TED2016
Cédric Villani: What's so sexy about math?
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
2,006,708 views
Hidden truths permeate our world; they're inaccessible to our senses, but math allows us to go beyond our intuition to uncover their mysteries. In this survey of mathematical breakthroughs, Fields Medal winner Cédric Villani speaks to the thrill of discovery and details the sometimes perplexing life of a mathematician. "Beautiful mathematical explanations are not only for our pleasure," he says. "They change our vision of the world."
Cédric Villani - Mathematician
Cédric Villani tackles perplexing problems in mathematical physics, analysis and geometry with rigor, wit and a signature personal style. Full bio
Cédric Villani tackles perplexing problems in mathematical physics, analysis and geometry with rigor, wit and a signature personal style. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
What is it that French people
do better than all the others?
do better than all the others?
0
804
4412
00:18
If you would take polls,
1
6454
1926
00:20
the top three answers might be:
2
8404
1807
00:22
love, wine and whining.
3
10235
4039
00:26
(Laughter)
4
14298
1301
00:27
Maybe.
5
15623
1159
00:29
But let me suggest a fourth one:
6
17530
2338
00:31
mathematics.
7
19892
1190
00:33
Did you know that Paris
has more mathematicians
has more mathematicians
8
21760
2853
00:36
than any other city in the world?
9
24637
1801
00:38
And more streets
with mathematicians' names, too.
with mathematicians' names, too.
10
26801
2494
00:42
And if you look at the statistics
of the Fields Medal,
of the Fields Medal,
11
30215
3449
00:45
often called the Nobel Prize
for mathematics,
for mathematics,
12
33688
2493
00:48
and always awarded to mathematicians
below the age of 40,
below the age of 40,
13
36205
3932
00:52
you will find that France has more
Fields medalists per inhabitant
Fields medalists per inhabitant
14
40161
3887
00:56
than any other country.
15
44072
1168
00:58
What is it that we find so sexy in math?
16
46286
2954
01:02
After all, it seems to be
dull and abstract,
dull and abstract,
17
50153
3204
01:05
just numbers and computations
and rules to apply.
and rules to apply.
18
53381
3483
01:10
Mathematics may be abstract,
19
58518
2112
01:12
but it's not dull
20
60654
1151
01:13
and it's not about computing.
21
61829
1729
01:16
It is about reasoning
22
64178
1747
01:17
and proving our core activity.
23
65949
2260
01:20
It is about imagination,
24
68513
1522
01:22
the talent which we most praise.
25
70059
2019
01:24
It is about finding the truth.
26
72102
2101
01:27
There's nothing like the feeling
which invades you
which invades you
27
75613
2737
01:30
when after months of hard thinking,
28
78374
2171
01:32
you finally understand the right
reasoning to solve your problem.
reasoning to solve your problem.
29
80569
3298
01:37
The great mathematician
André Weil likened this --
André Weil likened this --
30
85042
3576
01:40
no kidding --
31
88642
1151
01:41
to sexual pleasure.
32
89817
1589
01:44
But noted that this feeling
can last for hours, or even days.
can last for hours, or even days.
33
92197
5341
01:50
The reward may be big.
34
98804
1853
01:53
Hidden mathematical truths
permeate our whole physical world.
permeate our whole physical world.
35
101325
3864
01:57
They are inaccessible to our senses
36
105680
2670
02:00
but can be seen
through mathematical lenses.
through mathematical lenses.
37
108374
2724
02:04
Close your eyes for moment
38
112092
1592
02:05
and think of what is occurring
right now around you.
right now around you.
39
113708
3475
02:10
Invisible particles from the air
around are bumping on you
around are bumping on you
40
118337
3493
02:13
by the billions and billions
at each second,
at each second,
41
121854
2733
02:16
all in complete chaos.
42
124611
2063
02:19
And still,
43
127049
1151
02:20
their statistics can be accurately
predicted by mathematical physics.
predicted by mathematical physics.
44
128224
4688
02:25
And open your eyes now
45
133715
2792
02:28
to the statistics of the velocities
of these particles.
of these particles.
46
136531
3310
02:32
The famous bell-shaped Gauss Curve,
47
140510
3240
02:35
or the Law of Errors --
48
143774
2181
02:37
of deviations with respect
to the mean behavior.
to the mean behavior.
49
145979
2722
02:41
This curve tells about the statistics
of velocities of particles
of velocities of particles
50
149550
4302
02:45
in the same way as a demographic curve
51
153876
2539
02:48
would tell about the statistics
of ages of individuals.
of ages of individuals.
52
156439
3841
02:52
It's one of the most
important curves ever.
important curves ever.
53
160884
2650
02:56
It keeps on occurring again and again,
54
164137
3186
02:59
from many theories and many experiments,
55
167347
2403
03:01
as a great example of the universality
56
169774
3281
03:05
which is so dear to us mathematicians.
57
173079
3552
03:09
Of this curve,
58
177694
1227
03:10
the famous scientist Francis Galton said,
59
178945
3049
03:14
"It would have been deified by the Greeks
if they had known it.
if they had known it.
60
182018
4524
03:19
It is the supreme law of unreason."
61
187064
3351
03:23
And there's no better way to materialize
that supreme goddess than Galton's Board.
that supreme goddess than Galton's Board.
62
191818
6602
03:31
Inside this board are narrow tunnels
63
199774
3197
03:34
through which tiny balls
will fall down randomly,
will fall down randomly,
64
202995
4628
03:40
going right or left, or left, etc.
65
208295
5387
03:46
All in complete randomness and chaos.
66
214139
3251
03:50
Let's see what happens when we look
at all these random trajectories together.
at all these random trajectories together.
67
218085
6080
03:56
(Board shaking)
68
224189
5435
04:01
This is a bit of a sport,
69
229648
2844
04:04
because we need to resolve
some traffic jams in there.
some traffic jams in there.
70
232516
4870
04:11
Aha.
71
239715
1150
04:13
We think that randomness
is going to play me a trick on stage.
is going to play me a trick on stage.
72
241313
3587
04:19
There it is.
73
247609
1463
04:22
Our supreme goddess of unreason.
74
250382
2583
04:24
the Gauss Curve,
75
252989
1519
04:26
trapped here inside this transparent box
as Dream in "The Sandman" comics.
as Dream in "The Sandman" comics.
76
254532
6452
04:34
For you I have shown it,
77
262623
2698
04:37
but to my students I explain why
it could not be any other curve.
it could not be any other curve.
78
265345
5285
04:43
And this is touching
the mystery of that goddess,
the mystery of that goddess,
79
271128
2870
04:46
replacing a beautiful coincidence
by a beautiful explanation.
by a beautiful explanation.
80
274022
4701
04:51
All of science is like this.
81
279027
2333
04:54
And beautiful mathematical explanations
are not only for our pleasure.
are not only for our pleasure.
82
282213
5348
04:59
They also change our vision of the world.
83
287585
2660
05:03
For instance,
84
291040
1237
05:04
Einstein,
85
292301
1150
05:05
Perrin,
86
293476
1150
05:06
Smoluchowski,
87
294651
1150
05:07
they used the mathematical analysis
of random trajectories
of random trajectories
88
295826
3559
05:11
and the Gauss Curve
89
299409
2037
05:13
to explain and prove that our
world is made of atoms.
world is made of atoms.
90
301470
4928
05:19
It was not the first time
91
307524
1802
05:21
that mathematics was revolutionizing
our view of the world.
our view of the world.
92
309350
3390
05:25
More than 2,000 years ago,
93
313555
2212
05:27
at the time of the ancient Greeks,
94
315791
2610
05:31
it already occurred.
95
319502
1479
05:33
In those days,
96
321827
1286
05:35
only a small fraction of the world
had been explored,
had been explored,
97
323137
3283
05:38
and the Earth might have seemed infinite.
98
326444
3042
05:42
But clever Eratosthenes,
99
330034
1767
05:43
using mathematics,
100
331825
1417
05:45
was able to measure the Earth
with an amazing accuracy of two percent.
with an amazing accuracy of two percent.
101
333266
5111
05:51
Here's another example.
102
339969
1416
05:54
In 1673, Jean Richer noticed
103
342238
3805
05:58
that a pendulum swings slightly
slower in Cayenne than in Paris.
slower in Cayenne than in Paris.
104
346067
6912
06:06
From this observation alone,
and clever mathematics,
and clever mathematics,
105
354350
4400
06:10
Newton rightly deduced
106
358774
2306
06:13
that the Earth is a wee bit
flattened at the poles,
flattened at the poles,
107
361104
5541
06:18
like 0.3 percent --
108
366669
1601
06:20
so tiny that you wouldn't even
notice it on the real view of the Earth.
notice it on the real view of the Earth.
109
368843
4413
06:26
These stories show that mathematics
110
374276
3928
06:30
is able to make us go out of our intuition
111
378228
4762
06:35
measure the Earth which seems infinite,
112
383512
3485
06:39
see atoms which are invisible
113
387021
2294
06:41
or detect an imperceptible
variation of shape.
variation of shape.
114
389339
3381
06:44
And if there is just one thing that you
should take home from this talk,
should take home from this talk,
115
392744
3847
06:48
it is this:
116
396615
1194
06:49
mathematics allows us
to go beyond the intuition
to go beyond the intuition
117
397833
4378
06:54
and explore territories
which do not fit within our grasp.
which do not fit within our grasp.
118
402235
4249
06:59
Here's a modern example
you will all relate to:
you will all relate to:
119
407609
2999
07:03
searching the Internet.
120
411362
1667
07:06
The World Wide Web,
121
414037
1342
07:07
more than one billion web pages --
122
415403
1804
07:09
do you want to go through them all?
123
417231
1674
07:11
Computing power helps,
124
419660
1802
07:13
but it would be useless without
the mathematical modeling
the mathematical modeling
125
421486
3186
07:16
to find the information
hidden in the data.
hidden in the data.
126
424696
2563
07:20
Let's work out a baby problem.
127
428491
2379
07:23
Imagine that you're a detective
working on a crime case,
working on a crime case,
128
431872
3807
07:27
and there are many people
who have their version of the facts.
who have their version of the facts.
129
435703
3788
07:32
Who do you want to interview first?
130
440032
1745
07:34
Sensible answer:
131
442681
1915
07:36
prime witnesses.
132
444620
1437
07:38
You see,
133
446878
1234
07:40
suppose that there is person number seven,
134
448136
4220
07:44
tells you a story,
135
452380
1151
07:45
but when you ask where he got if from,
136
453555
2014
07:47
he points to person
number three as a source.
number three as a source.
137
455593
3036
07:50
And maybe person number three, in turn,
138
458653
2068
07:52
points at person number one
as the primary source.
as the primary source.
139
460745
3696
07:56
Now number one is a prime witness,
140
464465
1661
07:58
so I definitely want
to interview him -- priority
to interview him -- priority
141
466150
3238
08:02
And from the graph
142
470148
1151
08:03
we also see that person
number four is a prime witness.
number four is a prime witness.
143
471323
3228
08:06
And maybe I even want
to interview him first,
to interview him first,
144
474575
2443
08:09
because there are more
people who refer to him.
people who refer to him.
145
477042
2359
08:12
OK, that was easy,
146
480354
2664
08:15
but now what about if you have
a big bunch of people who will testify?
a big bunch of people who will testify?
147
483042
5246
08:20
And this graph,
148
488864
1352
08:22
I may think of it as all people
who testify in a complicated crime case,
who testify in a complicated crime case,
149
490240
5619
08:27
but it may just as well be web pages
pointing to each other,
pointing to each other,
150
495883
4022
08:31
referring to each other for contents.
151
499929
2071
08:34
Which ones are the most authoritative?
152
502878
2336
08:37
Not so clear.
153
505587
1334
08:40
Enter PageRank,
154
508091
1900
08:42
one of the early cornerstones of Google.
155
510015
2536
08:45
This algorithm uses the laws
of mathematical randomness
of mathematical randomness
156
513337
4242
08:49
to determine automatically
the most relevant web pages,
the most relevant web pages,
157
517603
3857
08:53
in the same way as we used randomness
in the Galton Board experiment.
in the Galton Board experiment.
158
521484
5062
08:59
So let's send into this graph
159
527341
2341
09:01
a bunch of tiny, digital marbles
160
529706
2850
09:04
and let them go randomly
through the graph.
through the graph.
161
532580
3749
09:08
Each time they arrive at some site,
162
536353
1667
09:10
they will go out through some link
chosen at random to the next one.
chosen at random to the next one.
163
538044
4166
09:14
And again, and again, and again.
164
542234
1753
09:16
And with small, growing piles,
165
544358
1628
09:18
we'll keep the record of how many
times each site has been visited
times each site has been visited
166
546010
3753
09:21
by these digital marbles.
167
549787
1945
09:24
Here we go.
168
552243
1151
09:25
Randomness, randomness.
169
553418
1848
09:27
And from time to time,
170
555811
1448
09:29
also let's make jumps completely
randomly to increase the fun.
randomly to increase the fun.
171
557283
3952
09:34
And look at this:
172
562471
1216
09:36
from the chaos will emerge the solution.
173
564358
2785
09:39
The highest piles
correspond to those sites
correspond to those sites
174
567483
2485
09:41
which somehow are better
connected than the others,
connected than the others,
175
569992
3511
09:45
more pointed at than the others.
176
573527
2273
09:47
And here we see clearly
177
575824
1722
09:49
which are the web pages
we want to first try.
we want to first try.
178
577570
3032
09:53
Once again,
179
581507
1151
09:54
the solution emerges from the randomness.
180
582682
2460
09:57
Of course, since that time,
181
585775
2251
10:00
Google has come up with much more
sophisticated algorithms,
sophisticated algorithms,
182
588050
3707
10:03
but already this was beautiful.
183
591781
2280
10:06
And still,
184
594981
1476
10:08
just one problem in a million.
185
596481
1611
10:10
With the advent of digital area,
186
598734
2270
10:13
more and more problems lend
themselves to mathematical analysis,
themselves to mathematical analysis,
187
601028
5016
10:18
making the job of mathematician
a more and more useful one,
a more and more useful one,
188
606068
4365
10:23
to the extent that a few years ago,
189
611166
2722
10:25
it was ranked number one
among hundreds of jobs
among hundreds of jobs
190
613912
3779
10:29
in a study about the best and worst jobs
191
617715
3968
10:33
published by the Wall Street
Journal in 2009.
Journal in 2009.
192
621707
2975
10:37
Mathematician --
193
625445
1852
10:39
best job in the world.
194
627321
1433
10:41
That's because of the applications:
195
629646
3068
10:44
communication theory,
196
632738
2139
10:46
information theory,
197
634901
1820
10:48
game theory,
198
636745
1260
10:50
compressed sensing,
199
638029
1446
10:51
machine learning,
200
639499
1562
10:53
graph analysis,
201
641085
1567
10:54
harmonic analysis.
202
642676
1742
10:56
And why not stochastic processes,
203
644442
2640
10:59
linear programming,
204
647106
1630
11:00
or fluid simulation?
205
648760
2028
11:03
Each of these fields have
monster industrial applications.
monster industrial applications.
206
651292
3895
11:07
And through them,
207
655211
1151
11:08
there is big money in mathematics.
208
656386
1999
11:11
And let me concede
209
659400
2040
11:13
that when it comes to making
money from the math,
money from the math,
210
661464
2477
11:15
the Americans are by a long shot
the world champions,
the world champions,
211
663965
3824
11:19
with clever, emblematic billionaires
and amazing, giant companies,
and amazing, giant companies,
212
667813
4619
11:24
all resting, ultimately,
on good algorithm.
on good algorithm.
213
672456
3280
11:29
Now with all this beauty,
usefulness and wealth,
usefulness and wealth,
214
677091
3972
11:33
mathematics does look more sexy.
215
681087
2284
11:36
But don't you think
216
684399
1617
11:38
that the life a mathematical
researcher is an easy one.
researcher is an easy one.
217
686040
4120
11:42
It is filled with perplexity,
218
690959
2741
11:46
frustration,
219
694347
1150
11:48
a desperate fight for understanding.
220
696172
2445
11:51
Let me evoke for you
221
699955
2140
11:54
one of the most striking days
in my mathematician's life.
in my mathematician's life.
222
702119
4380
11:58
Or should I say,
223
706523
1151
11:59
one of the most striking nights.
224
707698
1737
12:02
At that time,
225
710713
1151
12:03
I was staying at the Institute
for Advanced Studies in Princeton --
for Advanced Studies in Princeton --
226
711888
3151
12:07
for many years, the home
of Albert Einstein
of Albert Einstein
227
715063
2139
12:09
and arguably the most holy place
for mathematical research in the world.
for mathematical research in the world.
228
717226
4428
12:14
And that night I was working
and working on an elusive proof,
and working on an elusive proof,
229
722878
3844
12:18
which was incomplete.
230
726746
1378
12:21
It was all about understanding
231
729304
2208
12:23
the paradoxical stability
property of plasmas,
property of plasmas,
232
731536
3823
12:27
which are a crowd of electrons.
233
735383
1958
12:30
In the perfect world of plasma,
234
738423
2736
12:33
there are no collisions
235
741183
1778
12:34
and no friction to provide
the stability like we are used to.
the stability like we are used to.
236
742985
3658
12:39
But still,
237
747392
1151
12:40
if you slightly perturb
a plasma equilibrium,
a plasma equilibrium,
238
748567
3033
12:43
you will find that the
resulting electric shield
resulting electric shield
239
751624
2688
12:46
spontaneously vanishes,
240
754336
2339
12:48
or damps out,
241
756699
1975
12:50
as if by some mysterious friction force.
242
758698
3294
12:54
This paradoxical effect,
243
762728
1835
12:56
called the Landau damping,
244
764587
1477
12:58
is one of the most important
in plasma physics,
in plasma physics,
245
766088
2989
13:01
and it was discovered
through mathematical ideas.
through mathematical ideas.
246
769101
3002
13:04
But still,
247
772970
1151
13:06
a full mathematical understanding
of this phenomenon was missing.
of this phenomenon was missing.
248
774145
4230
13:10
And together with my former student
and main collaborator Clément Mouhot,
and main collaborator Clément Mouhot,
249
778399
4786
13:15
in Paris at the time,
250
783209
1492
13:16
we had been working for months
and months on such a proof.
and months on such a proof.
251
784725
4086
13:21
Actually,
252
789832
1335
13:23
I had already announced by mistake
that we could solve it.
that we could solve it.
253
791191
4746
13:27
But the truth is,
254
795961
1725
13:29
the proof was just not working.
255
797710
2147
13:32
In spite of more than 100 pages
of complicated, mathematical arguments,
of complicated, mathematical arguments,
256
800196
4349
13:36
and a bunch discoveries,
257
804569
1690
13:38
and huge calculation,
258
806283
1267
13:39
it was not working.
259
807574
1169
13:41
And that night in Princeton,
260
809290
1681
13:42
a certain gap in the chain of arguments
was driving me crazy.
was driving me crazy.
261
810995
4301
13:47
I was putting in there all my energy
and experience and tricks,
and experience and tricks,
262
815658
4593
13:52
and still nothing was working.
263
820275
1742
13:54
1 a.m., 2 a.m., 3 a.m.,
264
822553
3882
13:58
not working.
265
826459
1308
14:00
Around 4 a.m., I go to bed in low spirits.
266
828545
4321
14:05
Then a few hours later,
267
833915
2460
14:08
waking up and go,
268
836399
1151
14:09
"Ah, it's time to get
the kids to school --"
the kids to school --"
269
837574
3357
14:12
What is this?
270
840955
1151
14:14
There was this voice in my head, I swear.
271
842130
2142
14:16
"Take the second term to the other side,
272
844894
1913
14:18
Fourier transform and invert in L2."
273
846831
1919
14:21
(Laughter)
274
849257
1151
14:22
Damn it,
275
850432
1702
14:24
that was the start of the solution!
276
852158
2113
14:27
You see,
277
855519
1151
14:28
I thought I had taken some rest,
278
856694
2283
14:31
but really my brain had
continued to work on it.
continued to work on it.
279
859001
3388
14:35
In those moments,
280
863008
1597
14:36
you don't think of your career
or your colleagues,
or your colleagues,
281
864629
2601
14:39
it's just a complete battle
between the problem and you.
between the problem and you.
282
867254
3690
14:44
That being said,
283
872098
1328
14:45
it does not harm when you do get
a promotion in reward for your hard work.
a promotion in reward for your hard work.
284
873450
3949
14:49
And after we completed our huge
analysis of the Landau damping,
analysis of the Landau damping,
285
877808
5160
14:54
I was lucky enough
286
882992
1615
14:56
to get the most coveted Fields Medal
287
884631
3030
14:59
from the hands of the President of India,
288
887685
2867
15:02
in Hyderabad on 19 August, 2010 --
289
890576
3920
15:07
an honor that mathematicians
never dare to dream,
never dare to dream,
290
895453
3251
15:10
a day that I will remember until I live.
291
898728
2399
15:14
What do you think,
292
902366
1447
15:15
on such an occasion?
293
903837
2141
15:18
Pride, yes?
294
906002
1150
15:19
And gratitude to the man collaborators
who made this possible.
who made this possible.
295
907791
3640
15:24
And because it was a collective adventure,
296
912304
2212
15:26
you need to share it,
not just with your collaborators.
not just with your collaborators.
297
914540
4142
15:31
I believe that everybody can appreciate
the thrill of mathematical research,
the thrill of mathematical research,
298
919548
5692
15:37
and share the passionate stories
of humans and ideas behind it.
of humans and ideas behind it.
299
925264
4318
15:42
And I've been working with my staff
at Institut Henri Poincaré,
at Institut Henri Poincaré,
300
930494
4774
15:47
together with partners and artists
of mathematical communication worldwide,
of mathematical communication worldwide,
301
935292
5181
15:52
so that we can found our own,
very special museum of mathematics there.
very special museum of mathematics there.
302
940497
4587
15:58
So in a few years,
303
946537
1777
16:00
when you come to Paris,
304
948885
1577
16:02
after tasting the great, crispy
baguette and macaroon,
baguette and macaroon,
305
950486
5658
16:08
please come and visit us
at Institut Henri Poincaré,
at Institut Henri Poincaré,
306
956168
3663
16:11
and share the mathematical dream with us.
307
959856
2515
16:14
Thank you.
308
962395
1151
16:15
(Applause)
309
963570
7000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Cédric Villani - MathematicianCédric Villani tackles perplexing problems in mathematical physics, analysis and geometry with rigor, wit and a signature personal style.
Why you should listen
His Byronesque hair, colorful ascots and spider brooches have earned Cédric Villani the nickname “the Lady Gaga of Mathematics.” But this moniker has not obscured Villani’s deeper, serious mission: inspiring students to delve into the mysteries of mathematics.
Villani’s fame is based on his work resolving difficult problems of kinetic theory, for which he received the Fields Medal in 2010. His book Birth of a Theorem is an exhilarating journey into the nocturnal dilemmas of mathematicians hot on the trail of discovery.
Villani was elected to the French National Assembly in June 2017.
Cédric Villani | Speaker | TED.com