ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Kate Stafford - Oceanographer
Kate Stafford's research examines migratory movements, geographic variation and physical drivers of marine mammals, particularly large whales.

Why you should listen

Dr. Kate Stafford has worked in marine habitats all over the world, from the tropics to the poles, and is fortunate enough to have seen (and recorded) blue whales in every ocean in which they occur. Stafford's current research focuses on the changing acoustic environment of the Arctic and how changes from declining sea ice to increasing industrial human use may be influencing subarctic and Arctic marine mammals.

Stafford is a Principal Oceanographer at the Applied Physics Lab and affiliate Associate Professor in the School of Oceanography at the University of Washington in Seattle. She has degrees in French literature and biology from the University of California at Santa Cruz and wildlife science (MS) and oceanography (PhD) from Oregon State University. Before going to graduate school, she lived as a Fulbright scholar for a year in Paris studying Medieval French literature. Stafford's research has been featured in Wild Blue: a Natural History of the World's Largest Animal by Dan Bortolotti, the New York Times "Scientist at Work" blog, The Planet magazine, and in Highlights for Children magazine. She has collaborated with artists around the world, providing sounds for multimedia art exhibits.

More profile about the speaker
Kate Stafford | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxCERN

Kate Stafford: How human noise affects ocean habitats

Filmed:
1,233,640 views

Oceanographer Kate Stafford lowers us into the sonically rich depths of the Arctic Ocean, where ice groans, whales sing to communicate over vast distances -- and climate change and human noise threaten to alter the environment in ways we don't understand. Learn more about why this underwater soundscape matters and what we might do to protect it.
- Oceanographer
Kate Stafford's research examines migratory movements, geographic variation and physical drivers of marine mammals, particularly large whales. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
In 1956, a documentary
by Jacques Cousteau won
0
1033
4784
00:17
both the Palme d'Or and an Oscar award.
1
5841
3001
00:20
This film was called,
"Le Monde Du Silence,"
2
8866
2861
00:23
or, "The Silent World."
3
11751
2092
00:26
The premise of the title was that
the underwater world was a quiet world.
4
14427
5350
00:32
We now know, 60 years later,
5
20459
2315
00:34
that the underwater world
is anything but silent.
6
22798
3436
00:38
Although the sounds
are inaudible above water
7
26677
3007
00:41
depending on where you are
and the time of year,
8
29708
3310
00:45
the underwater soundscape can be as noisy
as any jungle or rainforest.
9
33042
5858
00:51
Invertebrates like snapping shrimp,
fish and marine mammals
10
39791
4858
00:56
all use sound.
11
44673
1205
00:58
They use sound to study their habitat,
12
46354
2913
01:01
to keep in communication with each other,
13
49291
2302
01:03
to navigate,
14
51617
1283
01:04
to detect predators and prey.
15
52924
2209
01:07
They also use sound by listening
to know something about their environment.
16
55737
5289
01:13
Take, for an example, the Arctic.
17
61050
2679
01:15
It's considered a vast,
inhospitable place,
18
63753
3228
01:19
sometimes described as a desert,
19
67005
2581
01:21
because it is so cold and so remote
20
69610
2933
01:24
and ice-covered for much of the year.
21
72567
2211
01:27
And despite this,
22
75268
1713
01:29
there is no place on Earth
that I would rather be than the Arctic,
23
77005
4044
01:33
especially as days lengthen
and spring comes.
24
81073
3639
01:37
To me, the Arctic really
embodies this disconnect
25
85464
4303
01:41
between what we see on the surface
and what's going on underwater.
26
89791
5256
01:47
You can look out across the ice --
all white and blue and cold --
27
95685
5006
01:53
and see nothing.
28
101691
1296
01:55
But if you could hear underwater,
29
103653
2637
01:58
the sounds you would hear
would at first amaze
30
106314
3381
02:01
and then delight you.
31
109719
2087
02:03
And while your eyes are seeing
nothing for kilometers but ice,
32
111830
4022
02:07
your ears are telling you that out there
are bowhead and beluga whales,
33
115876
5463
02:13
walrus and bearded seals.
34
121363
2276
02:16
The ice, too, makes sounds.
35
124661
1909
02:18
It screeches and cracks
and pops and groans,
36
126594
3484
02:22
as it collides and rubs when temperature
or currents or winds change.
37
130102
4954
02:28
And under 100 percent sea ice
in the dead of winter,
38
136112
3819
02:32
bowhead whales are singing.
39
140784
2307
02:36
And you would never expect that,
40
144247
1867
02:38
because we humans,
41
146138
2191
02:40
we tend to be very visual animals.
42
148353
2597
02:43
For most of us, but not all,
43
151434
3045
02:46
our sense of sight is how
we navigate our world.
44
154503
2538
02:49
For marine mammals that live underwater,
45
157725
2692
02:52
where chemical cues
and light transmit poorly,
46
160441
3863
02:56
sound is the sense by which they see.
47
164328
4075
03:00
And sound transmits very well underwater,
48
168427
2314
03:02
much better than it does in air,
49
170765
1932
03:04
so signals can be heard
over great distances.
50
172721
2994
03:08
In the Arctic, this
is especially important,
51
176270
3091
03:11
because not only do Arctic marine
mammals have to hear each other,
52
179385
3913
03:15
but they also have to listen
for cues in the environment
53
183322
3111
03:18
that might indicate
heavy ice ahead or open water.
54
186457
3908
03:22
Remember, although they spend
most of their lives underwater,
55
190862
3399
03:26
they are mammals,
56
194285
1224
03:27
and so they have to surface to breathe.
57
195533
2279
03:30
So they might listen
for thin ice or no ice,
58
198458
3856
03:34
or listen for echoes off nearby ice.
59
202338
3049
03:39
Arctic marine mammals live in a rich
and varied underwater soundscape.
60
207094
5120
03:44
In the spring,
61
212726
1242
03:45
it can be a cacophony of sound.
62
213992
2134
03:49
(Marine mammal sounds)
63
217329
3886
04:05
But when the ice is frozen solid,
64
233169
2890
04:08
and there are no big temperature
shifts or current changes,
65
236083
3708
04:11
the underwater Arctic has some
of the lowest ambient noise levels
66
239815
4299
04:16
of the world's oceans.
67
244138
1720
04:17
But this is changing.
68
245882
1322
04:19
This is primarily due to a decrease
in seasonal sea ice,
69
247228
3664
04:23
which is a direct result of human
greenhouse gas emissions.
70
251796
3592
04:28
We are, in effect, with climate change,
71
256354
2906
04:31
conducting a completely uncontrolled
experiment with our planet.
72
259284
3674
04:35
Over the past 30 years,
73
263765
2089
04:37
areas of the Arctic have seen
decreases in seasonal sea ice
74
265878
3853
04:41
from anywhere from
six weeks to four months.
75
269755
4415
04:46
This decrease in sea ice is sometimes
referred to as an increase
76
274820
4610
04:51
in the open water season.
77
279454
1863
04:53
That is the time of year when
the Arctic is navigable to vessels.
78
281341
3511
04:57
And not only is the extent
of ice changing,
79
285560
2654
05:01
but the age and the width of ice is, too.
80
289345
3329
05:05
Now, you may well have heard
81
293356
1458
05:06
that a decrease in seasonal sea ice
is causing a loss of habitat
82
294838
3483
05:10
for animals that rely on sea ice,
83
298345
2131
05:12
such as ice seals,
or walrus, or polar bears.
84
300500
3573
05:16
Decreasing sea ice is also causing
increased erosion along coastal villages,
85
304858
4839
05:21
and changing prey availability
for marine birds and mammals.
86
309721
3566
05:26
Climate change and decreases in sea ice
87
314319
3078
05:29
are also altering the underwater
soundscape of the Arctic.
88
317421
4515
05:35
What do I mean by soundscape?
89
323370
1728
05:37
Those of us who eavesdrop
on the oceans for a living
90
325833
2857
05:40
use instruments called hydrophones,
91
328714
2254
05:42
which are underwater microphones,
92
330992
2045
05:45
and we record ambient noise --
93
333061
1946
05:47
the noise all around us.
94
335031
1924
05:48
And the soundscape describes
the different contributors
95
336979
3341
05:52
to this noise field.
96
340344
1517
05:54
What we are hearing on our hydrophones
97
342743
2601
05:57
are the very real sounds
of climate change.
98
345368
3535
06:01
We are hearing these changes
from three fronts:
99
349503
2638
06:04
from the air,
100
352831
1772
06:06
from the water
101
354627
1453
06:08
and from land.
102
356104
1349
06:10
First: air.
103
358319
2220
06:13
Wind on water creates waves.
104
361904
2613
06:16
These waves make bubbles;
105
364541
1825
06:18
the bubbles break,
106
366390
1367
06:19
and when they do,
107
367781
1506
06:21
they make noise.
108
369311
1203
06:22
And this noise is like a hiss
or a static in the background.
109
370538
3904
06:27
In the Arctic, when it's ice-covered,
110
375298
2951
06:30
most of the noise from wind
doesn't make it into the water column,
111
378273
3631
06:33
because the ice acts as a buffer
between the atmosphere and the water.
112
381928
4590
06:39
This is one of the reasons
113
387000
1345
06:40
that the Arctic can have
very low ambient noise levels.
114
388369
3703
06:44
But with decreases in seasonal sea ice,
115
392834
2630
06:47
not only is the Arctic now open
to this wave noise,
116
395488
4367
06:52
but the number of storms
and the intensity of storms in the Arctic
117
400459
3487
06:55
has been increasing.
118
403970
1263
06:57
All of this is raising noise levels
in a previously quiet ocean.
119
405725
4489
07:02
Second: water.
120
410748
2226
07:06
With less seasonal sea ice,
121
414481
1874
07:08
subarctic species are moving north,
122
416379
2676
07:11
and taking advantage of the new habitat
that is created by more open water.
123
419079
4552
07:16
Now, Arctic whales, like this bowhead,
124
424504
3025
07:19
they have no dorsal fin,
125
427553
1712
07:21
because they have evolved to live
and swim in ice-covered waters,
126
429289
4768
07:26
and having something sticking
off of your back is not very conducive
127
434081
3523
07:29
to migrating through ice,
128
437628
1810
07:31
and may, in fact, be excluding
animals from the ice.
129
439462
3779
07:35
But now, everywhere we've listened,
130
443835
2647
07:38
we're hearing the sounds
of fin whales and humpback whales
131
446506
3058
07:41
and killer whales,
132
449588
1469
07:43
further and further north,
133
451081
2231
07:45
and later and later in the season.
134
453336
2048
07:48
We are hearing, in essence,
135
456003
1412
07:49
an invasion of the Arctic
by subarctic species.
136
457439
3733
07:53
And we don't know what this means.
137
461874
1963
07:55
Will there be competition for food
between Arctic and subarctic animals?
138
463861
4667
08:00
Might these subarctic species introduce
diseases or parasites into the Arctic?
139
468965
5198
08:07
And what are the new sounds
that they are producing
140
475035
2777
08:09
doing to the soundscape underwater?
141
477836
2390
08:12
And third: land.
142
480980
1762
08:15
And by land ...
143
483188
1656
08:16
I mean people.
144
484868
1257
08:18
More open water means
increased human use of the Arctic.
145
486714
3728
08:23
Just this past summer,
146
491254
1318
08:24
a massive cruise ship made its way
through the Northwest Passage --
147
492596
4181
08:28
the once-mythical route
between Europe and the Pacific.
148
496801
3463
08:33
Decreases in sea ice have allowed
humans to occupy the Arctic more often.
149
501386
6381
08:40
It has allowed increases in oil
and gas exploration and extraction,
150
508167
4641
08:44
the potential for commercial shipping,
151
512832
2630
08:47
as well as increased tourism.
152
515486
1797
08:50
And we now know that ship noise increases
levels of stress hormones in whales
153
518394
4865
08:55
and can disrupt feeding behavior.
154
523283
2082
08:58
Air guns, which produce loud,
low-frequency "whoomps"
155
526051
5249
09:03
every 10 to 20 seconds,
156
531324
2574
09:05
changed the swimming and vocal
behavior of whales.
157
533922
3241
09:09
And all of these sound sources
are decreasing the acoustic space
158
537723
4938
09:14
over which Arctic marine mammals
can communicate.
159
542685
3217
09:18
Now, Arctic marine mammals
are used to very high levels of noise
160
546914
4384
09:23
at certain times of the year.
161
551322
1481
09:25
But this is primarily from other
animals or from sea ice,
162
553327
4076
09:29
and these are the sounds
with which they've evolved,
163
557427
2496
09:31
and these are sounds that are vital
to their very survival.
164
559947
3490
09:35
These new sounds
are loud and they're alien.
165
563461
3195
09:39
They might impact the environment
in ways that we think we understand,
166
567161
5151
09:44
but also in ways that we don't.
167
572336
2293
09:48
Remember, sound is the most
important sense for these animals.
168
576998
4801
09:53
And not only is the physical habitat
of the Arctic changing rapidly,
169
581823
4575
09:58
but the acoustic habitat is, too.
170
586422
2216
10:01
It's as if we've plucked these animals up
from the quiet countryside
171
589086
3717
10:04
and dropped them into a big city
in the middle of rush hour.
172
592827
3256
10:08
And they can't escape it.
173
596837
1604
10:11
So what can we do now?
174
599685
2009
10:15
We can't decrease wind speeds
175
603019
2388
10:17
or keep subarctic animals
from migrating north,
176
605431
3180
10:20
but we can work on local solutions
177
608635
2433
10:23
to reducing human-caused underwater noise.
178
611092
2795
10:26
One of these solutions
is to slow down ships
179
614817
3157
10:29
that traverse the Arctic,
180
617998
1790
10:31
because a slower ship is a quieter ship.
181
619812
3438
10:35
We can restrict access
in seasons and regions
182
623934
3792
10:39
that are important for mating
or feeding or migrating.
183
627750
4291
10:44
We can get smarter about quieting ships
184
632497
3304
10:47
and find better ways
to explore the ocean bottom.
185
635825
2752
10:51
And the good news is,
186
639727
1943
10:53
there are people
working on this right now.
187
641694
2792
10:58
But ultimately,
188
646240
1501
10:59
we humans have to do the hard work
189
647765
2867
11:02
of reversing or at the very
least decelerating
190
650656
4156
11:06
human-caused atmospheric changes.
191
654836
2472
11:09
So, let's return to this idea
of a silent world underwater.
192
657332
4459
11:15
It's entirely possible
193
663006
1495
11:16
that many of the whales
swimming in the Arctic today,
194
664525
3337
11:19
especially long-lived species
like the bowhead whale
195
667886
3535
11:23
that the Inuits say can live
two human lives --
196
671445
3757
11:27
it's possible that these whales
were alive in 1956,
197
675226
3761
11:31
when Jacques Cousteau made his film.
198
679011
1885
11:33
And in retrospect,
199
681877
1712
11:35
considering all the noise
we are creating in the oceans today,
200
683613
3908
11:40
perhaps it really was "The Silent World."
201
688644
3060
11:44
Thank you.
202
692873
1264
11:46
(Applause)
203
694161
2404

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Kate Stafford - Oceanographer
Kate Stafford's research examines migratory movements, geographic variation and physical drivers of marine mammals, particularly large whales.

Why you should listen

Dr. Kate Stafford has worked in marine habitats all over the world, from the tropics to the poles, and is fortunate enough to have seen (and recorded) blue whales in every ocean in which they occur. Stafford's current research focuses on the changing acoustic environment of the Arctic and how changes from declining sea ice to increasing industrial human use may be influencing subarctic and Arctic marine mammals.

Stafford is a Principal Oceanographer at the Applied Physics Lab and affiliate Associate Professor in the School of Oceanography at the University of Washington in Seattle. She has degrees in French literature and biology from the University of California at Santa Cruz and wildlife science (MS) and oceanography (PhD) from Oregon State University. Before going to graduate school, she lived as a Fulbright scholar for a year in Paris studying Medieval French literature. Stafford's research has been featured in Wild Blue: a Natural History of the World's Largest Animal by Dan Bortolotti, the New York Times "Scientist at Work" blog, The Planet magazine, and in Highlights for Children magazine. She has collaborated with artists around the world, providing sounds for multimedia art exhibits.

More profile about the speaker
Kate Stafford | Speaker | TED.com