Now, this may sound like the beginning
of the High Line story in Manhattan,
229
649320
3416
11:04
and it's very similar, except they haven't
developed this into a park yet,
230
652760
3296
11:08
although they're working on it.
231
656080
1536
11:09
So for now, it's still this little
sort of secret wilderness
232
657640
3176
11:12
in the heart of Philadelphia,
233
660840
1416
11:14
and if you know where the hole is
in the chain-link fence,
234
662280
3096
11:17
you can scramble up to the top
235
665400
2056
11:19
and you can find this
completely wild meadow
236
667480
2816
11:22
just floating above
the city of Philadelphia.
237
670320
2160
11:25
Every single one of these plants
grew from a seed
238
673200
2336
11:27
that planted itself there.
239
675560
1336
11:28
This is completely autonomous,
self-willed nature.
240
676920
2936
11:31
And it's right in the middle of the city.
241
679880
2256
11:34
And they've sent people up there
to do sort of biosurveys,
242
682160
3216
11:37
and there are over 50
plant species up there.
243
685400
2440
11:40
And it's not just plants.
244
688560
1256
11:41
This is an ecosystem,
a functioning ecosystem.
245
689840
3496
11:45
It's creating soil.
It's sequestering carbon.
246
693360
2456
11:47
There's pollination going on.
247
695840
1896
11:49
I mean, this is really an ecosystem.
248
697760
1960
11:53
So scientists have started calling
ecosystems like these "novel ecosystems,"
249
701400
3856
11:57
because they're often
dominated by non-native species,
250
705280
2576
11:59
and because they're just super weird.
251
707880
1736
12:01
They're just unlike anything
we've ever seen before.
252
709640
2456
12:04
For so long, we dismissed
all these novel ecosystems as trash.
253
712120
4016
12:08
We're talking about
regrown agricultural fields,
254
716160
2416
12:10
timber plantations that are not
being managed on a day-to-day basis,
255
718600
3576
12:14
second-growth forests generally,
the entire East Coast,
256
722200
2656
12:16
where after agriculture moved west,
the forest sprung up.
257
724880
4136
12:21
And of course, pretty much all of Hawaii,
258
729040
2616
12:23
where novel ecosystems are the norm,
259
731680
2816
12:26
where exotic species totally dominate.
260
734520
2576
12:29
This forest here has Queensland maple,
261
737120
2416
12:31
it has sword ferns from Southeast Asia.
262
739560
2840
12:35
You can make your own
novel ecosystem, too.
263
743160
2056
12:37
It's really simple.
264
745240
1216
12:38
You just stop mowing your lawn.
265
746480
1496
12:40
(Laughter)
266
748000
1576
12:41
Ilkka Hanski was an ecologist in Finland,
and he did this experiment himself.
267
749600
3696
12:45
He just stopped mowing his lawn,
268
753320
1576
12:46
and after a few years,
he had some grad students come,
269
754920
2536
12:49
and they did sort of
a bio-blitz of his backyard,
270
757480
2496
12:52
and they found 375 plant species,
271
760000
4256
12:56
including two endangered species.
272
764280
2120
12:59
So when you're up there
on that future High Line of Philadelphia,
273
767560
6456
13:06
surrounded by this wildness,
274
774040
1816
13:07
surrounded by this diversity,
this abundance, this vibrance,
275
775880
3776
13:11
you can look over the side
276
779680
1256
13:12
and you can see a local playground
for a local school,
277
780960
3256
13:16
and that's what it looks like.
278
784240
1936
13:18
These children have, that --
279
786200
2016
13:20
You know, under my definition,
280
788240
1456
13:21
there's a lot of the planet
that counts as nature,
281
789720
2376
13:24
but this would be one of the few places
that wouldn't count as nature.
282
792120
3336
13:27
There's nothing there except humans,
no other plants, no other animals.
283
795480
3376
13:30
And what I really wanted to do
284
798880
1456
13:32
was just, like,
throw a ladder over the side
285
800360
2096
13:34
and get all these kids to come up with me
into this cool meadow.
286
802480
3536
13:38
In a way, I feel like this is
the choice that faces us.
287
806040
3296
13:41
If we dismiss these new natures
as not acceptable or trashy or no good,
288
809360
4600
13:47
we might as well just pave them over.
289
815040
2576
13:49
And in a world where
everything is changing,
290
817640
2536
13:52
we need to be very careful
about how we define nature.
291
820200
2800
13:55
In order not to steal it
from our children,
292
823800
2056
13:57
we have to do two things.
293
825880
1936
13:59
First, we cannot define nature
as that which is untouched.
294
827840
3840
14:04
This never made any sense anyway.
295
832360
1576
14:05
Nature has not been untouched
for thousands of years.
296
833960
2496
14:08
And it excludes most of the nature
that most people can visit
297
836480
3816
14:12
and have a relationship with,
298
840320
1976
14:14
including only nature
that children cannot touch.
299
842320
3400
14:18
Which brings me to the second thing
that we have to do,
300
846360
2616
14:21
which is that we have to
let children touch nature,
301
849000
2496
14:23
because that which
is untouched is unloved.
302
851520
2496
14:26
(Applause)
303
854040
2960
14:35
We face some pretty grim
environmental challenges on this planet.
304
863400
3736
14:39
Climate change is among them.
305
867160
1536
14:40
There's others too:
habitat loss is my favorite thing
306
868720
2496
14:43
to freak out about
in the middle of the night.
307
871240
2696
14:45
But in order to solve them,
308
873960
1336
14:47
we need people --
smart, dedicated people --
309
875320
2736
14:50
who care about nature.
310
878080
1776
14:51
And the only way we're going to raise up
a generation of people
311
879880
2976
14:54
who care about nature
312
882880
1216
14:56
is by letting them touch nature.
313
884120
2176
14:58
I have a Fort Theory of Ecology,
314
886320
2296
15:00
Fort Theory of Conservation.
315
888640
1896
15:02
Every ecologist I know,
every conservation biologist I know,
316
890560
3216
15:05
every conservation professional I know,
317
893800
1896
15:07
built forts when they were kids.
318
895720
2200
15:10
If we have a generation
that doesn't know how to build a fort,
319
898840
2936
15:13
we'll have a generation that doesn't
know how to care about nature.
320
901800
3176
15:17
And I don't want
to be the one to tell this kid,
321
905000
2256
15:19
who is on a special program
322
907280
1336
15:20
that takes Philadelphia kids
from poor neighborhoods
323
908640
2456
15:23
and takes them to city parks,
324
911120
1416
15:24
I don't want to be the one to tell him
that the flower he's holding
325
912560
3176
15:27
is a non-native invasive weed
that he should throw away as trash.
326
915760
3080
15:31
I think I would much rather
learn from this boy
327
919760
3176
15:34
that no matter
where this plant comes from,
328
922960
2656
15:37
it is beautiful, and it deserves
to be touched and appreciated.
329
925640
4176
15:41
Thank you.
330
929840
1216
15:43
(Applause)
331
931080
8190

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Emma Marris - Environmental writer
Emma Marris is a writer focusing on environmental science, policy and culture, with an approach that she paints as being "more interested in finding and describing solutions than delineating problems, and more interested in joy than despair."

Why you should listen

Emma Marris has written among others for Nature, Discover and the New York Times. She challenges the notion that nature can only be preserved in its pristine, pre-human state, a too-narrow characterization "that thwarts bold new plans to save the environment and prevents us from having a fuller relationship with nature." Humans have changed the landscape they inhabit since prehistory, and climate change means even the remotest places now bear the fingerprints of humanity. In her book Rambunctious Garden: Saving Nature in the Post-Wild World, she argues that we need different strategies for saving nature and champions a blurring of the lines between nature and people for a responsible care of our humanized planet.

More profile about the speaker
Emma Marris | Speaker | TED.com