TED2012
Michael Tilson Thomas: Music and emotion through time
Filmed:
Readability: 4.1
1,667,198 views
In this epic overview, Michael Tilson Thomas traces the development of classical music through the development of written notation, the record, and the re-mix.
Michael Tilson Thomas - Musician, Conductor
Conductor Michael Tilson Thomas (call him MTT) is an all-around music educator -- connecting with global audiences, young musicians and concertgoers in San Francisco and London. Full bio
Conductor Michael Tilson Thomas (call him MTT) is an all-around music educator -- connecting with global audiences, young musicians and concertgoers in San Francisco and London. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Well when I was asked to do this TEDTalk, I was really chuckled,
0
917
2363
00:19
because, you see, my father's name was Ted,
1
3280
3793
00:22
and much of my life, especially my musical life,
2
7073
4014
00:26
is really a talk that I'm still having with him,
3
11087
3121
00:30
or the part of me that he continues to be.
4
14208
3748
00:33
Now Ted was a New Yorker, an all-around theater guy,
5
17956
3604
00:37
and he was a self-taught illustrator and musician.
6
21560
4315
00:41
He didn't read a note,
7
25875
1535
00:43
and he was profoundly hearing impaired.
8
27410
2965
00:46
Yet, he was my greatest teacher.
9
30375
3258
00:49
Because even through the squeaks of his hearing aids,
10
33633
3437
00:52
his understanding of music was profound.
11
37070
3180
00:56
And for him, it wasn't so much the way the music goes
12
40250
3381
00:59
as about what it witnesses and where it can take you.
13
43631
4196
01:03
And he did a painting of this experience,
14
47827
2617
01:06
which he called "In the Realm of Music."
15
50444
3089
01:09
Now Ted entered this realm every day by improvising
16
53533
6488
01:15
in a sort of Tin Pan Alley style like this.
17
60021
2781
01:18
(Music)
18
62802
6842
01:25
But he was tough when it came to music.
19
69644
3354
01:28
He said, "There are only two things that matter in music:
20
72998
2706
01:31
what and how.
21
75704
2213
01:33
And the thing about classical music,
22
77917
3787
01:37
that what and how, it's inexhaustible."
23
81704
3328
01:40
That was his passion for the music.
24
85032
2168
01:43
Both my parents really loved it.
25
87200
1857
01:44
They didn't know all that much about it,
26
89057
2258
01:47
but they gave me the opportunity to discover it
27
91315
3727
01:50
together with them.
28
95042
1916
01:52
And I think inspired by that memory,
29
96958
3212
01:56
it's been my desire to try and bring it
30
100170
2003
01:58
to as many other people as I can,
31
102173
1045
01:59
sort of pass it on through whatever means.
32
103218
3574
02:02
And how people get this music, how it comes into their lives,
33
106792
5010
02:07
really fascinates me.
34
111802
1456
02:09
One day in New York, I was on the street
35
113258
2257
02:11
and I saw some kids playing baseball between stoops and cars and fire hydrants.
36
115515
5405
02:16
And a tough, slouchy kid got up to bat,
37
120920
2701
02:19
and he took a swing and really connected.
38
123621
2704
02:22
And he watched the ball fly for a second,
39
126325
1702
02:23
and then he went, "Dah dadaratatatah.
40
128027
3404
02:27
Brah dada dadadadah."
41
131431
3486
02:30
And he ran around the bases.
42
134917
1833
02:32
And I thought, go figure.
43
136750
2735
02:35
How did this piece of 18th century Austrian aristocratic entertainment
44
139485
5081
02:40
turn into the victory crow of this New York kid?
45
144566
4672
02:45
How was that passed on? How did he get to hear Mozart?
46
149238
4402
02:49
Well when it comes to classical music,
47
153640
1921
02:51
there's an awful lot to pass on,
48
155561
2256
02:53
much more than Mozart, Beethoven or Tchiakovsky.
49
157817
3737
02:57
Because classical music
50
161554
1612
02:59
is an unbroken living tradition
51
163166
3417
03:02
that goes back over 1,000 years.
52
166583
3250
03:05
And every one of those years
53
169833
2044
03:07
has had something unique and powerful to say to us
54
171877
3498
03:11
about what it's like to be alive.
55
175375
3225
03:14
Now the raw material of it, of course,
56
178600
2559
03:17
is just the music of everyday life.
57
181159
1716
03:18
It's all the anthems and dance crazes
58
182875
3033
03:21
and ballads and marches.
59
185908
1735
03:23
But what classical music does
60
187643
2690
03:26
is to distill all of these musics down,
61
190333
4860
03:31
to condense them to their absolute essence,
62
195193
3686
03:34
and from that essence create a new language,
63
198879
3288
03:38
a language that speaks very lovingly and unflinchingly
64
202167
5485
03:43
about who we really are.
65
207652
2100
03:45
It's a language that's still evolving.
66
209752
2844
03:48
Now over the centuries it grew into the big pieces we always think of,
67
212596
3571
03:52
like concertos and symphonies,
68
216167
3000
03:55
but even the most ambitious masterpiece
69
219167
3331
03:58
can have as its central mission
70
222498
2419
04:00
to bring you back to a fragile and personal moment --
71
224917
4500
04:05
like this one from the Beethoven Violin Concerto.
72
229417
3208
04:08
(Music)
73
232625
22386
04:30
It's so simple, so evocative.
74
255011
5984
04:36
So many emotions seem to be inside of it.
75
260995
2860
04:39
Yet, of course, like all music,
76
263855
1728
04:41
it's essentially not about anything.
77
265583
2459
04:43
It's just a design of pitches and silence and time.
78
268042
3783
04:47
And the pitches, the notes, as you know, are just vibrations.
79
271825
4092
04:51
They're locations in the spectrum of sound.
80
275917
2953
04:54
And whether we call them 440 per second, A,
81
278870
4101
04:58
or 3,729, B flat -- trust me, that's right --
82
282971
6718
05:05
they're just phenomena.
83
289689
4096
05:09
But the way we react to different combinations of these phenomena
84
293785
3757
05:13
is complex and emotional and not totally understood.
85
297542
3794
05:17
And the way we react to them has changed radically over the centuries,
86
301336
3831
05:21
as have our preferences for them.
87
305167
2375
05:23
So for example, in the 11th century,
88
307542
3291
05:26
people liked pieces that ended like this.
89
310833
3840
05:30
(Music)
90
314673
11733
05:42
And in the 17th century, it was more like this.
91
326406
5156
05:47
(Music)
92
331562
5438
05:52
And in the 21st century ...
93
337000
3842
05:56
(Music)
94
340842
7408
06:04
Now your 21st century ears are quite happy with this last chord,
95
348250
5319
06:09
even though a while back it would have puzzled or annoyed you
96
353569
3473
06:12
or sent some of you running from the room.
97
357042
1500
06:14
And the reason you like it
98
358542
1416
06:15
is because you've inherited, whether you knew it or not,
99
359958
2488
06:18
centuries-worth of changes
100
362446
2554
06:20
in musical theory, practice and fashion.
101
365000
3500
06:24
And in classical music we can follow these changes very, very accurately
102
368500
5090
06:29
because of the music's powerful silent partner,
103
373590
3983
06:33
the way it's been passed on: notation.
104
377573
3629
06:37
Now the impulse to notate,
105
381202
1965
06:39
or, more exactly I should say, encode music
106
383167
2791
06:41
has been with us for a very long time.
107
385958
3058
06:44
In 200 B.C., a man named Sekulos
108
389016
3901
06:48
wrote this song for his departed wife
109
392917
2950
06:51
and inscribed it on her gravestone
110
395867
1591
06:53
in the notational system of the Greeks.
111
397458
2625
06:55
(Music)
112
400083
27375
07:23
And a thousand years later,
113
427458
2417
07:25
this impulse to notate took an entirely different form.
114
429875
4010
07:29
And you can see how this happened
115
433885
1365
07:31
in these excerpts from the Christmas mass "Puer Natus est nobis,"
116
435250
6583
07:37
"For Us is Born."
117
441833
2375
07:40
(Music)
118
444208
4633
07:44
In the 10th century, little squiggles were used
119
448841
2242
07:46
just to indicate the general shape of the tune.
120
451083
3042
07:50
And in the 12th century, a line was drawn, like a musical horizon line,
121
454125
7042
07:57
to better pinpoint the pitch's location.
122
461167
3578
08:00
And then in the 13th century, more lines and new shapes of notes
123
464745
8330
08:08
locked in the concept of the tune exactly,
124
473090
3618
08:12
and that led to the kind of notation we have today.
125
476708
2667
08:15
Well notation not only passed the music on,
126
479375
3671
08:18
notating and encoding the music changed its priorities entirely,
127
483046
4681
08:23
because it enabled the musicians
128
487727
1956
08:25
to imagine music on a much vaster scale.
129
489683
3656
08:29
Now inspired moves of improvisation
130
493339
3328
08:32
could be recorded, saved, considered, prioritized,
131
496667
4000
08:36
made into intricate designs.
132
500667
2541
08:39
And from this moment, classical music became
133
503208
3240
08:42
what it most essentially is,
134
506448
2594
08:44
a dialogue between the two powerful sides of our nature:
135
509042
5041
08:49
instinct and intelligence.
136
514083
2375
08:52
And there began to be a real difference at this point
137
516458
3375
08:55
between the art of improvisation
138
519833
2917
08:58
and the art of composition.
139
522750
1408
09:00
Now an improviser senses and plays the next cool move,
140
524158
4517
09:04
but a composer is considering all possible moves,
141
528675
3617
09:08
testing them out, prioritizing them out,
142
532292
3319
09:11
until he sees how they can form a powerful and coherent design
143
535611
4472
09:15
of ultimate and enduring coolness.
144
540083
4407
09:20
Now some of the greatest composers, like Bach,
145
544490
1552
09:21
were combinations of these two things.
146
546042
2229
09:24
Bach was like a great improviser with a mind of a chess master.
147
548271
4285
09:28
Mozart was the same way.
148
552556
1944
09:30
But every musician strikes a different balance
149
554500
3246
09:33
between faith and reason, instinct and intelligence.
150
557746
3796
09:37
And every musical era had different priorities of these things,
151
561542
4908
09:42
different things to pass on, different 'whats' and 'hows'.
152
566450
3967
09:46
So in the first eight centuries or so of this tradition
153
570417
4568
09:50
the big 'what' was to praise God.
154
574985
2848
09:53
And by the 1400s, music was being written
155
577833
2625
09:56
that tried to mirror God's mind
156
580458
4084
10:00
as could be seen in the design of the night sky.
157
584542
3916
10:04
The 'how' was a style called polyphony,
158
588458
3292
10:07
music of many independently moving voices
159
591750
3750
10:11
that suggested the way the planets seemed to move
160
595500
2708
10:14
in Ptolemy's geocentric universe.
161
598208
2629
10:16
This was truly the music of the spheres.
162
600837
3786
10:20
(Music)
163
604623
29294
10:49
This is the kind of music that Leonardo DaVinci would have known.
164
633917
5250
10:55
And perhaps its tremendous intellectual perfection and serenity
165
639167
3598
10:58
meant that something new had to happen --
166
642765
2860
11:01
a radical new move, which in 1600 is what did happen.
167
645625
4125
11:05
(Music) Singer: Ah, bitter blow!
168
649750
6833
11:12
Ah, wicked, cruel fate!
169
656583
4792
11:17
Ah, baleful stars!
170
661375
6917
11:24
Ah, avaricious heaven!
171
668292
6958
11:31
MTT: This, of course, was the birth of opera,
172
675250
3708
11:34
and its development put music on a radical new course.
173
678958
2612
11:37
The what now was not to mirror the mind of God,
174
681570
4340
11:41
but to follow the emotion turbulence of man.
175
685925
2950
11:44
And the how was harmony,
176
688875
3292
11:48
stacking up the pitches to form chords.
177
692167
3291
11:51
And the chords, it turned out,
178
695458
1750
11:53
were capable of representing incredible varieties of emotions.
179
697208
4084
11:57
And the basic chords were the ones we still have with us,
180
701292
4799
12:01
the triads,
181
706091
1261
12:03
either the major one,
182
707352
3259
12:06
which we think is happy,
183
710611
4608
12:11
or the minor one,
184
715219
3345
12:14
which we perceive as sad.
185
718564
3936
12:18
But what's the actual difference between these two chords?
186
722500
3269
12:21
It's just these two notes in the middle.
187
725769
2237
12:23
It's either E natural,
188
728006
2965
12:26
and 659 vibrations per second,
189
730971
4700
12:31
or E flat, at 622.
190
735687
4688
12:36
So the big difference between human happiness and sadness?
191
740375
5625
12:41
37 freakin' vibrations.
192
746000
2750
12:44
So you can see in a system like this
193
748750
3917
12:48
there was enormous subtle potential
194
752667
2029
12:50
of representing human emotions.
195
754696
1875
12:52
And in fact, as man began to understand more
196
756571
3733
12:56
his complex and ambivalent nature,
197
760304
2163
12:58
harmony grew more complex to reflect it.
198
762467
2658
13:01
Turns out it was capable of expressing emotions
199
765125
4059
13:05
beyond the ability of words.
200
769184
1733
13:06
Now with all this possibility,
201
770917
3333
13:10
classical music really took off.
202
774250
4083
13:14
It's the time in which the big forms began to arise.
203
778333
3396
13:17
And the effects of technology began to be felt also,
204
781729
4604
13:22
because printing put music, the scores, the codebooks of music,
205
786333
4436
13:26
into the hands of performers everywhere.
206
790769
2010
13:28
And new and improved instruments
207
792779
2221
13:30
made the age of the virtuoso possible.
208
795000
3292
13:34
This is when those big forms arose --
209
798292
3250
13:37
the symphonies, the sonatas, the concertos.
210
801542
3119
13:40
And in these big architectures of time,
211
804661
4006
13:44
composers like Beethoven could share the insights of a lifetime.
212
808667
5708
13:50
A piece like Beethoven's Fifth
213
814375
2460
13:52
basically witnessing how it was possible
214
816835
4358
13:57
for him to go from sorrow and anger,
215
821193
5517
14:02
over the course of a half an hour,
216
826710
3707
14:06
step by exacting step of his route,
217
830417
3791
14:10
to the moment when he could make it across to joy.
218
834208
4340
14:14
(Music)
219
838548
22494
14:36
And it turned out the symphony could be used for more complex issues,
220
861042
5041
14:41
like gripping ones of culture,
221
866083
2627
14:44
such as nationalism or quest for freedom
222
868710
2748
14:47
or the frontiers of sensuality.
223
871458
3871
14:51
But whatever direction the music took,
224
875329
3771
14:55
one thing until recently was always the same,
225
879100
2538
14:57
and that was when the musicians stopped playing,
226
881638
3029
15:00
the music stopped.
227
884667
2375
15:02
Now this moment so fascinates me.
228
887042
3363
15:06
I find it such a profound one.
229
890405
1911
15:08
What happens when the music stops?
230
892316
1367
15:09
Where does it go? What's left?
231
893683
3442
15:13
What sticks with people in the audience at the end of a performance?
232
897125
3288
15:16
Is it a melody or a rhythm
233
900413
1772
15:18
or a mood or an attitude?
234
902185
2780
15:20
And how might that change their lives?
235
904965
2269
15:23
To me this is the intimate, personal side of music.
236
907234
3933
15:27
It's the passing on part. It's the 'why' part of it.
237
911167
4541
15:31
And to me that's the most essential of all.
238
915708
3258
15:34
Mostly it's been a person-to-person thing,
239
918966
3959
15:38
a teacher-student, performer-audience thing,
240
922925
2607
15:41
and then around 1880 came this new technology
241
925532
2777
15:44
that first mechanically then through analogs then digitally
242
928309
2691
15:46
created a new and miraculous way of passing things on,
243
931000
4287
15:51
albeit an impersonal one.
244
935287
1788
15:52
People could now hear music all the time,
245
937075
3717
15:56
even though it wasn't necessary
246
940792
875
15:57
for them to play an instrument, read music or even go to concerts.
247
941667
4541
16:02
And technology democratized music by making everything available.
248
946208
5304
16:07
It spearheaded a cultural revolution
249
951512
1761
16:09
in which artists like Caruso and Bessie Smith were on the same footing.
250
953273
4860
16:14
And technology pushed composers to tremendous extremes,
251
958133
3921
16:17
using computers and synthesizers
252
962054
1700
16:19
to create works of intellectually impenetrable complexity
253
963754
2919
16:22
beyond the means of performers and audiences.
254
966673
4535
16:27
At the same time technology,
255
971208
2500
16:29
by taking over the role that notation had always played,
256
973708
3292
16:32
shifted the balance within music between instinct and intelligence
257
977000
4542
16:37
way over to the instinctive side.
258
981542
3291
16:40
The culture in which we live now
259
984833
1890
16:42
is awash with music of improvisation
260
986723
3069
16:45
that's been sliced, diced, layered
261
989792
1625
16:47
and, God knows, distributed and sold.
262
991417
3750
16:51
What's the long-term effect of this on us or on music?
263
995167
3287
16:54
Nobody knows.
264
998454
1007
16:55
The question remains: What happens when the music stops?
265
999461
3722
16:59
What sticks with people?
266
1003183
1951
17:01
Now that we have unlimited access to music, what does stick with us?
267
1005165
3952
17:05
Well let me show you a story of what I mean
268
1009117
2420
17:07
by "really sticking with us."
269
1011537
1792
17:09
I was visiting a cousin of mine in an old age home,
270
1013329
3088
17:12
and I spied a very shaky old man
271
1016417
3335
17:15
making his way across the room on a walker.
272
1019752
2277
17:17
He came over to a piano that was there,
273
1022029
2516
17:20
and he balanced himself and began playing something like this.
274
1024545
4330
17:24
(Music)
275
1028875
4535
17:29
And he said something like, "Me ... boy ... symphony ... Beethoven."
276
1033410
8863
17:38
And I suddenly got it,
277
1042273
1552
17:39
and I said, "Friend, by any chance are you trying to play this?"
278
1043825
2920
17:42
(Music)
279
1046745
4951
17:47
And he said, "Yes, yes. I was a little boy.
280
1051696
2429
17:50
The symphony: Isaac Stern, the concerto, I heard it."
281
1054125
4596
17:54
And I thought, my God,
282
1058721
1683
17:56
how much must this music mean to this man
283
1060404
2846
17:59
that he would get himself out of his bed, across the room
284
1063250
4117
18:03
to recover the memory of this music
285
1067367
3300
18:06
that, after everything else in his life is sloughing away,
286
1070667
2908
18:09
still means so much to him?
287
1073575
2258
18:11
Well, that's why I take every performance so seriously,
288
1075833
3923
18:15
why it matters to me so much.
289
1079756
1750
18:17
I never know who might be there, who might be absorbing it
290
1081506
3452
18:20
and what will happen to it in their life.
291
1084958
1750
18:22
But now I'm excited that there's more chance than ever before possible
292
1086708
5087
18:27
of sharing this music.
293
1091795
1330
18:29
That's what drives my interest in projects
294
1093125
1746
18:30
like the TV series "Keeping Score" with the San Francisco Symphony
295
1094871
3379
18:34
that looks at the backstories of music,
296
1098250
2567
18:36
and working with the young musicians at the New World Symphony
297
1100817
3177
18:39
on projects that explore the potential
298
1103994
1594
18:41
of the new performing arts centers
299
1105588
3506
18:44
for both entertainment and education.
300
1109094
2374
18:47
And of course, the New World Symphony
301
1111468
1967
18:49
led to the YouTube Symphony and projects on the internet
302
1113435
3648
18:52
that reach out to musicians and audiences all over the world.
303
1117083
3004
18:55
And the exciting thing is all this is just a prototype.
304
1120087
4780
19:00
There's just a role here for so many people --
305
1124867
2238
19:03
teachers, parents, performers --
306
1127121
2796
19:05
to be explorers together.
307
1129917
2860
19:08
Sure, the big events attract a lot of attention,
308
1132777
2785
19:11
but what really matters is what goes on every single day.
309
1135562
3480
19:14
We need your perspectives, your curiosity, your voices.
310
1139042
4470
19:19
And it excites me now to meet people
311
1143512
3090
19:22
who are hikers, chefs, code writers, taxi drivers,
312
1146602
3098
19:25
people I never would have guessed who loved the music
313
1149700
2765
19:28
and who are passing it on.
314
1152465
1115
19:29
You don't need to worry about knowing anything.
315
1153580
3741
19:33
If you're curious, if you have a capacity for wonder, if you're alive,
316
1157321
3762
19:36
you know all that you need to know.
317
1161083
3060
19:40
You can start anywhere. Ramble a bit.
318
1164143
2209
19:42
Follow traces. Get lost. Be surprised, amused inspired.
319
1166352
4104
19:46
All that 'what', all that 'how' is out there
320
1170456
4619
19:50
waiting for you to discover its 'why',
321
1175075
2463
19:53
to dive in and pass it on.
322
1177569
3058
19:56
Thank you.
323
1180627
2498
19:59
(Applause)
324
1183125
7112
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Tilson Thomas - Musician, ConductorConductor Michael Tilson Thomas (call him MTT) is an all-around music educator -- connecting with global audiences, young musicians and concertgoers in San Francisco and London.
Why you should listen
As a conductor, Michael Tilson Thomas might be best known for his interpretation of the emotionally charged music of Gustav Mahler. But his legacy won't stop at his Grammy-winning recordings of the complete Mahler symphony cycle with his home orchestra, the San Francisco Symphony. He's also the founder of the New World Symphony, an orchestra that helps to educate young and gifted musicians as obsessed with their craft as he. Since its establishment in 1987, New World Symphony has launched the careers of more than 700 young musicians, and in its new Miami Beach concert hall designed by Frank Gehry, it's bringing well-played classical music to a truly popular audience.
He's the guest conductor of the London Symphony Orchestra -- and the artistic director of the YouTube Symphony Orchestra (YTSO), a 96-member ensemble selected from online video auditions. Tilson Thomas conducted the YTSO at Carnegie Hall in 2009 and in 2011 in Sydney, Australia. And he's the creator of the Keeping Score education program for public schools, which uses PBS TV, web, radio and DVDs, and a K-12 curriculum to make classical music more accessible. In 2010, Tilson Thomas was awarded the National Medal of Arts, the highest award given to artists by the US government.
Michael Tilson Thomas | Speaker | TED.com