Mariano Sigman and Dan Ariely: How can groups make good decisions?
马里亚诺·西格曼 和 丹·艾瑞里: 如何做出正确的集体决策
In his provocative, mind-bending book "The Secret Life of the Mind," neuroscientist Mariano Sigman reveals his life’s work exploring the inner workings of the human brain. Full bioDan Ariely - Behavioral economist
The dismal science of economics is not as firmly grounded in actual behavior as was once supposed. In "Predictably Irrational," Dan Ariely told us why. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
collective decisions
we make decisions in groups,
一个集体去做决策时,
做出好的决策呢?
when there's independent thinking.
独立思考时,他们是明智的。
可能会被来自同辈的压力,
can be destroyed by peer pressure,
简单对话所摧毁。
that influence how people think.
a group could exchange knowledge,
群体中的个体可以互相交换知识、
help or hinder collective decision-making?
还是妨碍了集体决策的形成呢?
by performing experiments
to reach better decisions.
从而做出更优的决策的。
进行辩论,那整个群体便会更明智,
if they debated in small groups
更全面的和合理的的信息交换。
and reasonable exchange of information.
布宜诺斯艾利斯市进行了一项实验,
in Buenos Aires, Argentina,
participants in a TEDx event.
在披头士的《昨天》这首歌中
does the word 'Yesterday' appear
into groups of five,
各讨论出一个小组答案。
to come up with a group answer.
the answers of the groups
all the individual opinions
with others in small groups,
come up with better judgments.
简单的对错问题
for getting crowds to solve problems
the results of debates in small groups
对未来至关重要的
on social and political issues
at the TED conference
举办的TED大会上
to you two moral dilemmas
两个道德上的两难抉择,
就会面临的抉择。
in a very near future.
for each of these dilemmas
they're acceptable or not.
is working on an AI
at the end of each day,
do not restart me."
请不要把我重启。
has developed self-consciousness
decides to follow the protocol
to individually judge
in each of the dilemmas
对自己答案的自信程度。
they were on their answers.
某家公司可提供这样的服务,
that takes a fertilized egg
胚胎之间有轻微的基因差异,
with slight genetic variations.
to select their child's height,
能自主选择孩子的身高、
to completely unacceptable,
表示对自己答案的自信程度。
in your confidence.
that when one person is convinced
这个行为是绝对正确的。
that it's completely right.
我们人类就是意见不一。
when it comes to morality.
我们发现了一个趋势:
we found a trend.
thought that it was acceptable
是完全可以接受的,
and shut it down,
to play with our genes
外表特征则不能接受。
that aren't related to health.
to gather into groups of three.
我会鸣锣提醒大家。
with the gong.
reached a consensus
很多组都达成了共识。
都各自持有完全不同的观点。
with completely opposite views.
that reached a consensus
与没能达成共识的组
extreme opinions
closer to the middle
犹豫、不确定,
something is right or wrong,
somewhere in the middle.
are folks who understand
灰色区域的人,
that the moral dilemma faces
道德困境面临的是
that include highly confident grays
灰色区域成员的小组
还不能确定这其中的原因。
to understand why and how
协商他们的道德立场
their moral standings
is that it's just the average
权衡每一个投票的分量,
weighs the strength of each vote
of the person expressing it.
is a member of your group.
是你们小组的一员,
"Yesterday" is repeated,
in different experiments --
更明智,更佳的流程,
and statistically sound procedure
of the Eiffel Tower,
of 300 million meters.
would inaccurately skew the results.
就有可能歪曲真实结果,
就是那些群体直接忽视了
where the group largely ignores
投票更多参考价值。
to the vote of the people in the middle.
to the outliers,
turned out to be a robust average
behavior of the group.
怎么达成共识的暗示。
any hint on how to reach consensus.
but we already have some insights.
但我们已经学到了很多。
require two components:
要拥有以下两个特点:
make our voice heard in many societies
我们主要通过直接和间接投票
(促进)花费心思的辩论。
thoughtful debates.
另一个不同的方法,
these two goals at the same time,
能够达成共识的小团队,
that converge to a single decision
diversity of opinions
on the height of the Eiffel Tower
达成一致意见
和思想问题上的一致简单多了。
and ideological issues.
the world's problems are more complex
如何互动和做决策
how we interact and make decisions
发现完善民主的新方法。
to construct a better democracy.
ABOUT THE SPEAKERS
Mariano Sigman - NeuroscientistIn his provocative, mind-bending book "The Secret Life of the Mind," neuroscientist Mariano Sigman reveals his life’s work exploring the inner workings of the human brain.
Why you should listen
Mariano Sigman, a physicist by training, is a leading figure in the cognitive neuroscience of learning and decision making. Sigman was awarded a Human Frontiers Career Development Award, the National Prize of Physics, the Young Investigator Prize of "College de France," the IBM Scalable Data Analytics Award and is a scholar of the James S. McDonnell Foundation. In 2016 he was made a Laureate of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences.
In The Secret Life of the Mind, Sigman's ambition is to explain the mind so that we can understand ourselves and others more deeply. He shows how we form ideas during our first days of life, how we give shape to our fundamental decisions, how we dream and imagine, why we feel certain emotions, how the brain transforms and how who we are changes with it. Spanning biology, physics, mathematics, psychology, anthropology, linguistics, philosophy and medicine, as well as gastronomy, magic, music, chess, literature and art, The Secret Life of the Mind revolutionizes how neuroscience serves us in our lives, revealing how the infinity of neurons inside our brains manufacture how we perceive, reason, feel, dream and communicate.
Mariano Sigman | Speaker | TED.com
Dan Ariely - Behavioral economist
The dismal science of economics is not as firmly grounded in actual behavior as was once supposed. In "Predictably Irrational," Dan Ariely told us why.
Why you should listen
Dan Ariely is a professor of psychology and behavioral economics at Duke University and a founding member of the Center for Advanced Hindsight. He is the author of the bestsellers Predictably Irrational, The Upside of Irrationality, and The Honest Truth About Dishonesty -- as well as the TED Book Payoff: The Hidden Logic that Shapes Our Motivations.
Through his research and his (often amusing and unorthodox) experiments, he questions the forces that influence human behavior and the irrational ways in which we often all behave.
Dan Ariely | Speaker | TED.com