ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Dave Brain - Planetary scientist
Dave Brain studies the plasma environments and atmospheres of unmagnetized planets.

Why you should listen
Dave Brain is an Assistant Professor of Astrophysics and Planetary Science at the University of Colorado at Boulder. He's interested in the evolution of the atmospheres of planets such as Mars, Venus and Earth, and in particular how planets lose (and gain) atmosphere over time. He uses spacecraft data and computer models to help figure out how light and particles from our sun strip away atmospheric particles, possibly changing them from habitable worlds.
More profile about the speaker
Dave Brain | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxBoulder

Dave Brain: What a planet needs to sustain life

Filmed:
1,867,290 views

"Venus is too hot, Mars is too cold, and Earth is just right," says planetary scientist Dave Brain. But why? In this pleasantly humorous talk, Brain explores the fascinating science behind what it takes for a planet to host life -- and why humanity may just be in the right place at the right time when it comes to the timeline of life-sustaining planets.
- Planetary scientist
Dave Brain studies the plasma environments and atmospheres of unmagnetized planets. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
I'm really glad to be here.
0
943
1421
00:15
I'm glad you're here,
1
3015
1688
00:16
because that would be a little weird.
2
4727
1833
00:19
I'm glad we're all here.
3
7460
2105
00:22
And by "here," I don't mean here.
4
10303
2853
00:26
Or here.
5
14831
1150
00:28
But here.
6
16728
1152
00:29
I mean Earth.
7
17904
1150
00:31
And by "we," I don't mean
those of us in this auditorium,
8
19627
3943
00:35
but life,
9
23594
1470
00:37
all life on Earth --
10
25088
1449
00:38
(Laughter)
11
26561
5382
00:44
from complex to single-celled,
12
32280
1991
00:46
from mold to mushrooms
13
34295
2324
00:48
to flying bears.
14
36643
1378
00:50
(Laughter)
15
38045
1366
00:53
The interesting thing is,
16
41736
1509
00:55
Earth is the only place
we know of that has life --
17
43269
3031
00:58
8.7 million species.
18
46324
1877
01:00
We've looked other places,
19
48660
1254
01:01
maybe not as hard
as we should or we could,
20
49938
2097
01:04
but we've looked and haven't found any;
21
52059
1927
01:06
Earth is the only place
we know of with life.
22
54010
2276
01:09
Is Earth special?
23
57318
1274
01:11
This is a question I've wanted
to know the answer to
24
59591
2454
01:14
since I was a small child,
25
62069
1254
01:15
and I suspect 80 percent
of this auditorium
26
63347
2032
01:17
has thought the same thing
and also wanted to know the answer.
27
65403
3008
01:20
To understand whether
there are any planets --
28
68879
2167
01:23
out there in our solar system or beyond --
29
71070
2278
01:25
that can support life,
30
73372
1458
01:26
the first step is to understand
what life here requires.
31
74854
3197
01:30
It turns out, of all of those
8.7 million species,
32
78575
3563
01:34
life only needs three things.
33
82162
2198
01:37
On one side, all life
on Earth needs energy.
34
85032
2852
01:39
Complex life like us derives
our energy from the sun,
35
87908
3485
01:43
but life deep underground
can get its energy
36
91417
2101
01:45
from things like chemical reactions.
37
93542
1722
01:47
There are a number
of different energy sources
38
95288
2151
01:49
available on all planets.
39
97463
1243
01:51
On the other side,
40
99400
1156
01:52
all life needs food or nourishment.
41
100580
2705
01:55
And this seems like a tall order,
especially if you want a succulent tomato.
42
103741
4474
02:00
(Laughter)
43
108239
1716
02:01
However, all life on Earth
derives its nourishment
44
109979
3066
02:05
from only six chemical elements,
45
113069
2030
02:07
and these elements can be found
on any planetary body
46
115123
3004
02:10
in our solar system.
47
118151
1336
02:12
So that leaves the thing
in the middle as the tall pole,
48
120537
3227
02:15
the thing that's hardest to achieve.
49
123788
1954
02:17
Not moose, but water.
50
125766
1892
02:19
(Laughter)
51
127682
2781
02:23
Although moose would be pretty cool.
52
131285
1794
02:25
(Laughter)
53
133103
1158
02:26
And not frozen water, and not water
in a gaseous state, but liquid water.
54
134285
5535
02:32
This is what life needs
to survive, all life.
55
140748
2453
02:35
And many solar system bodies
don't have liquid water,
56
143680
3336
02:39
and so we don't look there.
57
147040
1636
02:40
Other solar system bodies
might have abundant liquid water,
58
148700
2993
02:43
even more than Earth,
59
151717
1335
02:45
but it's trapped beneath an icy shell,
60
153076
2450
02:47
and so it's hard to access,
it's hard to get to,
61
155550
2261
02:49
it's hard to even find out
if there's any life there.
62
157835
2719
02:53
So that leaves a few bodies
that we should think about.
63
161475
2995
02:56
So let's make the problem
simpler for ourselves.
64
164494
2429
02:58
Let's think only about liquid water
on the surface of a planet.
65
166947
3341
03:02
There are only three bodies
to think about in our solar system,
66
170312
2956
03:05
with regard to liquid water
on the surface of a planet,
67
173292
2582
03:07
and in order of distance from the sun,
it's: Venus, Earth and Mars.
68
175898
4826
03:13
You want to have an atmosphere
for water to be liquid.
69
181265
3372
03:16
You have to be very careful
with that atmosphere.
70
184661
2378
03:19
You can't have too much atmosphere,
too thick or too warm an atmosphere,
71
187063
3412
03:22
because then you end up
too hot like Venus,
72
190499
2905
03:25
and you can't have liquid water.
73
193428
1737
03:27
But if you have too little atmosphere
and it's too thin and too cold,
74
195189
3953
03:31
you end up like Mars, too cold.
75
199166
2024
03:33
So Venus is too hot, Mars is too cold,
76
201865
2475
03:36
and Earth is just right.
77
204364
1164
03:37
You can look at these images behind me
and you can see automatically
78
205552
3475
03:41
where life can survive
in our solar system.
79
209051
2597
03:44
It's a Goldilocks-type problem,
80
212296
1600
03:45
and it's so simple
that a child could understand it.
81
213920
2490
03:49
However,
82
217452
1180
03:51
I'd like to remind you of two things
83
219450
2928
03:54
from the Goldilocks story
that we may not think about so often
84
222402
2954
03:57
but that I think are really relevant here.
85
225380
2096
04:00
Number one:
86
228056
1150
04:02
if Mama Bear's bowl is too cold
87
230311
2792
04:05
when Goldilocks walks into the room,
88
233833
2008
04:08
does that mean it's always been too cold?
89
236642
2143
04:11
Or could it have been just right
at some other time?
90
239825
3268
04:15
When Goldilocks walks into the room
determines the answer
91
243650
3681
04:19
that we get in the story.
92
247355
1332
04:21
And the same is true with planets.
93
249114
1730
04:22
They're not static things. They change.
94
250868
2026
04:24
They vary. They evolve.
95
252918
1742
04:26
And atmospheres do the same.
96
254684
2043
04:28
So let me give you an example.
97
256751
1702
04:30
Here's one of my favorite
pictures of Mars.
98
258477
2002
04:32
It's not the highest resolution image,
it's not the sexiest image,
99
260503
3131
04:35
it's not the most recent image,
100
263658
1503
04:37
but it's an image that shows riverbeds
cut into the surface of the planet;
101
265185
3494
04:41
riverbeds carved by flowing, liquid water;
102
269320
2584
04:45
riverbeds that take hundreds or thousands
or tens of thousands of years to form.
103
273515
4886
04:50
This can't happen on Mars today.
104
278425
1618
04:52
The atmosphere of Mars today
is too thin and too cold
105
280067
2481
04:54
for water to be stable as a liquid.
106
282572
2141
04:56
This one image tells you
that the atmosphere of Mars changed,
107
284737
4348
05:01
and it changed in big ways.
108
289109
2032
05:03
And it changed from a state
that we would define as habitable,
109
291714
4809
05:08
because the three requirements
for life were present long ago.
110
296547
3590
05:13
Where did that atmosphere go
111
301049
2068
05:15
that allowed water
to be liquid at the surface?
112
303141
2820
05:17
Well, one idea is it escaped
away to space.
113
305985
3347
05:21
Atmospheric particles
got enough energy to break free
114
309356
2667
05:24
from the gravity of the planet,
115
312047
1653
05:25
escaping away to space, never to return.
116
313724
2689
05:28
And this happens with all bodies
with atmospheres.
117
316437
2688
05:31
Comets have tails
118
319149
1172
05:32
that are incredibly visible reminders
of atmospheric escape.
119
320345
3257
05:35
But Venus also has an atmosphere
that escapes with time,
120
323626
3409
05:39
and Mars and Earth as well.
121
327059
1660
05:40
It's just a matter of degree
and a matter of scale.
122
328743
2968
05:44
So we'd like to figure out
how much escaped over time
123
332092
2676
05:46
so we can explain this transition.
124
334792
2116
05:48
How do atmospheres
get their energy for escape?
125
336932
2611
05:51
How do particles get
enough energy to escape?
126
339567
2131
05:53
There are two ways, if we're going
to reduce things a little bit.
127
341722
3185
05:56
Number one, sunlight.
128
344931
1151
05:58
Light emitted from the sun can be absorbed
by atmospheric particles
129
346106
3412
06:01
and warm the particles.
130
349542
1714
06:03
Yes, I'm dancing, but they --
131
351280
2108
06:05
(Laughter)
132
353412
1471
06:07
Oh my God, not even at my wedding.
133
355693
1912
06:09
(Laughter)
134
357629
1492
06:11
They get enough energy
to escape and break free
135
359145
3003
06:14
from the gravity of the planet
just by warming.
136
362172
2500
06:16
A second way they can get energy
is from the solar wind.
137
364696
3162
06:19
These are particles, mass, material,
spit out from the surface of the sun,
138
367882
5026
06:24
and they go screaming
through the solar system
139
372932
2404
06:27
at 400 kilometers per second,
140
375360
1785
06:29
sometimes faster during solar storms,
141
377169
2594
06:31
and they go hurtling
through interplanetary space
142
379787
2722
06:34
towards planets and their atmospheres,
143
382533
2446
06:37
and they may provide energy
144
385003
1625
06:38
for atmospheric particles
to escape as well.
145
386652
2128
06:41
This is something that I'm interested in,
146
389182
1969
06:43
because it relates to habitability.
147
391175
1713
06:45
I mentioned that there were two things
about the Goldilocks story
148
393378
3132
06:48
that I wanted to bring to your attention
and remind you about,
149
396534
2984
06:51
and the second one
is a little bit more subtle.
150
399542
2239
06:53
If Papa Bear's bowl is too hot,
151
401805
2788
06:58
and Mama Bear's bowl is too cold,
152
406180
3234
07:03
shouldn't Baby Bear's bowl be even colder
153
411057
3111
07:07
if we're following the trend?
154
415081
1796
07:10
This thing that you've accepted
your entire life,
155
418195
2312
07:12
when you think about it a little bit more,
may not be so simple.
156
420531
3070
07:16
And of course, distance of a planet
from the sun determines its temperature.
157
424513
4028
07:20
This has to play into habitability.
158
428565
2266
07:22
But maybe there are other things
we should be thinking about.
159
430855
2930
07:25
Maybe it's the bowls themselves
160
433809
1616
07:27
that are also helping to determine
the outcome in the story,
161
435449
3056
07:30
what is just right.
162
438529
1300
07:32
I could talk to you about a lot
of different characteristics
163
440765
2865
07:35
of these three planets
164
443654
1151
07:36
that may influence habitability,
165
444829
1569
07:38
but for selfish reasons related
to my own research
166
446422
2594
07:41
and the fact that I'm standing up here
holding the clicker and you're not --
167
449040
3588
07:44
(Laughter)
168
452652
1006
07:45
I would like to talk
for just a minute or two
169
453682
2109
07:47
about magnetic fields.
170
455815
1297
07:49
Earth has one; Venus and Mars do not.
171
457715
2532
07:52
Magnetic fields are generated
in the deep interior of a planet
172
460825
3123
07:55
by electrically conducting
churning fluid material
173
463972
3717
07:59
that creates this big old magnetic field
that surrounds Earth.
174
467713
2905
08:02
If you have a compass,
you know which way north is.
175
470642
2396
08:05
Venus and Mars don't have that.
176
473062
1494
08:06
If you have a compass on Venus and Mars,
177
474580
1914
08:08
congratulations, you're lost.
178
476518
1396
08:09
(Laughter)
179
477938
1903
08:11
Does this influence habitability?
180
479865
2040
08:15
Well, how might it?
181
483175
1302
08:17
Many scientists think
that a magnetic field of a planet
182
485024
2604
08:19
serves as a shield for the atmosphere,
183
487652
2395
08:22
deflecting solar wind particles
around the planet
184
490071
3355
08:25
in a bit of a force field-type effect
185
493450
1815
08:27
having to do with electric charge
of those particles.
186
495289
2700
08:30
I like to think of it instead
as a salad bar sneeze guard for planets.
187
498362
3627
08:34
(Laughter)
188
502013
2279
08:36
And yes, my colleagues
who watch this later will realize
189
504962
3381
08:40
this is the first time in the history
of our community
190
508367
2544
08:42
that the solar wind has been
equated with mucus.
191
510935
2279
08:45
(Laughter)
192
513238
1650
08:48
OK, so the effect, then, is that Earth
may have been protected
193
516978
3475
08:52
for billions of years,
194
520477
1169
08:53
because we've had a magnetic field.
195
521670
1850
08:55
Atmosphere hasn't been able to escape.
196
523544
2179
08:57
Mars, on the other hand,
has been unprotected
197
525747
2107
08:59
because of its lack of magnetic field,
198
527878
1842
09:01
and over billions of years,
199
529744
1952
09:03
maybe enough atmosphere
has been stripped away
200
531720
2180
09:05
to account for a transition
from a habitable planet
201
533924
2593
09:08
to the planet that we see today.
202
536541
1666
09:11
Other scientists think
that magnetic fields
203
539059
2989
09:14
may act more like the sails on a ship,
204
542072
2163
09:16
enabling the planet to interact
with more energy from the solar wind
205
544958
5037
09:22
than the planet would have been able
to interact with by itself.
206
550019
3272
09:25
The sails may gather energy
from the solar wind.
207
553315
2491
09:27
The magnetic field may gather
energy from the solar wind
208
555830
2666
09:30
that allows even more
atmospheric escape to happen.
209
558520
3244
09:33
It's an idea that has to be tested,
210
561788
2254
09:36
but the effect and how it works
211
564066
1885
09:37
seems apparent.
212
565975
1151
09:39
That's because we know
213
567150
1151
09:40
energy from the solar wind
is being deposited into our atmosphere
214
568325
3075
09:43
here on Earth.
215
571424
1151
09:44
That energy is conducted
along magnetic field lines
216
572599
2405
09:47
down into the polar regions,
217
575028
1348
09:48
resulting in incredibly beautiful aurora.
218
576400
2136
09:50
If you've ever experienced them,
it's magnificent.
219
578560
2656
09:53
We know the energy is getting in.
220
581240
2006
09:55
We're trying to measure
how many particles are getting out
221
583270
3033
09:58
and if the magnetic field
is influencing this in any way.
222
586327
3038
10:02
So I've posed a problem for you here,
223
590722
2380
10:05
but I don't have a solution yet.
224
593126
1546
10:06
We don't have a solution.
225
594696
1276
10:08
But we're working on it.
How are we working on it?
226
596702
2357
10:11
Well, we've sent spacecraft
to all three planets.
227
599083
2298
10:13
Some of them are orbiting now,
228
601405
1476
10:14
including the MAVEN spacecraft
which is currently orbiting Mars,
229
602905
3072
10:18
which I'm involved with
and which is led here,
230
606001
3532
10:21
out of the University of Colorado.
231
609557
1809
10:23
It's designed to measure
atmospheric escape.
232
611390
2282
10:26
We have similar measurements
from Venus and Earth.
233
614022
2474
10:28
Once we have all our measurements,
234
616953
1665
10:30
we can combine all these together,
and we can understand
235
618642
2875
10:33
how all three planets interact
with their space environment,
236
621541
3417
10:36
with the surroundings.
237
624982
1162
10:38
And we can decide whether magnetic fields
are important for habitability
238
626168
3522
10:41
or not.
239
629714
1158
10:42
Once we have that answer,
why should you care?
240
630896
2265
10:45
I mean, I care deeply ...
241
633185
1300
10:48
And financially as well, but deeply.
242
636128
2006
10:50
(Laughter)
243
638158
1842
10:52
First of all, an answer to this question
244
640763
1918
10:54
will teach us more
about these three planets,
245
642705
2103
10:56
Venus, Earth and Mars,
246
644832
1160
10:58
not only about how they interact
with their environment today,
247
646016
2911
11:00
but how they were billions of years ago,
248
648951
1927
11:02
whether they were habitable
long ago or not.
249
650902
2062
11:04
It will teach us about atmospheres
250
652988
1644
11:06
that surround us and that are close.
251
654656
1995
11:09
But moreover, what we learn
from these planets
252
657127
2184
11:11
can be applied to atmospheres everywhere,
253
659335
2021
11:14
including planets that we're now
observing around other stars.
254
662485
2913
11:17
For example, the Kepler spacecraft,
255
665422
1755
11:19
which is built and controlled
here in Boulder,
256
667201
3208
11:22
has been observing
a postage stamp-sized region of the sky
257
670433
3285
11:25
for a couple years now,
258
673742
1247
11:27
and it's found thousands of planets --
259
675013
2228
11:29
in one postage stamp-sized
region of the sky
260
677265
2913
11:32
that we don't think is any different
from any other part of the sky.
261
680202
4089
11:36
We've gone, in 20 years,
262
684815
1810
11:38
from knowing of zero planets
outside of our solar system,
263
686649
4037
11:42
to now having so many,
264
690710
1753
11:44
that we don't know
which ones to investigate first.
265
692487
3139
11:49
Any lever will help.
266
697269
1460
11:52
In fact, based on observations
that Kepler's taken
267
700539
3584
11:56
and other similar observations,
268
704147
2129
11:58
we now believe that,
269
706300
1169
11:59
of the 200 billion stars
in the Milky Way galaxy alone,
270
707493
4699
12:04
on average, every star
has at least one planet.
271
712786
4604
12:10
In addition to that,
272
718819
1503
12:12
estimates suggest there are somewhere
between 40 billion and 100 billion
273
720346
5701
12:18
of those planets
that we would define as habitable
274
726071
3332
12:23
in just our galaxy.
275
731139
1412
12:26
We have the observations of those planets,
276
734590
2037
12:28
but we just don't know
which ones are habitable yet.
277
736651
2484
12:31
It's a little bit like
being trapped on a red spot --
278
739159
3606
12:34
(Laughter)
279
742789
1171
12:35
on a stage
280
743984
1232
12:38
and knowing that there are
other worlds out there
281
746178
3562
12:43
and desperately wanting to know
more about them,
282
751042
2776
12:47
wanting to interrogate them and find out
if maybe just one or two of them
283
755174
3934
12:51
are a little bit like you.
284
759132
1610
12:54
You can't do that.
You can't go there, not yet.
285
762244
2559
12:56
And so you have to use the tools
that you've developed around you
286
764827
3993
13:00
for Venus, Earth and Mars,
287
768844
1295
13:02
and you have to apply them
to these other situations,
288
770163
2813
13:05
and hope that you're making
reasonable inferences from the data,
289
773000
4696
13:09
and that you're going to be able
to determine the best candidates
290
777720
3118
13:12
for habitable planets,
and those that are not.
291
780862
2399
13:16
In the end, and for now, at least,
292
784139
2715
13:18
this is our red spot, right here.
293
786878
2787
13:22
This is the only planet
that we know of that's habitable,
294
790376
3336
13:25
although very soon we may
come to know of more.
295
793736
3191
13:28
But for now, this is
the only habitable planet,
296
796951
2736
13:31
and this is our red spot.
297
799711
1302
13:33
I'm really glad we're here.
298
801976
1420
13:36
Thanks.
299
804507
1175
13:37
(Applause)
300
805706
3231

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Dave Brain - Planetary scientist
Dave Brain studies the plasma environments and atmospheres of unmagnetized planets.

Why you should listen
Dave Brain is an Assistant Professor of Astrophysics and Planetary Science at the University of Colorado at Boulder. He's interested in the evolution of the atmospheres of planets such as Mars, Venus and Earth, and in particular how planets lose (and gain) atmosphere over time. He uses spacecraft data and computer models to help figure out how light and particles from our sun strip away atmospheric particles, possibly changing them from habitable worlds.
More profile about the speaker
Dave Brain | Speaker | TED.com