TEDxBoston 2012
Timothy Prestero: Design for people, not awards
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
1,074,577 views
Timothy Prestero thought he'd designed the perfect incubator for newborns in the developing world -- he even won awards for it. But he and his team learned a hard lesson when their incubator completely failed to catch on. Hear his hard-earned manifesto on the importance of designing for real-world use, not accolades.
Timothy Prestero - Designer
Timothy Prestero loves a flashy "concept car." But in his own work, he aims to design products for social impact, keeping users in mind. Full bio
Timothy Prestero loves a flashy "concept car." But in his own work, he aims to design products for social impact, keeping users in mind. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
I've got a great idea that's going to change the world.
0
136
2576
00:18
It's fantastic, it's going to blow your mind.
1
2712
1711
00:20
It's my beautiful baby.
2
4423
2200
00:22
Here's the thing, everybody loves a beautiful baby.
3
6623
2236
00:24
I mean, I was a beautiful baby.
4
8859
1801
00:26
Here's me and my dad a couple days after I was born.
5
10660
2222
00:28
So in the world of product design,
6
12882
1649
00:30
the beautiful baby's like the concept car.
7
14531
3065
00:33
It's the knock-out.
8
17596
1401
00:34
You see it and you go, "Oh, my God. I'd buy that in a second!"
9
18997
2767
00:37
So why is it that this year's new cars
10
21764
3300
00:40
look pretty much exactly like last year's new cars?
11
25064
3288
00:44
(Laughter)
12
28352
1622
00:45
What went wrong between the design studio and the factory?
13
29974
2625
00:48
Today I don't want to talk about beautiful babies,
14
32599
2599
00:51
I want to talk about the awkward adolescence of design --
15
35198
2985
00:54
those sort of dorky teenage years
16
38183
3999
00:58
where you're trying to figure out how the world works.
17
42182
3516
01:01
I'm going to start with an example from some work that we did on newborn health.
18
45698
4117
01:05
So here's a problem:
19
49815
1984
01:07
Four million babies around the world,
20
51799
2534
01:10
mostly in developing countries,
21
54333
1199
01:11
die every year before their first birthday,
22
55532
2966
01:14
even before their first month of life.
23
58498
1852
01:16
It turns out half of those kids, or about 1.8 million newborns around the world,
24
60350
3479
01:19
would make it if you could just keep them warm
25
63829
2636
01:22
for the first three days, maybe the first week.
26
66465
3100
01:25
So this is a newborn intensive care unit in Kathmandu, Nepal.
27
69565
3650
01:29
All of these kids in blankets belong in incubators --
28
73215
3033
01:32
something like this. So this is a donated Japanese Atom incubator
29
76248
4633
01:36
that we found in a NICU in Kathmandu.
30
80881
2167
01:38
This is what we want.
31
83048
2267
01:41
Probably what happened is a hospital in Japan upgraded their equipment
32
85315
2617
01:43
and donated their old stuff to Nepal.
33
87932
3600
01:47
The problem is, without technicians, without spare parts,
34
91532
3683
01:51
donations like this very quickly turn into junk.
35
95215
3605
01:54
So this seemed like a problem that we could do something about.
36
98820
3060
01:57
Keeping a baby warm for a week,
37
101880
2500
02:00
that's not rocket science.
38
104380
2000
02:02
So we got started.
39
106380
1783
02:04
We partnered with a leading medical research institution here in Boston.
40
108163
3118
02:07
We conducted months of user research overseas,
41
111281
3717
02:10
trying to think like designers, human-centered design.
42
114998
2634
02:13
Let's figure out what people want.
43
117632
2943
02:16
We killed thousands of Post-it notes.
44
120575
1954
02:18
We made dozens of prototypes to get to this.
45
122529
2933
02:21
So this is the NeoNurture Infant Incubator,
46
125462
3217
02:24
and this has a lot of smarts built into it. And we felt great.
47
128679
4150
02:28
So the idea here is, unlike the concept car,
48
132829
2200
02:30
we want to marry something beautiful
49
135029
2016
02:32
with something that actually works.
50
137045
2201
02:35
And our idea is that this design
51
139246
1916
02:37
would inspire manufacturers and other people of influence
52
141162
3984
02:41
to take this model and run with it.
53
145146
2533
02:43
Here's the bad news:
54
147679
3518
02:47
The only baby ever actually put inside the NeoNurture Incubator
55
151197
3348
02:50
was this kid during a Time magazine photo shoot.
56
154545
3917
02:54
So recognition is fantastic.
57
158462
2432
02:56
We want design to get out for people to see it.
58
160894
3100
02:59
It won lots of awards.
59
163994
1234
03:01
But it felt like a booby prize.
60
165228
2048
03:03
We wanted to make beautiful things that are going to make the world a better place,
61
167276
6515
03:09
and I don't think this kid was even in it long enough to get warm.
62
173791
3377
03:13
So it turns out that design for inspiration
63
177168
2899
03:15
doesn't really --
64
180067
2518
03:18
I guess what I would say is, for us, for what I want to do,
65
182585
3549
03:22
it's either too slow or it just doesn't work, it's ineffective.
66
186134
4050
03:26
So really I want to design for outcomes.
67
190184
2800
03:28
I don't want to make beautiful stuff.
68
192984
1500
03:30
I want to make the world a better place.
69
194484
1734
03:32
So when we were designing NeoNurture,
70
196218
2350
03:34
we paid a lot of attention to the people who are going to use this thing --
71
198568
2923
03:37
for example, poor families, rural doctors,
72
201491
2560
03:39
overloaded nurses, even repair technicians.
73
204051
3650
03:43
We thought we had all our bases covered, we'd done everything right.
74
207701
2649
03:46
Well it turns out there's this whole constellation of people
75
210350
2950
03:49
who have to be involved in a product for it to be successful:
76
213300
3100
03:52
manufacturing, financing, distribution, regulation.
77
216400
2701
03:55
Michael Free at PATH says you have to figure out who will "choose, use and pay the dues"
78
219101
4994
03:59
for a product like this.
79
224095
1785
04:01
And I have to ask the question --
80
225880
2184
04:03
VC's always ask, "Sir, what is your business, and who is your customer?"
81
228064
3021
04:06
Who is our customer? Well here's an example.
82
231098
3022
04:10
This is a Bangladeshi hospital director outside his facility.
83
234120
3379
04:13
It turns out he doesn't buy any of his equipment.
84
237499
2265
04:15
Those decisions are made by the Ministry of Health
85
239764
2784
04:18
or by foreign donors,
86
242548
2067
04:20
and it just kind of shows up.
87
244615
1400
04:21
Similarly, here's a multinational medical device manufacturer.
88
246015
3300
04:25
It turns out they've got to fish where the fish are.
89
249315
2766
04:27
So it turns out that in emerging markets, where the fish are,
90
252081
3633
04:31
are the emerging middle class of these countries --
91
255714
3201
04:34
diseases of affluence: heart disease, infertility.
92
258915
3501
04:38
So it turns out that design for outcomes in one aspect
93
262416
4832
04:43
really means thinking about design for manufacture and distribution.
94
267248
3117
04:46
Okay, that was an important lesson.
95
270365
1883
04:48
Second, we took that lesson and tried to push it into our next project.
96
272248
4883
04:53
So we started by finding a manufacturer,
97
277131
2599
04:55
an organization called MTTS in Vietnam,
98
279730
1734
04:57
that manufactures newborn care technologies for Southeast Asia.
99
281464
3467
05:00
Our other partner is East Meets West.
100
284931
2033
05:02
This is an American foundation that distributes that technology
101
286964
2883
05:05
to poor hospitals around that region.
102
289847
2667
05:08
So we started with them saying, "Well what do you want?
103
292514
2769
05:11
What's a problem you want to solve?"
104
295283
1465
05:12
And they said, "Well let's work on newborn jaundice."
105
296748
2432
05:15
So this is another one of these mind-boggling global problems.
106
299180
3437
05:18
So jaundice affects two-thirds of newborns around the world.
107
302617
4164
05:22
Of those newborns, one in 10 roughly,
108
306781
4991
05:27
if it's not treated, the jaundice gets so severe
109
311772
2437
05:30
that it leads to either a life-long disability,
110
314209
3084
05:33
or the kids could even die.
111
317293
1884
05:35
There's one way to treat jaundice,
112
319177
2334
05:37
and that's what's called an exchange transfusion.
113
321511
2549
05:39
So as you can imagine, that's expensive and a little bit dangerous.
114
324060
3336
05:43
There is another cure.
115
327396
2364
05:45
It's very technological, it's very complex, a little daunting.
116
329760
5400
05:51
You've got to shine blue light on the kid --
117
335160
2967
05:54
bright blue light on as much of the skin as you can cover.
118
338127
4066
05:58
How is this a hard problem?
119
342193
2500
06:00
So I went to MIT,
120
344693
3480
06:04
Okay, we'll figure that out. (Laughter)
121
348173
3237
06:07
So here's an example. This is an overhead phototherapy device
122
351410
2883
06:10
that's designed for American hospitals.
123
354293
2816
06:13
And here's how it's supposed to be used.
124
357109
2434
06:15
So it's over the baby, illuminating a single patient.
125
359543
3468
06:18
Take it out of an American hospital,
126
363011
2232
06:21
send it overseas to a crowded facility in Asia,
127
365243
1917
06:23
here's how it's actually used.
128
367160
1866
06:24
The effectiveness of phototherapy is a function of light intensity.
129
369026
3151
06:28
So these dark blue squares show you where it's effective phototherapy.
130
372177
3300
06:31
Here's what it looks like under actual use.
131
375477
2867
06:34
So those kids on the edges
132
378344
1117
06:35
aren't actually receiving effective phototherapy.
133
379461
2615
06:37
But without training, without some kind of light meter,
134
382076
2735
06:40
how would you know?
135
384811
1965
06:42
We see other examples of problems like this.
136
386776
1950
06:44
So here's a neonatal intensive care unit
137
388726
1717
06:46
where moms come in to visit their babies.
138
390443
2367
06:48
And keep in mind, Mom maybe just had a C-section,
139
392810
2565
06:51
so that's already kind of a bummer.
140
395375
1884
06:53
Mom's visiting her kid.
141
397259
1301
06:54
She sees her baby naked, lying under some blue lights,
142
398560
3466
06:57
looking kind of vulnerable.
143
402026
1882
06:59
It's not uncommon for Mom to put a blanket over the baby.
144
403908
3135
07:02
From a phototherapy standpoint, maybe not the best behavior.
145
407043
3967
07:06
In fact that sounds kind of dumb.
146
411010
3000
07:09
Except, what we've learned
147
414010
2166
07:12
is that there's no such thing as a dumb user -- really is what we've learned.
148
416176
3668
07:15
There are only dumb products.
149
419844
1666
07:17
We have to think like existentialists.
150
421510
1683
07:19
It's not the painting we would have painted,
151
423193
1515
07:20
it's the painting that we actually painted.
152
424708
2000
07:22
It's the use -- designed for actual use.
153
426708
3325
07:25
How are people actually going to use this?
154
430033
1349
07:27
So similarly, when we think about our partner MTTS,
155
431382
4199
07:31
they've made some amazing technologies for treating newborn illnesses.
156
435581
3394
07:34
So here's an overhead warmer and a CPAP.
157
438975
1956
07:36
They're inexpensive, really rugged.
158
440931
2816
07:39
They've treated 50,000 kids in Vietnam with this technology.
159
443747
3116
07:42
But here's the problem:
160
446863
1067
07:43
Every doctor in the world, every hospital administrator,
161
447930
2568
07:46
has seen TV -- curse those "E.R." reruns.
162
450498
4916
07:51
Turns out they all know what a medical device is supposed to look like.
163
455414
4365
07:55
They want Buck Rogers, they don't want effective.
164
459779
3534
07:59
It sounds crazy, it sounds dumb,
165
463313
2518
08:01
but there are actually hospitals who would rather have no equipment
166
465831
2385
08:04
than something that looks cheap and crummy.
167
468216
2466
08:06
So again, if we want people to trust a device,
168
470682
3467
08:10
it has to look trustworthy.
169
474149
1703
08:11
So thinking about outcomes,
170
475852
1515
08:13
it turns out appearances matter.
171
477367
2401
08:15
So we took all that information together.
172
479768
2317
08:17
We tried, this time, to get it right.
173
482085
2282
08:20
And here's what we developed.
174
484367
1401
08:21
So this is the Firefly Phototherapy Device,
175
485768
2085
08:23
except this time we didn't stop at the concept car.
176
487853
3049
08:26
So from the very beginning we started by talking to manufacturers.
177
490902
3632
08:30
Our goal is to make a state-of-the-art product
178
494534
3068
08:33
that our partner MTTS can actually manufacture.
179
497602
2833
08:36
So our goal is to study how they work, the resources they have access to,
180
500435
3900
08:40
so that they can make this product.
181
504335
2583
08:42
So that's the design for manufacture question.
182
506918
3102
08:45
When we think about actual use,
183
510020
1265
08:47
you'll notice that Firefly has a single bassinet.
184
511285
2483
08:49
It only fits a single baby.
185
513768
2066
08:51
And the idea here is it's obvious how you ought to use this device.
186
515834
4333
08:56
If you try to put more than one kid in,
187
520167
1518
08:57
you're stacking them on top of each other.
188
521685
1533
08:59
(Laughter)
189
523218
1136
09:00
So the idea here is we say, you want to make it hard to use wrong.
190
524354
4214
09:04
In other words, you want to make the right way to use it
191
528568
1983
09:06
the easiest way to use it.
192
530551
2468
09:08
Another example: Again, silly mom.
193
533019
2932
09:11
Silly mom thinks her baby looks cold, wants to put a blanket over the baby.
194
535951
3000
09:14
Well that's why we have lights above and below the baby in Firefly.
195
538951
3067
09:17
So if mom does put a blanket over the baby,
196
542018
2084
09:20
it's still receiving effective phototherapy from below.
197
544102
3184
09:23
Last story here:
198
547286
1998
09:25
I've got a friend in India who told me
199
549284
1901
09:27
that you haven't really tested a piece of electronic technology
200
551185
3282
09:30
for distribution in Asia
201
554467
2087
09:32
until you've trained a cockroach to climb in
202
556554
2613
09:35
and pee on every single little component on the inside.
203
559167
2185
09:37
(Laughter)
204
561352
1433
09:38
You think it's funny.
205
562785
2134
09:40
I had a laptop in the Peace Corps,
206
564919
1632
09:42
and the screen had all these dead pixels on it.
207
566551
2616
09:45
And one day I looked in, they were all dead ants
208
569167
2235
09:47
that had gotten into my laptop and perished --
209
571402
2499
09:49
those poor ants!
210
573901
1299
09:51
So with Firefly, what we did is --
211
575200
3167
09:54
the problem is electronics get hot
212
578367
1734
09:56
and you have to put in vents or fans to keep them cool --
213
580101
3100
09:59
in most products.
214
583201
1398
10:00
We decided that I can't put a "do not enter" sign next to the vent.
215
584599
4234
10:04
We actually got rid of all of that stuff.
216
588833
1967
10:06
So Firefly's totally sealed.
217
590800
1833
10:08
These are the kinds of lessons --
218
592633
1601
10:10
as awkward as it was to be a pretty goofy teenager,
219
594234
2849
10:12
much worse to be a frustrated designer.
220
597083
2268
10:15
So I was thinking about, what I really want to do is change the world.
221
599351
3050
10:18
I have to pay attention to manufacturing and distribution.
222
602401
2500
10:20
I have to pay attention to how people are actually going to use a device.
223
604901
3599
10:24
I actually have to pay attention. Really, there's no excuse for failure.
224
608500
4017
10:28
I have to think like an existentialist.
225
612517
1550
10:29
I have to accept that there are no dumb users,
226
614067
1834
10:31
that there's only dumb products.
227
615901
1865
10:33
We have to ask ourselves hard questions.
228
617766
2144
10:35
Are we designing for the world that we want?
229
619910
3330
10:39
Are we designing for the world that we have?
230
623240
2154
10:41
Are we designing for the world that's coming,
231
625394
2033
10:43
whether we're ready or not?
232
627427
1450
10:44
I got into this business designing products.
233
628877
3351
10:48
I've since learned that if you really want to make a difference in the world,
234
632228
3299
10:51
you have to design outcomes.
235
635527
2184
10:53
And that's design that matters.
236
637711
1616
10:55
Thank you.
237
639327
1266
10:56
(Applause)
238
640593
3685
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Timothy Prestero - DesignerTimothy Prestero loves a flashy "concept car." But in his own work, he aims to design products for social impact, keeping users in mind.
Why you should listen
Timothy Prestero is the founder and CEO of Design that Matters, a nonprofit that collaborates with social entrepreneurs and volunteers to design products for the poor in developing countries. A former Peace Corps volunteer and MIT graduate, Tim has worked in West Africa, Latin America and Asia. He is a Martin Fellow at the MIT Laboratory for Energy and the Environment, a Draper Richards Kaplan Fellow, and was named an Ashoka Affiliate in 2004. His awards include the 2007 Social Venture Network Innovation Award, and the 2009 World Technology Award. This year, Design That Matters was named the winner of the National Design Award in Corporate and Institutional Achievement.
Tim and his team made a splash when they created the NeoNurture Infant Incubator, named one of TIME Magazine's "50 Best Inventions of 2010." However, the product wasn't a hit with manufacturers or with hospitals in developing countries and forever remained a prototype. Design That Matters learned an important lesson from the experience -- that good design must keep in mind who will procure equipment, who will be using it, as well as the myriad ways it could be used incorrectly. As Timothy says, "There's no such thing as a dumb user; there are only dumb products.
Timothy Prestero | Speaker | TED.com