Jake Barton: The museum of you
May 16, 2013
A third of the world watched live as the World Trade Center collapsed on September 11, 2001; a third more heard about it within 24 hours. (Do you remember where you were?) So exhibits at the soon-to-open 9/11 Memorial Museum will reflect the diversity of the world's experiences of that day. In a moving talk, designer Jake Barton gives a peek at some of those installations, as well as several other projects that aim to make the observer an active participant in the exhibit.Jake Barton
- Designer and storyteller
Principal of the New York media design firm, Local Projects, Jake Barton creates interactive and digital exhibits for the likes of the 9/11 Memorial Museum, Cleveland Museum of Art and Storycorps. Full bio
Double-click the English subtitles below to play the video.
This is Charley Williams.
He was 94 when this photograph was taken.
In the 1930s, Roosevelt put
thousands and thousands of Americans back to work
by building bridges and infrastructure and tunnels,
but he also did something interesting,
which was to hire a few hundred writers
to scour America to capture the stories of ordinary Americans.
Charley Williams, a poor sharecropper,
wouldn't ordinarily be the subject of a big interview,
but Charley had actually been a slave
until he was 22 years old.
And the stories that were captured of his life
make up one of the crown jewels
of histories, of human-lived experiences
filled with ex-slaves.
Anna Deavere Smith famously said that
there's a literature inside of each of us,
and three generations later, I was part of a project
which set out to capture
the stories of ordinary Americans
by setting up a soundproof booth in public spaces.
The idea is very, very simple.
You go into these booths, you interview your grandmother
or relative, you leave with a copy of the interview
and an interview goes into the Library of Congress.
It's essentially a way to make a national oral histories archive
one conversation at a time.
And the question is, who do you want to remember --
if you had just 45 minutes with your grandmother?
What's interesting, in conversations with the founder, Dave Isay,
we always actually talked about this
as a little bit of a subversive project,
because when you think about it,
it's actually not really about the stories that are being told,
it's about listening,
and it's about the questions that you get to ask,
questions that you may not have permission to
on any other day.
I'm going to play you just a couple of quick excerpts from the project.
[Jesus Melendez talking about poet Pedro Pietri's final moments]
Jesus Melendez: We took off, and as we were ascending,
before we had leveled off,
our level-off point was 45,000 feet,
so before we had leveled off,
Pedro began leaving us,
and the beauty about it
is that I believe that there's something after life.
You can see it in Pedro.
[Danny Perasa to his wife Annie Perasa married 26 years]
Danny Perasa: See, the thing of it is,
I always feel guilty when I say "I love you" to you,
and I say it so often. I say it to remind you
that as dumpy as I am, it's coming from me,
it's like hearing a beautiful song from a busted old radio,
and it's nice of you to keep the radio around the house.
[Michael Wolmetz with his girlfriend Debora Brakarz]
Michael Wolmetz: So this is the ring that my father gave to my mother,
and we can leave it there.
And he saved up and he purchased this,
and he proposed to my mother with this,
and so I thought that I would give it to you
so that he could be with us for this also.
So I'm going to share a mic with you right now, Debora.
Where's the right finger?
Debora Brakarz: (Crying)
MW: Debora, will you please marry me?
DB: Yes. Of course. I love you.
MW: So kids, this is how your mother and I got married,
in a booth in Grand Central Station with my father's ring.
My grandfather was a cab driver for 40 years.
He used to pick people up here every day.
So it seems right.
Jake Barton: So I have to say
I did not actually choose those individual samples to make you cry
because they all make you cry.
The entire project is predicated on this act of love
which is listening itself.
And that motion of building an institution
out of a moment of conversation and listening
is actually a lot of what my firm, Local Projects,
is doing with our engagements in general.
So we're a media design firm, and we're working
with a broad array of different institutions
building media installations for museums and public spaces.
Our latest engagement is the Cleveland Museum of Art,
which we've created an engagement called Gallery One for.
And Gallery One is an interesting project
because it started with this massive, $350 million expansion
for the Cleveland Museum of Art,
and we actually brought in this piece
specifically to grow new capacity, new audiences,
at the same time that the museum itself is growing.
Glenn Lowry, the head of MoMA, put it best when he said,
"We want visitors to actually cease being visitors.
Visitors are transient. We want people who live here,
people who have ownership."
And so what we're doing is making a broad array
of different ways for people to actually engage
with the material inside of these galleries,
so you can still have a traditional gallery experience,
but if you're interested, you can actually engage
with any individual artwork and see the original context
from where it's from, or manipulate the work itself.
So, for example, you can click on this individual lion head,
and this is where it originated from, 1300 B.C.
Or this individual piece here,
you can see the actual bedroom. It really changes the way
you think about this type of a tempera painting.
This is one of my favorites because you see the studio itself.
This is Rodin's bust. You get the sense
of this incredible factory for creativity.
And it makes you think about literally the hundreds
or thousands of years of human creativity and how
each individual artwork stands in for part of that story.
This is Picasso,
of course embodying so much of it from the 20th century.
And so our next interface, which I'll show you,
actually leverages that idea of this lineage of creativity.
It's an algorithm that actually allows you to browse
the actual museum's collection using facial recognition.
So this person's making different faces,
and it's actually drawing forth different objects
from the collection that connect with exactly how she's looking.
And so you can imagine that, as people are performing
inside of the museum itself, you get this sense
of this emotional connection,
this way in which our face connects with the thousands
and tens of thousands of years.
This is an interface that actually allows you to draw
and then draws forth objects using those same shapes.
So more and more we're trying to find ways
for people to actually author things inside of the museums themselves,
to be creative even as they're looking
at other people's creativity and understanding them.
So in this wall, the collections wall,
you can actually see all 3,000 artworks all at the same time,
and you can actually author your own
individual walking tours of the museum, so you can share them,
and someone can take a tour with the museum director
or a tour with their little cousin.
But all the while that we've been working
on this engagement for Cleveland,
we've also been working in the background
on really our largest engagement to date,
and that's the 9/11 Memorial and Museum.
So we started in 2006
as part of a team with Thinc Design
to create the original master plan for the museum,
and then we've done all the media design
both for the museum and the memorial and then the media production.
So the memorial opened in 2011,
and the museum's going to open next year in 2014.
And you can see from these images,
the site is so raw and almost archaeological.
And of course the event itself is so recent,
somewhere between history and current events,
it was a huge challenge to imagine
how do you actually live up to a space like this,
an event like this, to actually tell that story.
And so what we started with
was really a new way of thinking about building an institution,
through a project called Make History,
which we launched in 2009.
So it's estimated that a third of the world
watched 9/11 live,
and a third of the world
heard about it within 24 hours,
making it really by nature of when it happened,
this unprecedented moment of global awareness.
And so we launched this to capture the stories
from all around the world,
through video, through photos,
through written history,
and so people's experiences on that day,
which was, in fact, this huge risk for the institution
to make its first move this open platform.
But that was coupled together with this oral histories booth,
really the simplest we've ever made,
where you locate yourself on a map.
It's in six languages, and you can tell your own story
about what happened to you on that day.
And when we started seeing the incredible images
and stories that came forth
from all around the world --
this is obviously part of the landing gear --
we really started to understand
that there was this amazing symmetry
between the event itself,
between the way that people were telling the stories of the event,
and how we ourselves needed to tell that story.
This image in particular really captured
our attention at the time,
because it so much sums up that event.
This is a shot from the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel.
There's a firefighter that's stuck, actually, in traffic,
and so the firefighters themselves are running
a mile and a half to the site itself
with upwards of 70 pounds of gear on their back.
And we got this amazing email that said,
"While viewing the thousands of photos on the site,
I unexpectedly found a photo of my son.
It was a shock emotionally, yet a blessing to find this photo,"
and he was writing because he said,
"I'd like to personally thank the photographer
for posting the photo,
as it meant more than words can describe to me
to have access to what is probably
the last photo ever taken of my son."
And it really made us recognize
what this institution needed to be
in order to actually tell that story.
We can't have just a historian or a curator narrating
objectively in the third person about an event like that,
when you have the witnesses to history
who are going to make their way
through the actual museum itself.
And so we started imagining the museum,
along with the creative team at the museum and the curators,
thinking about how the first voice that you would hear
inside the museum would actually be of other visitors.
And so we created this idea of an opening gallery
called We Remember.
And I'll just play you part of a mockup of it,
but you get a sense of what it's like to actually enter
into that moment in time
and be transported back in history.
(Video) Voice 1: I was in Honolulu, Hawaii.
Voice 2: I was in Cairo, Egypt.
Voice 3: Sur les Champs-Élysées, à Paris.
Voice 4: In college, at U.C. Berkeley.
Voice 5: I was in Times Square.
Voice 6: São Paolo, Brazil.
Voice 7: It was probably about 11 o'clock at night.
Voice 8: I was driving to work at 5:45 local time in the morning.
Voice 9: We were actually in a meeting
when someone barged in and said,
"Oh my God, a plane has just crashed into the World Trade Center."
Voice 10: Trying to frantically get to a radio.
Voice 11: When I heard it over the radio --
Voice 12: Heard it on the radio.
Voice 13: I got a call from my father.
Voice 14: The phone rang, it woke me up.
My business partner told me to turn on the television.
Voice 15: So I switched on the television.
Voice 16: All channels in Italy were displaying the same thing.
Voice 17: The Twin Towers.
Voice 18: The Twin Towers.
JB: And you move from there
into that open, cavernous space.
This is the so-called slurry wall.
It's the original, excavated wall at the base of the World Trade Center
that withstood the actual pressure from the Hudson River
for a full year after the event itself.
And so we thought about carrying that sense of authenticity,
of presence of that moment
into the actual exhibition itself.
And we tell the stories of being inside the towers
through that same audio collage,
so you're hearing people literally talking about
seeing the planes as they make their way into the building,
or making their way down the stairwells.
And as you make your way into the exhibition
where it talks about the recovery,
we actually project directly onto these moments
of twisted steel all of the experiences from people
who literally excavated on top of the pile itself.
And so you can hear oral histories --
so people who were actually working the so-called bucket brigades
as you're seeing literally the thousands of experiences
from that moment.
And as you leave that storytelling moment
understanding about 9/11,
we then turn the museum back into a moment of listening
and actually talk to the individual visitors
and ask them their own experiences about 9/11.
And we ask them questions that are actually
not really answerable, the types of questions
that 9/11 itself draws forth for all of us.
And so these are questions like,
"How can a democracy balance freedom and security?"
"How could 9/11 have happened?"
"And how did the world change after 9/11?"
And so these oral histories,
which we've actually been capturing already for years,
are then mixed together with interviews
that we're doing with people like Donald Rumsfeld,
Bill Clinton, Rudy Giuliani,
and you mix together these different players
and these different experiences,
these different reflection points about 9/11.
And suddenly the institution, once again,
turns into a listening experience.
So I'll play you just a short excerpt
of a mockup that we made of a couple of these voices,
but you really get a sense
of the poetry of everyone's reflection on the event.
(Video) Voice 1: 9/11 was not just a New York experience.
Voice 2: It's something that we shared, and it's something that united us.
Voice 3: And I knew when I saw that,
people who were there that day who immediately
went to help people known and unknown to them
was something that would pull us through.
Voice 4: All the outpouring of affection and emotion
that came from our country was something really
that will forever, ever stay with me.
Voice 5: Still today I pray and think about those
who lost their lives,
and those who gave their lives to help others,
but I'm also reminded of the fabric of this country,
the love, the compassIon, the strength,
and I watched a nation come together
in the middle of a terrible tragedy.
JB: And so as people make their way out of the museum,
reflecting on the experience, reflecting on their own thoughts of it,
they then move into the actual space of the memorial itself,
because they've gone back up to grade,
and we actually got involved in the memorial
after we'd done the museum for a few years.
The original designer of the memorial, Michael Arad,
had this image in his mind of all the names appearing
undifferentiated, almost random,
really a poetic reflection on top of the nature
of a terrorism event itself,
but it was a huge challenge for the families, for the foundation,
certainly for the first responders,
and there was a negotiation that went forth
and a solution was found
to actually create not an order in terms of chronology,
or in terms of alphabetical,
but through what's called meaningful adjacency.
So these are groupings of the names themselves
which appear undifferentiated but actually have an order,
and we, along with Jer Thorp, created an algorithm
to take massive amounts of data
to actually start to connect together all these different names themselves.
So this is an image of the actual algorithm itself
with the names scrambled for privacy,
but you can see that these blocks of color
are actually the four different flights,
the two different towers, the first responders,
and you can actually see within that different floors,
and then the green lines are the interpersonal connections
that were requested by the families themselves.
And so when you go to the memorial,
you can actually see the overarching organization
inside of the individual pools themselves.
You can see the way that the geography of the event
is reflected inside of the memorial,
and you can search for an individual name,
or in this case an employer, Cantor Fitzgerald,
and see the way in which all of those names,
those hundreds of names, are actually organized
onto the memorial itself,
and use that to navigate the memorial.
And more importantly, when you're actually at the site
of the memorial, you can see those connections.
You can see the relationships between the different names themselves.
So suddenly what is this undifferentiated, anonymous
group of names springs into reality as an individual life.
In this case, Harry Ramos,
who was the head trader at an investment bank,
who stopped to aid Victor Wald on the 55th floor of the South Tower.
And Ramos told Wald, according to witnesses,
"I'm not going to leave you."
And Wald's widow requested that they be listed next to each other.
Three generations ago, we had to actually get people
to go out and capture the stories for common people.
Today, of course, there's an unprecedented amount of stories
for all of us that are being captured for future generations.
And this is our hope, that's there's poetry inside of each of our stories.
Thank you very much.
- Designer and storyteller
Principal of the New York media design firm, Local Projects, Jake Barton creates interactive and digital exhibits for the likes of the 9/11 Memorial Museum, Cleveland Museum of Art and Storycorps.Why you should listen
Jake Barton is principal and founder of Local Projects, a New York-based design firm which specializes in media design. Since 2006, Barton and his team have been working on creating the media design for the 9/11 Memorial and Museum; they also worked to develop the algorithm used to place names around the 9/11 Memorial itself. Other clients include the Cooper-Hewitt National Design Museum, the Frank Gehry-designed Eisenhower Presidential Memorial and Cleveland Museum of Art.
In 2013, Local Projects was named the National Design Award winner for Interaction Design, while in 2011 it was listed as the second most innovative design firm by Fast Company magazine. Meanwhile, The Atlantic writes of Barton, "At the crux of Barton's work is the idea of collaborative storytelling, which invites museum and memorial visitors to share their own experiences, observations, and memories through interactive technology, turning passive observers into active participants."
The original video is available on TED.com