TEDGlobal 2012
Mina Bissell: Experiments that point to a new understanding of cancer
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
1,094,158 views
For decades, researcher Mina Bissell pursued a revolutionary idea -- that a cancer cell doesn't automatically become a tumor, but rather, depends on surrounding cells (its microenvironment) for cues on how to develop. She shares the two key experiments that proved the prevailing wisdom about cancer growth was wrong.
Mina Bissell - Cancer Researcher
Mina Bissell studies how cancer interacts with our bodies, searching for clues to how cancer's microenvironment influences its growth. Full bio
Mina Bissell studies how cancer interacts with our bodies, searching for clues to how cancer's microenvironment influences its growth. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Now, I don't usually like cartoons,
0
432
2722
00:19
I don't think many of them are funny,
1
3154
2510
00:21
I find them weird. But I love this cartoon from the New Yorker.
2
5664
5223
00:26
(Text: Never, ever think outside the box.) (Laughter)
3
10887
2612
00:29
So, the guy is telling the cat,
4
13499
2469
00:31
don't you dare think outside the box.
5
15968
5371
00:37
Well, I'm afraid I used to be the cat.
6
21339
3307
00:40
I always wanted to be outside the box.
7
24646
3058
00:43
And it's partly because I came to this field
8
27704
3482
00:47
from a different background, chemist and a bacterial geneticist.
9
31186
5213
00:52
So, what people were saying to me
10
36399
2602
00:54
about the cause of cancer, sources of cancer,
11
39001
3191
00:58
or, for that matter, why you are who you are,
12
42192
3081
01:01
didn't make sense.
13
45273
1874
01:03
So, let me quickly try and tell you why I thought that
14
47147
3047
01:06
and how I went about it.
15
50194
2601
01:08
So, to begin with, however,
16
52795
2432
01:11
I have to give you a very, very quick lesson
17
55227
4426
01:15
in developmental biology,
18
59653
1767
01:17
with apologies to those of you who know some biology.
19
61420
4062
01:21
So, when your mom and dad met,
20
65482
3014
01:24
there is a fertilized egg,
21
68496
2674
01:27
that round thing with that little blip.
22
71170
2121
01:29
It grows and then it grows,
23
73291
3055
01:32
and then it makes this handsome man.
24
76346
4153
01:36
(Applause)
25
80499
1415
01:37
So, this guy, with all the cells in his body,
26
81914
5658
01:43
all have the same genetic information.
27
87572
4212
01:47
So how did his nose become his nose, his elbow his elbow,
28
91784
4375
01:52
and why doesn't he get up one morning
29
96159
2176
01:54
and have his nose turn into his foot?
30
98335
2560
01:56
It could. It has the genetic information.
31
100895
3240
02:00
You all remember, dolly,
32
104135
1208
02:01
it came from a single mammary cell.
33
105343
2681
02:03
So, why doesn't it do it?
34
108024
1934
02:05
So, have a guess of how many cells he has in his body.
35
109958
5503
02:11
Somewhere between 10 trillion to 70 trillion cells in his body.
36
115461
7402
02:18
Trillion!
37
122863
1640
02:20
Now, how did these cells, all with the same genetic material,
38
124503
4638
02:25
make all those tissues?
39
129141
2208
02:27
And so, the question I raised before
40
131349
3144
02:30
becomes even more interesting if you thought about
41
134493
3614
02:34
the enormity of this in every one of your bodies.
42
138107
4586
02:38
Now, the dominant cancer theory would say
43
142693
3000
02:41
that there is a single oncogene
44
145693
2312
02:43
in a single cancer cell, and it would make you
45
148005
3704
02:47
a cancer victim.
46
151709
2649
02:50
Well, this did not make sense to me.
47
154358
3666
02:53
Do you even know how a trillion looks?
48
158024
3182
02:57
Now, let's look at it.
49
161206
1719
02:58
There it comes, these zeroes after zeroes after zeroes.
50
162925
5041
03:03
Now, if .0001 of these cells got mutated,
51
167966
6818
03:10
and .00001 got cancer, you will be a lump of cancer.
52
174784
5257
03:15
You will have cancer all over you. And you're not.
53
180041
2296
03:18
Why not?
54
182337
2309
03:20
So, I decided over the years,
55
184646
3722
03:24
because of a series of experiments
56
188368
1928
03:26
that this is because of context and architecture.
57
190296
4880
03:31
And let me quickly tell you
58
195176
2177
03:33
some crucial experiment that was able to actually show this.
59
197353
3927
03:37
To begin with, I came to work with this virus
60
201280
3911
03:41
that causes that ugly tumor in the chicken.
61
205191
3393
03:44
Rous discovered this in 1911.
62
208584
3360
03:47
It was the first cancer virus discovered,
63
211944
3565
03:51
and when I call it "oncogene," meaning "cancer gene."
64
215509
4891
03:56
So, he made a filtrate, he took this filter
65
220400
2912
03:59
which was the liquid after he passed the tumor through a filter,
66
223312
4256
04:03
and he injected it to another chicken, and he got another tumor.
67
227568
4001
04:07
So, scientists were very excited,
68
231569
2711
04:10
and they said, a single oncogene can do it.
69
234280
2168
04:12
All you need is a single oncogene.
70
236448
2296
04:14
So, they put the cells in cultures, chicken cells,
71
238744
2895
04:17
dumped the virus on it,
72
241639
2035
04:19
and it would pile up,
73
243674
1449
04:21
and they would say, this is malignant and this is normal.
74
245123
3021
04:24
And again this didn't make sense to me.
75
248144
2018
04:26
So for various reasons, we took this oncogene,
76
250162
3286
04:29
attached it to a blue marker,
77
253448
2312
04:31
and we injected it into the embryos.
78
255760
3008
04:34
Now look at that. There is that beautiful feather in the embryo.
79
258768
4193
04:38
Every one of those blue cells are a cancer gene
80
262961
4279
04:43
inside a cancer cell, and they're part of the feather.
81
267240
4416
04:47
So, when we dissociated the feather and put it in a dish,
82
271656
4600
04:52
we got a mass of blue cells.
83
276256
2712
04:54
So, in the chicken you get a tumor,
84
278968
1466
04:56
in the embryo you don't,
85
280434
1704
04:58
you dissociate, you put it in a dish, you get another tumor.
86
282138
3992
05:02
What does that mean?
87
286130
1223
05:03
That means that microenvironment
88
287353
2984
05:06
and the context which surrounds those cells
89
290337
4009
05:10
actually are telling the cancer gene and the cancer cell what to do.
90
294346
6927
05:17
Now, let's take a normal example.
91
301273
3312
05:20
The normal example, let's take the human mammary gland.
92
304585
3185
05:23
I work on breast cancer.
93
307770
1480
05:25
So, here is a lovely human breast.
94
309250
3007
05:28
And many of you know how it looks,
95
312257
1948
05:30
except that inside that breast, there are all these
96
314205
2853
05:32
pretty, developing, tree-like structures.
97
317058
3377
05:36
So, we decided that what we like to do
98
320435
2898
05:39
is take just a bit of that mammary gland,
99
323333
2960
05:42
which is called an "acinus,"
100
326293
2032
05:44
where there are all these little things inside the breast
101
328325
3641
05:47
where the milk goes, and the end of the nipple
102
331966
3543
05:51
comes through that little tube when the baby sucks.
103
335509
3544
05:54
And we said, wonderful! Look at this pretty structure.
104
339053
3407
05:58
We want to make this a structure, and ask the question,
105
342460
3769
06:02
how do the cells do that?
106
346229
1704
06:03
So, we took the red cells --
107
347933
1792
06:05
you see the red cells are surrounded by blue,
108
349725
3248
06:08
other cells that squeeze them, and behind it
109
352973
3329
06:12
is material that people thought was mainly inert,
110
356302
3718
06:15
and it was just having a structure to keep the shape,
111
360020
3597
06:19
and so we first photographed it
112
363617
2928
06:22
with the electron microscope years and years ago,
113
366545
2768
06:25
and you see this cell is actually quite pretty.
114
369313
3056
06:28
It has a bottom, it has a top,
115
372369
2463
06:30
it is secreting gobs and gobs of milk,
116
374832
2681
06:33
because it just came from an early pregnant mouse.
117
377513
3192
06:36
You take these cells, you put them in a dish,
118
380705
2327
06:38
and within three days, they look like that.
119
383032
3345
06:42
They completely forget.
120
386377
3160
06:45
So you take them out, you put them in a dish,
121
389537
2800
06:48
they don't make milk. They completely forget.
122
392337
2663
06:50
For example, here is a lovely yellow droplet of milk
123
395000
4899
06:55
on the left, there is nothing on the right.
124
399899
2255
06:58
Look at the nuclei. The nuclei in the cell on the left
125
402154
3729
07:01
is in the animal, the one on the right is in a dish.
126
405883
3496
07:05
They are completely different from each other.
127
409379
2736
07:08
So, what does this tell you?
128
412115
2025
07:10
This tells you that here also, context overrides.
129
414140
4967
07:15
In different contexts, cells do different things.
130
419107
3385
07:18
But how does context signal?
131
422492
2745
07:21
So, Einstein said that
132
425237
2542
07:23
"For an idea that does not first seem insane, there is no hope."
133
427779
6653
07:30
So, you can imagine the amount of skepticism
134
434432
5960
07:36
I received -- couldn't get money,
135
440392
2401
07:38
couldn't do a whole lot of other things,
136
442793
1943
07:40
but I'm so glad it all worked out.
137
444736
1729
07:42
So, we made a section of the mammary gland of the mouse,
138
446465
3815
07:46
and all those lovely acini are there,
139
450280
3183
07:49
every one of those with the red around them are an acinus,
140
453463
4211
07:53
and we said okay, we are going to try and make this,
141
457674
3694
07:57
and I said, maybe that red stuff
142
461368
3232
08:00
around the acinus that people think there's just a structural scaffold,
143
464600
5125
08:05
maybe it has information,
144
469725
1940
08:07
maybe it tells the cells what to do, maybe it tells the nucleus what to do.
145
471665
4566
08:12
So I said, extracellular matrix, which is this stuff
146
476231
4283
08:16
called ECM, signals and actually tells the cells what to do.
147
480514
4391
08:20
So, we decided to make things that would look like that.
148
484905
3767
08:24
We found some gooey material
149
488672
2880
08:27
that had the right extracellular matrix in it,
150
491552
2875
08:30
we put the cells in it, and lo and behold,
151
494427
2539
08:32
in about four days, they got reorganized
152
496966
2821
08:35
and on the right, is what we can make in culture.
153
499787
3408
08:39
On the left is what's inside the animal, we call it in vivo,
154
503195
4496
08:43
and the one in culture was full of milk,
155
507691
2584
08:46
the lovely red there is full of milk.
156
510275
2800
08:48
So, we Got Milk, for the American audience.
157
513075
3416
08:52
All right. And here is this beautiful human cell,
158
516491
5344
08:57
and you can imagine that here also, context goes.
159
521835
4946
09:02
So, what do we do now?
160
526781
2716
09:05
I made a radical hypothesis.
161
529497
2224
09:07
I said, if it's true that architecture is dominant,
162
531721
6663
09:14
architecture restored to a cancer cell
163
538384
4486
09:18
should make the cancer cell think it's normal.
164
542870
2989
09:21
Could this be done?
165
545859
1484
09:23
So, we tried it.
166
547343
2528
09:25
In order to do that, however,
167
549871
2038
09:27
we needed to have a method of distinguishing normal from malignant,
168
551909
4885
09:32
and on the left is the single normal cell,
169
556794
3997
09:36
human breast, put in three-dimensional gooey gel
170
560791
3963
09:40
that has extracellular matrix, it makes all these beautiful structures.
171
564754
3864
09:44
On the right, you see it looks very ugly,
172
568618
2888
09:47
the cells continue to grow,
173
571506
1648
09:49
the normal ones stop.
174
573154
1576
09:50
And you see here in higher magnification
175
574730
2832
09:53
the normal acinus and the ugly tumor.
176
577562
4352
09:57
So we said, what is on the surface of these ugly tumors?
177
581914
4224
10:02
Could we calm them down --
178
586138
2168
10:04
they were signaling like crazy and they have pathways all messed up --
179
588306
4920
10:09
and make them to the level of the normal?
180
593226
3064
10:12
Well, it was wonderful. Boggles my mind.
181
596290
4720
10:16
This is what we got.
182
601010
2161
10:19
We can revert the malignant phenotype.
183
603171
3679
10:22
(Applause)
184
606850
2568
10:25
And in order to show you that the malignant phenotype
185
609418
3112
10:28
I didn't just choose one,
186
612530
1718
10:30
here are little movies, sort of fuzzy,
187
614248
2770
10:32
but you see that on the left are the malignant cells,
188
617018
3656
10:36
all of them are malignant,
189
620674
1344
10:37
we add one single inhibitor in the beginning,
190
622018
4800
10:42
and look what happens, they all look like that.
191
626818
3457
10:46
We inject them into the mouse, the ones on the right,
192
630275
3447
10:49
and none of them would make tumors.
193
633722
2240
10:51
We inject the other ones in the mouse, 100 percent tumors.
194
635962
3536
10:55
So, it's a new way of thinking about cancer,
195
639498
2672
10:58
it's a hopeful way of thinking about cancer.
196
642170
2400
11:00
We should be able to be dealing with these things at this level,
197
644570
3976
11:04
and these conclusions say that growth and malignant behavior
198
648546
5912
11:10
is regulated at the level of tissue organization
199
654458
3872
11:14
and that the tissue organization is dependent
200
658330
3992
11:18
on the extracellular matrix and the microenvironment.
201
662322
3696
11:21
All right, thus form and function interact dynamically and reciprocally.
202
666018
7631
11:29
And here is another five seconds of repose,
203
673649
4120
11:33
is my mantra. Form and function.
204
677769
4422
11:38
And of course, we now ask, where do we go now?
205
682191
3646
11:41
We'd like to take this kind of thinking into the clinic.
206
685837
2995
11:44
But before we do that, I'd like you to think
207
688832
3924
11:48
that at any given time when you're sitting there,
208
692756
3588
11:52
in your 70 trillion cells,
209
696344
3013
11:55
the extracellular matrix signaling to your nucleus,
210
699357
3473
11:58
the nucleus is signaling to your extracellular matrix
211
702830
3078
12:01
and this is how your balance is kept and restored.
212
705908
5994
12:07
We have made a lot of discoveries,
213
711902
2215
12:10
we have shown that extracellular matrix talks to chromatin.
214
714117
3088
12:13
We have shown that there's little pieces of DNA
215
717205
3447
12:16
on the specific genes of the mammary gland
216
720652
3823
12:20
that actually respond to extracellular matrix.
217
724475
2864
12:23
It has taken many years, but it has been very rewarding.
218
727339
3697
12:26
And before I get to the next slide, I have to tell you
219
731036
4391
12:31
that there are so many additional discoveries to be made.
220
735427
5112
12:36
There is so much mystery we don't know.
221
740539
2528
12:38
And I always say to the students and post-docs I lecture to,
222
743067
4361
12:43
don't be arrogant, because arrogance kills curiosity.
223
747428
5663
12:48
Curiosity and passion.
224
753091
2192
12:51
You need to always think, what else needs to be discovered?
225
755283
3897
12:55
And maybe my discovery needs to be added to
226
759180
2975
12:58
or maybe it needs to be changed.
227
762155
1792
12:59
So, we have now made an amazing discovery,
228
763947
3504
13:03
a post-doc in the lab who is a physicist asked me,
229
767451
3104
13:06
what do the cells do when you put them in?
230
770555
2177
13:08
What do they do in the beginning when they do?
231
772732
3294
13:11
I said, I don't know, we couldn't look at them.
232
776026
1481
13:13
We didn't have high images in the old days.
233
777507
2593
13:16
So she, being an imager and a physicist,
234
780100
2695
13:18
did this incredible thing.
235
782795
1744
13:20
This is a single human breast cell in three dimensions.
236
784539
4376
13:24
Look at it. It's constantly doing this.
237
788915
2528
13:27
Has a coherent movement.
238
791443
2096
13:29
You put the cancer cells there, and they do go all over,
239
793539
4334
13:33
they do this. They don't do this.
240
797873
1904
13:35
And when we revert the cancer cell, it again does this.
241
799777
4008
13:39
Absolutely boggles my mind.
242
803785
2184
13:41
So the cell acts like an embryo. What an exciting thing.
243
805969
5344
13:47
So I'd like to finish with a poem.
244
811313
2856
13:50
Well I used to love English literature,
245
814169
3064
13:53
and I debated in college, which one should I do?
246
817233
2607
13:55
And unfortunately or fortunately, chemistry won.
247
819840
4612
14:00
But here is a poem from Yeats. I'll just read you the last two lines.
248
824452
5724
14:06
It's called "Among the School Children."
249
830176
2659
14:08
"O body swayed to music / O brightening glance /
250
832835
4521
14:13
How [can we know] the dancer from the dance?"
251
837356
3150
14:16
And here is Merce Cunningham,
252
840506
1911
14:18
I was fortunate to dance with him when I was younger,
253
842417
2984
14:21
and here he is a dancer,
254
845401
2193
14:23
and while he is dancing, he is both the dancer and the dance.
255
847594
3304
14:26
The minute he stops, we have neither.
256
850898
3701
14:30
So it's like form and function.
257
854599
3474
14:33
Now, I'd like to show you a current picture of my group.
258
858073
5779
14:39
I have been fortunate to have had these magnificant
259
863852
3528
14:43
students and post-docs who have taught me so much,
260
867380
3224
14:46
and I have had many of these groups come and go.
261
870604
3263
14:49
They are the future and I try to make them not be afraid
262
873867
4577
14:54
of being the cat and being told,
263
878444
3703
14:58
don't think outside the box.
264
882147
1593
14:59
And I'd like to leave you with this thought.
265
883740
2495
15:02
On the left is water coming through the shore,
266
886235
4745
15:06
taken from a NASA satellite.
267
890980
1895
15:08
On the right, there is a coral.
268
892875
3049
15:11
Now if you take the mammary gland and spread it
269
895924
4002
15:15
and take the fat away, on a dish it looks like that.
270
899926
3445
15:19
Do they look the same? Do they have the same patterns?
271
903371
3352
15:22
Why is it that nature keeps doing that over and over again?
272
906723
3952
15:26
And I'd like to submit to you
273
910675
2360
15:28
that we have sequenced the human genome,
274
913035
2177
15:31
we know everything about the sequence of the gene,
275
915212
2880
15:33
the language of the gene, the alphabet of the gene,
276
918092
2431
15:36
But we know nothing, but nothing,
277
920523
3239
15:39
about the language and alphabet of form.
278
923762
4663
15:44
So, it's a wonderful new horizon,
279
928425
3044
15:47
it's a wonderful thing to discover for the young
280
931469
3750
15:51
and the passionate old, and that's me.
281
935219
2480
15:53
So go to it!
282
937699
2048
15:55
(Applause)
283
939747
11500
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Mina Bissell - Cancer ResearcherMina Bissell studies how cancer interacts with our bodies, searching for clues to how cancer's microenvironment influences its growth.
Why you should listen
Mina Bissell's groundbreaking research has proven that cancer is not only caused by cancer cells. It is caused by an interaction between cancer cells and the surrounding cellular micro-environment. In healthy bodies, normal tissue homeostasis and architecture inhibit the progression of cancers. But changes in the microenvironment--following an injury or a wound for instance--can shift the balance. This explains why many people harbor potentially malignant tumors in their bodies without knowing it and never develop cancer, and why tumors often develop when tissue is damaged or when the immune system is suppressed.
The converse can also be true. In a landmark 1997 experiment, mutated mammary cells, when dosed with an antibody and placed into a normal cellular micro-environment, behaved normally. This powerful insight from Bissell's lab may lead to new ways of treating existing and preventing potential cancers.
Mina Bissell | Speaker | TED.com